Отзыв ведущей организации (Точные космологические решения в теориях гравитации со скалярными полями и нелокальными взаимодействиями)

yTBEPXIAIO:fl zp exrop 06r e4uHtiHHoro r4HcrnTyraflAepHbxr{c cneA oBaHrafinpoQeccop B.A.Mareeen,/"'\S \fl/t .1"/1j/-=E{,ffikf,\\tir!l{ttt)8P.\#!!!ury.d::'"trV,/0,*<<ToqHrte KocMonorvqecKze pelueHr.rs B Teopusx rpaBr,rrarlvtr co cKanspHbrMt4no ilflv,Lr HH e Jr oKarrbHbrHa colrcKauueMH 83 auMoA e itcrsusvrkb>, np eA c raBreHHyroyr6uofi creneHu Aorffopa Qzanxo-MareMarr.rqecKr4xno cnel14€urbHocrr4 0L.04.02luccepraqux C.IO. Bepnoea-HayK(ceoperr4r{ecKafl Szauxa><<ToqHue KocMo/rorr4rrecKze perxeHr,rfl B TeopnflxfpaBl,ITaqun co cKtulflpHblMt4 fro/rffMr4 u HeroKa/rbHbrMH B3ar4MoAeucTBvrflMu)) nocBsqeHaaKTyanbHofi npo6neMe coBpeueHsofi Teopervqecrofi $uzuw1 a HMeHHo, rzcc"rreAoBaHnrorno6a"nrHofi enonro4nH Bceneusofi. 3ua uccneAoBaHnffB€DKHbrB cBere nonyqeHnsBTeqeHHe noc/reAHlrx ryecxrunetuit HoBbrx ua6nro4arenbHbrx AaHHbrx, He HMerou{nxo6qenprcHaHHoro reopernr{ecKoro onzcaHHq.BqacrHocrt4, o4Hofiu3npo6nemsBrrfleTcfl orrilcaHr.re npHr{HH coBpeMeHHoro ycKopeHHoro pacllIvrpeHnn Bcenennofi.O4ruala r43 cnoco6oe onuc aHufl, KaK coBpeMeHHoro ycKopeHHoro pacuupeHr4sBcenenHofi, rax u 6onee paHHr4x eranoB eti eeonroquu (rnnorb Ao raHQnnqrau), annarorcaKOCMOJrOrUqeCKr.re MOAe"[r4, MOTHBr.rpOBaHHbreqacroBKJrroqarorB ce6srrao4uQrzxar{r4}o rpaBHrar{uu.CrpyHHOfi reOpZefi.

[IO4O6HUe MOAenr4HeJIoKaJrbHbre cKurspHbrenorrfl vrnvr HenoKanbHyroB AHccepraI{HI4 npeAJro)KeHbI HoBbre MeroAbr HccJreAoBaHvfl,no4o6r+rx KocMoJrorr,rqecKr.re MoAe/refi, nxnrcuarorques ce6s noucK Tor{Hbrx peureHuficoorBercrByror{r4x ypaeueHufi (DpnguaHa. Paccuarpr4BarorcflKaKMeroAbrpeKoHcTpwuuv noTeHr{r4ana cKanspHoro noJrfl, TaK r,r MeToAbr nozcKa ToqHbrx qacTHbrxpeileru{rl coorBercrByroqr,D(ypaBHeHrdrX @pu,uuana, rroAxoAflrrpD(Nrfl,onvcanurs.ruo6amHofi gnorrorpu Bcenesnofi. Eomuroe BHprMarrr4e yAeneHo pa3Brmruo MeroAoBnoKzrJru3ar*ru HeJroKiurbHhrx KocMonornrlecxr.D( MoAenefipememffiHeJroKzrJrbrrbrxc qenlro orblcKanprfl rracrrrbrxnermnefrnrrx ypannerurri uo4uSm4rposannofi rpaBrmarlupr.Anryamnocrb reMbr He Bbr3brBaer couHenrrfi, [ocKoJrbKy 3arpor{yrbre B Ar,rccepru&rvrnpo6neuu aKTr{BHo rrccneAyrorcx yv€uuMrr MHorrlD( crpaH..{uccepraqur cocrorrrIIt3 BBeAeHIrtf,, rrrecru rJraB ocHoBnororeKcra, 3zrKJrrorreHlrr,rpex npllJrox(et*riltu crrrlcKa JrllTeparypbr, BKJrroqarcrqero s ce6x 455 salruenonarnrfi.B llepnofi fraseEccneAyrorcf, KocMoJrorwrecKr{e MoAenncKiuurpHbrMlr rroJurMpr.

