Отзыв официального оппонента 2 (Влияние присоединения к ВТО на металлургическую промышленность России)

B .4zoceprauuoHHblfi coeer [\ 212.232.3 4na 6ase (De4epanrHoro rocyAapcrBeHHorooroA)KerH oro oopa3oBaTeJrbHoroyqp exAeHr,rf, Bbrc[Iero o 6paso BaHLrfl,anr<r-Ilerep 6yprcrufirocyAapcrseHHrrfi yHuB epcurer)<COT3bIBrroHeHTa Ha Allcceprallurc Kapruna Enrenus CepreenzqaHa reMywHeHurfl, r ts TO Ha Merarlnyprl4r{e cKyrc rlp oMblrrr JIeHH o crb Poccrzu>>,H a c oLr cK au;"vre yv enoft ererr eH,I{ KaHAI{A ara oKoH oMI4rI e cKI{x HayK IIoofi cuequ€LrrbHocrl{ 08.00.14 - MupoBaf, oKoHoMIrKao$uquanuroro<lhusnue nrrpeAcraBJreHHyE.C.Arrcceprarlr{oHHoro I{ccJIeAoBannfl.. Arryanruocrr sH6pannofibr Ar4ccepTaIII4oHHOfO 14CCneAOBaHkrfl.

OlpeAenqercf TeM, qroArcrya.rIrHKapnlurrrvlMerrannyprl4rlecKa.'IyqacrBylorqllx Bpocckll4cKoI4MsKOHrrpoMbIIxneIIHocTbnoABepxeHbl tsJII4-f,npuMepe yAo6noBIIPIflHVII. BO BCEMBaxnrrrr,rAVICCepTAT\Lrkr,3apyoelKHblK I4ccJrPocczur llltO nAeTaIrlr3ar\w IIoIICCJIe.UOBale.I1^frfocyAapcrsr:HHofiaI.all.ta\vu .flarrll4oHKar< 6nuoMer€Lnnyprraqecr<ofiToproBnrl Poccrauao6asleHHofi crorrpoMbrrrrJleHHocTb fl. IrfleTcfl. oAnofi 143 naz6olee aKTI4BHonapo,4nofi ToproBne HecbIpbeBbIX orpacnefi pealbHoro ceKTopawKvr.

B oBt3ll c orLIM, c oAuofi cropoHbl, MeraJlnyprulqecKaf,fl, oAnofi vg orpacneft, Koropble B n lz6onrruefi crerIeHLIr,rro r{3MeHenufi B ToproBofi noluruKe, a c 4pyrofi oropoHbl, Ha eepOBOAr4Tb aupO6aqzro HOBIIX uOAXoAOB K kIcCneAoBaH1aIO TaKoIoMHOIOO0pA3krn.ooycnaBnl4BarorlllM aKTyaJrbHocrbpaKTI,IqecKI4M aCTIeKTOM,ere-fl coxpaH-flrot\uitcg. 4eSIaqrar KaK orer{ecrBeHHbrx, TaK kronauuit, [ocBtrIIIeHHbIX aH€Ur krcy BnvflH]I.u ycJlo Yufi, rtpuco eAI4HeHI4 torpacnz HarllroHaJrrnofi [poMbrrxJreHHocrLI c BblcoKofi creuenrroHbrM rpynlaM.

