Отзыв официального оппонента Ерофеевой Е. В. (1100853)

Просмтор этого файла доступен только зарегистрированным пользователям. Но у нас супер быстрая регистрация: достаточно только электронной почты!

Текст из файла

OT3bIBo .{krccepr ar\LrrPE3B VX?IHOfr IOlzu An erc anApolHhr<<KonrrucKa,perkroH€rJrbHarJreKcuKa20-x - :rra.rura30-x ro4on XX BeKa>Ha cor4cKaHneyuenofi crefreHr,rKaHAr{Aaraf,zlonoruqecKrrx HayKro crerlr4€rrr6Hocrr410.02.01 - Pyccrczft.flsrrKllpe4craureHHoe K 3arIu.ITe.{LTcceprarlrlouHoezccneAoBa:nuerrocBrrrleHoKOMIIJIeKCHOMyMHOTOaCUeKTHOMyperl4oH€Irlrnofi JIeKcpIKLt 20-x TpaAI4IIL[oL1s}9lellJuflCIICTeMHOMyOTIIICaHLIIOlnaqara 30-x rr. XXperl4oH€lJlbHofiJreKcI4Kr{rOnrrvrCrOfts. Pa6ora [poAonx(aerBCenepo-BocTorrHoMrocyAapcTBeHHOM yHLIBepCVTeTe.Pernonal vlcrkrna B coBpeMeHHoM t3bIKo3Ha ;nvILr3aHr4Maer oco6oe Mecro.Co cpe4uHrr XX s. B cLIJry pa3rllrrHhlx @arropoB oKcrp€rlLrHrBLrcrr4qecKoroXapaKTepa aKTLIBI43LtpoB€uII4cb[pOqeCCbI (pa3repMeTLrcaIIVD)OTHoCI{TeJIbHocaMocrotrenbHblx QopturcylqecrBoBaHufl.fl3brKa, r4x cMelrrentrs,,nepecrpofixllBcex rpaAkIIIuoHHbIX HAI4OMOB.3rv[poUeccbr xapaKTepHbr AJrr MHorr4xcoBpeMeHHbIX fl3bIKoB, Ho B QynrqnoHl4poBaHr{r4 pyccKoroorpovrHofireppr{ropr,rHpacnpocTpa}IelJvrflfl3brKa, B cr4rryKOIUqCCTBApasnoo6pasnefiruzx t3bIKoB, Koropble KoHTaKTvpyror c HrrM Ha p€BHbrxrracrf,xeroft TeppllTopurv, oHr4Llrpalor oco6yro ponb.

B Hacrosulee BpeM{ npoqecchrCMeIIIeHAtIIALIOMOB IIpI4BeJII4 K TOMy, IITO B KOMMyHVTK.aT\LLHrrpoMexyTorrHbreSoplau cyuecrBoBantrt r3brKa craJrv BeAyrqlrMn,HeKoTopbrerlocreneHHo 3aHnMalor Mecro rpaAr,rquoHHbrx Qoprur. K raruupen4oJIeKT, KOTOpbILI BbITeCHSer, A TOqHee yx(eI,rxHrIXorHocLrrcs 14npaKTr4qecKv BbITeoHHJI,TpaAI'II{uoHHbreMecrHble roBopbl. floHznnaune vr HayuHoe onkrcanue rrpoqeccoB,nponcxoAflIrlux B Hacrotlqee BpeMr,Bcour4onr4HrBracrnqecrofi cr4creMepyccKol'o .f,3brKa,a raKx(e [porHo3r4poBaHr4f nyreft pa3Bzrrufl srofi cr4creMbrHeBo3Mo)KHo6es no4po6Horo orrucaHur pur3HbrxperlroneKToB. B cs-flslr c 3TLrMaIffyaJI b Hocrb nsl6paHnofi reuu Irccne.qoBaHLrs.He Bbr3hrBaercoMHenufi.flpn erou Lrperr.roH,roroprrfi paccMarpr4Baercfl,n pa6ore, z nu6panurrftAnflkI3fIeHLIrIIIepnoAJrlrHrBr4crnqecKoftBpeMeHII,ToqKLr.f,BJI'IOTC'3peHrrf,:KpalrHeuHTepecHbrMcSKCTp€urrrHrBI4CTLrqeCKUe yCnOBLrrrreorpaSzqecKoro, rIoJILITuqecKoro14 SKoHoMr4qecKoroxapaKTepa rrpr{Benu KB3al{MoAeftcrszlo B paMKax oAHoro pernoHa pa3Hbrx QoprurcyqecrBoBantrfl, krcrr4neI4 pyccKoro .fl3blKa, a raK)Ke Apyn4x s3brKoB - .fl3brKoBaoopurenHoroHaceJIeHurI H t3bIKoB a3naTcKo-TLIXooKeaHCKOIoperLToHa.

