Отзыв оппонента3 (Исследование устойчивости резонансных вращений спутника на эллиптической орбите)

YTBEP}KAAIOpeKrop Qe4epanrHoro rocyAapcrBeHHoro6roANerrro ro o 5p a: oB,areJrbHo ro yrrp e)K TeHufl,hBbICIUefOKI4VIfocyAapct",._--uHA.I{.H., II.Mepsnxronao T3bIB BEAyIII EI4 OprAHI43AUr,ILr$e4epanrHoro rocyAapcrBeHHoro 6ro4xeuroro o6pa:oBareJrbHoroyqpexAeHn.f, Bbrcrrero o6pa^:o BaHLrfl< Y4uypr crcuir ro cyA ap cre e H Hrrfi y H kr B ep c r4rer>Ha .{r4cceprarlurc E.A. I{ercu:r'oi,t<<I4c cne.{o n aHrre ycrofi uue o crr4 p e3 oHaHcHbrx Bp arq ewuitcnyrHr4Ka Ha oJrnr{[ru.{ecKofi op6ure>npeAcraBleHnofi Ha cor{cKaHr,re yqeHofi creneuvKaHAHAara S rasvr xo -MareMarr.rqe c Krrx HayK rro cleur4 aJrbHo cru01.02.0 1 - reoperr{qecKa_s MexaHraKaB ne6ecnoft vexanvrKe vr AI{HaMr4Ke KocMr{qecKrax ailraparon (KA) BaxHyroponb I{rpalor raK Ha3hIBaeMbIe pe3oHaHcHhre ABTDKeHT{-{, [pr4 Koropbrx [epuoAo6paqeHl{.fl ctIyrHI4Ka orHocl4TeJrbHo rIeHTpa Macc n a6coruorHoM rrpocrpaHcrBeHaXOAI4Tcfl B paIII4oHaJIbHoM OTHOIIIeHkIV A ilepnoAoMABI,IX{eHLI' elo IIeHtpa Maccuo op6ure.

K uacroflIlleMy BpeMeHI4 raMeerc.fl HeMaJro [pHMepoB pe3oHaHcHbrx4nuxeHnfi ue6ecnr'rx reJI B Cornequofi cr{creMe. Izlsyueuue pe3oHaHcHbrxABI4X{eHI'Ifl TaK}Ke MOXer rlpeAcraBr{Tb rrHTepec u3a4aq oplIeI{TaIIW v cra1wtusa\Lrur ABIrDKeHr4s KA.An{ pellle]Hhrfi.

[pLIKJraAHbrXB erofi cB.fl3l4 Ar4cceprarlr4tE.A. 9ercnuofi, rrocB.luleHHat IzlccJreAoBaHr4ro ycrofivunocrr{ pe3oHaHcHbrxnpaqeuufi c[yrHI{KoB, [peAcraBJr.f,ercr HecoMHeHHo arcryalruofi KaK AJrtpa3Bkrrvfl o6rqefi Teopr4H.4r4HaMr{KZ KA, TaK H AJr_rr ee upurloxeuufi.B pa6ore paccMarpl,IBalorct .qBa rr{rra pe3oHaHcHbrx Bparq evwit cily.rHgKa,oTBerIaIOlInx TOTIHbIM pelxeHl{.trM r43BecrHoro ypaBHeHr,r{ Eeleqrolo.Vcrofi.{unocrb AaHHbrx 4nraxenufi[ocTaHoBKax, a HMeHHO:uccneAyeTc.rr aBTopoMB_pa3nr4rrHbrxB HeJrI4HefiHofi [ocraHoBe c yqeToM ToJrbKO [nocKr{x no:vryu1eHufi,ilrrfl HepaccMoTpeHHbrxpaHee sHa.{eHrafr [apaMerpa3 KcrIeHTp Haur er a op 6zru;B Henr{HefiHofi rrocraHoBKe c Anfl Au:Fra%vrYrecKr4 cr4MMerpr,F{HofoCNYTHT'IKA C YI{ETOM KAK IIJIOCKI,IX, TAK U IPOCTPAHCTBEHHbIXBO3MyrrIeHr4fi.B nr{HefiHofi nocraHoBKe An.'I CrryrHI{Ka c HepaBHbIMr{ MOMeHTaMTTVH9pI\LII4 c yqeToM KaK TIJIOcKI{X, TaK u IIpocTpaHcTBeHHbIXBO3MyuIeHvrfi;B uepnofi rJIaBe AI,IccepraIII4Lr Aarorcs rrocraHoBKrr 3a;ia.u o6 ycroftqzBocrr4ABI'IX{eHI4f CtIyrHI{Ka OTHOCT4TeJTbHO efo rIeHTpa Macc B rIeHTpanbHoMHbIoroHoBcKoM lpaBural{rroHHoM rroJre cvr.

