Отзыв официального оппонента 2 (1103820)

Просмтор этого файла доступен только зарегистрированным пользователям. Но у нас супер быстрая регистрация: достаточно только электронной почты!

Текст из файла

OT3bIBpa6oryo(f uqvranrnoro orrroHeHTaHa AprcceprarlrroHHyroKpacnonofi Arencan,upu KupuJrJroBHbrooMexaulrgMbrycnopeHun gn{Sy3rrrr KJracrepoBua.reuryftuarofi nosepxHocruot,(pu:uro-rrrareMarr,rqecKr,rxnpeAcraBJreHHyloHa corrcKaHzeyuenoft creneHr.rKaHAr4AaraHayKrro cleqrranbHocrpr0L04.07 @uszra KoHAeHcHpoBaHHofococrorHr4tr,{zccepraqux A.K. Kpacronoft npeAcraBnf,er co6ofi reoperkrqecKoe lrccJreAoBaHr4eqacrrirq,3aKoHoMepnocrefi croxacrr.rrrecxofi AI,rHaMIaKr{ AByMepHoro ancala6rsegaulaoAeficrByrorquxc 4nuxyrqeftcx rroBepxuocrbro. Pa6ora raMeer gKcnepraMeHTanbHyrorrpeAnocbrnKyB Br,rAena6nroAaeproftariouamno 6rrcrpoft gu$@ysrrr,rKnacrepoBpsAa MeraJrJroB[[porr.rrr4qecKoro rpa(frara. O6qeupuusrorono rroBepxHocrlr BbrcoKoopr4eHTlrpoBauHoroo6rscHeH[r groro rBJreHr.rrAo cr4x nop He 6ruro noryreHo, rrro rrpzAaer Ar{ccepraurEoHnoftpa6ore aKTyanbHocrr.

Vrasauurrft npoqecc flporeKaer rrpr4 co3AaHr,MAByMepHbrxcrpyKTyp(ronruxrrJreHoK,MaccrirBoBuaHouacruq) MeroAoM rasepuofi orrr,rraKcr{p1.IlonuruaHue ero3axonoMepnocrefi BaxHo [rfl pazur4Tr4qHaHorexnonorrafi,qro o6ecuequeaer rIpaKTI,IqecKyIo3HaquMocrb rrpoBe.4eHnbrx reoperrrqecKrixuccre4onanufi.o6rscneHzecynepau$$y3prurcBflsaHoc renJroBbrMABrrxeHLIeMcJroenrpa$ura Apyr rro Apyry, qro MoxerIIpI,IBOAT,ITbK yCKOpeHHOMy ABIrXeHr4rO KnaCTepOB 3a CqeT [epeAaquBoguoNnoer4M 3HeprUU B pe3ynbTaTenaauruo4eficrBvrfl.c ABprxyrqeficr rpa$rrosofinoAroNnoft.

Pa^enrarueerofi HAeH B paMKaxplnTepnperallllfl cocraBJrrJlooAHy rr3crarllcrlrqecrofi lrexannKr4 Lr ee repMoAr4HaMl,IqecKasfJraBHbrxAocrrrrHyrsrx qenefi flpeAcraBJrennofipa6oru. .{pyroff saNHoft uenbro Arrcceprarlr4r46ruro uareMarlrqecKoe I,IccJreAoBaHI,IeBo3HriKaroqrlx .qI,IHaMI,rqecKLtxpexr,rMoB c rroMorrlbloTeopulacryrafinux rpoqeccoB r.rqrrcJreHHbIXsKcrIepr4MeHToB.Ha grov nyru 6un noryqeH p{AHoBbIx pe3ynbraroB, Koropbre, MoxHo HaAe.rrrbc.rr,uaft.ayt cBoe [pLIMeHeHr{eAIrfl olancanvrflcoBeplrreHHor,rHbrxQrasuuecr<uxsnreuuft .nr{TeparypHoro o6sopa, onr4cankrfl.Lrccne4yeMbrx[uccepraqus cocronT r.r3 BBe.4envrs,pesynrrarauu, rJIaBhI,Susuvecxnx rd MareMarnqecKl4xnao4enefi,Tpex rJIaBc alaJrrTvrrrecKlrMr4rrocBflIrleHHofi.IucreHHoMy MoAeJrr{poBaHHIo,3aKrroqeHr.,rs.,crmcr.a coKparrleul,Ifin ycronusrxo6osHa.reHIEft,cnucnoB Jrureparypbr,prrcyHKonrara6uaq, a raKxe ognofo [punoxeHlrs.