Ormlsrrremnoft oco6ennocrbroKOCMOJIOTITLTeCKID(cHeJroKaurbrrbrMprpaccMarprrBaeMbrxUOAeneft flBJ.rfleTgs. Ha.JIr{rrHe CKilUTpHOIO trOJIfl CHeJIOKZtrrbrIbIMKrrHerruecKr4M qJreHoM, BnlrrcqaroqnMs ce6s aH€u[{Tr{qecKyo $ymcrgtro or orreparopa.{anarr,r6epa. Harur.rne uoAo6noro rroJrfl, rfpruoqero ponb relaHofi gHepruu,Morr{BI{poBaHo nonesofi reopuefi crpyH.Brarcror MoAeJUrx ecrecrBeHHo rrotrBJurK)Tctrlorenls.riurbr calroAeficrsnx cxurJrrprrbrx noneficnfrae oro IrorerilMiil rropofipl.zrcceprar1lrrlr,vBnpocrefnnevrcrerreHr4.

,,{aHnufi cnyqafi uogpo6no paccMorpeHBIlo;ry.reunuff naerog rro3BoJrf,er cBecru nor4cK qacrffirx peruerudypannenrafi 3firrrrrefi-nacBprIe rroJrr{HoMoB.c$opuyrupoBaH iurroprmM rrprrBeAeHr4;r HeJroK€t"rrbrrbrx yparnernniMoAeirra K JroK€r.JrbrrbrM.3foimrefiHascHenoraJrbrrbrM cKurJurprrbrM rroJreMJroK€urbr{brMr,r cK€rrrpr{brMr,rK ilrrrJrr.By yparHemlfiLr $arrrourrrua cK€rmprrbrMr{ rroJrrMr{. BAuccepr{u[fl4 safigesu HoBbre roqHhre KocMoJroru{rrecKpre perrreur{r{ yparneuurl3ftmrefina cHeJroKurJrbr{brM cKzurflprrbrM rroJreM.Taxxe paccMorperrbr MoAenucIpOI,I3BOJIbIIbIMI/I IIOTeIil$0.JIaNlvt, vI Antt HI,D( IIpeAJIOx(eH MOTOA IOLICKa TOTIHbIX pemerurfiypaBHeuprfirroJrf,. Hosrre rorrHbrenpol/t3BoJrbHoropeueHr,rr ororo ypaBHeur4rr nafiAenrrry6ruecroro [oTel{ru4arra LrNrs.HecKoJrbKr.D( HerroJrnHoM}rairbHbrxrroreHllrlaJros.

norca3arro, rrro Ao6asreHueM BcnoMorareJlbHoro cKaJrflpHoro rroJrf, MolrcHorror]lrrrrbMoAeJrb c rorrrrbrM qacrHbrM pemeur,reM Bcex ypanHeuru?3fumnefrna.Crpyrrnar reopn{rroJrr flBJrf,ercf, Morr{Br.rposrofi Anfl, iraoAelefi ne;rorcanurofirparr,rrtu@{. Orpra rrs TaKrrD( uo4enefi, B Koropofi neloralbHocrb BBogr,rrc{ c rroMorrlbroarraJrr4rurrecrcofitlFucrgm orreparopa flarravr6ep4 geficrnyrouefi HacK€rJrf,p Eprmu3rrbr,paccMorpeHa B Lnane 2.

