Отзыв оппонента1 (Моделирование теплофизических процессов в высокочастотном ионном двигателе)

OT3hIBolpr4rlr{anbHoro o[[oHeHTa Ha AACCepTaUr4roKpyruona Kupu.n.ra llropenuvaOAEJII,IPOBAHI,IE TCITOQU3I.IqCCKI{X NPOqCCCOBe),npe.qcraBJreHH)'IoxHrrqecKprx HayKHaBBbICOKOqACTOTHOM IIOHHOMcoucKaHr,re yrreHofi crerreHl4 KaHAr4AaraIIo cnequaJrBHocTr4 05.07.05 - "TenroBbre, gneK'rpopaKerHbreI{faTeJII4 I4 3lreprOycTaHoBKI4 JIeTaTeJIbHbIX a[[apaToBrll.Arcrya.nrnocrb reMbr uccflelosaHr.rfi3nexrpzvecrrze paKerHbrexHriKe, Haqr{uaxcABr.rrarenr{.(3P{) ucnonl3yrorcr s KocNaa-recrofi70-x roAOB IIpOIIJIOTOCTOJIeTT.IJI,r4rru3ar\vltr op6uTrr r.cKycarBeHHbrx cIIyrErIKoB 3erunraAJrr KOppeKrILIu 14(I4c3). B cccp uan uau6oltureere ClI,{,pacnpocrpaHeHze IIoJirILIJILI ABI,IfaTeJIbHbie yCTaHoBKI4 HaTaK KaK gTor rr,r[ 4rnrarelefi o6la4aer Har4Menruet uesoi rsruJICKTPI4qECKA{ MOUIHOCTb, NOTPE6JI'EMA'ABI.IIATEJIEM, OTHECCHHAqKBEJIIIqI4HC).

flo uepe pa3Burrtfl xocl,rpr.recKofi TexHr4Kr.r MoulHocrb r,rcrorrHr4 KoBexrpllvecr<ofi 3Hepfrir4 Ha 60pry20 rBr Ha raKKAH€l3brBaeMbrxuefitlzfr ee pocr ao 50-100 xBr.zc3{nrsnerrpr,rqecKfie pa*erHbreerrbHbrM rzMnyrrbcoM (25 - 30eospacraer.ABr4BHacrosiqee BpeMf oHarrxeJrhrx l1tC3 u nporHo3vpyercsKoppeKr{r{uucra6urusa\nz op6ururareJrr.r AoJrxHEro6raaa*BbrcoKr,rMru/c).Bnocne4nee Aecrrrluerr4e gJleKTpr,qecKr,re paKerHLre ,4Br'fareJrr{ craJu4EH'T'C' B KAqECTBC OCHOBHOTO UCTOI{HI.IKA Tfl,ILI AIIfl MCXNJIAHCTHbIXETOB I,I IIOJICTOB B ,UAIbHI4ft KOCMOC.B grOU.{ 4onxen 6rrrr (30 -50) ru/c u 6oree.CJI}'qAC YAErrrUrTfi iIMIIYJIbCT,rI4Kpolre roro, conpelteHurieop[ooJraAarr BbrcoKr{M roe$$r.rquenroM [oJre3Horo getcrnurIrrr'rM pecypcorra. 3rarrarpe60nanrxv yAoBnerBoprrcT r4.H'bre(KIID.qB'rareJrr,r. B Pocczr orfi ABurarerrw paspa6arrtBarorc, s nil_l Ofyllt.tu<Ifenrps Htr4tr4 IIMD MAI4.

