Отзыв ведущей организации (Моделирование теплофизических процессов в высокочастотном ионном двигателе)

<<YTBEPX,4AIO)3aMecTlrTenb Ar.rperoopanayvnofi pa6oreP.A. CaHAyOT3bIBBegyrqei opraHv3arlr4r4Ha ar.rcceprar{rlroKpyrnora Kupr.rrra UlropeBr.rqa''MOreru.IPOBAHI4E TETIO<DA3I{TIECKI4X IIPOTECCOB B BbICOKOTIACTOTHOMHOHHOMpLITATEIE",npeAcraBneHHofi Ha concKaHr4e yqeHofi crerreHr4 KaHAHAara rexHr4qecKnx HayKno cnequaulbHocrl4 05.07.05-<Tenronrre, 3JlelopopaKerHbre ABr4rarenz u 3HeproycraHoBKr4JIeTareJIbHbx annaparoB)'Pa.apa6orr<a BbrcoKoqacrorHbx r r.roHHr,rxpa3Br4Tltr,r4nnrareaefi (Btil4D-HoBoe HanpaBJreHr4erexHoroft4[ 3neK'rpuqecKr{x paKerHbrx grvrarelefi (3P{) n Poccufrcxofi@e4epaqr.rlr.Texnonorvq 3P,{, pa-:nrzrue roropofi HaqaJrocb B KoHrIe 50-x rogon fipornJroro BeKavuclryreoKa3aJlacbarounofigHeprurr4(rnacro-erqee rperr.rrvpesnr'uafino nlo4ornopuofi.yqeHbre r{ r.rHxeHepbt.Bee pasnurue 6onrnofiB nacroxrqee BpeMr 3neKTpopaKerHbrena 6a.ge crauuoHapHL'rx nJra3MeuH6rx ABr4farenefi3aAarl KoppeKlll{lrr4crroJlb3oBaHl4HI{I-! <Kypvarorcrufiop6zrrt orevecrBeHHbxt 6rrAO 6u(cn{)Bzncrrary"r>),BKJTaA BHeoJII{ coBsTcKve.4Br,rrareJrbHbreycraHoBru(3p[v)rxlrpoKo npr.rMerurrorcr Anr peureHr4toKoJIo3eMHbrx KocMr4qecKrrx a[naparoB(KA).

Ees ruHeBo3MOXHO IIOAAep)I{aHr4e KocMI4qecKI4X CI4CTeMo6pa:onaHHsrx reocraqr.roHapHbrltrBKA. TesaeH\r4v pagBwrur xocr"lraqecxofiCBL3A,TexHlrKH rpe6y,rorpa,spa6orxu u [pr{MeHeHr.rr Anrrarelefi c 6olee BbrcoxlrM yAcJrbHbrM uMrryJILcoM TtrI4, .{eM ycoBpeMeHHbrxcfl!, gnro6ecneqeHuq Anr4TeJrbHr,rx cpoKoB ar(IvBHoro cyulecrnonanza KA.3rurpe6onanna onpeAeiurror flepcreKr]rBbr npr4MeHeHkr aoHHbrx 4eurarerefi (lI{), npa:pa6orre Koropblx [pI,IHI4Masr yqacrne co]4cKareJrb.

Pa6orrr no co3AaHr.rrc Bq]IA na,{arr-rcr sPoccnftcrofi @e4epaquuoxBarHJrr4s r*pl IIM3 MAI4orgocri:reJrbHo HeAaBHo- n2010ncpa3vpa3pa6orry gelrrareaefi rraorqnocTr,ro or HecKoJrbKrrx coren Ba.rr,4o 15-20 xBrHa 4aHnolr erane paspa6orxa BrIH{ 6onruoe 3HaqeHue r4Megr MoAe-rrr4poBaHr4e.cos4anue Ha,qe)(Hr,rx tfusuro-lrareuarnqecxfix 14 pacqernbrx uo4erefi, onr4cbrBaK)r]Irrxpa3Jrr4qH6re npoqeccbrno BLIZA, wx anpo6a4ua unpr4MeHeHr.reHa craAurt npoeKrr4poBaHrdIO3BOJI'ET CHI,I3IITb PI,ICKI4 NPI,I PA3PA6OTKC KOHCIPYKIII,II4, CAKOHOMLITL.PP9UT.]4CPCACTBA HAFffffi1iffi*,g:r;4rpa3pa6orKy.