fialauas MoAenb o6raAaer rorrnbrMr{ qacTHbrMlr perrreHlrflMpr,rroJr)ruraeMbrMrlMoAeJrr,r.ycloruficroMorrlhro AorroJrHr.rTeJrbllblx yclonufi, noKiurlr3yrcrllrlD( ypaBHeHlnrB gucceprarrrlr [oKa3aHo, nro nocne HzlJlo]r(eHprf,yKa3aHHbIX AorroJruktreJrbrrbrepaccMarpr{BaeMzur HeJroK€rJrbHa"s MoAenb cBoAn:rcfi K MoAenn ft2 rparr,rrarry4.Taxxe Anfl orofi nenorcarunofi MoAenrr nafiIeno HoBoe rorrHoeperrleHr,re rHna (oTcKoKD).Tperrr lrasaAeficrsre Koropblx.nocBrnleHa MoAeJrrM nenoranrnofi rpaBrmarppr,BKJrIoqeHai[opuympoBr4 Koropaf,B3alrMoAeftcrnytoqm<s ce6xBKJtrorraerfimgroftB cedx lpac rpanrrarpefi.

BBtDKHo rroHlrMarb,,{alau6ep4MoAeJrrr rmBecrHaJroK€IJrbH€urAlrcceprae{r{ paccMorperrbrrarome Mareprto rr KocMoJrorrarrecKyro KoHcrar{Ty.lloerouyr{cxoAHoecKaJr4pHbrx rroJur, HeMr{HrrM€rJrbHoAeficrsue MoAenH BXoAm aHaflrilIa.recKffr QynxquxH3Harluurbno.B$ymuur or o6parnoro oreparopageficrnyrolqero Ha cKaiulpHyro KprrBlr3Hy.BKJtroqaroryreKocMoJrorwrecKoec.f,sLrAMoAeJrr{,Oruerr*r, rno Broropofi He orpeAeJrflerc{KaKr{Mrr Qysmuasruu Mo.{eJr}r MoryrAocraroqHo peawrcrrdrruo orrrachrBarb pa3r[q]Dre granhr oBoJnorry{u Bce.nennofi.

BAncceprar[il{ pa3Brm aflropmM, rro3BoJrf,roqrd BoccraHaBru{Barb3aAaHHoMy noBeAeHlrro rapaMerpa Xa66ra.gKClOHeHTOfi,tO MOAenb OolaAaetllorasano, sro ecJrrr $yrutryngrapaMerpoM Xa66nar;l,zgraH:n/t.flouauo aroro, uafi4erru $pmqnurrcf xr'tlrrcxKOCMOrOrHqeCKrrMrr peuIeHI{tMpI, omlchlBuuollll{Mr4ocHoBlrhre grarlbr oBoJlrour4rr Bcerer*roft, a naeruro, pe[IeHrlteM .qecSymrro .fCrrrepa rr perneHrleMCoorsercrByroqne pemeHr.r{ nonyrer{br f,Buo.f, ,rperyfitrJurrorquecodofi cyMMbr rroKa3areJrbrrhrx$ylilcl1rtft, c KoropblMrr, B 3aBr{cldMocrpl or Haqiurbnbrx AaHIrbIX, Mo}KIro rroJrfrarb KaKpemeHrre c rocrotrHrrbrM rrapaMerpoM Xa66m" TaKLrcH:n/t.B uo4erur c sKcfloHeluluanbHoft SyHxrg{efi "f, BKJrrorrruorqefi sKocMoJlorr{rrecKyro )KaAKocrbucedg rgeaJrbr{yrcKocMoJroruFrecKyro KoHcraHTy, upoueg€naHaJrr43cra6unrnoctrn pemerunl Ae Crrrrepa orHocrrmeirbHo aHrrcorporrrbrx rosrvryqeHraiMETpHKeI.Ersm<ltBHafi.qerlnI Aocrarorrr{bre ycnoBurr cra6purnocru perueruul AeCrrrrepa.rlern€pran Lirana ilocBsrrleHaKocMoJrorxrrecKnM MoAeJrflMcSarrounuuucKzlJr{prrbrMu [oJr{Mrlr, Mr{Hr{M€urbHo B3€l}rMoAefigrsyro[s{Mrr c rpaBr'ilaq[eft.

