Отзыв официального оппонента (Коммуникативные пространства русскоязычного населения в Германии (на примере Баварии))

OT3bIB 00141WAJIbHOTO 011110HEHTAThoKTopa coumo.aorwiecion HayK Jle,aeHeBOrl BHICTOpHH 10pbenmaHa miccepTaumo Ba3aHona Bap4m.nomeil A.rieKcaHaponwiaHa Temy <<KOMMyHHKaTHBHbIe npocTpaHcma pyCCK0513b111HOTO HaceaennmB repmamm(Ha npHmepe BaBapHH)»npeAcTas.aeHnyio Ha coHcKaHHe ymeHoti cTenem KaH,rumaTaCOHHOJIOTH‘leCICHXHayK HO CHeinHaJIbHOCTH22.00.04 - couHaabHan cTpyKTypa, COIMaJIbHbIe HHCTIITyTbI H npoueccm(coullo.nOrwiecKne HayKH)AHccepTam451 Ba3aHoBa B.A.5larDleTC51 OpHrHilaJ113HbIMHarnimmHccneAoBaHHem, 110C1351MeHHIDIM axTyanbHoil H, BmecTe c Tem, HextocTaToinioH33r1 IeHHoll npo6neme: KynE•TypHo-HcTopHtiecimm 4opmam o6pa3oBaHH5I rpynnmmrpaHToB, c °moor CTOpOHM, H nponeccam noagemicalmsi icymaypHmxH KyJIbTypHE.IX OCO6eHHOCTe1 AaHHbIXrpynn, c Apyroti.

Bspew' npmcyrcTByeT Bce Bo3pacTaionwilPOCCHH ByeTaHOBOKHacTosnneeHHTepec CO CT0p0HbI B.TIaCTH HoftnecTBeEmbix opramnankni K rpynnam MHIpaHTOB, npo)KHBaloinlix BHe POCCHH. Bxonuenunn BHellaller1 110JIHTHKH POCCHH o6o3Hag eHa pa6oTa c cooTetiecTBefunncamll3a py6excom. Kites' ”pyccicoro mHpa" H pa60TbI C cooTemecTBeHHHKamHo6cpualoTcsiB HarTHOricpe,ae. Ha3TanecoBpemeHHoromHoroicynbTypHoro poccHticicoro oftecTBa aKTyaJIbHbIMOCMIDICTIeH1451conHoKynbTypHoil HanpaBneHHocm oTnomennil mexuky camHmHmHrpaHTamH, a Taxwe mexcgy mHrpaHTamllnocsreaHHe rum,H MeCTHbIM HacemeHnem.

B Twice Bpemsr BB CI3513H C MHFpanHOHHbIM KpH3HCOM, B repMaHHHnpo6nema couHoKynbTypHotiAKTya.TIbHOCTbcospememmaxpa3BHTH5ICTaHOBHTCSI BonpocnoHcKa 011THMaTIMIOCI mo,aeRH HHTerpanHH, He06X0AHMOCTH narmoroH 1-10HHMaHH5LaKTHBHOa,aaHTaHHH Ho6ocTpanacbHHTerpanHH murpaHToB.HccneAoBaHHA BO mHorom onpe,aensfeTcsi pa3BHTHemOTHOHICHHil mexcAyFepmanneilHPoccneil, rAe BonpocperynHpoBaHaa B3aHMOOTHOHleHHil nepeceneHueB H mecTHoro HaceneHHA moweTCJIpICHT13 BaNCHBIM 43saKTopom al151 BbICTpaI4BaHH5I mHrpanHoHHoil HOJIHTHKH o6ekoc1cTpaH. Tema AncKyTHpyeTcstB MH0r011HCJIeHHbIXHarnibixcrnecTByeT mHoweCTBO mexcityHapoRmax ,BoxymeHroB,HCCJIe)10BaH1451X,HaII140HaabHbIX HpernoHanbmAx 3aKOHO,LIaTenbHbIX aKTOB, Be,LIOMCTBellHbIX, per140HallbHbIX HMyHH111411aJ1BHbIX HJIaHOB, KoHuenLwi, Hnporpamm,HOCB511.11eHHbDC npo6nemamconnoxyabTypHo g ananTannn H kurrerpaiwn MHIpaHTOB.

