Отзыв ведущей организации (1145539), страница 2
Текст из файла (страница 2)
I{oensHa HayrrHblx no.loxeHufirBbIBoAoBpeKoMeH4aqufi,14cQopvry.ttupo BaHHblx B A rlccepraIIuu.Hayv.:.at HoBI,I3Ha AI4ccepraIII4oHHoroLIccneAoBaHr4s',rrpoBeAeHHofoflucapeurco Xannofi Bzrroponuofi, 3aKJrroqaerc.fl, rpe]KAe Bcero, n pa:pa6orKepa3Bu1vr4 o,6ulefi KoHrlerrrlr4ra SunancosofiKoHBepreHIIrIuLIKoHrJIoMepaIJvrvr BycnoBlrf,x )rcrofi.{r4eoro pa3Bvrrvrfl coBpeMeHsofi cucreMbl Ml,Ipoxog.f,ficrBeHHblxcB.q3efi; B pacKpblTvrkr vrx cyrrlHocTr{ H coAepx{a]Flkrfl Ha cTpaxoBoM r4 rreHcHoHHoMceKTopax M,tdpoBoro pr HarlraoHanbHbrx pbrHKoB Suuanconuxoco6essocrefi, o6ycnonneHHbrx peSopvrupoBaHr4eMclrcreM pa3BI4TbIX crpaH14ycnyr, araKxrecorlr4€LnbHo-oKoHoMuqecKr4xrocyAapcrB c 6rrcrpo pa3BuBarcx\vrMr4cs, pbrHKaMH;nrrpa6orre peKoMeHAa\uit ilo pe nr4poBaHr4ro rpoqeccoBBSunaHconofiKoHBepreHr\w orl4x ceKTopoB $unanconoro pbrHKa Ha Harlr4oHairbHoM uMe)KAyHapoAHoM ypoBHrx.Knaz6oree3Haqr4MbrM HayqHbrM pe3yJrbraraM r4ccneAoBaHvrfl,xapaKTeppl3yloqlrM efo HayrrHyrc HoBLr3HyLrcoAepxarrlt4M npkrpaqeHr4e HayqHofo3naHufl, B r4ccneAyeMbrx o6racr-f,x, cneAyer orHecrr4 cneAyroqee:rro c[erlnaJrbHocrrr 08.00.
1 4 <<Mnponafl sKoH oMrrKa>1. B pa6ore Ha ocHoBe aHurvsa ra o6o6uIeHH{ ocHoBHbrx:reoperr4rrecKr4x noAXoAoBTIOHI4MAHI'IIO MECTA KT PONT4 TPAHCHAIII4OHAJIbHbIX KOPIOPAqUI4cr4creMe Mapoxo3sficrseHHrrx cwzeit,KoHBepreHrlvuBBKCOBPEMCHHOPIa rarcKe rrpoqeccoB QunanconofiMrrpoBoM xog-f,ficree yrorrHeHo noH-rrrr4e <QunanconofiKoHBepreHrlr,ru) KaK gKoHoMr4qecKofi xareropkrv\ orrrvrqzreJrbHofi oco6eHHocrbrorcoropofi .qrBr.flercq yqacrr4e cy6lerron pa3nr4qHbrx ceKTopoB MupoBoro$uuanconoropbrHKa, paHeeB3ar4MonpoHrrKHoBeHrzeKoHKypzpyrculr4xcy6rerron SuuaucoBoropaHee cefMeHTbI IIo3BoJrfleT paccMaTpr4BaTbMex.qycooou;pbrHKa Ha He cnoficreeHHbre I{MefoKaK MexaHLr3M TTOBbIIIIeHLI{KoHKypeHrocnoco6Hocrrr Anq pa3nr,rrrHbrx ceKTopoB SraHanconoro pbrHKa vr AaerBo3MoxHocrr 6onee roqHo onr4carb coBpeMeHHyro reHAeHrlr4ro pasBurrvrflMrrpoBoroxog.sficrs a (ct.
