Отзывы оппонентов (Двумерные нестационарные волны в электромагнитоупругих телах с плоскими или сферическими границами)

coBer A 2I2.I25.05B Alrcceprarlr4oHHbrfiBOrrprdO|EOY"MocKoscxzfiaBvra\vosHufi r{HcrnTyr (uaquosamsrtfir4ccneAoBareJlrcrprfiyHl4Bepcnrer)" MAIrI125993,r. MocKBa,A-80, BoroxonaMcKoeIIOCCe,n 4OT3bIBoQuqlanruoroorrnoHeHTaHa Axccepraunrc Becrsra B.na4Ilmupa Anarofl sesuqaHecraqlonapubre BoJrHbrB gJrenTpoMarH[Toynpyr[x",{nyuepnuereJrax crrJrocKtlvrH rrJrHcQepH.recKr{MH fpaHr{rlaMHtt, trP€AcraBJreHHofi Ha coI|cKaHHeyqeHofi cre[eHrr AoKTopa Qusu rco-MareMaruqecKnxHayI( no cfleuuaJrbHocrrr01.02.04- ttMexaHrrKa4eQopnrupyeMororBepAoro reJrarf,aBcoBpeMeHHofi TexHHKe B rrocneAHr4e foAblllu4poKoe rIpaKTHrIecKoenpr4MeHeHueHuxoA,aTgJreMenrbrxoncrpyrcrlrafi,$ynxqraouvpyou{ue na s(f$exrenonei.cBr3auHocrlr MexaHLIqecKLIxlt gJIeKTpoMarHI4THhrxno4o6uoiPa6otu,nocmul€uuueTeMarI,IKe paccMarpuBaJu4cb B ocHoBHoM B tlocraHoBKax orAeJlrHorossal4l\4oAeicrslls MexaHI4qecKI4x noleficgreKTpI4rIecKI4MIt,MaTH THIIMI{ utrnecJII{ no greKTpoyflpyrocrr4 ulrv repMoyflpyrocrllTeMneparypHrrv,u.

VI'I AaxegJreKTpOTepMOy[pyrocTlIpe3yJIbTaTBI,To I1oBcrpeqaloTct 3aKoHqeHHbIeB JII,ITepaTypeI,I ynpyrux noleiTeMarr4KeHeycraHoBltBlxeroct B3al4Mo4eficrnurSJIeKTpoMarHI4THEIxraxueny6nuKaqr4ll MoxHouccreAoBaHr4seo6racruBcrperl4T6 B eAIlHI4rtHLIx pa6orax.uecraquouapnoficero4u.ruruufi AeHbHecoMHeHHotBJltnrctC.ne4oaatenruo,gJleKTpoMarul4Toy[pyrocrltHaaKTyuuIbHEIMI4.B rrepBofr rJraBe aBTopoMnpoBoAurcfl.o6:op ro reMarrlKe Aucceprar]:ala.BO6rOpe ynOMI4HaIOTCt OcHoBHHe MoHorpaqu 14 n XypHaJIbHbIe CTaTLI4, I4MeIOqI4e3a nOcJIeAHI4eAectTxiIeTI4t.

flpe4Crarnexa O6rqarOTHOrleHrieK TeMe AI,ICCepTatIr4r4nnneapZOOrannOirrOCTaHoBKa3aAaq CBf,3aHnOfi:repuosleKTpOMarHLITOylpyrOCTI,I,COCTotHIlf,,z: rcorOpOfiBIIBoAI,ITCI3aMKHyTErtHeKOToporOHaqaJIbHoFOOTHocr4TeJIbHollpoqeccoB B lr3oTpofIHbIX IIpoBoAH Kax. Cssgr noneficr4cTeMa Anfl,kr3oTepMr4qecKr4x-5qtlr-;l:,uurin,i@:.{,wii;:er:renf|ocyqecrBJrrercr 3a cqeT cnJrhrJlopeHqa 14o6o6qeHHoro 3aKoHaOrr,ra.Ha ocHoBarruugrofo[pr{BeAeHbr cucreMuypaaHeHni coorBercrByrorqv x AByMepHhrx 3aAaq BAeKaproBofiu csepuqecKoit cncreMax KoopAt4Har.Bo eropofi HraBe rrpr4BeAeHanocranoBKa 3aAaqlt o6 enexrpouarnuroynpyrofinorynJrocKocrl.r, HaxoArureicq noA AeficrsueN4 HecrarluoHapubrx rroBepxHocru;rxHafpy3oK.

