Автореферат (Реструктуризация крупных портфелей ценных бумаг в условиях низкой ликвидности рынка)

Ha npaeax pyKonucuBurcropoBl,IqHayvreHno B"rraAr.IMIrppEc T PyKTyPpI3AIII,Ifl KPy[HbIX rI OPTOEJIEpITIEHHbTXFvMAf B yCJIOB Vrfl)( HI{3KOIZJITTKBI{NHOCTI,I PbIHKAo6parqeul4eI{ KpeAI{rCneuuaruHocrb 08.00.10- OuuaHcbl,AeHex{HoeABTOPEOEPATAHccepr ar\vrr4Ha co14cKaHI4e yv eu ofr cr eII eHI4HayKKaHArrAaraSKoHoMr4qecKuxMocxea- 2012Pa6ora BbInoJIHeHaHa xa$e4pe ynpaBneHr4flpvrcKav^ru crpaxoBaHrar SaxyJrbreraoKoHoMuKnSe4eparbHoro rocyAapcrBeHHoro aBroHoMHoro o6pa3oBareJrbHoroyqpexAeHlrr Bbrcrxero npo$eccuoHiurbHoro o6pa:oBaHkrfl<HaquoHamnufi r4ccneAoBarenbcKnfiyuunepcrrrer <Brrcuraq ITIKoJIaSKoHoMHKr4>.Hayunrrfi pyKoBoALIreJrb:KaHAHAaTSv:zr<o-vareMarlrqecKr4x HayK, AorIeHTCruupuoeCeprefi Hnrcoraesu.rO@nquanbHbreonrIoHeHTbI:ArexnHBopucllsaHonuqHayK,npoQeccop,AoKrop sKoHoMrrrrecKr4xPoccuficx uir rocy 4apcrBeHHbrfiryuauurapHrrfiyHprBepcr4rer,npo$eccop ra$e4prr <<@unancrrr4KpeAr.rr>Srouour4qecKoroSarynrreraLlncruryraoKoHoMr4KH,yilpaBreHr4q v ilpaBaJIo6anon A.nerccefiAnaro.nreBrrqKaH.{IIAaT 3KOHOMprrreCKr4XHayK,IfeHrpanrnufi 6aux Pocczficrofi @egeparJW(Banx Poccuu),3aMecrr{renbAr.rpeKropaBaHvfl[euapranaeura6asroBcKoroperynr.rpoBe4yrqax opraHv3arlr4q:Mocrconcr<ufirocyAapcrBeHnufiyHrrBepcr{TerrrMeHrrM.B.

Jlo*rouocona3anlura cocrol4rcx <<20>>ceuu6pr 2012 r. e 14.00 qacoB Ha 3aceAatr4ur:aecepraIII{oHHorocoBera 4212.048.07 upraHaquosarbHoM r4ccneAoBareJrbcKoMyHr4Bepcr4Tere<<BrtcuraqITIKoJIaoKoHoMr{KH)rro aApecy: 101000, Mocrna, yn. Mxcnr4qKar,r.20,ayt.327-K.B 6u6tuotexe HaquoH€LrrbHoroC 4ucceprarluefi Mo)KHoo3HaKoMI,ITbcrr{ccneAoBaTeJrbcKoro yHr4Bepcurera <<Brr aurafl,rrrKoJra 9KoHoMr4Kr,r))(AnropeSepar p€BocJraH2012r.YqeHrrfi ceKperapbAHCCepTarIrroHHOfO COBeTa,AoKTop 3KoHoMHr{ecKHXHayK, upo$eccop(DznocoQonaTarrqna f eoprr4eBHaI.

