Отзыв оппонента Пастушенкова (1097680), страница 2
Текст из файла (страница 2)
C~M0 ~6~MHpe3HaYeHHfipe3KOBbIpOCH3-3aO ~ H ~ P Y X ~ H H BR a . J I I o ~ 0 6 0 p a ~ a ~M ~ ~ H M T O ~ J I ~ K T P H Y ~ IIOJIRpH3aIJHH.CKO~~O n p e ~ e J I e H H b ~ eCMCnOJIb30BaHHeM C I I ~ K T P O C K O I I H Y ~ C K OHH@oPM~IJMH~~n a p a M e l p b 1 KpHCTa.JIJIMYeCKOr0nOJIR n o 3 ~ o n ~ nA.A.H)@MHAOBY KOJIHYeCTBeHHO O n H C a T b n O J I e B b I e H T e M n e p a T y p H b I eH o - ~ O A C H CBTTeIIJIOeMKOCTb~M~IHHOJIRX (AO 200 Tn).
B b ~ ~ e n mYTO,3aBHCHMOCTH HaMarHHYeHHOCTH, PaCCYHTaTb BKJIaA3@@eK~ 3 e e ~ a H aBCHJIbHbIX......-MarHHTHbIX-.P ~ C C Y M T ~ H HC~ IyzIeTOM~~CBepXTOHKOrO B ~ ~ H M o A ~ ~ ~ c T BBKJIaAHRH o - I I O A C H C T ~ M ~ IBTenJIOeMKOCTbH o A ~ ~ ( B OnpeACKa3a.JI~)~HasIHYHe H n o B e A e H H e B lTOJIe aH0MasIHHLUOTTKH,KOTOPbIe lTOATBepAHJIHCb CAeJIaHHbIMH n O 3 A H e e H3MepeHHHMH.
~ ~ O B ~ Ao6111~p~oe C p a B H e H H eMarHHTHbIX,MaTHHT03JIeKTPHYeCKHX,TenJIOBbIX,M a r H H T o y n p y r H X H C ~ ~ K T ~ O C K O ~ ~ YC ~B OC ~KC T~ BX a J I m ~ o 6 0 p a ~ Ho ~oA~~(BO~H O ~ - ~ N ~ ~ AH~ra~1~106opa~a~ ( B O ~ )H~ o G ~ ~ ( B OK~o )T ~o p, o e ~ O ~ B O J I H J I aOB T o p y c A e n a T bBbIBOA 0 ~ o J I ~ I I I o MBJIHRHHH H a MarHHT03JIeKTPHYeCKEIe C B O ~ C T BKPHCTaSLTIHYeCKOrO~,,_ _ .. -.- .
'nom. I I o ~ m a ~ YTOo , x a p a K T e p H ~ M ~ H ~ H cH nRo n e M H ~ e ~ n e p a ~ y p~oa ik ii 6 o n b r u H xMYJIbTHnOJIbHbIXKaYeCTBeHHOMMOMeHTOBCOrJIaCHHpeAKO3eMeJIbHOrOCKPHBbIMH~ ~ O ~ H ~ . J I H ~ H ~B 0O3 MB O~ XHH b~I eIHaXOAHTCRBIIPkIYHHbIOTMeYaeTHOJIHOMM ~ T H H T O ~ J I ~ K T P H Y ~ C KlTOJIRPH3aIJHH.O~~YMeHbIIIeHHRM~~HHTO~JI~KTPHY~CGoparax H b c o 6 e ~ ~ o eec ~KOppeJIRIJHHaIIOJIRpH3aqHH B HCCJIeAOBaHHbIXasasorpon~efi. ABTOPHOHaCM ~ ~ H R T H OH~M~P~HHRIIOJIII~H~~IJHH BBaxHocTb3 T 0 AaCT B03MOXHOCTb J I ~ Y I I I ~IIOHRTb x a p a ~ ~ e pT ~ - I A ~ ~ . ~ S C ~ . ~...