Отзыв оппонента 2 (1090840)
Текст из файла
OT3bIB04lHU;HaJlbHOrOCepreeensrKaTaJlHTHqeCKHMnpeACTaBJleHHYIOonnonenra«OCHOBbIHa COHCKaHHeAKryaJlbHOCTbyxeaoä05.17.04 -TeMbIrrOCBSI~eHa paJpa60TKenonyseaaaTeXHOJlOrHHAHccepTaU;HH.OCHOB TeXHonorMMxnopaponaaaeaMeTaHaTeXHHqeCKHXpacnonararomeäOrpOMHbIMM sanacasraBew;eCTB.)J;aHHaSl ,lJJ1ccepTalJ,M9HHaSl paöorarrpoM3BoAcTBaxnopMcToronpapozraoronepeopaerrrauaarasa,BHa ero XßMMlJecKYIO nepepaöorxyBMexaHM3Ma peaxuaanpO.IJ:YKTOB.l103TOMYMO.IJ:enb, YlJMTblBalO~YIOKOMrrOHeHTaMM xaranasaropa,rrpO.IJ:YKTa npasoznrrnpenno.raranocsCBSl3aHaB nepnyropaspaöorarr,conpaacemreocymecrsnarouraxaKryMbHOH 3a.IJ:alJeH.oxacmrrem.aoroKMHeTMlJeCKMX.IJ:aHHbIXrrosaomrn asropyMaprnpYTOB,oxepezrs C nepecvorpovxnopaposanasMeTaHa.
AHMM3CO.IJ:ep)J<aTenbHYIOKMHeTMlJeCKYIOxaranaaapyexux)J;OKaJaHO TaK)J(e, lJTO KpaJnMlJHbIMM06paJOBaHßIOHe B3aßMO.IJ:eHCTBßeMeTaHa C MoneKynSlpHbIMpanee,onedmasr,CMHTe3a,B TOM lJMCne, B aasmae<PYHKIJ,MOHMß3aIJ,MIOMeTaHa, SlBMeTCSI,öesycnosao,HCCJleAOBaHHHPOCCMM,KOTOPbIH ncnonssyercaC03.IJ:aHMeHOBbIX ß YCOBeprneHCTBOBaHMecy~eCTByIO~MX rcxaononrä,oömerrpansroroCTaAMeHxosnrnexcarrepcrrercmse nepeära OT sxcnopra csrpsa K sxcnopryHOBH3HaMeTßnaSlBnSleTCSInepsoäTorrnMBHO-3HepreTßlJeCKOrOuemrsre rrpO.IJ:YKTbIOCHOBHoro opramrsecxoroHayxaasHaYK noB KOTOPOM rrOCTOSlHHOB03paCTaIOT. YlJßTbIBaSIcrpyxrypuOCHOBHOMKaK saeproaocnrens,nOA AaBJleHHeM»,OpraHHqeCKHXMeTaHa.
)J;aHHbIH npouecc3TMneHa, norpeöaocrnCHJlHHOH HPHHbIXJlOpHCTOro MeTHJlaCTeneHH KaHAHAaTaTeXHOJlOrHHoco6eHHOCTMrr03BonMT BnonyxeaaaOKHCJlHTeJlbHbIM XJlOpHpOBaHHeMCneU;HaJlbHOCTHoxacmrrensnsrapaöoryHa AHccepTaU;HOHHYIOa B3aßMO.IJ:eHCTBßeMeTaHa C conaaaueneaoroxnOPOM, KaKxaramrsaropa,TaKMM06PaJOM .IJ:OKaJaHaKaTMMTßlJeCKaSlaKTßBHOCTbOCHOBHbIXero KOMrrOHeHTOB.IIpaKTHqeCKaH3HalJeHßHueuuocrspa60TbIOCHOBHbIX napauerpoarexneparypanpouecca,3aKnlOlJaeTCSIB ycranonneaanpeaxnanOXM(cooraomenaeBpeMSI KOHTaKTa, COCTaB xaranasaropa),.IJ:OcTßraeTcSIBbICOKaSICeneKTßBHOCTbrro IJ,eneBoMYxnOPßCTOMY MeTßny.Ouemca•cOAepJKaHHH H