Отзыв оппонента (Моделирование теплофизических процессов в высокочастотном ионном двигателе)
Описание файла
Файл "Отзыв оппонента" внутри архива находится в папке "Моделирование теплофизических процессов в высокочастотном ионном двигателе". PDF-файл из архива "Моделирование теплофизических процессов в высокочастотном ионном двигателе", который расположен в категории "". Всё это находится в предмете "технические науки" из Аспирантура и докторантура, которые можно найти в файловом архиве МАИ. Не смотря на прямую связь этого архива с МАИ, его также можно найти и в других разделах. , а ещё этот архив представляет собой кандидатскую диссертацию, поэтому ещё представлен в разделе всех диссертаций на соискание учёной степени кандидата технических наук.
Просмотр PDF-файла онлайн
Текст из PDF
OT3hIBoQzrlnarbHofo onloHeHTa Ha .qucceprarlr4ro Kpyrnona Kupurra Zroperuva<<Mo4eruponanze rerro@u:zuecr<zx npoqeccoB B BrrcoKorracrornoM I4oHHoMABr{rareJre)), npeAcraBneHrryro Ha corzcKaurre yveHoft crerreHr4 Kar^AvAa a rexHr,rlrecKr4xHayKcreqr.rmbHocrr4 05.07.05Tenronrre, 3neKrpopaKerHbre ABr{rareJrr4 rl3HeproycTaHoBKI4 JIeTaTe[LHBrX amraparoBno-[uccepraquouua;r pa6ora Kpyr.rrona K.I,I.
nocssueHa r,IsyqeHrto $usuvecrofirrprlpoAbr ra paspa6otce Mo.qeJrr4 Te[JroBErx npoueccoB, rrporeKfforqux BBrrcoKoqacrorHoM r.roHHoM ABnrarene (Br{I4D, rrro rBJrrerc{ BecbMa aKTyaJrbHbrM HeTOJTbKOAJI' pAotn peHrr.' Har{HoroHayqHo-TexHl{llecKux 3aAaq3HaHvfl> Ho 14s o6racruAIltBo3MoxHOCTr4ynpaBJreHr4fl IIoJIeroMrrpeIIIeHXr pr,qay,qJIIzHeHIuI cpoKoBaKflrBHofo cyqecTBoBaHl,rr KocMr4qecKr4x anlapaToB.AnryarbHocrb reMrt Alrccepraul{u cBr3aHa c Heo6xo4uuocrblo pa3Brrrl.rtTexHoJrorurr B9tr4[, o6laaaroqeft pl4ou rexHoJrorfiqecKax 14 gKcnJryararlnoHubrxno cpaBHeHr4lo c rexHonor[efi uonnrrx ABllrareJrefi c pa3prAoMrrocro.rrHHoro rora (I,I[T|I). O6e sru KoHKypupyoqr4e rexHorrorru noJryqr4rrr.r Bnpel{MynlecrBHacrorrueenpenrnau6oJrbrrree paclpocrpaHeHrre.
I{e.rrecoo6pasHocrr paspa6orruTexHoJrorur4 BbrcoKolracrorHbrx r4oHHbrx ,qer4rarerefipa3Br4Tusore.recrseHHoI r<ocuuqecrofireHAeHrlv.f,Mr.rTexHr,rKr4.Peqen:upyenral Ar4cceprarlur cocrol,IT@opuynuponxe nocraBJreHubrx(Br{I4D o6ycnouenar.rqerbrpex fJraB rr 3aKJrroqeuur.r43 BBeAeHI4.f,,perxeHHbrx B Ar,rccepraur,rrr sagau cnoco6crnyrorcBeAeHI4t, cucreMarr,I3rlpoBaHHbre aBTopoM Bo BBeAeHutr14 I -ofinpo6leuax 3KclepI,IMeHTa!'IbHoro fi pacirerHo-Teoperr4qecKoromaBe ,4l4cceprarlr4r4, ouccneAoBaHl,t-fi TeIrnoBbIXnpoqeccoB, rrporeKaloul[x npr4 pa6ore BTIUA, neo6xoguuocrrlMoAenl4poBaHr,rr g.rrx nu6opa MareplrajroB Ha grarre [poeKTItpoBaHuA,Kpr4Tr4qecKux 3JreMeHToB KOHCltpyKrIr4r4 ABnrAreJrtTeMneparypbl,a TaKxe AJI' perneHurnocyrlecrByronpeaeJrbHofi serr,rqzHe pa6o.refi(KA). flpunog.rrcrflpoqeccoB, nporeKarotuux npr4 pa6orelr4x pacqerHbrx rerrJroBbrx uoAelefi lrgKonepr.rMeHTffrbHr'rx AaHHbrx,orucaHr4eABr,rrareJrr,o63op[oJD4reHHbIX paneeQopuylzpyercr nocraHoBKaMoAeJrI4poBaHI4t I'I SKcnepxMeHTa!'IbHoro [ccJreIoBaHrlt TenJloBbrxB mare 2 rrpwrogttcx oBbrrBJreHIrJrBonpoca TerrJroBofo conprxeHr4r ABvfaTeJrr c,qpyrr,rMt4 cr4creMaMr4 KocMr,rr{ecKoro annaparaTerrJro(pr43r,rqecxr,rxnrflTerrJroBoro3aAA9lUTenJTOBOfOIIpoleccoB s BrIZ,4.ucaque renJroBofi pacqerHol MoreJrr4, nocrpoeunofi naocHoBe yqera pzrJrrrqHbrx $r.isz.recrux MexaHr43MoB rrepeHoca reIrJIa BoEfitilri 0J_tu\freL_E :mcIll{AyKrIr4oHHhrM BblcoKoqacrorHrrM pa3prAoM.