0411aKO, conHonorwiecKnenoica3aTenn, xapaKrepn3poinnenepeceneHneBBCOCTOSIlikle aztanTanlin Hnffrerpanin4 mHrpaffroB 14o6Lnecise, CBH1(eTeJ113CTBrOT 0 TOM, IITO H B Hatiane XXI Beimnpo6nemm B 3T01 cs:Depe He TOJII3K0 He peineHm, HO H ewe 6onee ycllsnmaloTcsipe3ynbTaTe BHenmetiHOJIHTHKHBeAyawx cTpaH mnpa.BY1114TbIBaSI TO, MTO Bnocnemme ronm mnrpannoHHasi anyannst B mHpe cyntecTBeHHo H3MeH51eTC51 110,aBJIHAHHeMreononnTwiecm4x 43satcropoBmnrpannollHoilHBo3pacTaeT p0J1b H 3HalleHHe110JIHTHKH, KaK OCHOBH0r0 perynKropa MHIpalIHOHHI,IX nponeccoB,awrop itenaeT aKIleHT Ha Teopermco-meTo,rtonornmecxomconnonorntlecKoro no,21xoAaKOMMyHHKaTHBH0r0K HCCJIe,/(0BaH1410H3r1eHHOCTH BJIH511011114X Ha110BCeAlleBHOrl KOMMyHI4KalAHH H noBe4eH TiecicnxpyCCK0513bIgHbIXBnffrerpanmo oco6eHHocTetio6pa3noB,1113HHATbIX B pa31-11,1XmitrpaifroB, ctinTatonatx ce6A pycexEmnBOCITHHHMa1011114MHC51 KOpeHlIbIM HacenemiempaccmaTpnBaeTcstnpo6nem 4)opmnpoBaH1451npocipaHcTBa pyCCK051313.1 11H0r0 HaceneHnst B repmaHlin.lipo6nema cn g oilrpynnaxOCMbICJIeHHHHKax pyccicHe mkirpaHma,AnccepTankn4 C 11031414Hrl crpyicTypHo-cpyHiciwoHanbHoro HHHCTHTy11140HaTIbH0rono4txo,rtoB.MeT0,,110.110THileCKHX OCHOB n3yg eHn5iABTOp BbIXO,E(HT4:topmnpoBaHnst rpynnHa pa3pa6oTicyMHI-paHTOBHe c TotncH3peHns{ lix 3THREIHOCTH, a c Toincn 3peHn5l I4X KynbTypHo g H,LIeHTITLIHOCTH.Pa60Ta OTTIfitlaeTCA Elly6HHOI1,ELOCTaTOLIHOH3r1eHOnpopa6onu4 paccmaTpnBaemmxy6eAnTenbHoll aprymeffrannell BbutBnraembix,EtocTaTotmoe ARA macinTa6Hmx o6o6inem411Tpy,Etbi KJIaCCHKOB COLIHOJIOn4H, cospemeHHbrxBOI1p000B H110J10)KeHHII.

ABTOpOMKOJIHIleCTBO HCTOIIHHKOB:C01.1340J10r0B, TeopeTnxoBmnrpannonorkm, 110JIHTOJI0r0B, 3TH0rpa40B, a Taime pe3yJIbTaThl couHonorwiecKnxnccne,ttoBaHnii no H3r1aem01 npo6neme.2HarlHa51 HOBH3Ha HpencTaBneHHoro Hccegraimotmoro HCCJIe,LIOBaH1431, eroTeopeTHilecicasi H ripaKTHilecKam 3HaIIHMOCTb, B nepripo otiepens, 06yCJIOBJICHbI Tem,irro o6o3Hag eHHasi awropom Hpo6nema He &ma npenmeTom moHorpai4n4qecicHxHccne,aoBaHHil, B TOM Ifficae H Ha ypol3He KaH,L(H,LIaTCKIIX nHccepTaimil B o6nacTHOTelleCTBeHHOrl C014110110rHH.Harmasr 1.3(ellHOCTb pa6oTsi B.A.Ba3aHoBa, 1:11aBHbIM o6pa3om, 3axmo gaeTc5i BTOM, IITO B KOMILTIeKCHO Hccne,nioBaH otieHomeH opyccicoro 3apy6excssm BrepMaHHH, BBIABJICHEJ TeH,L1e1114HH H AHaReKTHKa pa3BHT1451, naHa 061eKTHBHa51oueHica noTeHuHana pyCCKHX 3MHFIJaHTOB.MeT0,.110J10114 11CCKOrl OCHOBOR nHccepTaHHoHHoro HCCIICA0BaHH51 5113J151eTcmo6rHeHayqHmil nHaneKTHgecicHil meToA 1-103HaHH51 COIIHaJ11311131X ARTIeH1411npoueccoB.

