Отзыв ведущей организации (Влияние химического состава и структуры на обрабатываемость резанием титановых сплавов ВСТ2К и ВТ6)

MIIHOEPHAYKI{ POCCUUr[egepa.nrnoerocy.qapcrBeHHoe6roAxeruoeo6pa3oBarefiBHoeyrrpexAeu[eBbrcrrreroo6paroranun<Pu6uncxuftrocyAapcrBeHrrr,rfianuaqnonnrrfirexnr.r.recrnfiyHrlBepcrrreruuenu fI.A. Co,rorr.ena>>(PIATY uueun II.A. Co.nosrera)YTBEPXNAIOPexrop PfATYuueuulI.A.Corosresa,flyuruua yn., .u.53, Pu6rucx,.ffpocaaecraro6t.. | 52934.Ter. (4855)28-04-70.<Darc(4855)21-39-64.E-mail:root@rsata.ruil.// apryx!OT3hIBBeAyrqefi opraHl{3allln$e4epanrnoro rccyAapcrBeHuoro 6loAxerHoro o6pa3oBareJlbHorof{pexAeHI'IrITexHI4qecKI'IfiBrrc[Iero o6pa3oBauut <Prr6r.rncrrafirocyAapcTBeunblftaBI'Iaql'IoHHbIfipa6oryyHuBepcrrrer I{MeHLIlI.A.

ConosbeBD) Ha AI{CCepraIIrroHHyIoMrarponoltcr oit Hatutuu f eoprueenrr<BJrlrrHrrexrrMlrqecKoro cocraBa I{ crpyrTypbl Ha o6pa6arblBaeMocrbpe3aHI'IeMrr,rraHoBLrxcrJraBoBBCT2K 148T6>, flpe,qcraBneHHyloHa coItcKaHI'Ie) {eHofrcrerreHr4KaHAu.qararexHr,rqecKl,IxHayKno clleqrlanbHocrl{ 05'16'01 Ir cnJIaBoB.o6pa6orKa MeTaJIJIoBMerarroseAeHlle I,ITepMl,IqecKaf,AKTvarbHocrbreMbr.uucceDTaul,Iu.c[JIaBoBpe3auaeMcrol{Tllpo6neua rrnoxoft o6pa6arrrnaeuocrll rI'ITaHoBbIXOCTpO,qro CyqeCTBeHHO[OBBIIIraer ce6ecro[Mocrb rIpoI43BoAcrBaAOCTaTOqHOIIO CpaBHeHI'IK)c ApyfI4MI{r.r3AeJrlrftI,I cHI,IXaer Irx KoHKypeHTOCIOCO6HOCTbLI3|OTOBJIeHI'IAMeTaJIJIUqeCKUMIIMaTepI{aJIaMI,I, HaIIpuMep, cT,uItMI'I, [pI4MeAvrlrrHcKr.rx v3lle:Jrhrir,He cMorp,I Ha I{x tBHOe [peI{MyITIeCTBO'IIOSTOUyycTaHoBJreHr.Ie3aKoHoMepuocreft BILUIHI,ISpa3n[tlHbrx $arropoe (xraulrvecrorococraBa n crpyKTypHoro cocrotHl4rl crrJraBa)Ha o6pa6arbrBaeMocrb pe3aHlreMI'IKatlecrBo o6pa6atunaeuofi rroBepxHocTl{ HeCOMHeHHO.fiBrfieTog aKTyaJIbHOfigaaa.refi.OAnunr Ils gQQeKTIdBHbrxMeroAoB cHI,IXeHIII ce6ecrollMocrll rLITaHoBofinpOAyKIII,I[ tBJIf,eTCt CO3AaHI'IeTLITaHOBbIXcIIJIaBoB' npl4 [poI'I3BoAcTBe KoTopbIXpa6ore Murponolrcroft H'f.rrcflonb3yercrBropr{rrHoecbrpbe.B Alrccepralll4oHHofipaccMorpeHKaK p€!3 TaKofi "BroplqHblft" cflraB BCT2K, co3AaHHbIiB OAO6nrasxuMrro KoHcrpyKIrr{oHHbIM<Kopnopaqlrr BCMIIO-ABI4CMA" z r'wl-rLrouJuirct'cfinaBy8T6.pac[pocrpaHeHlroMyrETaHoBoMycBoficrBaMrrrr4poKoOgnaxo, B TaKrtx "nropuvn6lx"cnJlaBax rlpl4cyrcrByerAoBoJIbHo 6oluuoiB pa3HbIX[JIaBKaX,B pe3yJlbrarepa36poc IIo coAepxaHI,IIonerupyorqux sJIeMeHToBqero cTpyKTypa, a, cJreAoBaTeJIbHo,TexHoJIO IFIeCKUe LI MeXaHUIIeC(I{e CBOfiCTBarr3roToBJreHHbrx u3 Hr,rx [oJryQa6puKaroB MOryT CyrqecrBeHHo pa3rr'IqarLct.

