Отзыв официального оппонента Б. М. Проскурина (Английский исповедально-философский роман 1980-2000 гг), страница 2

((HeHaAex(HoropaccKa3qHKa).BonpoluaeMoarb )I(e'rro MHeHHro r4ccneAoBareJrfl,coeAI4HeHHafle npeAenbHofi o6naxeHHocrbto Ayurl4rlpl4cyrcrBufl (3KcnnI4IIHpoBaHHoro I4JII4repof,, AHKTy61TTaKXe o6x:arelrHocrbrloAreKcroBoro) KoHSHAeHTaqa,ue npogcxoA.[{T- r4MriJrr4rlt{poBaHHoro,II4pI4r{HocTbPI(a4pecara) ucnone4u, r{To IIpI4AaeT IIoBecTBoBaHHIooco6UeX''{epprAa'B erofi qaeTvI BBeAeHI4flBcneA 3a M'Eaxruurrrrl'rryat"ort".BCrKofirr4rrrer o5 aN,r6usaJreHrHocrr4ll.AxcenrMoM, ll.Epyxcovr o.A.fxynafinoUCnOBeAyIouIefoa{Iepof lr3peHr4flOTKpbrTocTI4/HeOTKpbITOCTI4c TOr{Kr4LlCnOBeAr,lrITO tBJIflerCq ocO6eHHO IIOKa3aTeiIbHbIM AntBO3MOXHOCTI4((HenOnnOfi [paBAbI))'IIepI4oAa B Asrunu' B erour4crloBeAanbHo-Ounoco$cKoro poMaHa yKa3aHHoroHpa3Aene o6oSHa.{aloTct BoceMb ocHoBHbIX npO6neMHo-TeMaTI4r{eOKI4X44)'(crtl' crp' 43crpyKrypHo-no3rl4r{ecKux KpI4repHeB BbIAeTIeHI'It Naupar{acTI'I BBeAeHHfl c1lpaBeAnllBo IIocBqrU€HCavufi pa3BepHyTblfi noApa3Aen 3rofiHaqI4HaeT cHCTOpT4HXaHpa HcrroBeAr4, OTCr{eT KOTOpOfi o.A.fxyMafrnoElaNesHoro Anrycrraua (u 4axe paHbuc cesexu z Mapxa Anpenrar)'TOT QaXr' UrOCTaHOBHTCflKOHeUUO,COBepIXeHHOIIpaBI4JIbHbIM,Ha HaIII B3rJIflA,aBTOp.{enaeT Ha TOM6olruruff aKrIeHT B 3TOfi qacTT KOHIIe[TyaJIbHO|OBBeAeHpItc poMaHTuKoB u PycCo'oTpe3Ke BeKTopa pa3BvITVfl,XaHpa, rOropufi Har{IIHaeTCqTOfipa3BI'ITI4I4[pI,IHIII,InI4aJIbHocrII'ITaeTnoBopoTHbiM nyHKToM BO.A.[xyMafino(r.e.

pouaHaM coBpeMeHHbIXJrrrHavrx(aHpa,KoTopar 6lr.rNe Boefo K ee Marepwanyyrx tIkIauTelefi), <3anucru I43 rIoAIIoJIbt)) @'M'[ocTOeBcKofo' PasAeI'aHI-JII4ficKI4cIIoBeAI4 KaKoSpauleHnrtfi K fiocroencKoMy vr ero ponl4 B cTaHoBIeHui469), KaXeTc{ oAHUM vr3 caMbIXoK3r,rcTeHlll4anbHoro Bo1polxaHufl (c.51vrB 3Toil !{aertr pa6orbr. 3Aecr oqeHb MHoro |ny6oKHXBrerrarrfrourzxoIIbITa npoxI4BaHIUr4HTepecHbrx pa3Mbrrxneuuit o cyTH 3K3pICTeHIII4anbHofoctrleprefi, o AuaneKTI'IKeIIcr4XoJIofI4rIecKofi TpaBMbI V 6olt't, noTepb vlHaqaJI' openI,IrI4O3Hofo V cBeTCKOro, rICl{XoJIorI4r{ecKOro 14 SulocoSCKOrOcpeACTB, pa3pa6OTaHHbIX .{oCrOeecxnna V HaBcerAaCneqrasure IIO3THT{9CKI,IXgTaliap{crIoBeAI43aAonfo Ao nocTMoAepHI4CTCKOfOBOIXeAIXUXB [paKTI4Ky XaHpacaMopeQneKQvlr'ABofiHI4r{ecTBo, nefiTMoTuBHocTb' MoAenuefo pA3BkI"rvto6pas l4cnoBeAyroqerocfl aHTu-repofl' v rrp'paHee HecoDIacI4IOIIOBnaecre Q TeM, Cpa3y )Ke AO6aBJIIOK BbICKa3aHHOMy(aBTo)6norpaQl{3Ma erqe oAHonoBoAy Heo6t3aTeJIbHocTI'IAnt poMaHa-uctloBeAg3aMeqaHue.pflAy rex, Kro cKa3aJI cyulecrBeHHoeB BbrcrpoeHHoM o.A.fNyMafinocTvI' cTpaHHbIM O6pasovtcJroBo B MOAenr4poBaHr4HCOBpeMeHHOfiI4CnOBeAanbHonpofpaMMHblfi poMaH KOTOpOfo oKa3aJIoTcyTcTByeT vrwfl.