CTPYKryPbIAHccepTaU;HHonTßMMbHbIXnpnpearenron,KOTOPbIX•Crpyxrypacrpanauaxzracceprauaa5IBJI5IeTC5Ixnaccasecxoä.,lJ;ßCCepTaU;ß5Iß3JIO)l(eHa Ha 196MalIIßHorrßCHoro TeKCTa ß COCTOßTas BBe.n;eHß5I,rnrreparypnororrOCTaHOBKli aana-m,conepxanas,excnepaaearam.aoäqaCTßBbIBO.n;OB,npanoxeaaaß cnacxaßxersrpexnacreämrreparypsr,oösopa,OCHOBHoromonoxaromero161HaßMeHOBaHße.BoBBe.n;eHßß zranopaapaöoranaocra,axryansaocrapa60TbIC<POPMYJIßpoBaHbInens ß OCHOBHbleaanaxaHOBß3Ha, reoperaxecxassaunrry,oöocaoaaaaeanpoöarnorß npaxrasecxaspa60TbI, a raioseßcreneaaeeßCCJIe.n;OBaHß5I,nayxaas3HaqßMOCTb, rrOJIO)l(eHß5I, B,bIHOCßMble Hanonpoöaoonacanacrpyxrypazmccepranaonrroäpa6oThI.nepsoäBcymecrnyromaxraroxe,[JIaBe(OE30PJU1TEPATYPhI)Ha ceroznonnnaä.n;eHbcnocoöosnanoaaropyxaaeraxaOKliCJIßTeJIbHOrO XJIOpßpOBaHß5I MeTaHa.
IlpoaeztenasräC<POPMYJIßpOBaTbOCHOBHYIOuem, pa60TbI ([JIaBaaanasn, xoropsre neoöxonavopennrrs.n;JI5Irrposenenaspeaxnan2), a TaK)l(e onpenenarsee .n;OCTß)I(eHß5I.OXM, oöpaöorxa'raroxe, MeTo.n;ßKß ßCCJIe.n;OBaHß5Ixnaeraxanposeztenaaxpovarorparpasecsoroxaramrsarope,.n;JI5Ionpeneneaaapeaxnaa.aaanasa,coapeaeansrxMeTo.n;ßK nonyaeanasxcnepaaearansnsrx.n;aHHbIX,a,lJ;eTaJIbHOe onacaaneorrpenenennaKOJIßQeCTBaxnopoaonopozraßCCJIe.n;OBaHß5Ixaranasaropoaß MexaHß3MaHaJIß3 rr03BOJIßJITpeTb5I rnana (MeTo.n;ßQeCKa5I QaCTb) BKJIIOQaer ormcaaaexarannsaropa,ormcamre,rrOJIYQeHß5IHß31IIßX OJIe<pßHOB, a.n;eTaJIbHO paCCMO'IpeHbI TeXHOJIOrß5I, xaramrsaropsr,npoueccanonpoönoecoztepacaaasMeTo.n;ßKliMe.n;ß Bß xnopa, a TaK)l(e npasreaeaae<pß3ßKO-xßMßQeCKliX MeTo.n;OB,TaKßXTaK P<l>A ß 3JIeK'IpoHHa5I MßKpOCKOrrß5I,He OCTaBJI5IIOTCOMHeHßll B .n;OCTOBepHOCTßrrOJIYQeHHbIXpe3YJIbTaTOB.OCHOBHble pe3YJIbTaTbI pa60ThI ß3JIO)l(eHbI B rJIaBaX 4-7 znrccepramra.coseranaenpasreneaaeoxcnepaverrram.asrxcoapeueansrxzmccepranaoanoäßpaCQeTHbIX MeTo.n;OB, aTaK)l(e onpaanaaaoe<pß3ßKo-XßMßQeCKliX MeTo.n;OBaaanasapa60TbI npezrnozorrsYnaxnoerr03BOJIßJIO asropyC6aJIaHcßpoBaHHYlO rro XJIOpy npamnmaansayroTeXHOJIOrßlleCKYlOcxesry rrpOMbIlIIJIeHHOllYCTaHOBKlinpouecca OXM.IIo.LJ:TBep~eHueHaY"lJHbIXnyönaxannsx.U3.LJ:aHUSlX.ony6JIUKOBaUuSIOCHoBHoeOCHOBHbIX.
