Отзыв оппонента 1 (Математическое моделирование пространственного распределения лучистой энергии от сложного излучателя)

3rs.tOT3bIBo$uqvalbHoro orrrroHeHTaHa Avrcceprarlurc@uruuuosa fre6a Cepreenzqa Ha re[pocrpaHcrBeHHoropaclpeAeneHrlrlny.Iurr,ry:<<MareMarkrrrecKoeMoAeJrlrpoBaHr4ecroft 3HeprLrHor cnoxHoro r.r3nfrareJrD)rro creqraJlbHocrn01.02.05 <<MexannraxLr.{Kocrrr) ra3a u rrJra3MbD),[peAcraBneHHyloHa coucKanLreyrenofi crerleHu KaHHayKALrAaraQusuro-rraareMarlrqecKlrxllpu npoeKTlrpoBaHvrvrcoBpeMeHuofi"asuaquonnofi TexHuKLIyAenterctpe)Kr,IMoB,oIIpeAeJI{rotIIHxcepresuoe BHr4MaHLreoIIeHKepetull,r3yeMblxTerrJroBbrxKaK OCHOBHbIeee JIeTHO-TeXHHqeCKI4eXapaKTepUCTI4KlI,TaK LI C[eqU€LJIbHbIe,K KOTOpbrM oTHocl4Tcfl,orTHrrecKar 3aMeTHocTb.frasHrrNau LrcroqnrrKaMz IrlK-u:ryrelr'nfl, JIA n gaAHefi uorryc$epe fBJltlorcfgJreMeHTbr ABLrrarenrnofi ycraHoBKrir, pa3olpeBaeMble BrIXJIonHrIMLI ra3aMrI, crpy{BbrxJrorrHbrx ra3oB, MororoHAoJra, noBepxHocrra JIA I4crlblTbrB€lrorlue €DporepMllqe-crzfi HarpeBrrplr ABr4x(eHuuJIA s arrvrocSepe,orpax6HHoeroBepxHocrblo JIA ursprcroqHr,rKoB(npeN4e Bcero,3eulu u Comrqa).nlnreHr4eecrecrBeHHbrxvr3nr.v.q1eli'vrs.JIA s lil{.Auaua3oHe'craflozcrc cloco6on oueHKur{ cHrr}r(eHvrs.HoBLrrc-f,eaxHofi zagateit, rroAxoAbr K perueHl4ro Koropofi pa^:pa6arrraarcTc-syx{eAaBHo.

Cyrqecrnyroqr{Mlr cuoco6arulr cHrl}Kerrus,Iil{3aMerHocru JIA .f,BJlflrorcfl:rr,ro4raQurca:qi,lrfl,feoMerpr4tr BbrxJro[Horo ycrpoficrBa 4Bllraremnofi ycraHoBKLI (Ay)KaK c rlenbro cHrDreur{f, nnorqaApr HaxoMrrIVXct n npr*roft B[AkIMocrLI ee roptquxgJreMeHToB,cMerrreHllt BIIXJIoIHrIX rtr3oB c arMoc$epofiTaK Lr Anfl.nHrencusvrKarrvrvrB rlenrx uakrlKenufrZK-usnyrenvrfl BhrxJrorlHofrcrpyu; HcrronrsoBaHue pa3rLItIHhIXcuoco6oe oxnax{AeHur BHeruHr,rxrroBepxnocrefi Harperblx gJIeMeHToeAV; [pLIMeHeHI{e cilequaJrbHbrx Marepl{zuloB, o6naAaroqnx olpeAeneHHbIMI4 orITHr{ecKI4MHI4reuloSu:r4qecKrrMrr ceoficrsaNau v r.il.Heo0xoHeOOXOVrI\-A!.I.ATra3OHeJIA B Irfr(l'uarta3oHe3aMeTHocT}I JIAperueur4fl3al\aT{vcnu>r.eHlan3a4a'uvcHlr)r{eHur/lnr perueHLrflftrALrMo npoBeAeHrde LrccJreqoriatrufa uo pa":pa6orKe uoAerefiLI €ulropvrMoB pacv€raJIA, BKrloqat l43nyqeHl4eBcex KoMrroHeHToBorrpeAeJrf,rcrq[x cyMMapnoe Ll3n1^renrzeBbrxJrorruoroycrpoftcrna.

