Отзыв оппонента (Модели и алгоритмы определения приоритетного направления движения воздушного судна по заданным маршрутам)
Описание файла
Файл "Отзыв оппонента" внутри архива находится в папке "Модели и алгоритмы определения приоритетного направления движения воздушного судна по заданным маршрутам". PDF-файл из архива "Модели и алгоритмы определения приоритетного направления движения воздушного судна по заданным маршрутам", который расположен в категории "". Всё это находится в предмете "технические науки" из Аспирантура и докторантура, которые можно найти в файловом архиве МАИ. Не смотря на прямую связь этого архива с МАИ, его также можно найти и в других разделах. , а ещё этот архив представляет собой кандидатскую диссертацию, поэтому ещё представлен в разделе всех диссертаций на соискание учёной степени кандидата технических наук.
Просмотр PDF-файла онлайн
Текст из PDF
OT3bIBo$urlrzanbHoro orrrloHeHTaAoKToparexHl4r{ecK}rxHayK,upo$eccopaArexceeea Bra4Iauupa BuralbeBur{a Ha AuccepralllloHHyro pa6oryToe Bafi Tyu <MoAenI4 I.t anropuTMhlonpeAeneHplqnplzopl4TerHoroHanpaBJreHr{{fIOCyAHaBO3AyTHO|OABr4xeHI4lI3aAaHHbIMMapupyraM> rrpeAcraBneHHyro Ha colacKaHpleyreuofi creneHltKaH.qr4AararexHI4qecKux HayK rlo cneqv€IrlbHocrtl 05.13.01Cr,rcrerrauufi anaJrvr3, ynpaBneHrle lr o6pa6orrca unQopnaaquu( anraaqraoHHat Ia paKerHo -KocMtItIe cKat rexuura)Arrya;rrHocrbreMbr AuccepraIIHIro6opouocuoco6Hocrrl P@ uenosMox{HoPagsurue 3KoHoMuKvru rroBbrlrleHrae6egpa3BLrrr4flaBna\w.Pa:eurueaBlvra\vLrHHreHcr4BHocrr4 rroJreroB Bo3AyluHbrx cyAoB (BC).aHTeHcr4BHocrH rroJreroB BC5e:onacuocrr4oco6yrorIoBbIIxeHHenpeAnonaraerycnoBn{xB3HaquMocrbrIoBbIIIreHI4flBonpocblnplao6perarorrroJreroB.
AeroNaarvaar\prfl, npoqecca yilpaBneHus BC B rroJlere,BbIrroJIHeHI{u MaHeBpoB,cyrqecrBeHHo cHrrx(aer BIrvrqHr4e,TaK Ha3brBaeMoro qeJloBeqecKoro Sarropa, urroBbrrrraer 6esonacHocrb rIoJIeroB. I4gsecrHo, rITo rlpr4 aBToMaruuecKoM vJrtloco6essoBcJro)KHbrx MereoycnoBl4tx[pI4urro p€t3HbIMnpl4r{uHanr, c6ouaBroMarr43lrpoBaHHoM yrrpaB rrenr4v BC cyurecrByror,n $opuupoBaHr{t4 HelpepbrBHoro clarHa[a yflpaBneHus. B cBfl3u c DTTIMTeMaAr,rccepraquouHofi pa6ou cor4cKarent 1^reHofi creuenra frBlrflercfl arryalrHofi .CreneusO6OcnOnaHHOCTII HayrIHbIxnO.nOxteHnfi,BrIBOAOBVp eKoMeH4a q Iafi , cS o p vty.llu p oBaHHblx B AIrccepra II u uB nepnofi ruraBe, Ha ocHoBe AocraroqHo rny6ororo cllcreMHoro aHaJrvrsanpeAMerHofro6nacru, aBToppa6omr B IIenoM rlpaBl{nbHocQopuynnpoBaJrIlenb I43a1aqv HccneAoBaHvrfl.,o6ocuonarpa3peneHr4rcyxIecTByIoUI4Xfipo rHo3r4poBaHr,r-f,(err6opa)ransopuaqzu.O6ocnosaHatrpplMeHeHnrrfi uareMarl4qecrcuit annapar AntIIpoTLIBope'aufi,BpeIxeHHI,ITpaeKTopvvr ABLrlKeHr4flBC e ycnoBllsxrrocraHoBKaorrrl{Mll3aqr,ronnoficooTHoIIIeHug.orrTl4M€urbHofoo[peAeneHr4eMprHr{MI43rrpyrcrqux orura6 rcy I4x BoccraHoBreul{-f, .napaMeTpoB3ap.arllaorcyrcrBu-sga!.a-uvKaKABI{}KeHI4-fl,Tar<uu o6pa:ovr, pe3ynbrarbr aHaJrvr3aupe.4uernofi o6lacru rro3BonlzJlt4aBTopy BbrrBr{Tb pr^4 oco6eHuocreft MareMarl4rlecKoro u nporpaMMHoroo6ecneqesras r4ccneAyeMoro npoqecca, Koropbre paHee He yqI4TbIB€uIucbrpnnpoBeAeHr4r4uoAo6nrrx uccneAoBa:nuit (xounnercHoe npHMeHeHI{e MeroAoBeereefi v rpaHr4rl v Ir HaM:aLrecKoronpofpaMMupoBaHnfl; vrepapxvrfl yponuefrnnagnpoBaH'1lrnonera BC; MareMarl,ItlecKoeoilLlcaHrre peurv3ar\vs.
