Отзыв официального оппонента Б. М. Проскурина (Английский исповедально-философский роман 1980-2000 гг)

OT3bIBorlloHeHrao Ancceplltrl'o$raqnanbHoroO.nuru AuarolseBHbl AXTYMAI'IIOponaan1980HcrIoBeAanuno-Qra'nocoQcrcufi<<AHr.nuficmnfi2000 r:>>'Ha coI4cKaHI4eyrleHofi crenegncneIrHaJIbHocrl4AoKTopa SznonornqecKIIX HayK rlorlpeAcraBlesuofi10.01.03- Ilureparypa HapoAoBcrpaH :apy6eNu(aueplrxaHcKat n eepouefiaKaflJII'ITeparypa)co6ofi {yu4aueHTaJlbHoe.{uccepraUuq O.A. fxyrtaafino npe4craBJlflerB oAI4HH3 caMbIXr{ccJIeAoBaHI{exl4TepaTypHoronpoUecca s BeluKo6putauuu3ror [epl4oA' c oAnofi cTopoHbl'[epuoAoB ero pa3BvrTLrfl'.nro6olrpnuxHauHoHanruofi nl4TeparypblBoaKKyMynupyeTocHoBHbIeTeHAeH\rIH^LIHaMI4KI{s 1970-e fr'' c 4pyrofiBTopoil rroJroBl{HeXX n., B oco6euHocTl'IHaMeTHBIIIvIecfl14 IIOCToTpaxaeT ceoeo6pasue 6pHraucxofi nl'IrepaTypbl r3TrlepoBcKofokI xynrrypHofr vleTopplrT3TqepOBcKoro3TaIIa IIOJII4THqecxofi,coqnal*iofio roM, r{To 3Tor [epl4oA B pa3Br"tvvr nnTeparypblCra:arrarpu"ir.aH|JII4CTI4KeB OTerlecTBeusofrOCMbICIIeHVIflire 6rui npeAMeTOMBelnr<o6pvTaH]lIVrHeJIb3tr:KaHAnAaTcKI4ev|AoKTopcKHeAI4ccepTaIII4oHHbIencQneAoBaHlO'f'Cu4oponofi'E.H.Eenonofi, -fl.C.fpe6eHr{yK,B.I'1.ien'tuna, B.f.Ho6raxoeofi,E.f.flerpoconoft u Ap'' Hec.A.crpHHroK, c.ll.Tonxa91eBa,o.B.llepexoArlenoff,Crareft B pa3Horo PO.qaHayunoil nepI4oAI4Ke'rOBOpr O 6olruoM KoJII4aIecTBeK 3ToMyo He3aTyxarcu{eM[HTepece pOccnftcxl4x aHilII4cToBcBuAeTenbaTByIoTK ClOXnefiruerraynepr4oAy B vaTopvn nuTepaTypbl Benrzxo6pvTaH]u:vI,V IIOcTMoAepHncrcxofi83anMOAeffCreZrc peanHcTI4uecrofi, MOAepHncrcrofi(uananu3wpyeMoeO.A.[NyMaftnoPa6oru3crerrrqecKux .ruiu4t.t.nonyr{I4BlxaflVouorpaSux,eeAlrcgepTarluoHHoe I{ccneAoBaH?Le, VCIeUI4aII{CTOB' eeOCHoBaTelrgrtfi pe3OHaHC B Kpyrax OTer{eCTBeHHIIXB HayrIHbIXXypHanax)npo6leuuo-3aocrpeHHble 14cBeXI4e11o[oAXoAaM crarbqOTer{ecTBenHofiuayxofiBHOCflTCyrqecTBessufi BKJIaA B IIpOUecc ocBoeHI',Iflpa6oTbl nep1aoAa(xorr no XoAy I4ccneAoBarklflaBTopyKa3aHHoroB 3aHIaB;71vrfpaHI4IL fIOCKOnbKyHer436exHoBbrxoAlrT3a paMxa o6osHat{eHHbIXBpeMeHHbIXf,BIIeHHe((XI'IBoe)), HenpepblBHoeV qenocTHoe)'nr4TepaTypngfinpoqecc I4ocneAoBarelrcxHft II9AXSA, OnpeAensrorquilllpe4noxennrrfi o.A.fxynaafiloopnrr{HaJIbHOCTbAlICOepTauHpI,[onbITKaIIOCMOTpeTbHAAHHaMHKytlepe3 [pI43My o6Haxesnoronr4repaTypHororepot I4 epo orHoIIIeHwfrc MI4poMHennuenpnqTHofoBonpouaHl{',scaMofoCaMOOIIeHKI4,aH4fl,14npoqecca caMoIIO3HMecra B coullyMe,i6^, rcl4xonoro -aHarvrr4qecKoro ocMblcJleHufl aBoeroXaHpoByro Sopt*y'coBpeMeHHofiEpu TaHW, ((oTJiI4BIIIeroct))B ollpeAeneHHyrooTKpbrBaeTolteHbI4HTepecHblerIepcIIeKTI{BbIBbIIIepqI'IBaHLrfl' cyUIHOCTHbIXocBoeHnqKOHTypoB nurepaTypHofo rrpoqecca, T.e, cJIOBeCH0-O6pa:uoroqeJIOBeKaOrgOUreuUfiHeBepOtTHOycnO)KHHBiUHXCtHa cTbIKe AByX TbICflLIeJIerUfic MI4pOM,efo oKpyxaroulnM.epraIII4H COBepIXeHHOkIHa,Le foBopfl , a KTya Jrb Ho crb alanv3krpyeMofi AI4ACHa ceroAHqlxHufrorreBuAHa, d B caMofi padore oHa BeabMa rotlHo orlpeAeneHa:IIpOaHanI43I{poBaTbaHTJII4CTI4Keor{eHb BaxHoAeHb B oTeqecTBeHHOficnoxHefiIlleenepeilJleTeHl4epeanI4OTI4qecKI4XHIIocTMoAepHI4cTcKI4XcTpyKTyp,paccMaTpuBaeMofoaHfnI4ftCKOiI nl4TepaTypblcocTaBJrflrorqee cBoeo6pa3l4eoTJII4BUIefrctB3TltKo-HpaBcTBeHHOft[apaAI4fMbI'o6ocrpeHl4eyBuAeTbilepuoAa,ocnoxHeHHyrorroBecrBoBarenbHy}o soptry,ToM r{r4cJre u B r4ctroBeAanbHyroI4MeHax 14 flBIIeHldflXnosruxofi, cucteMHo H B KOHKpeTHbIXrrocTMOAepHr4CTCKOfinpoqeoca Bennxo6pvraHvrv 1980-xJll4reparypHoforrpeAcraBv^rb AvrftaMllKyr{TO HafIIaBHbIM O6pa:orr',l a reM',cBfl3aHapaSorrr2000-x fr.

HOsugHa2000-x fr' (6oleepoMaHoB 1980-x3Har{r4reJbsrrfi Kopnyc asuHftcruxo'A'[xyrtaftloI4CCJIe'qoBa]H]?Lfl',)MaTepI{aJI.o.*"n"routufirpaAqarH),craslIIetlNauponofi n'ro4u$raxawvpoMaHa'nocMoTpena B pa3pe3e o[peAelerisofiIrvHvrfl'TpaKTyeTcq KaK feHepalbHaqa:Harrv3A,AI4HaMI4Kaxoropofio6renrounl4TeparypHofo rlpoqeccaxaHpoBolo pa3BiziT]/Lfl,'K AOoTI4XeHI4Ionn^.rrrflKOTopolIH UeJIb HCOIeAOBaHr4fl'He srtsrtu3at"otpaNegtafipa6ora B CaMoM Aene He roJIbKor{AeT yBepeHHO14OCHOBaTeJIbHO:o.A.fNyrrlaftlocnoeO6pa3Horo Vvr HoBaTOpcKIrM HcaneAoBaHueMcTaJra ruy6oruNaneplloAa6pnraHCxofi nl4reparypblMapKr{pyrculefo frIaBHbIe o.o6.n"o.rtQ e H o r r , r e H a s r a r r o c o s c K o - I 4 a [ o B e A a n b H 14o f o p o M a H a B e f o lreopeTl'IKo/ a T o p l / . I dHo T2010-x fr.'' HO o6osHa'Iv1napfl'F'oepeAr4Hbr1970-xAo eABa JII4HeI , I c T o p I 4 K o - n H T e p a T y p H b I x n e p c I I e K T I 4 B - A a n b H e f i r u e r o I 4 c c JtIpoAyMaHbIIeAoBaHVfl'nr,rreparyp"o.o' ,riour..uBpwrauuvr.

