Отзыв оппонента (Некоторые задачи эволюции движения деформируемого спутника в центральном гравитационном поле сил)

OT3hIBo$uqua.rrruoro o[roHenTa A.$.-M.H. Illarnuofr Alr6lrnu BnxroponnrrIra Arrccepraq[rc [o qynr Eo <<Hexoropbre saAaqrr 3BoJrroqnn ABrr]rceHrrfl,qeQopMr.rpyeMorocrryrurrrca B IIeHTpaJrbHoM rpaBETarI[oHHoM noJre crrJD) Ha corrcnaHrre yrreHofi crenenuKanArrAara Qnsnxo-MareMarrrrrecKlrx HayK rro c[eqnaJrbHocrlr01.02.0I<<Teoperu.recrcafl MexaHr.rKD).{uccepmquouHa, pa6ota .{o r{ynr Eo nocnxrqena r.rccneAoBarr}rro sBonroq}r[ ABrrxeHuf;crIyrHI,IKa, xotopufi MoAeJrr{pyercs m,r6o oAHopoArrbM r{3orponHbrM Bs3Koy[pynrM rrrapoM, ru6oALIHaMLIIIeoKI,I clrMMerplIrIHbIM TBepAbM TeJroM c xecrKo rrpr,rKpeilnennoft r HeMy Bf3KoynpyroficocTaBJIflIOIqefi. PeueHI,Ie MOIenbHbIx 3a,qarr, [o3BoJurrorqEx froHflTb xapaKTepHbre 3aKor{oMepHocTr.rAI{HIIMI,IKII I,ICKyCCTBeHHbIX CTIyTH}IKOB, CoAepxarq[x Br3Koylpyme SJreMeHThr, HecoMHeHHoIrpeAcraBilret nay.mrrfi }I fipaKr[rrecrufi uurepec.

AxryalbHocrb paccMarpr,rBaeMBrx B lu.rcceprarl]r]rrIBce 6olee Bo3pacralolqllMlr rpe6onauuxM[ K TorrHocrr,r o[peAeJreHr.Irr3eutu B HaB[rarlr4rl, reoAe3r,rr4, reoSrlsrEre..{racceptaqus cocrofiT I,rs BBeAenrrfi, rtflT?t HraB, 3aKJrroqer}r.f, r,r cfl]rcra JrfiTeparypu. OsacoAepxLIT 120 crpanull MiunuHollEcHoro reKcra, BKrrorrr[orqero 7 pucyrKoB r,r crrcoK JMTeparypbr3a4arr o6ycuonueHauapaMerpoB Bpa[IeH[sus 59 uaraMenosanr,rfi.Bo sreAeHurn o6ocnoBaua axTyilJrbHocrb reMbr .uucceprarlvrv\ ee Hafruuur HoBu3Ha I,rllpaxrl,IqecKafl 3Harll4Mocrb. onpeAenenbr rleJru H sma,qiu HccJreAoBaHuit. LlznoxeHo KparKoecoAepxaHl,Ie Allccepraul{onuoft paoorbl flpe4cranneHbr ocHoBHbre rroJroxe:flt4fls BbrHocr,rMbre Ha3aIqI,ITy.flepnax HIaBa HtrbrBaercs <Heo6xoArurte cBeAeHr.rs rl3 MexaHr{Kr.r 4e([opuupyeMbrxTBepAbx rerD>. Oua sBJlflercf, BcloMorarenrHofi I{ [peAcraBJreHa B nr,r4e pe([epara. B Heft r,lgloxeurrMero.4br, paspa6otaunrre BlaApIMlrpoM feoprueru.reN{ B}ImKe AJI' MexaHlrqecKl{x crrcreM c6ecxone.urhlM rII,IcJroM creneneft cno6o4rr, TaKxe MeroA MoAanbnoro aHaJrlr3a (rr,rero4 pa3roxeu[sno co6crseuubrM ([opuau), ]rc[oJrb3yeurrfi n Ar.rccepraur{}r.Bo nropoft HIaBe Alrcceprarll4ll paccMarpl,IBaerc.f, orpan[qeHHuur 3aAaqa o6 ssorrorlr4rrBpalrlarenbHoro ABlIxeHI,IlI cilytHfiKa, Hecyrqero nonyc([epr.rqecxyro aHTeHHy, Ha gJrJrrrrrrraqecxofiop6urc.