-.(nOsKOJIbKyBO~)~,B3aMMOCBR3H ~ O J I X p H 3 a I J H H H M ~ ~ H H T H aHH30TPOIIHH.O ~ ~B CBR3H C TeM, YTO Ba.JIIo~060pa~axCAeJIaHHbIe06HapyXe~BbIBOAMH~ H ~ ~ H T c K MH~~~ ~H H T O ~ J I ~ K T & ~ H Y 3~ @C@KHe K~~~, TOAOCTHTHYTOenpeACTaBJIRIoTCRBaXHbIMH.npeACKa3aHHOrOaBTOPOMKOJIHYeCTBeHHOeOIIHCaHHeB O ~ M O X H 3KClTePHMeHTa.JIbHOeO~HCCJIeAOBaHHe~ H ~ ~ H T C KMO ~~~ H H T O ~ J I ~ K T P H Y ~ CIIOBeAeHWlnon~p~3Ha qo ~A ~~ ~ ( B OH ~T) ~~ I A ~ ~ ( BB O~ O~J I)I ~~I I I H XMarHkITHbIxIIpOBepHTbCAeJIa-HHbIeHH@oPM~IJHIO.lTOJIRpH3aqHHlTpeACKa3aHHRMOXHOO X H A a T b ,YTOHAaCTnonRx ~O~BOJIHTAOnOJIHHTeJIbHyIOl T p e ~ J I 0 ~ e H H b 1 f iaBTOPOMAJIRPaCYeTOBMeTOAn03BOJIHTOllHCbIBaTb H n p e A C K a 3 b I B a T b B 0 3 M O X H b I e r M r a H T C K H e 3HaYeHHR nOJIRPH3aIJHH BHeHCCJIeAOBaHHbIX6opa~axm 3 ( B 0 3 ) 4 , aB03MOXHOHBAPYrHX,cue~ J I H ~ K H xnoC B O ~ ~ C T B ~MarHHT03JIeKTPHKaX.M,~ ~ K J I H ) Y H T ~ J I ~ BOCbMaRH~RrJIaBaIIOCBRueHaHCCJIeAOBaHHIoOCO~~HHOCTnOBeAeHHR MarHHTOCTPHKIJHH H TenJIOBOTO PaCIIIMPeHHR B U I ~ M O ~ O P ~P T~ ~CXY.~nOJIeBbIX H T e M n e p a T y p H b I X ~ ~ B H C H M O CMyJIbTHnOJIbHbIXT~~~MOMeHTOB HOHOB ~ 0 ~H ' -~ m ~H 'O n p e A e J I e H H eMOMeHTOBII03BOJIHJIHMaI'HHTOCTpHKqHIOK O ~ @ @ H L ( H ~ H T O BBKOJIHYeCTBeHHOJ I H H ~ ~ ~ H ~KIOx M ~ H H ~ ~ U RHX~H~oJI~IIIBxOIIHCaTbH o A ~ ~ ( B OH~ )IIPOAOJIbHYIO~IIPOAOJIbHYIOHMarHHTOCTPHKIJHIOIIOIIepeYHyIOTrnl~l~(BO~4O T M ~ Y Y , 9 T O aBTOPY yAa.JIOCb O n H C a T b H ~ M O H O T O H H ~XI a~P~a K T e P MarHEITOCTpHmHEIH O A ~ ~ ( B HPEIO ~ )HarrpaBJIeHEIH~MarHEITHOrO IIOJIX BAOnb OCH C.
