Отзыв официального оппонента к.ф.-м.н. Я.Б.Казановича (Функциональная интеграция нейрональных популяций в мозге человека)

OT3BIB OOHL(HAJIbHOrO OnHOHEHTAna flHccepTauHio UJapaeea MaKCHMa FeHHaabeBHna "<I>yHKUHOHajibHaH HHTerpauHHHeiipoHajibHbix nonyjiHUHH B M03re HejioseKa", npe/tcTaBJieHHyio Ha concKaHHe yneHoiiCTCHCHH KaH/uwaTa 4)H3HKo-MaTeMaTHHecKHx nayK no cneuHajibnocTH 03.01.02 EHO(J>H3HKaMosra SBJIHIOXCJI OOTHM H3 npHopnxexHbix HanpaBJieHHH coBpeMCHHOH, nocKOJibKy, SXH nccjie^oBaHHH nosBOJunox ynyHuiHXb (J)yHKLi:HOHHpOBaHHe Mosra npnpemeHHH pasjiHHHbix saztan, oxKpbraaiox nyxH ZUIH JieneHHfl HeHpoaereHepaxHBHbix HnCHXHHCCKHX 3a6oJlCBaHHH H CTHMyjIHpyiOT pa3pa60TKy CHCXCM HCKyCCTBCHHOrO HHXejIJieKXa,cpaBHHMbix no HHTejuieKxyajibHbiM cnocoGnocxHM c BOSMOKHOCTHMH nejiOBeKa. OJIHHM H3cymecxBeHHbix npen^TCTBHH na nyTH STHX Hccjie/ioBaHHH HBJiaeTCH orpaHnneHHOCTbHCHHBaSHBHblX TCXHHHeCKHX Cpej3,CTB, C HOMOmbK) KOTOpblX MO>KHO HOJiyMaTb HH(f)OpMaUHK) Opa6oxe Mosra, a xaK^ce cjio>KHOCTb o6pa6oTKH nojiynaeMOH B 3KcnepHMenTax HH(J)opMauHH,Koxopaa, KaK npaBHiio, HMCCT 6ojibmoH oGteM H xapaKxepHsyeTCH cno)KHbiMHB3aHMOfl6HCTBHHMH MOKfly HHCJDOpMaUHOHHblMH KOMnOHCHTaMH.B HacToamee BpeMa Han6ojiee a^^eKTHBHbiMH H HHCJDOpMaTHBHbiMH cpe^CTBaMHMosra ^BjiaioTca MarHHTHaa 3Hue4)ajiorpa4)H5i (M3F),norpa4)HH (33F), no3HTpOHHO-3MHccnoHHaa TOMorpa4)HH(II3T) H (JDyHKUHOHanbHaa MarHHTHO-pesoHaHcnaa TOMorpa(J)HH.

(4>MPT). Y Ka>Kfloro HX STHXecxb CBOH ocoGeHHOCTH npHMCHeHHa H CBH3aHHbie c HHMH npeHMymecTBa HM3F HanpaBjiena Ha BbiHBjieHHe jioKanHsauHH HCTOHHHKOB noBbimeHHOHHCHpOHHOH aKTHBHOCTH. Ona npefltJIBJl^eT OHCHb BblCOKHC Tpe6oBaHHH K H3MepHTeJlbHOHannapaxype, HO no cpaBHCHHio c 33F cymecTBCHHO MCHbuie noziBep>KeHa HCKa>KeHH5iM HaBHyxpHHepennbix HeoaHOpo^HOCTHX H noKpbiBaiomHx TKaHJix, HTO cymecxBCHHO noBbimaexxoHHOcxb jiOKajiHsauHH. 33F HBJIHCXCH nanGojiee aeiueBbiM n aocxynnbix cpe^cxBOMperacxpaunn, o6jiaAaK)m,HM BWCOKHM paspemeHHCM no BpeMCHH, HO cpaBHHxejibHO c;ia6biMpaspemeHHCM no npocxpaHcxsy.

