Отзыв официального оппонента 2 (1105085), страница 2
Текст из файла (страница 2)
OTJlWII151 Ha Ha4aIlbHOMY4aCTKe Kpl1BbIX HH,LI,yKll,HHcpeyopeCLJ,eHll,HI1 (CTa,LI,IDIP-S-M)npH 06pa60TKeJII1CTbeB NaFHa cBerycpoccpaTa3bl. ITPH 3TOM, OTHOIIIeHHeYMeHbiliaeTCJIRtdCPOTOCI1HTeTI14eCKOHaKTHBHOCTH, aBTopoM,ll,eHCTBHI1NaFHa pa60TY AT<D-CHHTa3HOrOBbIBO,ll" 4TO 06pa60TKaJII1CTbeB NaFpa3Mep aHTeHHbI <DC2 BCJIe,ll,CTBHeHHrH6I1pOBaHI151= (FM2-FT)/FTHI1)Ke, 4eM B KOHTpOJIe.
ITOCKOJlbKY H3MeHeHIDIRtdJIOrHLfHO 06'b5lCHeHbI aBTopOM TeM, 4TOnpH 06pa60TKeCOOTBeTCTBYJOTOTHOCHTeJIbHbIM 113MeHeHI151MB COOTBeTCTBl111C ,ll,aHHbIMH JIHTeparypbIBblpaw.eHHbIXC,ll,eJlaHH3 CeM51H,KOTopble npOIIIJII1 ITpe,ll,nOceBHyIObOITbITHbIX pacTeHHH B paC4eTe HanpH O,ll,HOBpeMeHHOM YBeJIWIeHHI1 OTHOmeHI15! XJlYKa3blBaTb Ha I13MeHeHI1e CTeXI10MeTpl14eCKOrocBeToc06l1palOw.I1MI106 HHrl1611pYIOIl.\eMKOMITJleKCa H PE<D-Kap60KCI1Jla3y-oKCl1reHa3Y3nI1HOM 11LJ,HPKOHOM,CO,ll,ep)!mHI1e XJlOPOCPHJlJlOBa HCblPYJO Maccy 6blJIO BblIIIe,6blJlO cyw.ecTBeHHonpHBO,ll,I1Jla K CHH)!(eHI1JO I1X CPOTocHHTeTI14eCKOH aKTHBHOCTH.B JlI1CTbJlX pacTeHHH TPHTHKaIle,06pa60TKyJIHCTbeB NaFa/XJl b;ITOCJIe,ll,HeeMO)!(eTCOOTHOilieHIDI Me)l(,LI,y «KOPOBbIMH» HKOMITJIeKCaMI1CPOTocHcTeM. CTaLJ,110HapHbIe 3Ha4eHI151 nOKa3aTeJl51co y paCTeHI1HTPI1TI1KaIle nOCJIe 06pa60TKI1KOHTPOJIbHblX pacTeHHH,ceM5II;l peryJl5lTOpaMH4TO cooTBeTcTByeTpOCTa 6bIJIH ITpHMepHO Ha 25%BblIIIe,4eM yrrOJIO)!(HTeJIbHOH KOppeJIJlll,HH Me)!(,ll,y CTaLJ,110HapHbIM3Ha4eHHeM co 11cO,ll,ep)lmHl1eM XJlOpocpHJIJla.