T a ~ x enOKa3aH0,6onbrrree kI3MeHeHEIe MarHEITOCTPHKqEIH AJIX IIOJIX B 6 a 3 H ~ ~ 0 fIIJIOCKOCTEI,iYeMYTOnPEIHalTpaBJIeHEIEI MarHEITHOrO IIOJIX BAOnb T P H T o H ~ . J I ~ H oOCEI,~~O ~ Y C J I O B J I ~ H O~ O J I ~ U I E I M E IkI3MeHeHHHMEIO ~ H ~ ~ Y XaHOMa.JIHEI~ H H ~OnEIcaHbI AJIX a . J I E O ~ 0 6 0 p a ~ TmA13(B03)4aEI n p e A C K a 3 a H b I AJIXa K T y U I b H b I X MYJIbTEInOJIbHbIX MOMeHTOB.T e n n o B o r o pacmEIpeHHXH 0 A 1 3 ( B 0 3 ) ~ H T m A 1 2 .
5 S c o 5(BO3)4.B3aKJIIOYeHEIEIC@OPMYJIEIPOB~H~I MHOrOYEICJIeHHbIeBbIBOAbIHPe3YJIbTaTbI~ ~ c c e p ~ a q k ~pa60~b1,o ~ ~ o in ei p e m c n e H E I e K O T O ~ ~ I~X~ H X J 26I O VHKTOB.-C p e a E I OCHOBHbIX lTOJIYYeHHbIX Pe3YJIbTaTOB CJIeAyeT BbIAeJIEITb CJIeAyIoII@fe:P ~ ~ B H TT ~~O ~ ~ T E I Y ~ C KMOAeJIb,~ ~ IlIO3BOJIRIOIIJaXPaCCYHTbIBaTbTePMOAEIHaMEIYeCKEIe XaPaKTePEICTHKEI ~ O ~ ~ TRM3(B03)4O B(M =Al, Cr, Fe, Ga)YEICTMX, 3aMeII@3HHbIX EI P ~ ~ ~ ~ B J I ~COCTaBOBH H ~ I XC JIEO~MMEIPeAKEIMH 3eMJIHMEI.-B n e p ~ b ~Pea c c w T a H b IXapaKTepHCTHKHKOJIEIYeCTBeHHaXaKT)G3JIbHbIeMarHmHbIe,MarHmoynpyrHe~ O ~ ~ T RM3(B03)4O BBHHTepnpeTaqEIXnapaMeTpbIPaMKaXCneKqocKonmecKHeEIeAEIHOr03KCnepEIMeHTaJIbHbIXAaHHbIX(napa~eTPb1KpHCTUIJIEIYeCKOrOII~oB~AnOAXOAa.EIOllpeAeJIeHbIlIOJIX, 3HaYeHHH O ~ M ~ H H ~R-Fe noneii, HkI3KOTeMIIepaTypHOe P a C w e I I J I e H E I e OCHOBHOrO COCTORHHX RHOHa BCJIeACTBEIe f-d B ~ ~ E I M O A ~ ~ ~ C T B E3 IHXa,Y e H m 3 ~ e p ~ H fyi p o ~ ~ e fOCHOBHOrOi-....MyJIbTHl-IJIeTaR-HOHOB,KOMnOHeHTbI g - T e H 3 O p a OCHOBHOrO COCTOXHHX R-HOH~KOHCTaHTbI aHkI30TPOIIkIEI F ~ - ~ O A C H C T ~EIMAP.).~I- Y C T ~ H O B MeXaHH3MbI~ ~ H ~ I H OlIklCaHbI CnOHTaHHbIe kl HH)JJ'qkIPOBaHHbIeBHeLLIHHMFe-FeHMarHHTHbIMnOJIeMC l I a 3 0 ~ b I e IIepeXOAbI.(~lf),EI, , IpeAKO3eMeJIbHbIXH C C ~ ~ A O B ~ K0HKYPHPyK)WPiXH H ~I/R:)'I .EI X e J I e 3 ~ 0 f i lIOACHCTeM B IIOJIHjW M a I H H T H j Wa~ri3o~ponam3 a ~ e q e ~ ~ b@eppo6opa~o~1xR!!),R?)F~,CAeJIaTbI I p e ~ n b ~ i b k e ~ E I0eBKJIaAOBI(BO, ),B O ~ M O X H O ~ peUIEI3aqEIEI~OTKTIOHeHHbIMH OT OCH C MarHEITHbIMH MOMeHTaMEIno3sonanoYrJIOBOrOaBTopyCOCTOXHHXXeJIe3a.