,{X.cOnraHAXepa,repo{ BO BTopofiMorUHoe Bo3AeficTBI4e Ha o6paaultr<u I4cIIOB9AI{ MOJIOAOTOBO P)KI'I))HCXX S. xtAII, I{TO 3TO VMfl V POMAH <HAA IPOIACTbIOIIOJIOBI4HE06 H3yOTH9CTUKaKBcrrrrbrBaloTAaXe TorAa, KorAa aBTop AI4ccepTaIlHI4 rIHlxeTB coBpeMeHHoM I4cnoBeAaJIbHoMpOMaHe' AQopue n: Ip?[JaI\uI4IIoBecTBOBaHI4typoKl4 TeX III4CaTeJIefr'KTOMexAy TeM COBepixeHHoor{eBr4AHbIC3JII{HAXepoBcKI4e3vtt'tc' rlbe((naIIaHoB)): pa11uir MaprznCo3AaBaJI, Hanpl4Mep, I4crIoBeAI4K ToMy' tIToTBoprIeaTBoIro xoay-pa6oTbl c[paBeAJIHBo oTHeceHo O'A'fNyMafino'lad-fiction'(<naqaHcraxHa3blBaloraHrJrofl3brrrHbre r.rcropr4Kn nllreparypblpaBHO KaK I'I Henl4TepaTypD), Tf,roTeeT ZMSHHOK 3ToMy Tnny IIoBeCTBoBaHVf,I43BecrHblfi co3AareJlbynoMrHy;brfi, ilo-MoeMy, Hr{ pa3y B pa6ore eure .AHHnpl4ropoAa))' (EJII43ocrb))raKoro pola IlcnoBeAeir Xaun$ Kypefrul'r (<EyAAa H3r{TO B3pOCnbIr TIeJIOBeK' yxerrocJle trH,,ri4poMaH BOO6U{enrc6onblTeH TeM'noApocTKono <py6HT c IIJIeqa))'o6peruenessrtfr AB)Mfl AeTrMI'I' TeM He MeHee14 HeyAarluOfi' rarc OH noJlaraeT'r4crroBeAailbHo rloABOA{ lITOrll ceoefi npourlofinpI43HaTb3acnyfyHSO6XOAI4MOxr43HH Vr rrbrTafl3b HairTLrce6fl 3aHoeo).

KoHeqHo,-uccneAoBaTel,fl,IIplIBJIeKIUe|oKa]Han]E{3yTpI4AIIaTbBoceMbpoMaHoBBOObMI.IpoMaHI4cToB o6ulefi KaprI4HbI Herr,rcaTeJleft, a uoroMy nponycK oAHoro-AByXMeHqeT.oAUaXOl4cT0pl',IKo-nl',lreparyp1afl'cnpaBeAnI4BOCTbBexlbBecbMaBaxHaq, a B KaKHX-TOMOMeHTaXI4 HeO6XOE]/lMAfl"pa6oryv MeTOAOnOft{rIecKI4 HanpaBnqlouleu BCIOflpuuuunvanb:Hoir,(I4cnoBeAanbHocTb H nOCTMOAepHll3M)rrepBafl fraBa ATICCepTaIIUUaTaHoBr4TCf,6necrxrqylo 3pyAHuI4Ior4 ee ruecrb rroArJraB,rAe aBTop He ronbKo AeMoHcrpl4pyer(nnevaufleT cIII{coKB O6nacTV TeopVvI, UeTop14714 npaKTHKI4II9CTMOAgpHI43MaUI4rI4pyeMbIX V[oaTMoAepHI43My, oOBoeHHbIX vI o6ullsorpyAoB IIoHo v y6e4HrenrFlo aHann3llpyer BKoMMeHrr,rpyeMbIX HccneAoBaTenbHnqefi),M'3uuca'K'I4cvrfypo'fp'Cnn$ra,KoHrIenryaJIbHoM aclleKre p{A npou3BeAeHl4fir{To BI4CXOAflnpexAe Boefo H3 IIOCbIJIKI4'[N.Bapnca, ,{.Tou aaa, vI.MaKbIO3Ha,qTeHI4q)) poMaHax (<Bo4oeeMbe)), <3anucrnr436paHHbrx Anr ((rrpHcTanbHofo(Dno6epu' <<Eelblfipefi.ren) H (EepeMeHHafl BAOBa)),<Be:yreurHble)), dlonyraftIIoAHI4MaIoTCflABe' rlo CyTI4'OTeJrb)),<IrICxynleHI4e)) u (UeMeHTHbIfi aaAHK)))TpaBMbI VpoMaHa-llcnoBeAl4 IIepHoAa[poSneMbrrleHTpanbHbtx(upraruuaxlnenpwunux) fpyzozo.