YBeJlH4eHI1e nOKa3aTeJI5I co y TpHTI1KaIle npl1 06pa60TKeCeM5IH perYJl5lTOpaMH pOCTa MO)!(eT TalOKe CBH,ll,eTeJIbCTBOBaTb06 YBeJII14eHI1I1 CPOTOCI1HTeTI14eCKOHaKTI1BHOCTI1OrrbITHblX pacTeHHH,pacTeHliH4TO MomoTpl1TI1KaIle 11rrOBbJilieHIDI6bITb npWIHHoHYPQ)KaHHocTH.ITpl1 I1CCJle,ll,OBaHI1I1,ll,eHCTBI15InperrapaTOB3Ko<DycaHa cpoHe rep61111,H,ll,OBnpI1BO,ll,I1Jla K YBeJlI14eHI1JO 3Ha4eHI1H06pa60TKI1YCI1JIeHI1J1POCTOBbIX npOll,eCCOB y onbTTHblXH LJ,l1pKOHa6blJlO HaH,ll,eHO, 4TO HX ,ll,06aBKaRtdB nepBbIeHeCKOJIbKO,ll,HeH nOCJlepaCTeHI1H, 4TO CBI1,ll,eTeJlbCTByeT 0 CTI1MYJIl1pYlOll.\eM ,ll,eHCTBI1I13TI1X npenapaTOBCPOTOCI1HTeTI14eCKI1HannapaT.CMeCI1 - 60Jlee7CTI1M)'JIHpyJOIll,ee ,ll,eHCTBl1e nperrapaTOBcoxpaH51JlOCb 60JleeHa3,ll,HeH, a I1X,ll,HeH.
YCI1JIeHI1e CPOTOCI1HTeTH4ecKoHaKTI1BHOCTI1 11POCTOBbIX rrpOLJ,eCCOBB pe3YJlbTaTenpl1MeHeHH5! 6110rrpenapaToBB KOHeLIHOM I1TOre OKa3aJIO nOJIO)!(J1TeJlbHOe BJlH5!HHe Ha nOKa3aTeJII1YPQ)KaHHocTH JlbHa-,ll,OJlryall,a.ITpe,ll,CTaBJIeHHble B KOHLJ,eTeKCTa ,ll,HCCepTall,HI1 OCHOBHble pe3YJIbTaTbiT04HO oTpmKaJOT KJII04eBbieB11TO )Ke BpeM5!, HeCMOTp51Ha, 6e3YCJlOBHO, nOJIQ)KI1TeJIbHYIO OLJ,eHKY,ll,I1CCepTaLJ,110HHOHpa60Tbl,I1MeeTC5Ip5l,ll,3aMe4aHHH1. Cyw.ecTBeHHbIMH B aBTopecpepaTeH no)KeJIaHI1H.He,ll,OCTaTKOM ocpopMJleHIDI )l,I1CCepTall,I1I1JlBJlJleTCJIOTCYTcTBHe 11B ,ll,I1CCepTaLJ,HI1,pacIIIHcppoBKI1HCIlOJlb30BaHHbIX 0603Ha4eHI1H.2. Ha Pl1c. 2 B ,ll,I1CCepTaLJ,HHHeT paCmI1CPPoBKH 0603Ha4eHHH,3TOM pHcYHKe npe,ll,CTaBJIeH 1I,I1KJIH4eCKI1HTpaHcnopT3.11BbIBO,ll,bl KoppeKTHblnOJIO)!(eHH5I ,ll,I1CCepTaLJ,HOHHOHpa60TbI.CTp.39,CTp.
42 H ,ll,pyme.I1cnoJlb30BaHI1e11,XOTJI B TeKCTe YKa3aHO, 4TO HaB <DC2, Ha 3TOM pl1cYHKe TaKoroHeT.B ,ll,I1CCepTaLJ,1111pa3HbIX e,ll,I1HHll, ,ll,Jl51xapaKTepl1CTHKHYCJlOBI1H oCBew.eHI151, - BT/M2, JlIOKCbI 11MK3/M2 C, - 3aTPY,ll,H5IeT aHaIll13 noey4eHHblxABTOPY CTOHJIOnOTpY,ll,HTbC5I, 11HJIH ,ll,aTb K03CPCPHll,HeHTblnepec4eTaOKOJlOKmK,ll,OrO 3HaLIeHH5I B BbI6paHHbiXTpaHcnopTape3YJlbTaToB.(c Y4eToM ,ll,JII1HbIBOJlHbI), I1JIHaBTopOM e,ll,I1HI1ll,ax ,ll,JlJl,ll,aHHOrO 3KcnepHMeHTanpl1BeCTH3Ha4eHI15I B ,ll,pyrI1X e,ll,HHHll,ax.ITpH aHaIlH3e pe3YJlbTaTOB B pJl,ll,e CJIY4aeB CJle,ll,OBaIlO 6bI C,ll,eJIaTb 3TOT aHaJIH3 60Jlee nOJlHbIM.1. HaCTp. 28 11,ll,aJIee.