P ~ C YB ~A T~ HCH Oy r~J I~0 ~ 0 f i@a3enO3BOJIHJI B AeTaRIlX n p O a H a J I H 3 H p O B a T b IIOBeAeHEIe MarHEITHbIX MOMeHTOB R"'~)UFe IIOACHCTeM EI OlTEICaTb aHOMaTZHEI H a MaTHEITHbIX XapaKTePHCTHKaX n p H C @ ~ O B ~ I Xnepexogax. OTM~YY,YTO n o 3 ~ ~ enep e A n o n o x e H H o e y r n o B o e C o c T o H m e GMSIO3KCnepEIMeHTa.JIbHO 0 6 ~ a p y X e ~B0@epp060pa~ePrxY1-xFe3(B03)4.- B n e p ~ b ~n ep O B e A e H 0 A e T U I b H O e TeOpeTHYeCKOe HCCJIeAOBaHHe T ~ ~ H C @ O P M ~ ~ HM ~ ~ H H T HCTP~K*~IO~~npll p a 3 6 a ~ J I e ~ E I k 1H'M'pHeM B @epp060pa~eP r x Y 1 - x F e 3 ( B 0 3 ) 4 .EAEIHM~~T ~ O P ~ T H Y ~ C KIIOAXOAH~~II03BOJIHJI O n H C a T b B e C b H M ~ I O ~ H ~ ~ 6ora~b1iiCII~ K C ~ ~ ~ E I M ~ HM aTT eUp HI U~I HMarHEITHbIX~ I ~ ~COCTaBOB C X =XaPaKTePEICTkIKPrxYI-xFe3(B03)4AJIX1,0.75, 0.67,0.55,0.45 EI 0.25.- AOCTEI~H~TOOnEICaHHe MaTHEITOCTPEIKqHEI @ ~ P P O ~ O P ~ T OkIB ~ J I I O M O ~ O P ~ T O B .H a n p ~ ~ e pAJIX, P X A a C O ~ A H H ~ H aHB ~T O p y YAaJIOCb OnEICaTb O ~ H ~ ~ Y X ~ H aH O3 K C n e p H M e H T e HeMOHOTOHHOe..
. . - .nOBeAeHEIe MarHHTOCTPHKqEIkI EI H 3 M e H e H H e 3 H a K a CPOCTOM IIpEInOXeHHOrO B H e I I I H e r O MarHEITHOrO nOJIX.-n p e ~ J I 0 X e ~ 0 p H r E I ~ a J I b ~ b I f i MeTOAnonxpasaqa~~.I l o ~ m a ~ oYTO,xapaKTepOnEICaHkIXM~~HHTo~JI~KTPEIY~cEI~M~H~HHc Xn o n e MH~e~nepa~ypoH ~ H ~ O I I ~ L L T MyJIbTHlIOJIbHbIXEIXMOMeHTOB peAKO3eMeJIbHOrO H O H a HaXOgEITCX B IIOJIHOMKaYeCTBeHHOMCO~~~CEIH C3KCIIepHMeHTUIbHbIMkI3aBPiCPiMOCTXMEI5II03BOJIRIOqkIX KOJIkIYeCTBeHHO6opa~oH~ . ~ O B ~O qAe H ~KaHK O~~ @ @ H ~ H ~ H T OOIIkICaTb IIOJIRpkI3aqkIIO kI IIpeACKa3aTb ee IIOBeAeHkIe BHekICCJIeAOBaHHbIX AkIaIIa30HaXIIoJIeii kI T e M I I e p a T y p .M ~ ~ H ~ I T o ~ J I ~ K T P ~ IIOJIRPkI3aqkIkIIY~cKo~~K ~ kIK BCRKOe 60nbruoe HCCJIeAOBaHkIe, AkICCePTaqkIR A.A.
