Отзыв официального оппонента 3 (Исследование новых эффектов в стационарных и нестационарных системах нескольких тел)

OT3bIBo(fuuuanrnoro orrroHenra flensroea (De.uopaMuxafiroBl,Iqa Ha Ar4ccepralllroHHyloHoBbIx s(f(perron epuOoty Pylnena Bna4raruupaAlercanApoBlrqa <I,IccreAosaHI,Ie.cTarlproHapHbx r4 HecTarlr{oHapHbrxcucTeMax HecKoJIbKI'IXTeJI>,[peAcTaBneHH]TOHacor4cKaHr{e crerreHr{ AoKTopa $u:zro-uareMarl4r{ecKl4x HayK IIo cfleu[aJlbHocrl{01 .04.02 - reoperurlecKaq $usuxareMbl AltccepralrulrpIB .quccepraqrau B.A.

Pylnera <Irlcc:reAoeaHlle HoBbIx e(p$ercroB B craul'IoHapHbrxHecrarlrroHapHbrx crrcreMax HecKoJrbKr{xreJI)) orpaxeHbl pe3ynbrarbl l{ccneAoBanuft, naureAlrrueqaCTIIU'HeCKOJIbKnXCI{CT9MaMI'IHa6Opepa6Or, CBt3aHHbIXC KBaHTOBbIMI{rrpl{MeHeHpreB IIrr,rpOKOrrAHa ocnoee nprMoro pelxeHr.rq crarlr{oHapHbrx LI HecraulloHapHbrx 3aAar{ HecKoJrbKI{xreJr aBTopArrya.nrnocrbrroJr1nrr4npe3ynbrarbr, rro3BoJrriBrrrue Bbr.f,Bl4rbHoBbIe oipSerru v 3aKoHoMepHocrl{ KaK AntIIOJI'MI4.BrIcoKaqcrarlr4oHapHbrxcr4creM, TaK lr ;tns cprcreM, ssauN,IoAeftcrBylounx c BH€IITHI4MI4$usuxu, HaxoAtlrluxcs Brlprrr4pyeMocm pa6or B.A. Pyaneea n o6racr{x aroMHoft tt uoleryllpnoftuccreAoeaHl4[ueHTpe BHr,{MaHlrr3KclreplrMeHTaropoB, He ocraBJlfler coMHeHuft e arrya-nbHocrl4AlrccepTaHTa.Hayunar HoBI{3HaAnroporr,r Aprcceprarruu nonyr{eHbr HoBbre Bax(HbIe @n:nuecrue pe3ynbrarbl.

YAalocrBbrflBrrrb cBs3b MexAy eS(percrou EQunrona u rrunueft @ullunca. O6uapyxeHbr H rIccJIeAoBaHbIMOJIeKyJI'cepr4r4 oKononopofoBbrx pe3oHaHcoB B pacceqHI{I,I opI{eHTI'IpOBaHHbIxnontpHbxBburBJIeHa cB.fl3b MelKAy eerr.r.{nHofi noJlHoro ceqeHl4q paccefrHvrs. Ll anusorponueft6ul npeAcKa3aHe(p(ferr BlrrrflHtrs'(pa:rtara$(fepenqlraJrbHofo ceqeHr.r.spaccefl:nkrs.[uccepranrou3neKTpoMarr{r.rrHoror{Mnyrrbca Ha Soro.uuccoqIaalll4]o MoneKynqpHblx cl4creM, noATBeprus]irruitcfl'uBnocneAcrBvturHa 3KcrreplrMeHTe,nocrpoena o6uaq reopuq Blrkrsntrfltpasrr NleNay Hecyuefteo:4eficrnus Ha KoHerIHoe cocrotHlle xganrosoft cucreMbl' Brt:rlioru6aroqeft ulrnylrcHoroo6rque KaqecrBegHbre,Kacarorqraecsrro6sx KBaHToBbrxcllcreM, ycJIoBlIs' [pI4 KoropbrxBbu{BJregbrcr4creMbl.$a:a unanynbcaMoxer BJrrl{Tb Ha KoHetmoe cocrornr.re3ru pe3ynbrarbr nonyr{eHbr Ha ocuoBe pa:pa6oraunrxBbIIII{CJII,ITCJIbHbD( METOAI'IK, BKJIIOqATTIUXvpea[pl3oBaHHbx aBTopoMUCNOJIb3OBAHI'IC ACI{MIITOTI'IqECKI'I ONTIIMA'IIBHbIX CETOK Bc}IcreMbl ypanirenufirp€xuacrrw6rx pacu6rax, HOBbTXnoAxoAoB K npeao6ycnaBJrl4BaHl{ro@a44eeea,peanr{3arlu}rB6rcoKogS$ercrurrrrx MeroAoB pelneHplqypaBHeHplslllp€auurepa rnecocrosnuft 'Hecrallr{oHapHbrxCogepxanrle AIrccePTaIIrruilo TpI4 rJIaBbI, uBKIIOqaIO1ql1x,{uccepraunr cocTor{T tr3 Bne4enur, AByx uactefi,3axffo-{eHuq.Bo Bse.{eHr{rraBTopo6ocnoerrsaer arTyaJrbHocrbpa6oru, $opruylupyer e€ ue:ru Lr3an.arlkl,Ha 3aIqI{Ty.cyJvlMl{pyeTTIoJIOXeHI'I',BbIHOCI4MbIeqacrb1tocBqrleHa noporoBrrM s$(perrau B cucreMax HecKoJIbKI'IXreJI.