pe3YJIbTaTOBconepacaaneITo MaTepUaJIaM zmcceprauaapa60Torryönaxosanoorpazceno.LJ:UCCepTaIIuu BB5 naysnsrxasropcxaxpa60TBBe,lJ;YInHX penensapyeauxnaysnsrx)l(ypmUIax,MHHHCTepCTBa oöpasosaaaaH HaYKH P<l>, a 'raroxe rrony-renaaroperpepara 'raxsce rrOJlHOCTblOcoorsercrayerBKJUOqeHHbIX BconepzcaamonepenensBAK1 rrareirr P<l>. Conepzcanae,lJ;HCCepTanHH.Ilo ,lJ;HCCepTanHOHHoHpaöore HMeIOTC}IcJle,lJ;YIOInHe3aMeqaHHH:1.IlposeztenaepeaKQHH OXMnocraaoaxysanasnmrreparypsr,B KOTOPOM3TOMY sorrpocynparrOBbIlIIeHHOM ,lJ;aBJlemm BbIHeceHO BH B Ha3BaHHe ,lJ;HCCepTanHoHHOHpa6OTbI,KaKHe npeavymecraaH rronpaxrnvecrorKaKOH npaxaaeonnaxoHe yneneaoBHHMaHH}I, He }lCHO,O)l(H,lJ;aIOTC}IOT TaKOH, oprannsanaanponecca.
PeaKnH}I HCCJle,lJ;OBaHarrpn 'rpex BeJlHqHHaX ,lJ;aBJIeHH}I:1,arvocrpepaouHaH60JIee rrO,lJ;p06HOHMeHHO npnKOTOPbIH OInYTHMO YJIyqlIIaeTC}I npaKaTaJIH3aTopa. IlposonanacsTaKOHopranasauaaH3 oösopa6 H 9 aTM., rrprrrev,,lJ;aBJleHHH.E,lJ;HHCTBeHHbIHnapauerp,rrOBbIlIIeHHH ,lJ;aBJIeHH}I-rrpOH3BO,lJ;HTeJIbHOCTbouenxa 3KOHOMHqeCKOH neJleC006pa3HOCTHJlH asroponnpouecca? BbIlIIe 9 aTM. 3KcrrepHMeHTOB He 6bIJIO. Ilosexy?BTaKOM cnysae spxn JI~ MO)l(HOHa3bIBaTb 3TO ,lJ;aBJIeHHeOrrTHMaJIbHbIM.2.qeM onpenenancsXOT}I 6bI npenaaprrrensno.oraesaer4.2.6BbI60p HOCHTeJI}I?EbIJIH JIH acnsrraasrTpe6oBaHHIO HaJIßqH}{ He6oJIblIIOH y,lJ;eJIbHOHnosepxnocra60JIblIIOe qHCJIO OKCH,lJ;HbIXHOCHTeJIeH,nanpnaep,aJIlOMOCHJIHKaT YKa3aHnonpaayxeaaernpyroroeroztpyrae HOCHTeJIHcpasneaaeKaKOrrTHMaJIbHbIHOKCH,lJ;THTaHa.