3rpr MoAenr{crpyrrrrofi reopnefi rroJrs, r(oropzur odocnosrrsaerMoTuBrnpoBaHbrQarnonnroroflorsHeJroKa.JrbHocTbrolrcxo.srofi MoAenu. Taxxe cBrsb co crpynnofireopnefi rroJrs HnKJraAbrBaer o{panruemkrs Ha BUI uoreHrryrrura.Teopr{HrroflBJreHr{ellpngToM us crpynnofirroJr{ He cneAyer roqr{brft sng noreHrlrlaJr4 nosroMy npr.rMer{nercs [porleAypapeKoHcrpyKrryrfi.qm nocrpoenrrf, uoAenefi r€unofi gHeprr{r{. llocrpoena MoAenbc$arrrorcrrrM cKanflplrbrM rroJIeM Id [oJII{HoMpIaJrbIrbIM [oreHr[,IarroM, B Koropofi raueercrTorrHoe cradrarrlnoe pelrreuuerrr[a KlrHKa. ,{nx nporepKrr coorBercrBr{rrnadmogareJrbrrbrM Aarrr{brMoHa6urap$ynbrare qero [oJrfreHo, qro rrplroHepruplAurHHofiuoAerupacmnpeHa BKJTaAoM rerunofi Marepnu,coBpeMeHHoM oruorrreHrruvr renanoft MarepHH 3xaqenue [apaMerpaB[rrorHocrefi r€lrsofir€unofi 3Heprulr-1.

Tarxe s tlern$profi l"rranecocro-flHr{nron1^{aercs 6ru3xoe K na6rrogaeMoMy, To ecrbrnOCTpOeHa KOCMOJIOII4TI0CKUI MOAenb CIOJIIIHOMITIUUIbHbIM fIOTeIilptULIIOM,Morr{Br,rpoBulHr{brMcrpyrxroft reopr,reft rroJrfl, H AByMr cKa.JurpnbrM}r rroirrMpr, o4{oKoropbrx {BJrf,ercfi Sarrounuu.MuolKecrBo rorrrrbrx peruerud.coorBercrByruT[p]rH3B erofi MoAenr{ roJrfreHo AByxnapaMerpr{rrecKoeflpu groM HeKoropbreroqHbre pemeHnrr (no ne nce)6ommrm BpeMeHix [apaMerpy cocrof,Hrdn r€nmofigHeprr4rd6ommervry -1, ror4a KaK Apyrrre coorBercrByror [apaMerpy cocroflHr{r, Merrbureuy -1,qrocooTBercrByer HapyrrreHr4ro r{3orporrHoro ycJroBr4f,3HeproAoMrrHaHTHocTu.flpoanarrcll,IpoBaHa ycrofi.rmocrb rroJrfreHHbrx pemernrfi.

Oriuernna,rrocrpoeHl,It yKinarruofi uoAerrrToJrbKo npuuen€H, Ho rI pil3Br.n.cqroAByMTI rroJurMu MeroA cyfieprrorerilryraJraB .racrnocru, gror MeroA 6rrn ucuoJrb3oBau6rrrNrfineHe roJrbKoAJIrI peKOHCTpyKII[u uOTeHIS,r&Jra IIO 3aAaHIIOMy pemeHl,ilo, HO Ilt AJIfi IIOXCKa HOBbIXTorrnbrx peneurfr.Orruerrau,qro aarurrfi MeroA peKoHcrpyKr[tr{ rroreHrs{€ila 6lr o6o6rq€nrraKocMoJroruqecKxe MoAeJrr{ c HeMriHraMamsofi cBs3bro cKaJrf,pHoro [oJrfl H rpaBxTarwr,KorophrM rrocBflrueHailsras Inana4llcceprar1lil{. B eroft ilrane nafiAerrsr rrorer[ptzurblcKtrrrrpHoro rroJr{, Koropbre rro3BoJlrtrorKOCMOJrOrr4rreCKr{MrlrMoAeJrHc@usnuecxuTaxxe B grofi rJraBe nafiIenrrBtDKIrbIMr.Ir1trilerpl/rpyeMbleMOAem'r C HeMprHr{Mt[JrbHO B3ar'rMoAefiCmyrOrqrnU CKaJUrpr{brM frOJreM,KOCMOJTOTTIIIIeCKHenonfraeMbreperneHr{nMr4.[onyrrmbvsprcBecrrrbrx r{rnerpr4pyeMbrxcKaJUrpHbrM noJreMcuoAereftcMprHLrMa.JrbHo cBtr3aHHbrMrroMorrlbro ron$opnruoro npeo6pasoBt[rvfl.

