Отзыв официального оппонента 2 (Роль органических кислот в механизмах устойчивости растений амаранта к действию тяжелых металлов)

OT3LIBoOr4uaanbHoro o[rroHenTa Ha Arrcceprar]r4ro By Bser 3yrra na reMy: (PoJrr, opfauzrrecKrixKucror B NrexaHu3Max ycrofivueocru pacreHHii aMapaHTa K neficreurc TI)KeJI6IX Merar,loBtno cnerluaJrbHocrr4 03.01.05 - tfusuororur u 6uoxutrtut paclenuitHa colrcKarrue yqeHoft creneHlt KaHA]tAara 6uonoru.recr<ax Hayr<Heo6xo4ururocrr, a raKxe 3HaqlrMocrr, u3yqeHl,ts noJrHocrrro He pacrpbrrbrx nepB[r{HbrxMexaHr43MoB ycTofirrfiBocTl4pacreuuii K AeiicrBlrrc Bbrco(rrx ronqenrpaqzfi qriHKa rz oco6eHHoKaAMrIg, SBI{IOTqUXC,f, ULIpOKO paCnpOCTpaHeHHLIMII IOJIJIIOTaHTaMT'I,BCBeTe BO3paCTaHIitypoBH.{ 3arpt3HeHl4r cpeA6i TsI(eIbrMIz MoTaJIJIaMT{ HacToJIbKO OqeBLIAHI,I, qTO aRTyaJrr,]rOCTbIucceprarlr4oHHoil pa6oru H9 Hyx,{aeTcr B oco6oM o6ocHoBaEriri.

Xorx n noc:re4ur.re 10-15 reTAocrrirHyr3Haqr,rreJrLHr,rfir4ccJre4oBamrenporpecc B rr3yqeEurr MexaHV3MoB ycrofiquBocrr.r pacreHrdl, uxu Zn sB pacreHrlsx aMapaHra B ycJroBu.{x noBr,rlreHHbrx Ao3 CdlprrMeHeur.IeM opIIruiHalILHr,Ix rroAXoAoBI{cpgAe cr4crroJrb3oBaHrieM pa3Hoo6pa3ubtx coBpeMeHHhIXMeroAoB I4Meer l{eocnopxMoe reoperlrqecKoe 3uaqeHlze. Teoperr.ruecxan 3HaqlrMocrb pa6orbrcocroltr BycraHoBJreHr4r4 Krro-reBofiponlr oKcanara B MexaHr{3Max,qeroKcl.IKarlrrr4 Ka.4Mr4.rr BJrl4crr,rx A. caudatus fiyreM $opMr4poBaHr,rr B Hr.rx Kpr4crannoB oKcaJrara KaAMlrr. TeoperuuecrclrBar(eH Br,IBoA o6 opuenrnponaHHocrr.r 6uoxr.rvprqecxrax flepgcrpoeK .]rcrpecca Ha unreucu(pzraquro aKKyMynrqrir4 Mararar{cra B ycroBl4qx Cd u ZnoKcaJrara, noATBepxAaroul.rii po:rsopraHuqecKIix KIlc]ror B MexaHr43Max ycroii.{r4Bocrn pacreuuit aMapauTa K nos4eficrnuro BbIcoKIixr<ouqenrpaqrdiCd u Zn,Teoperu.reclcr.r 3r{aqvMbrraxxeoAaHHbre3aBr.rcr.iMocrriuera6olraqecr<oro orKJrrzKa B Jrrrcrrrx aMapanTa or Bo3pacra nrrcra npu Aeficrsun CduZn.O6:serr r.rccle4oBanr.ir - Bt4ALr po4a Amaranthus flpeAcraBnrror rrpanTuqecxyro rIeHHocrtKaK Br,rcoKo[po,[yKr]rBHbre rruueBbrerr KopMoBbre Kynbrypbrz o6rexrsr gru$r.rropeue4uaqur.rcpeAbr, 3arp{3HeHHofi rs)(eIr,rMLI MeTaJUraMr{, yqr.rTLIBtuI Izx HaKorr}rTeJIr}HbIe Bo3Mo)nHocTr.r II3r{aqLITenr,Hyro 6uoir,raccy.Pa6ora ourzqaercx nounruoii, HalprrMep, Br[sHr4e KaAMrrr Ia qr{HKa Ha ponbopraHI4qecKLIX KIrcJIor B aKKyMyntrquu MeraJrnoB, Sopuuponanr,re (pr.icrarnnoB oKcaJrara KaAMur BJrrrcrbtx pacrenufi A.caudatus B rrpucyrcrBr4r.r B6rcoKr4x r<onqeurpaqllft Cd, uera6olrnecruftorK:rrrK Ha AedcrBne BrrcoKnx r<ouqenrpaqrzii MerarJroB, rz:yveuurrfi 4uQQepeuquponaHuo rroopraHaM AByx Br4AoB e|MapallTa.Crpyxrypa ALIccepraI{IrrI B[oJrHe craHAaprHa AJrfl Slrsuo:rorzuecruxll6uoxzrraraqecruxpa6or.