B paszrene(peKOMeH,lJ;OBaHHbIH), qTOC ,lJ;pyrHMH HOCHTeJI}lMH, HJIH C aJIlOMOCHJIHKaTaMHCOCTaBa.3.B pasnenerOTOBHJIHnpomrrxoä3.1. 3KcrrepHMeHTaJIbHOH qaCTH YKa3aHO, qTO KaTaJIH3aTOpB H36bITKe pacTBOpHTeJI}I C rrOCJIe,IJ;yIOIneHCYIIIKOH npa11O-130C.,[(aJIee npn HCCJIe,lJ;OBaHHHKaTaJIH3aTOpa 6bIJIO YCTaHOBJIeHOqTO COJIH nepaeaovepaopacnpenenensrrroerorrosepxnocraHpacrsopsrrrJIOXO npoaaxarorBnopsr.Ilpencraanaercs60JIee neJIeC006pa3HbIM B ,lJ;aHHOMcnysae HCrrOJIb30BaTbnpornnxyrroBJIaroeMKocTH (B03MO)l(HO HeO,lJ;HOKpaTHYIO)C rrOCJIe,IJ;yIOIneH,lJ;JIHTeJlbHOHCYIIIKOH rrpnKOMHaTHOHreaneparype.4.IlpencraanaercsKaTaJIH3aTOpe CsaxynopxeHMaJIOBep0}lTHbIM, qTO YBeJIHqeHHe coztepzcanas6 ,lJ;O8% npasenerMe,lJ;HBK TOTaJIbHOMYCHH)I(eHHIO rrOBepXHOCTHH rrOJIHOHrrop, HO 3TO JIerKO nponeprrrsH3MepeHHeM BeJIHqHHbI rrOBepXHOCTHrro E3Toöi.eaa rrop ,lJ;JI}I6 H 8% KaTaJIH3aTOpaCOOTBeTCTBeHHO,TeM öonee, qTO Heo6xo,lJ;HMbIHHHCTPYMeHTapHHHMeeTC}I (pasnen4.2.4 cTP.
99).5.HnrepecnoeKaTaJIH3aTOpeno6-8%06b5lCHeHHH (pasnen6.crenensxornaHe H3MeH5IeTC5I, K CO)l(aJIeHHIO, OCTaJIOCb 6e3pens«CKOPOCTbIO 06pa30BaHIDI»anerrrpe)l,CTaBJI5IeTC5I He BrrOJIHe0 CbeMe HJIH rrpOH3BO)l,HTeJIbHOCTH KaTaJIH3aTOpa (PHC.98, pHC. 43, CTp. 100, qaCTO B rexcre).7.HescernarrOH51THO, B qeM(Hanpavep,YCJIOBIDIX?CTaUICTHKa,TO8.Ta6JIHU;bInoseayaKIJ;eHTrrOBbIllIeHHOM)l,aBJIeHHH,(conepacanaeMe)l,H,BJIIDIHIDI(Ta6JIHu;a 4.8, crp.B9.He» (crp.H4.8,B rrapaxonsrrsr61-63).npnO)l,HHaKOBbIXECJIHaapsapyensrxHe )l,JI5I scex)l,eJIaeTC5I HaBrrOJIHe 51CHO,BpeM5IKOHTaKTa,)l,aBJIeHIDI 'raioxesronpocronapaxerpos)l,JI5InpoueccanposenenaenoseayorrTHMH3aU;HIOresmeparypa)erorrpOBO)l,51T rrpnB351JIH KaTaJIH3aTOpHeOXMnparrapaxrerpos1aTM.?OrrTHMaJIbHOrOIIpHCOCTaBa99).ueynaxaueTeKCTe )l,HCCepTaU;HH BcrpeqaIOTC5I«rrOKa3aTeJIH KaTaJIH3aTopa»«nosenenae4.7.OHa npasenenaIIoCKOJIbKYH3yqeHHHOTJIHqHe onsrrosaxcnepaaenros?)l,aHHOH cepanTOM...yaoca5.1, CTp.