B ro )Ke BpeMf,, pe3yJlbrarbl LIMeHHo raK[xpaspa6orr<rapeAcraBnsrorc.fl HauooJlee 3HarII4MbIMlI Anfonr4Tr4Klr Iro pa3BLITI{rc COOTBeTCTByTITII4X OTpaCneI4 kr crparerufibHbrx KoMrlaHkrfi r yclonu.gM qreHcrBa B BTO.HO OTrvrerreHo aBTopoM, [nfl crpyKTypbr eHeIIIHefi ToproBnplupo4yrcquefi xapaKTepHa ra x{e npo6lenaa, rrro u An.s nHeruHefiB TIeJIOMAOMr{HI,IpOB aHUe TIpOAyKIIUII c orHocureJrbHo Hltgt<ofiMOCTbIO B sKcrropre pI rpoAyKIIlIU O orHocr4TeJIbHo srrcoKofi2,IIOOABJIEHHO]II CTOI4I4CCJIE.IIOBAHTTfl.Qarcr, qTo rrocTaHoBKa 3Ag.ar1, xoAa6orrca [paKTLIqecKI{X peKoMeHAa\uit rro ero pe3ynbTaraMtrcXOAt tI3 IIp9AIIOCbIJIKII O HSO6XOAIIMOSTII pe1ueHlls 4auuofiocTbro B r4MnopTe.

TolT4ocyuecrBJIf.lII4tcb[pooneMbl :ia cqer COI{ETAHZ' I4MNOPTO3AMEIIIE]JL4fl. VT HAPAUII4B AHLIfl. AONI4 IIPOAYKTOBrny6oKofi repeP oTKr{ B 3KCnOpTe, AOIIOJIHLITeJIbHO IIOBbIIIIaeT aKTyanbHocTbMeHeHHbIX B HeM IIOAXSAOB B CeloAH-f,111Hefi SKOHOMllrIecrOfruccJleAoBallrrfl. krcvTyaI\krl4.eTr4Tb qeTKyIo JIOII{KyCle4y'errkr cTpyKTypy AI{ccepTaIIIloHHOfoKTTTBHOCTI{ MSTOAOJIOIuqeCKOIOpeIIIeHI4fl IIocTaBJIeHHbIX sap;a.r^.rrccJreAoBaHufl)COI4CKATEJIC\,Iatt1rapaTa, BbI6paHHOIollpone.4eunrrfi aBTopoMCyqecT'ByIoIII4X TeOpeTI{r{ecKI4x IIOAXOAOB I4 OCHOBaHHbIX Ha HI4XPoccltuI4CCJIE.IIOB AH];NAX LlO Borrpocy BlrkrflHr4fl, IrpI{coeAlIHeHVfl, K BTO Ha sKoHoMI{Ky3HaqI4MtIe npo6eJlbl B HI4x, KoTopble 14 orlpeAelrvrlrvr HarIpaBJIeHI4erro3BoJII4iI OlIpeAenArrc cepTaIIu (cIllrIof o ccJIe.{oBaHll-f,.Anroporvr 6 w paccMorpeHbl BCe OCHOBHbIe HarIpaBneHI{t nOTeHIII4aIIbHOCTBA B BTO Ha noJIO)KeHI{e 14 IIepCrIeKTI4Bbr pa3Br4'tkrfleogleficrelllrcpaBHl{Telrnufi anr43oTpacJIH, B TOM qucJle B[rvrflHne cBf,3brBaHHt llMrIOprHbIX VrI4 noAAep)KKI43KCrIOpTHbDll IroIuJI H, orpaHu.resufi B cQepe [poMbrrrrneHHofi IToJII{TIIKI43MoXHoCTefi, OTKpbIBaIOUlIXafl.

