Отзыв оппонента 1 (Многополюсные синхронные электрические машины обращенной конструкции)
Описание файла
Файл "Отзыв оппонента 1" внутри архива находится в папке "Многополюсные синхронные электрические машины обращенной конструкции". PDF-файл из архива "Многополюсные синхронные электрические машины обращенной конструкции", который расположен в категории "". Всё это находится в предмете "технические науки" из Аспирантура и докторантура, которые можно найти в файловом архиве МАИ. Не смотря на прямую связь этого архива с МАИ, его также можно найти и в других разделах. , а ещё этот архив представляет собой кандидатскую диссертацию, поэтому ещё представлен в разделе всех диссертаций на соискание учёной степени кандидата технических наук.
Просмотр PDF-файла онлайн
Текст из PDF
OT3hIBOqnUJ,11aJIbHOrO OrrrrOHeHTa re'll11B.5I.Ha ,n11CCepTaIJ,I1IO I1BaHoBa H11Kona51 CepreeB11'lla «MHOrOrrOnIOCHbIeC11HXpOHHbIe 3neKTP11'lleCK11e MaIII11HbI 06paIIJ,eHHOH KOHCTPYKIJ,1111»,rrpe,nCTaBneHHYIO Ha C011CKaH11e Y'lleHOH CTerreH11 KaH,n11,naTa TeXH11'lleCK11X HayKrro CrreIJ,11aJIbHOCT1105.09.01AKryaJIbHOCTb«3neKTpOMeXaH11Ka 11 3JIeKTp11'lleCK11e arrrrapaTbI»TeMbI.POCT3JIeKTpOTeXH11'lleCK11e YCTpOHCTBaCaMOJIeTaX,,neJIaIOTBeTP03HepreT11'lleCK11eHeo6xo,nI1MbIMrrOTPe6JIeH11513JIeKTp03Hepr1111,HOBbIeB 3neKTPOM0611JI5IX 11 3JIeKTp11<p11IJ,I1pOBaHHbIXYCTaHOBKI1pa3pa6oTKYMOIIJ,HOCTbIOHOBbIX10MBT1160JIee3JIeKTpOMeXaH11'lleCK11Xrrpe06pa30BaTeJIeH. C11HXpOHHbIe MaIII11HbI 06paIIJ,eHHOrO 11CrrOJIHeH1151 rr03BOJI5IIOTBp5l,neCJIY'llaeBpeaJI1130BbIBaTbKOHCTPYKIJ,1111,He,nOCT11)1(11MbIerrp1111CrrOJIb30BaH1111 MaIII11H TPa,nI1IJ,110HHOrO I1CrrOJIHeH1151, KpoMe Toro, 06paIIJ,eHHbIe3JIeKTp11'lleCK11e MaIIII1HbI 11MeIOT YBeJI11'lleHHbIH KI1HeTI1'lleCK11H MOMeHT.B,n11CCepTaIJ,I10HHOH pa60Te I1BaHoBa H.C.
paccMoTpeH Ba)l(HbIH BorrpocCpaBH11TeJIbHOrO aHaJI113a ,nByx Ha1160JIee rrepCrreKT11BHbIX T11rrOB C11HXPOHHbIXMaIII11H 06paIIJ,eHHOH KOHCTPYKIJ,1111 rrOCT05lHHbIXMarH11TOB11CC B036Y)l(,neH11eM OT BbICOKOK03PIJ,11TI1BHbIX3JIeKTpOMarHI1THbIMB036Y)l(,neH11eM,BKJIIO'lla51B036Y)l(,neH11e OT BbIcoKoTeMrrepaTypHbIX cBepxrrpOBOMIIJ,11X rrpoBo,noB BTopororrOKOJIeHI15I. ,naHHbIH aHaJI113 