KpoMe xoro, B 33F npncyxcxByex 6ojTbinoe KOJinnecxBOapxe(J)aKXOB H inyMOB, xpeGyiomHx HexpnBHajibHbix MaxeMaxHnecKnx MCXOZIOB ^JIH H3BneneHHJinojiesHOH HH(J)opMaaHn. FI3T B nccjie^OBaxejibCKOH npaKXHKe nocxenenHO4)MPT, ocxaBjmi sa coGon cneu,HajibHyK) o6nacxb, CBH3aHHyio ccneuH(J)HHecKnx KJiexonnbix penenxopOB. ^MPT noHBHJiacb cpaBHHxejibHO He^aBHO H3HaHHxenbHO ycHjiHjia apcenaji annapaxypw no HCCJieaoBannK) Mosra. Ona ocHOBana nanapaMarHHXHbix CBOHCXBax OKcnreHnpOBanoro n aesoKcnreHHpoBaHoro reiviorjio6HHa H ^aexBO3MO>KHOCXb yBH^CXb HSMeHCHHH KpOBOXOKa B paSJIHHHblX oGltaCXHX rOJlOBHOFO MO3ra BsaBHCHMOcxH ox HX HCHpOHHOH aKXHBHOCXH. Y 4)MPT HecKOJibKo jxyHUiee paspemeHHe nonpocxpancxBy, HCM y 33F, HO cymecxBCHHO ycxynaiomee 33F paspemeHHe no BpeMeHH,nocKOJibKy npoueccbi KpOBOxoxa npoxexaiox 3HaHHxe;ibHO MeaneHHee, HeM 3JieKxpHMecKHCnpon:eccbi B Mosre.

OCHOBHOC npeHMym,ecxBo 4)MPT B Gojibmon HH(J)opMai],HOHHOHperncxpHpyeMoro CHrnajia, aocxaxoHHO a^eKBaxHO oxpa^aiomeronpoueccbi B Mosre. OflHaxo HSBJieneHHe HH(J)OpMauHH H3 (J)MPT npe^cxaBJiaex3HaMHxenbHbie MaxeMaxHHecKHe xpy^Hocxn H xpe6yex pasBHxna cnenHanbHoroMaxeMaxHHecKoro annapaxa KaK na yposne MO^ejinpOBanHH HenpoKHbix cexefi, xax Honpe,nejieHHH napaMexpoB SXHX cexeft H HX HSMCHHHBOCXH npn HSMeneHHH (f)yHKnHOHanbHoroMO3raPaccMaxpHBaeMaa pa6oxa nocBamena pemenHK) zisyx 3a^aH CBHsaHHbix c onncaHHCMMe>Kay cxpyKxypaMH Mosra. Flepsaa sa^ana nocBHmena xaK nasbmaeMOHcexH no yMOJinaHHK) (DMN - Default Mode Network), aKXHBupyiomeHcsi BCOCXOHHHH noKoa B ycjiOBHHX oxcyxcxBH^ BHeuiHHX BO3fleHCXBHH.

Bxopaa sa^ana nocEHmenaCCXH, aKXHBHpyiouj,eHCH B OXBCX na spHxejibHbin cxHMyji. O6e 3a#aHH HMCIOX 6ojibmoenoHHMaHHH pa6oxbi Mosra. Cexb DMN aaex 6asy ^JIH paccMoxpeHHHHacxynaiomiix B pa6oxe Mosra npn ero cxHMyjiHHHH. CHCxeivia spnxenbHoroo6teKxoM MHoroHHCJieHHbix HCCJieflOBaHHH, HO £0 nacxoamero BpeMeHHcxpyKxyp Mosra npn spHxejibHOH cxHMyjiHUHH ocxaexca ziHCKyccHOHHOH.B Hacxoamee BpeMfl HMCCXCH o6niHpHbiH MaxeMaxHHecKHH annapax,o6pa6oxKH ^annbix o HCHPOHHOH aKXHBHocxn. HanGojiee nacxo HcnojibsyioxcHHHCXpyMCHXbi cneKxpajibHoro anajiHsa, KoppejianiiOHHoro aHajiH3a, BeHBJiex-npeo6pa30BaHHa Hx.fl. B CBflSH co cneH,H(])HKOH cxoflmHx 3a^aH B KanecxBe MaxeMaxHHecKoro annapaxaflHccepxanxoM Hcnojib3OBanbi ase nepcneKXHBHbie XCXHHKH: xpaHC(J)epHas[ 3Hxponnji (T3) HOTHaMHHecKoe KaysajibHoe MOzte^HpOBaHHe (/],KM).