Ona uccne4yercr c ncnorb3oBaHueMnpeo6pasonanuir Jlatr,aca rro BpeMeHuu (Dyple no npocrpaHcrseHHoftKoopAl,rnare.Ocnosnar npo6leua 3aK;rrcqaercraopr4rr4HzuroB.Haxox(AeHur4furee perueHr.naBTopy yAaJrocbrrpr4Becrr,r[cxoAHy]opeKyppeHTHLrxLlcKoMbrxKpaeByro3aAaqyK cr4cTeMe3aAaqc noMorrlbropa3JroxeHr,rrt,tQynrquft B crerreHHbreprAhr rro M€uroMynapaMerpy cBr3Lr gJreKTprrqecKoroMexaHr4qecKoronorefi. Pelrer'vfl,^3a1aLt 3arrncErBarorcr B [HTerpaJrrnoft (fopue cs41paMr4,rBnrrorqraMr,rcr$yurqrarvra fpuna, AJrr Koroprrx orAeJrlHoperuarorcr 3a4aqLrNrflenerrpouanrutnoftra ynpyroiqacreft.uocrpoexluhu[oBepxuocrHbrx n o6l€unrrx Qyur<qufi fpuna ynpyrofi qacTu 3aqaqu npr,rrr,rerleuerempouaruzrHoficocraBJrrroqefinaxo4urcrOpuruna.lr lfynxqr,rlr lpzuaroqHo.ocHosaHHrrfiHa Lrx aHurvrrr,rqecKoMcnequalruuft a[rop[TM HaxoxAenr4ropl4rr4Huura,rorrHbrepeureHr4rHosofi scnoNlora'relrsofinpeAcraBreH[u. 3ro noggoJuerHaxoAr.rrbarra o6qefi cersaHHofi npo6leuuAeicrgnevo6leusoficr4Jrbr.

B3a.4aqno AB[xeHuI,r ynpyrofi [oJIyIrJIocKocrI{ rroA3aKrK)qeHI4I,I HIaBhI rrplrBoAf,Tct no4po6uueaJlropr.rrMbr peureHr4r o6u1r,rx cBr3aHHbrx 3aAaq o pacnpocrpaneHllll AByI\{epHEIxHecrarlrloHapHblxrroBepxHocrHhrxKr4HeMarlqecKl4xLtrLI 3reKTp[tlecrnx nosuyu{ealfiyx(e nai4ennrre paneeB gJreKTpoMafHn'r'oynpyrofi[oJrynJrocKocrr4,r4cnoJrb3yrcrrlr4e$yurqr,uafpuua.PesyllrarufiasrclpaBl4Tbcs c2 rrpeAcraBJurorct HoBhIMn.Anropy yAEUIocEAocraroqHo rpouos4xofi ananz:uaroi u noryql4Tb p.rA ToitHEIxperuenufi, B qacrHocrll3aAaq o HecraIII4oHapHoM ABI4xeHur,r ynpyrofio6leuuuxnoJIy[JIocKocrI4 IroA Aefictsuevcr4Jl I,I o HtxoxAeHl4x 3reKTpoMarHI4THoroIroJIt n AsulKylqeicsno3aAaHHOMy3aKOHyIOnyIUIOCKOCTIi.2BrperbefiHecraquoHapHbrxHraBecraBu tcs.ga4arta opaclpocrp ar-er.uugneKTpoMamnroynpyroiaosnayulenr.rfi BrroBepxHocrHbrxToJlcrocreHHofi cQepe.

Mero4cBfl3annatperxeHur ocHoBaH Ha pa3JroxeHr.rr,rB prArrco6c:rseHHrrr4Qyuxqnxrra oneparopa rasefinofinoreop[u ynpyrocrrr c [ocJreAyrorqr4MnpeAcraBJreHuervrrcoeQlpraqueuToBnocJreAHr4xB Br,rAecrerrenHbrx prAoB rro MrrJroMynap€rMeTpy, qro rro3BoJHeT cBecTr xcxoAHylo KpaeBylo 3aAaqy K peKyppeHTHorrlocJreAoBareJrbHocrr43aAaq, KaxAar r,r3Koropbrx r4ccJleAyerct He3aBrlclrMo./J,lrflperrreHrzrpaccMorperbAorroJrHr4TeJrlHo norpe6oralocr\xHoBEreraKverroJu B 4rlrxyrqefcrBcnoMorarerbHble 3a,qaql4KaK HaxoxAeHue 3JIeKTpoMarHr4THofono 3aAaHHoMy3aKoHy c$epe u o HecraqrroHapHoMABI{}KeHI,rzyupyrofi c(peprr no4Aeficrsraera3aAauHbrxo6l€usrrxBaxHhIMcr,rJl,rrro caMo rro ce6e qsrrercs oTAeJILHLTMpe3yJr6TaroM.7Aflpra peruexnr{ 9Tr{x 3aAaq, [oMr,rMo cloxnocreft,npeo6pasoaauurcBr3aHHhrxc o6paqeruevJlaruraca, Bo3Hr4Kaer Ao[onHr4TeJIbH{uInpo6nerua HaxoxAenl4t(pyurqrar.r fpr.rHa ererrpovaruuruofinecraqronapnofi Qynxqun fpunaqacrlrucrarlsaqav'v.