HapaBHe C HHM coHcKaTens HCII0J1b30BaJIa H IlaCTHO-HarlHbIe meToAsEcormonorwiecicHe H cTaTHeTHilecicHe, "(ITO 1103B01151eT HpoBepHTs AOCTOBepHOCTbOCHOBHE4X BbIBO,L10B, 110J10)KeHlIrl HnpennoxeHHil nHccepTaHTa H ar1eKBaTHOCTbHHTepripeTamm Hony g eHHEax ef pe3ynsTaroB.OrppcTypHo nHccepTaum o6semom 257 cTpaHHH COCTOHT H3 BBCACHH31, AByxrnaB, 3aK.T110 11eHH51, crmcKa nliTepaTypsi H 11IKI)OpMaIII4OHHhIX HCTO IIHHKOB HapyccKom, aHranticxom 11 Hemeuom 513bIKaX 143 239 HaHmeHoBamil, TpexripHnoxceHliti.HaH6onee HeHHLamH II0J10)KeH1451MH Hporie,aeHHoro B.A.Ba3aHoinamAliccepTarlHoHHoro HCCJIe,110BaHH51, HO creneHH Hx.

3HatIHMOCT14 ,111151 coBpemeHHotiHapcH, Ha Ham B31'1151,L1, SIBJ15110TC51:a) aBTOp BBO,2111T 1-101151THe "KyabTypHoil HAelITHIIHOCTH" KaK oT.aensHoe OT"3THWIeCKOCI HaelITIVIHOCTH", H OHO CTaHOBIITC51 OCHOBHbIMaHanma (c.29);6) co6cTBeHHoe HccneAoBaHHe asTopa, KoTopoe onHpaeTcm Ha 3mr[HpHgecicHilmaTepHan, B TOM 11HCJIe co6paHmail camHm nHccepTaHTom. Ansi 110.11y11eHH51 ,L(aHHBIXnHcceprraHT nposen Ha TeppHTopHH repmaHHH noneBoe HccnenoBaHme.

T(HccepTaHTHCII0J1b30Ba.TI KagecTBemme MeTO,TIM c6opa Hml)opmaHHH: HonycwyKTypHpoBaHHoe14HTepBb10. BaX11131M B pa6oTe ABJ151eTC51 yica3amie Ha TO, IITO crieuklilmca3OHINHOL1 IS311413.0fla :0E1I311UdIO0d11 00Hcbaclific>1 tdk.L.:11ficX OHHOIAIH`HOrOlIf14, 01DICBEI ISOIOIWEEN clI3OHhHIHOVH OH 0Th `IAIOI 0 VO£11c1$11 I08110117 IHUIc1033141/'1114TIMIHHXIAIWON H IcicLCI(111XX t£1.1.0HUd130d1.1 OJOHc111THOHII1HOlfedi H0114HBWHH011 >1 I(1110XV01.1 10XdHEHIC1H1 HIO0HhHHICimadiXIcHAIOXV01103H ISHHEfiodHwdocpridoixacpIc11703C170L1 ‘aonHoir000dou014)1301.1Hd0I3H-OHcHfEHT10310/CdHEH1IEHR dOIEM 0£1BILI 011H uireHdarew IAIOHHOMOIfEH B1141-11001011'30113 PIIIBEIATO OHHOW0c1110MTO H V4MdlEdULI elIVHdaLBIA1 EH ioalroiro 0Hh14,101f1d0I031`Ic11tO£IPIE1 NOI010WH UittYKLIBdULI oioncex onHom fl 51o4Tedipcitu g loom 'ell UHoirolivedg amu 'ICHHOIOV0If30H 1A101411BE1OH0090 WHX00hHI0d001 ISOIOISIIEEIS PEEVE" ISEEKI0jj'011411UNHHXWIATOM E0d0h OHHOWH IS900gdkIclIfic>1 ki c11f0)1001.1 `IAIHHOWHdll OHIagH VOXI/011 IHHJ HHTIMIHH/CIAIWONHLUAU/Cm 01113017)1COI 0 UIfIfOX 'EC gLIMIHHd11 0,103130hH.10If0170101A1 EH IS1OX3HIOISHOWildil INBIc1000HI7 IckbaclIfiCX OHIICHOU '00E113fiedLOOdLI 00W1IfEHOHITUH0HBth>>`OcII3OHhHHIC>>‘<aqH1f0f1OPIHHOMIEdIHW>>ICIILISHOHIIVEI0dHEHLTHBOd1.103101VI douiy LLOITBd130dLI X1c1HEIHIMIHHXWWON H d0113E1417 HHBEIOV01f33H`LIFITIENHHMAIWON HlidOOI LIHHOMCHIOOV W0IHEId033HV 0114HRHOEcHfOLIOH ISclUrOJE1f9WFILDICOIATEOE1 01f813 h1flE WOdOlEIU X1c1HH0IMI00LI OHHOIII0d 'ISHIME101701f3OH0101A1E3 q uod H 0130W FIHOHOTIO OHIUEDIOITE OHH0f11010£11003 `ICHHB£101101f30HIHOIAIOW H LIHHOMCHI3Or X1c1HhtitH OHHISOI300 `IcHA101f90dLI HIOOHHOlaEll c1HOLIOIOung aocImuaraireodu wodatav .

