Отзыв оппонента (Расчетно-теоретическое исследование процессов переноса в твердооксидном топливном элементе)
Описание файла
Файл "Отзыв оппонента" внутри архива находится в папке "Расчетно-теоретическое исследование процессов переноса в твердооксидном топливном элементе". PDF-файл из архива "Расчетно-теоретическое исследование процессов переноса в твердооксидном топливном элементе", который расположен в категории "". Всё это находится в предмете "технические науки" из Аспирантура и докторантура, которые можно найти в файловом архиве НИУ «МЭИ» . Не смотря на прямую связь этого архива с НИУ «МЭИ» , его также можно найти и в других разделах. , а ещё этот архив представляет собой кандидатскую диссертацию, поэтому ещё представлен в разделе всех диссертаций на соискание учёной степени кандидата технических наук.
Просмотр PDF-файла онлайн
Текст из PDF
OT3bIB O OUIIIAJIbHO| O OITIOHEHTAHa Ar4cceprarlr4oHHyiopa6ory Kacnnonofi ExarepilHrr Baleprennu <PacqerHo-Teoperlrr{ecKoer{ccJreAoB aHHe rrp ouocco B lrepeHoca B TB ep.4o OKCIIAHOM TOIIJII{BH OM gJIeMeHTe )),rrpe.4craBJreHHyro Ha cor4cKaHue y.reuoft crerrenl{ KaHAL{Aara rexHI4tIecKI'IX HayK rlocneqr{aJrbHocru 01 .04.I4*<TenloQyr3vrKaI4Teoperl4rIecKaq rerlJlorexHlrKa)llpuueHeur{e BoAopoAa B coBpeMesnoft oHeprerl4Ke cnoco6crnyer perIIeHI'Iro KaK npo6leuHrroBbrrueHgs gHepreuaqecroft e$$exrnmrocru, TaKocHoBHbIXycrpoficrn BoAopoAHofi oueprervKu-trDKorofuqecKl4x upo6lena' Cpe4uTOfIJII4BHLTX 3JIeMeHToB,IIo3BoJIflIol{I4x cnr,lcorofi sssexrunHocrbro o6ecnequeam [pqMoe rlpeBpauleHire xraunqecrofi sHepn'IH BBaxHoe MecTo 3aHr4MaloT TBep.4OOKCI4,4HbIe TOIIJII4BHbIe 3JIeMeHTbI (TOT3).sneKTpr4rrecKyro-Orla Aocrarorlgo nprrBneKareJIEHbI, rIocKoJIbKy I{cKJIIorIIrreJIr,Ho "Bcefl4Hbl" I4 orHocI4TeJIbHoJIeTKO BCTparABaIorcg B pa3nr4rrHble 3HeprerlrlrecKr'Ie qprKJrE'I 3a Cr{er BbIcoKonoreHIII'IaJIbHOfOTelJra npoAyKToB peaxrlr{H.
Enaro4apx oqeHE, sntcorofi pa6ouefi TeMneparype B HI4x B Kar{ecrBeTorrJrr4Ba, KpoMerrr4croro BoAopoAa, Moxer 6nrrr' ncnoJlb3oBaHo AalKe rIJIoxo oql4uleHHoeTorrrr,rBo, Harrpr4Mep, npoAyKTbroKr.rcr yrnepoAa.r4ccJreAoBaHr4eBra:z$uraql4l4 TBepAofo yfns co 3HarI[TeJIbHr,IM4ucceprarlNouuoft pa6ore E.B. Kaculonoit flpoBe,4euo reoperl'IqecKoenpoqeccoB rrepeHoca B 3neKTpOXUMI4qecKoM feHepaTope Ha ocHoBe TBepAOrooKcr,rAHoro sneKTponura. O6nacrb r4ccneAoBaHr4s.