flpe4noxenoBMeproe€ xea3llcrarvqecxufi aHaIJIor.lprAep yflpyroit \acru 3aAar&r[peAJIoxeH cueqzalrnrtiHaxoxAeur,rr oplrruHzr.JroBctpyuxqufi qepe3gneMeHTapHLIer4cKoMblxocHosaHHHfiHa npeAcraBJreHr4naJrropl4TM,qTo n 4affineftureM [o3BoJILtJIo[ocJreAyroulr4Mpa3JroxeHr4eMB prA I1o 3KcrroHeHTaM,c floMoxlbto craHAaprHhIXTeopeMT@KII. B aarepruenuunafiru roqno r4x oprrrr4HEUIbIrJraBbfnpuBoArrcr anfoplrrMbr peueHr.lt o6qefi careansofi oceczulr,terpuvuoft 3a4a.rnrore6anuxx roJlcrocreHHoi cQepu no4o paAuurnbHbrxn e€ .racrHorocJryqar- gafta.c,r4eicuuenrHecraIIlIoHapHbIx noBepxHocruhlx Bo3Myrqexr,rfi.flpnro4rrcrcpaBHeHr{tToqHoro pe[reHr4r c aHEUIofIrqHoirza1a,reia,rge tpanc<popMulHThltAep o6paqanuclTII4CJIEHHO.flounuouHrepecuniperudnnoficsggaHHofi3a7aqvrrtaea3[peAcraBJlterpe3yJl6Tar B qacrl4 HaxoxAeHl4t roqHbrx perueNui,ce6s'B ToM qI'IcJIe HoBblxHecTar{rloHapHhtx CBt3aHHbIx 3aAarr e 4oynaepnofi [oCTaHOBKe 4lxcSepu.us'rOlCrocrennOiB vern€profiruaBe rrocraBJreHa3aAaqa o Hecrarrr4oHapurrxrone6anurxfipocrpaHcrBaco cSepuuecrof noroctrro nog geftcruueueJreKTpoMarHr4ToylpyroroHIaBe3 ueto4auu, cBo3Myrrleur4i.3a1aqapeuaerct aH€IJIorI{qHbIMI,IrroBepxHocrHbrxrofi pa*ruqef, qro B orJruque or roJlcrocreusofi cQepu a cl4ry ofpanr4rreHnocrl4tAepr,rHrerpaJrbHhrx npe4c:rannenlrixoe$Qr.rquenrorptAoBI,Ix BBIpoKeHIit qepe3He coAepxar gKc[oHeHT B 3HaMeHareJIe,.ITo yllpoqaergJreMeHTapuhre(pymqnnperreHbl neo6xo4zurreaJlfopr4TM o6parqenra-a.

[onolnurenrHoArfl r4rorosoficsqgaHHoi npo6nerr,trr Bc[oMorareJl],Hme ga4aqu o HExo)KAeHI4Ii gJIeKTpoMarHLrrHoroco cQepuvecxofi nonoctlrcrroJrr B ABl4xyrrleMcr [pocrpaHcrBeIt 3aAaqa oynpyroFo npocrpaHcrBa co cQepuvecxofi nolocrrroHecraquoHapHoMABr4x{eHr4r4no.q.qeficrsr4er\4o6lev rtrx craa.B"*nqrofiHlaBepaccMarpuBaercteJleKrpoMurrnllroynpyruftruaprtoAAeftcrsueN,rHecrarllroHapHrrx rroBepxHocrHErxBo3Myrqegrafi.flo auauloruu c rnaeaMl43u4crpor4Tcfla[ropI,ITMpeIIreHI4to6qeftgJreKTpoMarHr4ToylpyrocrrrAJII uapa. flapauenruocsqsaHuofisa4avl4peu€n pa4 BcloMofareJlb*rt*,'noHecrall[oHapHoe ABI4xeHueB Toxe BpeMr HoBbIx saAaq.