B3a4asapa6ore Mutpouolrcxofi H.f. [ocTaBJIeHaaKTy€IIIbHaiIAr4ccepraqr{ogHoftpa3pa6orKr.r TEXHOJIOruII4 o6pa6orru [oJry$a6pl,IKaroB I'I3 c[JIaBa BCT2K,noJrrreHHbrxI,I3 CJII'ITKOB c p€r3HbIM XI{MIITtIeCKLIMCOCTaBOM,O6eCUeUranalOUlefiQoprrauponaruteoAuorl4nuofr ctpyrtyprtI{, coorBercrBenuo, craollJlLHoro ypoBHqCBOIICTB.Pa6ora Mr'trponolrcrofiH.f.nocBtIIIeHa I{3){eHI4Io 3aKouoMepnocrefi(poprvruporaurlr crpyKTyp6l B clJIaBe BCT2K pa3gol'o xLIMI4qecKofococraBa np1aTepMuqecKoM Bo3Ae[crBLI[ I{ lI3MeHeHI,IrI TepMocLIJIoBbIX rlapaMerpoB pe3aHI'I{ B3aBI{CuMocTrrOT xLIMI{qecKorO coCTaBa u cTpyKTypbl cIIJIaBa.

Kpove roro, n pa6oteycraHoBJreHbr 3aKouoMepHocrlr Ia3MeHeHI{s IuepoxoBarocru [oBepxHocTu (Ra) nOT COAepXaHI{JItIJIIOMI{HIISB ClnaBe 8T6.3aBUCr{MOCTI,IB AnccepraqlioHuofi pa6ore Mlatponolrcxofi H.f.HA}^{HLIXPE3YJIBTATOB, NO3BOII'rcUIIIX[oryqeH psA HoBbIXAAEKBATHO cpaBHrrBaTb, oIIeHI4BaTb 14rporHo3rrpoBaTb o6pa6a:rgaaeuoc6 p€aHr4eM (o,+B)-ruraHoorrx c[rraBoB cxr{Mr4qeCKItM cocTaBOM z Cr:pyrctypofi, a TaKXe upoI43BoAI4TbO6OCHOBaHHIIft nu6Op CIIJIaBOB C OnpeAeJIeHHbIM xI'IMIlqecKlIM CocTaBoM I4CTpyKTypoft AJUI AOCTLIXeHU' o[T[M€IJIbHOro coqeTaHl,If TexHOJIOrIlqecKI{X lIMeXaHr.IiIeCKItXcBOfiCTB.Tar, n pa6ore IIOKa3aHO,qTO pacCTOqHI{eMeXAy IIoJIocaMI4pa3IuqH6IMcABlrra (L.), o6paoyloul,IMlrct B cTpyKType cTpyxKn' MoxHo I{crIoJIb3oBarBBKarrecTBeKpI{TepIIf o6pa6atrrraevrocTl4 cruIaBape3aHlleM' II ycTaHoBJIeHo'rITo qeMMeHbIIIe gTO paCcTOtHI{e, TeM tlyqge O6pa6aTbIBaeMOCTbpe3aHI{eM: Hltxe yCLIJII{eqTOpe3axlrf 1r TeMrlepaTypa B 3oHe pe3aHLIt.