B I{eurpe Kelguura pa:pa6aruaarorc,r.rouHbreo6u-(t4t4 0f AE"it8x.llAtiA B IIWI |IMM MAVIcoKoqacrorHbre rzoHHbre ABrrfareJrrz (B.il,ID. llpu pa:pa6orre orr.ixnocrorHHofo roKa (I44lT),er4 BaxHo 3HaTb BeJrr4qrrHy TeMlrepaTypErn ee pacnpeAeneHtre Be yxe Ha srarre npoeKrr.rpoBaHr{r, 3ro suauNe oco6ennoueobxo,ur,rrr,tonpaBraJrbHofo uu6opa KoHcrpyKTr,IBHbrx napaMerpoB gJreKTpoAoB r4oHHo-nraqecxoft(LIOC).

llosronry co3AaHvecv cTeMbIMneparypHbrx norefts Btil4AHa ocHoBe MareMarrrqecKofi renrosoftBecbMa axryalruoi.CrenenrnoueH4aqufi,taxoilCosAaHueqI.ITe.[bHo coKpaTLIrE pacxoAbr Ha2.Mero.qr,rKr4 pacr{eraMo_rreJrr4MeroALrKr4 no3BojII4Tpa:pa6orxy B.il,IA.no.roxenn[,HayqHbrxOOOCHOBAHHOCTIIcQopuy.nupoBanHbrxBBbIBOAOB*rOcnosHureAnccepTarlHrr.o,I(eHl{f I BbIHOCHMble HA 3AIUIITV:.EanagcosatMo.ueJrLrrra3MoQu3rz.recKr.rxouusaquefi pa6overo reJraflpoqeccoB, o6ycloaleuurrxcaMocTo{TeJrbHoM T.IHAyKIIAOHHOM pa3prAe,BKJrroqaloulat asarzuo4eftcru{e qacrI4II: lIoHoB, gJieKTpoHoBeMeHraMr{ KoHcrpyKrlr.rr4B9I,I.{Cpa3Jrr4r{HbrMri$asilvecrrzvaa doronoeccsoftcrgai\4r.1.'Ten:roeat MoAeJI6, olpeAensrouarl cBt36 TelJloBbrx noroKoB Ha [oBeDxHocrt4ofr xauepu (fPK),oullccr4oHHoroeKTpoAoB c r,rHTetpurnbHbrMr4 xapaKTeptrcrr,rKaMv.(3O)uycxoparoqero (yD)Br{l1ATenroear pacqerHaf MoAeJrb BqI4A, AorrycKapr{a{ nocneAoBarenbHoeoxHeHi.Ie [yTeM [oBbrrueHr{s ypoBurr AeraJrr,r3arlrlr.rrONPI4OJIIIXCHIi'IKoMlbrorepnoroeeo6rerra c rone'+roi qelrroo6terra r< paspa6orannofiu.recKofi MoAeJrr,t, a npr4 co3AaHr.ru ,ra6oparopnofi tro4e_nu H K peaJrrHoMyKTY.Mero4uragKcrrepr,rMeHraJrbHofo a3MepeHr.rrCIIIHI,IX sJICMEHTAX KOHCTPYKIII4I4[tttBI{I4!reMleparypHbrx noreft eoC UCIOJIB3OBAHIiEM TENJIOBI,I3ODA.COCTABJIEHI,I' 6AIATTCOEOfi MOACIU TCIJIOBbIAEJIEHI4'IB3JICMEHTAXHCTPYKIII{IZ ABI{TATEJI' ABTOPOM AHCCEPTAIIPII4 TIIIATEJIbHO NPOAH'UII43IZPOBAHbI2Qusavecrue npoqeccbr a (fPK).TCII.,'IOBEIX IIOTOKOBI{OHOBI{HACTCHKLI3JIEKTPOHOBHAreMneparypbr 3neKrpoHoBIPK gearare;urro3BoJrr4Jr oflpeAer,rrlTb nJ.rorHocrbfPK, 33 U Y3rrOBCJIIZqVIATEI' iASEII4qUHOIaHaJrI,r3 $ZSUVeCXIXnpoqeccoBYKA3AHHbIE sJICMEHTbI ABVs fPK, TqaremnuftHC NJIOTHOCTI4 TOKArocJry)KuJr naAexnofi ocHosofi Anr paspa6orxu ren-rrosofi MoAerr,rBIIIIA.