CrsosHaq vtreflrroHHMaHus,lueuoiuMaHr4.sBOCnpoI{3BeAeHI4faBTOpaMI4OIIbiTa eTpal.aHvrfl'ataJrv3apoMaHoB - OCO6eHHOCTI4peKoHoTpyl4pyeMofo caMI4MH efo npoxr4BaHr{r feporMr4 (HepeAKOKaK 5_U AaNe[IKaK y cezsra B (BoAo3eMbe))' unl4 Boo6paxaeMofofepoeM-noBecTBOBaTeJreM,B <I4cxynlenrarz>)'TaKUMO6pa:ou ((ocroxeTuBaeMofor, *u* y Maxtro3HaB KaxAoM v3 noApa3AenoBI4ueuso B 3roM paKypce o.A.fNyMafinoc TorIKI4 3peHl4sHeKOTOpbIenpoMexyTotlHble' Ho BecbMa BaxHbIeITOABOAI4T9AI4HCTBa V tIO3TZr{eCKOrO CBOeO5pa3I4flAHHaMI4KI4 I4AefiHO-TeMaTHr{eCKOrONanponblx MoAl4sraxaurafirrpeAeTaBJreHHbrxB TBopr{ecKoft [paKTHKe IIi4CaTeJIefiIJIAB I4 IIOAIJIABI{TO 3TOTNPLIHUI4TIrIOETPOCHI,IflI4TOII,I.CPA.Y CKAXTEM,I{CTIOBEAI,I,qacrfix pa6oru' B erofi rJIaBeco6nroAaercq Bo BOeX OCTaJIbHbIXAHCCepTaur4r4MeCTa: pa3MbIIIIneHVfl', OecTb, Ha Haru B3rJr{A, OCO6eHHO ttHTepecHble(c na3efiKofi> (no M.Eaxrnny) t't <yurtlrtxABoftHr4rrecrBeKaK r{cnoBeAaJrbHocrr4I'Iclrrypo' Iaccax B pa3AenenuO."Ur"X)) (c.86 AHccepraIII4u) e <Be:yreluHbix))o-no6epa>) !I 3CCe <o no'IToBOft1.2 o nepeKnnr{Ke poMaHa Eapnca <llonyrafi- 100).