KHHVH01/0110014 HNHIOHdOINgdUX 0HX30h14101f0170101A1-ONHIOd001ONH$10H00IIRCIBIOVOdLIIHeId0331117'HHH0r09CI! (ILI `LtI 'LII ' IOI '9G .0) <<rimr°HHOUOH>> H 00cD1C091dPE oomooAd» :aauludillw mwamiXdi mAticav AnKaw 1,11411011-10HI0ff orumeaodamo pikida H OPIHH0dOEIPTE101HHUEEffeclI0Icifl 011 UdOIEMJq oJcl(6Z I ' IZI ' ZL 'E9-090) HHITUdIOIHH H mmudici g lax)re 'llnrusrammoaa:LauaLaclioH90xmoce9X0d1. 01I0H00 H HIO0W11fOIHELLOHOI1' tI011£10111700,3011 xiskinaiano110103 XFIHHOMTEcLIHIAI ISHH8E10dHHOHIDIHX(f) H ISHHEEI0dHIAld04) XICI00HH09030UdOIEM IcHrOlIFIE1 `14HHEEI0V0If3OH WOHHOlt0f10d11 1H OPTHIMEIOHOO (9t(6L *0) HXdO9FIEEIJ0HEIHI21H0E0dLI0d ISHHOOdLOOL1 1flfaIE110111/0d1.1 011 011 c111Th2HEH ISHITE£10)701f33HHOdEIO„ HIlT HI4330,1 ,110HHOIAIOdEl03(L1 I„HHITUd_IHIAIHIOOMICEEE 0 aillitEMIXlAlIc11130d01Hll 'wgxku-n/cedu WrIIIHOEII3d£ITX30,I OHHOHIOHIO IfBEIOdH£HIITHBOdll.HM403341 • (LE I '3) EI0I314IfeHTIOU0 XEIHHOIIIBILIHdll HOMO HIATEHOIfh 3 I'LLO9Vdklog000 g ioomiraig iramc H IO1HdJHN OHHEMXX KOIOISIMIS WOVOEITIEI WIcIHXCECILEITH 'EH ` 0>ICXEI 'HI4330c1 H 1114lledIa1HH HXHIHIfOLI ISHHBEIMEdLOPIEI MHO&11XhOI 0 HONCBEIToaiFIHHV *(1.

EOIOUd£OEI BIOEIOXL3OdlIOLI Et 01HHEIAld0OHIIIEII99Hdll `FITIHOII000d011 KaLOIKIIEUS HIAlIclHhHIENIOlf90d11 30II09HUHISHHOd£ HXhal. 3 Olh `A.VOEIPIEI >I IHV0XI4dLI IHRIA030H11 'Math XNIAIOXVOlf3OH EIOHOIfhnililEth XF1H130:1£0E NO.LOILS 3 BlOdOIEM HOIMPIOndll EIOINLHOX EHIMHP H 0HII10HII0oamxgg 'rexSINUSoxorg iISHHOILLUh3l1EI 3111Eldall 10/cdH£HIfelfUKUM £H 1H01300 ISRdOIOX'Etoimair000dau i q uiadd tIOINCUX3EfUlf-I HOdOLEI oogyed.redeu[OdOISIoaIAI0IHRLd033H11' Hairag iondu XPIHHEIT40£E9 IUNC/CII3OHHUOHUO 'ISHHEEfottoiroom al0E101f011 CUOMO ISHH011'OEIOdllXISH01II01100HKHHEEI017.0IfOOH 012,LcIlfic£0d H 30c1HH0hfurOU CHUMP MOTU "BH IcIHEEI0H0090 OHlikeH 'OULU IJOHHEr El dOlEt£ IHVOXVIdII WIcIdOION X `FIVOEIPIE['00E1OdEtriCOOJ-IIIMLIHInl>> `<<OELL3011190-IHUdIllIk>> `<<IliedIHW-IHWITHW>>tIHHOITIOHIO 0HHBEIOdHIAId04)k_10,1.03 xNHIr1H11oo XPIHHOHllgdMIX 1A1014HISHIfEl`111,1110IfEUS OJOHI/OdEHXIMOIAI XUX `iion-redim onmroa 110*10H>> H 0191)1(09Xdg£al0X30Sd>> BH31IOH0CD IAT0HH0hX£14 IAIPIHONOIllIWON0 0FIHHE£1SEI3 `Nwoirgodu ONHEIOHOOnurornH 1IfIlIf0EI£OU H HHITEId003HIT UX0If9 a_10)100h14I9d0al.