B nepnoEllepnanpeureHl'Is ypanneuufirJraBe paccMarpuBalorcr eucoxoe$$eKTnBHble BbIr{IlcJII4TeJIbHbIecxeMblrlocrpoeHl{flrsai{rosoft MexaHVKz B craulroHapHoft rrocraHoBKe. Anrop $op*rylupyer npI{HIrI4nbIceToK BTaKI4X cXeM, paccMaTpl4BaeT r4cIIOIIb3OBaHI4eacI4MrITOTI4r{ecKI',IonTI4MaJIbHbxAI4cKperI{3oBaHHbxrp€xuacruunr,x pacv€Tax, [peAJrafaer noeHft rIoAXoA r npe4o6ycJIaBJIIrBaHI'IIoypaBHeHr,rfi Oag4eeea,cr.rcreMnoseorsroquficoKparl,Irbs(f(perrunnytopa3MepHocrbrrpocTpaHcrBaperueHpu.Bo nropoft rJraBe MeroA, pa:pa6orannrrfi s nepnoff rJIaBe, npl4MeHterct K peIxeHLIIo3aAaq. B nepBoM pa3Aene fJraBbI orll4caHo no,Upo6noe recrl4poBaHlrerp€xuacrzunrrxcxeMbr Ha npplMepe cl4creMbl rpex aroMoB rerl4q. lloapo6uopeanr{3oBaHnoft srrquclurelrnoftrIoBJII4trb Ha cornagoBaHuocrbcuoco6nuerrpoaHanrr3r,rpoBaHbrrrcroqHlrKr,{ [ofperuHocrpl,[poAeMoHcrpl{poBan, qro Anfl noreHlluaJlbHbrxpe3ynbraroB pa3Hbx aBTopoB.

,{nccepraurnao.4elefi, onpe4elenHbrx B eAr{Hr.rqax reMrreparyprr, paspa6oraHHall cxeMa pemeHl{s 3a4arrrrBbrrroJlHflTb BbrrryrcJreHr,rr c ror{Hocrbro, onpeAeJlseNaoft HeorlpeAen€nnocmroBo BTopoM pa3Aene fJIaBbI I4ccneAyerct Koppen.flIll4t gHepruplnocrosHHoft Bonrquana.qacTI'IIIbI na CSXgaHHo[rpex uacruu I4 AJILIHbIpilCeefrHvrfl,oKononopofoBofo cBx3aHHOfOCOCTOqHr.rrrro3BoJrreryHl,IBepcanrnrrfi xapaKTep [oBeAeHI'Is rarofiKoppenrqnr4 B pex$aMe B3anMoAeircryux,6rusrcoN,{ r etpuuoncrofi ynurepciulbHocrll, 14noJlf{eHoHoBoe coorgo[reHue [rs.oKononopofoBbrx na6nroAaeubrx npu TaK]Ix ycnoBusx nsalalvlo.4efcrBllt.nape, noAo6naslultrfi@ullunca.BussreHpacceflHkrflnoBeAeHI{e ceqeHllxnopofoBoenonqopr{eHTr.rpoBaHHbxnoJrflpHbrx MoneKyn. florasano, r{To npl4 Bapva\uu ilontpll3ylouefonoporoBoe noBeAeHr.recetreHnr pacce{Hns onpeAenqercl yHuBepcalrHofi cepueft pe3onaHcoB.llpnne4ena maccu$nxaUur rilKlrx pe3oHaHcoB, BbUIBJIeHagBt3b BeJIL{qI4HIInoJlHoro ceqeHpls cBrperreftrJraBericcneAyercsaHH3orpon ueit p acce r.uun.Bropax qacrb nocBrrqeHa r{ccJreAoBarruroBJrlrtrrur (pasrr Me)KAy necyrueft u oru6arorqeftgneKTpoMarHI,ITHofol,IMrrynbcaHa B3ar{MoAeftcrnyroru}rec HrIM KBaHToBbIecl4crgMbl.kasa 4 uocesilIeHa peureHr{ro Hecrarluonapnofi rsaHrosofi 3a!.atl;zrrp0x rel Ha ocHoBeMeroAa cranrlpoBaHnrrx KoopAunar.