oAUaXO TaKXe ycTaHoBJIeHO'cpaBHeHr4e AaHHOTO [apaMeTpa MoxHo npoBoAI{Tb TOJIbKO AIS CIIIaBa OIHofococTaBa B pa3HbIX CTpyKTypHbrx cocToqHr4tx, TaK KaK IIpI{ Ir3MeHeHIrI4XI'IMItqeC(OfOCOCTaBaCnJIaBa 3aKOHOMSpHOCT6I,I3MeHeHI{t L" COxpanrerCt, HO a6cOJIIOTHbIe3HaqeHr,IrIMOryT CyIqeCTBeHHOOTJII4rIaTbc{'Mzrpononrcrofi H.f. ycrauoBrleHo,qro AJII crJIaBaBCT2K crpyKrypa c14TBepAocrblo35-37rno6yrspHofi Mop$oIorl1eft IIa9TI4IIc-Sa:n pa3MepoM3-7 Iraxr'aycvrve pe3alJrt\ I'I TeMfleparypy B 3oHeen.HRC o6ec[eqfiBaer MI4HIZM€IJIEHbIepgaH1rr. A nnq c[JIaBa 8T6 uoxa:ano, qTo cTa6r4JrbHoB6ICOKOeKaqeCTBOfloJrr,rpoBaHuofinonepxtrocu{ 3aroroBKll (c urepoxonarocTblo Ra < 0,04 unrr,1)COAepXaHI,IuanIOMuHI{S 6,0-6,3yo.

VneluqegUe r4IIvIO6ecle.{uBaeTcfl rrpIaCOAepXaHI,I.s AJIIOMVIH.I.4TOTHOCI4TeJIbHO 3TO|O I4HTepB€Ina npI',IBOAI',IT KKAqECTBAIIOBEPXHOCTII.}TXYAIIIEHI'IN I,I HCCTA6I,IJIEHOCTI,Igua.IIaIr,Ioc'rt pa6OTrr COcToIIT B pa3pa6oTKe pelKI4MoB oTXI'Irallparru.IecraqyMeHLIIIeHIIeropsqeKaTaHbrx [OIyOa6puKaTOB LI3 CIUIaBaBCT2K pa3Horo xI'IMIIqecKofo cocTaBa'oAHorl4nHoficrpyKTypblu cra6llrtbHbrxcBoficrB.o6ecne.IusaloqnxOopMupoBaHI,IeAnroponr oflpe,{eJleHbl TeM[eparypbl HarpeBa It cKopocrb oxJIaxAeHI'r{ BaropoB B cIIJIaBe' a pa3pa6oTauubleoT coAepxag vs, P-ATa6vnvtg3aBr,rcrrMocTl,IpexolMrr orxrrra o6ecle.rvBalor He T6JI6KOTpe6yeMblr ypoBeHb cBo[cTB, HO I4pe3aH[eM.cIIJraBanruryro o6pa6arrraaeuocTbKporrre roronpa6or:e MnrpononrcrofiH.f .AaHEI IrpaKTI4qecKI'IepeKoMeHAarlr4r4IIo Bbr6opy xr{MraqecKorococTaBa rpyrKoB ue cnlana 8T6,lpeAHa3HaqeHHbrxAnrLI3TOTOBJTeHTUTrlapoBbrxroJroBoKSHAOIpOT$OBTa3o6eApeuHorocycraBa: AJUryMeHr[reurir BpeMeHLro6pa6omu ]r o6ecneqenuscra6r.IrbgoBLrcoKofoKaqecrBaIIonuDoBaHHoirroBepxHocTr4 coAepxaHr4eaJIIoMI,IHIr.fln nonySa6pr.rxare6,0 - 6,3 Macc.yo.AoJrxHoJrexarbB rrHrepBaJreTaruu o6pa:oru, B Aficceprarluouuoi pa6ore Mra:rpouonscrofi H.f.rrocTaBJreHbr14 yc[errrHo pe reHbr aKTyanbHEIe3a.Aaqll ycTaHoBJreHI,It BIrLlsIJLrtrxr4Ml,IqecKorococTaBa 14 cTpyKTypbrcIIJraBoBBCT2K u BT6 Ha KoMrrrreKcMexaurarrecKlrxcsoficrs r.r TepMocr,rnoBLrenapaMeTpbrpe3aHr,rr,r.r pa:pa60rxlr nagTofi ocHoBerexuoJrorr{fi tx o6pa6orKr,r,o6ecne.rr.rBaroqfixperuraMenrr.rpoeanHofiypoBeubQusr.uco-lrexaHr,rqecKr4xceoftcrs.coBpeMeHHOrO [oBepeHHofooOOpyAoBaHLIt co6ecneqega I4crroJrb3oBaHI,IeMJII{IIeH3LIoHHbIM npofpaMMHLIMo6ecne.renr,rer4,rrpoBeAeHrderrlrzcnrrrannfi u mzvepeuui.rB coorBercrBnr-r c fOCT,xopolrr{M coB[aAeHr,IeMSKoIIepI{MeHTEUIbHbIXpaCqeTOB,AaHHbrXV TeOpeTIZqeCKUXI{C[OJIb3OBaHI,IeM MeTOAOBp€ynbTaToB.MaTeMaTI{rIeCKOlICTaTITCTITKII npfio6pa6o:rreB Hase 3 anroporr.r[ccJreAoBaubr gJIeKTpoxI{MIrqecKIrexapaKTepr.rcrr4Kt4BCT2Kpa3Hbrxpa:pa6oraHHbrMpexr{MaM.clJIaBarpexcocraBoB flocJreorxlrra no].B .rerneproft DraBe aBTopoNr6rrrv pa3pa6oraHbr pexr4Mbr ynpovunoulefireprurEuecrofio6pa6o:rrr.rAnfi SToro c[JraBarz o[peAeJreHypoBeHbMexaHrzqecKr.txcBoficTB, oAHaKo aH€rJrorurrHbrer{ccJreAoBaHr,rrKoppo3l{oHHofi croftrocru BynpoqHeHEoMMoDrr{6u npe4craerrrr,cocro.rrHrar.rxorr pe3yJrr,Tar6rorcyTcTByroT,uparctavecr<uftr.rHTepec.2.

