Диссертация (1140840), страница 8
Текст из файла (страница 8)
79;9?KL;ABKA?A ?@;@N9;@9NIA@I;9SAA (n = 106)79;9?KL;ABKA?9";>::R :9MALNK@<1 (n = 42)# (n = 51)2@ONRP ?;AKL;AP& (n = 13).1" <R:@HNLN9G@1 vs # — p > 0,01*32(76%)36(71%)10(77%)I@B:AK9HAW9MAA.1"!ATL;91 vs & — p > 0,01*& vs # — p > 0,01*14(33%)17(33%)2(15%);L?@QLNG@<9N9**1 vs # — p > 0,01*1 vs & — p > 0,01*& vs # — p > 0,01*.1" <R:@HNLN911(26%)16(31%)2(15%)1 vs # — p > 0,01*<@ <;LQJ1 vs & — p > 0,01*I@B:AK9HAW9MAA& vs # — p > 0,01*)LW>HVK9KR .1",30(71%)33(65%)10(77%)1 vs # — p > 0,01*< K@Q OABHL:1 vs & — p > 0,01*QN@I@B@B>GABK@L& vs # — p > 0,01*:@;9YLNAL;!"#$%&'(#%: * — ;9WHAOAJ BK9KABKAOLB?A NLWN9OAQR;** — :@?9W9NAJ ? .1" > U@HVNR= ULW $.- @:;LGLHJHA :@ ;LW>HVK9K9QN9I;>W@ONR= :;@U.79;9?KL;ABKA?9 ;L<9B?>HJ;AW9MAA QA@?9;G9 (<9;A9NKR >YL <R:@HNLNN@I@@:L;9KA<N@I@ <QLT9KLHVBK<9 A <@WQ@YN@BKA LL :;@<LGLNAJ) > N9TA= :9MALNK@<:;LGBK9<HLN9 < K9UHAML 3.18.4829UHAM9 3.18.
79;9?KL;ABKA?A ;L<9B?>HJ;AW9MAA QA@?9;G9 > :9MALNK@<,<?HXOLNNR= < ABBHLG@<9NAL (n = 106)79;9?KL;ABKA?9";>::R :9MALNK@<1 (n = 42)# (n = 51)2@ONRP ?;AKL;AP& (n = 13)!ATL;9)L<9B?>HJ;AW9MAJ<R:@HNLN9, < K@Q1 vs # — p > 0,01*OABHL:1 vs & — p > 0,01*1.D;12(29%)15(29%)4(31%)& vs # — p > 0,01*BKLNKA;@<9NAL14(33%)23(45%)3(23%)1 vs # — p > 0,01*1 vs & — p > 0,01*& vs # — p > 0,01*)L<9B?>HJ;AW9MAJ 9(21%)15(29%)1(8%)<@WQ@YN91 vs # — p > 0,01*1 vs & — p > 0,01*& vs # — p > 0,01*$K?9W @K2(5%)2(4%)1(8%);L<9B?>HJ;AW9MAA1 vs # — p > 0,01*1 vs & — p > 0,01*& vs # — p > 0,01*!"#$%&'(#%: * — ;9WHAOAJ BK9KABKAOLB?A NLWN9OAQR'@ ?@HAOLBK<> :;@<LGLNNR= .1", <?HXO9J A <R:@HNLNNRL W9 <;LQJI@B:AK9HAW9MAA, A OK@ U@HLL <9YN@ — :@ ?@HAOLBK<> <R:@HNLNNR= A:H9NA;>LQR= ;L<9B?>HJ;AW9MAP QA@?9;G9 G@BK@<L;NR= ;9WHAOAP QLYG> I;>::9QANLK.3.1.3.