,{rEccepraqna nocBrrrleHa paspa6orxerenrto$rEsr.rvecrrlx npoqeccoBpa3MepHocrr4.Bro B\IHA -@3AaHr4roaanpo6aqura MeroAHKlt pacqqrarenrtosofi rraoaenrl B1II,IA pa,:luvuoficngre LI3JIoxeHHoro, pemaeMa:r B Ar4cceprarlux sa4aua .rpesnrruafinoaKryilJrbHa.Cnoxnocr, cro.aqefi nepeA cor.rcxareneM3aAarrr.r,ro6yclonaena neo6xo4lrrvrocrrropruKax TennoBofi lro4enu co3AaHur HaAexlrrrx pacrleTHbrx rrrogenei renlo$asrzvecrzxnpoqeccoBno BWIA:[Jra3MeHH6rx, o6ycroBreHHbrx raoxusaqrEefi pa6overo reJraBcaMocrotreJlbHoM I.IHAyKIIHoHHoM pa3ptAe, TenJroBbrAeJreHur npn nsarauogefrcrBr,rn nJriBM[,r csreMeHTaMli KoHcrpyKqr4r.i,r4cnonb3yeMr,rxBIr,c yqeroM pa3HopoAHoro xapaKrepaBr{2.{ lrarepuaaon.

Yxe 3To noAqepxrrBaer HoBr.r3Hyco6crBeHuo, TeruroBbrxKoHcrpyKr1rrunpoBeAeHHofo uccJIeAoBaHr4rr.,{uccepraurorr.l coBeprxeHHo o6ocnoeaHo yrBepx4aercr, qro noaoxanelugrrftp$yJrbTaT B perxeHr{l.t yKa3aHHbx npoolerrl Moxer 6Hrr AocTr4fHyr Ha ocHoBe3Kcnepr.rMeHTilJrbHo-pacqerHoro uccneAoBaHrlr, BKJrroqarculeroTenJroBblAeJreHHrB3JreMeHTax KoHcrpyKuHHBLIHA ssanr\ao4eficrsyouaxo6o6rqennoft ruoqenu rennotf H3r{qecKlrx flpoueccoBpa3MepHocrlr,paspa6orxy noAelefiBcnlasnofi, xKoHcrpyKrlr.rrx BTIZA pasnnvnofia raKr(e paspa6orryMeroAuK 3Kcnepr.rMeHTitJrbHoro olpeAeJreHruTeM[eparypHbrx pacnpe,qenenufi n o6pasqax BqaA.

B AHcceprarl]rll 3Tor noAXoA K perrreHr4royKiL3aHHbIx npo6lena peanl43oBaH.Amop o6ocHoral ocnonnofi noAxoA K onpeAeneHriro floror(arauepu (f?K) u snerrpoAH BgH,{ vepes sa4anaeuufi naMorrlHocrH Ha creHKr.r rasopa.sp.rguofi3Tane npoeKrr4poBaHlEtABlrrareJrrr.ronnrrfi ToK rD IKa, 14, KaKnJra3MeHHOrOyAeJrbHbreIrHaAe)rGouslrepaeuufi npr4 r4cnbtraHr.{rx fiapalMerpCJTeACTBI,Ie, IJTOTHOCTb uOHHOTO TOKa,-BblnaAarcIqero Ha fpaHr.rllblO6reua.

3aganue npE pacqerax BToporo Bzrx(Horo napaMerpa, 3aAauorleronoroKri Mor{r{ocru, 3.[eKrpoHHofi rerr.rneparypbr, MeHee o6ocHoBaHo, TaK KaKHeoll4pagrct na rarlre-nr.r6o Ir3MepeHHt H 3Aecb flprrxoAurcr ocHoBbBarbcs Ha rl4TeparypHbrxIAI{HbIX.cnerygr orMerurb npH3ToM, rITo renJroBrur MoAeJrb ABr4rare;It co3Aaercr, KaK npaBuJro,Ha STane pa3pa6orKr.r 3cKr4Horo flpoema, B cBr3r.tcqeM 3Kcnep[MeHTalJrbHajr npoBepKa nAoKa3areJrbcrBo etprf exrr.rnHocru r4 AocroBepHosrr4 MoAeJrr4nocJre peanrj3auul{ ABr,IrareJIrocyudecrBnrr, Ha AByx(Buoxsr 6rrft.npoBeAeHa ronbKox(ejre3e)). ,{r.rccepranry yAaurocb raKyro npoBepKyBrII4! pasnofi pa3MepHocrt4 I{rroKa3arb AocroBepHocrb noJTvqaeMbrxnprr qHcJreHHoM MOAenEpOBaHr.tI4 p$yJIbTaTOB.Pacqsrrr npoBeAeHbr ilBTopoM AJrr rpex 4nr,rarenefi pasnofi uoulnocrr: 4o 0,3 rBr, 3xBr ra 20 rBr.

