Отзыв официального оппонента к.ф.-м.н. Я.Б.Казановича (1105172), страница 2
Текст из файла (страница 2)
KaK H B cjiynae T3aHanH3HpOBajiHCb nepBa^ H Bxopa^ nojioBHHa CKanoB, npn SXOM apxnxeKxypaCBflsen npe^nojiaranacb o^HHaKOBOH ^JIH BCCX HcnbixyeMbix (BejiHHHHbi CBHSCH, ecxecxBCHHo,MOFJIH 6bixb pasHbiMH). Jinx Bbi6opa Han^ymiieH apxnxcKxypbi B CMWCJIC Hanjiymuero 6a;iaHcacnoco6HocxH onncaxb nojiyMCHHbie B 3KcnepHMenxe ^aHHbie AJIH BCCH rpynnbi HcnbixyeMbixMCXOA GanecoBa cpaBHeHHa Mo^ejieH. T-KpnxepHH Cxbfo^eHxa noasojinji, KaKne H3 napaMexpoB CBHSCH HMBIOX cpeAHee 3HaneHHe B rpynne, snanHMO OXJIMMHOCox nyjifl.AnajiHS nojiHOH MO/ie-nM MMCJI uejibK) He xojibKO BbmBHXb SHaHHMbie CBJISH B ^aHHOHHO H npOACMOHCXpHpOBaXb HeHSMCHHOCXb CBMSCM B GaSOBOH MOfl,QJ\H. 3x0 AOJDKHO 6bIJ10HXO apxnxeKxypy CBaaen MO>KHO ycxaHaBjiHBaxb, nocneAOBaxe^bHO ao6aBJiHH K CMCXCMCHOBbie cxpyKxypbi. C SXOH uejibK) K 6a30Bofi MOACJIH H3 nexbipex o6jiacxenAo6aBji5ijiacb o^na H3 naparHnnoKaMnaiibHbix oGjiacxen H npoBep^^iHCb rnnoxesbiBcex BO3MO>KHfaix B ^aHHOM cjiynae 96 apxnxeKxyp.YcTOHHHBOCTb o6Hapy>KeHHbix apxHTCKTyp cBflsefi npoBepflmacb raioKe nyTCMMS oGjiacreH.
B KanecTBe raKOH oGjiacTM Gbijia BbiGpana oGjiacTb PCC. 3xo HPHBOAHJIO KHHCJia B03MO>KHbix apxMTCKTyp ,n,o 72. Bee npoue^ypbi no nposepKe rnnoTes BpaCLUHpCHHOH MOAC-TIM H B MO^,eJlM C y^aJlCHHCM O^HOH M3 oGjiaCTCH OCTaBaJlHCb TaKHMH )K6, KaK Bcjiynae 6a3OBofi MO^CJIH.BTOpaa nacTb rjiaBbi 1 nocBflmena HCcneflOBaHHio cexeH spHTejibHoro3flecb B KanecTBe SKcnepHMeHTajibHbix ^aHHbix HcnojibsoBajracb sanncn 33F, a BanajiHsa /JKM.
3xo CBJBano c TCM, HTO ynacTByiomHe B peaxuHH nao6jiacTH Mosra xopomo H3BecxHbi, a ycxaHOBHTb nazio Jiniub KaKHe CBJOH3THMH o6jiaCTHMH HBJI«K)TCH SCjxJDeKTHBHblMHnpH CTHMyjIHt[HH. 3xO MO^CT 6bITbnyxeM cpaBHCHHH (J)HKCHpoBaHHoro Ha6opa pasjiHMHbix apxHxeKTyp H BbiGopanpaBflOnO^oGHOH. B TO yKQ BpCMH, HCHpOHaJIbMblH OTBCT Ha 3pHT6JlbHbIH CTHMyjI SaHHMaCT H6Gojiee COTCH MHjijiHceKyH^, nosToiviy RJIK ero perncTpaitHH MezuieHHaji CHCTeMa <J)MPT ne,/JjM c6opa aaHHbix npHBjieKajiocb OKOJIO .znsyx aecaxKOB HcnbiTyeMbix. Sa^a^aHcnbiTyeMbix 4)opMyjiHpOBajiacb B napa^Hrivie oait-6ojiJi, npH KOTOpoM H3o6pa>KeHHaTHna (cxaH^apTHbie) BpeMH OT BpeMeHH nepeMe^KanHCb Hso6pa)KeHHJiMH ^pyroro THna.