O6uras xapaKTepucrnKapa6oru.ArcryannHocrb reMbl rIccJIeAoBanu;r.r.IrlnrepecHayr{HbrxKpyroBra$uuanconopr$eneM B ycnoBr4rx Hlr3KofiruxeuAHocrr4 pbrHBbrxr4HcruTyroBK yrrpaBneHr4roKa 3Harrr4reJrbHoBo3poc B cBfl3n c rIocneAHI4MI,IKpl43r4cHbrMr4co6rrrzqNaw 2007-2009ff., orJrr4qureruuofi oco6eguocrbloKoropblx cr€ulo pe3Koe rraAeHl4eH Aaxe r4cr{e3-pbrHKaHeKoropsrxSuuaucoBbrxr.rHcrpyMeHToHoBeHr.reKBHAHocrr4B.Jrr4pbIHKailpLr rr3MepeHr4vtpvcKa nopr$enrHeo6xoAr,rMocrbyqera nrIKBI4AHocrH14rrocrpoeHuvrruoAenefiqeHoo6paeoBaHprflQuHaucoebrxaKTrrBoBnpoAeMoHcrpr{posa o6rseJreHr4eMBaJrvco6sttur^, nocneAoBaBrxr4e4e$onra rro BHyrpeHHeMyAonrypblHor{Hoi,t:luxnugHocrr4Ha pa3BrrrbrxPocczra77 anrycra 1998 roAa.

IrlcqesHoneHl4epbrHKaxKanr4Tiura,Koropble, flo o6rqeupraHqroMyMHeHI,IIo,He [rMeJrLrHr{KaKoroorrBJreHHeM.llpou:orue4HorrreHrrf,x poccraficKoMypbrHKy,cruuro6ecupeqeAeHrHbrMltui,r B pe3ynbrare 3roro Kpax xe4N-SoH4a Long Term Capital Management(LTCM)pblHKa rrpnrroKa3aJr,qro B cnyqae BHe3arrHoro r4crrapeHr4flJrHKBr4AHocrr4MeHeHr{e cJro)KHbrxSunauconblxMoAenefi, ue yqurblBaloull4x pbrHor{Hyro Jrr4KBr4A-HOCTb,MOXeT rrpHBeCTr4K Cepbe3HbrMrrocJreAcrBr4rMAnq Bcex yqacrHr4KoB pbrHKaHe3aBHOr{Moor xapaKTepa [poBo.{r{Mbrx onepaqufioco6o orMerr{Tb, trro EasemcrHfiHa pbrHKax KarruTaJra. Crorarxotuurer IrocJIe 3TI4x co6rtrrafi BnepBble o0rauu-puuxon'.Jrr4KBr4AHocrr4aJrbHorrpr't3HanBaxHocrb vrcy-ueHtrfl,Saxropon u [r4HaMvrKr,rpvcKa H ynpaBneHwflnopr$enev eB nepnyro oqepeAb upo6reua r43MepeHlrflr4HBecropoB,ycnoBr4rx HHsxofi JruKBrrAHocrrraKTyzLrrbHaAn{ r4HcrHTyIIHoHiuIbHbrxII3MeHeHrIecrpyKTypbl noprSenr Moxer noAnfl Koropbrx Aa)KeHe3HarrlrreJrbHoeBrer{b ra co6oft coBepueHrrecAenoKKynnu-[poAaxl{ KpynHbIXo6reMos.

B erccrpeno r{eHHofi6yuare I4nI4npoI43BoAHoMycnyqaqx o6reru no3r4rlr4r4MaJrbHbrxSr.rHaucor{To tIpH se6laronpvtrBoMy r4HcrpyMeHTyMoxer 6um HacroJlbKo3Har{ureJIbHbIM,qeHbr ero BbrHyxgeuyan' uttu go6poBoJlbHat nLIKBI'IAauua6yAer coHoM ABprxreH:z;z-y6rrrKaMl4 BrrJlorb 4o 6auxporcrBa. Kpovre roro,rrpoBoxAarbcr KoJrocc€LrrbHbrunIMarket liquidity: researchfindings and selectedpolicy implications.- Bank for InternationalSettlements- Monetaryand EconomicDepartment,Committeeon the Global FinancialSystem,1999.to6ecneqenuq.rpe6onauuqo BHeceHI4IrAononHI,ITeJIbHoroHanprrap, B cnyqaenonyrreHr4fl[po6neMa II4KBI4AaIIvI4no3l4l{uit,uau6onee ocrpo nporBnflercfl Ha pbrHKax,o6latITo nyqure Bcero orpa)Kaercs, crra1r'tu o6revovAarcIrII4xHtzsxofrnrIKBLIAHocrbK),ToproBnl4wlutu ruupoKl4Mu6u4-acrcc[p3AaMIr, Koropbre oco6enno xapaKTepHbrAJ]spa3BrrBaroquxcqpbrHKoBKanrrr€ura,B T.tI.

