Отзыв официального оппонента (Сравнительно-морфологическое исследование желточного синцитиального слоя в развитии костистых рыб)
Описание файла
Файл "Отзыв официального оппонента" внутри архива находится в папке "Сравнительно-морфологическое исследование желточного синцитиального слоя в развитии костистых рыб". PDF-файл из архива "Сравнительно-морфологическое исследование желточного синцитиального слоя в развитии костистых рыб", который расположен в категории "". Всё это находится в предмете "биология" из Аспирантура и докторантура, которые можно найти в файловом архиве СПбГУ. Не смотря на прямую связь этого архива с СПбГУ, его также можно найти и в других разделах. , а ещё этот архив представляет собой кандидатскую диссертацию, поэтому ещё представлен в разделе всех диссертаций на соискание учёной степени кандидата биологических наук.
Просмотр PDF-файла онлайн
Текст из PDF
OT3bIBoQuqua.rrHoro o[[oHeHTaHa Ar{cceprarlrronnyro pa6ory Kongar<onoft ErcarepunrrA.nerccaHApoBHbr<<CpanuureJrbHo-MopSoloruuecKoe r{ccJreAoBaHrne }fi errorrHorocrrHlllrrrraJrbHoro cJrorr B pa3Brrrlru Kocrr{crbrx prr6>>, [peAcraBJreHHyroHa col{cKaHrre yrreHofi creuenu KaHArrAara dzoloru.recKrrx HayKro creqrraJrbHocrr{03.03.05- 6uolorzs pa3Bnrrrr, eu6puororuq[raccepraql{oHHas pa6ora E.A.
Konaarcosofi noeBf,rqeHa npo6leuav $oprr,ruponaHnx,crpoeHldfllrglrprlunHar\vn xerrorrHoro cLrHrlr.rrrraJrbHofo cJror(n{CC)nponusopuofienr6puoHantnofi crpyKTypbl, y npeAcraBurerefi rpex orprAoB Kocrr4crrx pu6. Axryaltuocrr,AaHHofo vccile!oBanurfl oqeB[AHaBcBr3r.rco sHaqr4rertHofi Ba]KHocrbrorpoQuuecrofi,Itop$orenerz.{ecxofi l,I LIMMyHHofi SyHrcrluft ckrrTurJr4urbHofo cJror Artx o6ecre.reHvfl. rtvralus.3apoAblllra rtI,IBorHbIXcrraepo6nacrr.rqecKr4M Tr,rrroM Apo6neHraxHa Bcexorarraxsu6puonalbHofo I4 HaqaJIbHbIX gTanax Jrr.rqr4HoqHoro nepr{oAoB pa3Br4Tnx.
Cu:egrzaltnuficloft[pLIHI,IMaer aKTLIBHoe yqacrrleB npoqeccaxcnequ$ur<aqvrz oHTolepMbr14BeHTpoirarepalHrofi Me3olepMbr, pa3Blrrlrfl nr4rleBapr4Temnofi u cepAer{Ho-cocyAr4 crofi cucreu,a raKxe ps,Aa rpyrkrx crpyKTyp B3pocnhrx pu6.[orocJ]e,qHero BpeMeHr4 cyrqecrBoBaJrone6onrmoe qzcro pa6or, [ocBf,rrleHHbrx rraop(fonoruzTJIaBHbIM o6pasonrHa3apoAblllraxrrsrofi crpyKTypbr,Jrr4rrrbBbrrroJrHeHHbrxpu6.Jrl4rruHKax npoMbrcnoBbrx BrrAoBI-{enrroAl{cceprallnonuofi pa6orbl E,A. Kon4axosofi nocnyxr4na rraopQo:roruqecKar xapaKreprrcrrrKaxeJlToqHofo oI,IHIILITTIaJIrHoIo cJIo.rI B eiu6pnoreHe3enepl4oAa rlpeAcraBl{renefi8uPerciformes (xoropra Euteleosteomorpha),npI4HaAJrex(Hocrr,rpu6 xapaxreprr3yrorcflK pa3rr,rrrHbrMTaKcoHoMr,rqecKr.rMpa3HbrMr.r ycnoBr.r.f,Mr4u GasterosteusraKxe o unoroo6pa3vrtru oco6ennocrrx opraHennpa3MepoB ra (foprurycnoxHeHl4n (foprvru flAep Ha cra4lrflxBr.rAbro6ntavus'co3AaHr4e npe4craueHuficrpyKTypuo-@yHxqzoualrnofi perr4oHanr43arlr4t4 X{CC, rlposBnrrotr1eitcstKoHIIeHTpaIII4LI ixeJrrorrHbrx BKJrroqe:euitaculeatus.rpynnaM zccneAoBaHHbreBaxnrnuu pe3ynbraraMr{ Ar,rcceprarlraoHnoft pa6oru flBurrrucbor<nrz4on pu6: Danio rerio, Cyprinus carpio koi, Misgurnus fossilis,Coregonus peled, C.