Pa6oraI,I3noxeHa na 89 crpaHrrrlax, co,qepxr4t 79 nuteparypHbrx r,rcroqHlrron, 27 plrcyHKoB r{ 1ra6nzqy.Bo BneAenupro6ocnoBaHaaKTyanbuocrbreMbrAr4cceprarlrau,c$opuynupoBaHaocHoBHafnpo6lenaav pr4efl.ee pemeHr4"fl,rrocraBJreuao6qas qem pa6orbr- r.rccJreAoBaHr,recroxacrr4qecKr,rxnpoqeccoB Ha ABrrxyilIefics nosepxHocrr.ru c$oprvryrr{poBanbrKonKperHbrezanaqu, Koropbreneo6xo4IaIvropeilrl4Tb AJrr ee AocrH}KeHI,Ifl.[zuree lepelrr,rcJreHbrocHoBHbrelloroxteHr,r.s,BbIHocI4MbIeHa 3aIqI,ITy, o6ocnosaHrr :uayrrnafl.HoBH3Ha,Teoperl4qecKa-flu [paKTl,IqecKatr3Haqr4MOCTb,aTaKXeAOCTOBepHOCTb [OJryqeHHbrXpe3ynbTaToB,npr4BeAeHCrilrCOKxon(fepeHquit, na Koropbrx rrpoBoAr.rJracranpo6aqus.irvrx p$ynbraroB, onprcannuqHr,rftBKna.qcozcrareni B r4xnoryrreHkre,yKa3aHo6nenar{ crpyxTypa Akrcceprar\vv.B uepnofi rJraBecoAepxr.{Tcxo6:op nrrreparypbr,cocroflrquirus rpex pa3Aenoe.B [epBoMpI3HI,IX[poaHiInI,I3I,IpoBaHbrny6ruraqun, nocBsrleHHbre6unrrpAnrrM A[HaMr,rrrecKr,rMMoAeJrrMrrux [pr.rMeHeHrzrorrrfl orrlrcanvrs.Su:uuecr<ux ssnenlrfi.

Han6onruree BHhMaHLreyAeJreHorroHrrr4roycKopeHr,rr@epua, ero npzpoAe I4ycnoBLIrMBo3HHKHoBeHLrre 6vrupAnbrx cprcreMax.(DepuH B cnyqae croxacrr,rqecKoroABrrxeHrltrrpaHprrlycKopeHr4.f,flpune4eu pacqer Berr.rtrr4HbrpacceraBarenfl. Bropoftpa3.4en nr{Teparypuoro o6sopa nocBrrueH gKcnepr4MeHTaJrbHbrMny6rurxaqzxnro arE$$y3r4r{KnacrepoBr{3 aroMoBMerannoBHa rroBepxHocrurpa(pura. floxasano,qro Kaxyuuftcx xoe(f(fuqvreHrara$$yarEIrKnacrepar4MeeraHoMilJrbHo6onruyro BeJrr,rqr4Hy,HocraHAaprH)'ro appeHr{ycoBcKyro3aBlrcnMocrb orreMrreparypbr.