Pacqgrnrre MoaeJIIt ABl4rarenefi paccvuranrr Ha r4cnoJrBoBaHLIu nporpaMMHoroxoumerca ANSYS, roroprrfi xoporro3apeKoMeHroBaJr ce6r flpu peIIreHr4t4 noAo6Hbrx 3aAarr.Cle4yer floaqepKH]'rb oco6oe Mecro Br{ccJreAoBaHnr reMleparypHbx nolefi n KorKperHbxar.rcceprarlrru gKcnepr{MeHTaJrbHoroo6pa:qax BIIH,{. IlporeaeHr4e srrrxnolefiuccre,qonaar.rfi norpe6onaro pa3pa6orKr.r MeroALrKu r,BMepeHr4r reMneparypnr,rxC ognoficropoHbr,6nlopa.ar{arlHoHHbre napaMeTpbr npHMerureMbrx B KoHcTpyKqur,rBIII,I!r{cnoJrb3oBaHr,reM TenJroBrropa.mareparype na6nroAaercr 3Haqr4Temnufi pas6pog a c 4pyrofipa6orlr B!II4,{ no reM[eparypHoMy Harpyxenuro-Heo6xoA[MorraarepuaaoB,conpeAeJrr4Tbno KoTopbrMBycnoBrlr [peAeJrbHrrx pexrrMoBKpr4Tr4qecKr4x 3JreMeHToB KoHcrpyKrrr,rr4,I4cxoA{ I,I3 peanrnoft TexHoJIOrI4I4 I43foToBireHqrr qnrararelefi.

Kporrae roro, npr4 r8MepeHr.rrrxTer\fneparyp B ycJroBr4rx ucnrnanrafi B BaKlTMe3a4av',no3BoJrr.rBrur.re npoBoAr,rrbx3MepeHwr6tuonneo6xoglrMo perrr4T6 TexHr4qecKu eun(ppaxpacxoM Arrana3oHeTularenrnocrr rulerogn.recrofi npopa6orrr.r usuepeHr,rfi noAqepKuBasr,qrorrTo aBTop I,IccJIeAoBirn gKclepLIMeHTilJrbHo H noKa3aJr,BbrxoAsrrleroItH,qtrKarpr4ca TellnoBoroc [oBepxHocrH reparr.ravecrofi rasopasp-r4uofiKaMepbr,AonycKaer oIrHcaHI4e KocxHycol4AirJlbnofi ganr,tcurr,rocTbro. Pacqernuep$yJr6TaTbr HaxoMTcrHecorraneuno,BHanpr,rMep,c 6ollllrofiuror(farr,'./ary.qjel{v'',ToqHocrbro3Kcnepr.rMeHTaJlbHbrexoporreM corJracnx.A cceprawtr.rlraegr6onrlroe flpaKrraqecl<oe 3HaqeHue. B nei cogepxarc.rpe3yJrbrarbr He roJrBKo MeroAr.rqecKoro xapaKrepa, Hor4peKoMeHAaqura no nrr6opy npeaenbHbrxpexfl{MoB pa6orbl BqI4A paslnqsofi pa3MepHocrl,I c yqeroM TexHoJroruu r,rxnpl4cnercry)a.I4CnOJI[,3OBaHHI4 ClnaBOB TI4TaHaAonycrr{Miur reMneparypa 3nercrpoAoBonrurqecrofi crrcreMbr He AoJDfiHaBusroroeler*rl.

Tar,KaqeCIBe MaTepIlZUIa 3IeKTpOAOB,MaKCT4MaJIbHZUT(nnepnyro oqepeab, srvflrccuonnoro) y3Jra rroHHonpeBbrurarb 400-450 oc. Ha ocnose npoBeAeHHoro aBTopoMEccreAoBaHl'ru n paspa6aruraeMblx ABLIfareJUrx nJloruocrb uoHHofo roKa B HoBbrx nDoe(TixorpaHu.rfiBaercr serrav[Hoft 65 -7 0 Nu2.flonyrennrre aBTopoM B Ar.rcceprarlr4r4 p*yJrbrarbrHarn.r .r npr,rMeHenuen pxge oKp urrpr.BHaHlr pa3pa6or.{ura[{r,r Br{I4A B npoMlrruneHubx opraHr.Barlr4rx.ClelygrorMerl4Tb, rorurqHocrb rrpeAcraBneHHoro aBTopoM B Ar4cceprarlr4lr MarepnaJra.Ana"nzs, npone4enurrfir fnaee1,nosnonu rrerro nocraBr b 3aAa.{y [ccJreAoBanr4q.