O6cyx,4aercr MareMarr{qecKatlocTaHoBKa 3aAauu, o6ocuonaHHocTb rpaHl,rqurxycrowti u cxeMbr rrLIciIeHHoro pacqeTa.fnana 3 sBrserc . Hau6olee o6tdusofi u coAep)KareJrbHofi rnaeoft 4accepraqura. Bneil npe4crauenrrpe3yn6Tarbr pacqeroBArzaMerpaMr4 r.roHHbrx rryqKoB.rpex lrogelefi BVI,I.{ cPacqeru npoBeAeHbr ,qlrx perneHr4rBorrpocoB IIpr4MeHr4MocrrI Bbr6paHHbrx MareprziuroB gneKTpo,qoBpa3nvrrHbrMr,rnpaKrr4qecKr{xI{3JreMeHToBKoHclpyKrlr4fi paccMarpr.{BaeMrrx trogelefi Ha pa3rnrrHbrx peNulrax pa6orrr 1nararelefi.B trase 4onucaua crteuuaJlbHo pa:pa6oranuax MeroIVKarenJroBr43l4oHHbrxI43MepeHl'rfr, no3BonvBIIIat nonyql{Tb 3KcnepI{MeHTaJIbHEIe AaHHbIeIIoI{3MepeHLIIoTeMneparyp o6pa3qoB sJreMeHToB tconcrpyrqufi r4ccJre.qyeMbrx r.rogeleii ABr.rfareJrbHbrx6roxoe.,[ocronepxocrr u o6ocnonan'ocrb noryqeHHblx B Al4cceprarlr4lr p$yJrbraroBo6ycloeneurr ucnoJrbsoBaHI,IeM B 3KcnepuMeHTax coBpeMeHHoro rr3MepI4TeJr6HoroTerrJroBu3HoHHOrO KOMrrneKCa, npoayMaHHocrbroSKCNEPI,IMCHT{UIbHbIX AAHHbIXNOMerorr4r ra:uepenr.rftONPEAEJIEHI{IO CTCIIEHI4 qEPHOTbITenJloBofo Ll3 yqeEur ,{JIt gJreMeHToB KoHcrpyKIII{u BHLI4vpacqerHbrxr.rvo6pa6orruUI,HTIIKIj'IP],1IC:I,Ia raKxecxoAl,IMocrbloSKcnepr4MeHTaJrbHBIX pe3yJrbTaTOB.K no:ryuenHrrrraB ar4ccepraur,roHHoiipa6ore nau6oree 3Harrr{M6rM HoBr,rM HayqHbrMpe3yJrbTaTaM MoxHo OTHeCTT4 CJreAylo lr4e:-npe,uJroxeHauo6ocnosaHa 6a,'rancosas MoaeJrr, nnasuo$usuvecKr{x rrpoqeccoB,IIPOTEKAIOqI4X IIPI4 CAMOCTO'TEJIbHOM I,IHAYKUI4OHHOM PA3PflTCBBbICOKOqACTOTHOMI{OHHOM AB14raTeJlel-pa.:pa6oraua renJroBar MoAeJrb, onpe,qeJrrrorlar cBr3b reruroBbrx rroroKoBnoBepxHocrr,r m3opa3ptAHot KaMepblr{HTerpiurbHbrMu xapaKrepucrrrarraznHa)JleKrporoB r4oHHo-onrl4rtecxofi cucreuu cBr{I{1, c 6olrllroft ToqHocrbro r43MepreMbrMr4B3KCnepI,IMeHTe;-NPOBCAEHbI BT,]TII4CJII4TEJIbHbIC 3KCIICPIZMCHTbI NO I4CCJICIOBAHI,IIOPACNPE,qCJICHI,I'T€MneparypHbrxABr4rareirr-norelBII4A-B