poccufi croro.Taruru o6pasoru, QraHauconbrMrrHcrr4TyraMH KpynHbrMKoMnaHrzrM,rrpoBoAtI{r4M orIepaIIHH Ha pbIHKax KarII4TuuIa,Heo6xo.{r4M r4HcrpyMeHTapnir Als rr3MepeHI4t prrcKoB H Bo3Mo)KHbIXrlorepb, cBt3aHHbrx c HeyAalrHofi pecrpyxrypra:ar1Hefrnopr$erx.Ero pa3yMHoe rIpI4MeHeHrae6y4er cuoco6crBoBarbrroBbrrrreHr4rocra-6ulrsocrr.r 6auron H KoMrraHuirt,v r.tr. poccnficrux.CreneHr parpa6oraHHocrlr reMbr. Hecrr,rorp.aua o6rqenpr43HaHHyro3Har{[pbIHKa [I OKa3bIBaeMOfOero BJIH'HLTflHA TpaH3aKrIr4OHHbIeMOCTbII4KBI4AHOCTI4r43AepxKI4, He cyrqecrByer eAI4Horo rIoAXoAa K I43MepeHr4roAaHHoro ceoficrBa pbrHKa.Eoree rofo, Ant c[equaJrucroB e o6racrnpbrHQunanconbrx pbrHKoB Jrr4KBr,rAHocrbKa Moxer [IMerb puBnl4r{Hbtfictuucr. foeop-r o n}rKBr4AHocrH,oAHr,rnoApa3yMeBarorcnoco6uocm6rrcrpo roproBarb,Apyrl4e - cuoco6Hocrb 3aKrror{arb cAeJrKHKpy[-nrrx o6teMoB, Tperbr4- cuoco6uocrb roproBarb c Hr43Kr4Mr43arparaMr.r.[pyrravraCJIOBaMI4,JII,IKBI4AHOCTb[MeeT HeCKOnbKO aC[eKTOB, [pr4r{eM pa3nr4rlHbre r.rHBecTopbrrlo-pa3HoMyonpeAeJlslor 3HaquMocrbroro HJrr4r4Horo acrreKTa.BcleAcrBne raxofiMHoforpaHHocrI'IrroH{THt nI,IKBrIAHocrr4B nr4TeparypeHe cyqecrByer ee o6qenpraHTTO|OOrrpeAeneHlrr.B pa6orax, [ocBtIrIeHHbIX I{ccneAoBaHVflMnHKBHAHocrrz,npocJrexr4BarorctABa ocHoBHbIXHa[paBJIeHI{f, onucaHu{ cocroqHr4r SuHancoBoro pbrHKa.

flepuoe nocBf,IIIeHo I4ccneAoBaHI,IIo crarl4crnqecKl4x 3aKoHoMepHocrefr, cBr3brBarorrlnx pa3JIHqHbIelrHTefpanbHble xapaKTepvrcT[Ku pbIHKa, TaKr4eKaK, HarrpHMep, Jil4KBT4AHOCTbrr BoJrarrrJrbHocrb.[pyroeHarlpaBneHr4eKoHrleHTpr4pyerc{Ha v3yv'elr^nuMHKpo-crpyKTypbl pbIHKa c Ilenbro aHaJrv3a BrvrflHkrfl,ycrpofrcrBapbrHKa z 4eficrnwiror-pbrHKa.AenbHbrx efo yrIacTHHKoBHa JIIIKBI4AHOCTbIrlccre4onaHvrfl, HanpaBneHHble Ha Bhr-rIBreHrIecrarkrcrvrr{ecKl4x 3aKoHoMepHocrefi 4lxorrprcalnnfl,cocro.nHrlt pbIHKa, paccMarpr4Balor nlrKBrrAHocrb KaK oAHy r43pbrHKa(nnrecre c BoJrarr4JrbHocrblor4HTerpanbHbrxxapaKTepLrcrr4KrleHbr,TpeHAoM14ap.).