B QBfl3II C AocTyIIoM K MeXaHu3MyrrpoI43BOAI{TeJIeI4,MeraJlnypru.recKofipa3pelrleHlltt CIIopoI4 KOJII4IIECTBEI{HbIX METOAOB I4CCJIEAOBAHI4fl', BKJIIOqA{I4CUOJIb3OBaHI',Ie BMATEMATI4TI€)CKOE M Aenl4poBaHue 3KOHOMI4TIeCKZX [poqeccoB, a TaK]KeAHAJTVT3A MIACCVIBA ATATI4ATVTIECKI4X AAHHbIX O BHCIIIHETOP|OBbIXKar{ecrBe 0a3blrroTIOTOKAX M.E]T€UIJ] ftrqecKofi npoAyKIII4II c llbICoKOfi cTeIIeHbIo AeTauIvl:,aI\vuTOEapHbIM I'pynr M 3a 2005-2016 IoAbI o6yclanlllBaer BbIcoKyIo creneHbCoqeranueAOCTOBepHOCIII4 rIaBTOpOMlqeJILIIIpucoeAuHeHLItHayvuancneAyroqzx rIoJIorI ycllelllHoe AocTI,IlKeHI4e nocTaBJIeHHOI4ccneAoBaHnr nolyrreHr4.fl o6rerrrasHoft OIIeHKI{ BIII4flHI4fleHHbrx pe3ynbTaToBBTO Ha MeraJlnypruqecKyro npoMbIIrIJIeHHocrb.rr3Ha AIICCepTaIII{OHHOfO I{CCJIeAOBAHI.dfl.

3aKJIIOqaeTCf,r4H KIdflXIarrpo6allu.s HoBoro noAXoAa K I4crloJlb3oBaHuroHofi KoHKypeHrocnoco6Hocrl{ (revealed comparative advantage),HAJrvrIvIe ycTofirII{BbIX Ha AII4TeJIbHOM BpeMeHHoM ropI43OHTer4MyrrlecrB Poccuu rro pflg1y roBapHbIX rpyuu Merannyprl{rlecKofia vI ycrrelxHat1.PTOKA3ATEI-fl I}bIII03BOJIT4BIIIAflTIECTBEHHbIXTIOKOI{KypeHTIIhlx rrrrpoAyKIII4I{ BbIcrpyKrype l)KcrIO2. flomyuenx IIepeAeJIoB,(rtp. 53-55).IITO CO3AaeT nlleAIIocbIJIKI4 Anf, yBenuqeHpIs.vxAOJII4 BnpofHo3llpyeMoro BlrvrflH]dfl. I43MeHeHU.flH Ha MeT'aJlnypfuqecKyro upoAyKIIUrc AO KOHeqHOTO cB.[3aHHOrOrrMIIOprHbD( fIOcrefleHbro neT aJrlr3arJvlr4 (lo ypoBHt qerblpex 3HaKoB ToBapHofiypoBHq c BbrcoKI4CIIOJI63OBaH14eMBHerIIHegKOHoMtIqecKOfi AetTeJIbHoCTI4) cHOMeHKJraTypblM MSTOAI4KI4 pacqeTa 3[acTI4rIHocTI4 o6reua ?IMIIOpTa IIo IoIIIJII'IHOrrpeAJlox(ennoft a(crp.

86-92).KOJrr{rIecTBeHHOft OIIeHKI43arroBeAeHLrr BepTr4K€uIbHoMaTeMaTI4rIeCKOI4 MO.4eJII4r4HTerpupoB€rHHoI.o peAnpr,r,rTll;,fl Ha BHyrpeHHkrx kr MllpoBbrx pbIHKax rlpoMe)KyrorlHol4 I4KoHeqHoft np0AyKII r4, Koropar Iro3Bo lrvrila aBTopy rpoaHaJII{3LIpoBarb e$Ser<rnnHocrbft nowlruKr4 14 gKoHoMrrrrecKofi noruruKl4 B ueJIoM KaK crI{MyJIoBp€Bnr4qHbrx r{ep Topr4Hbr rrepepa6orr<z cblpbf, ("tp. 93-101).,IIJI' IIOBbIIIIEHI4' I'Br,ls.sreH e n o6ocHosaHue ocHoBl{oro ptlcKa Anq Merannypru'IecKoficB.rr3r4 c npucoeAr.rHeHl4eM Poccuu r BTO, 3aKJlloqarouefoc-fl BrrpoMbrrxJleHH()crl4zrr ypoBHt SKcIIopTHbrx IIOITTJTI4H Ha JIOM rIepHbIX U HeKOTOpbIXcyIIecTBeHH,OM CIHII4.p. 103-111).UBCTHbIX METAJIJIOBrrpeAnox(onuit rlo KoMnneKcy Mep rocyAapcrseHHofi IIoJII4TI4KLI[oAAepxKkI ut crl4 yJrLrpoBaHBIfl pasBuTI4fl MeTaJlnypru.IecKOfi tIpoMbIIxJIeHHocTI4 BB BTO, ocHoBaHHoro Ha nonyqeHHbrx B xoAe I4ccJleAoBaHlrflycloBusx rIJIeroqarctqefo oTAeJIbHbIe npHHIII4nI4aJIbHO HOBbIe LIHCTpyMeHTbMpe3ynbTaTax v5.Pa^lpa6or(cry.