f l e ~ k ~ ~H eo n~a rau e H aHeAOCTaTKOB. B KaYeCTBe 3 a ~ e Y a ~ k IMOXHOfiOTMeTkITb CJIeAYIOqkIe:1. B p a 6 o ~ eaHaTIkI3HPYIOTCR 3KClTepkIMeHTaTIbHbIe KPkIBbIe HaMarHkIYHBaHkIR kIB o c n p m m k I B o c T k I An2 6onbruoii CoBoKynHocTkI n p e ~ c ~ a ~ ~ ~c ee n~ ee if ii c ~Y ~~I aC T ~ I@epp060pa~0~.O A H ~ KOTCYTCTBJQOTOCpaBHeHkIR HMeIOqkIXCR 3KCIIepkIMeHTaTIbHbIXKPkIBbIX H a OAHOM I ' p a @ k I ~ e . a a ~ ~ br p~a @ek I ~ k I II03BOJIkIJIkI 6b1 C 60~1b~oHarJIRAHOCTbIO OTPa3kITb 0 6 c y x ~ a e ~ Bp TeKCTe pa3HkIqY B O ~ H ~ P Y X ~ H HaHOMaTIkIRX AJIR JlerKOIIJIOCKOCTHbIX kI JIerKOOCHbIX @eppo60pa~o~.2.
He IIpOBeAeH 06qk1ii c ~ ~ B H H T ~ J aHaTIkI3I ~ H ~ IO~ ~~ H ~ P ~ X ~ HMaKCkIMaTIbHbIXH ~ I XBeJIkIYkIH MarHkITOCTPkIKqkIkI M e X A y @ e p p o 6 0 p a ~ akI~ ~~ J I I ~ M O ~ O ~ ~ TA~ ~MHHH.CpaBHeHkIe6b1no 6b1 XOPOLUkIM AOIIOJIHeHkIeM K kIMeIOqeMyCR B p a 6 o ~ eCPaBHkITeJIbHOMY aHaTIkI3y MaKCkIMaTIbHbIX BeJIkIYkIH ~ J I ~ K T ~ H Y ~IIOJIRpH3aIJkIkI.c K o ~ ~3. HacTpaHuqe145oneramaecTbBnepBoMYBeJIkIYeHkIR COAepXaHEuI IIpa3eOAkIMa @OPMHPY~TCR~ o ~ o p oBf ei m o pHaIIpaBJIeHkuI BpalIJeHkIR.AOJIXHO'IMepeMarHkITHlH CTPyKTYpa,B~ H T ~ I @ ~ P P O M ~ ~ nHo A~ cTH c~TIe M~ bM1 ~xene3a n o c T e n e H H o B p a q a e T c R6 a 3 ~ c ~ o~JIOCKOCTHii...I1.OT ~ p k ~ r o ~ m b O~ Co~ iIKi p M c T a n n a B H a n p a s n e H mIIJIOCKOCTH..yr"nonpeAnoxeHmBM~CT". ..OT T ~ H ~ O H ~ T IOCH~ H KpkICTaTIJIaO ~ ~B HaIIpaBneHkIkI ~ E S ~ I C H O6 b 1 ~ by K a 3 a H OI I p o T k I B o n o n o X H o e "OT~ ~ ~ ~ I cnJI0CKOCTE.IHoEBHaIIpaBJIeHkIkI T P H ~ o H ~ T I ~ OCkIH o ~K P H C T ~ T I J I ~ ~ ' .4.
