2003 Лекции по философии, страница 15

J_g_>_dZjl;bh]jZnbybkhqbg_gby. J_g_>_dZjl±jh^beky\hNjZgpbb±\x`ghcLmj_gbHg[ue\hkiblZggbdhfijb\be_]bjh\Zgghcb_amblkdhcdhee_]bb^Z\Z\rbchq_gvohjhr__ihl_f\j_f_gZfh[jZah\Zgb_lZdZydhee_]by±ZgZeh]PZjkdhk_evkdh]hebp_y\JhkkbbgZqZeZXIX \_dZ<]h^mihke_hdhgqZgbydhee_]bb>_dZjlgZqZeiml_r_kl\h\Zlvih?\jhi_Zk]h^Zihklmibe^h[jh\hevp_fgZ\h_ggmxkem`[m±lZdhcimlv[ueqmlvebg__^bgkl\_ggufrZgkhfm\b^_lvfbj\]h^uLjb^pZlbe_lg_c\hcgu<Zjfbb[m^msbcnbehkhn \uihegye h[yaZgghklb \jZqZ wlZ jZ[hlZ hlgbfZeZ g_ kebrdhf fgh]h \j_f_gb Zihlhfm >_dZjl bf_e \hafh`ghklv m^h\e_l\hjylv ebqgu_ bgl_j_ku khklhy\rb_ \ bamq_gbbmkljhckl\ZfbjZIhg_dhlhjufk\_^_gbyfhgex[behklZ\Zlvky\ihkl_ebihqlb^hkZfh]hh[_^Zij_^Z\Zykvk\hbffukeyf<]h^mJ_g_m\hebekybaZjfbbb\iehlv^h]h^Z`be\hNjZgpbbkh\_jrb\jy^iml_r_kl\bcih?\jhi_]^_\wlhlfhf_glgZklmibehi_j_fbjb_Ihke_]h^Z>_dZjli_j__a`Z_l\=heeZg^bxihkdhevdm\hNjZgpbbmg_]h\hagbdZxlijh[e_fukdZlhebq_kdhcp_jdh\vx m]ey^_\r_c_j_kv\ljm^ZonbehkhnZp_jdh\v[ueZ lZd`_ g_^h\hevgZ ZgZlhfbq_kdbfb wdki_jbf_glZfb >_dZjlZ =heeZg^by [ueZ ih l_f\j_f_gZfkZfhckihdhcghcb^_fhdjZlbqghckljZghc?\jhiu±Zlfhkn_jZa^_kvkihkh[kl\h\ZeZaZgylbyfgZmdhcbnbehkhnb_cH^gZdhb\=heeZg^bb>_dZjlg_fh] mdjulvkyhlbgd\babpbb mqzguc ^h ihke_^gbo ^g_c bf_e gZijy`zggu_ hlghr_gby k p_jdh\vx Z jy^ _]hljm^h\m^Zehkvhim[ebdh\Zlvebrvihke_kf_jlb@b\y\=heeZg^bb>_dZjlih^^_j`b\Zehlghr_gbykhfgh]bfb\_^msbfbmqzgufbbfukebl_eyfb?\jhiukhojZgbeZkvh[rbjgZyi_j_ibkdZnbehkhnZ±hgke_^beaZihke_^gbfbgZmqgufbhldjulbyfb^ZbkZf\gzkg_fZeuc\deZ^\gZmdmkha^Z\ZgZeblbq_kdmx]_hf_ljbx<]h^m>_dZjlZ\ua\ZeZdk_[_r\_^kdZydhjhe_\Z`_eZ\rZy\ukemrZlv mq_gb_\baeh`_gbbkZfh]hZ\lhjZnbehkhnm[uehg_m^h[ghhldZaZlvkyhghlijZ\beky\R\_pbx h^gZdh kujhc b oheh^guc debfZl ih]m[be fukebl_ey ± >_dZjl kdhgqZeky f_g__ q_fq_j_a ]h^ ?]h hkgh\gu_ ijhba\_^_gby ± ©JZkkm`^_gby h