muksun, C. nasus, Stenodus leucichthys nelmaflouuuoJII{r{I{HorIHororpex orpsAoB Kocrrrcrux pu6: Cypriniformes (roropra Otomorpha),Salmoniformes (xoropra Euteleosteomorpha)KoropblM orHoc.t{TcflI{ Ha HarIiuIbHbIX gTarlaxraep XCC,spa3nr4r{r4-rrx rtoB pa3Hbrx yqacrKaxXCC,u o6 yBenr4qeHw,r nnor4AHocrrrar,r6racrylu z racrpyrrbr. E.A.
Kou4aronofi ycranoueno,qTo Ha 3Tarre opfaHofeHe3a 3M6pHoHa Ha6JrroAaercq cra6r.rJrbHocrb I4 oAHoO6pa3I{e CTpOeHI4flXCCpa3nurrHbrx Br.rAoB pbr6, He cBoficrBeHHafl 6oree paHHI4Mpa3Bnrvs.,r,rccJreAoBanaqro ona 6ulaBbuIBJIeHazno4po6Hoy prr6 !r paHee Ha rrprrMepe $oprr,rzpoBa:nurfl pa3nurlHbrx cLIcreM opI'aHoB (Kov6c,flpu erourrro QuroreueruqecKl4 6rvIsKueAr4ccepraHT ycraHoBr4Jr,onpeAerreHHoe pa3Hoo6pa:ue B crpoeHnr,r4nr plr6 c xerrorrubrMl,IBnuvuroqHblM oranaM,{uccepraur HaxoAlrr coorBercrBpre erofi 3aKoHoMepHocrLI B (MoAenI4 necorlHblxrracoB) (Irie, Kuratant, 2014), Ho MoxHo 3aMerr,rrb,2002).vBkIAbI npotBnslorXCC, a wan6otee cJIoxHaJI crpyKrypa xapaKrepHaKarrJItMI,I B cocraBe xeJITorIHofo KoMIIJIeKca.pa6ore4rEccepraquonnofiE.A.Kon.{aronofiBnepBbreHArrrcroJrofnqecKoM ypoBHe oxapaKrepr43oBaHa crpyKTypa X{CC B pa3Blrrlrr4 fi nu4on Kocrl4crbxy rpex v3 Hrrxprr6,:r'arrvnas.cparrHrzx crap.uit pa3Bvrrvrs.
Bnepnue orlllcaHayJrbrpacrpyKTypa }I{CC AaHr.ro-pepuo. Buepnbre BbrrroJrHeHo corocraBneHlle crpyKTypbl n{CCKaKypoAcrBeHHbrx, TaK ray$unofeHerrrqecKr.r orAaJIeHHbrx BI{AoBco cralvv. racrpynblI4KOHIIAJI JII,IqU HOIIHbIMV CT AAVflM!\,BtrsoArr Arzcceprarlrrlr orpaxaror pe3ynbrarbr rrccneAoBarvrfl. I{ [peAcraBIrflrorc . BnoJIHeo6ocnoeaHHbrMrz AocrarorrHbrMAr,rccepraHToMcnpr,rMeHeHr,reMo6teuou $arcrnuecxoro Marepuana,I4ccJIeAoBaHHofopa3Hoo6pa:nrx coBpeMeHHbIX MeroAoB I,IccJIe.4oBaHvrfl., B roMqI4CJIC CTATI'ICTI,IqECKI4X.,{ocroeepnocru HayrrHbrx noroxenzfivBbIBoAoBrvccepra\w E.A.KonAaKosofiOllpeAenfleTolr 3HaqIITeJIbHbIM O6terr,tOr,t MaTepuana, IIOBTOp.fleMOCTbIO pe3ynbTaToB, BrICOKI{MMeTOAOnOt[qecK[M