HaPkICYHKe4.4 ( c T ~ . 145)IIOAnHCbKPkICYHKYHeCOrJIacyeTcRPkICyHKe AaHHbIMkI. B IIOAIIkICkI y K a 3 a H a 3aBHCHMOCTb.-.OTKJIOHeHkIR MarHkITHbIX MOMeHTOB XeJIe3a OT OCH "c", a H a PHCyHKe OT G ~IIpHBeAeHHbIMkIYrJIaHaIIJIOCKOCTH, T.e. 3HaYeHEuI YrJIOB OTJIkIYaIOTCR H a~HcH90 I'paAyCOB.C ~ M ~ Y ~HeAOCTaTKkIH H ~ I ~ HH B ~ 0 e 6M e p e H eAkIccepTaqkIkI pa6o~b1A.A. f l e ~ ~ ~ o ~ a .X a p a ~ ~ e p a s ypa6o~yxB qenoMco6oii 3aKOHYeHHOe aKTyaTIbHOeCCHkIXaIOTo6qeiiB ~ I C O K OOqeHKkI~~MOXHO c K a 3 a T b , YTO A A c c e p T a q m n p e A c T a B n R e TTeOpeTkIYeCKOekICCJIeAOBaHkIeMarHkITHbIX,MarHHTOyIIpyrkIX kI C~eKTpOCKOnHYeCKkIX C B O ~ ~ C T B3HaYkITeJIbHOrO KOJIkIYeCTBa(34)n p e ~ c ~ a ~ ~ ~~eonce~i pi e 6 o ~ a C~ ~~Mo ~r Go C T6Bo~p a ~ oRIvI~(BO~)~.~~~OCTOB~PHOCIIOJIyYeHHbIXpe3yJIbTaTOBTeOpeTkIYeCKkIXIIOJIyYeHHbIXIIOATBepXAaeTCRM O A ~ J I ~ G , COBpeMeHHbIXpe3yJIbTaTOBCAHCCepTaqkIkI CJIeAyeT OTHeCTkIkICIIOJIb30BaHkIeMYHCJIeHHbIX3KCnepkIMeHTaTIbHbIMkI,aanpo6k1po~a~~bMeTOAOBAaHHbIMkI.kIKCOrJIaCkIeMAOCTOHHCTBaM6ora~b1iiH J I J I I ~ C T P ~ T H B H ~MaTepHaTII~~(172PkICYHKa kI27 ~ a 6 n ~ q A) ,~ M O H C T P ~ I P Y I O ~AOCTkIrHYTYIOH~~CTeIIeHb OIIHCaHkIR 3KCIIepkIMeHTa.ABTOPOMCAeJIaH C Y ~ ~ C T B ~ HBKJIaAH ~ I B~ ~@ k 1 3 H ~ y MarHkITHbIX 2 ~ J I e ~ k I fBi o 6 n a c ~ k 1OIIkICaHPHIIOBeAeHkIRXapaKTepHCTkIKBpeAKO3eMeJIbHbIXC T k I M y J I k I p y I O ~ e e BJIkIRHkIea ~ 0 ~ a T I k I f iP.II03BOJIReTRM3(B03)4MarHkITHbIXHaIIOJIRXHkI3KOTeMIIePaTYPHbIXC O ~ A H H ~ H H ~YTO,,3KCnepHMeHTaTIbHOeYkICTbIX,peAKO3eMeJIbHbIMkIOnkICbIBaTb3aMeqeHHbIX3JIeMeHTaMkIkI,kIYTOYaCTHOCTH,RBJIIIeTCR BIIOJIHe O ~ ~ HkI MHH3KOTeMnepaTypHbIeC B O ~ ~ C T B~ ~ O ~ ~ TP ~ ~ ~ ~ B J I ~ HCOCTaBOBH ~ I xBaXHO,OKaXeT0 6 ~ a p y x e ~npeACKa3aHHbIX~e~ ~ B E aBTOPOMT T ~ I ~T~~ O P ~ T E I Z I ~ C IIOAXOAKH~~KOJIkIYeCTBeHHOB@H~HY~CKHXMOXeTCJIIOG~IMH6 b 1 ~ b npkIMeHeHIIpkI6HCCJIeAOBaHHH H APYrHX MarHkITHbIX MaTepkIZLJIOB C4fH3dHOHaMH.