,{ucceprarlr4r r.r3Jro)r(eua na 178 crpaurzqax, cocror4T ri3 BBeAeHr.rr, o63opa rrzreparypbr,MareprzanoBr.rMeroAoB, pe3yJrbraroB u o6cyN4enux, 3aKrrorreHu.rr, B6rBoAoB, cnucxa coxpaulenaft,cnucxa Jrr4reparypu, roropsrft BKJrroqaer 362 ucrotuura, B roM qrrcJre 225 sa anrtuitclroM s36rKe.[uccepraqul ral;rocrpuponaua 71 pzcylmou u 3 ra6nzqauu.Moncno orlrerrnr, no:rnrrit, rroqrr4 ficqepflbrearoufiii oqepK rr4Teparypbr no reMe, BKrroqasMuorne u3 grrrx pa6o'r npuenexarorc.,{ raxrrecaMyro coBpeMenuyro.rpu o6cyrr4ennuaBTopoMrlonyr{eHHbrx pe3yn!,TaToB.r\^^A^\ruuuu u.reA)sr uuAqepKHyTL qeTKOCTb 14 JIOIIITIHOCTL BIIOCneAOBaTeJILHOCTIiu coorBercrBeHl{o B fiocrpoeH lr Alrcceprallul{: ocHoBHas fraBa cSKCIIepV MeHTan[,H6tX AaHHbrX pa3AeneHa Ha prA pa3IenOB ri MHO]KoCTBOlpoBeAeHHbIX liccne.EoBaHliiiLI3IOXeSIZeMrroApa3AeJroB, o6u;rsno r.iJrJrroorprrpoBaHHrlx pficynl(aMu.ocHoBHoIiqe,rlr u pacKpblTux)Bce ero cnoco6creyerAocrr{}KeHr]roBcex [ocraBneHH6IX 3aAaq.,{uccepraqaouu ax pa6ora By Brer 3ynra narncana xoporrr4M {3brKoM, Tqarerruo Bbrrrr4ranar4rlpeKpacHo oQopMneHa.OcuosHr,re rroJrolxerruq,BbrHocr.rMT,IeHa 3arIrzry, o6ocnosaul;t pa3HocropoHHHMI{3KCnepHMeHTan6HLIMrr r4CCneAOBAIlI.JtlMrl, C npIiMeHeHLIeM CaMLIX COBpeMeHHbrX MeTOIOB.B pa6orey6e4Ltrenr,no nora3aHo,KourleurpaqntM Cduro ycroftuunocru, pacrenuilu Zn oflpeAer.{erc;r slf$ercrunnrru cB.r3brBaHr.reMKaMapaHTaMerairJroBBbtcoKt4MB r{opH{xr.iux B rt4cr6.rrx npll yqacrlzu optaHlar{ecKl4x r<uclor.