105).CJIOBOCOqeTaHHeKoppeKTHbIM,41, crp.Ha6JIIO)l,eHHe 0 TOM, qTO rrpn YBeJIHqeHHH CO)l,ep)l(aHIDI Me)l,H B(crp.46),IlpaseneaasreH orresarxn:«HOCHTeJIb KaTaJIHTHqeCKOH aKTHBHOCTH» (crp.48),COJIeH Ha rrOBepXHOCTH HOCHTeJI5l» (crp.100), Ha3BaHHe pasnenassrpaaceaas5.2 (crp.64,108), nonexy111),«oöpanrrsBHHMaHHe HaTOJIbKO HOCHTeJIeH?3aMeqaHIDI He CHH)l(aIOT u;eHHOCTHH 3HaqHMOCTH ztaccepranaonaoroHCCJIe)l,OBaHIDIH He BJIIDIIOT HaoöuteerrOJIO)l(HTeJIbHOe nnesarneaaeOT pa60TbI.3aKJIIOQeHHe~HccepTaU;HOHHa51XJIOpHCTOroMeTHJIapaöoraCHJIHHOHKaTaJIHTHqeCKHMH.C«OCHOBbIOKHCJIHTeJIbHbIM XJIOpHpOBaHHeM)l,aBJIeHHeM» rrpe)l,CTaBJI5IeT H3 ce651 3aBepllIeHHYIOHa aKryaJIbHYIOTeMY, HMeeT cymecrseaaoe3HaqeHHeOpraHHqeCKOrOpa3pa60TKHOCHOBTeXHOJIOrHH rrOJIyqeHIDI 3THJIeHa.aBTopOMnanpaanenanpaaepe6bITbHapeurenaeBa)l(HOH)l,JI5I rrpHMeHeHIDICnonsana-ra -K HCCJIe)l,OBaHHIO MexaHH3MarrO)l,TBep)l,HJIH CBOIO 3<p<peKTHBHOCTbC03)l,aHH5I a)l,eKBaTHOH CTerreHHOH KHHeTHqeCKOH MO)l,eJIHpeKOMeH.lI.OBaHLIMeTaHa)l,JI5I HaYKH H rrpOMbIIlIJIeHHOCTH)l,HCCepTaU;HH nonxoznrpeaKU;HH OKHCJIHTeJIbHOrO XJIOpHpOBaHH5I MeTaHaHarrOJIyqeHIDIHayqHO-KBaJIH<pHKaU;HOHHYIO paöoryOCHOBHoroPaspaöoraaasreCHHTe3a,TeXHOJIOrHHu;eJIbIOrrOBbIllIeHIDInpoueccaH MOryT3<p<peKTHBHOCTHcy~eCTBYIO~MXrronyxarsMC03,UaHIDI HOBbIXKaTaJIMTMqeCKHX np0l(eCCOB,n03BOJUlIO~MXueaasre np0'uYKTbI OCHOBHOrOOpraHMqeCKOrO CMHTe3a.Pa60TaCOOTBeTcTByeTOpraHWIeCKMXBe~eCTBXMMWIeCKMXOCHOBBMnacnoprypaanenaxHn.4MCCJIe,UoBaHMM n.2TeXHOJIOrMqeCKMX npMHUMnoBTeXHOJIOrHM, II03BOIDIIO~MX pemarsöesonacaocra.»CneUMaJIbHOCTM 05.17.04np06JIeMbI-TeXHOJIOrml«Pa3pa60TKaHaYKoeMKMXpecypcocöepexeaas<pM3MKO-XMMMqeCKMXM 3KOJIOrMqeCKOM«Co3,UaHMe HOBbIX KaTaJIMTMqeCKMX CMCTeM M TeXHOJIOrMMnpOM3BO,UCTBaOpraHHqeCKHX npO,UYKTOBHa MX OCHOBe».,n;MccepTaUMOHHIDI paöora«IloJIo)KeHIDI0 nopsnxesceaCOOTBeTcTByeTnpMCY)KJleHM5I yseasrxcreneaeä»I1paBHTeJIbCTBa POCCMMCKOM<I>e,UepaUMMNQ842 OT 24M3MeHeHM5IIlocTaHoBJIeHIDI"Tpe60BaHIDIM(nn.9-14,UeMCTBYIO~eroIlocTaHoBJIeHIDICeHT5I6p51 2013r.IlpaBMTeJIbcTBa POCCMMCKOM<I>e,UepaUMMOT 21r.
Характеристики
Тип файла PDF
PDF-формат наиболее широко используется для просмотра любого типа файлов на любом устройстве. В него можно сохранить документ, таблицы, презентацию, текст, чертежи, вычисления, графики и всё остальное, что можно показать на экране любого устройства. Именно его лучше всего использовать для печати.
Например, если Вам нужно распечатать чертёж из автокада, Вы сохраните чертёж на флешку, но будет ли автокад в пункте печати? А если будет, то нужная версия с нужными библиотеками? Именно для этого и нужен формат PDF - в нём точно будет показано верно вне зависимости от того, в какой программе создали PDF-файл и есть ли нужная программа для его просмотра.
![](https://s.studizba.com/z.php?f=/templates/si/i/noavatar.png&w=100&h=100&t=1"){kind=avatar}