Bunucrrnalorc_fl ypaBHeHr4rrIIBI4)KeHI4{ clyrHl4Ka B KaHoHnrrecrcofi faMr4Jrbronosoft Soprue. llpano4xrcxycJIOBH-{, npl{ KoTopbIX AaHHbIe ypaBHeHH{ IIMOIOT TotIHbIe peIueHII.q,coorBercrByloque paccMarprrBaeMbrM n pa6ore pe3oHaHcHbrM BparrleHr4.sra. OrzBparrleHr.rr [peAcTaBJrrroT co6ofi rnocKHe ABr4X{eHXr C[yTHr4Ka, ilPU KOTOpOMoAHa r43 ero rJraBHbrx r{euTpaJrbgux ocefi raHeprlr4r4 HanpaBJreHa rr0 HopM€Lnrr KnnocKocrrr op6uru, a caM oH coBep[raer B rrepBoM cryqae oAuH o6opor ua6comonrou rpocrpaHcrBe 3a ABa o6opora rleHrpa Macc ro op6nre (ruuBpaIqeHI{x I:2), a Bo BropoM cnyqae rpr{ o6opora n a6coruorHoM rrpocrpagcrBe 3aABa oSopora I{eHrpa Macc ro op6rare (ruu BparqeHra.fl 3:2). B oKpecrHocrr4pe3oHaHcHbrx eparqeHrafiBO3MyrrIeHHof o .{Br4KeHHfl[onyrreHo pa3no)KeHr{eBpflATAMI4JIbTOHI4AHA.Bo nropofi rrtase AIlccepraLP4zr uccneAyerc;r ycrofivunocrb pe3oHaHcHoroBpalrleHutr rvrna l:2 c yrreroM ToJIbKo TIJIocKI{x Bo3Myrrleluir s Her4ccneAoBaHHbrxpaHee cnyqa-flx.

ilttx 3Toro cHaqaJra LrccJreAyerc.rr ycrofivunocr.rcoorBercreyxlulefr nzHeapl43onal*rofi crrcreMbr Ha ocuoBanukr aHaJrzr3a ropHefi eexapaKTepl'IcrLlrlecKoro ypaBHeHr4fl.3atena, e o6racr-sx ycrofiulrBocrrz n nnuefisol,rupu6nraxe]Huvr npoBoALITcfl crporiafi neluuefisrrfi alarrkr3 ycroftvranocrr4, KaK Bpe3oHaHcI{bIX, TaK I4 B Hepe3oHaHcHbrx cnyqarx. 34ecr, ocoSo cneAyer orMerr.rrb,qro aBTop BbITI0JIHIaJI aHaJII{3 ycrofivunocrlr B ToM qr,rcJre vr4.nfl AJrfl AByx oco6r,rxsuaqeHl4fi SKcIIeHTpI4cIlTera, npl4 Koropbrx rrorpe6onalocb yqurhrBarb tureHbrAoluecro f o noptAKa BKJIIorII4TeJrbHo B p a3n ox{ envrvSyuxqran f aiuranrro Ha.B rperuefi rJIaBe Allccepraru4r4 B ruasefinoft nocraHoBKe HacneAyerc.flyc'rofivznocrb pe3oHaHcHoro BparqeHrzx rkrrra 1:2 cnyrHlrKa c HepaBHbrMr,rMOMeHTaMLI I{HepIIUU C rreroM KaK [JrOCKrrX, TaK kr rrpocrpaHcrBeHHbrxnosuyqeHnfi.eroropaccMaTpvBaeTcfl[ttscooTBeTcTByrorrdeexapaKTepl4crl4qecKoe ypaBHeHr{e a Ha ocHoBaHr4I4 rrr,ICreHHofo aHarr?r3a eforopuefr crpotrct AuarpaMMrr ycrofivr4Bocrr4 B rrJrocKocrr{ AByx He3aBracrrMbrxrlapaMerpoB 3aAaqkl.