B OXJIUHHC ox apyrnx MCXO^OB T3 H RKMn03BOJIHK)XOLlCHHXbH6CXaXHCXHHCCKHe3aBHCHMOCXHMOK^ypa3JlHHHbIMHCXpyKXypaMHMosra, HO BbiHBHXb peajibHbie B3aHMO^,eHCXBHH MOK^y 3XHMH cxpyKxypaMH. HpeHMymecxBo T3saKJHO^aexca B XOM, HXO ona nosBOJiaex ycxaHOBHXb CBHSH Me>K^y cxpyxxypaMH Mosra 6e3KaKOH-jiH6o npe^BapHxejibHOH HHCJDOpMauiiH o 4)yHKyHOHHPOBaHHH JioKameM B OCHOBCHCHpOHHOHCCXH.BeeBblBO^blMO>KHOC^CJiaXbHaOCHOB6JIHUIbHH(f)OpMaUHOHHbIXxapaKxepncxHK npoxcKaiomnx npoueccoB. FIpH HcnojibsoBaHHH ^KM ^ejiaroxca onpe^eneHHbienpe/inoJiO)KeHHJi icax o caMOH HeHpoHHon cexn, xax H o npeo6pa3OBaHHH ee aKXHBHOCXH BC MaxeMaxHHecKOH XOHKH speHHH ffKM CBO^HXCH K onpeflejiennio napaMexpOB cHcxeMbiZiH(|)4)epeHn,HajibHbix ypaBHeHHH.

OcnoBHbiMH HS SXHX napaMexpOB HBJIHRDXCH K03(J)4)HnHeHXbiB3aHMo^eHcxBH«, onpc^ejiHiomHe KaK cHJiy BHemneH cxHMyjiaijHH HCHPOHHOH cexn, xaK H cHjiyBOSzteHCXBua OZIHHX HeftpOHHbix cxpyKxyp Ha apyrne. Mexoa /JKM 6bui pa3pa6oxan KapJiOMOpncxoHOM H ero coxpy^HHKaMH OKOJIO 15 jiex nasaa H c xex nop nocxoHHHOycoBepuiencxByexcH. B Hacxonmee BpeMH HMeexcH naKex nporpaMM /^KM, HaxozunuHHCH BoxKpbixoM ziocxyne. B ocnoBe /],KM JIC^HX GanecoBCKHH nonxoR K OHCHKC napaMexpOBZtHHaMHHecKOH CHcxeMbi.

CorjiacHo sxoMy no^xofly oueHKa napaMexpOB BbinonHHexcH nyxeMMaKCHMH3aHHH anOCXCpHOpHOH BCpOHXHOCXH 3HaH6HHH HapaMCXpOB npHyCJIOBHH ^aHHblX,nojiyneHHbix B SKcnepHMenxe. BbiJio noKasano, HXO npn onpe^ejienHbix orpaHHHCHHHX naanpnopHbie H anocxepnopHbie BepoaxnocxH (npezinono^eHHe rayccoBOCXH cooxBexcxByiomHXpacnpe^ejieHHH) MOHCHO Bbinncaxb JiBHbie 4)opMyjibi JUJIH anocxepHopnoH BepoaxnocxH.

B CHJiyHeJIMHCHHOCXH HCXO^HOH ^HHaMHMeCKOH CHCXCMbl MaKCHMH3aUHH BbinOJIHHeXCH HXepaUHOHHOnyxeM nocxeneHHOro yxoHHCHHH cpe^HHX H ^HcnepCHii HZteHxncJDHHHpyeMbix napaMexpOB.PeiueHHe nocxafijieHHbix 3a^;an noxpe6oBajio ox asxopa KaK BbinojiHHXb c6op3KcnepHMeHxanbHbix ^.aHHbix, xaK n npoH3BecxH HX MaxeMaxHHecKyio o6pa6oxKy c uejibK)onpeaeiieHHa snaHHMbix napaMexpOB H npHHaxna pemeHHH o pe^HMax neHpocexeBoroBsaHMo^eHCXBHa. 3KcnepHMeHxajibHbie aannbie ^JIH nepBOH 3aaaHH 6biJiH nonyneHbi cnoMonj,bK) (J)MPT, a HX o6pa6oxKa npOH3BO^HJiacb KaK c noMombio Mexo^a T3, xaK H cnoMombK) /],KM.