Cnyruur cocrol,IT us taepAoft uacru, coegranennoft rourofi noxr<ofi c nr:roynpyrofiuo.uyc(fepuqecxoft anrennofi. flpeAnoraraerc4,rtotndpAaa qacrb cuyrulrKa flBrrflercfl.o4nopognofiu ocecl{MMerpu.rHoft, [puqeM ee ocb cI{MMeTpI,II{ coBna,4aeTt ocbro cr{MMeTpr.ru uonyc([epr,rqecrofiaHTeHHhr (upr,r orcyrcrBull .qeQopl,Iaqufi). Aurenua flpeArroJrzrraerc, oAHopoAHofi z ueorponnofi,rlpeAcraBJrrrorqefi co6ofi .qocraroqHo xectnqe tnepgoe rero, 4e([opMarl]r]r Koroporo MrurBr, aqacrorhr co6crseHHrx xone6anprfi nauruoro 6omrue ymonoft cKopocrlr BparqeHr.r, c[yrHrlKa.B $ 2.1 orucaua rocraHoBxasmavtuB pzIMKux masefinoft MoAeJrr{ reop}rr yrpyrocr}r.B 52.2no4po6no BbIBoALITcfl BbIptDKeHIae .4Jrq ([yurquonana rroreHrlualruoft oneprrur rpaBr.rrarl[oHHororIoJIt.

B $ 2.3 peuraercs KBa3lacrarl{tlecKa,a 3aAaqa reopuu y[pyrocrr{. IIpr groM r{crron*yercffMeroA pa3AeJIeHlL ABl4xeHlrft, paspa6orannsrfi B.I. Bumxe, MoArurbnrrft uoAxoA, a raKxe .flenrrfinnA co6crneHHblx $oprnr ,{rs roHKofi uoryc([epruecroft o6ono.rrx, 3aKperrJrennofi n rroJrroce,rIoJIfreHHbr[ PsreeM. B pesynrtate BbrBoAr,rrcfi c]rcreMa ypanuenufi Anrr o[peAeJreHlrfl MoAirJrbHbD(rlepeMeHHbx Ir HaxoAlITc, pemeHlle srofi clrcreMbr.

B $ 2.3 BbrBo,{rrc, ypaBHeHr.rs, oflrrcbrBulrorq}reAHHaMIIKy BpalqarenbHoro ,{BI{xeH!rt cflyrHrara. 3ru ypaBneur{r Bbmr{cbrBuuorc, B KarroHrrqecroMBIIAe c I4c[oJIb3oBarI]IeM rrepeMeHrbrx Auayarle. ,{a.nee gBoJrrorlu, ABr,rxeur{fl crryrHprKapazl:ar,aercfl.Ha.uBa 3Ta[a. Ha nepnorra gTarre 6rrcrpofi gBoJrroq]M n $ 2.5 rpaBr,rraqflouHbre cr,rJrbr He )nmTLrBarorc.f,I4 BbIBoAI4Tcfl MeroAoM ycpeAHeHLI.f, clIcreMa yparuenlEfi Ars [epeMeuHbrx geficrnue, orrl{cbrBarorqzurBparrlareJlbuylo gBoJIloIIHlo ABr,rxeHru c[yrH]rKa oruocr{TeJrrHo rIeHTpa Macc. floKa3auo, uro(.I2-rvro.qynb BeKTopaK]rHeT]IqecKoro MoMeHTa G npanlareJrbHoro AB[xeHr,rs,IIepeMeHHhle 12, \GHa HopMtulb K lrJrocKocrr.r op6nru) B 9Tr{x ypaBHeHzrx He9BOJITOq[OH]rpyIOT, a flepeMeHruaX \ (1r - rrpoeKur{rr BeKTopa G na ocb c[MMerpr.rr4 cnyruura)gBonloqrloHrlpyer. B clyvae AuHaMLIqecKLr BbrrsHyroro crryrHr.rxa(A>C) sua.reHr.re flepeMeunoft\ -rpoeKIILIf, BeKTopa1.I1 /MeHBuIaeTc.s Ia cTpeMllTcfi K HyJIIO, a B CJI)FIae ,{I,IHilMLrqecK[ CxaTOro c[yTHr.rKa (A<C)3HaqeHlae [epeMeHHoit 11 !rcImtILIBaeTc, I,I cTpeMI,ITc.f, coBIIacTb c I2.KauecTBeHHo gToT pe3yJrbTaTcooTBeTcTByIoT paHee [poBeAeHIrbIM r,rccneAoBaH]rqM, Harrpr.rMep, AJUI ABHxeHr,rS Cr,rMMeTpr{rrHorocrryrHlrKa c Br3Koyrrpyrr{Mu crepxHf,Mr,r Ha KpyroBofi op6ute:1) EonomuHa H.8., Buaarce B.f.

