Отзыв ведущей организации (Методика оценки влияния климатических условий и эрозионного износа на характеристики ТРДДФ)

L-CATVP*'ilrxput-r*e aKUkl*HepHfie cc'"qel*Hry:I! - nq1*3 B*q!rqeryW:!,,i****r-r:o** * {*, y p *OT3bIBne,4yrqefi opraHu3arluu Ha ALrcceprarlLroHrryro pa6ory A64enreaxzga MoxaMMeAaE a-rrla <<Mero,quKa oqeHK u Brrvrfllakrr Kru MaruqecKux yclonufi r{ 3po3uoHHorokr3Hoca Ha xapaKTepncrLlKlr TPAAO), flpeAcraereHHofi Ha coucKanvre yrenoficrerreHra KaHAr4Aara rexuuqecKr{x HayK no crrequallbHocrLt 05.07.05 - "TeilroBble,3neKTpOpaKeTHbIe ABLITaTOJII4IiI sHeprOyCTaHOBKu JIeTaTeJIbHbIx auuapatOn".fincceprarllroHHatr pa6ora cocrorrr yr3 BBeAeHu.[ ) frflTkr uIaB, ocHoBHbrxBbrBoAoB, crrucKa uclonmyeMbrx LtcroqHr{KoB Lt3 95 HauMeHoBauwit, AByxrrpr4noxeuufi, u:lroxeHa sa 175 crpaHurl€x MaurI,IHorIkIcHoro reKcra, BKJlroqaroulero9 4 utrtroarpallrll4 u 6 ra6tw\.Arcrya"rrnHocrb reMblTexnpr.{ecKoe cocro fl:,j{ue I{ xapaKTepucrrrKpr aBuaIIr{oHHbIx ABLlrarelefi npu LrxgKcrlnyaral\vru B ycnoBlrf,x 3arrblJrennofi arrraoc@epbl rI rloBruuenHofi BJIaxHocrI4yxyAr[aroTcf,, B QBfl3r4 C qeM IpOLT3BOAUTeJII,I aBUaqUOHHSIX ABLIfaTeJIeU UopfaHpr3ar\uv, 3Kc[nyaTlrpyroq[e aBrrarlrroHHyro TexHrrKy, yAeJIflroT ,{aHHOMyBolpocy oco6oe BHuMaHI{e.,{lnrerurax 3Kcrlnyarar\krfl, B ycnoBlrrrx sanHreHHofi aruoc$epucorrpoBoxAaercf, 3po3I4oHHbrM r43HocoM gJreMeHToB [poroqHoit qacru ABvrrarelrfl,, vrIIpexAe Bceto JrorraroK KoMrrpeccopa, rrTo rrpllBoAl{T K 3HaquTenbHOMy yXyAIneHI4IOcocToqHprfl vr xapaKTepr{cT[K KoMlpeccopa, cHl{xeHuro 3arraca Ia3oAr4HaMn'Iecrofiycrofiuurocrra, Lr, coorBercrBeHHo, IxyAureHkrlo [apaMerpoB ABrIrareJI{ B IIenoM.flosrrtrreHHa, BJraxHocrb Bo3Ayxa rrptr BblcoKlltx 3HaqeHurlx arurocQepnofiTeMrreparypLr rrpo{Bnfl.ercfl B B}rAe rr3MeHeHl4tr reuno$navqecKllx cnoficm Bo3Ayxa unpoIyKToB cropaHr{rr TofrJrnBa, rrTo rrpr{BoAuT K cyIqecTBeHHoMy II3MeHeHUIOrrapaMeTpoB ABI{| aTenf,.Cyqecrnyrorrlue MeroAlrKr.l f{era Brrvrflraus gpo3uoHHoro u3Hoca u BJraxHocr}IHa xapaKTepuc'rkrKvr aBprarlrloHHbrx 4nnrareuefi rpe6yror yrorlHeHl{.r ucoBeprxeHcTBoBaHr4f,, a TaKxe He rro3BoJIrIoT IIpOBOAI,ITb OIIeHKy C r{eTOMcoBMecruoro BrrvrflHus.

pa3lurrHhrx ro [pupoAe Sarropoe. 3to o6yclonllrBaerneo6xoAuMocrb paspa6omr.r KoMrrJreKcHbIx MeroAuK orlpe,qeneHil, TexHrlqecKolococToflHr.rr, xapaKTep[cTprK 3JreMeHToB Lr ABuraTenf, B IIeJIOM, r{I{TbIBaIOUI}1X3po3r{oHHrrfi zsHoc flporoqHofr.rtactu u rroBbllrleHrrylo BJlaxnocrb Bo3Ayxa.Taxlru o6paeorra, paspa6orKa coBpeMeHHbrx MeroAuK Anf, oIIeHKu BlrLrl.lru.flp€BnrrrHbrx oKcrrJryararduoHHux SarropoB Ha xapaKTepLIcrLIKu TPAA@ sBJUIerc,aKTyarrbHofi nayruo-TexHr{qecrofr :a4a.refr .q':1*I1*''-:"--*t.r0c,tlt,,'-*'Y=*-'r+i:r:i,L,III{e"urro pa6oru flBrrfl.ercfl pa:pa6orr<a MeroArrKr4 oIIeHKHBlrprflHr4fl,nocle4crnufr spo3r4oHHoro r43Hoca v uosrrueHHofr BJIaxHocrI{ arvroc$epHoroBo3Ayxa Ha xapaKTeprrcrrrKu TPAAO c yqeroM r43MeHeHH.rI ra3oAl4HaMl4r{ecKuxxapaKrepr{cTr{K oceBofo KoMrrpeccopa.Hayunan HoBr{3Ha rroJryqeHHblx pe3y,'rbraroB pa6orrt3aKnroqaerc.s Bpa":pa6oraunofi MeroAr4Ke yrrera BrrLrflHtrfl.

nocneAcTrrafi eposl4oHHoro rl3Hoca HafeoMeTpHr{ecKr4e napaMeTpbr JrorraToK KoMilpeccopa v efo xapaKTepkrc"u4K[,Ilo3BoJlflIoqefr yuurblBarb rl3Hoc, KaK I,I3oJII4poBaHHbIx JlonarorrHblx BeHIIoB, TaK I'IMHOfOCTyreHqaTbrx oceBbrx KoMrrpeccopoB c yqeToM xapaKTepHblx zsl\4eueuufipa[uanbHbrx 3a3opoB 14 reoMerprrr,r upo$znefi no Bbrcore nonaroK; paspa6orasuofiMeTOArrKe OrIeHKr4 BrrkrfrHkrfl. BJraxHocTr{ Bo3Ayxa Ha xapaKTepvcTrlKl4 KoMnpeocopa,o6ecuequearcqefi norsrrff yr{er ur3MeHeHrra Susr.ruecKrrx ceoficrs pa6ouero rena vtrroBbrrrreHr4e ror{Hocrr4 nonyqaeMbrx pe3ynbraroB; pa:pa6orausofi rrporpaMMepacqera BbrcorHo-cKopocrHbrx xapaKreprrcrlrK TPAA@, rro3BoJlflroulefi upoBotrI,IrbKoJrrrlrecrBeHHyro oIIeHKy Blrvfllc^Lrfl rrocneAcTnufi epo:LroHHoro H3Hoca I4 BJraxHocrl4Bo3.qyxa Ha napaMerpbr ABr4rarenfl c yr{eroM oco6eusocrefi nporpaMMblynpaBneHr4r; a raKxe B pe3ynbrarax pacirerHblx HCcJreAoBa:r'uit Blrr4flrlurs.3po3r,loHHofo r{3HOCa v BJTaXHOCTT4 BO3AyXA Ha XapaKTepVCTI4KLr KOMnpeCCOpA krrPAA@.CrpyrcryparcoAep)KaHlre pa6orrrfiEcceprarlr{oHHaq paSora cocrorrr r43 BBeAeH:zfl, rrflTr4 rJIaB, BbIBoAoB, cnucKanrrreparypbr I,I npuroxenufi .Bo eeedeHuu orpaxeHbr aKTyanbHocm pa6orbr, IIeJrb ) 3ap'a.uv uccneAoBaHns.,HayqHa-{ HoBr43Ha, MeTOAbr r4CCneAOBa}{r4fi) TeOpeTHqeCKa.f, LI npaKTI{qeCKas3HAI{IIMOCTb, A TAKXE IIOIOXEHII,fl, BbIHOCIIMbIC HA 3AIIIIITY AI4CCEPTAqUOUUOfipa6o:rrr.Ilepeaa zflaaa nocBrqeHapaccMorpeHulo ocoSeusocrefi 3KcrlnyararJr4kraBr4arluoHHbrx fTA B ycnoBrr-f,x sanrlreHHofi aruoc$eprr fl nosrIueHHofrBJraxHocrt4, B qacrHocrr4, Ha rrprrMepe Cenepnofi ASpnxu.