BrocJreAHeM pa3AenelepeqkrcreHbrJrnTeparypHbrecJroeB(ueuryerc)rpa$nra orHoclrreJrbHoAaHHbreo noABI,IXHocrr.rorofo ABprxeHr4f,,B qacrHocrr,r,Apyr Apyra, n o $arcropax, oflpeAenrrcruux xapaxTepr{crr4xr,rcBepxcKonb3Kocrb. O6sop nr{Teparypbr noABo.{r4T rrr{TareJrr K r.rAee florrcKa [purruHbrycKopenux@epurl B HccneAyerr,rBo3HlrKHoBeHr,rsofi S u:uuecrcoficucreue.Bo nropofi rJraBepaccMorpeH psA (fIa:uvecrrax rrao4erefi.llpeN4e Bcero, Ha ocHoBesKcnepr.IMeHTaJrbHbrxKnacrepoB3oJrorana rpa(fvrreAaHHbrxcAenaHBbrBoAo roM, uro 4raqp$ysr4figKc[epLrMeHTyHe Moxer r4MerbaKTr.rBarlrronnufixapaKTep.Bne4enrr ABe He nporr,rBopeqaur4eMoAeJrr,rnepeMerrleHr,rflKJracrepoBrro rroBepxHocrn: npaKTr.rqecKzcso6oAHoe ABuxeHr.rer{MeAneHHat4ra$(fysux B pe3ynbrare rrepexoAoBMexAy rreracra6purbHbrMrlcocrorulrsruu.

.{a-ueeoIII4caHbITpr4 TI,InaABr{xeHr,r{ueruyfir<nrpa$rara: 6ucrpoe KBa3r,rnepnoAurrecKoeABr4xeHr4e,6rrcrpoe cryuafinoe ABr,rlxeHr{er{ MeAJreHHoeclyuafiHoe ABr.rxeHrre.fnana 3aKaHrrr4Baerctpa3AenoM, fAe paccqprTaHaKpr,rTrlrrecKascKopocTb KJracTepa,rtpI,r npeBbrrrreHr4r4roropofi1utrcxpgnanMoAeJrbycKopenuxOepruu.6omrue ue o6ecne.rlrBaerBo3Hr,rKHoBeHr,reTperr.a rJraBa rrocBrrrleHao6o6qeuurc ypaBHeHr,rs@oxrepa-llnaHxa, orrrcbrBaroueropaccer.rBarersMr,r(ueuryfireABI{xeHI4e qacrllrlbr (rnacrepa) Ha 6ranrrpAe c noABraxHbrMurrpa(pura), ua crryuafrrepuoAlrqecxux rone6anzft creuox 6umxp4a.

C$opuynrapoBaHbrycJroBr4r,npz Koropbx r.BMeueHr,reMo.qynflcKopocrraMo)KHopaccMarpr4BarbKaKMapKoBcKr.rftupoqecc, nKoropoM pac[peAeneHlreqacrr,rq rro cKopocrrM orrrrcbrBaercsypaBHenuerrOorrepa-lllaur<a.Perueuue orofo )paBneHr{s rro3Bonser paccqr,rrarb Benuqr4HyycKopeHr4r@eprrrra,hpu srouoKtnblBaergfl,rITo oHa poBHo B Tpr4 pasa 6onure, qeM B cryqae, KorAa rone6auus creHoK1utrcxp4a Hocf,T croxacrurrecruft xapaKTep.[a"nee rroKa3aHo,trro pacaMorpeHHoeABlrxeHr4eMox(HooilucbrBarbc rroMorrlbroypaBHeHr{.flJlanNeeeHaKaKKBa3r{cra6nnrsrrfinopnenofi rrpoqeccBeccers.CyruecrneHnrrfir,rHTepecnpeAcraBnserTepMo,4prHaMr{qecKasrpaKToBKa 6unsxp4uofi[peAJroxeHHascorrcKareJreMMoAenr{.