HarrpaBJIeH Ha BbI5IBJIeH11e 60JIee paIJ,110HaJIbHOrOrrpI1MeHeH1151 Toro 11JI11 11HOrO T11rra B036Y)l(,neH1151, a TaK)I(e rr03BOJI5IeT OIJ,eH11TbIJ,eJIeC006pa3HOCTbrrepexo,naOTo,nHoroT11rraB036Y)l(,neH1151K,npyroMy ,nJI5IKa)l(,noH KOHKpeTHoH TeXH11'lleCKOH C11CTeMbI.OCHoBHbIe pe3YJIbTaTbI H HaYQHaH HOBH3HaHaY'llHa51 HOBI13Ha pe3YJIbTaTOB ,n11CCepTaIJ,110HHOH pa60TbI 06YCJIOBJIeHaCJIe,nyIOIIJ,11M11 rrOJIO)l(eH1151M11:1.Pa3pa60TaHaHOBa51MeTo,n11Ka3JIeKTpOMarH11THOrOpaC'lleTaCI1HXPOHHbIX MaIII11H 06paIIJ,eHHOH KOHCTPYKIJ,1111 C B036Y)l(,neH11eM OT rrOCT05lHHbIXMarHI1TOB, OCHOBaHHa5I Ha aHaJIl1Tl1qeCKOM paCqeTe .n:BYXMepHbIX pacrrpe.n:eJIeHI1HMarHI1THbIX rrOJIeH B aKTI1BHOH 30He CI1HXPOHHOH MalIII1HbI.2.Pa3pa60TaHaHOBa5Io6pameHHoHKOHCTPYK~1111B036Y)l(.n:eHl1eHarrpOBo.n:OB.OCHOBeCMeTo.n:l1KapaCqeTa3JIeKTpOMarHl1THbIMBbICOKOTeMrrepaTypHbIXMeTo.n:I1KarrOCTpoeHaHa6a3eCI1HXPOHHbIXMallll1HB036Y)I(.n:eHl1eM,BKJIIOqa5ICBepxrrpOBO.n:5Iml1X(BTCI1)aHaJIl1TI1QeCKOrOpaCQeTapacrrpe.n:eJIeHU5I MarHl1THbIX rrOJIeH B aKTl1BHOH 30He MalllI1HbI.,I(aHHbIeMeTo.n:I1KI1yql1TbIBaIOTCBOHCTBaMaTepl1aJIOB,CTpyKTypy11reOMeTpl1IO aKTl1BHOH 30HbI.3.HaCpaBHI1TeJIbHbIHOCHOBerrOJIYQeHHbIXaHaJI113Cl1HXPOHHbIXaHaJIl1Tl1QeCKI1XMalIIl1HpelIIeHI1H06pameHHOHrrpOBe.n:eHKOHCTpyK~l1l1CB036Y)l(.n:eHl1eM OT IIrv111 3JIeKTpOMarHI1THbIM B036Y)l(.n:eHl1eM.C<p0PMYJIl1pOBaH Kpl1Tepl1H, rro KOTOPOMY MO)l(HO rrpoBo.n:l1Tb o~eHKy4.~eJIeC006pa3HOCTI1 rrpl1MeHeHl15I BTCI1 rrpoBo.n:oB rrpl1 rrpOeKTl1pOBaHl1l1 3MI1o6pameHHoH KOHCTPyK~l1l1.OCHOBHhle pe3YJIhTaThI ,1J;HCCepTaU:HH1.Pa3pa60TaHbI MeTo.n:l1KI1 paCQeTa .n:ByxMepHblx MarHl1THbIX rrOJIeH 11rrapaMeTpoBCI1HXPOHHbIXMallll1Ho6pameHHoHKOHCTPyK~l1l1CIIrv111C3JIeKTPoMarHI1THbIM B036Y)l(.n:eHl1eM;2.Pa3pa60TaHa MeTo.n:l1Ka Ql1CJIeHHOrO paCQeTa Cl1HXPOHHOH Mallll1HbIo6pameHHoH KOHCTPyK~l1l1 C IIrv1;3.I10JIYQeHO3HaQeHI1eM,I(C06MOTKI1B036Y)l(.n:eHl15I(OB),3KBl1BaJIeHTHoe 3HaQeHl1IO M,I(C IIrv1, KOTopoe MO)l(eT 6bITb I1CrrOJIb30BaHO rrpl1o~eHKe ~eJIeC006pa3HOCTl1 rrpl1MeHeHl15I OB l1JII1 IIrv1 B l1H.n:YKTope Mallll1HbI.CTpYKTypa H o6beM ,1J;HCCepTaU:HH,I(l1CCepTa~l15I COCTOI1T 113 BBe.n:eHI15I, QeTbIpex rJIaB, 3aKJIIOlJeHl15I 11 Crrl1CKaJIl1TepaTypbI.