VI nce gTrr rrpoqeccbrB coBoKyrlHocrl4 oKasarlz BIrr4flHvrena Soprr,r?rpoBaHr.rez Synxqr4oHlrpoBaHlreKonblMcKoft peruonanrnofiJIeKcLIKI{.Paccuarprasaeiurrft B AlrcceprarlrroHHoMLTccneAoBallvIv[epl4oA (20-e - Hoe€IrIo30-x rr. XX n.) B xor3Hr4Haruefi crpaHhrB qenoM vr B XLI3HI4 rrCCneAyeMOfOpeH{OHa flB[rflI7c.flBeCbMa 3HaqLrMbrM,rlocKonbKy I4MeHHoB 3TO BpeM' CoquanbHbreycnoBlrr oK€r3brBaJftrorpoMHoeBlrvrflrrr4eHa neKcll.recxufi rrJracr.rr3brKau Ha QopMrrpoBaHkreocHoB pen4oneKTa.Teoperzvecroft oqrosofi pa6orrr FO.A.Pesnyxznofi ssnflercr reopkr{pefr4oJreKTa, aKTI4BHO pzBB[Baror\aflCfl.Bconpeuennofi JruHrBrrcrr{Ke.BAvrcceprar\vu no4po6Ho paccMarpr4Barorcfl p€r3Hbre[oAXoAbr K noH.flTrrro(pefl4oHzl"JlbHoe Bapbr4poBaHvte nlrreparypHofor3brKD) r4 p€t3Hbre rroHlrMaHlrfltrolJflTvrfl. (pefI4oHzuILI3M)), IloKa3brBaloTcfl CJIO)r(HOCTbVr HeOAHO3HaqHOCTbpeIUeHLIJI 3TI{X BonpocoB, qTo AaeT qlmaTeJlro o6reunoe[pe.{CTaBJIeHLIe ocoBpeMeHHoM cocroflHkrvr 4annoft o6nacrpr.

B .racrHocrr.r, aBTop ALrcceprar\nunoKEBbIBaeT IOTIbITK]I(perzoH€ulpt3M>,a((3THOrpaQUSm> r4JII4HTBI4CTOBpa3BeCTI{ TepMLIHbr (JrOK€uII43M) UTaKxe,4p.cxoAHbleY6eAnrelrnoTepMr4Hbr((npoBt4HrIHaJrr43M),AeMoHcrpkrpyercflIIpOTI4BOTIOCTaBJIeHI4TI3TI4X TepMr,rHOB Vr [peA[OqTeHr4eHeqerKocrboTAaeTCr TepMr4Hy(pen4oHaJln3M). Tarcofi nu6op repMllHa rlpeAcraBrsercr o6ocronaHHbrM errle 14noroMy (xorr aBToppa6orul u He rrrrruer o6 erorr,r),qro KoHKypr{pyrcqlreBocHoBHoMTepMr4Hbr(JroK€rJrrr3M))(nosHuruunfi paHee) Lr ((peruroH€urLr3M)r{Meror, B cyrrlHocr}r, oAHy BHyrpeHHroro Qopuy6onrruzncrBoMJItlHrBlIcroBckrHoHLrMLrqHo, Honynorpe6nrrorcf,repMktH(perI4oHarrH3MD1) coornocLrrcfl.