flpoqeccaBoccraHoBreHt,rq BeKTopa Kaxyqefrcs cKopocrll B BHAe KBaAparI4r{HbIXIOJTLIHOMOBfroMerOAy,OCHOBaHHOMyHa pefpeCCI4OHHbIX [pOIIeAypaXC14c [o Jrb3o BaHr4eM MeToAa HaLIMeHbIrrI{x KBaApaToB).Cne4yer orMerr4Tb, qro o6reu uepnofi fJIaBbI, sa uofi B3rJrrA, neperpyx(eH(56 c. wz 120 c.). Ho, ro-BrlAlrMoMy, ro ApyroMy aBropy rocryrrr4m 6uro Herlb3t- Hacro,qbro o6rerueH rrpeAMer I4ccneAoBaHvfl.Bpe3ynbrarenpoqreHz-fluepnofirJraBbrArzccepraqr4rrilpocnexuBaercrnorr4Ka r4ccneAoBalnLrr: rrporHo3 rpaer<ropufiTpaeKTopr4r4- Mero4krKa peureHr{rr 3a\aqu - anfopuTMEr peaflvrcarJvrfi.rrerKoeu6opBo eropofi rrtaee aBToppa6orrr npeAcraBr4JrorrrlcaHr4epa3pa6oraHHoror4Mro:4eficreufiHa HcrroJrHr4TeJrbHbreanrop14TMa nporHo3a yrrpaBnrrorlllxnpe4rrreruoffMexaHu3MrrBC.
Marepr.ran rJraBhryBs3aHc pe3ynbraraMr aHaJrr43ao6tacrn,rrpoBeAeHHoro B nepnofi fJIaBe, a pe3ynbrarbr Koppenr{pyrorc-f, cBbIBOAaMI'I,CAeJIaHHrrN,rIae Hefi .y6e4raremnoAeroppa3pa0oTaHHoforrpoAeMoHcrpl{poB€Lnefoanfopr4TMaorJIrIr{r{TeJIbHbre npI43HaKIz,IIOCTO?IHCTBA:LICIIOJIb3OBAHLTErroJrr4HoMrznamuofi arrnpoKcr4Malluu sHa.{eHLIfr cHrHaiIoB ynpaBneHu{ cr4HTepBan BpeMeHrr krnocre4yrorqefi sKcrparor^roluefi Ha $urcuponaunrrfiBo3MolrHocrrSoplar4poBaHvrs. yrrpaBnf,rcIllLrx Bo3Aeftcrr'uir Ha r4c[oJrHr,lTeJrbHbleMexaHV3MbrBC,ocHoBbrBarcb Ha vnSopuaqzu,noryraerraofi Ao MoMeHTanpofpaMMHoro ynpaBneHn.rl.I4ccle4oeaHue eroro anroprarMa [o3BoJrr4JroaBTopy pa6orrr nepefirra Brpemeft rJraBe K perxeHr4rocne.qyroulefi saAarrvr- pa^:pa6orKeMareMarr.rqecKl4xoco6eHnocru vccneAoBaHufl; IlporpaMMHoroynpaBneHnr v orrpeAeneHlrr [pr4opl,ITerHoro HarrpaBneHzr BC B ycJroBl{txn H$ opu arlr4oHHbrxBo3Myrrlesuir, u pa:pa6 orKe anropurMa ee p eurv3alqlztu.OpHrrananbHblM flBlrfleres.