Pa60Ta 113JIO)l(eHa Ha14 Ta6JII1~.154CTpaHl1~aX, BKJIIOlJaIOml1XCrrl1COK JIl1TepaTypbI COCTOl1T 11387HaI1MeHOBaHI1H.60Pl1CYHKOB,BrrepBOHrnaBerrpOBO,n:I1TC5IMHOrOrrOnIOCHhIXCI1HXPOHHhIXB036Y)K,n:eHl1eMIIMOT11KpaTKI1HMalIIl1H0630p06nacTeH06pameHHOHC 3neKTpOMarHI1THhIMrrpl1MeHeHI15IKOHCTPYKIJ:1111B036Y)K,n:eHl1eM.CITpl1Be,n:eHhIOCHOBHhle rrpel1MymecTBa 11 He,n:OCTaTKI1 paCCMaTPI1BaeMhIX MalIII1H.
TaK)Ke BrnaBerrpOBe,n:eHaHanl13MarHI1THhIXrroneHIToKa3aHO,qTO11HayqHhIXrrapaMeTPOBBorrpOChI,rry6nl1KaIJ:I1HrroMHororronIOCHhIXCB5I3aHHhleCMeTo,n:I1KaM3neKTPI1qeCKI1XpaCqeTOM11paCqeTaMalIII1H.rrpOeKTl1pOBaHl1eM3neKTpl1qeCKI1X MalIIl1H 06pameHHOH KOHCTPYKIJ:1111 B nl1Teparype paCCMOTpeHhIHe,n:OCTaTOQHO rro,n:po6HO.BoBTOPOHrnaBeMHororronIOCHhIXKOHCTPYKIJ:1111rrpe,n:CTaBneHaCI1HXPOHHhIXC rrOCT05IHHhIMI1aHanI1TI1QeCKa5I3neKTpl1QeCKI1XMalIIl1HY Ka3aHhIMarHI1TaMI1.MeTo,n:I1KapaCQeTa06pameHHOHOCHOBHhle,n:orrymeHI15I,rrpl1HI1MaeMhle rrpl1 rrOCTaHOBKe 3 a,n:aQI1, OCHOBHhle paCQeTHhle COOTHOlIIeHI15I 11rpaHI1QHhle ycnOBI15I.pacrrpe,n:eneHI1I1o6pameHHoHBrnaBeMarHI1THhIXKOHCTPYKIJ:11112rrpl1Be,n:eHhI pe3ynhTaThI pelIIeHI15I 3a,n:aQI1 0rroneHCBaKTI1BHOHB036Y)K,n:eHl1eM30HeIIM.OTCI1HXPOHHOHHaMalIIl1HhIOCHOBe,n:aHHoropelIIeHI15I rronYQeHhI COOTHOlIIeHI15I ,n:n5I TaKI1X rrapaMeTpoB MalIII1HhI, KaKxonOCToroxo,n:a11rnaBHoeI1H,n:YKTI1BHoeCOrrpOTI1BneHl1e.3,[(CITpoBe,n:eHoI1ccne,n:OBaHl1e 3aBI1CI1MOCTI1 3TI1X rrapaMeTpoB, a TaK)Ke MOmHOCTI1 MalIIl1HhI OTQl1cna rrap rronIOCOB 11 OTHOCI1TenhHOH BhICOThIBTpeTheHpacrrpe,n:eneHI1I1rnaBerrpl1Be,n:eHoMarHI1THhIXrroneHIIM.aHanl1TI1QeCKOeBpelIIeHl1eaKTI1BHOH30He3a,n:aQ11MalIIl1HhI0C3neKTpOMarHI1THhIM B036Y)K,n:eHl1eM.