coorBercrByer01.04. 1 4-coAep]KaHI4eMrlacloprycneUI4aJIbHocrI{<Tenno$rr3vKa u reoperl4r{ecKas reIIJIorexHI'IKa).Arcrya.nnnocrb reMblO4irofi r43 riprzoprrrerHbrx 3a1laq Ha cero4ununufr AeHI' flBrlserc.fl tIoBbIIIreHI'Ieotf$errnnnocrr,r [pou3BoAcrBa 3neKTpogHeptuv [pI4 oAHoBpeMeHHoM cHI4xeHI4Ir BpeAHbIXeosAeficrsl,Ifi ua or<pyNarouyrc cpeAy. 3ueprernuecKa.fl IIOJII4TI4Ka pa3BI4TbIX cTpaH BKJIroqaeTBce6g uoucx rexHrlr{ecKrrx pemeHr4fi, ocnonauHblx Ha HoBbIX [pI'IHTII{[ax leHepaIII4Il. B KaqecrseoAHofo I{3 TaKI4x peureuufi paccMaTplIBaloTcfl TOT3, pa6ora KoTopLIx ocnoBaHaHaHerrocpe,4crBeHHoM upeo6pasoBanpryr xrrMrrr{ecKofi suepruu B SneKTp[qecKylo, rlporeKalorleMKepaMlrqecxoft elerrpoAHo-3JreKTpoJrrrrHofi c6opxe.nplrMeHeHlrro HaHoArrclepcubrx noporrrKoBnpopbrB, r{To llpuBeno K crpeMlrrenbHoMyBC xonua 90-x roAon XX nexa 6naro4apxTexHoJrofLII4 rIpoI43BoAcrBapocryTOTS [pol43olirenI4HTepeca K HI'IM BO BCeM MI4pe.Conpeneunrre larapen TOT3 o6laAaror BbIcoKHM sneKTpI4qecKHMlpaKTlrqecKr{ He 3aBrrcyrror MotrlHocrn.
KBKIIA,xoropuffHacro-flrrreMy MoMeHTy lr3BecrHbr 14 IrcrIEITaHbIycraHoBKr4 Ha ocHoBe rBepAooKcr4AHbIX 3rIeMeHToB, pa6orarotquerro cxeMaM KofeHepaul4l4,Tpl4reHepaulzl{urr46pr4AHbrM cxeMaMcra3oBofi Typ6r4Hoft.3rukr xoe$$uqueHrpeureHr.rs rro3BonsrorAorIoJIHI4TeJIbHo rloBbrcr4TbsSQexrirnuocrr3HeprernqecKl4x ycraHoBoK cTOT3, qro B coqeraHr4z c MoAyJrbHofi xoucrpyrqriefi 6arapeia uHI43KITMLIr4crroJrb3oBaHulr rorrJruBanu6pocauu 3arpt3Hrroirlr4x BeqecrB.qeJraer rrcrroJrb3oBanue TOT3 [epcneKTr4BHbrMBcaMlrx pa3Hbrx o 6racr.sx sHepf err4Kr{ r{ ilp oMbrrrrJreHHo crrl.TOT3 cocrol4T Lrs xepaunuecxofi gneKTpoAHo-oneKTponuruoft c6opxn c czcreuoftfa3opaclpe,4enl{TenbHblx KaHaJroB, rro KoTopbrM rroABoI'flTcfl peafeHTbrorleKrpoxurr,tzqecroft peaKullrr.llpu pa6ore TOT3 B crpyKrypeHeKoropoe pac[peAeneHr4e KoHrleHTpaur4r4, rrJrorHocrr,r roKapacnpeAeneH[I{ srlaxBeJrr4qr4HoIITI{MI43aquro paOo.rero pexr,rMaIroTBoAsTcfl rrpoAyKTbr3neMeHTa ycraHaBruBaercqreMrreparypu.
HepanHoMepHocrr,HerarrrBHo cKa3brBaercx na s(p$exrr.rBHocrr4 r{ pecypce oJreMeHTa.Pa6ora BeAyIrrI4x I4ccJleAoBareJrbcKr4x3neKTp[qecKl4xra14r{KoJrJreKTrlBoBKoHcrpyKrlr.raBo MHorr4x crpaHax HalpaBneHaTOT3 3a cr{errepMoArlHaMr4r{ecKrrx [apaMerpoe. PeueHraeHaclorDnelotrs. fpaAr.reHToBsrofi 3a4aqu HeBo3MoxHo6esu3penLrfl. oco6euHocreft npoqeccoB rrepeHoca B 3neMeHTe. llosronay aKTyanbHocrb reMbrAr4cceprarluouuofi pa6omr E.B. Kacranoeofi He Bbr3brBaer couneHufi.Hayuuan HoBrr3Ha rr 3Harrr{Mocrr, pa6ornrOcHosnoe AocroLIHcrBo H HoBr4:na pa6ornr cocror{T B paccMorpenuu $yu4aMeHTaJrr,Hbrx3aKoHoMepHocrefi rpoqeccoB rrepeHocaaBTop [paKTL{rIecKI4 Hen TOT3.