OanaKo Ao cr4x nop He nrrpa6oraHo eArrHoeMHeHr4eo cocraBe 3Tr4xxapaKreprrcrr{K, a rroroMy rax Ha6op 3aqacryro oyqecrBeHHo pa3nuqaercr B p€r3HbrxMoAersx. OqeBI4AHo,tITo 3To BbI3BaHoorcyrcrBl{ela o6ulenpuutroi,t AzHaMr4r{ecrofinroero nHTeAenH SynxquoHlrpoBaHrrq pbIHKa, B cBt3rl c qeM Her r4 3aKoHoB.{HHaMr4Kr4rpanbHbrx xapaKTepl4crl4K.,.{ocrarouuo rpKr4M npuMepoM f,BJrrercr orcyrcrBr4eeAI4Horo MHeHI4flo roM, KaK Brl4qer iII4KBI4AHocrbpbrHKa Ha ero rau$oprnrarllroHHyloe$SexrHnHocrb.llonrrrrunoABecrrl npounrrfi reoperurlecxufi SyH4arraeHTrroA perxeHne3rr{xqenoro KJraccaMr{KpocrpyKTypHbrxrr,to4elefinpo6rena [ppIBenH K Bo3HHKHoBeHLIIopbIHKa.IrIx rlertrro tBJlterct 6oree AerulrrbHoeorrr4caHr4eBHyrpeHHero cocrorHr4tpbrHKa.lanHrre MoAeJIr43aqacrylo cyqecrBeHHo orJrr4r{arorcrApyl or Apyra r(aKorlpeAeneHrreMcocroqHur (rnurru r4lru HeflBHrrna),TaK H Ha6oporraorrr4cbrBarculr4xefo [apaMeTpoB.Bo vuorux MrrKpocrpyKTypHblxMoAeux pbrHKanpr4 orrr4ca:n:zraJrr4KBr4AHocrr.rI4crlon*yerct npeAno)KeHHufiA.

Kafinorr,r3noAxo.q - paccMarpr4BarborAeJrbHbre:)pbIHKa,Koropbre orrr4cbrBalornlrKBuAHocrbpbrHr{ac6onee MenKIzexapaKTepr4crr4Kupa3HbIXyrnoB 3peHl4svr rrpr4o6re4raHeHnuAaror AocraroqHo nonHyro Kaprr4Hy.lloMHeHI,ITA. Kafina, JrI{KBI4AHocrbHe sBrrercq qerrofi KoHrlenquefi, norouy r{To oxBarblBaerp{A pa3nI4rIHbIXceoficre pbrHKa,cBr3aHHbrxHepa3pbrBHoc caMr4MrrpoqeccoM ToproBnn. Onuparcb Ha npeAnoxeHHble @. Enexolao yclonvflrrvKBvrAHocrr4((cxarocrb))pbIHKa,oH BbI.qenI,Inrpu acIIeKTa(a:rr,repenun,atpu1yra) lraxer4AHocrr4:(t ightness), rny6zH y (depth) u penaKcaryuro(r esi I i ency)5.,.{nr nonHolleHHoro MoAenupoBanlzflpr4cKapbrHorrHofiluxeu4Hocrr,r Aon]r(eH6strr yqreH xax4ufi H3 srl4x acneKToBJrHKBr4AHocru.O4uaKo Ha 4aHHrrfi MoMeHTt Kyle,l.

Continuous- 1985.- Vol. 53. - Pp. l3l5auctionsandinsidertradingll Econometrica.1336.aBlack,F. Towardsa fully automatedexchange,part I ll Financial AnalvstsJournal. - 1971.- Vol.?' 7.-Pp.2e-34.C qeruo Hg6exarb ABycMblcneunocrefi 3Aecb I,rAanee npr.IBoAqrcr aHfJros3brrrHbregKBrrBitr'reHTbrTepMr,rHOB.AJrt HeKOTOpbTX((C)KarOCTb))14 rny6vHa,TOJTbKOAnt rIpaKTLIqecKI4XIlenefr IXI{pOKO r4CrrOnb3yrOTCSKoropbrM coorBercrByrcrcneAyrorqr4e H3Aep)KKr4JTHKBlaAaT\vprnopr$en{:cnp3A LI I43Aep)KKI.IBJII4tHr4fl.Ha I{eHy (market impact).