c repMLIHoM(pefl4oneKD) n 2) uveer rpaAr4rlr4roynorp e6tenus,e sapy6exnofi nunrsracrr.rKe.orvreuau, qro B Al4cceprar\vrr4qerKo oroBopeHbr r4 flpr.rHrlr4rrbrorHeceHr4flcJIoBaK perr4oH€rJrrrcMaM.3ru npnnqunbr He Bbr3hrBarorHHKaKr4xBo3paxgrtnit uBax{Ho,qro oHI4 frurblBarcT He roJrbKo ceMaHTr4qecKoe,Ho LI QoHeruuecKoe r4rpaMMaTVqecKOe Bapbr4poBaHue cJroBa.oqenrcrpor4Tcs cBaxtHo, qro Lr3rreHr4e perl4oH€Irrurofi JIeKcI4Kr4B IvCCepTArJ.nHr{eroMperl4oneKTa. V'rersKcrp€rnvHfBr{crr4qecxofi curyarryrkr SopuzpoBanus.corlkI€ulbHoro KoHTeKcra no3BoJurer aBTopy He roJrbKorloK€l-3arbBce nyrl4 QopvrupoBaHnfl perl{oH€upr3MoB,Ho Lr BbrAenr{TbB Hr{xoco6ufirrJracr-(coBern3MbD)HoMr4Harlr4r4ssreuuirpr co6rrruft,cnoficrseHHbrx couLrzurr4crraqecxoficr.rcTeMe.I4Cropua r.BrraeMofo pefr4oHaTaKoBa,qro 6es frera coBerI{3MoBaHalrvr36ru 6u HerroJroHH He cr4creMeH.flocne4orarenrnrrft amatrtr3groro cJror JreKcr4Kr/rB acrreKTeSyHrqzoHr4poBaHr{rrperlloH€ulbHoro BapbLIpoBauufl B 4auuoft pa6ore [poBoAr.rrcfl BnepBhre vrHarJItAHo noK€l3blBaer, KaK npnqyAJrLrBonopofi coqerarorcfl noJrurLrqecKare,SKOHOMr{qeCKr4eUlpl4BneqeHuellpe4craBJrrercq,qroAaHHOTO Marepr4aJra K I4ccJIeAOBaHLrrO{BJLfleTCr BDKHbTM UAOnXffiO 6rrrr rrreHo[aunaxeruorpaQuqecKr,re Saxropu.B Apyrnx krccneAoBaHVfrXnO4O6nOrO pOAa.aBTopoM pa6oturraccuQnKarlurJreKcr4K]r no ucror{Hr4Kyrlpot4cxo)KAelJkrfl,BKJIIoqaer 8 rpynn.

14 cava xlacczQuKarlu.f, u ee rrpuHrlkrnbrHerlporl4BopeqI4Bbr. Baxno,rITo[oryqenHbrerpynrrbrJreKcLrKr4AarorrIpeAcraBJIeHHeo pa3Hoo6pazun LIcroqHLIKonSoprr,rupoBaHnrr{MeHHoruecrHofiJIeKOI{KH,perr4oHa n ra:yvaenarrfi)^tI{ThIBaIor oco6eHHocrl,Iqgrrroeoft ckrryarJpr2rrIepI4oA. To r(e caMoe Mo)I(Ho cKa3arb 14 o nlaccuQzKarlr4tr JreKcr4KLrrroTeMaTI{qecKLIMrpymlaM: BbIAeneHHbrereMaTr{qecKr4erpyllrrbr AeMoHcrp}rpyrorcneqnQzny pen{oH€rJrr43MoBvMeHHo 4aunoft reppr4ropr.ru.Anrop pa6orucKpoMHo yrBep)KAaer, qroKaqecrBerlpeABapl4Telrnofinpone4enuufirrllrore3bl,aHaJILI3JreKcr4Krr(rro3BoJrrer, BroBopr4TbocyrqecrBoBaH;g1urKoJIbIMcKoroperzoJleKTa s 20-e roAbl XX nera> (c.