f_lh^_», «F_lZnbabq_kdb_ jZafure_gby», «GZqZeZnbehkhnbb», «HibkZgb_q_eh\_q_kdh]hl_eZ».Mq_gb_ h f_lh^_ >_dZjl ± i_j\uc ij_^klZ\bl_ev jZpbhgZebafZ \ gh\h_\jhi_ckdhcrdhe_ ± kqblZ_l hkgh\hc bklbggh]h ihagZgby jZamf bklbghc ^ey g_]h ± ihegu_ b hdhgqZl_evgu_ agZgby Fukebl_evij_^klZ\ey_l nbehkhnbxdZd ^_j_\h f_lZnbabdZ ± dhjgb nbabdZ±kl\hewlbdZf_oZgbdZf_^bpbgZb^jm]b_gZmdb±djhgZIjbwlhfdZd_^bgh^_j_\hlZdbnbehkhnby^he`gZ[ulv_^bghc\k_f_zjZa^_eZfke_^m_lbkihevah\Zlvh[sb_l_hj_lbq_kdb_agZgbybbkihevah\Zlvh^bgblhl`_f_lh^ihagZgbyBf_gghihwlhfmmq_gb_>_dZjlZgZqbgZ_lkyk\hijhkZhf_lh^_.JZkkfhlj_gb_f_lh^Z gZqbgZ_lky dZd b m ;wdhgZ k djblbdb klZjuoijbgpbih\ ihagZgby \ qZklghklb >_dZjl h[jmrb\Z_lky gZ kbeeh]bafu :jbklhl_ey kf dZd hkgh\mkoheZklbq_kdhc eh]bdb ih _]h fg_gbx khq_lZgb_f ^\mo ihkuehd g_evay ihemqblv q_]hlhijbgpbibZevghgh\h]hgm`gubgu_ijbzfuNbehkhnnhjfmebjm_lq_luj_ijZ\beZf_lh^Z: i_j\h_ ± ke_^m_l ijbgbfZlv aZ bklbggh_ \kz qlh \hkijbgbfZ_lky ykgh b hlqzleb\h g_^Zzlih\h^Zkhfg_\Zlvkygbh^ghfma^jZ\hfukeys_fmq_eh\_dmLZdbfh[jZahf>_dZjlZ[khexlbabjm_l jZpbhgZevgmx bglmbpbx ± lh qlh ykgh b hq_\b^gh ex[hfm lZdZy bglmbpbybklbggZihhij_^_e_gbx±wlhkZfucgZ^z`gucf_lh^ihagZgby<lhjh_ijZ\behaZdexqZ_lky\lhfqlhex[h_keh`gh_ke_^m_ljZa[b\ZlvgZ [he__ ijhklh_ ^h l_o ihjihdZ qZklb g_klZgmlijhklufbbhq_\b^gufba^_kvbf_xlky\\b^mg_lhevdh\_sb gh bex[u_ ^jm]b_\hijhkubebihgylbyLj_lv_ijZ\behf_lh^Z±\u^_eb\ijhklh_ke_^m_lgZqZlvh[jZlgucimlvdkeh`ghfmIjbwlhfgm`ghg_bkihevah\Zlvkbeeh]bafuZkjZ\gb\ZlvjZaebqgu_ml\_j`^_gbybaZdhghf_jghklbg_h[oh^bfhihklhygghke_^blvaZkhojZg_gb_feh]bq_kdbok\ya_cZ lZd`_ bkihevah\Zlv ex[u_ ihemq_ggu_ \u\h^u ih fZdkbfmfm ^Z[u ihemqblv \hafh`gh [hevr__75qbkehgh\uo\u\h^h\GZdhg_pq_l\zjlh_ijZ\behaZdexqZ_lky\g_h[oh^bfhklbihklhygghdeZkkbnbpbjh\Zlv \k_ qZklb gZ dhlhju_ jZa[b\Z_lky keh`gh_ wlh h[e_]qbl