llorryueno o6IqeepemeHlte Nrx o.{gofi I{3TulKrlD(nro4elefi,aI{MeHHo, MoAenIr LilrAylu,IposaHHoftrpilBr,rra4{r,r co cre[eHr{brM [oTeHrIpIftiIoM.B lllecrofil"rrane uccneAyrorcfl Her{HrerpnpyeMbre c}rcreMbr o6rrruroseHlrbrxAnlpQepeHrs,rarrbHbrx ypaBHeHHrz14 pa3BHBaeTcfl MeroA rocTpoeHrLflToqr{brxoJurprrrrr4rrecKrD( perueHruic roMorrlbto Soprr,ranrHbrx peluernnl B Br4Ae prAoB Jlopana. Csroro MeroAas AnIx HeuHTerpupyeMbrx cJrfra{x o6odq€nnofi clrcreumrroMorqbroXenosa-Xefineca BlepBbre rronyqersr rp€xnaparr,rerpurrscKpre pemeHr.rflcxoA{rqrD(cf, p{AoB Jlopaua.gryxnapaMeTpr4qecKl,refinx grofipeilreHlrfl,uerreproro fiopflAKa lIoryrenoBBr,rAeMoAenu raK]r(e rroJrfreHbr HoBbre rorlrrbre.TTBJUIK)rqprecf, 3Jt[ulTrltirecKr{Mr.t tpyt+ctpnuururKxre 3JrJr]r[Tr{qecroe pemeHr{e ypaBHeHr{ffurn6ypra-Jlanaay nsrofi crerreHlr.Arryarruocrb reMbr,HoBrrsma H 3HaqprMocrbp$yJrbraroB paborrr He Bbr3brBarorcoMHeHns, nocKoJrbKy Bce ocHoBHbre pe3ynbTaTbr Ar{ccepTar[M frBJr.f,K)Tcr HoBbrMH uony6ruucoBarrbr B peKoMeHAoBaHHbrx3HarnrMocrbBAK perlemupyeMbrx)KypHaJrtx.llpamnrecKarrpa6oru cocror4r B Bo3MolrcHocrpr [prrMeHegr{fl nonf{eHHbrx p$yn6TaroB r{pa3BIITbIX IIOAXOAOBNls.IIOCTpOeHHfl Vl aHaJIIEa KOCMOJIOTHTI€CKI/D( uOgeleft,pealrucrr{rmo olrr{cblBaroul,D( oBoJrrol[ilo Bcener*rofi,B ToM qrrcreuuoguQrugpoBaHHoft rpaBprrargu.

llonyreuHbre pffiyJrbrarbr Lr MeroAbr Moryr safi-rprrrpprMeHeupreBMareMararrecrcofiprccneAoBaHunxrro KocMoJrorr&r, rpaBrmaqpu r,r B Apyrn oOnacrgxn reoperr,Frecrofi $urrmu, ilpoBoAr{Mlrx B O6reaHn€nnou rrHcrr/nyrerAeprrhrx uccneAoBarmf,r (.{y6Ha), I4ncnrryre tqepr{brx rlccneAosaHprfi PAH (Mocxna),IlHcrrryre reopermecrofi Susnru LrM.