ypoBHeM, oTpaxarcIlr4Mctrparnoo6pasHbrx MeroAoB r4ccneAoBanus..06BI{ctIoJIb3oBaHI4I4.4I{CCepTaHTOMgronr x{e cBLlAerenbcrByer rlpeKpacHoe KarlecrBofrrcroJrorrrqecKrrx 14 sJreKTpoHHo-Mr4KpocKorruqecKl4x npenaparoBLI nx$ororpa(fufi,BKIIOIIEHHbX B AI4CCEPTAIII4IO.PesyltrarrrrroJre3Hbrnpr4r4ccJreAoBaHr,rr xeJrrorrHofo cI{HIIIrrvaJIbHofoMoAenr.rpoBaHur4 npeo6pasosauufi,cJlot Kocrtlcrblx pu6 6yayrApyrlzx cvrnr\trrLrurbHblx[poBLI3opHbIXcrpyKTyp, Harrpr,rMep, cr{Hrlr{Tr,rorpo(fo6nacra MJleKorluraloIuux, Baxuoe Mecro ouu :aftruyr z nperrreHrrrr BorrpocoB [prrKJraAHoro 3HaqeHLIs, nanpurvlep,pa3BeAeHI,Iflnpvpaspa6offie TexHoJIofIruKocrr4crtrx prr6, cB.rI3aHHbIX c ru6emro rklr{I,IHoK IIpoMbIcnoBbIX BLIAoB nplznepexoAe Ha aKTr,rBHoe nr.rraHr.re.
floloxreHufl 4r4ccepra:1:zu Mofyr6ursucnoJlb3oBaHbl npunoAforoBKe JreKrlrzoHHbrx KypcoBr4xrllo JrOruru,rpl cTo JIollllrkr III,IToJI orro 6uotoruupa3BlaT:afl,cpannurelluofi eru6puoloruu,f I'IrI.,{uccepraqus E,A. KoHAaKosofi rs;1oNeHa sa I37 cTpaHI{Uax TeKcTa I4 npeAcTaBIqeTco6ofi pyKonvcb, nocrpoeHHyro r4 o$oprrrnenuyro no o6rqenpuusrofi cxeue. Ona BKJlroqaercneAylolql4e pa3Aenbl: <BseAeHrIe), <O6sop nuTepaTypbl)), <Marepual 14 MeToAbI)'<Pesylrraru>, <O6cyxAeHr{e)), <3aKruo.reHvre>> pr <Brteo4u>. ZnnrocrparusHrtfi Marepl'IanrrpeAcraBnen 3 ra6rulrlaMr{ u4lpucynr<otr,t.[raccepraUrroHgair pa6oraHecrolrroqpe3MepHoE.A.
KouAaKosoft BqeJIoM xopottro crpyKrypl'IpoBaHa'o6reuHufi rro orHoIIreHI,Irc K ocHoslioft qacrtrnr4Teparypnrrfi o6sop AeraJrbnov31."1re1yrfl.,B crvcKe nllreparypu 363 vcrotrHllKa,r4Ar4cceprar\Lrllr,rcqeplbrBarorle rIoJIHo paccMarpktBaer Bce acIIeKTbI r4croplrvro6pasonanr{r, crpoeHr4r r.r Mop$oSyunquouaJlbHbrx npeo6pa3oeauniL r(errorlHofocr,rHrll{Tl4iurbHoro cnosy pa3nurrHbx Kocrl4crblx pst6, a raKx(e Bolpoc o efo rrpoucxoxAeHllu.orpar(aer ee coAepll(aHlle. ,{ucceprauu.a HanI'IcaHa xopoIIIl{MHagsaHr,re Ar4cceprarlulrnr4TeparypHbrM r3brKoM, rrpaKTlrqecKrl6es orun6oK.