B nacrosqee BpeMf, B AaHHofi upe4vrernofi o6nacrx MHorlre MeroAhr cr4creMarl{3rrpoBaHbl?r oilvcanrr. K HI4MorHocflTcfl: MeroAbI nepeHocaceJreKTr{BHoro}r3nfreHr{rr BbrxJrorrHux crpyft B ycnoBllrlx JIoKaJIbHororepMoAI4HaMlrqecKoro paBHoBecvrfl;MeroA <<o6parHoroxoAa nyra) LI MeroA rlptMoro crarl4crl4rrecKoro MoAenupoBalc.vrs.Airs pelxeHufl.3aliaqu o nyqucroft Te[nolepeAaqe B rIoJIocTu, 3arroJurennofi (cepbrM) ra3oM u Ap. O,4naro, HecMorp.f,na 6olruroe KoJILIqecrBorenloo6ueHa, Mero4rr pacveuy6lnxaqaft n o6nacrvrpaALraqlroHHo-KoHBeKTLIBHoToycrTa onrr{qecKr4x xapaKTepklcrLtKTaKLrxcJrox(HbIXLl3nf{arelefi rax BbIXJIoTIHbIepoficraa (By) Ay JIA, cocrorrque rs 6omrloro KoJII{rIecrBaI{3nfraloilryIx rloBepxHocrefi c olpeAeJreHHbrMB3auMHbrMpaclonoxeHLleM I4 reoMerpueit, uttercrrtrxx pa3JII4IIHbIE TEMIIEPATYPbI }I OTITI4qECKI.IECNOfiCTSA, .f,BJI'IOTC.'I B HACTO.'IqCC BPCM' HCAocraroqno paspa6oraHnblMll.AHamas paspa6oraHHoro B Aansofi npegrr,rerHofi olr'acruHayqHoqTOMeTOALIIIeCKOTOanlapaTa IIoKa3hIBaeT,eMy npucytqu OlpeAeJreHHbreHeAOCTaTxz.

OcnoBHhIM HeAocrarKoM cyrqecrByrouvrx aHaJrurr4qecKLrxMeroAoB a rraoAelefiflBJlf,erct cJlox{Hocru yrera piBnLrqHbrx[apaMerpoB ABr{rarenrnofi ycraHoBKu\ cBfl3aHH€uIc pasnoo6pa3lIeM pexfl.IMoBnon€ra JIA. OAHr{Mr{3 HarpaBnenufi ycrpa*enufl.AaHHoro HeAocrarKa flBr.f,ercr coBeprrreHcrBoBaHkreu paspa6orKa HoBhrx MeroAoBMaTeMaTl4qecKoroMoAeJII4poBAHuflIIpocTpaHCTBeHHorOpaClpeAeJIeHLIf rryrNCrOfi3Heprrrn or cJloll(Horo u3Jl1^{uteJrflu pazpa6orKa qncJrennofi MoAeJrr{,nosnolxrorqefirlporHo3llpoBarb IrIK-z:lyreHLIe oJIeMeHroBKoHcrpyKrlr.rr4Ay nA c yrerovr olrr{qecKrrx u reuno$Lr3rrrrecKaxxapaKTeplrcrlrK.B ca.f,sll c grLIM TeMaAuccepraquu @zrurrnoBa f.C.

nocn.flrr{eHH€urMareMaTI4qecKoMyMoAenI4poBaHLIIo[pocrpaHcrseHHolo pacrrpeAerrennfl,nyrncrofi gHeprlrrdor cJro)nHoror{3nfrareJur, snrqercs axryalrHofi .llpz erona npaKTlrrrecKl{ Ba)KHoit ssnflercr uenb ,4ucceprarlun, 3aKJlroqaroIJJ.aflcfl'rIoBbIrueHuI{ ToqHocrr4 orIeHoK npocrpaHcrBeHHofo pac[peAeJreH]r.n I4KrI3n)nreHl/tt npoeKrllpyeMblx u cyulecrByloqux Ay JIA co cnoxHofi xoHcrpyrcquefiBbrxJrorrHoroycrpoft crea..{nx 4ocurDI{eHI{rInocraBJrennofi qenr4 aBTopoM perlaercr :aa1v.uHafl3a1a-rra3aKJlrorlarcryaflcfl n parpa6orKe MareMarr4qecrofi n q[cJreHHofi uogenefi pacverapacflpeAelrelJus B npocrpaHcrBe nyqr{crhlx froroKoB or cJrox{Horo r43nrrareJrr, cocrof,Irlero zs anQ$pHo orpax(aloqux noBepxHocrefi, rro3BoJrrroqux5nrecrr uponsBonbHoe KoJILIqecrBoI,I3nyltarcql4x IloBepxHocrefi co cBoHM]rreMrreparypaM]r vr vrsryqarenbHbrMtr cno co6no cr flMv\ a raKxe r{x B3ar4Mr{yro 3KpaHLrpoBKy.,,{ucceprallut cocroklT rI3 BBeAeHVrr,Tpex p€BAenoB,3aKJlroqeHrlrLr rrprnoxeHuft, lt3nox(eHa sa 136 crpaHrlrl€x Marrrr{HorrlrcHororeKcra, coAepxut 76 pucyyKoB 146 ra6r:ra4.