croltxecepbe3HoTeopeTI4tIecKI{eyIl{cTopl4Ko-nuTepaTypHble3aAaql|I4ccneAoBaHv':fl,u e o o x o A l t M o c T b n o c J I e A o B a T e J I b H o f o p e i x e H t { f l K o T o p b I Xvn prpl4Be]*1-i:::.-p-:eAoIIpeAeJlI4naAHHaM]/^Kyr.rccneAoBarerlbcKyloeecrpyKTypy Ar{acepraI|IIl^,K rIocTaHoBKe ocHoBHbIX IIOJIOXeHI4II'lfaw, c oAnoft cTopoHbl,Ar4CCepTaK OyH'qaltaeHrarlbHblM::l:^"ji:.:I',IBbrHocr4Mbrx Ha saruury, a c lpyrofiQIOXeTHO-KOMIO3I',IUI4OHHOI4Nauponofi,oT.e.aHDfl,[peAMeTe aBoefo uccneAoBKaKpoJII4 Lt MecTe HoBOfi I4CnoBeAaJIbHocTI4$yHxuran,rroBecTBOSareIrHOficanope$ne,xci.1-XiiKaK,uol-o6pu:uofino SoplaeI4coAepxaHllroBorrpouaHr4r,BcerAa orJlplqaB[IeHcf,aurtuitcrofi nr4Teparypbl,orarrHoro .rrBneHr4sB Hcropr4ufipoqecca caMoIIO3HAHVfl'I.epof'U:O6paNeunrcKBHr4MaHI4eMrroBbrrrreHHbrMTeopeTI{Koo4o6peHurB panHofi cTe[eHI4 3acnyxl4BaroTEe:ycloeuo,?Icropl{Kopa6orrt' aBfl3aHHblt t:MeroAoJroruqecKue rlocblrrKr'I-::u--g:""tt nl4TepaTypblu artwruit'cxofiI4CIIOBeAI4B I4CTOpHnHTepaTypHbtM XapaKTepoM )KaHpao T B e K a X V I I K B e K y X X I , B T o M I { I 4 c I e u O e e a l l 6 u n a l e H t H o f r , Kparr',lKaxa K I I I 4 I I Ipl4cyeuofieTaBTop,(nK 3aBepIIIeHHOCTracrpeMl4TQtllcnoBeAbKOfAanprapo4ofr,He flB[fleTcfl'HO IIO .ytl raxoeofi B npl4HullnecyAt6H r4 ee xu3HeHHbIX yrno";,nocKonbKy,KaKMbI3HaeMIIpOMaH,I4erorepofitBJItIOTCt((cTaHoBtuI[N4UCq)(iloABHX9HI4g 6I43HI4' llpuuqnnl4aJlbHo[ocToqHHoeMoAenqpyloTVM.Baxrrauy;Bax(Ho,tITopa3Mbllunf,flo63ToM'aBToppa6orrryquTblBaeTcepbe3HoesosAeircrBHeHaMHpoBo33peHqecKl4eycTaHosxuSoIrlII4HCTBaIII4CaTeJIeit'uIDup o M a H b I o K a 3 a J l u c b B u e H T p e I 4 c c n e A o B a T e J l b c K o r oTeoperuroBHI,IMaHuq'3tII4cTeMoJIofHqecKofo KpI43I,Ica.HAeoJIofI4I4nocTMoAepHracrcxoft3cTeTuKI4cB,'I3aHbITaKXe u c rofi cropoHofiMeToAoJIofuqecKHe ocHoBbI paSorstpy6exaoco6euso aKIIeHTHpOBaHasnoxofixaHpa r.rcnoBeAll, KOTOpat oKa3aJlaabrpaevtu,3crerI4KI{ paHl4Mocr}r, rlcllxoJlofl'IqeoKofiTbIcrrIeJIerr4ir.)B