Tarxenoxasarerefr6uA-acxB Kar{ecrBe npoKcr4-Mepbl nuKBrrAHocrI4 rlpr4MeHqrorcq pa3nnqHbre rroKa3areJrr4aKTr4BHo-crlz roproBJII4 Ha pbIHKe (o6opor roproBnrl, r4HreHcr4BHocrbroproBnr4 rr Ap.).Pa:yuHrtecrparer ukr IruKBlz'Aar\r4Lr[o3BorqrorcoKparr4Tb rr3,qepx(Kr4 BrrvrflHzflHa IIeHy, oKa3blBaeMoro 3aqBKaMLI3Hatrr4TerbHoro o6rerua. Oupe4eneHlre paquoH€uIbHbIXcrparerzfivcrIoJIHeHI4f,3afBoK o6rrqHo cBf,3aHo c MaKcr4Muzaryueito)KH-Aaeuofi rIoJIe3HocrI4yr{acrHl4Ka pbIHKa or JIIIKBIIAarllz:aroproeofirro3urlt4n npr4 He-KOTOpbIXAOrIyqeHr4flX, HailprlMep, O IIeHOBOMrrpOUeCCekrrrv BpeMeHHoMfopr43oHTe.MoAera 3Toro HarIpaBneHI4t, KaK IlpaBrrJro,3aAaror gK3oreHHylo cnerlr4$nraqraro 4nrBIrLrflrlrzflHa IIeHy.

llpz3rrpyrcqefr noregnocrb,erou 3arav,a Haxo)KAeHr4r crparerr4n JrHKBvAar\uvy MaKcr4Mr,rMoxer 6rtrr[ocraBJreHa pa3nr,rr{HbrMncnoco6anar,r(uanpr.r-uep, P. Anrurpen raH. Kpucc, {x. Eepr<onuq,z 3. JIo, .{x. BaHr u,{. Beprcr4MacA. O6r.rxaera,P. {xeppoy u A. CylpauauraaH).I{e;rru sapaqv uccJIeAoB anlafl . I-{enrro zccneAoB aHkrfl flBrflerefl pa:pa6orxacnoco6a rI3MepeHLIqcrol4Mocrl,I nopr$erx,yqr4TbrBaroqero JrHKBHAHocrbpbrHKa r.ro6levrt orKpbITbIXrIo3HIlI{fi, a rarNe per(oMenqa\uit no yilpaBJreHr4rouopr$enerr,rrIpI4ero pecrpyKrypv3arJnr4(nepecrpoitrceutu nHKBr{AarIuu)n ycnoBktf,xHu:rofi nuKBT4AHOCTr,rpbrHKa nLrMLr'tVpOBaHHbIX 3aSBOK.B cooreercrBl4lr c qenbrc HccJIeAoBaHvrfl,6lr'r'u rocraBJreHbrcneAyroilIue ocHOBHbre3AIaqV:1) lponecrl4 cpaBHr.IreJIbHbIitaHa:lus cyqecrByroqr4x uo4elefi pr4cKapbrHo.IHofi nHKBrI.{HocrI4c llenb}o nrr6opa uau6olee noAxoA{rrlefi c roqru3peHl4qIIenI4I4ccneAoBaHrfl.MoAeJII4crouAnr orIeHKuJrrzKBr4Aarlr4oHHofiMocrnnoprSenr;2) pazpa6orarbsonrtfi cnoco6 orpeAeneHnrJrHKBrzAarIr4oHHofrcrouvocrnpbrHKa,onr4parorqwircsnopr$enr c yqeroM uy6uurr u penaKcarluvruapbrHorrHonrr6pannyroMoAenbpr4cKait lluxr.ugHocrn;3) zcnonb3oBarb pa:pa6oraHHrtfi cnoco6 Anq onpeAeneHnqpaquouaJrurofiuopr$eJlf, c yrreroM pa3nr4qHbrxoco6eHnocreficrparerr4r4 nr4KBr4AarlzrapbIHKa nI4Mr,rTI4pOBaHHbrXMr4KpOCTpyKTypbI3arBOK;4) nrrpa6orarb o6ulprepeKoMeHAar\vr4no yrpaBJreHr4ronoprSeneM rrpr4pecrpyKTypH3aIJLrvB ycnoButx HH3Kofrz $parMeHTupoBasHofiJrr4KBr,rAHocTrrpbrHKa.O6rercr u [peAMer lrccJreAoBaHnfl.O6rerrovr r4ccneAoBaHuflrBJrflrorcr aKrlr4rrpoccuficrux KoMIIaHLIft,4onyrueHHbrxK TopraM Ha Mocroscxofi Naex6aHxoscrofi sanrorHofi 6r,rpNe (MMBE).