I2l- 44).Ocnonnuruu MEIIAHI{fl MII K AIICCEPTA \WrroAXoAbIflBNflIOTC-fl:o:rcyrcrByer aHarrl43 rIocJIeAHLIx zsMeHeHufi (2017 r.) BEnpoueficKoro Corosa B oTHoIII9HIIU MeToAI{KLI [poBeAeHLIt3aKOHOAare.lIbcrBepaccneAosannfi.. Karc .a3BecrHo, trPoAyKIIlIf, pocczftcrofiAHTI4IEMTIIlI].f OBb]txMeT€Lrrnyp f I4llecKofi rrpoMbrrxJleHHocrl4 3arlacrylr) craHoBI4Tc-[ o6rerrou [pI4MeHeHI4{1.AH TI4,II CM II UI]IBnLrfbIX IrorrrJII4H.OBvoTpa3tTct Ha KOHupo4ynquu? Karo r,rpuBpeIueHI,In cuopo2.HrovrgKcnopTa p,occuftcKar, cToTIKI{ 3peHu-tr aBTopa, yKa3aHHbre LI3MeHeHIltrocnoco6HocTtl poccuficrcux sKcnopTepax MeTannyprraqecrof[epcneKTI4BbI Ocrr prBa:Ivlfl. noeOfi MeToAI4KII B Oprane rron BTO?eeTc.fi BBt4Ay IIOAoftMerannyprvrv>><neeSSerruBHocrbro ronapnoft crpyKrypbl(ctp. 55, 58)? Kax aBTOp OIIeHLIBaeT 3TyeS$errunnoc:rr?3.

flpuocTaBJrter 0e3€Urr{3eI{MIIopra MeT nypruueclcofi rpoAyKlluu B Poccuro aBropkrvraHr4fl. aHTIaAeMnuHIoBbIe Mepbl, BBeAeHHbIe EnpasraficrcofigKOHOMI4rreCr<<1fi rcO vtccueit. Xorenocr 6rr noly'rl4Tb KoMMeHTapI{LI aBTopa Iro BJII{f,HLIroupoccuir.cKllx KoMIIaHufi. Karc oHLI MOIyr 6urr yrITeHbI B MoAenIl?STLIX Mep Ha rIO3I'I4. H,a cr . 136 aB'rop roBopl,Ir o Bvrrax cy6cuaufi', rpeAycMorpeHHbrxno cy6cuauw u KoMIIeHcaIILIoHHbTM MepaM. llpu sToM oHCorlaureHlIroM IITvrroMltHaer non-act nable subsidies - ro ecrb palpeureHHble.