qacrHocr1vtruitttoit'noTepqHHOCTI4aKcuoJlofia'{ecKofi6o1u,HpaBcTBeusoftB $ranoco$cKoM cMbIcJIecyulecrBeHHo c6luNaer<6pourenHocrI'I)) ('rrongerun)' Haroneq', elJler4crroBeAanbHyro 3CTeTr4KyO SK3I4CTeHIII4aII4OTCKI4MI4pa6oru QTaHOBI4TC{eenocrtlxofioAsofi (ecnu He rnaeHoft) TeopeTHr{ecxofiIIOSTOJIO|UIICCKAq3AOCTPEHHOCTb'ilPT'ICTAJIbHOCBNIqAbIBAHI4CB|IO3TI4KYXAHPABK aHanll3y tlpoH3BeAeuuit"p13rIpI4BJIeKaeMbIXqenoM (rar unnapraanra) lI Kax(AofoCTOpOUpa6oru cTaHoBI4TCseeorrvreuy, rrTo oAHofi us caNabIX[pnBIIeKaTeJIbHbIXB TOM tIpIcJIe 14 c o6pauleHneuTeopeTr4qecKar ocHaIIIeHHOCTb, cBt3aHHaflK 3HarIHreJIbHoMy Maccl4By SranocoQcxux'O.A.[xyuafrnoHa pyccKoM I4I4CCJIeAOBasuitHCTOpnqecKr4xu co6crseHHo JII4TepaTypoBeArIeCKI4Xfepot' xapaKTepa'r3brKax ro upo6nevraM poMaHa, nl4TepaTypHofor4HOCTpaHHbrxpeann3Ma, MoAepHI43Ma'nocTMoAepHlI3Ma'rroBecTBoBailvrt, lrcTopllr4 nl4TepaTypbl,BB I4ccneAyeMytonpo6neNlarl4Kycocrol4rInqnurfi BKJTaAo.A.fxyuafiloaBTopoB' I4x I'IHTep\perar\kru uaHarry13eAecflTKoB rrpor43BeAeuvtit 6purancxizxI4CTOpI4I'IKapTI4HbI BecbMa CJIOXHO|O nepI4OAaco3AaHr4lr qelocrsofixaHpa I4crloBeAanlHo-snnocoscxoroHaur4oHaJbuoff ngTeparypbr B UenoM kt3aKOHOMepHOCrefrAI4HaMI4KIIpOMaHa B ToM tII4Cne; B B6IqBJIeHI4I4BHyTpSHHI4XB KOHreKcTe 6oleenr4Teparypbr Benraxo6p vraH14u B yKa3aHHbIe [eeflT:z.IIeT:afl'vr coIIHaJIbHo-nOIII4TI4'IeCXOfrXynlrypnoftnr4repaTypnor,o6rur,rx npo6nevcrpaHbl.veropvrv'cooTBeTcTByIOT llacrlopryIIpo6.rreMaTHKa V BbIBoAbI AIIccepTaUIrlrrollrareparypa HapoAoB crpaH sapy6eNrr>creuuaJrbHocTtr (10.01.03cneAytoull4MnyHICaM:u'i'PolrnnreparypblBQopluapoBa1vruo6lnra3apydexst', B oIIpe'{eJIeHI4I'Inyrefi raxXyAo)(eOTeeHHofiKynbTypbl HapoAoB crpaHMl4poBorollepuo4I'r3a\vs't.2.pa3Bvrvfl;o6uecreeHHo-AyxoBHoroB 3BonIoUuI4 nllTepaTypnr4TepaTypHoro npoqecca; upoSlenau cTaAHanbHocTI4BeAyxlllx HaIII4oHaJIbHbIX 3apy6eXHbIX3TaIIbI pa3BvrTvLfi.3anaAa vr Bocrora;KoHreKcTa' couI4aJIbHOnr4TepaTyp; n.3.