ihke_^mxs__©kh[bjZgb_ªqZkl_c\p_eh_±a^_kvihkmlb^_eZnbehkhn]h\hjblh[m`_ mihfbgZ\r_ckyiheghc bg^mdpbb kf ©Kh[bjZgb_ª ^he`gh ij_^klZ\eylv kh[hc bf_ggh lZdh_ ihegh_i_j_qbke_gb_^Z[uh[_ki_qblvihegmx^hklh\_jghklvlZdbfh[jZahfihegZybg^mdpbyg_ihkj_^kl\_gghk\yaZgZk^_^mdpb_cbaaZq_]hhgZbihemqbeZ\lhjh_gZa\Zgb_±ijhlb\hiheh`gZy ^_^mdpby GZ hkgh\_ wlbo q_lujzo ijZ\be >_dZjl \ukljZb\Z_l k\hx nbehkhnkdmxkbkl_fm]^_hl^_evgu_jZa^_euagZgbyk\h^ylkydnbabd_nbabdZ±d]_hf_ljbbZ]_hf_ljby±dZe]_[j_:e]_[jZ\ukljZb\Z_lkykljh]h^_^mdlb\ghhlbglmblb\ghhq_\b^guoZdkbhfdkeh`gufml\_j`^_gbyfIjbgpbi khfg_gby.

<jh`^zggu_ b^_b Mq_gb_ h f_lh^_ g_ihkj_^kl\_ggh klZ\bl \hijhk dZdb_ `_ ml\_j`^_gby fh`gh kqblZlv bglmblb\gh hq_\b^gufb" >_dZjl bkihevam_lke_^mxsbcijbzfimklv\hdjm]g_lgbq_]hbklbggh]h\kzklZ\blkyih^khfg_gb_Gh^Z`_\wlhfkemqZ_kZfnZdlkhfg_gbyg_khfg_g_gZjZadlhlhg_dh_h[h[szggh_Ykhfg_\Z_lkylhhgfukebllZdbfh[jZahf©yfukex±agZqblykms_kl\mxªLZd>_dZjlijboh^bldk\h_fmhkgh\ghfmijbgpbimcogito ergo sumihemqZyl_fkZfufi_j\mxZdkbhfmH^gZdhh^ghcwlhcZdkbhfuhdZau\Z_lkyy\ghg_^hklZlhqghbnbehkhnmijboh^blkyijb[_]gmlvdihfhsb«\jh`^zgguob^_cª hg ml\_j`^Z_l [m^lh g_dhlhju_ b^_b aZeh`_gu \ q_eh\_dZ k fhf_glZ_]hihy\e_gbyWlhlZdb_ihgylbydZd[ulb_[h]Zkms_kl\h\Zgb_ihgylbcqbkeh^ebl_evghklvl_e_kghklvk\h[h^Z\hebZdkbhfu©g_evayh^gh\j_f_ggh[ulvbebg_[ulvª©bagbq_]hg_[u\Z_lgbq_]hª©\kydh_ijhly`_gb_^_ebfhª©mrZjZ_klv\k_]hh^gZih\_joghklvª© ª A^_kv >_dZjl g_ jZaebqZ_l bglmblb\gh]h b lh]h qlh bglmblb\gh hq_\b^gh gh^hdZam_fhgZijbf_jihke_^g__ml\_j`^_gb_\hagbdZ_lb^jm]Zyijh[e_fZhldm^Z[_jmlkyb^_bqm\kl\_ggh]h\hkijbylbyihq_fmq_eh\_dhljh`^_gbykihkh[_gqlhlh\hkijbgbfZlvbg_hagZqZ_leb\jh`^zgghklvlZdbob^_cqlhqm\kl\_gguchiulh[t_dlb\_gbklbg_g"=h\hjy h ©\jh`^zgguo b^_yoª >_dZjl \ qZklghklb h[jZsZ_lky d ijh[e_f_ ;h]Z ihfg_gbx nbehkhnZ ;h] ± ]ZjZgl kms_kl\h\Zgby fbjZ ihklhygkl\Z aZdhgh\ ijbjh^u \hafh`ghklbihagZgbyfbjZbbklbgghklbjZamfgh]hihagZgbyFukebl_evijb\h^bljy^^hdZaZl_evkl\kms_kl\h\Zgby;h]Z: i_j\h_±g_^himklbfhklve`b\fbj_g_le`bex[h_g_ijZ\bevgh_agZgb_±wlhebrvagZgb_\dhlhjhfhlkmlkl\m_lijZ\bevghklvZagZqbl_klvdlhlhdlh©hojZgy_lªfbjhlhe`b<lhjh_^hdZaZl_evkl\h]h\hjblhlhfqlhkZfZfukevhkms_kl\h\Zgbb ;h]Z dZd \k_kh\_jr_ggh]h kms_kl\Z fh]eZ [ulv aZeh`_gZ \ q_eh\_dZ lhevdhwlbf kms_kl\hf < lj_lv_f ^hdZaZl_evkl\_ >_dZjl ml\_j`^Z_l ba ml\_j`^_gby ©;h] fukebfªke_^m_l ml\_j`^_gb_ ©;h]_klvªQ_l\zjlh_^hdZaZl_evkl\hk\yaZghk l_f qlh ex[Zybglmbpbyhkgh\ZgZgZbglmbpbbh\k_kh\_jr_gghf[ulbblh_klv;h]_<k_q_luj_^hdZaZl_evkl\Z\_kvfZkhfgbl_evgu\i_j\hfg_h[hkgh\Zghhlkmlkl\b_\fbj_e`b\h \lhjhf blj_lv_fgZjmr_guijZ\beZf_lh^Z±g_lg_h[oh^bfhceh]bq_kdhck\yabq_l\zjlh_ijb\h^bldeh]bq_kdhfmdjm]m\_^v;h]b_klv]ZjZglbglmbpbbL_fg_f_g__>_dZjlkqblZek\hb^hdZaZl_evkl\Z m[_^bl_evgufb ohly hgb [ueb ^Z`_ keZ[__ koheZklbq_kdbo kf H^gZdhijbwlhf>_dZjlij_^\hkobsZ_l©lbibqgh_ªgh\h_\jhi_ckdh_ihgbfZgb_;h]Z±]ZjZglZklZ[bevghklbaZdhgh\ijbjh^ubkms_kl\h\ZgbyfbjZghg_l\hjpZ>_dZjllZd`_ijb\h^blg_dh_ih^h[b_l_h^bp_bihq_fm;h]]ZjZglihagZgby^himkdZ_l hrb[db \ ihagZgbb fbjZ ex^vfb" Nbehkhn hl\_qZ_l lZd ;h] gZjhqgh k^_eZe ex^_chrb[Zxsbfbky^ey[he__]em[hdhc]Zjfhgbb<k_e_gghcijbqbgZhrb[hd±\k\h[h^_q_eh\_q_kdhc\heb>eymkljZg_gbyhrb[hdgm`_gf_lh^dhlhjuc]jZfhlghgZijZ\blq_eh\_q_kdmx\hexgZihklb`_gb_bklbggh]hagZgbyMq_gb_hkm[klZgpbyoHkgh\Zf_lZnbabdb>_dZjlZ±mq_gb_h^\mokm[klZgpbyo: km[klZgpby ih hij_^_e_gbx nbehkhnZ wlh lh qlh g_ gm`^Z_lky gb \ qzf ^jm]hf ^ey k\h_]hkms_kl\h\ZgbywlhkmsghklvkZfhck_[yGZhkgh\ZgbblZdh]hhij_^_e_gby>_dZjl\u^_ey_l^\_g_aZ\bkbfu_km[klZgpbbijhly`zggmxbfukeysmxDZdke_^m_lbagZa\Zgby ]eZ\gh_k\hckl\h ijhly`zgghc km[klZgpbb ± ijhly`zgghklv ihjh`^Zxs__ \k_ ^jm]b_ k\hckl\Z76Ijhly`zggZykm[klZgpbybgZq_gZau\Z_lkyl_e_kghcbg_ij_ju\ghaZihegy_l\_kvfbj\_^vimklhlug_lihkdhevdmh^gZba©\jh`^zgguob^_cªml\_j`^Z_lmgbq_]hg_lk\hckl\bagZqblhghg_kms_kl\m_lIjhly`zggZykm[klZgpby±ihkmlb^_eZfZl_jbywlZfZl_jby[_kdhg_qgh ^_ebfZ h[ wlhf lZd`_ ]h\hjbl h^gZ ba ©\jh`^zgguo b^_cª \_qgZ [_kdhg_qgZ bh^ghjh^gZA^_kvgZ[ex^Z_lkyk\h_h[jZagZy]_hf_ljbaZpbyijbjh^u±>_dZjlhlh`^_kl\ey_lZ[kljZdlgh_g_ij_ju\gh_]_hf_ljbq_kdh_ijhkljZgkl\hbj_ZevgucfbjH^gZdhbah^ghjh^ghklbfZl_jbbke_^m_lqlhiehlghklv\kx^mh^bgZdh\Zhsms_gb_]h\hjblh[h[jZlghfl_eZh^bgZdh\uojZaf_jh\fh]mlbf_lvjZagmxfZkkm>eylh]hqlh[ujZaj_rblvwlhijhlb\hj_qb_fukebl_exijboh^blkyijbagZlvhlkmlkl\b_fZkkubh[ty\blvjZaebqby\\_k_dZ`msbfbky wlhfm kihkh[kl\h\Zeh b hldjulb_ =Zebe__f g_aZ\bkbfhklb kdhjhklb k\h[h^ghiZ^Zxsbo l_e hl bo fZkku >\b`_gb_ ± hlghkbl_evgh_ kf_s_gb_ ^\mo l_e ihwlhfm dZd^\b`_gb_ lZd b ihdhc hlghkbl_evgu >_dZjl \i_j\u_ nhjfmebjm_l ijbgpbi bg_jpbb ZlZd`_g_dbcZgZeh]aZdhgZkhojZg_gbybfimevkZLZdh\u k\hckl\Z ijhly`zgghc km[klZgpbb hkgh\guf k\hckl\hf \lhjhc km[klZgpbby\ey_lky_zg_ijhly`_gghklvKhhl\_lkl\_gghwlmkm[klZgpbxg_evayh[gZjm`blvhj]ZgZfbqm\kl\ ± hgZ dZd [u jZkl\hj_gZ \ l_e_kghf Q_eh\_d ± khq_lZgb_ ^\mo km[klZgpbc l_eh ±ijhly`zggZykm[klZgpby^mrZ±fukeysZyg_ijhly`zggZykm[klZgpby±gZoh^blky\rbrdh\b^ghc`_e_a_]heh\gh]hfha]Z Gh dZdb_ nmgdpbb fha]Z hlghkblvd ^_yl_evghklb ^mrblhevdhfure_gb_bebkhagZgb_\hh[s_bfukebbhsms_gby">_dZjlkqblZeqlhd^mr_hlghkylkyh[Z\b^Z^_yl_evghklbfha]Zh^gZdh`b\hlgu_ih_]hfg_gbxg_h[eZ^Zxl\lhjhckm[klZgpb_cihijbqbg_g_jZamfghklbbohsms_gbcL_fkZfufnbehkhnkh^ghcklhjhgu \ha\urZ_l q_eh\_dZ gZ^ `b\hlgufb ijh^he`Zy ljZ^bpbb ]mfZgbklh\ kf Z k^jm]hcklhjhguqZklbqghj_Z[beblbjm_lqm\kl\_ggh_ihagZgb_dhlhjh_hdZau\Z_lky\kz`_qZklvxfukeys_c\ukr_ckm[klZgpbbBf_ggh \ mq_gbb h q_eh\_d_ ©\kieu\Zxlª hkgh\gu_ ijhlb\hj_qby ^mZebafZ >_dZjlZih hij_^_e_gbx km[klZgpbb