[lr uero aBrop 3ro AeJIaer,wx cy6cn41r,rft yxe repecraJna cyqecrBoBarb BTO. Tarxe cneAyerEJIU .IIAHHA{ K.ATCoTMeTI4Tb, rrTO IIe a Bce actionable subsidies - ocrapvBaeMble cy6cuguu - MoxHoOTBETUTb KOMTIEH rlLroHHbrMI{ MepaMu (a ero Mo)KHo cAeJrarb He BcerAa) u cruucJl I4xqepe3 MexaHu3Mrr BTO MoxHo BJIpr.rITb Ha lI3MeHeHUe rOprOnoficocToI{T B 'foM.rIoJrI4TLlKI{ C',rpaH,n r{MeHflIOUIIIX Mepbl, TIOAUaAaIOIIIUe rroA 3Ty KaTefopllrc.4CAMOCTO'TEJIbHbIMf,BJIf,ETC.'IE.C.Kapruua[uccepraryunepxarrll4M gJIeMeHTbI nayuuofi HoBlI3HbI KaK B qaCTI4 BKnaAa BBrrno,tu.14CCJreAOBaHpleM,pa3BLITI4e reOpeTLIrracTkrKr{X rroAXoAoB K aH€LnI43y MexrAyHapoAnofi ToproBnl4' TaK kI B[paKTI4qeCKrIX peKeuAarlvfi n c$epe ropronofiTIoJII{rI4KI4.BeAeHHOfo klccneAOBalr.lafl, MOryTPesynrrarurnnofi II9JII{TIIKI4 IIopa:pa6omv rocyrlpoMbIIUneHH0CTBI,[uccepr:aqnx6rrrrIacIIoJIb3OBaHbI B paMKaXpzl3BlITI4Io MeTannypru'IecKofiTaKXe rrpu Bblpa6orrce IIo3I4llI4I4 Poccuu Ha TopIoBbIX lepeloBopax.llacuopra HoMeHKnarYPbrIIOJIOXEHI4'McooTBeTcTByercrleul4aJIbHOtlTeplayqHbIX pa6oruuron Mu,uo6pnayKI4 Poccltz p.:;.flclreul4€rnbHoiSTI{.00.14IIpeAbIIBn.sOIYIbIMKCOOTBETCTBT4:KT Q IITMuponax sKorroMuIKa vrorBer{aer rpe6oeanvrflM)ccepralll{tM Ha coucKaHl{e yveHofi creneHpl KaHAI4Aara HayK Bv 9, 10, 11, 13 pr 14 llonoxelnvrfl' o rlpucylK4eunpr yqeHbrxHoro [ocTaHoBJIeHLIeM flpanvrelbcTBa Poccllltcreueuefi,2013 r.

J\b 8,12.BHayqHofior 24 cenrr6pxocHoBHbIe IIOJIO)KeHI,Ifl VI pe3ynbTaTbl AIICCepTaIIUOHHOIOT,ITbI B IIOJITIOM O6IEUE.r4ccJIetroBalI)ls"E.C. l(aprun vr ouy6nraKoBaHbl 8 pa6or (n rorvr uI4cJIe 7 crareit' B XypHaIIax II3repeqH{ peqeH3up MbrX I43AaHIafi, percoueHAoBallHux BAK npu Muuo6pnayrcz Poccura),coAepxalqu.K ocrlo bre p e3ynbrarbl Au c c epral{I4o HH Of O kI C CJIeAO B AHVfl'.Taruuo6pKAHI.I"IAUTA SKOHOM, E.C. Kapruu 3acJlyxs{Baer npucy}IcAeHkrfl. yqeHoI'IqecKLIX HayK rlo HayqHofi creIII{€LrIbHocrLI 08.00'14CTEIIEHIIMraponarSKOHOMI{KA.TpoSuMeHKoO$uqnanrnrrfi onnAorIeHr r<aQe4prrrr,tSKOHOMlIqe0Kofo(De.4epalrH0rooronxerHoro o0-ponofi3KoHoMI4KIaJIbTETABATEJIbHOIOllblc[r fo oopa3oBaHr4[<Canru-flcrepSyp KVTVT05.04.18ilurut-tyto noAnncbAapcTBeHHOfoyqpe)KAeHu.tlfocyAapcrBel{HbII4KaHA[Aar SJKOHOMI4Olrra lOPrennar4Bepcl4Te'r)),KI{X HAVKEB l-lporacona.