BrrnoJIHeH oSsop pa6orro HccneAoBaHr{rc BIwrfrHLIfl. 3po3rroHHofo II3Hoca u BJIaXHOCTTT BO3AyXa HaxapaKrep :zcrkrKr4 KoMnpeccopoB tz f Tf .Bo emopoil znctle orll4cblBaerc-r paapa6oraHHafl. MeroAI4Ka yr{era Blrvrfllr^Lrfluocre4crnufi gpo3r{oHHoro LI3Hoca Ha xapaKTepLrcrLrKu oceBbIX KoMnpeccopoB.flpuueuxercx nosrrfi noAxoA ilnflMOAenHpOBaIdI'4fl XapaKTepa rI3MeHeHI4flfeoMeTpHrrecKrrx flapaMerpoB JIoIIaToK KoMnpeccopa npu 3po3I4oHHoM I43HOCe.flpe4cranJreHbr pe3ynbrarbr pacrrera Brfi4flHr4fl SpO3I4OHHOrO U3HOCa HaxapaKTepnc'trtttr oceBbrx KoMnpeccopoB, nonyr{eHHbre c noMo[Ibro paspaSorausofiMeTOArlKr4.B mpemueilenaee olr4cbrBaerc-rr p€Bpa6oraHnaq MeroAr{Ka oueHKI4 BlrzrfllouflBJraxHocrrr Bo3Ayxa Ha ceofictsa paSouero reJra r{ xapaKTepverkrKvr KoMrlpeccopa.Mero4urca ocHoBaHa Ha rroJrHoM yqere rz3MeHeHrr.{ ceoficre paSouero reila rroTpaKTy KoMrrpecoopa BcneAcrBr,re rr3MeHeHu{ BnarocoAep}Kanprfl..

IIpe4cranJIeHbIpe3ynbTaTbl pacqeTa BJrkrflIJLrfl BJIaxHocTr4 Ha xapaKTepkrcTLrKkr oceBblxKoMrrpeccopoB, flonyr{eHHble c IIoMo[Ibro paspaS oraunofi MerotrLrKl4.2B qemlepmo;t zna6eorrr4cbrBaercf pa3pa6ora:aerafl MeroAI4Ka pacrreraBbrcorHo-cKopocrHbrx xapaKreprrcrr4K TPAAO, rlo3Bonrloula{ [poBoAurbKOJrrrqecTBeHHyIo oIIeHKy BIrI4flHkIfl. 3pO3I4OHHO|O r{3HOCA Lt BITaXHOCTTI BO3AyXa HaxapaKTepvc'tLlKr ABufaTe[-s c yqeToM v3MeHeHIIfl xapaKTeprrcTHK KacKaAoBKoMrrpeccopa B pe3ynbrare BJrprflHufl, sTvtx Sar<ropon. Ha ocHoBe auarlrrvqecKl4xcooruourenafi [poBoArrrc, Aeralruufi aHaJrLt3 BrrLrfll,:'rfl, BnarocoAepxaHrlfl Hacnoficrea pa6o.rero reJra rro BceMy rpaKTy ABr4rarenf, r{ ycnoBllfl coBMecrnofi pa6orrrEfO 3JIEMEHTOB.B nnmoil zra6e rrpeAcraBJreHbr pe3ynbrarbrpacr{erHoro zccneAoBant4flBIMflHVtf.

3pO3HOHHO|O r{3HOCa Lr BIaXHOCTT4 BO3AyXa HA BbICOTHO-CKOpOCTHbIexap aKrep vervKrr ABr4rarent P f3 3 -2C.B euteodax orpur<eHbr ocHoBHbre pe3ynbrarbr Ar4ccepralll4ouHofi pa6orsr zpeKoMeHAyeTCfl r{crronb3oBaTb ktx Anfl nporHo3rrpoBaHl,.fl. 3KcrInyaTaIII4OHHbIXxapaKTepracrr4K TPAA@, ero rexHr{rrecKoro cocroflHllf, npl4 3Kcrlnyara\r4r4 BycnoBufl x 3arrbrJreHHofi aruoc$ eprr r4 IloBblllrensofi BnaxHocrl4.3na.uN{ocrb rloJryqeHubrx pe3yJr[,TaloBPe:ymrarbr ArrcceprarlrroHHofi pa6orbr qBrflrorc.f, 3HarrI4MbIMrr An-s pa3Brtruruanuaquouuofi HayKr4 Lr rexHr{KH. Pa:pa6oraHHbre nporpaMMbl 14 MeroAI4KI4rro3BoJr.rrlor orleHr4Tb Brrr4flHr4e pa3nr4trHbrx sKcnnyarallr{oHHblx $axropon HaxapaKrepurcrurKr KoMrrpeccopa v TPAAO.