CJIe,ll,OBaIlO 6bI JlCHO 06'b5lCHI1Tb, KaK ,ll,BIDKeHHe XJlopOnJlaCTOB no,ll,,ll,eHCTBl1eM CBeTa CB5I3aHO C H3MepJleMbIM He CPOTOXHMI14eCKI1MTymemreMcpJIyopeCLJ,eHll,IfH. CJle,ll,OBaIlO6bl 06Cy,ll,I1Tb 3Ty npl14I1HycpJTyopeCLJ,eHLJ,I1J1XJlopoqmJlJla11,ll,JT5I06'bJlCHeHIDI 113MeHeHIDI cpOPMbJcneKTpa,5.IlI1CTa npl1 oCBew,eHI1I1, npW-mHOH LlerO, KaK CIle)J,yeT 113)J,I1CCepTa~HH 5!BJ15IeTC5I60IleeOTHOCI1TeJIhHOeTyrneHHeHM (pHC.
13,a, 6;q)JlyopeCLI,eH~HI1 Ha )J,IlHHe BOIlHhI 685 HM no cpaBHemnopHC. 14, KpHBhle 1,2),MO)f(eT 6hlTh nepepacnpe)J,eJIeHHeee cBeToc06l1pmOw,eHCHJIhHOeC )J,IlHHOH BOIlHbI 740He OrpaHH4HBa5!Ch TOIlhKO O)J,HHM06b5!CHeHHeM, LITO npI1L1I1HOH:meprHHB036Y)l()J,eHH5!Me)I<,ll,y <DC B [JOIlh3Y <DC 1 3a CLleT YBeJIHLleHI151aHTeHHbI npl1 Q:>ocQ:>opl1JmpOBaHI1I16eJIKOB CCK2.TalOKe Ha CTp. 60. YTBep)f()J,eHHe, LITO Q:>aKT,LITO3HaLleHH5! KBaHTOBoroBbIXO)J,a<DC2, YMeHhrna5!Cb CYBeJllfLleHI1eM I1HTeHCI1BHOCTI1)J,eHCTBYIOllJ,erOCBeTa, )J,Jl5!CMHero CBeTa OKa3bIBaI-OTC5!60IlhilIeaHaJ10rH4HbIX )J,Il51KpacHoro,I1CnOIlh30BamfHMO)l(eT «CBI1)J,eTeIlbCTBOBaTb06 I1H,LJ,yLl,l1pOBaHI1I1avoidance-3Q:>Q:>eKTa npl1CI1HerO CBeTa», CJle)J,OBaJIO6bI )J,onOJIHHTb 06b5lCHeHHeM, nOLleMY 3TI1 )J,aHHhleCB(1)J,eTeIlhCTBYIOT06 HH,LJ,y~l1pOBaHI1I1HMeHHO61 0 BKJ1a)J,eavoidance-3Q:>Q:>eKTaB ypoBeHh2.
CTp. 45. )JjI5I 06b5lCHeHH5! Toro,TyweHl1eQ:>Ilyopec~eHIIHHavoidance-3Q:>Q:>eKTa».To )Ke H )J,Jl5!paccY)f()J,eHHH Ha CTp.qI.LITO npl1 nOHH)l(eHHH OCBellJ,eHHOCTI1npM Bblpaw,I1BaHI1I1npH )J,IlHHe BOIlHbl 685 HM Ha cBeTY YMeHhWaeTC5I, npHLleM CI1JIhHee, LleM npl1)J,IlI1He BOIlHbI 740 HM, H npH OCBellleHHOCTH 20-:-30 IlK H Hi1)l(e npaKTHLleCKI1 OTCYTCTByeT, Bbl)J,BI1HYTOnpe)J,nOJIO)f(eHl1e, LITO « ... npH4HHO~3Toro3Q:>Q:>eKTaMO)l(eT 6hTTh CHIDKeHl1e HeQ:>OTOXI1MI1L1eCKOrOTyweHl15! Q:>JIyopeClleHLI,HHno Mepe 3aTeHeHH5! pacTeHllli...».3TI1X pe3YJIbTaTOB HeT B )J,l1ccepTaLl,I1I1.3.