KaK-TO pa3JIHHaTb 3TH CTHMyjibi OT HCHblTyCMblX HC Tpe6OBaJIOCb.33F perncTpHpoBajiacb no 128 KananaM B ananasone nacTOT 0-200FU, c nocjie^yiomeHB aHana3OHe 0,3-30 Fu. OT^ejibHo paccMaTpHBajincb BpeMCHHbie cerMCHTbi sa100 MC AO npe^'bHBJieHHH CTHMyna H 1000 MC nocne npea'bHBJieHHH CTHMyna. C yneTOM ^ByxTHHOB cTHMyjiOB Bcero nojiynanocb neTbipe THna BpeMCHHbix cerMCHTOB, KOTOpweaHanHSHpoBajiHCb HesaBHCHMO. flufl rpynnoBoro anajiMsa 33F /jaHHbix AMCcepTaHTOM GbijiaHariHcana nporpaMMa, aBTOMaTHSHpyiomaa npe/i,o6pa6oTKy ziaHHbix, o6cneT Mo^ejieH MCTaTHCTHHecKHH anajiHS napaMexpOB MO^eneH.AHaJIH3HpyeMaH CHCTCMa COCTOHJia H3 nepBHHHblX H BTOpHHHblX o6jiaCT6H SpHTCJIbHOHo6pa6oTKH cHrnajioB. B KanecTBe TaKnx o6jiacTen 6buiH Bbi6panbi ^BC o6;iacTH VI H ^BCHHJKHeBHCOHHbie HSBHjiHHbi ITG (inferior temporal gyrus) - no oflHOH B Ka^K^OM nojiymapHH.OCHOBHOH Bonpoc - KaKHe CB5I3H B ^aHHOH CHCTCMe no^BCpraiOTCH HSMeneHHto npH noflaHeCTHMyna.
/Jjifl nojiyneHHH OTBCTa na nero 6biJiH npoTecTHpOBanbi Tpn MO/iejiM: 1)B KOTOpon CHJia csasen HC Moma MeHJiTbca B saeMCMMOCTM OT3KCnepHM6HTa (CTaH/],apTHbIH HJ1H ACBHaHTHblH CTHMyil), 2) MOflCJlb F, 171,6npaMbix CBasefi H 3) MO^ejib B, r^,e Moma MCHHTbca CHJia o6paTHbix CBasefi.Eme O^HH Bonpoc, na KOTOPWH npe^nojiarajiocb ^aTb OTBCT BCOCTOHJI B TOM, HTo6bI npOBCpHTb, HTO HOS^HHC KOMnOHCHTbl nOTCHUHajia B VIoGpaTHbiMH CHrnajiaMH OT ITG. Jinn STOTO MCTO^ ananHsa JJ,KM npHMCHJuica Ha pa3HbixBpeMCHHbix HHTepsajiax MOK^y 150 H 250 MC OT MOMeHTa npe,zrbflB.neHHfl cTHMyjia, npw STOM /uiflana/iHsa GpajiHCb TOJibKO OTBCTbi Ha CTaH^apTHbie CTMMyjibi (oueHMBaTb pa3HHuy B peaKUHM HapasHbie THnbi CTHMynoB B ^aHHOM Hccjre^oBaHHM UCJIH He CTaBHjiocb).3. B Cannon rjiase npHBOflHTCH pesynbTaTbi Hcc^efl,OBaHH« no o6eHM1. B 3a,naHe 1 (BbiHBJieHHe CTpyKTypbi DMN) c noiviombK) MCTO/ia T3 H cpaBHCHH* ccypporaTHbiMH BpeMeHHbiMH paaaiviH OUCHCH OOTOK HH(})opMauHH no MeTbipeM 6a30BbiMB 3TOH MacTH pesyjibTaTbi OKasajiHCb cxo^HbiMM c H3BecTHbiMH panee, HO, KaKHancHMH T3 no rpynne OKasajincb 6o;iee MHc})opMaTMBHbiMH, MCM cpe^HHe 3HaneHHfl.PCC OKasajiacb 3HaHHTe^bHbiivi HCTOHHHKOM, nepeAaK)iu,MM HH(j)opiviauHK) apyrHMMO^ejiH DMN.B cjiynae HOJIHOH MO^CJIH c uiecTbio o6nacTHMH noKasano, HTO naparannoKaMnajibHbieHHTCHCHBHO o6MeHHBaK)TC« HHtJDOpMaUHCH C 6a30BbIMH o6jiaCTHMH DMN,npH 3TOMTOJibKO B cjiynae LHIP o6Hapy}KHBaK>TCH snanHMbie HcxoflMiuHe OOTOKH HH(J)opManHH B mPFC,H PCC H CHMMCTpHHHyK) naparnnnoKaMnajibHyio o6nacTb RHIP npasoro nojiymapHH.