PaccuarpunaxHepaBHoBecnsrftcrarr4crr4rrecrnfiaHcarr6nr (4nynaepHufiH4eamHsrfi ras) raxux cr4creM,B Koropbrx rracrr{rlbrnpuo6peraror oneprlrrc 3a c.rer reurolepegauu tn6o B pe3yJrbrarecoBepmeHr{rMexaHprqecroftpa6omr (npu croxacrr,rrrecKoMpaccer4Barerefi,coornercrnenno), ar4nepr{oArrqecKoMABrDKeHr4r4TaKXe frocrorHcrBo rrr4cra qacrr4rl s aHcal46re 3a crrer rn6enz (Hnruo6urusarluu) nan6oreeqacrr.IrIaMLI,col{cKarenbnpllxo.ql4TK6srcrprrx kr3 Hr4xkt rrorloJrHeuns.ancaM6rg naeAreHHbIMr4BbrBoAyo cyqecrBoBaHlrr4pexr{Ma co crarluouapHbrMpaclpeAeneHr4eMcxopocreft aracrrrrr,xapaKTeplrsyevrru e$(ferrunnofirenneparypofi. Orueuaercx, qro paccMorpeunafl MoAenbnpeAcTaBnfleTTeopeTr4qecKr4ftlrHTepec, nocKonbKy B Hefi peanr43yeTcrIlpoqecc, KoTopbrfto6naAaerKBa3HpaBHoBecHbrMlrxapaKTepr{crr,rKaMl4,Ho Heo6fl3areJrbHoflBlrflercs.MeAJTeHHrIMBoBpeMeHH.Buerneprofi HraBe onlrcaH 4n$$yeraonuufi rpoqecc B 6ranrxp4nofi cr{creMe,xapaKTepl{:ytoqeftcxpacceuBareJrflMrr,pacrroJroxeHHbrMraB y3nax KBaAparHoitu:l.urpeyrolluoftnepnoAIlqecrcofipeurerKr414 LrMeroqr4M]rpa3Mep, cyuecrBeHHo rrpeBbrurarouufi paccrosuueMexAy lr'vtMut.PaccrrrorpeHHa.flMoAeJrborBerraer pexkrMy cr,rJrbHoronsararro4eficrBrlflMexAyKnacrepaMuu rpa$uronoft uoAroNxoft, rrpta KoropoM KJracrepcoBepmaer peAKr{enepexoAbrMexAy l,reracra6uJlbHblMl{lloragano, qro cpegruafiKBaAparcMeqeHI{{ qacrl4rlbrBcocTo.gHr,rsuu.raroficr4creMe pacrernponopq[oHaJrbHo KBaApary BpeMenlr, To ecrb na6lroAaercscynepan$(pysrzx.

Teprrro4zHaMvqecKaflTpaKToBKa3Toro pe3yJrbrara cBflsana c pocroMe(f$exruenofi TeMneparypbr qacrr4ubr B pe3ynbrare n:arauo4eficrBvrs.c paccer4BareJrrMr{,r4MerorqlrMn6ecrcone.*ro6onrruyro Maccy14TeMneparypy.llporznonoroxnrrftcnyuafi [oqrrir cno6o4lroro ABlrxeHr.r{KnacrepoBr{3freH s nsrofirJIaBeAl,Icceprallzn. CoornercrByrouar MoAeJrbrrpeAcraBnserco6oft AByMepHbrfiras Jlopenqapacce[Barerefi. floxasaHo, qro B oroM cnyqae noe(f(fuqrzenrco cry.rafiHblM pacrpeAeneHr4eMco BpeMeHeM,KaK rr AJrfl MoAeJrrd,4Ia$(fy:ura 6um-ap4Hofi uacrzqrr nanefiHo yBenl4qr,rBaercflusyreuuofi B rJIaBe4.