D+OQ*(L&-&+K-J Q(T%L&-+/ K "($*%N&PO% -%Q(O%K+O(-+QL"TLQ-%/&+U (ITL&-.(T%%)LW>HVK9KR AW>OLNAJ ?@Q:H9LNKN@BKA :9MALNK@< :;LGBK9<HLNR < K9UHAM9=3.19—3.21.4929UHAM9 3.19. )LW>HVK9KR AW>OLNAJ ?@Q:H9LNKN@BKA (n = 106): B@UHXGLNAL;L?@QLNG@<9NN@I@ @U;9W9 YAWNA'@?9W9KLHV?@Q:H9LNKN@BKA";>::R :9MALNK@<1 (n = 42)# (n = 51)2@ONRP ?;AKL;AP& (n = 13)!ATL;9-@UHXGLNAL1 vs # — p > 0,01*IA:@HA:AGN@P1 vs & — p > 0,01*GALKR14(33%)21(41%)1(8%)< K@Q OABHL::@BK@JNN@& vs # — p > 0,01*1 vs # — p > 0,01*8(19%)15(29%)0(0%)1 vs & — p > 0,01*& vs # — p > 0,01*.>;LNAL K9U9?9,13(31%)20(39%)6(46%)1 vs # — p > 0,01*1 vs & — p > 0,01*& vs # — p > 0,01*< K@Q OABHL9(21%)10(20%)6(46%)1 vs # — p > 0,01*:;@G@HY9XK1 vs & — p > 0,01*?>;AKV& vs # — p > 0,01*!"#$%&'(#%: * — ;9WHAOAJ BK9KABKAOLB?A NLWN9OAQR& @KN@TLNAA ?@NK;@HJ N9G Q9BB@P KLH9 ?@Q:H9LNKN@BKV @:;LGLHAKV NL>G9H@BV, :@B?@HV?> :9MALNKR G9YL NL @B@WN9<9HA NL@U=@GAQ@BKA <R:@HNJKV<;9OLUNRL ;L?@QLNG9MAA.29UHAM9 3.20.
)LW>HVK9KR AW>OLNAJ ?@Q:H9LNKN@BKA (n = 106): :;ALQHL?9;BK<LNNR= :;L:9;9K@<'@?9W9KLHV?@Q:H9LNKN@BKA';ALQ BK9KAN@<";>::R :9MALNK@<1 (n = 42)28(67%)# (n = 51)36(70%)2@ONRP ?;AKL;AP& (n = 13)11(85%)!ATL;91 vs # — p > 0,01*1 vs & — p > 0,01*& vs # — p > 0,01*50';@G@HYLNAL K9UHAMR 3.20< K@Q OABHL:18(43%)24(47%)6(46%):@BK@JNN@1 vs # — p > 0,01*1 vs & — p > 0,01*& vs # — p > 0,01*';ALQ35(83%)46(90%)9(69%)9NKA9I;LI9NK@<1 vs # — p > 0,01*1 vs & — p > 0,01*& vs # — p > 0,01*< K@Q OABHL::@BK@JNN@1 vs # — p > 0,01*30(71%)33(65%)6(46%)1 vs & — p > 0,01*& vs # — p > 0,01*';ALQ ULK9UH@?9K@;@<,1 vs # — p > 0,01*39(93%)50(98%)12(92%)1 vs & — p > 0,01*& vs # — p > 0,01*< K@Q OABHL ::@BK@JNN@1 vs # — p > 0,01*27(64%)34(67%)5(38%)1 vs & — p > 0,01*& vs # — p > 0,01*';ALQ36(86%)43(84%)8(62%)A1'!**/#)1***1 vs # — p > 0,01*1 vs & — p > 0,01*& vs # — p > 0,01*< K@Q OABHL:25(60%)39(76%)4(31%):@BK@JNN@1 vs # — p > 0,01*1 vs & — p > 0,01*& vs # — p < 0,01!"#$%&'(#%: * — ;9WHAOAJ BK9KABKAOLB?A NLWN9OAQR;**A1'! — ANIAUAK@;R 9NIA@KLNWAN:;L<;9Z9XZLI@ SL;QLNK9;***#)1 — UH@?9K@;R ;LML:K@;@< 1II5129UHAM9 3.21.
)LW>HVK9KR AW>OLNAJ ?@Q:H9LNKN@BKA (n = 106): B@UHXGLNALK;LNA;@<@ONR= A URK@<R= N9I;>W@?'@?9W9KLHV?@Q:H9LNKN@BKA&R:@HNLNAL";>::R :9MALNK@<1 (n = 42)2(5%)2@ONRP ?;AKL;AP# (n = 51)& (n = 13)23(45%)0(0%)!ATL;91 vs # — p < 0,001K;LNA;@<@ONR=1 vs & — p > 0,01*N9I;>W@?& vs # — p < 0,05*&R:@HNLNAL9(21%)23(45%)12(92%)1 vs # — p > 0,01*;L?@QLNG@<9NNR=1 vs & — p < 0,001URK@<R= N9I;>W@?,& vs # — p < 0,05*< K@Q OABHL::;L<RT9XK:@I;9NAOA<9XK22(52%)16(31%)1(76%)1 vs # — p > 0,01*1 vs & — p < 0,05*& vs # — p > 0,01*!"#$%&'(#%: * — ;9WHAOAJ BK9KABKAOLB?A NLWN9OAQR.';A AW>OLNAA ?@Q:H9LNKN@BKA U@HVNR= B 7/#- (BQ.