B srofiTOKOM3ror auarusMoAeJrrz ycraHoBJreHa cBr36IIyqKa r,roHoBr.r3u cpe4nefi rerrrnepa:rypofiABr4rarersTor nyvra u Bg nrorquocr'MexAy Br{ laorqnocrbro pa3prAa,gJreKTpoHoBs fpK.3aAarorc-s B TexHr4rrecKoM 3aAaHLrr{ ua pa,spa6orxyABI{rareJIt' TeM[eparypa sneKTpoHoB onpeAenterct no ypaBHeHr{rc coxpaHeHr4q3HEPN4I,I. TATOfi NOAXOA[O3BOIqCT OIIPEAEJII4TbKOHCTPYKTI,IBHbIC Y3JIbI ABI{IATCJI';NJIOTHOCTI4 TEIIJIOBbIX TIOTOKOB BfPK, 33 U Y3C AOCTATO'THOi TOI{HOCTbIO.Be*'r'''Ha srr,rx rroroKoB orrpeAenrer reMneparypy yKa3aH'brx 3JreMeHToB.9ucreusrte pacqerbr 6Hru sHnor'e'br c noMou,lbro rrporpaMMHofo KoMrIJIeKcaANSYS' HAAE)KHOCT' KOTOPOTO HE B'I3'IBACT HI{ KAKIZX COI,tHEgUfi. AETOPYALICCEPTAIT'4U YAAJIOCb AOBCCTI,I AJII4TEJIbHOCTbPACqETAAO ABYX qACOB1IYTEMcoKpaqeHrzr fiqeeK crrera.

ocHosofi AJrr gTOrO fiocnyxr4no oflpeAeneHr]e pa3MepoBo6nacr:eft c MaJro rz3Meuxrorqefi cx :revneparypoil.AnsgKclepr4MeHTaJrb'oro onpeAereHus reMneparypbrTerrroBr43op.BunoycraHoBJreHo,Tor{Hocrbro MeHee506'nucnoJrb3oBaHqro1rrfr olpeAereHr4.,r reMneparypbr cneo6xo4ulrao LI3MepeHIze creneHl,I qepHorr,IHerrocpeAcrBeHHo r43foroBJreHHbrx 4era,refi.[:rx fpK MeroAr4Ka onpeAeneHri,creneHr'r qepHorbr 6rrna pa^:pa60rana.

o60cnoBaHHocrb noryqeHHbrx pe3yJrbraroBloATBepxAeHa TepMonapHbrMr4r,r3MepeHr4fi Mrz.3. {ocronepuocrr, r{ HoB[3HaEccJreAoBaHrrq, loJryrregHbrx pe3yJlbraroB,BbrBoAoB rl peKoMeHAaqufi, cQopuy.,,rupoBaHHbtx BAnccepraqr{fi.HoerzsHapa6orrr cocror,rr B ToM, qroMCTO.4I4KI] PACqETA TCMNEPAT}?cyx{ecrBoBano.AeropyBs poccurrHayqHo o6ocnoBasHoisJICMEHTAX KOHCTPYKIIIZI4Ar.icceprar{fir4 yAanocb co3Aarb?BIILIAraKyroHEMeroAr4Ky.AOCTOBepHocTb[onrreHHbrx pe3ynbTaToB roATBepxAeHar'r3Mepe'r{'rMrr reMrreparypbrfpK AB'rareJrr.nprMbrMrzpacxoxgenrze usuepenuoftTeMleparypbr t4 TeMneparyphr floryr{eHHoft n pacvore HeflpeBbrrxaer 5%.