B pa:4ene 1'3 oqeur .lrro6onrtrHbl 14 IIoor*p"rtn.> x.Aeppttu(c.98MeIBI'IJIJIa H pOMaHOMTBopr{eCTeoNaHaCTOsUIeMy3BpI4cTl{tIHbInapaJlnenn MeXAyStudies); He MeHee [pI{BneKaTeJIbHbIpa3Mbllxneuktfl',{.Torraaca(u acnerte Trauma(a oco6eHHocrllo Bropofi qaervl <tr4cxylle HVfl>>Maxlroeuao.A.fNyMafrnorepoeB pOMaHa C HacToqIqUM' A3III43oAe) rar oIIbITe gTOJIKHSBeHv1fl'ATOHKSpCKOMqaeryr, HaclrJrqeM 14 3JI9M (eofinofi); paBHo KaK I4He MHr4MbrM,KaK n neprofiaBTopa (poMaHa Ba*arrv33Tofi qaarv [por{3BeA eHufl.KaK orrblTa nepeBonnouleH}It- 126 AHacepraUl4u)' He n'torypoMaHe)) Epafronr,r B crpaAaroxlero ,\pyzozo (c.125[pt{ pa3foBope o <<3anucxaxHe oTMeTr{Tb fny6oKr{e }r AoKa3aTeJIbHbIeaJIJIIO3HI4HenuuHocTI'I)) (rar HeKa'flPefi.Ien) M.Srrauca K V.Enefixy u ero <fIecHqM((HeBHHHOCTI'I))paccKa3rlnKa B poMaHe)'r4poHr4qecKar napannenb aBTOpa KasuHcTHKe cepbe3Hblfi pa:rorop OOrrraeuy TaK)I(e oAHH H3 nepBblx B HaIIIefiCIOXeTHo-TeMaTHrIecKoropo*uta (I-leMeHTnrtff caAI4K) MaKblO3Ha Ha OcHoBe[po6neMbl Tparur{ecKoro yAena B3K3r,rcTeHIIuaJII4cTcKoroKoHTpanyHKTa uMeus raKxe y6eAI4IIvI recvrrya\W cryllleHofr o6rtAessocrl4 (c.140 I4 Aanee)'C annlo3Hefi K Kauro u efoMecTa B 3TOM pa3Aene, KOTOpbIe cBs3aHbIa6cypAe 6sttun, KoTopoe'(flocTopoHHeMy)), 14 aKII9HT Ha 3K3I4ST9HIII4aJIbH9M(<:aqeueHTI4pOBaHHOM))rroAaeTcf, B HapoqI4TO KOHA9HCUpOBaHHOM6urue,HOCIIeAOBaTeJIbcKOe nHoHepcTBOTaKXeorlrevyBeTIIHOM o6lr,rre.(n uuen B BI{Ay HeoHa, BeporrHo, repBofi B Halxefi HayKeo.A.[NyMafino:vt pflA crarefi) o6paruJlacb K poMaHyToJrbKoAI4ccepraIIUp, Ho V ee MoHorpa$vwBHHMaHvreHa IIOBbIIIIeHHyIO(BM.Svrr,rca (SepeMeHHat BAoBa>, o6parnB oco6oenurepreKcTyanbHocTb'cr4ny I436paHHoro aBTopoM T:zrra repoq-pacaKa3r{HKa)v)aJrJrro3r4t{v napannenl4 C Ll[excnl4poM' Jloypeucotnl3Aecr y6e4nrelrHHr{To Al4ccepraHT cneqnanbHo nl4luer Lr oKoHerrH;, Ha6oKosrtN,I.

Baxuo,Ant efo TBOpr{ecTBa'3UHCa - {BJIeHI4I4CKBO3HOMOaMOIII'ITI4pOBaHZI4Hepa6oTbl, BCe xe HeJIb3',UKar 6rr BbrcoKo Mbr HH OIIeHI4BanI43Ty rnaByHa[pI4Mep' He cOBceM yAar{HbIMCAeJIaTbHeKOTopbIe 3aMerIaHI'Ifl K Hefi. Tax,<BoAoseMbe))' KorAa aHaIIIl3Ka)r(eTct HarIaIo pa3roBopa o poMaHe fp.CnuSrace1q eABa Irur He Bce npl4Merblo6pa^:a repofl-pa;cKa3qr4Ka, esuparoulero BHe Cpa3y' a KaK-TO[O6OqHO'BAHlLl^,BO3HI4KaeTB STOMIIOBeCTBOr4CIIOBe.[aJIrHOcTI4IIoHfTHo 3BytIHT pa3roBop oB acrreKTe TeMbr AtrCcepTaUUI4 He coBceMXoltou'c (oenl4KcoMllapannenrCeu$ra.rraJrr4MrrceaHocrr4 poMaH;rro6o[blTHa, Ho Bce xe c TOqKH 3peHHq cIIeTeHI4qpaAHKanOM) fx.3nHornl4pnrlecKofo fopa3Ao yMecTHeeI[IrIHOfO Vt C()IIHaJIbHO|O, 3tll4r{ecKofo vra To 14K <MuAAltt'tapqy))cMoTpenucb 6bI 3Aecb anJIIo3I{I4x <Caftlacy MapHepy)),VIA7V'HpaBcTBeHHOfO(ero <nra4fefiToBgKOfi> .racTu), e ocoSeHHOCTI4B acIIeKTeqI{CJIe H ((HaKa3aHHtr)) Korna-To CoBepIUeHHbIXAonfa lI 11ogneAcTBVi4 (e rort'r88 aBrop IIHrHpyer81rrocTyrrKoB 14 IIpI,IHtrbIX pelueHllfi.