3xo ^ano BO3MO)KHOCXb Hcc^e^OBaxb cncxeiviy CBHSCH B cexn DMN c zjByxcxopon: 6es anpHopnbix npe^nojio>KeHHH o cncxeivie H c HeKoxopbiMH 6HOJiorHnecKHonpaB^aHHbiMH npe^nojio}KeHHHMn. 3KcnepnMeHxajibHbie ^aHHbie AM BxopOH 3a^anH 6biJiHnojiyneHbi c noMouibio 33F. 3^ecb ne CXOJLJI sonpoc o cxpyKxype HCHPOHHOH cexn, Koxopaa6bma panee ycxaHOBJiena. TpeGoBanocb Jinuib npoBepHXb KOHKpexHbie rnnoxesbi o HanHHHHHJIH OXCyXCXBHH X6X HJIH HHblX CBH36H B pa3JlHHHbIX pOKHMaX CXHMyjlJIU,HH.flHCcepxaitHOHHaa pa6oxa HMeex cjieayiomyio opraHHsannio.

Fjiasa 1 HBJIHCXCHoGsopHOH. B HCH npeacxasjieHbi HeoGxo^HMbie oGuine CBeaeHHH o npoue^ypax nojiyneHHaflaHHbix H HX o6pa6oxKH. Fjiasa 2 nocBHineHa onncaHHio MCXO^OB HCCJieaosanHJi: Bbi6opo6teKXOB HCCjie^OBaHHH, nojiyneHHe H npe^o6pa6oxKa 3KcnepHMeHxajibHbix ^annbix,oco6eHHOCXH anajiHaa aannbix MexoaaMH T3 H ^KM. Fjiasa 3 nocBamena onHcaHHK) Ho6cy>K,zieHHK) nojiynenHbix pesyjibxaxoB.

B 3aKJiiOHeHHH pesioMHpyioxca nocxanoBKa 3a^,aH,Bbi6op MexoaoB HCCJie^oBaHna H no^nepKHBaexca snaHHMOcxb nojiyneHHbix pesyjibxaxos. BOcHOBHbie pesyjibxaxbi H BbiBo^bi KpaxKo ccj)opMyjTHpOBaHbiiHOcaLanecH na sauinxy.K paccMoxpeHHK) ^Hccepxaunn noFjiaea 1. B Cannon rjiase npuBO^HTca o6mHe CBe^eHHH o BsaHMO^eHcxBHH oGjiacxeiiM03ra, CBflsaHHbie c nocxaBjieHHbiMH sa^anaMH.

Onucbmaioxca anaxoMHH H npHHininbi4>yHKiiHOHHpOBaHHH o6jiacxeH Mosra ynacxByiomHX B DMN H B spuxejibHOM BOCHPHHXHHnpOCXblXCXHMyjTOB.PaCCMaXpHBaiOXCfl(J)H3HHeCKHeOCHOBbI(J)yHKU,HOHHpOBaHHfl33F H4)MPT, MCXO^HKH perncxpaiiHH aaHHbix, BOSMOKHOCXH HX MaxeMaxHnecKoro npe^cxaBJieHHs, axaK)Ke (J>aKxopbi, npHBOflflmHe K HCKa>i<eHHK) perncxpnpyeMbix ^biHHbix. OnHCbmaioxcHxeopexHHecKHe OCHOBBI MCXOAOB T3 H RKM, HX ^ocxoHHcxsa, ne^ocxaxKH H orpaHHHCHHfl.Fjiaea 2.

B Cannon rjiaBe nocjie^oBaxejibHO paccMaxpHBaexca MexoaojiorHH pemeHHH,HByx cc{)opMyjiHpOBaHHbix Bbime sa^an. RJVL HCCJie^oBaHHH cexen DMN npHBjieKajiocb OKOJIOXpCX 46CHXKOB HCnblXyCMblX. OpHHHMaJlHCb 3ailI,HXHbie MCpbl, HX06bI HCKJIFOHHXb apX6(|)aKXbI,CB5i3aHHbie c HenpaBHJibHbiM BbinojiHeHHCM HcnbixyeMbiMH ycjiOBHH 3KcnepHMCHxa. HoHcnbixyeMOMy coGHpancsi ^ocxaxoHHo Go^biuoH o6i>QM 3KcnepHivieHxajibHbix ^aHHbio6ecnenHXb BbicoKyro Ha^e>KHOcxb BbiBo/ioB.HocKOJibKy AaHHbie c|)MPT coAep>Kax B ce6e npocxpaHcxBCHHbie M BpeivieHHbie HCKa>KeHHa,CBfl3aHHbie C XCMH HJ1H HHblMH OXKJ10H6HMHMH OX H^eaJlbMblX yCJIOBHH 3KCnepHM6HXa, 6bIJlHnpHHHXbl Mepbl no (JDHJlbXpaUHH 3KCnepHM6HXaJlbHbIX 4aHHblX C yHCXOM HX KaHCCXBa. OxflCJlbHOHnpo6^eMOH HBjiaexca ziBH>KeHHe rojiOBbi, Koxopoe MO^ex npHBecxH K c^BHry BOKcejieK H cpesosxoMorpaMMbi.