3roO6CTOTTEN'CTBO YKA36IBAETHA TO, IITOI4crroJrb3oBarbc.a npupa:pa6orxe BgI4n.4' 3Ha'ruMocrbHayK[A.,'rqllparruvecxaxr.r[paKTr{Kr rroJryqe'Hbrx aBTopoM pe3yJrbraroB.3Haqr4MocTbexcnepuueuraarHofiTIPCANOXEHHilI METO.IIHKA MOXCTpa:pa6oraunofiaBropoMpacqeTHo-Kr4 orrpeAeneHr.r, TeMleparyp B gJreMeHT€xKoHcrpyKIII{Ir ABurareJlt cocrol{T B ToM, iITo c ee lloMorllbroMoxHo orIeHIzrEMeroAr4reMneparypy naz6oree Hafperbrx gJreMeHToB VIOC,a r,rMerruo pacnpeAeJreHrreTeMfieparyphl B gMLIcct4oHIroM gJreKTpoAenpoeKrr{poBaHrzr B\*ry,.croaMocrb paspa6orxv,I4ycKoprroqeM gJIeKTpoAe yxe Ha 3Tale3ruAaHHbIe no3BoJlrlor 3HaqI4TeJrbHo cHr.I3Iir6TaK KaK npu co3,qaHar4 onbrruoro o6pa:qa B[II4[YMCH'IIIACT qIZCJIO 9KCIEPAMCHTAJIbH'IX IrOAErrCft ABI4IATCJ'I, 14 BPEM,HAI4XI{CCJIeAOBaHI,Ie.5' Konrcpernbre peKoMeHAaIr[u uo ucrloJrb3oBa'firc pe3yJrbraroBr{ BbtBoaoBAnccepTarlI{u.Pesynrra*r pa6orrt peKoMeHAyercr r{cloJrb3oBarb flpu paspa.or:reo6pa:qoa3P{na ocHoBeBrII4[ c yAenb''rMJrerHbrxr4MrynbcoM en,ue 30rlur/c sfHLI(Dfyll <I{eurp Kerguura>, @fEOy BIIO <MocroscxrfirocygapcrnenHufiyHr4Bepcr4rer r4MeHa M.B.

JloMoHocoea>, @fBy<HauuoHalrnHiIrccrieAoBareJrtcxufi qeurp <<Kypvarorcxui r.rHcrr,rryr>,(DfyllOKE <(Daxea>.6. Oqenra coAepr(anufl Arrcceprarl[[, ee 3aBeprrreHHocrrr.Pa6ora lpeAcraBnser co6oi pyronvcr o6lerr.rov143 c:rpanuqri ner{aT'oroTeKcra, BKJrroqar 74 pucyuxa, 16 ra6nuq, aTaKxecrrrjcoK utrupyetrofiJll'ITeparypbr, coAepxaqr{fi 85 HazNreHosawuk. o],jta BKJrroqaer eilerblpe pa3Aena' 3aKJrIoqeHIre,Boace6lanegenue,raKxe cnvcoK u cnoJib3oBaHHbIX ucToqHuKoB.BBeAeHr4t4 npLrBoArrrcr o6ocHosaHae a*TyaJrbHocrr,r reMarrrKr4Ar4CCeprarIrloHHOrO pIccJIeAoBaHI{fl, KpaTKOe9KCIIepI4MeHTanbHofoI,IrpobretmroIII4CaHI4epacqeTHo-TeopeTllqecKofo t4ccIleAoBaHI,LflpoqeccoB, rrporeK€rrotqux rrpzl pa6oreB{IIA.TEIIJIOB6IXOnzcHeaerc.{CTEIICHbpa:pao0rairuocrz ras6paHuofi relrLl, sopvyrlzpyrorcr rleJrr.r u 3ara.tlu,HOBI'I3Ha' TeoperrzqecK€ulMeTOAOJIOTUTIr,IpI npaKTxirecKarHayrTHaA3HaEIr,rMocrb pe3yJrbraror pa6oru,MeTOAbr Ar.rccepTailr4oHlroro i4ccJre.qoBaHr4r,NOJIOXEHI4.fl,BbrHocr4Mbre Ha 3aulr,rTy, AocToBepHocTL [O,rryqeHHhrx pe3yJibTaToB, pearv3ar]'uAuBHeApeHr4e pe3yJrbraroBcBeAeHr4qo6 anpo6aqrzupa6orrr, luqnufi BKJtaa corrcrareJ,rr.