178), HaM )Ke Ka)r(ercr, rrro3He rpe6yeT oroBopoK: pa6ora noKzBbrBaer,qro KaK MLrHr{MyM3TO rroJro)r(eHr.reocHoBbr peruoneKTa cJroxfl4rrucby)Ke B 9To BpeMfl. 3ronoATBep)KAaercfl.vrAaHHbrMLro Apyrvx perr{oneKTax, HarIpI4Mep rrepMcKoM, 6asd" Koroporo, IroHarrrHMAaHHbrM,TaKxreo$oprvruracb B KoHqe XIX - Haqalre XX seKon.Taruu o6pasovr, aBTop BHocr{T3Haqr.rreJrcuufi Teopernqecrcnfi BKJTaAB noHrrMaHr4ecrpyKTypbr sgrrrosofi cvrya\kru KoJrbrMcKoroperuoHa He roJrbKoB rrccJle.qyenaufi[epvoA, Ho 14 B Hacrof,rrlee BpeMt, rlocKoJrbKy rroHuMaHLIecoBpeMeHHbrxrrpoqeccoB ocHoBbrBaerct Ha Lrcropr{qecKkrxAaHHbrx.floerouyTeoper[qecKafl 3HaqrrMocrr pa6orbl, c naruefi ToqKv 3peHlzfl,3aKnroqaercflBTOM, qTO OHa 3aKJraAbrBaeT OCHOBbI Anfl. Id3YleHl1rfl, pA3BnTLrfl, pefl,IOH€urbHOLlB3al,tMoAeitcrr,laflperuIoH€urrHofiJreKc[KurJreKcLrKrr,a raK)I(e Anf, l4ccneAoBaHLrgc nlrreparypHbrM r3brKoM u ee BrrHflHLrflHa nureparypnHfi .ssrm (cira.upuruepuco cJIoBaMLtvaqbtqa u Ky)tcytl, Koropble BrlocJleAcrBr4krBoruJIVn nureparypurrfixsur).Bce rIoJIo)KeHr4rvr BbrBoAbI pa6orsr rBJrrrorcr o6ocHosaHHbrMrr prBDKHbrMrrAn{ pa3Burrnfl.JrLTHfBI4crlFIecroftperuroH€urrrcrLrKl{.Bce, nuHocrrMbleHa 3arrlr4TynoJrox{eHvrfl.,B pa6ore AoKa3aHbr.Hay.rHarHoBrrsHa Arrcceprarl[oHHoro vccneAoBanvfl, onpeAeJrrerctrrecKoilbKl4Mr{acrreKTaMr{:Bo-nepBbIX, B Ha) rHbrft o6opor BBoArrcr HoBbreapXI/tBHBIeAaHHbIe; Bo-BTopbIX,B pe3ynbTaTe aHaJILI3aapXlIBHbIXMaTepI4zuIoBlon;nreHbl HoBbreAaHHbreo KoJrbrMcrcofirercuKe rr o KoJIbrMcKoMperrroJreKTeBIIeJIOM; B-TpeTbLrX, BrrepBbre TIeTKO rracczQuqupyroTcflr.rcTorrHlrKr{pefr,roH€IJrr,r3MoB; B-rreTBepTbrx,QopnrzpoBan:r,fl AaHHbrxBrrepBbrepaccMarpkrBaercs,ileplroA 20-x - Haqzua30-x rr., roropufi rBirrercfl rpafiHeBaxHbrM4m Qoprr,rupoBaHvrfl,rr3fraeMoro peruoneKTa B rlenoM.OrAemno cneAyer orMeruTb o6repr npoaH€rnr43r.rpoBaHHoroMarepvraJra,rcoropuft cocraBuJr 6onee 4 500 JrI{croB apxrrBHbrx Aon, a raKxre uTrrlarenbHocrbno46opaLrormcanvfl,rrcrorrHrrKoB.BA[cceprarlur4rIpeAcraBJIeHbIno4po6Hefiurue onkrcannfl,MareprianbHbrx rr JrrrHrBr{cr}rrrecKlrxCOcTaBJItIoquX[pOaHaJII43I/tpOBaHHbIX AOKyMOHTOB, aTaK)I(eAaeTCfl.CTLITTeCKOe OnLtCAHr4eHeKOTOpbrXaBTOpOB AOKyMeHTOB.c oqrl o JII4HTBI4Kporraeroro, [oArrepKHeMAo6pocoBecrHocrbH cKpyrryJreinocmaHurv3aBbrBoAoBoTHocI4TeJrbHoilpLIHflTvraperueHr4f,IIoMaTeprr€ura,AoKa:laTeJIbHocTbKalKAoMyperrroHiurrr3My.Bce sro, BMecre c aAeKBarHbrMr{MeroAaMrr aHarrv3a,He AaeT ycoMHrrrbcs B AocToBepHocTIr noJrlqeHHbrx aBTopoM pe3yJrbTaroBLTCCIeAOBA}Ikrfl.flparcru.recKyro3HaqltMocrb.{aHHorouccneAoBanvrg, rroMrlMoo6osna.{eHHoro caMLTM,{t4ccepraHToMI{cnoJrb3oBaH}rr B pa3JrLIqHbrxKypcax,rrpeAcraBJrfler, Ha Harx B3rJItrA,[pexAe Bcero cooraBJrennrrfi Ha ero ocHoBe<<Kparrnft cnoBapb KoJrbrMcKofiperuonaruroft20-x roAoB XX seKa).JreKcLrKLryKzBaHHororrepuoAa pa3HbrxB sror cnoBapb BoruJrLr6onee 100 pervoHaJrr43MoBTeMaTUqecKux IPYtrtr, rroSToMy AalKe Ha ero ocHoBe' MolKHo cocTaBlrTbnpeAcraBJreHlreo cneqzQrrKe xr43Hr4perrloHa B HccJreAyeurrfi nepproA.KporvreToro, [pnHrlr{[br, rroJro)KeHHbreB ocHoBy cJroBapr, MoryT 6um,frreHhrrrpLrKorpaQuuecroM onracaHhu LrApyrzx perlroneKToB.JreKcLrHecuotprHa Bbrcoxzfi yponenr I4ccneAoBaHufl,B rIeJroM, HeKoropbreMOMeHTbI B HeM BbI3bIBaIOT COMHeH?Lfl,,B CBg3Lr C rIeM BO3HI{KaK)T BOIpOCbI LI3AMEIIAHI4'.1.