J\m pemeHHa SXOH npo6jieivibi npHMCHaexcfl npoue^ypa BHpxyanbHOHnojio^ceHHH Mosra KaK reoMexpHHecKH HeH3MeH«eMOH (^nrypbi. Cneuna^bHbie Mepw6bijiH npHHJixbi npoxHB HeroMoreHHOCXH cxaxHMHoro M BO36y>K/i,aK)mero nojiefi xoMorpac})a, a xaK>KenpoxMB HH^HBHAyajibHbix pasjiHHMH Mosra H pacnojio>KeHMa Mcc.ieAyeivibix oGjiacxen y pasHbixHcnbixyeMbix. Ba>KHbiM cpe^cxBOM nosbiCHXb cooxHOiueHHe CMrHaji/iuyM aBJiaexca nacxoxHaa HnpocxpaHCXBCHHaa (J)HJibxpauHa CHraajiOB.

Flpe/],o6pa6oxKa ^aHHbix 6biJia BbinojiHCHa c noMombK)nporpaMMHOro naKexa SPM12, paspaGoxaHHoro B JiaGopaxopHH Opncxona.OyHKUHOHajibHbie CBSSH B CCXH DMN H3Becxnbi: 3x0 Me^HajibHafl npec^pOHxanbHajj KopamPFC, sa^HSiH nacxb noacHOM H3BHjiHHbi PCC, jiesaa LIPC H npasaa RIPC o6jiacxHHH>KHexeMeHHOH Kopbi, a xaK^e JieBaa LHIP H npasaa RHIP naparnnnoKaMnaJibHbie H3BHJiHHbi[59].

Cexb, BKHfonaiomaa mPFC, PCC, LIPC H RIPC, Koxopaa paccMaxpnBaexca KaK 6a30Baa, y>KeHCCJieAOBajiacb panee, HO BK^KDHCHHe B paccMoxpeHne rnnnoKaMnajibHbix o6jiacxefi AJIH OUCHKH3(J)(J)eKXHBHbix CBflsen 6biJio npoH3Be/i,eHO Bnepsue. J[j\n yMCHbiiieHHa pasMepHOCXH ox Ka>K/],OHo6nacxH HcnojibsoBajiHCb rnaBHbie KOMnonenxbi, nojiyHCHHbie npn pa3Jio>KeHHH 4>MPT ^aHHbix oxBCCX BOKcejieH o6;iacxH, Koxopaa onncbiBajiacb KaK cc})epa He6ojibiuoro pa^Hyca c uenxpoM,pacnojio>KeHHOM B ueHxpe cooxBexcxByKDmeH o6/iacxM.T3 paccHHXbiBanacb ztJia BCCX BOSMOKHWX CBH36H CHanana AJIH nexbipex o6nacxeH, anoxoM fljia Bcex LUCCXH. TJjia nposepKH cxaGnjibHocxH 3HaneHHH T3 sxapaccHHXbiBanacb nesaBHCHMO ana nepsoH H BXopoH nonoBHHbi cKanoB <J)MPT.^aHHbie xaK)Ke cpaBHHBajiHCb c cypporaxnbiMH aaHHbiMH, npe^cxaBjiHiomHMHBHHepoBCKHe npoueccbi.fljlHHaXOKACHHH3(J)^eKXHBHbIXCBH3CHMCXO^OM^KMCHaHajia6bIJlHc(J)opMyjiHpoBaHbi GnojiorHHecKH onpaB^aHHbie rnnoxesbi oxnocHxejibHO CBHSCHnexbipbMa OCHOBHWMH o6jiacx^MH, Bcero 8 apxHxeKxyp CBH36H.