coo6qatorcapa60ru u ny6tuxa4usx aBTopa, r.r3Jrafaerc, o616rr,r r.rcrpyKrypa Aucceprarlprr4. B rIepBoM pa3AeJIe OnI{CbIBaIOTC' TexHIITIeCK[exapaKTepI4crLIKI4 H3BecrHbIxBYI4,{, ux npeuMyqecrBa u HerocrarKx [ocpaBHeHIlIo c 6onee pac[pocrpaHeHHllMl4 r4oHHbrMr4ABrzrareJrrMr4 Ha locrornHoMrore.

llpueoAltrcr onucauze reuo$a:uqecKrrx[poqeccoB, rrporeKarotur4e npr4pabore ABr'rrarer.s B pa3r{r{Hbrx y3rax ero KoHcrpyKrlr{[. rlpano4urcro6sopcyuecTByrotqHx pacqeTHbrx TeuroBbrx uo.qe,rei. (DopvynupyercrnocraHoBKa3AAAITU TCIJIOBOTO MO,4EJIAPOBAHI4'ITelJroBbrx flpoqeccoBr4gKcnepIZMeHT€LIIbrIOfo r4ccJrenoBaHr4'a Br{I4{.

Bo aroporrrpa3,qene [pr4BoAr4rcr r.r3JroxeHr4 epaspa60rauHoft rennosofi pacveruofi MoAeJr, fipoqeccoB.B nto4errzrrepeuoc reflJraBKoHcrpyKrIZuTerlJrorlpoBoAHrru cuoco6oM,aB.[,IAocyulecrBrrercrraKxe qepe3KoHTaKTHbrenpri'rro,nr{r4cTbrMrz3 rrJra3M'r pa3pfl,.a,HA NOBCPXEOCTII PA3JII,IqHbIX SJICMCHTOBPA6O'[E qUCJIEHHbIMONPCACJI'}OTC' TCMIIEPATYP'I B ,JICMEHTAX KOHCTPYKIIIIUypaBHe'r'r renJronpoBoAHocrr4,ocnosHrrN{z [apaMerpaMaa3alr4car{HoroBgI4[plcoIIpoTrrBlieH14r.Onpegelxrorcr BbrpaxeHr.rr AJr{ TeruroB'rx noroKoBBIIUA.

Brrror,rAyqueO6PASOrr,rNY'CU PE,'EHI.Sa sopve ypaBHeHr,r,Ilannaca.npeAraraelrofi TelnoBou MoAe,rrI4 rBJlriorc,3Har{eHI4r gao.{zMofi BV lrorqnocru u I{.HHO.OTOKa r.r3 ABr,rrareJrr. 3TO gHSnaHoTeM' rITo, KaK [paBr4no, oHrr 3aAarorcr npr{ pa3pa6or*eBTII,IA. KpoueItoryr 6uTI, Ir3MepeHbr npz orpa6orKe.qBr{rareJrr.pe3yJrbrar pacr{era reMneparyp B MOAeJTbHoMcepur pacqeroB reMrreparyp BABr4fareJreroro ox'B pa:4e:re rrpLrBor.flTcrlBril4A-16. Buno,rueriaMoAeJrbHofi Koncrpyrrlr{rr 8r{14A_16cqenlrooooc'oBaHr{r ynporqenraft r,rBo3MoxHoro6oluleropacueruofi MO..eJrr4, CAera'Hbrx nn,^0uyiqenzficorpaueHr4, o6telra cqera.