B pa6ore 143)reHue pen4oH€trlbHbrxoco6ennocrefi pyccKoro t3blKaHa3BaHo MoJroAbrM HarrpaBneHlreM. MoxHolrr4 Ha3brBarb MoJroAhrMHarrpaBJreHrle,Bo3Hr4KrrreecaMoe no3AHeeB HaqaJre70-x rr.? Kaxercr, qro Her.flporulororrrr4 50 ler.A cau Bonpoc''o neo6xo4raMocrr4 TaKoro r43y-rrenvflcTaBI.IIrCfl. 3HaqUTeJrbHO paHblrle,uccneAoBankru. BO qeM CaMa Ar4CCepTaHTKa |OBOpI4T B CBOeMHacroflIrlee BpeMt pefr{oHzurucrvKa flBlrflercfl, BrroJrHec$oprr,rupoBaBrrrr{McflHarrpaBJreHlreMc . parnuroficucreuofinoHlrufi,TepMr4Honoru efi , np LrHrlutt aur4 v MeroAaMI{ 14ccJIeAoBalnuit.2.8 pa6ore He rrerKo cQopuynupoBaHonporr4BorrocraBJreHr4eraKr4xBax(HbIXttottxruit,KaK(perl4oH€ulbHoe5BapbupoBaHlre>BIIeJroMvr(pervoH€ulbHoeBapbI{poBaHVenr,rreparypHoror3rrKa>.

Характеристики

Тип файла PDF

PDF-формат наиболее широко используется для просмотра любого типа файлов на любом устройстве. В него можно сохранить документ, таблицы, презентацию, текст, чертежи, вычисления, графики и всё остальное, что можно показать на экране любого устройства. Именно его лучше всего использовать для печати.

Например, если Вам нужно распечатать чертёж из автокада, Вы сохраните чертёж на флешку, но будет ли автокад в пункте печати? А если будет, то нужная версия с нужными библиотеками? Именно для этого и нужен формат PDF - в нём точно будет показано верно вне зависимости от того, в какой программе создали PDF-файл и есть ли нужная программа для его просмотра.

Список файлов диссертации