C rloMolqL}o noeeiirxr4xxeJrarlipoBaHlzeMMeroAoB yAanocb AoKa3arb $oprrar'rponanr.ie KprzcrannoB oKcalrara KaAMr.rr B Jrlrcrr.rrx pacreuuiiB fipficyrcrBr{r4 BbrcoKr]xA.caudatusr<ouqeurpaquil Cd. Oco6o xoqercs BrrAeJl}rrb cepxrorzcclegonaurafi Mera6oru.recKoro orKnr{Ka na 4eficrnue BbrcoKrix rouqeurpaqilit Cdr4crroJlb3oBaHlieMMeroAa fa3oBoft xporraaro-rrracc-crrerTpoMerpIllr,reta6o:rurHlrx npoorzneii B sKcrpaKTax a3rIoA BJII4IHI{eM BbIcoKIrx xonqeurpaquiiJrrzcTr,eBu nopnefi AByx6ulnponeAeH64lorrpli crarucrurrecroii o6pa6orr<enoKa3ana 3r{aqr.rMocr}, 6zoxltNru.recKux nepecrpoeKBCaHaJIH3Br4AoB aMapaHra B HopMeCduZn.

Er,uo auuorupoBaHo ortr4cnonr,gonanrze MeroAa HaBHrrx KoMnoHeHTn Zn.u76^,re'ra6orrryoe.MaccLIBa AaHHrrxpacreHllsx orrbrrHblxBapIraHToB.Buzywmzagut ronqenrpaqufi Hr.i3KoMoneKyJrrpnrrx rrera6oruroB nyreM nocrpoeHur rerrnoKapr,BbItBITJIo Bo3pacraHl{e nyJroB oAHr4x coeAriHeHufi r.r cHr.r)KeHueBapIraHToBrrocpaBHeHzrocKo:rlrqecrBeHHr,rx cogepNaul.rftKoHrponeM.-Apyrux B pacreHrzqx oflLtrHLtxCle4yer BbrAerr4rr,pa3AeJrnoonpeAe.lleHr4roplga rrera6oluroB r.r Bo3Moxuocrr c 6o:nlrofi ynepeuuocrlrofoBoplirb o 6ltoxrzlru-recr<ux nepecrpoftxax pacreullit B ycnoBuqx rIoBr,rmeHHbIX Ao3o6cyx,qarr $opuirponanueMexaHr43MoBycrofiwreocrurlolta3auo, r{To KJIIoqeBlIMu coeAr.rueHlztMu4eiicrnueCd,u Zn rsrswrcr caxapa, aB .[vx slru. C rroMolubroMeraJrJroBHoBr,rx Me'r'oAoBs r.teta6orvqecKoM orKJruKe nopueil auapauranacrb.sx - oprannrrec]eie Kricnor[,r.Ec:ru paurue n 90-x ro4ax, KorAa M[,r HarrvHa,Tu uccneAoBaHur ycrofiuunocrli pacreurliiTs)rterbrM Merar,raM.rlvoNlto 6stlo roJrbKoBbrcKzr3brBarbfnore36t orHochrenbriorofo,rqroocHoBHbIMLI MoCTaMIT I4HaKTUBarIr4r{ MeTaiIJIOB B KOpHtX tBntIOTCt KIeTOrrHr,r9 CTeHKI4, a B JIIICT6'X'BaKyonlcopraHr4rrecr{r4Mr{ KucJroraM}t.To n uac'rolulee BpeM{ e gauuofi pa6ore sro yxenpuqeM C LIClOJlb3OBaHlIeM pa3JrrrqHbx, caMbrx coBpeMer{Hbrx.4OKa3aHO 3KCIepLIMeHTaJILHO,\4eTOnOB HCCneAOBaHI{r.Moxtuo c4e:raru HeKoropbre 3aMeqaulrs:C.22.