K9UHAMR 3.19—3.21)BK9N@<AKBJ @OL<AGNRQ, OK@ @NA G@BK@<L;N@ @KHAO9XKBJ @KN@TLNALQ ? N9I;>W?9Q:K;LNA;@<@ONRL N9I;>W?A G@BK@<L;N@ O9ZL G;>IA= <R:@HNJXK B@Q9K@K@K@NA?A, 9:9MALNKR B BLIQLNK9;N@P GL:L;B@N9HAW9MALP O9ZL :;L<RT9XK G@:>BKAQRLN9I;>W?A. &QLBKL B KLQ G;>IA= G@BK@<L;NR= ;9WHAOAP QLYG> I;>::9QA QR NLN9THA.&@WQ@YN@, :;A U@HLL GLK9HVN@Q AW>OLNAA :;A<L;YLNN@BKA ? :;ALQ>N9WN9OLNNR= HL?9;BK<LNNR= B;LGBK< (N9:;AQL;, < «OLH@<L?-I@G9=») @NA URHA UR<RJ<HLNR, N@ ;LK;@B:L?KA<N@ >BK9N@<AKV [K@ URH@ NL<@WQ@YN@.523.1.4. D("#%+*+Z%NLKI(M W("(I-L"%K-%I( Q(T%L&-+/1".QQ( ! — K+O(-+QL"TLQ-%/&(M (ITL&-.(T%M Q+ -%Q.
&L/"+Q(-%% (n = 42)";>::9 1 (NL<;@:9KAJ) < W9<ABAQ@BKA @K KLOLNAJ /#- URH9 :@GLHLN9 N9:@GI;>::R. & :L;<>X (11) <@TH@ 9 :9MALNK@< B NLUH9I@:;AJKNRQ KLOLNALQW9U@HL<9NAJ. ,>YOAN URH@ 2(22%), YLNZAN — 7(78%). '@GI;>::> 12(UH9I@:;AJKN@L KLOLNAL /#-) B@BK9<AHA 33 :9MALNK9 (17 Q>YOAN A 16 YLNZAN).';A B;9<NLNAA :@GI;>:: :@ ;LW>HVK9K9Q @UBHLG@<9NAJ (BQ. K9UHAMR 3.2—3.18) G@BK@<L;NRL ;9WHAOAJ (p < 0,001; K@ONRP ?;AKL;AP !ATL;9) @UN9;>YLNRHATV :@ G<>Q :9;9QLK;9Q: :9MALNKR :@GI;>::R 11 O9ZL U@HLHA -0 2-I@ KA:9 —< 8(89%) :;@KA< 14(42%) BH>O9L<.
#@HVNRL B NL<;@:9KALP A NLUH9I@:;AJKNRQKLOLNALQ 7/#- K9?YL G@BK@<L;N@ O9ZL @I;9NAOA<9HA URK@<RL N9I;>W?A —8(89%) :;@KA< 14(42%).% <BL= 9-KA :9MALNK@< :@GI;>::R 11 ?@;@N9;N9J U@HLWNV GLUXKA;@<9H9$.-: > 2(22%) ANS9;?K@Q QA@?9;G9, > @BK9HVNR= 7(78%) — BKLN@?9;GALP (K@ON@>BK9N@<AKV Q@QLNK :@J<HLNAJ 9NIAN@WNR= :;ABK>:@< URH@ BH@YN@ AW-W9B@:>KBK<>XZLI@ ?9;GA@NL<;@W9).