Pesymrarbr rrccJleryoBaHrfl Moryr 6urrr4crroJrb3oBaHbr An.f, orleHKkr vr [porHo3lrpoBaHr4tr TexHr4rrecKoro oocroflHl4x TP[[@,a raKxe paspa6orKr4 peKoMenAarlufr rro rexHr4qecxofi 3KcnJlyararJprr4 B ycnoBrl{x3a[brlreHHofr arlroc Sepu I4 tloBbllrleusofi BnaxHo cr]I.docronepHocrb rroJryqeHHbrx pe3yJrbraroB pa6orrro6ecne.ruBaerc,LrcrroJrb3oBaHrreM r{3BecrHblx MeroAoB pacrrera rpexMepHblx rer{eHrafi B louarorlHblxMarrrrrHax, ocHoBaHHbrx Ha perxeHrrr{ r43BecrHblx ypanHenufi Hanre-CroKca,ocpeAHeHHbrx rro Pefrnonr4cy, nepn$zqprpoBaHHbrx fio 3KcrreprrMeHTaJIbHrIMAaHHbrM; rrpr4MeHeHHeM II3BeCTHbTX V npOBepeHHbrX MeTOAOB MaTeMaTI4rreCKOfOMoAenapoBa:akrs.

paSouero npoqecca TPAAO; nepu$zr<aquefi pe3ynbraroBBbrfroJrHeHHbrx pacqeToB c AaHHbIMr,r, rroJryrreHHblMl4 3KOnepzMeHTarIbHO.Percouen aanqlav [oucrloJrb3oBarrnro pe3y,'rbraroB \t BbIBoAoBArrccepraquoHuofi pa6oru.rrccneAoBaHWfl Moryr HMerb [paKTl4qecKoenpr4MeueHrae B opraHu3arlraflx aBna1.BLttarenecrpor.Iremnofi orpacnl4 (OAO(yM|IO), OAO <<KrzMoe) 14 Ap.) r{ 3Kcrrnyarr4pyroruvrx aBr4ar\r{oHHble ABI4rareJII,I BycnoBr{-flx :aurrneuuofi arnroc$eprr v nonrrurennofi BnaxHocrrr trpv srrcorofiTeMrreparype Bo3Ayxa, a raKxe rrcrroJrb3oBarbcfl B Bbrclrzx yveSurrx 3aBeAeHkrflx vyue6nrx rleHTpax npr4 noAroroBKe c[erlua[racroB rlo aBr{arIrroHHbIM ABI,IrareJI.f,M.Ilolyveuuue pe3ynbrarbrIlory.reuuue pe3yn6Tarbr Moryr rrerroJrr,3oBarbc{ lnflorlpeAeneHl,I-soKcnnyararlr4oHHbrx xapaKreplrcrrrK TPAAO rrpr4 prx 3Kcnnyarar\vtv B ycnoBlrflx3arrbrJreHHofi aruo c $eprr u rroBbrrrreuuofi BJraxHo crn.3anreqaurrfl rro Arrcceprauuousofr pa6ore :1.

B pa6ore He orpaxeHo Blrprfllaute r,r3MeHeHz-f, rxepoxoBarocrl4noBepxHocrr4 JrofraroK BcJreAcrBr4e 3po3rroHHofo r43Hoca Ha xapaKTepr4crvKkrKOMrrpeccopa.Pa:pa6or2.a:rrnafl.MeroAr{Ka HeH3HOO JTOIaTOK KOMrIpeCCOpa B 3aBHCI4MOCTI4 OTernporHo3l4poBarb epo:uonuutaKOHIIeHTpaIII4I4 rr COAepXAHVIfl rrbIJII4rro3BoJr-f,n aruoc$epe.3. BnpeAcraBJIeHbI KoHKpeTHbIe peKoMeH.{arJuLr ronoAAepxaHlrrc rpe6yeurrx napaMerpoB .qBl4rarenfl [pI4 ero 3KcrlnyaTar\hu ByonoBr4qx 3 albrJreHHofr aruoc Qepu u rloBbllxeusofr BJIaxHo crr{.YrasaHHHe 3aMerraHr4q ro Aprccepraunrr He aHzxalor uayvuofi IIeHHocrI,I urroJroxr4Teruuofi oqeHKI{ pe3ynbraron pa6oru.pa6o:reHe3arc;rroqeuraef,ra M.B.