Ha crp'OAHO3HaTIHOKaasyo Irlcurypo 1998 r.' KOTOpbIe,Ha HalII B3rJItA'BbraKa3brBaHprfl.6onee cnoxHoft' r{eM IIpocTocBuAeTeJIbcTByIoT o TgfoTeHI{H tlucaTeJlf, KHa[ocTpoeHwfl' IIpOVI3BeAeHI',ItnocTMoAepHHCTCKafl,fIo3TI'IKe' T.e. K [paBI4naMIIO3AHCCB (OCTATKEAH{))HEKOfrCB'3HOCTI4'I{TO OH H TIPOAEMOHCTPT4PYETOCHOBEI7:1^ CTOI4T TpaKTOBaTb efosPqlfoBopt,<EeeyreurHbrx)). vla'aevIVBHeKOTOpbIXApyfI',IX aBTOpoB'BOIXeAIXI'.Ierrpon3BeAeHvr'^)a TaKXe npol'I3BeAe]H:/lfl.r{ToqI4cTO IIoCTMOAepHucTcKI4e'AyMaeTcf,'Kpyr I4HTepeaoB Ai4CcepTaHTKI4,KaKcTpoflTct B ToM tII4cIe 'I HaXapaKTepbl nepcoH an<efi.aHanV3VpyeMbIXpoMaHoBKaxocHoBe'peangaTl4Ko-ncl4xonof6r{egKofiHaIIuoHaJIbHofi6orarofraHrnl4ficKoit tmteparypbl HanpeAcTaB IIfleTQ'-,oAHofi I43 oco6eHHocTefr I4cTopHI'It{Ocepa Ao HaIIII4XAHefi peanvcTrqecKat cocTaBJL[rcXIatBCeMee npoTfl)Keil]|iVrOTHe flpepblBanacb' Bor fioqeMynr4TepaTypHofo rrpoqecca He pa3MbIBaJIaCbv3aBepueHl4e I4HTepecHefiuII4XKaxeTcr He BCerAa onpaBeAnuBblM O6ssarejllHoeKaK 3aKJIVHaHue Qpa:oit,aHalwrrv',ecKr4x naccax(efi o poMaHax floBTopfleMofinl4caTenfl: (B 3ToMyMan{rcIqefi HepeAKo 6oraTcrBo xyAo)KecrBeHHoft [anI'ITpbIpoMaHe...)) Mexay flpor{HM, ecJII4 6rl snocTMoAepHr{aTcKOMr,rQrroBeAanbHoMr{acTl4 <I4cxynne]Hvrfl>>'TO aBTOpyrJraBe cocTofJrcfl pa3roBop o nepBofiOrOeopxofi nucarr o6 oAHOSHa'{HOfinpr4ano., 6u c I43BecTHOfiAr4ocepTaur4r4eecJlyqae' yBI',IAeTbIIenoM' wtu' BO BCTKOMBpoMaHa3TOfor4cnoBeAaJrbHocTr4HeKoTopbIMI4 ApyfI4MI4 xaHpoBbIMI4cno3Tl4r{ecKoe cocyuIecTBOBaHI4er{To oAsoft He Ao KoHua perueuuofi npo6nertalapaAI{rMaMI'I' Kcrarra orMeqy'pa3B^eAeHI4epoMaHacTaHoBI4TC{xaHpa sznocosoKo-I{cIoBeAanbHofoAr,rHaMr,rKlr(uttvt,rrao6opor,.".l."".)Hcuone4efic(fl)-paccKa3ql4KoMvII4clloBeAeu,OTTperbefo JII4Ua'Opf aHI43OBaHHbIXIIoBecTBOBaTeJIbHOHe MeHee I4HTepecHoit' u KoHIIenTyaJIbHoI4;I-.lrasa BTOpafl npeAcTaBJlf,eTcfltro [opsAKy'q aBTopoM Al4ccepTarpvr, fl aAeJIaJI6rt ee nepnofi6onee Toro, 6ygrn o c K o r l b K y o H a , K a K A y M a e r c t ' B c e M c B o I 4 M n a s o c o v - - : : :'{acrefit:::HaIloc r o f H H oecJIHpa6or':qreHl4fl IIpeAbIAyUItzxBpeMtBoBonpocBo3H'rKaroulr4frHar{aJIaB a]Flarvr3vpyeMblxpoMaHaxQrairocoscKo-ucfloBeAanbHoroAoMr4HaHTaMnHpaBcTBeHHaqTpaBMbI,yKa3aHHofonepl4oAacTaHoB{TcflIlc}IxoJlofuqecKafl]r{eIIoBeKa' To oTKyAa oHI4 6epyrcr? Bropaa rJIaBa6olr, cTpaAaHl4flcoBpeMeHHoronflTbIOoTBeT Ha 3TOT BOIIpOo BceMI4uAoKa3aTeJlrgrtfipa:eepuy$rirAaeTpa3*et!l??-:^?:?,,YB 3roM orHotueHv."Ho oco6esHoIIoKa3areIIbHbIpa3AenaMr{,pa3AeJI, nocB'IIIeHHbII.HaAo Ha3BaTb2.5.