B ormr.rue oro6rqenpr{H.flToro rroAxoAa,rlclonb3yer gMnlrpuqecKr{e coorHollreHu.fl, lrro [o3Borser ug6extarrofpaHr4rreHuit, cnx3anHr,rx c xapaKTepr4crkrKaMpr KoHKperHofo gKcrlepr4MeHTa.B4uccepraquoHHofi pa6ore perxeHa 3aqa'r,a co3AaHr4fl yHraBepcanrnofi reoperuqecxoftMoAeJIITTOT3, npvueuzuofi Anq trrnpoKoroAr4ana3oHa pa6ouzxvKoHcrpyKTr4BHbrxnapaMerpoB gJIeMeHTa (renaneparypbr, AaBJreHr4.rr, crpyKTypbr r.r feoMerpr4rrecKr4x pa3MepoBoneKrpoAuo-oneKTponirrnofiHayunufic6 oprcu).I4 npaKTl,Iqecxufi rrHTepec rrpeAcraBnsror flonf{eHHbren pa6oreaHaJrr4Tr{rrecKr4eQopnrynsr AJIx paclpeAeJleHl4-s KoHueHTpauuit n nopr4croM aHoAe I4 TonJrr4BHoM KaHaJreTaKII(e oIIeHKI4uKarrecrBeHHr,re 3aKoHoMepHocrlr,TOT3,auailAennrie Ans paclpeAeJreHl4s roKa noA'II{HE 3JIEMEHTA.O6ocnonaHHocr[, rr AocroBepHocrb pe3yJrbraron pa6orrrBrrno4r,I [peAcraBneusofi Ar4cceprauraousofr pa6orrr nonyqeHbr aBTopoM Ha ocHoBeTilIareJIbHoro aHa;lu3a.
Bce cAeraHHbre AorryuleHr4s rroAKpelJreHbr co6crneusbrMr4 pacqerHbrMr4oueHKaMIz I4 ccbrrlKaMr,r Ha pe3yJrbrarbr ony6.lraronaHHbx r4ccJreAoBalrrzfi. Oco6oe BHr4MaHrrey,4eneHo aHNrpr3y IIpHMeHLIMOCTT4 [OryrreHHbrx 3aBr{cr,rMocrer4orrpeAeJrrroqr4x pexr4M rrepeHocar1Br,rBoAy Kprrrepr4eB,trrrfl. paccMarprzBaeMbrx 3anaH.flpaxruuecKafl rleHuocrb noJryqeHHr,Ix pe3yJr[,TaroBflolyveuurre n pa6orgKarrecrBeHHbre 3aBr.rcr4Mocrv 14 aHaltr4Tr4rrecKr4e orIeHKr4 HMeror[paKTI,IqecKyIo IIeHHOCTb, IIO3BOITAS, CH.n3krrb crelreHb HeonpeAeneHHocrr4 rrpr4 nnaHrzpoBaHi{r4SKCnepIrMeHTa, auilrtr3e oTIbITHbIX AaHHT,IX I4 IIOCTaHOBKe rIrrCJreHHbIX I4CCne.4Onanuft..Ilpe4noxteusufi MeroA pacqera pacilpeAenenr.rr roKa rroAnr4He oJreMeHTa npe4craBnfler6onrruofi HHrepec Ant oIIeHKI4 TeMneparypHoro r{ KoHrIeHTparIr{oHHofo rroJrr B 6arapee TOT3L{Moxer 6rtrr rzcnoJlb3oBaH npra pa:pa6orKe'u npoeKTapoBauvLr KoncrpyKuur4vro1yns.