27 -47; c. 67 -81).2. AnropfroKa3aJr,r{To qreHbr SzHauconoroAOnOnHr4TeJrbHbre MexAyHapoAHbre KoHKypeHTHbreKoHrJroMepara lonyqaror[per{MyrqecTBa, B ToM tII{cJIeBcQepe crpaxoBauut,6aurcoecrcofi Ae.rrrenbHocrr4, r4HBecrLrpoBaHr{-f, kr IIeHcI4oHHoroo6ecne.reHr4tr,npr rlcrroJrb3oBaHvrkr MexaHr43MoB cMe)r(Hbrx ceKTopon SunaHcoBofopbrHKa (crp.85-92).3. HaocHoBe rrpoBeAeHHoro aHaJrtrsa npoqeccoB Qzuancoeoft KoHBepreHIIIlrIaBTopoM Bbrf,BJreHbr napaMerpbr, rposBlreH:uflH ee upo6nenau, o6ycronJleHHbleBcelo,nos4eficrBkreM, rrpelrAenpoucxoA.f,ru4err,ro4zsurca\r4k1Buo6anugarJLrkrurru6epatnsarp4r4.llora:auo, rrropa3BnTbIX r4 nocTcoIJt4anLIcTkIrIecKI4x SKOHOMT,IKaX ilpoqeccbrperynr4poBaHnfl,$zuanconrrx pbrHKoBBbrpa6arbrBarorneo6xo4IzMble AorIoJrHrITeJrbHbre oJreMeHTbr yrrpaBneHr4f, rrpoqeccoM $znanconofiKOHBepfeHrIHkr rrpr4 oAHoBpeMeHHoM BbrrBreHprv ocHoBHbrx llpurrr4H rrpoBaJroBperyJrr4poBa\rvrfl.
Ae.rrreJrbHocrr4 Sunanconbrx KoHrJroMeparoB Ha HarIHoH€LrrbHoM14MexAyHapoAHoM ypoBHqx (c. 92- f29).4.,{ora^:auo, rITo npncHLDKeHvrvrponu rocyAapcrBeHHbrx H Me)KrocyAapcrBeHHhrxcxeM corlr4aJrbHoro o6ecnerreHur HoBbrMLt gneMeHTarrazKOHBepfeHrIr{I{ CTaHOBTTCq HarIrrOHanbHbreSou4u, I4 crpaxoBbreKoMrraHr,rz,rrrorlo6alrsofiLr Me)KAyHapoAHbreSunanconofirreHclroHHbrebrcryrraer ocnosofi pa:pa6orrz HosofiKoHrIerrIr4Lr ooBpeMeHHoro ro cyAapcrea 6raro cocro-fl Hr4x (c. 1 53 - I 7 2).5.Baxuoe 3HaqeHHe uMeror rrpeAnolKeHHbre n pa6ore nepcrreKTrrBHbre HarrpaBneHlrtpa3Br4TLrflKilK HarILrOHaJrbHOfO, TaK VMeX(fOCyAapCTBeHHOfO pefynr4poBAHLrfl.crpaxoBoro r4 rreHcr4oHHoro cerMeHToB Mr{poBoro Srznanconoro pbrHKa, B ToMrrucre c yqeroM Heo6xoAraMocrLr a\anrarJLrn r nosofi r4HcrLrryrlr4oH€urbHofi cpe4e,BbrreKaK)nleii us nprrcoeAlrHeHnr Pocczu6,r BTO (c.286-321).Anroporr,r paspa6orana sna-tr4uafl.
Anfl ycnonzfi ycrofiuueoropa3Br4Tnfl,coBpeMeHHor,r cr4cTeMbr Mr4poxo3_f,r4cTBeHHbrx cB-rr3er4 MeToAr4Ka HoBoIo clleHaputnocTpoeHr4r coquarrbHofo focyAapcTBa, 3aKJrroqaror\afl,cfl.BcorlocTaBIreHI/.krcoqlraJrbHo-opueHTlrpoBaHHbrx rreHcr4oHHbrx peQopnr, pe€urrr3yeMblxcrpaHaxLrB p€l3HbIXpernoHax Mr{poBoro xos.f,ficrBa. llpe4naraeMa.rr MeroAuKa ocHoBaHa Haucrronb3oBaTrl"4J{AByx Kpr4Tepr4eB- peanH3ar\HvrrreHclroHHbrx npaB HaceneHvrs.4eficrnyroulero MexaHr{3Ma rrepepacnpeAeneHr{t prrcKoB, rrro Ilo3Bonf,eroT paHeer43BecTHbrx MeToAprK AoKa3aTb rrpeuMyrrlecTBaIIeHCLTOHHO-CTpaXOBbIXCXeM,BKTIOTIeHHbTXBrrpoqeCc14B orJII{rII{epe$opuzpoBaHpltMe)rqyHapoAHoI4Suuauconofi r<oneepreHrluv (c.20 a-23 5).rlocneqnaJrbHocrr.r 08.00.10 <<@nnaHcbr, AeHerr(Hoe o6pauleHrre u KpeAlrr>:1.