VXH..10If KUHHUV'(g9 '0) „IMMO 01411cI1fEHOHTIUHOITEdL„ UHHIAIdOi 3B141. 00 OJOIICHHdllOLOONEE „WIIA103 OPIHHOELLOdBMCOOJOHMLL„ HHINIdal caUELOE'llf0110H `XUELLOdUlr1C301FIHOI.Ch "BILIOX ` 1414TIViCIH0 HHHEOHLIO Hdll VIHrid000ini'XIcIllEedalmaxamitodu K310101E1! WIc11130dOIHH -o) naLoowurg oci xrawnreanooxmligo `tumoiragiottodu 304M90 W0HHP11£00 I\IFIHI3OWELOO 3 I cIllg£1010 ORHIXOLI3d011IJOHhOdOOMOIT H E1011HOlf030d011 HMIRLI1014d0 SWOdOIOX 0H0VILI03 `OHHOX<Olf0IIWOIHR1d03314I7 00HHOVOEMdll IAIPTH>ICUEI iso,LoKirEcantrodu Etolosarm XHX3OhADIUdllISH110d£ HXhOL 3 mad" xrulaA'airoom KIll IAIPIHEI0H30 IfOIHUOIIBIO OHOH `<<HI30HhHIH01114 1,10X30hHHIC>> 10 00IFIII01110 >MX OHI00Hha1H0ITH IJOHdktclIfiCX>>9• "HIMBId03014)1 HIOONHfitHE 1j0X0hHINVd11-0HhiCUH H H100Hd0140100)1`14130H(111VHH.IHd0 NOELLOcHfa1OVH£10 IOVLISJON g UHO i(XclICONOOLI `UNHVOX900HUNc10011 (LIHHBEIO1OIr0OH XPIHHOILLOOMX JIfl1 1400c1H0 g IOUSIMBIOndli 300:191HHIJOHN1109 `AdOWHdll X) HXHdHlINC H SOVOgrig ICHTIBXHHXNNOX Kernarog `00HOWOH NO! 'FII09Bd XBITEILI g NHOXC8d10 0HcHMIOlt ISHHU g01110110314 0,10X00hHdHIMICPILUIcHric£0d Olcid0I0X0H 011goiroiccog -KIIHEHO1'0110011 ISHHOX(01f011 ONHELOHOOOlfe£10dHIHOWkIdU 00Hcill'HO H 1119 OlfEgOdHdLOOHIlfHOdLI O gIIIIIOILLO 001109 00dOIOX`KHHEEE011101f00H 0,10X3OhildHLIBIC 0,10X3d0I ge PlIBIcHfiCE0d H LffidUIHOWicd1OHHICHHOXCBdIO OJOHhOIVI0Or ITSVOXBH OH mmuidaoomi °Lomas.:14XIMLOOVOH•OPIdOIONOH H clIOrMgiC OHX<ON `14HriaLd003H1'IJOHHOX(0111(0d11 UglOHH0130V ONHIlicEH ONHHUCUX/COMPI g1H ISCLLON3014"g011I011000dOLIUHHEEIOVO11"00143CHHIOIXVOlf3OLI10XGON 0.Lh `01cliKIOIHH14HHOVOgOcIllHalNOcid0110V01.1clIHX0c1f0H KOI010}SIH `H‘ OlfUlOrt XPIHOOdOMH OHHB3HII0oHomcomrodu NH XPIHHOlfOirrlfl HHH13H110 Win BIOdOl gg 0109d'141411Eid0001417(1100HHO11 IfeHhiCVH ISOlOghOHIXE£ WOIC g tHHIOICOM100 g ISHHOlfgedHUH OJOHIMETXXtIHHOXCHI3012.