ITPI1 rrOCTaHOBKe 3a,n:aQI1 I1crronh30Banl1Ch,n:orrymeHI15I, aHanOrl1QHhIe ,n:orrymeHI15IM rnaBhI3a,n:aQI1, Ha OCHOBaHl111 KOToporo, orrpe,n:eneHhI2.3,[(CbhInOrronYQeHO pelIIeHl1exonOCToro xo,n:a, rnaBHoeI1H,n:YKTI1BHoe COrrpOTI1BneHl1e 11 rrocTpoeHhI OCHOBHhIe xapaKTepl1CTI1KI1 MalIIl1HhI.BTpeTheHCI1HXPOHHhIXrnaBeMalIIl1HB036Y)K,n:eHl1eM.orrpe,n:enl1ThBrrpe,n:cTaBneHo-CI1ToreMI1HI1ManhHyrocpaBHeHl1eB036Y)K,n:eHl1eMrronYQeHOBenl1QI1HYOT,n:ByXIIM11COOTHOlIIeHl1e,M,[(C,KOTOPyroTl1rrOBCo6pameHHhIx3neKTPoMarHI1THhIMKOTopoerr03BOn5IeTHeo6xo,n:I1MO C03,n:aTh,qT06hI BhIXO.n:Ha51 MOmHOCTh reHepaTOpa C 3JIeKTPOMarHI1THhIM B036Y)I(.n:eHI1eM6hIJIapaBHaMOmHOCTI1MaIIII1HhICrrOCT05lHHhIMI1MarHI1TaMI1B3a.n:aHHhlXra6apI1TaX rrpI1 TOH )l(e qaCTOTe BpameHI151. I1crrOJIh3Y5I 3TO Bhlpa)l(eHI1e, MO)l(HOOu:eHI1Th u:eJIeC006pa3HOCTh rrepexo.n:a K 3JIeKTpOMarHI1THOMY B036Y)I(.n:eHI11O 11, BqaCTHOCTI1, K B036Y)l(.n:eHI11O Ha OCHOBe BTCIT rrpOBO.n:OB.
BrJIaBe3rrpI1Be.n:eHCpaBHI1TeJIhHhIH aHaJII13 rro rreperpY30qHOH crroc06HOCTI1 .n:ByX TI1rrOB MaIIII1Ho.n:I1HaKOBOHKOHCTPYKU:I1I1C paBHoHJII1HeHHOHHarpY3KoH51KOP5l.IToKa3aHau:eJIeC006pa3HOCTh rrepexo.n:a K 3JIeKTpOMarHI1THoMY B036Y)l(.n:eHI11O rrpI1 ypOBHeTOKa B 06MoTKax B036Y)l(.n:eHI151 6JII13KI1X KI1CrrOJIh30BaHI1I1BTCIT06MOTOK100A, qTO .n:OCTI1)1(I1MO TOJIhKO rrpI1B036Y)l(.n:eHIUIpOTopa11KpI10reHHOMOXJIa)l(.n:eHI1I1 .n:o TeMrrepaTYP )l(I1.n:Koro a30Ta 11 HI1)1(e. ITpoBe.n:eHHhle B rJIaBepaCQeTHO-TeOpen1QeCKI1e I1CCJIe.n:OBaHI151 rrOKa3aJII1, QTO CI1HXPOHHhIe reHepaTophIC 3neKTpOMarHI1THhIMB036Y)l(.n:eHI1eMHa OCHOBe BTCIT rrpoBo.n:oB l1MelOT BHeCKOJIhKO pa3 60JIhIIIYIO MomHOCTh rro cpaBHeHI1lO C MarHHT03JIeKTPI1QeCKl1Ml1MaIIII1HaMI1 rrpI1 MaJIOM QI1CJIe rrap rrOJIlOCOB 11 rrpI1 60JIhIIII1X QaCTOTax BpameHl151pOTopa.)1;ocToBepHOCTh H anp06aQHH nOJIyqeHHhlX pe3YJIhTaTOB,ll.ocToBepHocTh pe3YJIhTaTOB .n:I1CCepTaU:I10HHOH pa60ThI rro.n:TBep)l(.n:aeTC5IrrpoBepKoHpa3pa60TaHHhlxMeTo.n:l1KCI1CrrOJIh30BaHHeMQI1CJIeHHhIX3KCrrepI1MeHTOB, KOTophle rrOKa3aJII1 BhICOKYIO CTerreHh TOQHOCTli pe3ynhTaToB,rrOJIYQeHHhIXHa.n:OKJIa.n:hIBaJII1Ch HarrOQeTHhIMliOCHOBe6MeTo.n:I1K.Pe3YJIhTaThIpa60ThIHayqHhlx KOH<pepeHU:I151X 11 6hIJII1 OTMeQeHhI rrpeMl151MI1 11.n:l1rrJIOMaMI1.peKoMeH.n:oBaHHhlxaHaJII1TI1QeCKI1XBAKABTOPOMP<l>.Borry6JII1KOBaHOrry6JII1KaU:I151X3pa60ThIaBTopaB)l(ypHaJIaX,.n:OCTaTOQHOrrOJIHOOTpa)l(eHhI ero OCHOBHhle HaYQHhle pe3YJIhTaThI.3aMeqaHHH1.AHaJII1TI1QeCKa51 MeTo.n:l1Ka paCQeT pacrrpe.n:eJIeHl151 MarHI1THhIX rrOJIeHB aKTI1BHOH 30He 06pameHHoH CI1HXPOHHOH MaIIIl1HhI C B036Y)l(.n:eHl1eM OTpaCCMaTpI1BaeT TOJIhKO pa.n:l1aJIhHO HaMarHHQeHHhleTIM.ITMO.n:HaKo, .n:JI5I rrpaKTl1Kl160JIhllIOe 3HaqeHIfe TaK)l(e IfMelOT CJIyqaIf TaHreHUIfaJIhHO HaMarHIfqeHHhIXIl1vfpa60Te paCCMOTPeHIfe TaHreHUIfaJIhHO HaMarHIfqeHHhIX2.BKaqeCTBeanpo6aUIfIfpe3YJIhTaTOBIl1vf.BOTCYTcTByeT.aHaJIHTIfqeCKIfX paCqeTOBBpa60Te npIfBe.r:t:eHhI pe3YJIhTaThI qIfCJIeHHOrO Mo.r:t:eJIIfpOBaHIf5l.
