Отзыв ведущей организации (Сравнительно-морфологическое исследование желточного синцитиального слоя в развитии костистых рыб), страница 2

KaXAan noArnaBKa (c 4.1 no 4.5)KoHTaKTapa3HbrxnocBrlqeHa xapaKrepurcrhKe pa3Bhrnspepn0, Kapna, BbloHa, cHroBbtxXCC y onpe4eneHHorohvnv rpynnbl BhAoB - AaHhoHeflbMbl, rpexnrnoil KopolltKH. Becsua 3Har.thMbtMHBViAaXCC Ha npuMepe AaHuo-pepno.ororo BNAa HeroMoreHeH: B pagnuqHuxnpeAcraBflerorce AaHHbte o6 ynurpacrpyKrype pasBuBapu.lerocgl-lonyveuu qerKue AoKasarenbcrBa roro, qro XCC yyqacrrax XCG eAonb Aopco-Beurpanuroil ocu noKasaHbr Bapnaqnr4 ynbrpacrpyKrypbr. AaropA[ccepTallhn orMeqaeT, qro Afls fll4qnHoK AaH]4o-pepno, Ten{ He MeHee, He cgofrcreeHHa rBHoBbrpaxeHHae nonflphsaqhflcnoApa3AeneHueM Ha (3oHy uepoxoBaroro OIIP>nooHy annapara[-onu4iru, KaK oro 6urno nora3aHo Ha Apyrhx BAAax pur6.

fl-lJepoxoaarsril oH4onnasMarnqecrnfiperhKyrtoM 14 MhroxoHAp1414 npeAcraBreHbr noBceMecrHoua6no4aercn reHAeHqhqpagflillLtHbrx goHaxhxnoKanhsaqnn npenMyqecrBeHHoXCC pasnngatorcg KonilqecrBorycrora pacnonoxeHhsBMr4KpoBopcl,rHoK)l(CC, oAHaKoannranuHoli o6nacrn. Bl-lr4Tonna3MeexefiTorrHbrx grnrc,{eHnri B rlr4TonfiagMe, Anr4Ha nanuxansuoi noBepxF{ocru. B annranssori o6nacrh XCC6utnh agtgeneHbt oKsoql4To3Hbre ny3brpbKr4, MyrbThBe3nKyfrgpr-{bre refla n BKntoqeHhfl, oKpyxeHHHeQn6pnnnrpHbrM MarephanoM.

BurcsneFrur raKxe cKonneHnfl qacrnq rnilKoreHa, KoropbtecoAepxarcfl npenMyqecrBeHHo e OaeanuHofi o6nasrn XCC. Snnxe K annKanbHoti noaepxnocrn}|(CC npmcyrcrBylor rereporeHHbre xefiToqHbre BKnrcqeHhtt, coAepxau{He sneKrpoHonnorxutnsneKrpoHonpoepavHurfi Marepnan. Aerop Aenaer cnpaBeAnileurfr eurao4ro roM, qro Bo BpeMeaffheHoil Wnntr'sayn xerrKa XCC nuqnHoK AaHno-pepro npeAcraer KaK cnoxHo opraHn3oBaHHaecncreMa, ynbrpacrpyKrypHHe sfleMeHTbr roropofi AeMoHcrpr4pyror MaKchMaflbHyro creneHbpa3Bl,tTt4fl.CpaaHnrensxoe niropQonorhqecKoe HccneAoBanne XCC h3yqeHHbrxBLTAoBrocrncrsrx put6- AaHmo-pepro, Kapna Koil, BboHa obHrcHogeuHoro, Tpex BnAoB curoBbrx H Heflbubr, npoBeAeHHoeBpa6ore E.A.