IImepurypHrrii o63op.(lloxapaKTepy pacnpeAeJreHr4r Cd, u Znv,expy opraHaMr4 pacreHr.lfiI{x fipfiqucnrror K I.icKJrroqareJrflM (exclurogepana.l I{ D{nepaKK)MyJrrropalr.> B ro x(e BpeM{, np}tcdonpeAereHHbrx ypoBHrxr.rnoco6enno Zncpeper{x KoHrleHrpaquu B HaA3eMHbrx opfaHaxIroryr 6rrrt Br'rue, r{eM B KopHrx, Ho He Aocrr4rarL ypoBHsfr4rrepaKr(yMynrropon. BugonfrinepaxKyr4yJrrropoB B npr.ipoAe orHocr.rreirr,Ho MaJro rr B Hrzx coAeplr(aHr.ie>1000 r'axrlr cyxoii 6uolraccr\ zn >10 000urxr/rcd 4olrrno 6urr(Reeves a. Baker, 2000; vogel-Mikus et al.,200s).c.22 Hetrcss roBopr'rrb o6ar<ryrrrynupyrorqeftcnoco6uocru pacreuuiiaMapaHTa, ueo6xogr.ruoYKA3bIBAT6 KAKOfi BIiA, NOCKOJIbKY 3TO NPEITMYIqECTBEIIHO BI,IAOBA'I XAPAI(TEPV CTI,IKA, A HE POAOBA'.Ha Pucyur<ax 12,21.,24,3r,47A,4BA, 49(I), 50(II) xopouo 6uno 6r,r clenarb pa3pr,rB rxxan;r Haneprlrr<a.rrHoft ocu,C.58.B rtrasevro6lr snauenrrr(MareprzaJl6luHr,r3Kr4xKonqeurpaqr.rfiMeroAbr uccJreAoBaHr4r))6suu orueuuno ur.rgnn.va puc.1 He Br4aHo.

KaKrIeorrbrrHr,Ierrpeacrauenu 4:rr o60Hx Br4AoB, cJreAoBaJro y(a3arb 3ro B rroanvca K prrcyHKy.C.74. Hetr'sst yrBeplrAarb, qro B ycroBusx al,Irrosuilnoro nv'taHus. BHeceHrze Cd u Zn oKetbrBaJr.oBapuaHrbrcrrrMynr{pyio4oe AefrcrBrze Ha nprrpocr 6uorraccr,r, KpoMe 3perLx nrlcrbeB, MoxHO roBoprirbToJr6Ko o reH.4eHr1rir4,T.(.

Her oqeHKri AocroBepHocrr.r,c.77. Puc.2r. BruqHuea pas6pocr4croqHr.rKoB a3ora Ha pacnpereJreHrrer4alnrrxBe:rr4n.armyMyJrrrluro cdroBopr, npHBoAr.rrcr roJrbKo aKKyMyJrrqur 3neMeHToB B pa3HLrx opraHax.BraZn. crporoAa:GHeilmuxpa3Aenax AeiicrBt4reJrbHo,4aercr orIeHKa paclpeAereHr.rs 3reMeEToB.c.79. HetrcssroBopt4Trr(rrpriorcyrcrBr,rr.r MeranJroBB lrpcAc) BKoHTpoJrbHoM BapaaHTeorHocr.rrerrHo Zn, r.r<. ero BHocr,rJrri s Aose 0.7 MKM.C.119.llpu o6cyN4enttrlpe3yJILTaroB Blr3yanr43aqrd.rIZ3 Jrr.rCTbeB r.r KopHefr aMapaHTa,nonropnocrefi B KaxAoMBapLIaHTexouqenrpaquii uera6o:ruros,BbrAcJlegHbrxuolruo 6luo orMervrE 3HarrurerbHyrc napua6elluocrronbtra, iITo oco6enno HausAHo floArrepxuBaer la6ulsnoctrnoKasareneft vera6o:touuoro aHarTu3a u Heo6xo4r.il,rocrb tsbuBJeHu.s crarvcrrzqecKu 3HaLrr.rMbrxpa3rrr4q4n.O4uaxo sru ue:rKr.re HeAoqerr,r He cHr4xaror o6rqeft nrrcorofi oqenrc.r .qucceprarlulr.Hecnaorpx naaBTopy y,qanoc6 no6ulye uanpan:renzit nccJreAoBalrar u Mgo)r{ecrBo noryrreHHr,rx pe3yJrbraroBuane<O6cyrrAeHr.re pe3ynbraron> xna,rru$uqr.rpoBaHHoo6o6rqurt ux,so3AaBcrpotHoe [pe.4c raBneHlze o ponH opraHHLrecKHX KI.Icnor B MexaHh3Max ycrofivaeocru pacreuliin4eftcrnuro Cd u Zn c ucrroJrr,3oBarrrzeM coBpeMeHuofi mzreparypu.