K CO)f(aJIeHIflO, He 06CY)f()J,eHO Ba)KHoe Ha6Jl1o)J,eHMe, npe)J,cTaBIleHHoeHa CTp. 51.3HaLleHH5! K03Q:>Q:>I1L1,HeHTaFv/Fm OCTaBaJ1aChnpaKTH4eCKH Hel13MeHHhIMH (OKOIlO 0,75)3HaLlHTeIlbHoro(B TPH-lliITb« ... LITOBnJIOTb )J,Opa3) YMeHhWeHl15! cO)J,ep)KaHH5IXJlOpoQ:>HJIIlaB IlHCTe, LITOYKa3hIBaeT HaBbICOKYIO Q:>OTOXI1MHLleCKYIOaKTI1BHOCTh Q:>OTocHcTeMhI2. I1pl1 nocIle)J,YIOllJ,eM cyw,ecTBeHHoMCH(1)f(eHI1I1cO)J,ep)l(aHI151XJlopoQ:>I1JTJTaOTHOWeHl1eFvl FmI1oCJIe)J,Hl1e 3aMe4aHH5I HOC5ITpeKoMeH)J,aTeIlhHbIHpe3Ko YMeHblTTaJ10Cb».xapaKTep,11He CTaB5IT no)J, COMHeHl1e OCHOBHblepe3YJIhTaTbI 11BbIBO)J,hI)J,HccepTaLl,I10HHOH pa60TbI.BL1,eIlOM)J,HccepTa~H5I "<Dnyopec~eHTHbleoCBew,eHH5! H 06pa60TKHQ:>H3HOJIOrH4eCKI1aKTHBHhIMH Bew,eCTBaMH" y)J,OBIleTBop5leT BceM KpI1TepI151M,YCTaHOBJIeHHhTMI1oIlQ)KeHl1eMYHI1BepCI1TeTe HMeHI1nOKa3aTeJlI1 IlI1CTheB paCTeHHH: BIlI1.51HHeYCIlOBHHM.B.0 npI1CY)l()J,eHI1H YLIeHHhIX CTeneHeH B MOCKOBCKOM rOCY)J,apCTBeHHOMJIOMoHocOBa,a ee aBTOp KaJ1Ma~Ka51 O.A.
3acny)KI1BaeTCTeneHH KaH)J,I1)J,amQ:>I13Hi<O-MaTeMaTH4eCKI1XHayK no Cne~HaJ1bHOCTI1 03.01.023aB. JIa60paTopHeHQ:>oTocHHTeTH4eCKoro 3IleKTpoHHoro<De)J,epaJIhHOrO rocY)J,apcTBeHHoronpI1cY)f()J,eHI151- bI10Q:>113I1Ka.TPaHcnopTa6IO)J,)l(eTHOrO YLIpe)f()J,eHl15!HaYKH11HcTHTym Q:>YH)J,aMeHTaJ1bHhTXnp06JIeM6HOJIOrHHPOCCI1HCKOHaKa)J,eMHH HayKI1BaHoB b.H)J,OKTOP6110IlOrHLleCKHX HaYK(cneLl,l1aJ1bHOCTb- 03.01.02bI1oQ:>l13l1Ka)01 H05l6p5l2017I1BaHoB bOPHC HHKOJIaeBH4<De)J,epaJ1bHOerocY)J,apcTBeHHoe6IO)J,)l(eTHOe YLIpe)l()J,eHl1e HaYKI1POCCHHCKOHaKa)J,eMI1H HayK142290r. I1YW,HHO, yJl.J1HCTHTYTCKa5!2TeIl.
8-496-773-36-013Il. nOLlTa: ivboni@rambler.rur..
![](https://s.studizba.com/z.php?f=/templates/si/i/noavatar.png&w=100&h=100&t=1"){kind=avatar}