Kon,qaKosofi, BKntovaer e cp6s xapaKrephcn4Ky ronunHur XCC, Koropag rsMeHgercFBpa3Hbtx ero goHax B xo4e eu6pnoHanbHoro h flr4qrHoqHoro pasBhrun, ToarnoqeHhfi, HanHqhFhxeKacaercn xenroqHbtxpacnonoxeHnq x]4poBbtx Kanenb, rycroTbr, Ant4HbtHpacnonoxeHugMHKpoBopcltHoK, HaflHqhf, cKonrreHnh a1ep r,r nnop$onornqecKrx xapaKrephcrhK nocneAHux. TaK,xapaffiepHori ocoOeuuocrup XCC chFoBbrx, BbrsBneHHofi e pabore E.A. KouAaKoBofr, rBflserctHannqile npynuoil xmpoaoil Kanfln B nepeAHeil qacrn xenro.lHoro KoMnneKca.B qutonna3ue,5oKpyxaloqem ttaccy xefiTKa, saMerHo pasAeneHne Ha BHyrpeHHplo o6rasrb, 3anonHeHHytoxeflTot{HblMl,l BKflloqeHhfMu pa3Hofo paSMepa, u 60nee rnaAKyto, roMoreHHyto HapyxHyto.Kannfl orAengercFxnpoeanorMaccbr xeJrrKa qHTonna3Marn.{ecrofr npocnoilrori, uanonuesuofrxerfTot{HblMh BKn}oqeHV9.Ml{, XOTg, nO-Bt4AhMOMy, gTO qt4Tonna3MaTnqecKoe oKpyxeHhe HetrlrouHoe.

Y cHroeHx Llt4Tonfla3Ma, oKpyxapqae xenroK, pasflnqhMo noApa3AeflserceHa ABe-TptlTonqnua XCC e4onb Aopco-B€xrpansuofi H nepeAHesaAneil och HeoAklHaKoBa Ha rar,4oriilccn eA oBaH noil cl.agnu pagBn nfl .3oHbt.BaxHurult ua6nrc4eunAMu, onilcaHHbrMhB <Pesynurarax), qBnstorcsuo4ttcprxaqrfi crpyrryput XCC, o6ecne.rhgaroulafr ero recsurriKoHTaKronucaHhec KpoBeHocHbtMt4 cocyAaMhn QopmrpynqrMucfl opraHaMh pa3BhBaroqerocr opraHn3Ma. Tar, y BbpHa B nephoA xenroqHoronvra*nn KpBbepoBbt nporoKr4 HaxoAercn e ceoeo6pasxurx yrny6neHr.nx Ha noBepxHocrlr XCC, vro,oLleBhAHo, oonerqaer Aocryn nhrarenbHbx BeulecrB ras XGC B KpoBb pasBnBanqeroce opraHhsMa.B peqeusrpyeuota pa6oreqrooAHhM r43 nprcHaKoB, xapaKTepHbtx AnF BnAa,FBfleerce uop$onornqecxafl xapaKTeprcrnKa FAep }KCC.

6unh gursefieHbt pasrhqHue runbt rAep,noK,asaHo,pa3nhLfanqnece t1o Sopue, pa3MepiaMhBsavMopacnoroxeHrap. B XCG Aaxuo-pepuo e4papaeuoo6pasHbt, HHorAa BecbMa nphqyAnhBoft $oprr,rur. V rapna raKxe Bcrpeqaorce eApa cnoxrofrQopuut, qacrooHr4 coeAnHeHbrMexAy e;o6oh MocrhKaMH.n4ep XCC y nnqhHoK AoxoArr Aolnruan4ep rny6raHHbrx Kfleror eu6praona (eeponruo, AHnnoHAHbrx) - orono 7MKM. Y BboHa, y Koroporo, KaK nsBe,crHo r4g flHTeparypbr, Bcrpeqaprc+ nonunnou4Hble FApa, B36 ruru, TorAaKaK AnhHapa6ore E.A.