llonyren nosuft pe3ynbrar, cBt3blBarorluit acuvnrorl4rlecKoeB cKanupoBaHubx KoopAuHarax c sorHoeofi (pyltlcuueft nrroBeAegue noruroeoft (fynxquur4MrryJrbcHoMrrpeAcraBJreHlrr4.3ro nosoe coorHolrreulle no3BoJlter nonyqarb pac[peAeneHl4enpeo6pasosatuir.$paruenroB peaKrlr.il ilo r,rMrrynbcar\46es ucrIoJIb3oBaHI4t I,{HTerpanbubxucrroJrb3oBaHqe MeroAaAnt I,IccJIeAoBaHLI{ MoAeneft $oro4nccoIIHaIII4I{O6cyx.4aercrnoJrox0.rTeJrbHoroMoneKynqpHofo lroHa BoAopoAa B noJle KopoTKoro cI'IJIbHOro na3epHofoK QaseraMnyirbca. Anroporra npeAcKa3aHa rryBcrBl{TeJlbHocrb KoHer{Hofo cocroflHllt3JreKTpoMarHr,rrHoro raMflyJrbca, Koropa{ Mo)I(er na6moAarrcs B yrnoBoM paclpeAeneHulz(ppanaenroB peaKrluu pr n eule 6onee cyrqecrBeHnofi rtaepeBJILI{er Ha pacnpeAeneHue (ppanueuronpeaKrIWI IIO CKOpOCTqM.B nsroft rJraBe uo4po6no paccMorpeu Borrpoc o na6ruoAaeMocrl4 npeAcKa3aHHbrx B.rem€proft uraBe $asonrxeQ$exroe B peanlcrllqecKoM cIIeHapI4I'I sKcnepI4MeHTa.

Aerop3aKrroqaer, qro A11sna6nroAenu.n $asonsx otp{erron B yrnoBoM paclpeAeneHur'r tppanraeHToB,o6ecne'{urrAtrccoqlrupyroqr4x r{3 HeKorepeHTHofo HarlarbHoro cocrotnfiq, neo6xoAnuo nu6oreoMeTpl4lo SKCnepuMeHTa, IapaHTI,IpyIOq)rc paBHoMepHoe pacllpeAeneHl',Ie I{HTeHCHBHOCT}IMlrrrreHpr, rua6o nrruoJlHtrL ceJIeKUI4Iope3ynbraroB IIo I'IHTeHcI{BHocrI4BHerrrHero noJrr. B :ro xe BpeMfl, nau6oree npocro na6moAarr $asonrre e1p$exru Mo)KHo HaxBocrax paclpeAenenrafi $panr,reHToB peaKIII4LI ilo 3Hepil{I{, qro ne rpe6yer HI4 iloAroroBKrlreoMerpl,Il4 3KcnepI'IMeHTa' floxasano, r{ToKorcpeHTHoro cocroqHl,Ir MHrrreHI4, HH croxnofina6lroAeurae (pa:onrx o$(pexron B Ar.rccoquaul4l{ MoJIeKyntpHbIX I4oHoB BoAopoAa nau6oleer.r3nyqeHus no o6r€uy6laronpuxrno[pr4 lrHTeHclrBHocTsx rroJrr, KorAa BepotrHocrl4I4oHI43aUI{I{ Pr AI4c0OIII4aIII4HcI,ICTeMbI OKa3EIBaTOTCS CpaBHI,IMbIMI4'lrasa 6 rocBrrrleHa nocrpoeHr4roreopuu $asonrx e$$erron fipu esautrdoAeficrBkruI2rlo;tq' AerOpOu [OnyqeHOrrpopr3BonbHoftKBaHTOBOftCucTeMbIC pIMnynbCOM3neKTpOMafHIITHOroBonHoBoft $yirxUuurrpeAcraBneHlre,no3BoJurroqee qBHbIMo6pasou BoccraHoBI4Tb3aBl4cllMocrbHMilynbcoM, oT oa3bl I{Mnynbca33ar{MoAeftcTB}rolllefi c SneKTpoMafHI4THbIMCr4CTeMbr,KBaHTOBOfiBO3MOXHOCTbno perxeHuro ypaBHeHr4q, He 3aBr40-silIefo oT $asu.