flpe4roxenrr npr4Hrlr4rrbr QopuzpoBalanfl neHcuoHHbrx npaB (ocrarounufi,nlocr<vfi, KoplrAopHufi, ernuriureHTHbr"), roroprre r{crroJrb3yrorcq Anr nocrpoeHuqpa3HbIX TpaeKTOpkIV pa3BLrTVtfl. Ha\VOHaJrbHbrX TIeHCI4OHHbTX CI4CTeM, r{TO AaeTBO3MO)KHOCTb OIIeHr4Tb COOTBeTCTByTOqUe oHHaHCOBbre frOCneACTBr4-rr frprrMeHeHr{.rrKaxAofi I{3 FII{x. Brrqsreubr HarrpaBrreHprfl pe$opur,rpoBaHlrr rocyAapcrBeHHoroperynupoBaurvrfl HaKorluTemuofi rreHcr,roHHofi r<orranoHeHTbr B p€BBr{Tbrx crpaHaxcrpaHax cpa3BLrBr4aroullrMr{cq pbrHKaMrr (c.20 4 -20 6 ; c.
21 6 -23 5).2. Baxnuvr HayqHbrM pe3ynbraroM, HMeroqr,rM Ha) {Hyrc 14 [paKTr4rrecKyro3Har{klMocrb, flBIrflerefl o6ocHoeaHue aBTopoM Bo3Mo)KHocrI4 LlcrloJrb3oBaHkrg.MeToALIKIz crarMaHarILtoHuLJIbHorocerMeHTon),- KoHBepreHrIrrHI{Anfl. aHattrasa Synrrlr4oHr4poBaHurfl,Mr4poBoro QranancoBoro pbrHKa (crpaxonorouro [por{urrocrpr4poBaHocorrocraBlreuvrfl. perl4oHanbHbrxzKaKlns PO Ha rrpr{Mepelrcy6rerronrreHcr4oHHorooMnr4purrecKoroQe4epanbHbrx crpaxoBbrx KoMrraHuit, rarcMupoBoro @Iauauconoro pbrHKaHa ocHoBe colocraB rreHr4fl14AnflSnnaHconuxKoHrJroMeparoB c "r<opeuuuru" 6auroBcKlrM Lrnv arpaxoBbrM 6usHecovr(c.|29-l35;c.136-149).3. Ha ocHose Mex{crpaHoBbrx conocraBresufiMorr{BarIVV yqaervrq rpa)KAannpeAJroxeHbr BapnaHTbr yBenrlqeHr4.f,s Hau6onee pe3ynbrarr{BHbrx cxeMaxrreHcl4oHHoroo6ecue.reHlrrr, rro3Bonrrcqrre uorpe6ureJrrM rrpr4 npr,rHflTLrv Suuauconrrx peruenufizs6exarr oruu6or<,cB.rr3aHHbrxcSrananconbrMr4 rrpoAyKTaMr4 AJILITeJIbHoTorroJrb3oBanux (c.
1 58- 1 70).4. TeoperuqecKaq H rtpaKT[qecKafl 3HaquMocrb pe3yJrbraroBrrccJreAoBaHuqTeope'ruuecKar 3HaqlrMocrb Ar,rcceprarlr4oHHoro krccJreAoBaHlzfl 3aKJlloqaercsBTOM,rrrope3yJrbTaTbr, nonyqeHHbre aBTopoM,IononHf,rorvpacrxl4pflIoTTeoperr4rrecxr{e npeAcraBJreHrlr no prAy HanpaBneunit, a r,rMeHHo: Teoperurlecr<ofipaspa6orKe KoHrlelrlr{rrpa3Br4Tr4fl.rreHcr4oHHoM ceKTopaxQr'ruauconofi xonsepreHrlr{Lr Ha crpaxoBoM$uuanconoro pbrHKa, rpanc$opMarlzu$uuanconux ycnyr, poJrr,rrzHcrr4Tyrlr4oHanbHbrx r4HBecropoBr4Hcrr,rryrlzorFriurbHo-opraHr{3aqraouuofi QopvmrI4crlcreMblproco6ofi- SunancoBoro KoHrJroMepara.flparcruuecKar 3HarruMocrb pe3ynbraroB pIcaJIeAoBauvrfl 3aKrloqaerctBO3MO)LHOCTr4 r{CrroJrb3oBaHr4flefope3ynbTaToBIIoBCneAyrcIquM ocHoBHbIMHaIIpaBneHLL,{M: B AetTenbHOcTI4 roCyAapcTBeHHbIX OpraHOB LI Me}KAyHapOAHbIX[nflopraHH3arluiiMexfocyAapcrBeHHofofocyAapcrBeHHofocoBeplxeHcrBoBaHI,IqpefyJrr4poBaHvrALrSzuanconuxTE,'ITEIbHOCTI4KOHfJrOMeparoB, BKrroqaroulzx rreHcHoHHyIo 14 CTpaXOByTO KOMIIOHeHTbI;BAerreJrbHocrn crpaxoBbrx KoMrraHuit, u HerocyAapcrBeHHblx rIeHcI,IoHHux $on4onAnfl rroBbrrrreHn.fivxKoHKypeHToc[oco6HocrLI; Anfl rIoBbIIrIeHI4x QunanconofifpaMoTHocTr4 HaceleHlrq Lr rcpI4Ar4qecKHX JILI{, CB-f,3aHHOI4crpaxoBbrM o6ecre.reHrreMvrCBo3MolKHocrI,I BoBrerIeHLIqAonrocpoqnrcfi ocHoBe B HHBecrHrILroHH rfi upoqecc14VfIeHCI4OHHbIMvxcpeAcrBHATeM caMbIM QopuzpoBaHr4eBHyTpeHHefO uHBecTr{rlr4oHHoro rroTeHrILraJIa cTpaHbI H KaK CneACTBI{e yBeII4qeHI4e6larococrofl:akrfl.