Cuucor ucrloJrb3onanHoftnr4reparypbr BKrroqaer 114 sauveHoBattuir.Bo sneAeHuu aBTop olpeAeJlter Ilenb l{ [peAMer Lrccne.{onartuit, ocyqecrBJlter o6sop orKphITbIX cylqecrByrorqux MeroAoB r4 rraKeroB rrporpaMM, rrprrMeHseMbIX Am MoAenI4poBaHLI-s[pocrpaHcrBeHHoro pac[peAeneHr{r renrosofi TelJroBoroI43nyqeHplflpa3nvY'Hblxycrpoftcrn. B gannofi -tacrv pa6orrr aBTopoM o6ocuoerrsaerct aKTy€rrrbHocrb Lr rraylmafl HoBrr3Ha pa6 oru.llepsar{ rrana I4Meero6sopnufi xapaKTepu rrocB{rrega onucaHr{ro6a:onofrMoAenI4np-fiMol-oLI3nfreHI{s nfrlrcTofi sneprul4 gJreMeHToBpeaKTr4Bnoroconla,{YIIA, a raKx(e rronrreHl4lo p$ynbraroB qLrcJreHHhrxsKcrrepr4MeHToBMoAeJrr.rpoBaaLrl_rrptMoro I43nfIeHI4t BHyrpenneft [oBepxHocrl4 corrJra B pa3nkrqHbrx pex{r.rMax rIrcouSnrypa\Lrflx.Bropa.f, rrana [ocBtlrleHa MoAen]rpoBaHr4rorrprMoro Lrcn;ytenwfllyvracrofisHeprI4LI3JIeMeHTonryp6aubl LI IleHTpttirbHoro gJrnr4rrcouAHororeJra Ay JIA, kr aHanLI3y ux BrrvrfllenflHa nHAlrKarpucy VlJf,.u:nyrenur [V JIA putr.pa3nr4qHhrxpexfl.rMoBa rcon$uryp a\wfi.

corrJra.B rpeuefi maee [poBeAeHo MareMar[qecKoe MOAOT.IpOBaHLI9 OTpa)K€HHOTOI43nr{eHr4.rrcJrox{Hofo LI3nyIaTeIrg.,cocTo.slllefo KaK r{3 BHyrpenneft [oBepxHocrrlcorIJIa, TaK H rypbuuu n IIeHTpEurbHorogJIJII4rIcouAHoforeJra, c yqeroM I4x orrrr4qecKr4xceoficrs.Anropou rpoBeAeHa oIIeHKa BKJIaAaB llHAlrKarpr,rcy [V JIA nepeorpax(aeMoro l43[yqaloqvMll rroBepxHocrrMr4u3nyrreuur. llpoBeAeHa nepv$urca\LrA MoAenHu ee rpolpauuuoft peaJrlr3arlunnaocHoBe:- cpaBHeHLIf,pacqeroB, rroJryqeHHbrxc noMorqbro pa3pa6oranHofi MoAeirr414MOAenV Ha OCHOBeMeTOAaHalpaBnqrorllrx KOCLTHyCOB,- cpaBHeHI4s c 3KCIIepLIMeHT€uIbHbIMIrtAaHHbIMI{ IIO [pOCTpaHCTBeHHOMypacrpeAeJrenr4rolyrzcrofi oueprvn or [Y TCzl.Anropotvt rpoBeAeHo MoAeJrkrpoBanuer.rHAlrKarpr{cbrx3JrfreHlrrr Ay AX31@ n IM guarra3oHe,a raKx(e rpeAnoxeHo r{ r{ccneAoBaHoHa e$$erruBHocrb crloMolrlbrc pa:pa6oraHHoro HM rlporpaMMHoro o6ecue.reHurflyarpoficreo, cHr{r{arotrlee ypoBeHb pl3nf{envrfl BbrrrreyKa3aHHoro!V anr 6omruuncrBa paKypcos Ha6rro-AeHLr{B 3aAHrorouorrycQepy.HaH6onee cyulecrBeHHhrMrr,iloryqeHHbrMr4nr4rrHo aBTopoM"sBnrrorcfl cneAyloqr4 e p e3yJrbrarbr 14ccneAoBaruuit:1.