3ro npe.ucTaBJIeHI{e'IaJIOnro6bre $asoeue esQerrri B repMuHax I'IHTep$epeHIIu[ KBa3I{sHeprerI4rIecKI'Ixr,rHreprrperr.rpoBixrbcocTogHl4il'oTBeqalolullxpa3nllqHoMyllucnyno|noilIeHHblxnu6oI4cnyueHHbIX$ororion.MoAeJIb AByrypoBHeBoft cl4creMbl, B3aI'IMoAeficTByIoIIIeft cpaccMorpeHalloApo6noMoAeJrE IIo3BoJII4JIa BbIqBI4Tb KaqecrBeHHble ycnoBl'ItoneKTpoMarHrrrHbrM rroJreM. 3ra(fasorsrx e$Qerroe. B .{acrHocTI,I, noKEBaHO' IITO AJI' noflBJlenux Qasonr',rxBO3HpTKHOBeHUTI4Mnynbca rIpI4 sTOMAJI}ITeJIBHOCTbe(f(fer<ron r{Mrrynbc AoJrx(eH6srrr AocrarorrHo I4HTeHCI4BHbIM,ponb.MOXeTI{rpIIrb BTOpOCTeIeHH}.IO:epTaHTOMHau 6o;r ee Ba,ItHbre p e3yJrbTaTbl, IIOJITIeHHbIeAI,ICC- pa3pa6oraH BbrcoKoo(f(perruenuft veroA rrpflMoro peureHuq KBaHToBofi3al.aqv rpex ren;- orKpbrrbr HOBbIe yHr{BepcanbHble 3aKOHOMepHocrI{,cBq3bIBarOrII4e oKonoiloporoBblepexplMe, nOAo6Hrre rtvntIpr OulluuCa;B 3aAaqeTpex rel n eSurvroBCKOMHa$nIOAaeMbIe- npeAcKa3aHbr yHlrBepcanbHbre cepprr4 oKono[oporoBbD( pe3oHaHcoB B pacceflHvrr4Al4noneft u ollplcaHbl I'lx cBoftcrBa;opr4eHTlrpoBaHHbrx- npeAcKa3an aQQerr BlfirflHvrs,Sa:rr r'rexAy Hecyqefi u oru6aroqefiMoneKyn;r,rMrrynbcaHa AI4CCOUnaqaro- Ilonr{eHbl npalflItrlecKl'Ie oIIeHKx na6molaeuocruMoneKynqpHoro uoHa BoAOpOAa;- IlocTpoeHa Teopus, o6rscHfroqatsrerrpoMarH?IrHoro(fa-:onoro e$(peKra B AI4ccoquaIIHpIBIIrrswAA $asrr MsXAy Hecyu{efi krI',ICI4CTeMy'r{M[yJrBCaHa B3arrMoAeficrnyroruylo c HI',IMKBaHTOByIOs(f(perruoru6aroueft slerrpouafHr{THofoo 6rscHeHrr KarlecrBeHHbIeycnoBut ITXTIotBJIeHHs'ptttu pe3ynbrarl'IBHol4llo upegcraBneHHoft Ar,rcceprarlur43aMerraHnft,racarorql4xct HayqHoitOuru6ru O$Opmneuus [lg'C9epTA\vtr'.cocTaBJrrrorqefr,ner.