Mo.qeJrrxgnnrare;refi BTIpIA MM, BTII4I- 16 u rpoeKrr4pyeMoro49 M;PA.:PA6OTAHA OPUII{H{UIbHUUI MCTOII4KA 3KCNEPI4MCHTTeMneparypHBrxTCIIJ1OI]I43ODA:nolefBo BHeIITHI4x 3JreMeHTax KoHcrpyKrllrr4IbHOIOI,BMCPEHII'BHI,I! c rroJrb3oBaHr4eM-noryqeHo coriracoBaHrre pe3yJrbraroB qI4cJIeHHbIX pacqgToB nonefr TeMneparypnpoer upyeMblx KoHcrpyKrlr{rx3KCnepr.rMeHTaJrbHbrx r{3MepeHl{fiBqI4A pa3rllqHhrx MolrlHocrefi cBAaHHhrMI4.Ocnosusarcr Ha npeAcraBJreHHbrx pe3yJrbrarax al4ccepraul4ouHofi pa6oru, uoxnocy.qrnrlo3Haqr,rreJu,HoMo6'rene npoBeAeHHbIX KoMnJIeKcHbrx HaytIHbIX pacrlerHo-3Kcnepr.IMeIrraJIBHLIx IzccJleAosaHuilaaropa.Zu 6Hru lro AocroIIHcrByorleHr4Tb;ruqnrrft BKiraAr4'IpyAsrrnorHeH Becb KoMnJreKc 3Kcnepv MeHTaJrr,Hhrx pa6or, [ocrpoeHblpacrreTubre Mo,qeJrr4rrBbrrroJrHeHbr KoMnbroTepHbre pacqeTbrAJrr Tpexruo,qenefi4nurareleft.flparcrnvecrcaq 3HaquMocrb pe3yJrr,TaroB pa6oru 3aKJrroqaercrBLlcnoirb3oBaHl,lu pa:pa6oraHuux pacqerHbrx uonereft N MeronoB TenJloBbtx rasvepeHufi nHI4OKP tt OKP atrs npoBe,[eul,It aHaJrn3a Brrur.nrrs.
Marepr,raJroB, ux renro(pzsr.recr<r,rxcnoficrn, KoHTaKTHbrx repMoconporr4sreul4fi Ha reMneparypy B Kpr.rrrrqecKl4x SJIeMeHTaxBqI,IA. flolyuennue pac peAeJreHnr reMneparyp 3neropoloBrepMoM€xaHr,rqecKr.rx pacqerax ysnonrrcnoJrb3oBaHbrBI'IOC BI{UA MM, BqI4I-16 u BHLII, MorrlHocrbro15-20 xBr.llo.qucceprarlur4 MoryT1). Pecypc pa6orrr6u'rr clelaHu cJreAyroque 3aMeqaHuq:Br{I{.{ n gsaquremnofiMepe 3aBucrrrorrrJrorHocrr4 MorrlHocrrrnep$apr.{Hbrx r.roHoB, BbrHocr4Mbrx Ha noBepxHocrb ycKopsrcuefo slerrpoaa (Y3).KaxouucpaBHr4TeJrbHble oueHKr4BMaAa gToro MexaHrr3Ma 9po3t4ltyO 1rrpaccMorpeHHbrx B Arrcceprarlura uo.qelefi Asrararerefi ?2). B ,qr.rcceprarlr{r4, HecMorpr ua orpottrrrft o6reu upegcT aBJreHHBrx Marepr4{uroB, HeyAeJreHo Mecra cpaBHr4telssofr oUeHKe AocroBepHocrr4 pe3yJrbraroB, noryqaeMbrx cnoMorqbro pa:pa6orannofi MoaeJrr4.