AoMoxo3sficre. IloryuenHrre pe3yJlbrarblHcrroJrb3oBar{blBMoryr 6uruAilnbHefirur4x Hayr{HbIX I4ccJleAoBanrlaflx, npoAoJlxatouluxLrpa3BrrBarorlr4x AaHHyro reMarr4Ky B KaqecrBe reoperl4Ko-MeroAolorI4rlecKofi 6a:rt,a raKxe AJrf, rroAroroBKlr yue6no-vreroAr4rrecKux MarepLIaJIoB [pI4 qTeHLILI KypcoB<MeN4yn apo1rrafl gKoHoMr4Ka)), <MeN4ynapoAHble BaJIK)THo-SuHaHconnteorHorrreHlrr)), <Muponofi pbrHoK crpaxoBaHl4-s 14 perynzpoBaHl4e crpaxonofiAe.rrrenbHoc:tr{)), <MuponofiprruorcrpaxoBaHnfl>>) <PerynupoBaHl{e crpaxonofiAerreJrbHoc:rr4)), dlescnoHHoe crpaxoBaHlle)), <CrpaxonaHlle 14 yrlpaBneHueplrcKaMr{)), (collnanbHoe crpaxoBaHrle))uAP.5.
[ucrcycclroHHble BorIpocbl rI 3aMerraHufl rro ArlccepraIIlruHecuorps Ha o6qyro rroJroxnTenbHylo oIIeHKy rlpeAcraBrleHHoroLrccneAoBaHnfl.KOTOpbre-flucapenro X.B., cneAyer o6parurrBHI4MaHI,Ie Hap-lA MoMeHToB,Tpeoylor aBTopcKofo yroqHeHlls:aBuop B Ar4cceprarlr4r{ orrr4paerc{ Ha o6urzpnrrfi uccJleAoBarelscrcunMarepuzln(n 6u6tuorpaSuuecKoM crrlrcKeoKoJIo 400 sararueHosaHlafi), o,quaro necoBceM rrolrHo orpa)KeH BKnaA poccHficrux yr{eHbrxaKTy€lJrbHofi reuarvrKvr vrccreAoBaHr4q.B qacrnocrl4,B paspaOoxyAasnoffHe KoHKperr{3I4poBaH BKnaApflAa aBTopoB, HerIpI{BeAeHbIvxcyuleorBeHHble pa6orbrvrpe3ynbTarblI4CCJIEAOBAIg.LTfi.- BAncceprar\vv He paccMarplrBarorctvHe oqeHuBarorc.fl npoqeccblponl,IQuuancoeofi roneepreHrlr{u n Bpa^:unvvr 14LIlr.guu, xor-fl aBTop yrloMl{Haer oEPI4KC Ha Mr.rpoBol,r SunancoBoM pbrHKe vr aHaJrv3t4pyer rpyunefiurue rcuraitcKLIeSunauconbre KoHrJroMeparbr.Enpocoro3avrflpu erou nau6olrurufiCIIIA, xor.f, B rrocneAHeeSraHanconbrx pbrHKoB crpaHcr4JrbHo BJII{f,erarcqenr cAenaH Ha crpaHblBpeM{ rleHcuonnrrfi I{ crpaxoBoft cerueHrc BbrcoKofi .ILIcreHHocrbIo HaceJIeHu{ AocrarorlHoHa uI,rponofi Qrauanconufi pbIHoK.