llpo6nervtrr I4CTOpI4KO-KynbTypHofoBbIAaIOUTIIXCflBO3HT4KHOBeHH'o6ycnoBJreHHooTr4lcplxoJrofu.recxofiV TIIII.JI.T}Ifl n'{TeparypHblxXyAoXecTBeHHbIX npol{3BeAeuvtit; n.4. Vlcroput']KAH?OB,CTHJIefi,ycrOfiuI4BbIXCo3HaH;,1lfl'Ha[paBneUuh, vugoB XyAo)I(eCTBeHHorOHaXOAIUIUX BbIpaXeHI4e Bo$paSoe [pO3bI, lIo33I4I4, ApaMbI vT ny6nnqHcTnKvr,n'6'III4CaTe-JibcKlIX fpyn[;vTBOptiecTBe oTAeJrbHbrx IIpeAcTaBvTenefi.nnI4TepaTyP' VX KOHTaKTHbIeHaUI4OHanbHbIXBranlrO4e fi.c]jsufl,I4 B3aI4MoBII:nflHI4fl'B oIIeHKerpoueccnHreparypHufifeHerr,rqeaKtre cBfl3vr; n.7.

3apy6exnHfio BeAeHI4fl',V KpLITH.KI4'r4Hofl3blr{HOrO U OTeIIe cTBeHHOrO n I4TepaTypB Aalruefiruefi pa:pa6orxeHayvuan UeHHocTL AHacepTaUI4I4cocTol{TI{I4X HcTopI4Ko-JII4TepaTypHbIXTeopuq XaHpoBbIX poMaHHbIX MoAI4OI4KaUI4fi'cyrl4 TaKoroScrerrrrrecKr,rx ocHoB, B pa3BvrtLrLr$unoco$cKoro-3creru'{ecrofinl4TepaTypHofoIIoHf,TI4fl,KaK((I4cnoBeAaJIbHocTb))BefocooTHoiIIeHI4I4e3rl',IKa)),Vr <<asro6uorpa$rasu>, (AI4CKypcr4BHafl'roHqrutflMr,l <6uorpasu3M))Hayuuar((HeofyMaHr4cTr,lqecKoer.r3MepeHr4eTeKCTa)) v H9KOTOpbIMIIApyfl{vru'gpuMeHeHI{eM IIpI4 aHanl43eqa""Oar" pa6orU CB{3aHa TaKxe c nJIoAoTBOpHbIMsCreTI4KHpoMaHaslAnoco$cKo-I{CilOBeAaJlbHofolpolr3BeA eiHuit xaHpapaHHMocTuV KaTefop6fi ((trauma studies>, paBHo KaK 14KaTeropl4fiporuaHHofinocTMoAepHI43MOM:(HeHa4exurtfiaKUSHTI4pOBaHH6IXoco6onorr"*r,paCCKa3qI4K)), ABOfiHHT{9CTB9, miS-en-abYffi€,MoHTaX,napaAOKC 14 HeKOTOpbIXApyfl4x.3HaqHMOCTb AI,ICCepTaIILII4 COCTOI4T B eo3AaHUVITeopernuecKafl6onee nonHofi, [o cpaBHeHr4roc HbIHe y Hac I4Melou]efrct, KaprI4HbI3Harrr4TeJrbHo- 2000*x m.; B roM, qro aBrop6puraucroro nl4reparypHoro tlpoqeaca 1980-xpoMaHa c Tor{KV 3penvIfl'AeMoHcrpl4pyer AHHaMI{Ky Sunoco$cxo-ncnoBeAaJlbHofoBO3paCTaIOXIefO 3TI4KO-3CTeTI',IqecKoroeAI4HCTBa XaHpa' or{eBI4AHOfO Aa)I(eaM6VBaneHTHoQTII'BOIIpeKI4 noaTMoAepHIIcTcKOfr penqT[BHOcTI4, I4rpe'Anroppa3Mbrrocrl4 u HeoAHo3HaqHocrr4 HpaBcrBeHHbIX I4MneparI4BoB repot'I4cnOBeAaJIbHoKoHIIe[Uurcnl4TepaTypoBeArlecKI,Ifi o6oporBBSAI{T BBonpouaHuq, AoMHHHpyIoilIero B ananI43vIpyeMoM XaHpe krSunoco$cKoropoMaHe