pelxeHlle aBTOpa paoorhr LrcrroJrb3oBarbfroJrr4HoMur{e6rrrueBa Ans. pelxeul4t 3a4a'v.vralrrpoKcr4Marlr4r4Lr IlocneAyrouleHvoAereft:BC,yuuurnaroulefi3Kcrparonflr\vv yrrpaBntrcrqux sosAeficreuft c rlenbro ycKopeHHf, rrpoqeccaBbIT{14CICHI4I4.flocranoeKa3a1arlrlrHa rrpoBeAeHlre gKcnepHMeHToB, npHBeAeHHbIeB erofirraBe ra nrr6op r{cxoAHbrxAaHHbrxB IIeJIoMKoppeKTHrrIa o6ocHoBaHbl.MeroArto6pa6orxrz pe3yJlbraroB Mo.{enl{poBaur4fl kI SKCrrepr4MeHTZIrrbHbIX AaHHbIXKoppeKTHo.npr.rMeHeHbr3ax,'rro.{eHHe pa6orrrorpax{aerocHoBHbIe pe3ynbrarblrrccneAoBaHkrfl,ronyqeHHrreToe Befi Tytt.auuit aBrop pa6omr ucronb3oBan coBpeMeHHoeflpra npoe eAeHVr4r,rccJreAoBrporpaMMuoeo6ecuerleHlre.[ocronepHocrbHCTIOJIb3OBAHI{EMfloryrleHHblxMCTONOBpe3yJrbraroB o6ecue.{eHa KoppeKTHbIMMATEMATI4qECKO|OMOAenZpOBaHVfl,CHCTeM,MareMarvr{ecKoficTurvrcTLlKLr,rIHcJIeHHbrxMeToAoBperueHLr{ypaBHeHufi,KOppeKTHbIMI{ IOCTaHOBKaMV 3AAaLr U UCTIOJIb3OBaHTIeM,B KarIeCTBe rrCXOAHbrX,3KClepHMeHT€LrIbHbIX AaHHbIX, nOATBepXAaeTCrCOTJTaCOBaHHOCTbTOnp[rBeAeHHbrXB pa6ore pe3yJrbraroB BbrrrlrcJrlrreJrbHorooKcrrepuMeHTa,AocraroqHo ruupoKofianpo6aquefi pe:ynrraroB.ZcnorrsoBaHplesKcnepI4MeHTiLIIbHbrxAaHHbrxrrpuBblr{plcrureJlbHoro 3KcnepI4MeHTarloATBep}rcAaereSQerruBHocrbilpoBeAeHr4r4pa":pa6oraHHbrxMOAener4r,ranf opr4TMoB.llpzee4ennufi anarll3 ALIccepraIII4oHHofipa6our rro3BoJurer roBopr4Tb oToM, r{To B IIenoM Ilenb pa6oru AocrrlrHyra, a [ocraBJreHHbre,Toe Befi TyH,3a\aqv HccneAoBaH.vr[,perxeHbr.OcnoeHrrNlla Ha) IHrIMLI pesyJlbraravrvr, o6raAaroullrMz npu3HaKaMr4n ay u no fi Ho BrI3Hbr, [on)^reHHbIMpIJrr4rrHoaBTopoM,cneAyer cqllTarb :anropr4TMyrrpaBJrrroulnxrrporHo3anos4eficreufiHaocHoBen oJrr,rHoMz anur ofi arrrrpoKcrr:'r'rla\upr;MoAenb o rrpeAener^ufl npuopLrrerHoro Halp aBlreHrz.s4nzxeHux B C ;MeroAHKa pa:pa6omuu€rJrropurM orrrrrMarrbHoro [porpaMMHofoyrpaBneur4fl B ycnoBl4.xx HerarIaBHbIXBo3Aeficreufi na raH$opMarlr4oHHyroqacrbcrcreMbr yrrpaBneHus BC.TeopernqecKaq 3HarllrMocrb pe3yJrbraroB Arrcceprarllrr 3aKJrroqaercrBpactrrplpeHl4l4Bo3MoxHocrefi MareMarllrlecKoro alnapara reopkrlr ynpaBJreHkrrHapeIxeHI,Ie 3a4arr rporpaMMHoro ylpaBneHr{rr BC B ycnoBr'rsx BHeruHr4xran$opnaaquoHHbrxno:uyrqenzfi.flparrnuecKaq3HarruMocrb pe3ynbraroB pa6orrr 3aKrroqaerc-{ Bpeanu3ar\r4v ocHoBHhrx, [peAnox{eHHbrx B pa6ore perueHzfi B Bvr4eanropl4TMl{rlecKofo o6ecne.{eHr,r.f, Anfl perrreHrarr 3aAaq, nocrpoeHz.fl cLrcreMynpaBneHr4qBo3AyrrrHbrMr4cyAaMvr,'o6ecne.ruBarorqrfxorrrlrMulrrbnufi uapupyr r,rxABlrxeHr,rrB ycnoBr4rx oTcyTcTBrlr-flAaHHbx or r'rusopMarlr{oHHofiuogcucTeMbr.Texcr Arrcceprarluu H3noxeH MareMarr4rrecKr4AocraroqHo crporo.Pyronucr oQoprvrneHaaKKyparHo.B IIeJIoM, coorBercrByer r4ryeflM,TeKcry LrBbrBoAaMAlrccepraqrau.