B qacrHocrlt t4ccJIeAoBaHbIynpyrororrrapa uoA AeficreueN,I o6lerr.trrxctrlnrgneKTpoMarHI,ITHoe rloJre BABr4XyxIeMcrno 3aAaHHoMy3aKoHyuape.B rlenoM crrr4Taro, r{To rrpeAno)KeHHbrfi vt peELIIIa3oBaHHbIfiB pa6orerBJrrercr HoBbrM gayqHLIM AocruxenxeM s o6racrz3reKTpoMarHr.rroynpyrocrll. B ouu.{uecBJ'3lr Me)KAy yIlpyrI4MI4rIoAXoAHecrallrloHapuofi cssganHoiolrpaAuquoHHhlxMeroAoB B [ocrpoeH[]rLr 9neKTpOMarHI4THblMl4 nOJI'MI4B3aAaqaxNntBJrteTCt XapaKTepHoeI4MeHHoAJI' IIpOBOAHI,IKOBHecTaHAapTHbIMnbe3oMaTepuEutoBnggTpoeHuesgazMHOfiCg.flgunoaefi C ngMorqbrc Culrt JlOpenqa, o6o6uldnnOrg 3aKoHaOrr4a uBBeAeH[t 6erpa:ruepnOrg napaMeTpa, CBt3bIB€lIoqerO XapaKTepI,ICTraKI4gJreKTpOMarHlITHorOI{ MexaH[qeCKOrOnolefi.llapa.nlelrnoperu€U tl ptA HOBLIXyKa3aHHbrxBbtrrre3aAaq MexaHHKu Ae$opMl4pyeMoro rBepAoro reJla.Pesyamarupa6orurraory'r 6urtperuenrafiAJrr reJl ranonluecrofiu cnlouuoftr4c[oJrb3oBaHblIIpI4 floc'rpoeH]rl4 HoBbIXreoMerpr4r,r,Tarux KaK 6ecrone.rnhli TorcrocreHuLltqr,I,II,IHApbI,6ecxoneqnuiclofi t't r.4.

Orn'revy crpeMJleHue aBTopa KpelxeHr4fi ArtcoorBercrBylou{I4x JII,IHeiHLlxB TaKoro poAa 3aAaqax q[cJIeHHbIxnocrauoBoK 6eg ucnonrgoBanns ^tpaAuL\I4oHHbIxHaxo)KAeHr4ro I1IMeHHo roqHbrxMeTOAOB,a TaK )Ke XOpO[ee BJraAeHI,IeMaTeMaTUqecKI,IMa[[apaToMTeopI4I4r upo6neuaM MexaHI'IKl4o6o6rqenusrx Qyurqufi 14MeroAaMI,tT@KII npI4MeHI,ITeJIbno4e$opnu4pyeMororBepAoro reJla.B 4ocronepnocrrl pe3yJrbraroB Ar4ccepralll4lt Her coMHeHLIt, nocKoJlbKy flpuHaxoxAeHuu pe3yJrbTaToBucnoJrb3oBaHbrKJracct,tqecKl{eMeToAbI oflepaltrI4oHHoror4crtr4cre:r'vr.,Teoplr[ o6o6rqennrrx $ynxqrafi, o6HrnoseHgrlx AnQ$epenqzzulbHblx'ypannenr.ri 14 'rpaAr4IIIrtoHHHeqI4cJIeHHbIeMeroAEI I{HTerpupoBaHI,u.

Kpoue sroro,pe3yJrbrarbt ruas 4 u 5 c nouorurrc [peAeJrEHLrxnepexo,4oBrlocrotuuo cpaBHLIBaJII4cr'c paHee[oryqeHHrrMri perrreHrlrMr.rB rJraBe3. B rrtaee 3 ro.rHoe pelreHl4e o4norvrepnofi3AAAI{II CpaBHUBaUIOCL CO CIIequEUlbHO [OryqeHHbIM"rAqVCJIeHHbTM pellreH]reMAJI'aH€LnoruqHoroMaTepI4EUra.He AI4ccepr a\vIV.Aerop eQepar rroJrHocrbro orp Dxaer coAep)I(aHCye" ro crlrcKy nnreparypbr B Arrccepra\hvr u aBTope$epare ocHoBHbIeeepe3yJrbrarbrony6nlrxonanrr s 54 pa6orax, 13 r.raroroprtx - B xypHaJraxlr3 cnl4cKa,I rorr'rurrotepua,rBAK P<D. O$t'rqlaarbuo 3aperurcrpl,IpoBaHapeKoMeHAoBannororpofpaMMa.IIo pa6ore IrMeK)TcflcJleAyrcqle 3aMeqaHlrfl.I.Yqerso6qeicltcreMeypaanenrlireMlleparypbl,6eayclonno,oAHaKoAls o$rqraxqenefi pa6otrr rBJIseTctJILIIIIHI,IM.[peACTaBJIteTctnOJIe3HbIM,2.