& 9N9QNLWL > 5 :9MALNK@< W9G@HI@ G@ :@J<HLNAJ<L;ASAMA;@<9NN@P BKLN@?9;GAA [K@K GA9IN@W >YL AQLH QLBK@ < B<JWA B?9;GA@NL<;@W@Q. 2;@L U@HVNR= G@ :@J<HLNAJ /#- AQLHA < 9N9QNLWL [?BK;LNN>XI@B:AK9HAW9MAX :@ :@<@G> ;9WN@@U;9WNR= Y9H@U; AW NA= 2 <RWR<9HA «B?@;>X:@Q@ZV» NL@GN@?;9KN@. & G9HVNLPTLQ ?9;GA@NL<;@W @BH@YNJH @:;LGLHLNAL?H9BB9 BKLN@?9;GAA A NL@U=@GAQ@BKA :;@<LGLNAJ HLOLUNR= QL;@:;AJKAP.&BL U@HVNRL [K@P :@GI;>::R :L;LNLBHA ANS9;?K QA@?9;G9, AW NA= 2(22%)— G<9YGR. '@ G9NNRQ .1" > 8(89%) AQLH@ QLBK@ QN@I@B@B>GABK@L :@;9YLNAL;1-P U@HVN@P [K@ @UBHLG@<9NAL NL :;@<@GAHA < B<JWA B <@W;9BK@Q A B@:>KBK<>XZLP:@HA<9HLNKN@P 9HHL;IALP.
% 1-P U@HVN@P < 9N9QNLWL URH9 @:L;9MAJ 1.D, LZL >1-P — BKLNKA;@<9NAL.. Q@QLNK> <?HXOLNAJ < ABBHLG@<9NAL > 8(89%) :9MALNK@< URH9BKLN@?9;GAJ III— IV !. :;A NL<@WQ@YN@BKA :;@<LGLNAJ ;L<9B?>HJ;AW9MAA (>53<BL= ATLQAJ <L;ASAMA;@<9N9 N9I;>W@ONRQA KLBK9QA); > 1 — >BK9N@<AKV ?H9BBBKLN@?9;GAANL>G9H@BVAW-W9B@:>KBK<>XZLPKJYLH@PBL;GLON@PNLG@BK9K@ON@BKA (> NLI@ ;L<9B?>HJ;AW9MAJ K9?YL URH9 NL<@WQ@YN9).->ZLBK<LNN@L @I;9NAOLNAL SAWAOLB?A= N9I;>W@? > <BL= URH@ @KQLOLN@K@HV?@ :@BHL :@J<HLNAJ /#-./W 33-= :9MALNK@< :@GI;>::R 12 (UH9I@:;AJKN@L KLOLNAL /#-) > 9-KAAQLHA QLBK@ KA:AONRL 9NIAN@WNRL :;ABK>:R, > 7-A — NLKA:AON9J H@?9HAW9MAJ AA;;9GA9MAJ U@HA.
& 1-Q BH>O9L W9SA?BA;@<9N9 Q9H@BAQ:K@QN9J BKLN@?9;GAJ,?@K@;>X URH@ ?;9PNL BH@YN@ <RJ<AKV :;A ;9BB:;@BL AW-W9 QN@I@OABHLNNR=Y9H@U N9 ?@HXZ>X AHA G9<JZ>X U@HV < :;L?9;GA9HVN@P @UH9BKA NL?@;@N9;N@I@ILNLW9./, :L;LNLBHA 26(79%) U@HVNR=; > 9(28%) AQLH QLBK@ :@<K@;NRP ANS9;?K.$:L;9MAA ;L<9B?>HJ;AW9MAA QA@?9;G9 URHA <R:@HNLNR 24(73%) U@HVNRQ: <11(33%) BH>O9J= — 1.D, <13(39%) — BKLNKA;@<9NAL. ';A .1" > 22(67%)OLH@<L? URH@ <RJ<HLN@ QN@I@B@B>GABK@L :@;9YLNAL.. Q@QLNK> <?HXOLNAJ < ABBHLG@<9NAL > 7(21%) :9MALNK@< BKLN@?9;GAJ<@WNA?9H9 :;A B;LGNA= N9I;>W?9= (II !..), > 9(27%) — :;A Q9HR= N9I;>W?9= (III!.); > 16 (48%) U@HVNR= :;ABK>:@< BKLN@?9;GAA NL URH@. (ZL > 1(4%) :9MALNK9 BQ9H@BAQ:K@QN@PBKLN@?9;GALP>K@ONAKV:L;LN@BAQ@BKVN9I;>W@?URH@NL<@WQ@YN@, K9? ?9? @N U@JHBJ :;@<LGLNAJ ?9?@I@-HAU@ N9I;>W@ON@I@ KLBK9.1".QQ( , — K+O(-+QL"TLQ-%/&(M (ITL&-.(T%M Q+ -%Q.
K+O(-+-+&%% ( n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
![](https://s.studizba.com/z.php?f=/templates/si/i/noavatar.png&w=100&h=100&t=1"){kind=avatar}