Vcrofi.{nBocrb AaHHofo ABr4}KeHr{x lstararcKe r4ccneAoBaHaaH€L[I{TI{qecKIz npu MaJIrIX 3HaqeHlrflx rrapaMerpa sKcqeHTpucureia op6zur.P esylrrarhl vncreHuoro 14 a*arrvrr.rrrecKo ro Lr ccn eAo B aHvrfl xoporrroc o rnacyrorc{.B vetneprofi rJIaBe Al{cceprardr{r4 ana-r,ara [pr4BoAHTar €Lnropr{TMycrofiuurocrl{ [epl4oAr.rrrecKr4x raMr{JrbroHoBbrx cr4creM c AByM{creIIeH{MLI cno6o4rr, paspa6orannrrfi' paHee A.il. Mapreenrrrra ArrflHepe3oHaHcHbIX Cryr{aeB vr cnyqaeB pe3oHaHcoB Tperbefo vr qerBeprofolop.[AKoB. 3arev, I4cnonrcyt aHafioil{r{Hyro MeToAr4Ky, aBTop paspalatbrBaeruccneloBaH.vrraJIropI4TM I4ccneAoBaHvrfl ycrofiYuBocrpr ilepr{oAl4qecKr4x raMl4nbroHoBbrx cr4creMc AByMTI crerleHfMu cno6o4bl B cnyqae.pe3oHaHcoB nepBoro H BToporo noprAKoB.Buno4rrcx tBFIbIe Sopnaynr'r /{nr xoe$SHr{ueHroBHopManr43oBauHorooro6paxeuua.B usrofi rJIaBe [poBo.ql{Tc{BpaIrIeHHitr4ccneAoB aHueruna I:2 u 3:2 gtx cnyqaxycrofivrzrocrr4 pe3oHaHcHbrxAr{HaMr.rqecKr4 ckrMMerpr{qHoro crryrHrrKa cyqeroM KaK rInocKHX, TaK I4 npocrpaHcrBeHHbrx Bo3MyrqeHufi.

llonyveHrr o6nacruueycrofrvl4Bocrn n ycrofivllBocrz s rl4HefiHorra upra6nn)KeHuu. OKasanocb, qro Bluuefinolr npra6nzxenwlr yqer npocrpaHcrBeHHbrx Bo3Myrrdenufi ne oKa3hrBaertsIruflHvrfl' Ha BbIBo4r'I o6 ycrofivznocrr4. B roxe BpeM-rr, Helnrtefinufi aHanzsycrofivHnocrI4, BbIIIoJIHeHuufi Ha ocHoBe MeroAraKr4 uerneproft rJraBbrAI4ACepTaIIUTI{, [OKa3€Ur, IITO rrpocTpaHcTBeHHbre BO3MyrrIeHr4_rr MOryT npr,rBoAr4Tb Kueycroftur4Bocrn paccMarpuBaeMbrx npaulenufiHaytrnan IroBLI3rIa pe3ynbraroB.v nrtno4o"Avrccepraqnu cocrordrBcneAyrouleM:trPaspa6oraH €LJIropIlTM IzccneAoB anufl.

ycroftuunocru [epr4oAlrqecKr4xfaMr4JrbroHoBbrx cr4creM c AByMtr CTerIeHrMI4 CnO6O4rr B Cnyqaepe3oHaHcoB rrepBofo 14 BToporo noprAKoB.HafiAenrr rpr4 HoBbrx r4HTepBana snaqeHuii oKcrleHTpvrcr4Tera, BKOTOpbTX pe3oHaHcHoe Bparr{eHze rkrfra l:2 rlpu orcyrcrBr,rr{lpocrpaHcrBeHHbrx no:naylqeunfi ycrofivuno ro Jlxnynony.lloryvenrr BbrBoAbr o6 ycrofiuznocrrr rro rlxnyHony Arrfl AByxoco6rrx sHaqeHrafi gKcrleHTpvrcvrera, B KOTOpbTX AHAilVr3ycrofi.runocrr4 rpe6yer yrrera qreHoB Ao rrrecTofo noprAKaBKJrroqr4TeJrbHo B p €t:nox e:r.r4trSynrqHH f arvrranrron a.flocrpoeuu AvratpaMMbl ycrofivnnocrrr s nuHefiHona nprad ilLrlKeHLrLrpe3oHaHcHoro BpauIeHLr{ TLI\A I:2 Anfl crryrHuKa c HepaBHbrMr4MOMeHTaMT4 r4Heprruu.

3a[a'r,a pe[reHa c yqeroM npocrpaHcrBeHHbrxBo3MyrqeHraft. KpoMe rofo, n AanHofi 3aAaqe IIpr4 Malnbrx 3HaqeHr{fx3 K CII eHTp zrCVrT eT A nonyrl e H br alJ^arrwT l4qe c Kr4 e Bbrp alK eH vrflAnfl f p aHr4rlo6racreft uapaMerpurrecKoro pe3oHaHca.flpone4euo rroJrHoe vr crporoepe3oHaHcHbrx Bparqerruit rr4rrar,rccneAoBaHHe ycrofi.runocrr{l:2 u 3:2 lnxcily.c,iafr Ar{HaMr4rrecKr4cr{MM eTpr4lIHO f O CIIyTHI4 Ka.I'Iccre4ona:avre) BbIIIoJIHeHHoe aBTopoM Arrcceprarluounofi pa5orur,ocHoBaHo Ha [pI{MeHeHIaI{ crporr{x MareMarl{trecKr4x MeroAoB.