Crpyr<rypa anropeQepara HeBTIoJIHecoorBercrByer crpyKType Ar,rcceprar\urr, ABe IIeHTpanbHbIe fJIaBbI AI4cceprarluu o5re[uHeHbl3Aecb B oAIrH pa3AeJI<Pe:ylrraru z o6cyNAeHLIe).K pa6ore r4Merorcs He6oluune 3aMerraHlls. 1. ,{uecepraUzxpa3Br,rTl,IrcBoHToreHe3e uopQolorvqecKofi cTpyKTypLI,rlaccusurarlr{s Kocrr{crbrx psr6 n Hefi 6y.Uer[ppIBeAeHaIIeJII4KoM nocBqlrleHaI4 MoXHo 6ulo oxl4Aarb,rlo nocneAHeMy I'I3AaHI'II0Helrcona c coaBropaMu (I.{elson et al., 2016) "Fishes of the World", co:4annofia;f1gur]r3aqToKHITTLIHa ocHoBaHkII'IMopoonorilqecKnx nprr3HaKoB. Terr,r He MeHee, 3Aecb I4crlonb3yercfl KJlaccH$IarcaunxEeranrypaccoaBropaMr.r (Betancur-R,et al,, 2013, 2014),MOJTeKyJIflpHOTO aHaJII43a I4 cyIqeCTBeHHo pacxoAf,tUaJlcfl'ocHoBanHar{Ha pe3ynbraraxc Tpa[r4quouHoil'2.
Xorelocr 6H errcxa3aTb noxeJraHr4e ArrccepTaHTy rlocTaparbct rlpliBecrrr B coorBercrB[eo6reu nl{TepaTypHoro o6ropa14ocHoBHHx'{acrefi s AanlHefiIxefi pa6oreB qenou, orMeqeHHbre HeAocrarKl4 He cHl,rxaror o6ulero xoporrero BIIeqarJreHVfl orAr,rccepralll{oHHoftp a6orsI.rtccJIeAoBaHI{eM'fluccepraqus. E.A, KonAaxoeofi ssrsercr IIenocrHbIM 3aKoHr{eHHbIMneo6xo4raubrM AJrr Sopur,rpoeannx o6rqux npe4crauenufipa3B1rrvrflKocrr{orbx prr6r,rMoxer 6um06 ocHoBax err'r6puonalbHofoony6JIIaKoBaHa KaK orAeJIbHarIMoHorpafiux'[uccepraulroHHa.f,pa6ora EnarepnnuA.nerccanApoBHbI KOHAAKOBOI'I<CpaenureJrbHo-MopQo;roruuecKoe rrccJreqoBanrre ?I(eJrroqHoro clrHurrrlraJrbHoro cJroflpa3Brfrrrr{ Kocrr{crbrx pu6> no creqrranbHocrll 03.03.05no coAepxaHtrro,-B6uoloruflpasB:zrvfl, eu6pt'Iolorux,aKTyanbHocrl4, Hayr{Hofi noengHe, o6:seuy npoBeAeHHbIX I4ccJleAoeaHufi, n3HaqeHr,rro nonyr{eHHbrx pe3ynbraroB coorBercrByer KpI,ITepI4{MrI.9,BbIABI4raeMbIM<lloloNeru4eM o noprAKe rrpucyx(AeHlr.s yr{eHblx creneuefi> (yrnepx4eno llpanuremcreoNa PQor24.09.2013 r.
Ns 842s peAaKrlLtu flocrauosreuur llpau4reJlbcrBa P@ or 02,08.2016 r.J\b748) u flpeAbrBn.f,eMbrM K ArrcceprarlyrflM Ha co[cKaHI,Ie yuenoft creneHl4 lKalF^4tr4uta HayK, a eeaBrop, KOHAAKOBA Ercarepuua ArerccaHApoBHa, 3acny)KlzBaer npl4cyx[ernfl yueuofirlo cleqrraJll,Hocrl{ 03.03.05crerregr{ KaHA[Aara duo.roruqecr<ux HayK6uororuqpa3Brrrrrfl , ou6puo.uorur.OQuquanrnrrft onnoHeur:frasHHfi nayunufi corpyAHI4K[pmop 6zorornqecKllx HayKCueqr,Ia-nrnocrr 03.02.06 - uxruoJlofl4tEes yuenoro 3BaHu{Bocr<o6ofiru.IKoBa Olrra CreuanosHat ur-^--19.04.2018O.C.
Bocxo6ofiHuroeaCseAeHzs o6 opranutaquvoEnEpAnbHoE focyAApcTBEHHOE BTOAXETHOE yr{PEXIEHI4E HAyKI4OJIOf I4qECKI4fi I4HCTI4TYT P O C CI4IZCKOIZ AKAAEMI4I4 HAYK (3I4H PAH)lg9 03 4, Casrr-flerep6ypr, VuznepcurercKas Ha6epeNuar, Aotlt I3OTer.: (812) 328-03-11E-mail: admin@zin ru, offiWWW: http://www.zin.ruce@zin.ru,'#U;iV;''vcti.tlc ; tp-4-4---:b'-.