Hecolrlrrerrgofi YAaqefr I4ccJIeAoBaTeJIflTotIHbIM u T.HKI4M<Ocrarox AHs)), c efo or{eHbaHaJrH3y po*u"u i"^rypoa H a J I I 4 3 o M < < a u m u f i c K o c T l 4 D : l I l { 3 M e H ' I o U I I 4 M I 4 c ' O T e I I e H I { e M3HaM.HI4TOI4"p:T::i.-::'paaltblruJreH'I{ o xapaKTepe3HaqeHue*.14.M'ICJTOM,COAepxaHHeMI4C[IOBeAI4 KaK HenpeMeHHOIOcAepxaHHOCTl4 B KOHTeKcTeasmufictcofic a M o p a c K p b l T l 4 f f I { e J I o B e K a I I o X o A y B c e f o p a 3 | : n a , g o o c o 6 e H H o oKa3blBaercffBero$uuale,nnoAorBOpHbIM23pa:4eleBneo6rF{airHo y6e4urenbHbr.o6o5uleHl4f, (review' SUrvey)' KorAa',ras6pannaf, crpyKrypa HeKoefo npoon.*"oroHaIIpuMep'pa3MbIIIIIIeHvIfl,o[oKoIeHI{ecKoMKpI43Hcev]IcTbIAe3acTpaHy,HarloJlHrrouruxIIOBeCTBOBaHr4errporafoHr4croB'onl4palorcqHeHaOAI4HpoMaH'aHaAyBaTenbCreo!))Koy' a pa:oSnaueH[ecpa3y u sa <Ycuex> Strluc a, v Ha<Kalcoeevtt<oU)HA alall'lt:e (nycrs 14KpaTKoM' no6a:rapyeTcf,T3Trlepu31raaHTpgII9JIOTI{I,IMaxtro3Ha'<AvrcrepAaMa)) u <<[utt' Bo BpeMesu>MaJIeHbKOe 3aMeqaHI{e: K'qepuullr'He MOfy He BbICKa3aTb OAHOqepuullr'a(ynoMl4HaeMat)) KeprancaMoMHaAenefJIaBe,srofiByfloMr{HaeugfiAeHbrI4)) 6rtla(He porr',raH)<cepreaurtenreca-o6o3peHl4ecutr4pvqeaKafl,eeHailvcaHa ero B 1987 r'Bpa3Aene2.4,nJIoAoTBopHbiMI4oKa3blBaloTcflpa3MbIIIIneHufl'oI I o c T M o A e p H I 4 c T c K o M c l 4 M y n f l K p e l l p l l a H a J w l 3 e X y A o ) I ( e c T B e H H o r oAnruuq)'peIIIeHu'B poMaHe Eapnca <<Aurlul',I4AeHTI4I{HOCTI4Harlr4oHaJlrsofinpo6teuu'{acrefi He TOJIbKOgrofi rJIaBbI' HO }1 SCefroanofi H3 CaMbIX KOHIIeilTyaJIbHbIXaHar'lrcI4rlecKupa3Aen 2'5, Y KoropoM O'A'/{Nyvtafilo'r/z flaB/ax>>Ar4ccepTaUi4l4,QTaHoBlITctcnusra, <I4cropur MI{pa e 10<BoAo3eMbe)poMaHrtHaoflr4paqcbc6oput'txn <He ornycxafi MeHfl)) L{curypo'Eapuca, <<Tau, fAe B AbIMKe XOJIM6I))paccKa3oB<Morrcrprr3firrurrefiga>M.3lrHca,ySeSuteJIbHotloKa3blBaeT'I{ Kynbrypbt'?-!-1^-1'0']1rorarlbHblM.qrlt auruufict<ofinrareparypblHacKorrbKo(arorluofi' feHHo-I1pKe-:tep::T'fr.