yKa3aHHOfOrIepI4OAaBAeMOHCTpHpyrouIefo (BocKperueHr4e cy6beKTa)) B3THqecKpIX IIeHHocTefi,$ranoco$cr<oqenOCTHoaTI4 erorrpeAenaxpa3pa6arrtsaerMr4poBo33peHqecKHxyCTaHOBOKr.r rro3r4ur4fi.Aerop AI'lccepTauI4HpOMaHOBvr uCtIOJIb3yeT KOMIIneKCHbIfiMeToAOnOrHr{eCKI4ftnOAXoA K aHan63yyKa3aHHOfi Xanp oeofi vroAraQvKar\r4pr.3HaqrrMocrb pa6orbl onpeAenflercfl Bo3MoxHocrblofIparcruuecKaflee Marepr4aJroB 14r4TofoB B By3OBCKOMnp eno [aBaHvrvr vr v3yl{eH'Id?r14crroJrb3oBa1],1lfl,- XXI ee., a TaK)I(e B [p]IMeHeulala6pHraHcxoro nuTepaTypHoro rlpoqecca XXcTpaH'MeroAlIKI{ AHAIMapOMaHOB K rIpOI43BeAeHHtMApyfI4X aBTOpOB14ApyfHXpa6oTbr, KaK y6eN4aer nporlreHne Bcefi [vaaepTal1:nv,crpyxrypa14npoAyMaHa v orBer{aer Heo6xoAr4MocrrM pelxeHnfl [ooraBJIeHHbIX 3aAar{'AHI1.flHq O6O3HaqeHHoft IIenH I4CCJIeAOBAOCTpI)KeHTeoperurco-MeroAoJrofuqecKr,re v IrcroplrKo-JrHTeparypH[,Ie ocHoBbIHo oco6eHHo BoBo (BBeAeHITI{>>,AuccepraUqu rronyqaror c[er{r4aJlbHoepa3BI4TI4epoMaHBropoM ero pa3Aene <3anaAuoeBporeficKufi I4croBeAanbHo-$HnocoSaKLit'a no3r4rlr4ftreopeu4rrecKofi vr vcropLrt{ecKoil [o3TlrKI,I)>.

B ueivt aBTop llHTepecHoAnfl pa6oTbl IIoHtTI4tMvI ucnosed7nbHocmb, poxtQHpa3MbIIIrn.rIeTHaA KJIIoTIeBrIMI4r{acrl4 AHccepraIII4lIucnosedb,|uozpa@rcrvr (asmoSuoepaQusu). I4venso B 3rofiHer.r36e)KHocrb cBq3KI4 I4onoBeAaJlbHoro Ha.{ara caBTop o6ocHoBrreaerHaycTaHoBKI4HenepBocTerIeHHoCTbyTBepxAaeT$HnocoocKr4M,rr4rre poMaHa-HCIIOBeAU(Vro, Ha MOfi B3rJLf,A,(anro)6uofpaor43M B COBpeMeHHOMC[OpHbIM MOMeHTOM,IIOCKOJIbKyB MOeM [peAcTaBJIeHI4I4flBIIfleTAs.AOCTaTOT{HOnHar{eB)flKafl HCrroBeAb npeAycMaTpr4BaeT HaLLrrille B Hefi TaK vIIruIpeanr43oBaHHoro6uorpa$urrecKofo, qarqe Bcero aBTo6l4orpa0l4'IecKoro' Har{aJIa),ecer4anoAqepKr4Baer Ba)r(Hocrb 3K3r4creHllnanbHoro onblTa repot, BHyrpI4 ce6rcrbnporr{Bopeqr{Boro.

3Aecr xe aKrleHTr4pyeret IpI4HIIHTIvallbHafl He3aBepIxeHHo(fl)I4OIioBeAyIOUIefoCfl repoq V BotlpouaeMocTb KaK rtpoqBneHne 3TOfiHeI'I36eXHoeaBTop cilpaBeAnl4Bo o6rscriqerHe3aBepIxeHHocTI{. 3rraunpqcyrcrBr4e B rroBecrBoBarenbHoft crpyKType arrnvfrcKofo I4cnoBeAaJlbHoropoMaHa 1980-x - 2000-x rr.