Pe:ylrrarr,rqucJleHHofo aHaITv3A XOpOIIO CofnaoyroTc.n c pe3ynbTaTaMvr, uonyqeHHbrMr4aHaJII4TI{qecKI4. lloerorr,ry AocroBepHocrb BbrBoAoB ALraceprarlur{ He Bbr3brBaercovseHnfr.launaxTeopI4rIAl{ccepralllaoHHaf,palora irHocrzr BKnaA Bpa3Br4Trle MeroAoBycrofivunocrl{ raMl4JlbroHoBbrx crrcreM, a ee pe3ynbrarbl r4 MeroAoJrorrl.rr14ccneAoBaH,LrflKJIACCI4IIECKOfiM0fyr[peAcraBJr.f,Tb r4HTepec Anfl cneqr{aJrr4croBu ne6ecnoft uexantrKn, araKxre AuHaMr{Kr4 cnyrHr4KoB.K;rnIOHHO14MEIOTC.'I CJIB o6lacruE 3AMEIIAHI4'' B rlane 4 npe4nolreH2.3.KoncrpyKTr4BHufi amopr{TM, rro3BoJr.f,rorrlr4ft uoryvarr,I{opManbHyto Sopnry SyHr<r1uu larvruJrbroHa 2n-nepuo4Hvecxofi cr4creMbr cAByMt crerleHtMu cno6o4bl npn HawrqLwr pe3oHaHca nepBoro nopsAKa. Ilpu3ToM yKa3hlllaerc.fl, rITo .{aunufr anfopl{TM Moxer 6rtrr IzIcfIoJIb3oBaH 14 npvrpe3oHaHce BToporo [opf,AKa. 3ro geficrnureJrbHo raK, oIHaKo, aBTopyAI4ccepraIJI4I4 crol4lo 611 6onee uo4po6uo ocraHoBnTbcr Ha gToM Bonpoce Irnonyql4Tb, f,BHbIe Qoprvrynu Anfr xoe$SraqLreHToB uoprraalruofi$opir,rufauulr,roHa B oroM cnyqae.B rJIaBe 5 AucceprarJnu LrcrroJrb3yrorc.r TepMrrHbr <<ycrofivuBocrb Ans6ollruuucrBa Haqanbublx ycronufi >> z <Sopna arrblafl ycroftvunocrb), oAHaKoorrpeAeneHr{r AaHHhrM rroH{THrM B pa6ore He Aarorc.f,.K coxaleHr{ro, n pa6ore [pucyrcrByror orer{arKa.

Tax, n @opuyne (2.26) uacrpanurle 38 n.rerneprofi crpoKe BMecro W j0 AJI9[OB€UIO ilOCTaBI4TbtrOS.VxaganHrre 3aMer{aHutl He BJru.gror ua o6qyro rroJrox{rrreJrbHyro oueHKypaSoru.Anrop rloK€tsaJI cno6o4noe BnaAeHr.re coBpeMeHHIIM MareMarl{rlecKI4MarraparoM reopLII4 ycrofivunocrll kr reopuvr az$SepeHrlrr€urbHbrx ypanHeuvfr."fexcr AtracepraL\vrLr :g'arrkrcar rpaMorHbrM MareMarHrrecKr4Mr3brKoM u r{Meercrporoe JlorxqecKoe rlocrpoeHlae. AnropeSepar Bepno 14 AocraroqHo rroJrHooTpaxaeT con ep)K aH vre l.na c epT ar\r4vr.[zccepraqus E.A.

rlercuHofi <<Zccre4oBaHr,re ycroffuunocrr4 pe3oHaHcHhrxBpalqeHl4fr cnyrnuKa Ha sJIJII4tITI4rIecrcofi op6ure> Hocr{T sanepueunrrfi xapaKTepkr 3acJlyxl{Baer nrtcotcofi oqeHKH. Pa6ora y.qoBnerBopf,er rpe6onauuxullocrasoulel{I4r{ llpanurerbcrBa P@ "O [oprAKe [pucyx{Aer{r,rr yqeHbrx creneHefi,a ee anrop r{erczna EereFlu-s ArexceeBHa, 3acJly)KnBaer [pncy)KAeHr4r yveHoficreIIeHIr KaHAI{Aar SH:raro-rr,rareMarzrrecKr4x HayK no clequ€urbHocrr4 01.02.01TeoperuuecKar MexaHr{Ka.3anegyrorquftrra6oparopaefiAoKTop Qnararo-laareMa.TlrrrecKr4x HayK.