g_aZ\bkbfu H^gZdh ohjhrh ba\_klgu ijbf_ju \aZbfgh]h\ebygby^mrbbl_eZkh^ghcklhjhgu^mrZaZklZ\ey_lq_eh\_dZ^\b]Zlvky^Z[uhsmsZlvdZdb_lh \g_rgb_ ij_^f_lu k ^jm]hc klhjhgu khklhygb_ l_eZ \eby_l gZ jZamf ]heh^gucq_eh\_d^mfZ_lg_hlhfhqzf^mfZ_lkulucNbehkhnlZdbg_kfh]jZaj_rblvijhlb\hj_qby\_^v^eywlh]hlj_[h\ZehkvhldZaZlvkyhl^mZebafZkm[klZgpbcBlh]b >_dZjl ± i_j\uc ij_^klZ\bl_ev gh\h_\jhi_ckdhc nbehkhnbb kha^Z\rbc _^bgmx b p_ehklgmx dZjlbgm fbjZ \ dhlhjhc h^gZdh hklZ\Zehkv _sz g_fZeh ijhlb\hj_qbcGZb[he__ \Z`guf y\ey_lky kha^Zgb_ dhgp_ipbb ijbgpbibZevgh hlebqghc hl ;wdhgZ ± hkgh\hc ihagZgby ijh\ha]eZrZ_lky jZamf A^_kv >_dZjl ijb[eb`Z_lky d koheZklbd_ ihwlhfm_]hhkgh\ghcaZ^Zq_cklZgh\blkyhk\h[h`^_gb_hl_zhrb[hd^eywlh]hhl\_j]Zxlkykbeeh]bafub\u^\b]Z_lkyb^_y^_^mdpbbL_fg_f_g__nbehkhng_kha^Zeiheghp_ggh]h^_^mdlb\gh]h \u\h^Z k\h_]h mq_gby ba Zdkbhf f_lh^ >_dZjlZ [ue iheghp_ggh j_Zebah\Zg ebrvKibghahc Bf_ggh a^_kv \_jhylgh djh_lky ijbqbgZ fgh]hqbke_gguo ijhlb\hj_qbc dZjl_abZgkdhcf_lZnbabdbbmq_gb_h\jh`^zgguob^_yobmq_gb_h^\mokm[klZgpbyobgh\u_^hdZaZl_evkl\Zkms_kl\h\Zgby;h]Zijb\h^yldijhlb\hj_qbyfH^gZdhwlhebrvi_j\ucrZ]± ke_^mxsb_ ^_eZxl KibghaZ b E_c[gbp kha^Zxsb_ gZ [Za_ f_lh^Z >_dZjlZ aZdhgq_ggu_jZpbhgZebklbq_kdb_mq_gbyHkh[_gghklbihabpbbDbk_ez\ZDbk_ez\kqblZ_lbf_ggh>_dZjlZjh^hgZqZevgbdhfgh\h_\jhi_ckdhcnbehkhnbbihkdhevdm;wdhgg_kha^Zekh[kl\_gghcdZjlbgufbjZ±h[wlhfkf Dbk_ez\ hq_gv o\Zebl >_dZjlZ dZd hkgh\hiheh`gbdZ jZpbhgZebafZ hlf_qZy ijbwlhfijhlb\hj_qb_djhys__ky\^mZebaf_km[klZgpbcHglZd`_ijb\h^bl\ukdZau\Zgb_=_]_eyhlhfqlhh[jZsZykvd>_dZjlmfu fh`_fgZdhg_pdjbdgmlv ©A_feyªihke_^he]h]hieZ\Zgby \ fmlghf hd_Zg_ kj_^g_\_dh\hc nbehkhnbb Djhf_ wlh]h Dbk_ez\ \kihfbgZ_lk\hx©jZ[hqmx]bihl_amª±jZkkfZljb\Zyfukeysmxkm[klZgpbxnbehkhnbyhiylvqZklbqghklZgh\blky©fure_gb_fhfure_gbbª77;ZjmoKibghaZ;bh]jZnby b khqbg_gby.