finuxeHl,Ie cl,IMMerpr.rrrHoro cfiyru]rKa BoKpyr rIeHTpa Macc Harpyronofi op6rre rrpll Hiull,Iqrnrn nr6rnx Bfl3Koyrlpyrurx crepxneft ll KocM[.recxre ]rccJreAoBauvrfi.,1984,r.22, nbrr. 1, c.13-19.2) Buaaxe B-f., Illamuua A.B. Ssoruoqrs ,{Bl{xerrr{trBr3KoyrIpyrI,IMI,I crepxHf,Mrl Ha KpyroBofiop6rrc //cr.rMMerpr.rwroroc rra6xuun1994,t.32,n:r;rr..cryrn}rKaKocrr,rfi.recKr.re rrccJreAoBaur,rr,4-5, c.5l-61.j)IIIamwa A.B. 3sorloqus Bparr(areJlbHoro ABLIxeHr,ur cr.rMMerpr.rqHoro c[yrHr,rra c ru6rrarrar,rBs3Koy[pynIMI{ crepxHrMr,r // Kocrura.recKr.re }rccJreAoBaHr4.f,, 2002,r.40,N2, c. 178-192.B $ 2.6 ll3fraerctr3TarI MeAJlennoft LucctrrrarvrsHoft ssorroqlrr4 BcneAcrB[e retrtcrsuxrpaBLITaIIlIoHHbrx [pI,IJII.rBoB B cJlf{ae Ar.rHulMuqecK}r cxaroro crryrxr.rr a ( A < C ), c,mtaa 6ucrpyrol.ucciltrarfiBHylo SBoirIoqlIIo 3aBepmeHHoft ra nolarail ,qaJree 11=12, et=g.

Haft.qeno crarlr{oHapuoepemeHr.rexoxet-.a+?,\lq+l'zl.Arffi rIePeMeHHoI'I- x=I3fI2.florasano,rrro-orHocI,ITeJIbHoa@infi[epeMennofixLIMeer elrle ABa crarl[ouapHbrx 3xaqenurs.ypaBHeHr.rexl--lrx2=1,roroprre,Bn rorc, neycroftvuBbrMll.B rperrefi tJIaBe Allccepralllrll paccMarpvBaercfl, 3a1aqa o [ocryflareJrbHo-BparrlareJrbHoMABVxeHlrI{ Br3Koyrlpyroro mapa B IIeHTpaJrbHoM rpaBrrrarlrroHHoM rroJre cul.

3aAaqa perlaercflMeroAoM pa3AeJleuru Anraxeuufi u ycpeAHemils. c uc[oJrb3oBaH]reM KaHoHr.rqecxvx ypannenrafiArryafie-AeJloHe. Brrno4xtcr ycpe,qHeulrbre ypaBneHlrr, orrr4cbrBuuoqze gBoJrxlrluro MeAJreHHrxyfJIoBbX rIepeMeHHEX - AOJIOTbI [ep[reJrr.rs OT BocxoArrrlero y3Jra g.r.r AoJrroTbr BocxoAflrqero y3Jrah.rletneprax ilraBa rBJlrercf; rlpo,qonxeHr{eM HraBhr 3. B neft BbrBoA}rrcfl ycpeAHeHHa"f, cr{creMayparneuuft orHoclITeJIbHo EepeMeHHbx <<4eftcrnr.re) paccMarpranaeuofi 3ap1arilr.B nsroft HIaBe craB?ffc , 3araua oflpe.qeneHxx .4e([oprraarlnfi 3ena.uu rroA BJrr,rrur,reMrpaBI,ITaIIuoHHbx nolefi Corsqa u Jlynu.

3eNrns paccMarpuBaercff KaK BrsKoyrpyroe reJro,I,IMeIoqee rBep,qoe sAPo. I4cnolrsyerc, MeroA pa3AeneHr.rr ABr{xeHr{ft u rraoAa-urnrrft [oAxoA. AJrfluoJrytleHr,Ifi KaqecrBeuHoro e$(!erra paccMarpnBarorc, ToJrbKo ABe Mo,uurnrHbre rrepeMeHubre Qzo ilP2O, KoTopble MoAeJlllpyror rIplInI,IBHhre rop6rr 3eIruu.

HaftAeurrxorra6rEnarlr.rr,rrrepeMeHnbrx, Koropbre olpgAeJrflror qacrorbr npr.rJrr.rBHbx 4eSopuaqzft .3agatu,paccMarpllBaeMbre B Al,Icceprarl[pr, sBJurrorcf, oqeHb cJroxHhrMr.rno o6reuyrayrnoBbx[o [ocraHoBKe, r{aHiIJII{TI4rIecKLIx BbIKJraAoK, Koropbre neo6xo4r.ruo [poAeJrarblpeAcraBJreHubx pe3yJrbraron. K 4r,rcceprarlprr4 r,rMeerc.f, px4 saueuaulrft.3apre.rannfl rro Ar{cceprarlrronHoft pa6ore.1) Bne,4enue He coAepxur o6rop tro reMarr,rKe lr,rcceprarluu.Ars. [oirfreHr.rfl2) IIo MHeHLIIO peIIeH3eHTa IrCCJIeAOBaHr,re Ha gTa[re rrle4nennofi Auccr,rrrarlrsHoft ssorroqufin $ 2.6 rllasbr 2 npone4euo HeKopperrno.