Flpn3TOM onapy>KeHbi jiniiib He6ojibuiHe H3MeHeHH« B naTTepne cBJBefi 6a3OBOH2. B XOH >Ke saziane c noMouibio Mexojja ffKM noKasano, HXO nojiHOCBH3HaaHaHjiyHuieH no rpynne HcnbixyeMbix. HaparxmnoKaMnajibHbie o6jiacxH LIPC/RIPCocHOBHbiMH nepe^axHHKaMH HH(J)opMauHH B DMN, a o6jiacxb mPFC SIBJIHCXCHOCHOBHbIM npHCMHHKOM HH(f)OpMaU,HH. ,fl,aHHbffl MCXO^ HC BbUIBHJI H3M6HeHHH naXXCpHa CBH3CH B6a30BOH MOflejiH. ApxHxeKxypa CBHSCH xaioice OKasanacb cxaGnjibHOH npH HCKJHOHCHHH OZIHOHH3 6a30Bbix o6jiacxeH.B UCJIOM peayjibxaxbi, nojiyneHHbie ;iByMfl MexoaaMH T3 H /JKM, aocxaxonuo xopomocoraacyioxcfl .npyr c flpyroM, a no oxHonieHHK) K BbiHBueHHK) ox^ejibHbix CBHSCH MoryxpaccMaxpHBaxbCH icax flonojiHjnouiHe H yxoHHHiomHe jipyr apyra. Mexo^OM T3 y o6jiacxHRHIP flOcxoBepHbix HCXO^LLIHX HOXOKOB HH^opManHH HC HaiweHO, HXO He cornacyexca co6menpHHHXbiMH npezicxaBJieHH^MH o CHMMCXPHHHOM o6Mene HH(J)opManHeH MOK^y LHIP HRHIP.
K co)KajieHHK) MCXOZIOM RKM 3xox (J)aKx, OHCBH^HO, npofiepen HC 6bui.Pesyjibxaxbi anajrasa B OCHOBHOM coBna^aiox, HO B aexajmx pacxo^axca c pesyjibxaxaMH^pyrnx HCCJieaoBaxejieH. Ho MHCHHIO asxopa 3x0 MBnaexcn cue^cxBHeMpasMepa Bbi6opKH B pa^e apyrnx pa6ox, a xaK>Ke He^ocxaxoHHOH xoHHOCXbK)^pyrHMH Hccne/iOBaxejiaMH MaxeMaxn^ecKOH XCXHHKH. BH^HMO, OKOHMaxejibnoe peuieHHeBonpoca BOSMO^HO JiHuib nocjie nepenposepKH nojiyneHHbix pesyjibxaxoB B3. B sa^ane 2 (BbiHBjieHHe apxnxeKxypbi CBH3eH CCXH Bbi3BaHHoro oxsexa Hac noMOLUbK) Mexo^a JIKM noKasano, MXO HanGojiee a/],eKBaxHo 3KcnepHMeHxajibHbieoxpa>Kaex MO^e-nb F, x.e. cmia np^Mbix csasefi ox o6;iacxeH V I K o6nacxflM ITGnpH oxsexe na Gojiee pe/i,KMH (.neBMaHXHbifi) cxHMy^. CpaBHCHHe MOAGJieR xo.ibKo cnpflMblMH F H C npflMblMH H oSpaXHbIMM FBCBH35IMH fl,JW paSJIMHHblX BpCMCHHblXnoKasajio, HXO no Mepe yBejiHHCHH« BpeMenH HHCJIO HcnbixyeMbix, ^JIH Koxopbix jiymiieHHBJiaexca FB yBejiHHHBaexcfl.