A-rrroprarnr<<ThermalRadiatioru> z rporpaMMnoe o6ecreqeHue Am perxeHrI][ Mero4oivrMoHre-Kapno 3apLarrno [pocrpaHcrBeHHoM pacnpeAeneHrrr4sHeprkrr{orcJloxtHoro Ll3[yqarenfl Nrfl cnpafl. rrp;rMoro rr3Jr]ryreHprr6es yrera orpaxdnHoro tr3JryIIEHI{'I.2. P*ynrrarbl pacueronB paMKaxarropLrrMa<Thermal Radiation) r{HAr.rKarpllchr orAenbHbrxpr3Jq4rarorqrlxrroBepxnocrefiAy nA.3.

YcnoxsdHnnfi anropnrM rI [porpaMMHoeo6ecue.reHr4eo [pocrpaHcrBeHHoMpaclpeAeJleHlluryrucroft sHepn4r,ror cJrox{HorornJr}4rarerrr.c yrerou orpoKeHLI;Ior BHyrpeHHr{xroBepxnocrefi Ay JIA.4. Pesylrraru pacu€ron B paMKax ycroxndnHoro urrrroprlTMa<<ThermalRadiation I4HAuKarprlcbrBcexLr3Jr1..raroquxrroBepxnocrefiAy JIA c yrerou MHoroKparHoronepeorpaKeHvfl.or BrryqpeHHHXrroBepxHocrefi.Ha)"rnar nosusHa p$ynbraroB LrccneAorialvrircocrotrr B:l.

Paspa6orKe MareMarrlqecKux uoAenefi rpocrpaHcrBeHHoro pacilpeAeJreHvrfl rrYilrcrofi SHepfI,IVor rl4rroBhrx 3JreMeHToBcJroxHoro lr3nfrarenr. llpra 3ToMyqreHbl peanbHbleorrrr4rrecKr{e}r rerrJro$usuvecrcuecsoficrBa r43nf{arcur{x rroBepxuoctefr, a Anfl.cn1yrafl.auQSy:no orpax(arorlr4x rroBepxnocrefi sJreMeHToBcnox(HoroIl3nfrareJrfl TaKxe pa:pa6oraHbr rr pealn3oBaHbr BhrqucJrr4TeJrbHbre€LJrfopLrrMEr.2.

llpe4no)KeHHoM oKpaHHoM ycrpoficrBe Anr cHrDxeHlnr LrHTeHcr4BHocrrrI,IK-u:nyv'elrrnflIY u npoBeAeHtrprarrurprcaero essercrunHocrx .qnr rrrrronoit asuaquosuoft ABr{rarenurofiycraHoBKrl.3. Paspa6orasnou [porpaMMnou o6ecleqeHLrn,[o3BoJr-trroqeMrroJrfrr4TbI4H,{HKarpI4cyLI3rryrlelrrvrflAy nA pa3nnqHofircon$urypa\nv AJrr pa3nr{qHbrxpenuuon pa6oru [Y.4.