flonara"ff, nro op6xramnilr yruroBtur cKopocrb arg MHoroyruonoft cKopocrl{ Bparr{eHl,If, cIrytHI,IKa IZIC, Ar.rccepraHT BBoAr,rr rualrrfi [apaMerpe1 = Cag f 12 I,I c roMolqblo paBeHcrBa sJ2 = Ca4 saveurer rrepeMeHHyro I2 ua roucmury. BMeHbIIrepe3yJlbrare BMecro cLIcreMhI ar.roSepeHlll,IiurbHbrx ypanuenuft BToporo floprAKa orHocr.rreJrbHo12, 13 (ckopoctu oBoJIrorII{I,I oTI,Ix [epeMeHHBD( r{Meror o.qr.rH nopx4or) r{3fraercf,auftQepenqllaJlbHoe ypaBHeHI{e repBoro ropflAKa orHocr.rreJrbHo fiepeMennofi x = cos dt = h I Iz.Haftgeno crarllro,apHoe pertreHlre .rg* ,rffifiBbr3brBaerfloKa3alro, lrro ypaBHeHI{e orHoc}rreJlbHo rrepeMeHHoftxl=-lrxz=l,xcoMHe,r,r.f,. Kpoueroro,rnueer erqe ABa craqr.ronapubx 3uarreur.rsKoropble sBrslorc, neyctoft.nrBrrMra. Ilolyrennsre BLrBo.(br pacxoArrc, cpByJIbraraMI,I, lI3JroxeHHbIMrI B BbrrrreuepeqlrcJreHHrx pa6orax [1-3], r4e 6ruro rroKa3aHo, qrocTarl[oHapHoe pemeHkre x=l xsJltercs yctofi.u.rnrrM) a x=-l -seycrofi.rznrru, T.e.

B cJrfraeA < C ABuxeHLIe crIyrI{I{Ka crpeMl,ITct K rlprMoMy Bparr{eH}rro BoKpyr ocr{ cr{MMerp}ru,HarlpaBJreHnoft no HopMaJII,I K IIJlocKocrIa op6uru. 3naqeH[e flpeAeJrbHoft yrnonofi cKopocrr{orlpeAeIseTc.f, HarrarrbHbrMrr ycJroBr,rrMr.r.3) 3nonroqr{oHHble ypaBHeHI,It, tloJrfreHHbre B HraBax 3 u 4, c rorrHocrbro Ao o6osHarir;Hufr.coB[aAalor c ypaBHeHI{tMI{, rlpeAcraBJreHHrrMr n pa6ore Mapxona lOpnr feoprnenu.ra:4) Maprcoe IO.f.llpocrpiurcrBeHHoe ABLIxeuue 4e([opMr.rpyeMoro reJra B rleHrprrrrbuoM rroJrecun I I Kocna[.recrfie r{ccJreAoBanyrs, 1988,.t.26, sttn.

2, c.236-245.flpn sroruB crrr,rcKe Jrr.rreparyphr gTapa6ora He 3Hatrr,rrc.f,.3aAa.ra o [ocryflareJlbHo-BparllareJlbuoM ,qBr{xenr{r{ Bs3Koylpyroro ruapa B ueHTpaJrbHoMHbIoroHoBcKoM [oJIe cr.rr 6rrna [ocraBJrena r.r pemeua B BeKTopHoM Br.rAe Bu.rrrxe B.f.:5) Bwurce B.f. fiuuxeul,Ie B{3Koyrlpyroro ruapa B rIeHTpaJrbHoM HbroroHoBcKoMflpnuaguax MareMarr4xa u MexaHr{ra, 1980, r.44, nrm. 3, c.395-402.r,orrecut.ll3areu 6rrnu [onrreHrl oBoJIIou]IoHHbre ypaBHeHr,r, BpaTrlareJrrHoro ABr{xeuus Br3Koyrrpyroro ruapaHa KpyroBofi op6ute II flocry[areJrbHo BperrlareJrbHoro ABr{xeHr{fl B (firJIocKoMD cJrfrae:6) Bunarce 8.f., Konatnoe C.A., Maprcoe IO.f. Ssorroqus Bparr{arenbHoro ABlrxeHluBr3Koyflpyroro ruapa B IIeHTpanbHoM HbroroHoBcxoM rroJre cr4Jr lltlpnxsnguaJr MareMarvKauMexaHr.rra, 1985,'r.49, nu[.