TOT3.3aMe.raHuq u HenocrarKuK 4uccepraqrara E.B. Kacnronofi r.rMeercs pflA 3aMerranurfi no coAepxaHr.rro u1. Brencre Al4ccepraulrv He yrroM{Hyrbr KoHKperHbre pa:pa6o'rxn TOT3Siemens, BloomEnergy,o6o@oprraJreHrrro:ypoBHe rexHLIKI4MHInIz(r<orvrnaHufi4pyrux), 3ro ne rro3BoJrser cocraBrzrb rroJrHoe npeAcraBneHr.reuccre4yenrofi o6lacruuHecKoJrbKo cHr4xaer Brrer{arJreHr4eornr{TeparypHoro o6sopa.2. Banrope$epare rIpI{BeAeH crr}rcoK rrcrroJrb3oBanuoft Jrr,rreparypbr, rrro HeBrroJrHeqelecoo6pa:no.3, B pa6oreTOT34.KaKHurrefo He cKa3aHoo raxoit earmoff o6racru[pr,rMeHeHr{q ycraHoBoK crprrreHepaqu{.B 4uccepra\vu paacMorpeHbr roJrbKo naMrzHapubrerer{eHr4-s.Errlo 6u qelecoo6pa:nopaccMorperb raKxe Borlpoc, B KaKr4x cryrrarx B KauaJrax TOT3 Bo3Molr(HoBo3Hr4KHoBeHrreryp6ynenrHocrefi.5.Anropona AorlyrueH psA HeroqHocrefr n $oprraynnpoBKax. B qacrnocrr{, B rJraBe 2 ua c.23 cxazaso <3na.reHae KoHIIeHTpaunrz B 3oHe gJreKTpoxrzrutr.recxofi peaKrlr{n TOT3 orruqaercqOT HOMI'IHaJILHOIO 3HaqeHI4g KOHIIeHTpa4IIU Ha BXOAe B 3JIeMeHT...)) VpacnpeAeneHl4e KoHlleurpaqraft no TonrILIHe rlopl{crbrx gneKTpoloeKOHIIeHTp aIIIIU KAKI-dX I4MeHHO KOMTTOH eHTOB rrMerOTCfl B BU IyTOT3),(HCCJIeAOBaHOHo He rroqcHrercr,.YltagaHutre 3aMerraHl.{s I4Meror qacrnr,Ifi xapaKTep r4 He cHl4xaror o6rqylo,fIoJIolIfl4TeJIbHyIo oIIeHKypa6orbr.
Anrope$epar aAeKBarHo orpaxaerBrIeJroM,coAep)r(aHueAl{ccepralluu. OcnonHble pe3ynbrarnr pa6oru n nornofi Mepe orpar(eHbr B nylnuxaguflx aBTopau anrope$epare.Brrnoarr rr 3 anJrrorreurrelloAsols I,ITorpaccMorpeHl{Io Ar{cceprarlraonnofipa6oru E.B. Kacurosoft,cneAyer3aKrroqlrrb, rrro oHa gBnqercr 3aBeprrreHHblM HayqHo-xna-rrv$uxarlldoHHr,M TpyAoM, I4MeIoIqr4MHayqHoe r4 [paKTr4qecKoe rrpr4MeHeHrre.fluccepraql4oHHat pa1ota E.B. Kacnnonofi yAourerBop-f,er rpe6onalluru BAK, a ed aerop3acJlyxl4Baer rlpucyxAeHl,Ifl01.04, 1 4-yreuoficrerreHr4 KaH[r4qara rexHr.rqecKr,rx HayKno cnerlr4anbHocrr4<Tenno$r43r{Ka r{ Teoperr4rrecKalr rerrJrorexHr4Ka).O$nquanlnsrfi onnoneur,AOKTOp TeXHr4qeCKHX HayK, AOTIeHT,npo Seccop na$e4prr xtrMuyr14sneKTpoxr,rMu.recxoft oHeprcTrrKr4OfEOy BIIOC.A.
fpnropren<Haquonalrurnl uccle4onarelrcrraftynaBepcr4rer <M3IrI>A4pec opraHr{3arluu: II1250, Poccux, r. MocrBa, yJr. KpacuoxasapueHuaa,4. 14I,lHrepner- caftr : http:I I mpei.ru|rene$ou: +7 495 362-75-60e-mail: universe@mpei.ac.ru30 vrapra 2015 r.floAnucr C.A.
fpzropr,eBaHaqarnunx yrrp aB JreHr,r.{&fr,0JX///;ffiE.IO. EapaHona.