3xo oxpa>Kaex xox <J)aKx, HXO na BpeMenax nopH^Ka 230-250 MCnepBHHHfaie 30Hbi spHxe/ibHOH Kopbi naHMHaiox nojrynaxb cymecxBCHHbiH o6paxHbifiMO^yJlHpyK)LU,HH CHTHa/l OX 60^66 BblCOKHX oGjiaCXCH o6pa6oXKH SpMXCJlbHOH HH(j)OpMaiJ,HH. 3XHpesyjibxaxbi corjiacypoxca c npe^cxaBJieHH^MH o BsaHMO^eHcxBHM nepBMHHbix M BxopMHHbix SOHBCHxpajibHoro spHxejibHoro nyxn, a xaK>Ke c AaHHbiMH no MCCJieAOBaHHJiM B paMKaxB cjiyxoBOH CHCxeMe.B UCJIOM pa6oxa BbinojiHena Ha BMCOKOM npo^eccHonajibHOM ypoBHe, a ee pesyjibxaxw3HaHHxejibHbm nnxepec.
Asxop npo^eMOHCxpHpoBan BiiazieHHeM Kax3KcnepHMeHxajibHOH xexHHKofi no perncxpanHH ^annbix 33F H qbMPT, xax H XCXKHKOHMaxeMaxHHecKOH o6pa6oxKH pesyjibxaxoB Mexo^aMH T3 H ^KM. Cjie^yex oxMexnxb, HXOB CHJiy CBOCH HOBH3Hbi Mano Hcnojibsyexca 3a npezienaMH jia6opaxopHH OpHcxona.H ycneiiiHoe npHMeHenne sxoro Mexofl,a HBJiaexca BancHOH sacjiyrofi ^nccepxanxa.pesyjibxaxbi aejiawx cymecxBeHHbiH BKJia^ B BbiMBjieHHe BsaHMo^eHcxBHH pasjiHHHbix cxpynxypMosra npH HanHHHH HJIH oxcyxcxBHH BHCUIHHX cxHMyjioB.
B HacxoHm,ee BpeMfl GojibuiofinpoeKx, HanpaBjieHHbiH na peuieHHe xaKoro po^a saaan peajiHsyexca B CIIIA (Brain ResearchThrough Advancing Innovative Neurotechnologies). 3xox 4^^KT nonasbiBaex aKxyajibnocxbnpOBe^eHHbix HCcne^oBaHHH H HX BOBJieneHHOcxb B OCHOBHOC nanpaBJieHHe pa3BHxnaCOBpeMCHHOH HCHpoGHOJIOrHH.Flo coaepxcaHHK) pa6oxw MO>KHO cziejiaxb cjie^yiomHe 3aMenaHHH.ABXOPOM npe^npHHHXbi ^ocxaxoHHbie cepbesnbie ycHJina, nxo6bi nojiynnxb Ha^e>KHbiepesyjibxaxbi H yxasaxb na npe^ejibi B03MO)KHbix ouinGoK. HojxyHeHHbie OUCHKH ztaioxnpHHUHnnajibHyK)BOSMO^nocxbnpstMorocpaBHCHHHnapaMexpoBMo^eneHc3KcnepHMeHxajibHbiMH aaHHbiMH. 3x0, oanaKO, c^ejiano, Kpanne cxyno H 4>aKXHHecKHorpaHHHHBaexca pnc.
3.13. Bbino 6bi >KejiaxejibHO, nxo6bi anajiorHHHbie HiuiiocxpauHH 6bmHnpe^i,HBJieHbi AJDI BCCX Mo^ejien, upexeH^yiomnx na a^eKBaxnoe npe^cxaBJieHne ^annbix.PasfleneHHC rnaB ^nccepxauHH na Mexo^bi H pesyjibxaxw ne Ka>Kexca y^annbiM. C XOHKHspeHHfl HHxaxejia 6biJio 6bi nojiesnee pas^ejinxb rjiasbi no sa^anaM. KpoMe xoro, HMCCX MCCXOCJIHUIKOM 6erjioe ocBemeHHe Ba>KHbix flexajiefi MCXO^OB. CCWJIKH na cooxBexcxByromHeny6jiHKaiiHH aaioxcH, HO 6bi.no 6bi jiyHme, CCJIH 6bi B .anccepxauHH co^epJKanacbHeo6xo#HMafl HHcfjopMaijHfl ZUIH noHHMaHHH. HxoGbi He yBejiHHHBaxb o6i>eM ^HccepxauHH 3xyHHCJDOpMailHK) MO)KHO 6bIJIO 6bl paSMCCXHXb B HpHJIO>KeHHH. B flaHHOM BH^C HpHJlOKCHHeaHHO KpaxKHM.saMenannH He yManaiox flocxHJKeHHH ^HccepxanHH.
![](https://s.studizba.com/z.php?f=/templates/si/i/noavatar.png&w=100&h=100&t=1"){kind=avatar}