I-{enecoo6pasno 6brro6u norasarrnper4MyuecrBanpeAJrafaeMofo noAxoAa Ha ocHoBe cpaBHeHr,rr c pe3yJrBTaTaMr4 MoAeJrr.rpoBaHur ApyruxaBTOpOB.3). Zsnecrno, qroBeJrI4trI,IHa KoHTaKTHoropacnpeleJreHve reMneparype c6opuoftconporr4BreHrl.s Moxer cIrIbHo BJrrrrrb HaKoHcrpyKrluu.KOHTaT(rHhre conportrBJreHr4[ 3a4aBarvcb B Br4ae KoHcraHT,Berl4quHe npoBoruMocrtr KoHTaKToBatrrllpunocraHoBre3aAarracoorBercrByrol(I4x o6parHofipa3nr4qH6rx MarepuanoB.Buecre c reM,3Tr,r3HaqeHI4t MoryT cyIIecrBeHHo trcMeHilr;cfl npr4 4eQopvaqzu 3JreMeHToB B npoueccepa6orn B97I!. BaprupoBaJrrrcbprvx3:r.aq,eHLrt nyKa3ana pa3MepHocrr npoBolr4Mocrr4 KoHTaKTa[K]pac.rerax? B gasr4c[vocru (2.41) ne:Br/(nr2K).c4).
Atts o6ocHogaH[t cAeJIaHHoro aBTopoM nu6opa MeroAa u3MepeHI'Is reMneparypIzoIIoJrb3oBaHI4eM TenJIoBI{3opa, cJleaoBzrno 6u npoBecrl4 6olee no4po6r*rficpaBHr4TeJrbHbritattutug rotlHocrl4 TepMorlapuoro, nlrpoMerpurlecKoroLrTENJ]OB14314OHHOf O METO.IIOB5). Ocrancr HeBbItcHeHHbIM Bonpoc, o KoropoM ynoMvHaer caM aBTop, oBKJIaAecorne.rHofi paliyra\w B SHepf err{qecKl,Ifi 6a,raHc.CAelannsre 3aMeqaHl4t He cHl{xaror AocroaHcrB Al4ccepraul,IoHuoft pa6oru, uocrrpeKoMeH.qareJrrusrfi xaparrepI{ Moryr 6rrrr npuHmu Bo BHI{MaHI4e npl4 rrpoAorxeHlzl4pa6or 4annoro HanpaBJrerutr.Bue.rrolr [peAcraBJreHHar aBTopoM pa6ora flBrr'erct coaep)I(areJlbHbrM14opr4fI,IHiIJIbHbrM rrccJreAoBaHr{eM, oTII4qaIouII4MCt oI4cTeMHOCTbIO nOAXOAOB B peIXeHIIUnocTaBJleHHbIX 3AIAqVTnIaTeJTbHOCTbIOB pa3paooTKe MeTOAI{K SKCnepLI MeHTaJIbHbIXuouepeunfi r4 MeroaoB pacqera.
.{uccepraqzr npe.qcraBJleHa sa 143 crpaHuuax,Brrrroqaer 74 pucynxa, 16 ria6xuu u cna6xeHa cnucKoM qurapyeuofi .nrzreparypu us 85HauMeHoBaHufi . AeropeQepar Ar{cceprarlnucoorBercrByer ee co,qepxaHl{ro.FIa ocuoaauuu BbrrrrecKa3aHHoro Mox{Ho 3aKJrroqr4Tb, qro .ql4cceprauuouua,a pa6oraK.l,I. Kpymona tBrqerct BID(HrIM HayqgbrM uccneAoBaHr4eM,riHayqHoM ypoBHevMerorur4M aKTyrrJrbHoe AJrr KocMr4qectcoftnprrMeHeHrre. .{Nccepraqr.rnperrrBJrreMbrMKorpaclrnpaKtuqecKoeK.I,I.
Kpyrnooa orBertaer aceu rpe6onaHuqv BAKKaHnr,rrarcKt4M ruccepraur.rrM, a ee aBTopKpyrnon 3acnyxr4Baer lpucyxAeHurnoBBTIoJTHeHHLIM Ha BbIcoKoMcreur4aJrbHocrt4 05.07.05SHepfoycTaHoBKI,I reTaTeJrLHLIX-errayP(D,- Kupurr tr4ropenuuyuenofi crerreHr4 KaHrrirara rexHrzr{ecKux HayK<<Tennonrre, 3JrercrpopaKerHbre ABr{rareJrr4*ralrraparoB)OQrzqrza.nnnui or[oHeHT,Aorcrop rexH.
Hayx, npo$eccopraQe4pu Teruoqpraszru Mtr4@14;I 15409 r. MocKsa. Kaurupcxoe u., a.3 I .HI4flV \M@1{ rer. (495)-788 -5 6-99* 90e-mail : OVMitrofanova@mephi.ruflo4nucs yAocrogcrrlrenbO.B. MurporfanonaBe pFgajlbHx(aA0hyl,4eHTaq 0HH0f0 06e3ar\4HaHtAqy MUA??4-g;l;Ye{:g\h"tt'$,g$aq. td,, &ot7 fr,a,*,1 -.