O.r:t:HaKo, If3BeCTHO,qTO, HecMoTP5I Ha BhICOKYIO TOqHOCTh cOBpeMeHHhIx nporpaMMHhIx npo.r:t:YKTOB,rr03BOJI5IIOII(IfX npoBo.r:t:IfTh qIfCJIeHHOe MO.r:t:eJIIfpoBaHIfe, pe3YJIhTaThI IfCnhITaHIfMMaKeTHhIX 06pa3UOB MoryT OTJIIfqaThC5I OT pe3YJIhTaTOB Mo.r:t:eJIIfpOBaHIf5l.3.Bpa60TenpIfBe.r:t:eHaqIfCJIeHHa51MeTo.r:t:IfKa paCqeTa TOJIhKO.r:t:JI5IMarHIfT03JIeKTpIfqeCKIfX MallIIfH, HeCMOTp51 Ha TO, qTO aHaJIIfTIfqeCKIfM paCqeTMallIIfH C 3JIeKTpOMarHIfTHhIM B036Y)l(.r:t:eHIfeM B pa60Te npIfBe.r:t:eH.3aKJlIOQeHUe.)l,IfccepTaUIfOHHa51pe3YJIhTaThIpa60ThIpa60TaHanIfCaHanpe.r:t:CTaBJI5IIOTHaBhICOKOM3HaqIfTeJIhHhIMHayqHoMIfHTepeC.ypOBHe,OTMeqeHHhIe3aMeqaHIf51 51BJI5IIOTC5I YCTpaHIfMhIMIf, o6II(a51 OueHKa .r:t:IfCCepTaUIfOHHOM pa60ThInOJIO)l(IfTeJIhHa.OTpa)l(aeTABTopecpepaT.r:t:IfccepTaUIfOHHoMpa60ThI«MHorOnOJIIOCHhIeHnOJIHOCThlOCHHXpoHHhIeOCHOBHoecooTBeTcTByeT3JIeKTpIfqeCKIfecO.r:t:ep)l(aHIfeeM.)l,HccepTaUH5IMallIHHhI06paII(eHHOMKOHCTPYKUIfH» 51BJI5IeTC5I 3aKOHqeHHOM HayqHO-KBaJIHcpIfKaUHoHHoM pa6oToM, OHay.r:t:OBJIeTBOp5leT.r:t:HccepTaUH5IM,BceMaeeTpe6oBaHH5IMaBTOp,BAK,I1BaHoBnpe.r:t:b5lBJI5IeMhIMHHKOJIaMKKaH.r:t:H.r:t:aTCKHMCepreeBHq,3aCJIY)l(HBaeTnpHCY)l(.r:t:eHH5I eMY yqeHOM CTerreHH KaH.r:t:H.r:t:aTa TeXHHqeCKHX HaYK..r:t:HpeKToparrepCOHaJIOM H COUHaJIhHOrO 06eCneqeHH5I107078, ropo.r:t: MocKBa, XOPOMHhIM TyrrHK, .r:t:OM 4,8-495-365-26-69; e-mail: vniiem@vniiem.ruA.r:t:pec:TeJI.:c£!Il\el\pUHa AT.!cTpoeHHe1..