B rrrase4 na nepnrrx gTarraxlrccJreAoBanr,rrBJrvrsnufrxI{MAqecKoro cocTaBacrrJraBaBCT2K Ha repMocr,rJroBbreflapaMerpbr pe3aHr{t (pa:,qer 4. 1) aBTOpp-cm6urrrsatopoByrBepxAaer,trro yBenuqeHr,re(parrrzuecrurKoJrr.HecrBaB crrJraBeHe BJII,IterHa yavrrkrflpe3aHrrrr(pucynor 4.2), u npI'IBoALITToJIbKoK rroBbrrueur.uoTeMrreparypbrB 3oue pe3aulrrr. Ognaxo, AaJree B TeKcre Ar,rcceprarllrr4,nprlr.rccJreAoBaHr.rrrBrrwt:,l,tr',rrapaMeTpoBcrpyKTypbr c[JraBa BCT2K Ha repMocr{JroBEreflap€Merprr pe3auvr (pasgene 4.2,) ua pficyrrKe 4.7 or'te'rnuro BrrAHa pa3Hfiqaycuttuit pe3aHr,rJrArs cocraBos 1 u 3 cnnana, flocJre pa3JrrirrHr,rxpexr4MoB:repur.r.recrofi o6pa6orru, Qoprnrupyroqux 6nrlsxlre flapaMerpbr crpyKTypbr rrK sroMy $axry anrop HenpHBoAur.rBep.{ocTr,rcocraBoB"llo.f,cHeHr,rfiAnr p€r3Hbrx3.

HeAocraroqso upopa6orauHhlM rlpeAcraBJlterct Borlpoc BJruxn:ruHa efoAonoJrHr,rreJrbHofonen{poBaHr4r BoAopoAoM cflJraBa BCT2K6rrr nrr6pau roJrbKo oAr,rHlrexanoo6pa6arbrBaeMocrb,T.K. AJr{ racc.[eAosaHr.rftcocTaB crrJraBa(u3 lpex r{ccJreAoBaHHbrxB paooreJ r4 r,rc[oJrb3oBaHToJrbKoo.ur4Hpexr,rM HaBoAopoxLIBaHI4s. BosN4oxHo I,I3MeHeHr4erepMo-KoHrIeHTpaI{r{oHHLIxrrapaMeTpoBBBeAeHI{rrBoAopo,qa uJrr{ ero BBeAeHr.reB c[JraB c MeHbrr]rIMr,IJIr46onrurzna[Mo]r*" Mo ro Aarb Apyrrrepe3ynbrarbr.C.uenannrre3aMerraHurHe cur{xaror Hayquofi r,r npaKTr4qecKofi[eHHocrr4pa6orlr.rao6utrefierrcoKofiorleHKr,r,qucceprarlr4r{B qeaou [peAcraBJreHHaErvcceprar\r4t BhIloJIHeHa Ha BbIcoKoM HayqHoTexHrrqecKoM )?oBHe tz [peAcTaBJr.rreT co6ofi 3aKoHqeHn]To Har{Hoxnarlr(fr.rxaquouuyro pa6ory, rroropofirc3Jrox(eHrrHaf{Ho o6ocnosautHeTEXHI.ITIECKITE IA TEXIIOJIOII{IIECKI,IE PEIIIEET4'.