ltarla2,npeAcraBJrrer co6ofi o6ocnon aHr4e Arrr. paspa6orru remonofi MoAeJrr4 Ha ocHoBe ,ueranbHoropaccMorpeHr4.{renro$asa.recrax npoqeccoB B caMocrocreJbHoMr4HAyKqr,roHnonaBgpa3prAe.Lrcxogx us oco6exnosrefi r(oHcrpyKrlr4n B.II,I.(, o6ocHonbrBarorcr Aoflycrr.rMbre ynpor{enr4r.Brnane 3 aanrr nparrratrec*He pe3ynbrarrt anpo6aquu reruroBbrx uoqeneft B Ko'KperHbrxPACqETHbTX I,ICCJIEAOBAFIUrX. ,{ErrArOrCr Ba)(HbIE BbIBOAbI IIO NPEAENbHO AONYCTI,IMbIMPCXI4MAMpa60rrr 4nunarerefi, npar avecrprpeaJrr,r3oBaHHwxn LfuLr rIMS MAa no 3aAaHr,rrMnpoMbruneHHbrx opranlrsaqrzft. 3rcnepzrraenranbna.fi faaBa 4 co4epxur BiD(Hyrounooprraaqarco Meroar'rqecKfx ocHoB:rx rsuepennfi TeM[eparypHbrx noirefiB ycJroBHJrXpa60rur 4w rarererirBaKyyMec ucnoJlblloBaHneM TelJIoBI43opa, AeMoHoTprrpygr xopouee coBnaaeHr4e pacrreTHbrx uSKCnepr4MeHTaJrbHbrx pe3ynbTaToB.,{uccepraqr.rr laarfircana xopouuM r3brKoM, no3BoJrrgr nemo opr4eHTzpoBarLctcnerlr4aJrr4crycoAepx€HneBpeuraeMbrx aBTopoM npo6neuax.

Arrope$epar noJrHocrbro orpoKaerAI,Icc epr aIIIdI.I.uAnpo6aqua pa6oru npoxo,quna na poccuitcKnxMe)(AyHapoAnbrx xou$epenqr.rrx.Pesynr,rarrr pa6orrr ony6nuxonanbt B AByx HayrrHbrx crarbrx B peqerrr4pyeMr,rx v3Aalaurtx.B 4raccepraqrau cireAyer orMerr4Tb cJreAyroqfie HeAocrarKu:-BnlaBe 2 ne Aocraro'{Ho apryMeHTI,IpoBaHHo yKa3aHo> oqHoBHBar{cb Ha KaKux LtccneAoBaHlrjtxr.rJrr4npeAfloJloxeHrurx, npr4Hrrro 3HatreHHe s 15 oA ot Bg uorqnocru AJUI MorqHocrl nyqr4crofo[oToKa-I,I3[na3Mbr;na crp.33 yra3aHo, rrro u3 3Kcnepr4MeHToB u3BecrHo 3HaqeHr4e roKa B uenuV3, paraoe2-3o/oor roKa r4oHoB n) rxa, oaHaKo ccbrJrKa Ha KaK[e-rz6o ny6nExarrun orcyrcrByer;- Ha crp.

39 4rra ifoprraynlr (1.21) nponyrueHo ontrcaHrie AJrr oAHoro rr3 cJraraeMLrx,-Ha crp. 60nQ.29) rcx troHoB1 o/o or rora }roHoB [y.rKa,QoprvryneonpeAeJU{eTcr paBHbrMnepesapflAr.u u3 o6lacru neiirpanusaqlruoAHaxo He onucaHo, noxarofinpnqr4He 3To3HaqeHI,Ie OTJIIIqaeTCt OT SKCnepr,IMeHTiUrbHbrx aaHHbrx, npeacTaBJreHHblx Bbrrue.Ornre'{exurre HeAocrarKr,r He cHr.DKatror Bbrcor<ofi oqexrrBxaqecrse pa3B..r*'^ uccle4orannfiNOXEJIAHI'IEBvoc ucceprarlnr4.Aricceprarlnrr MoxHo BbrcKa3arbTIPOBEAEHI,IU KOMNJIEKCHOTO SKCNEPI4MEHTArBMepeHrut reMneparypbr 3JrercrpoAoBrpanrrr{no reMe4CHE3ABI,ICI4MbIMII CPEACTBAMI4olpeAeneHwr flapaMerpoB nrasrt{rrn6rr.tsr4pa3prluofi nrtas rH e fPK.,{raccepraqraonnaapa6ora Kpyrnora K.H.