OcnoBHhrepe3ynbrarbr .{ucceprarllzraouy6nnrosaHH s 11peKoMeHAoBaHHbrxBAKflerrarHbrx pa6orax, vr3 Koropbrx 4 - B pr3/;a:rrurfrx,Co4epxaune anrope$eprd,MuHo6pa^:oBaHr{rLr laayK:aP@ lmrry6nuraqru{ pe3ynbraroB Ar4ccepral{I{oHHhrxr4ccJre,rloBauuit.Jluqnrrfi BKnaA aBTopa n ny6nurc4r\prflx, HarrllcaHHbrx B coaBTopcrBe, Bpaoore pa3rpaHlrqeH.Teua kr coAepxaHr4e AkrcceprallrIoHHoro r4ccneloBanvrfl.
coorBercrBylorryHKraM rracropra cleqrraJrbuocrl4 05.13.01: n. 10 <MeroArt vr €ulropllrMblr4HrerreKTyanbHofi noAAepxKH rIpH IJp?rIJ^flTvrvylpaBneHIIecKLIX perueHul4 BTexHr4qecKl4x, gKoHoMI4rIecKI,IX, 6prororuqecKr4x, MeALIIII4HcKI4x Lr coIII4aIIbHbIXcr4creMax.)); r.11<<Mero4u14 €urropuTMbr rIporHo3pIpoBaHLIt H oqeHKI4eS$exrznHocrl{, KaqecrBa u HaAe)KHocrLIcJro)KHbIXcLIcreM) vr, -tacrtrvrno, n. 3olllzrcanurfl. vr orIeHKH eSQerrunHocrl4<Paspa6orxa KpLITepLIeB vr IuoAeleftperxeHr4r 3aAaq cucreMHofoaHaJru3a. orITrIMrI3aIIuLT, yfrpaBneHllfl , npvrlfflTLr'perueuufi z o6pa6orrcn nn$opMallulr>).Ha ocuoee rrpoBeAeHuoro anaJrn3acoAep)KaHunpa6orbl cneAyer cAenarb3AKIIOTIEHI4E O TOM, IITO I43JIO)KEHHE MATEPU€LJIA B ALICCEPTAIIULI IOCNCAOBATCJIbHOCr4fioH{THoe, a 3a4a'tv\ Koropbre craBr{JIn pa6ore aBTop,pelueHbr rloJrHocrbro.Oqeuunaa pa6ory B r{enoM rIoJIox&ITeJIbHo, neo6xo,4lttr,to orMerurbcn eAyrorqze 3aMeqaHufl.
14peKoMeHAar\uvr:kIccneAoBannfl npl4BenKaqecrBe o6terraSopuynrapoBKy<SopvrupoBaHr{erroAxoAaorrpeAenenvrflpar\kroHallbHoro,c ror{Kl{1.Aerop3peljLrfl yclerxHoropa6oruBCy.4HaBO3AyTXHOTOperueHvrs.3aAaqv, HarlpaBJrelJufl ABLIlKeH.vfl.rro AorrycrrlMbrM Maprupyrau>>.llo MoeMy MHeHuIo era SoprvrynupoBKa6olrure6rzsraK SopvrylupoBKe peruaerraofiuayrnofi3a a-uvr (uparcrzvecrofi eeIlerecoo6p€BHo 6srno cQopvrylzpoBarb,peanrr3arluvt),a o6rerr uccneAoBarturfl,(npoqeccylpaBJreHLIt ABrIx(eHLIeMBC) wvHarpnMep KaK: ([poqecc$opurapoBaHkrfl. ynpaBntrroulprx Bo3Aeficrsuir Ha ucloJIHETelbHbIe Mexanr4sNdHBCB ycnoBr4f,xnos4eficrBLIt.HeraTLIBHbIXSarropon>>.2.
B pa6ore npncyrcrByror He coBceM yAaqHble coKpaqeHvrfl..Haupuuep,sa c. 12 rer<yueMy rorrerHoMy 3aqalalarocooruocurc-f, coKpalqeHuelIlI3.HarlpuMep,B Bblpaxenvrflx2.3 sa c. 57 u2.653. Heroropbre nepeMeHHbre,Korl4rrecrBocyMMI4pyeMbIXr4HTefpllpoBaHvrfl,14Ha c. 71, onpe4enqrculr4errpeAeJrbrHe pacKpblBaloTct, r{To 3aTpyAH'eT BocrIpH{THeCOOTBeTCTBeHHO3JTeMeHTOBTCKCTA.4.
Ha c. 6l aBTop ilpr.rBoAlrr rrr4cJroBoe3HaqeHue noKa3areJltBC pannuu 1.3. flouevry B cr{creMeyrnoBoir cra6wvr3arJr4uxore6areJrbHocrrrne o6rscHqer.Tar, sa c.94TeKcro6rqeugsecrHoroxapaKTepa.5. B pa6ore Bcrpeqaercs.Anf,aBrop rrpr{BoAprrBbrpaxeHlreAnlr qucna Maxa.