B rperreM pa3AeneIIpI'IBOAtrct pe3yJiETarLi pacireroB TeMneparypHbrxnonefi B TerIJioBEIX MOaeJr{xpa^:pa6ar'naeMbrx B HI4I'I IrM3 MArl rpexABr,rarenefi Bgz.{ pasHoiiMOrrIHoCTr' c ArraMerpaMrr r{oHHoro nyvxa g,16 u 4g cv. yncrennrre pacqerblTeMrleparypBABl4fareJrrx no3BoJrHJr4 0:rpa60rarr pacirerrryrc MOAeJ,rb,uonpe'qenr'rrb npeAeJi'Hyro Beralrr4 Hy Bg naour'ocrr4,,,pu xoropofrBMarepr{aJra gJreKTpoAoBI40c voNnoKar{ecrBeucrroJr*3.Barb rnranoarr[ cnnae BT1Paccqr.rrannrre npoSunu reM[eparyp rlo paAaycy4lr-f, 3O aAJit peuerr{r repMoMexan[.Iecrofi3aftavuy3_4.ucnolmoB.urr4cbycroivunocru gneKrpoAoBrrplrpaspa6orxe s MAtrI yK,BaHHbrx4rrzrarelefi. B 3TOM pa3AeJIe [prlBonr4Tc, TaK )I{erenJrosofi pacqer AJUr ABurareJrrnoft ycranorKr4Ha OcHoBe BriI4,{ c rr4aMerpoMnyvxa 8 cM, [JlaHLIpyeuofi 4na npl4MeHeHr4t B cocraBeKocMliqecKoro alnapara.rpore4eHurre pacqer'I [oKa3aJrIr, qro npeAJloxeHr{arMeroAIrKaonpeAereHl4,TeMneparypHblxnolefi Bs.rreMeHTaxB'[,IABIIOIHe npLIMeHI,IMa!.,IrsonpeAeJleHlrt reMneparyp6l 6rioroe, r4g Koropbrxcocrour ABHrareJrbHa,ycraHoBKa' B veteeprou pa3Aene flplrBoAlrrc{orlr4 caHae gKcneprzMeHTar,r'H'rxIrsuepeuafr reMfleparyprrbrxnolei e fpKr,r 3neKrpoAax VIOC ABirareJrr.I4:lrepenu.a reMreparyp [poBoAr4nr4cb IIpI,rrroMorq[ rennoBrz3opa I.LIRSC645.onacana MeroArrKa uslrepenufi 14 pe3yJibrarbru:vepenufi.

rlorasaHo, .{roI43MepeHHbre TeM[eparypEr B m3opa3prAHOftxarr,repe3Haqe'r4rMrrcTOqHOCTbTo 5%o. ?rorAocroBepHocrr.t [peAJroxeHHoftpe3yJrbralcoBlaAaror c pacqerHbrMr4cBkI AereJlbcrByervero4axu pacrrera reMneparyppeKoMeHAaiIv[, c4elannrtx Ha ocHoBaHrrr,r pacqeroB.o urrcorofrs BgI4nHluccepragnxIIoKa36IBarolIIzMrBiI.{eTctB03MOXHOCTbKOHCTPYKTI4BHbIX Y3JIAXBTIOJIHEpaclreraBlItrIA. IUCCEP.AI.,N3AKOHqEEHbIMpac[peAereHrz.rrreMrreparypbrBHANI,ICAHA XOPOIJJIZM JII4TEPATYPH'IMorMeTr{Tb, qTo ocHoBHbIe p$ynbTaTblfl3brKoM. Cne4yerr4ccJieAoBaHr.reM,AI,ICCepTarIr4oI{HOrOprccreAoBa'rrt n neo6xo4ulroM KorlzrrecrBeony6lzroaaHbl HayiIHEIX XypHiuax,BAK,PCKOMEH.4OBATTUTTXAarope$eparc14AOKJIAA'IBAJIITC' HA MEX.qYHAPOAH'IX XOHdEPEHTIIA'X.4ocrarovHoi norHotoft oTpaxaeTocHoBHOe co.qepxaHr4eI[CCepraqr4r4.7.