Brr.rzcJIXTeJIbHbIX €uropurMax,oTITTIMI{3rrpoBaHhIX[o.q I4crIoJIb3oBaHr{ena 3BM cpe4nefiMorrlHocru.gKcrIepLrMeHToB,5. Pesynrrarax BIITIIIcJILITeJIIHIIX[o3BoJIrlBIuxx [onyr{HTbI4HAuKarpracbrKaKor.qenbHbrxoneMeHron /{Y JIA, rar v ily B rlenoM.Hayrrrar HoBI{3Hap$ynbraroB LrccneAosaHr,rfirro.4TBepx{Aaerc,4 cnu4erelrcrBa o rocyAapcrseHHofi pen4crpaqur nporpaMM Anrr3BM.Teoperr,r.recKa.f,sHaqzlaocru pe3ynbraroB r4ccneAosaHufi 3aKrrcqaercf, B pa3Btrrvrv MeroAoB MareMarprqecKoro Mo.{eJrr4poBaErrfrrpocrpaHcrBeHHofo pacnpeAeIreHufl lyrucroft sHeprl{r{ or cJloxtnoro r{3nfrarerrsupazpa6orKe qlrcrennofi MoAeJrLI,flo3Bolxrotqefi [porHo3LIpoBarb I4K-usnyreHr,re Ay nA c yrerovr olruqecKrrxxapaKTeplrcr[K r43nyqaroqux fioBepxnocrefi .eHHOCTb ilI.'Ic,oepra4Wt 3aKJlrcqaerC.rr B BO3MOKHOCTTIUCUOJTb3O-Bi3,HuApe3ynbr€IroBpacqera AJU{orleHrn I4K-saMerHocrpr Ay .IIA u paspa6orru peKouerUar{nfi IIo ee cHLI]KeHITo,a raK)KeB Bo3Mo]KHocrnpacqera reruroBbD(pexonr,roBpa3JILIrrHbxycrpoficre, r4e rpe6yercx y.rer reruoo6ueHa r.r3J$ryreHr{eM.Pa:pa6oraHHoe [porpaMMnoe o6ecrerleHrle Mo)Ker 6urr r4crroJrb3oBaHorrpkluccne.{oBanvrnHa rlpeAnoqrr{TeJrbHyroc roqKr43peur{qypoBHr onrprqecKofrsal,rerHocrLI $opvry r ron$zrypaqurc oJleMeHroeryp6unbr, rleHrp€rrrbHororeJra r{ BHyrpeuuefi noBepxHocrrn,{VJIA.B 14ccn eAo r,anuir 6 a":npyer cfl Ha r{crroJrb3o BaHr4LrcllcreMHoro tIoAXoAa rrpr4 rrocraHoBKeHaf{Hofr :a4auu v ee AeKoMno3vrrJvrkrHa qacrHble 3al,a.rv I4ccneAoBalrtlan;Ha KoppeKTHoMnu6ope ucxoAHbrx AaHHhrx olpeAeJreHI4I{yclonrafi, orpaxaloryux Bce cyqecrBeHHbre Qarropu, BJrr{rroqvre Ha rlrcny{areJIbHhIexapaKTepr4cruKkrrroBepxHocrefi [Y JIA; Ha HarJUrAHofiSusnuecrofi r4Hrepnperallnu [pI4H{TrIX orpaHl{.reHllft I{ Aorryrueuuit; Ha KoppeKTHoMLrcrroJrb3oBaHvwranpo6zpoBaHHoro MareMarllqecKoro a[[apara MeroAoB MareMarr4.recxofi crarlrcrr4KLI.,IlocroeepHocrr pegymraros uccneAoBarruitnoATBepxAaercfl,4ocrarounofiAnt [paKTI{KlI CXOAI4MOCTbTOOTIOHOK[pOCTpaHCTBeHHOTOpaOnpeAeneHr{rr?r3Jl)fieHr.rfl,rloJrylleHHbrxc r4crronb3oBaHLreMpa-rpa6oraHHofoHa)nrHo-MeroAr4rrecKoroanrrapura,cpe3ynbraraMl4 3KcrIepLIMeHToBrro r43MepeHr{roxapaKTepLrcrlrKLr3n} reHr{r .{V ruuoBoro JIA z MoAenbHoro cno)KHoro r43JryqareJrr.llonyrenHbre B AucceprarlI,tupe3ynbrarbr peanlr3eBA]rbr:1.

Vcnoxn6nnrrfi €ulroplrrM r4 [porpaMMHoe o6ecue.{eu}re o npocrpaHcrBeHHoM pacnpeAeneHHlIlyrucroft 3HepruI,ror cnoxHoro u3n1n{arelrflc yrdrou orpaxeHI{t or BIryrpeHHLx noBepxHocrefi Ay JIA n OKE uvr. A. Jftolrxn Szlzal OAOyMIIO upx orIeHKexapaKreplrcrlTKIrlK-ucny.reHr.rr4y .IIA.2. Mero4bl MareMarl4rlecKoro Moren Hp oBaLrprflrrpocrpaHcrBeHHoro pacnpeAeneHrr{ ny'rucrofi SHepfI4LIor cJIo)KHofoH3nyvarerfl r4 rrllcJreHHa.trMoAeJIb,Iro3Bonlxrcrlaf [porHo3tlpoBarb tr{K-us.rry'.reHrretry tIA c yrdrol,r orrrlrqecKux vr renno$ra3HtIecKIrIXxapaKTepr4crvrK,n yre6HoM rlpoqecce MocxoBcKoro aBrlarg{oHHoror{Hcrr{ryra (naqr{oH€urbHorouccneAoBareJrbcKoroyHr4Bepcrarera).llonyreHHble pe3ynbrarbr r{ccneAoBauuit MoryT 6rmr ucnoJrb3oBaHbr:B HafrHo -I4ccneAoBareJlbcKax1^rpe)KAeHH;rxMiano 6opoHrr Poc cnu (I!fufu|BBKO, BBC Muuo6oponrr PocctrarvrAp.) npero6ocnosauuurpeloeaHuftK Lr3nyqareJrbHhrMxapaKrepucrurau JIA;B opraHl43allntx rpoMbrrrneHHocrr{ (OKE urvr.A.JftorrbKr{, tIAfI4uu.