Sronrycnoco6crnye'r ror Saxr, qro Arrcceprar{v oHHoe r{ccneroBaHr{e Haqaro He Ha nycroM Meore, aaMapauraClI6fYfipoaonx(aer cepr4ro pa6or, rrpoBoArrMbrx Ha KalbeApe (rusao:roruu a 6uoxuir.rvv pacreuuilnoA pyKoBo.ucrBoira r.6.n.H.l.OclroroncrcofiBr,lnogr,r, csopuymponauH.breo6tevou..B Ar4soep'r'auuuAocroBepHbr,rny6oxo o6ocnosaHr,ruccJIeAoBaHlzt, ncnoilb3oBaHI4eM pa3JIIrqHr,x coBpeMeHHT,Ix Mero,4oBI4scer4MeroAI4I{XCCIEIOBAHTI'.flo:rararo, rrro Arrcceprartruonnoe rrccneAoBaHue ByBrer 3yrra He roJrT,Konocranreuuoii qeJrrr, Ho Brloclrr cyrqecrnennrril nrorag BMexaurr3MoBuycroiivunocru pacreHr'rit x 4eiicrnuro ZnaMapaHTy. Pesy:mrarr,r r4ccJreAoBaHu.,r By Bser 3ynraAocruraerrroHrrMaHrre o6rqe6l.Io:roruuecruxoco6esno Cd, npucyrqux He ron6Kolroryr 6utt ucnolrgoBanr,r rprirrreHrrr.rxypcoe rexquii no Sz:uo:rorrza u 6uoxnttuu pacreuuft, cflerlKypcoB rro Mrrr{epaJrbHoMy nr.iraHuroycroiivueocru pacreHzitK crpeccoBrrM ycnoBu;rM cpeAbr.Arpo6aquu pa6orr,r.

Pesy:trarrr rzccre4onaruii no reMe aor.lraALrBanucbHa pa3rr4rrHr,rxrrpecrrrrrrrbrx Kon$epenqlux.IIo lrarepua,raru Arrcceprarl[u ony6lurconano 10 pa6or.Taxuu o6pasorr,I cceprarJLrq By Brer 3yura uacor.rcKanr4eyueuoil c'renenuKar-rAuAara6uo:roruqecxux HayK "sBnl{ercx salepueunoit uayvno-rna:ru$ur<arll.ronuofi pa6orofi, n roropoicoAepxrrTct perneHlie 3aAaqu ycTaHoBneHu.s poiru opf aHl-iqecKl.ix Kr{cnoTBMexaHII3Maxycroftvueocru pacreuufi aMapanTa K AeiicrBliIo r.gxeJIrIX MeraJrnoB, uuerorqeit cyxjecrBeuuoe3HaqeHue An.x coorBercrByrorqefiorpacrn snanaii,aulreuuo Qu:uororuu li 6uoxlruurz pacreHu.ff,rlro coorBercrByer rpe6onaunmr n. 7 <lloroNesrl{ o floprAre rrpucy]xAeHrrr yueHr,tx creneneii>,a ee aBTop,By Brer 3yur, sac:ryrrunaer [p[cyxAenrrs ucKoa4oii yveuoil creneuu.OSurlua,'ruHurfi onnoHeHr.Begyrqr.iit nayuusrfi corpyAHr4x @fEYH Eoranrqecroro r4Hcrr4Tyrarzna.

B.JI. I(oirranona PAH.KauAllaar 6uororu.recrux, nay5, craprulrii nayvnliii corpyAHriKArercceeea-Ilon oea H.B.4 //L'ra'<,"u/'4r14 nroHs 2018r.{,,it'tstr"Hv,i:', \'.,^';:'.P*C'"\ * frq;f\-LnHni_'-iiHrrcTHT"yTa.