Taxanr o6pasorra,o6e uoAerr rpeAcKa3brBarorcynepau$$y3r,rrcqacrrarl,Koropat Moxer o6rscHsm ycKopeHHblftpocr crpyKrypbr ocrpoBKoBMeranJraHa rroBepxnocrr4rpa$ura.lllecras rJIaBa rrocBrrrleHa q[cneuHoMy MoAenrdpoBaHr,rro[oBeAeHus rracrurlbr B6nlrrp4ax . c ABl{xyrquMuc . rpaHr4rlaMr.r.Onucana co3.{aHHa{ corrcKareJreMrrporpaMMa, Bxoropoftpeanl43oBaHaBo3MoxHocrb [epr4oAI4qecKoro vrJrv cryuafinoropacrroJroxeHr.rtpaccel{Barelr.eit,a raKxe cnyuafiurrx rlnu rapMoHr.rqecKrzxxore6anprft HX creHoK. llpune4enupe3ynbTarbrBbrrroJrHeHHbrxc ee noMolrlblo pacqeroB, Koropble B IIenoM [oKa3aJrr{xopomeeconlacl4e c reoperrarrecKr4MurrpeAcKa3aHuflnavlHa6nroAaeMbrepacxoxAeHzr Bo3pacraror cyBenl{qeH[eMaMrrJrr.rTyAbrcKopocrr.rpaccerrnarereftv vx panuyca u o6t scHflrorcsHapymeHr,reMnpeAnonoxenuit, [pI,IHsrbIXB Teoperr,rrlecKl{xMoAenrx.MoNno cAeJrarb BbrBoA, rrro B Aucceprarluossofi pa6ore BbrnoJrHeHo.ueranbHoeI4ccneAoBaHVecreHKaMprvrroJrf{eHbrrLrnaMvKprAByMepHHx6umspHbrx crtcreMc noABr4xHbrMr.r(pvlsz.recru ocMbIcJIeHHbIe pe3ynbrarbr, no3BoJrrrorqrre o6rscHIlm na6ruoAaeurrfi BgKcnepl4MeHTaxycKopennsrftpocr MeraJrnuqecKl,IxcrpyKTyp Ha rroBepxHocrurpa$rara.Bce sHHeceHHbIecol4cKareJreMHa 3aIrIpITyrroJroxeHlrfl rrpeAcraBJrrrorco6oft HoBbreHayqHble pe3ynbrarbr.

Brrno4rr Lr peKoMeHAaur{uxoporrro o6ocnoeaHH. ,{ocronepnocunoryqeHHblx pe3ynbraroB o6ecne.reua npzMeHeHr{eMrr3BecrHbrxreoperr.rqecKr4xrroAXoAoBcrarncrzqecroft MexaHr.rKHvrHepannonecnoft TepMoAHHaMr,rKr,r,a raKxe qr4creHnoroMOAenr4poBaHpr'.Pa6o:ra HanucaHa AocrarorrHo JrofLrrlno, AocryrrHbrM s3bIKoM vt B IIenoM xopomoo$opunena, xor.fl r,rcoAepxr4ToreqarKr4z op(porpa(fuuecxueorupr6rcu.Brrcrcaxy p{.4 3aMeqaHufiu noNerralouit.1) Cn.ssr c lpra:uuecroftcucreuoft,ucnoJrb3oBasnofi rrrfl rrocraHoBKr4 3ara'ur4, rro MepeBbInoJIHeHI4tr,4llcceprarlzonnofi pa6orrr 6r'rna 6esno3BparHo yreprHa. Hu oAun u3 pacqerubxpe3ynbraroB He colocraBJreH c gKc[epr{MeHTaJrbHbrMr.rAaHHbrrvru.Pa6ora cyx{ecrBenHo 6srBbrr4rpaJra, npeAJrorfl4xor.r{corrcxareJlb6urro3BonflroilIue npoBepaTb HeKoropbre H3 rrpeAcKa3aHuit reopuu.

Характеристики

Тип файла PDF

PDF-формат наиболее широко используется для просмотра любого типа файлов на любом устройстве. В него можно сохранить документ, таблицы, презентацию, текст, чертежи, вычисления, графики и всё остальное, что можно показать на экране любого устройства. Именно его лучше всего использовать для печати.

Например, если Вам нужно распечатать чертёж из автокада, Вы сохраните чертёж на флешку, но будет ли автокад в пункте печати? А если будет, то нужная версия с нужными библиотеками? Именно для этого и нужен формат PDF - в нём точно будет показано верно вне зависимости от того, в какой программе создали PDF-файл и есть ли нужная программа для его просмотра.

Список файлов диссертации