KosAaxoaoil 6uno npop,eMoHcrpr4poBaHo yBennqeHue pasMepoB FAeprafipyflntlt4r4.4o nogAHero nnqhHoqHoro nephoAa.flpr erouorcraAtAAnoxa3aHo, r.tro B ocHoBHoM yBenrqeHhepa3MepoB FAep npohcxoAl4T Ha cTaAAtA racTpyfiFr_I]4h, Ha nocfleAyrc|4hx cra4nex rr4r.rbHeMHcffoqilcneHHbre AApa Aosturalor EecbMa KpynHbrx paaMepoB.qro Ha craAun racrpynflqhil e XCC nponcxoArrr4HTeHcnBHbre3rn 4atusre yKasbtBator Ha ro,npoqeccbr yMHoxeHLrR reHoMa,KoTopHe Ha 6onee nosAHt,rx cra4nsx or{ToreHe3a sExBarbrBapr ropa3Ao n,teuuulufi npoqeHT ngep. BXCC uyxcyHa Bo BpeMe racrpynflqnn E.A.

Kou4aroaofr BbrnBrreHbl flApa npnqyAnheofi Sopnau,AnHHa nx npeBbrtxaer 100 uru. B X,CC cilroebrx aBTop orMeqaer raKxe oqeHb KpynHu.e flApahcKnoqhrenbHo cno)KHoil $optvtut, qacT'o coeAhHeHHbre Mocrhmaun. flpe4craBnrrercg nHTepecHbrM,E.A. Kou.qaKoaofi, pa3Mep, Sopua r BsauMopacnonoxeHile eAep XCC ornrqaerceB pa3Hbrx ero yqacrKax. Hanpnuep, BbrFBfl€Ha reH,qeHqhr yBenhqeHhe pa3MepoB eAep (cnepeAhqro noAaHHbrMHa3aA).ero yrasuaaerpasnnL{HflMh pasHbtx goHHaro,Lrrooco6essocrn opraHnsaL$n AAep cBflsaHH c $yrrqrorafibHbrur4XCC.B rnage <O6cyxgeHhe), saHnMatot4era 16 crpaurq, K.A. Kou4aroea Aaer noApo6HyroxapaKrepilcrhKy o6ulnx qepr h pasnrrvnft XCC e npeAen€x KaMoro h3 yl3yi{eHHbrx raKcoHoBKocrncrbrx pur6. Oro no3Bonuno aBropy qAenarb oAHopa6orutr,r3 r-rraBHbrxgaKrloqeHhfi 4rccepraqnosHorlo roM, qro XCC npeAfiaBuTenei Bc€x r43yqeHHbtx paGore BrAoB pu6ceofrcrBeHHacrpyKrypHafl pernoHannsaqn+, o6ycnoeneHHafl pasAeneHneM QyHrqni MeXAy yqacrKaMrcBs3aHHag, B ToM r{r4cJle, c pa3fltlqxori rnxteHcyrBHocrbro npoqeccoB acchMt4nf,l14ho6nacrsx n xlailMoAefrcreueil c nphflerxaquMh crpyKrypaMil (overrnxerrKaXCCr,rB pa3HbrxcBhAerenbcrByror ornl4r{nfl noKonnqecrBy xefiToqHbrx grnrcqeurft, rycrore pacnoaoxeHhn MnKpoBopcl,rHoK XCC (aaxno-pepno),6a raKxe oonsuloeKoJil4qecrBo exnlo,'{eHhfico cna6ooKpaueHHbtM coAepx}lMbtM B nepe4Hefi,sa4ueil u AopcafibHofi oOnacrcx XCC (rapn).B4aHxota rflaBe AhccepTaHT Aaer oqeHKy BogMoxHblx MexaHngMoB Bo3Hl4KHoBeHHHonilcaHHblx e <Pesynurarax) gAep cnr)xHofi, nonacrroil $opnrrsl.

E.A. Kou4aroea paccMarpnBaerfixKat( Bo3MoxHoe nponBneHhe $parmeHTalllru qAepB xoAe pasBnrn* KfleToKc- FBfleHnF, Koropoe 6utno eulsefleHo KaK oraflaHAononr{nnomAHuMn f,ApaMA,p$ynbraroM Koroporo n,toxer 6urrsobpasoaaHne MHoxecrBa Hil3KonoflhnnohAHbrx R4epHbrx Sparrr,rexroB BHyrpH rnraurcxofr KflerKyl,BKaK OTO nOKa3aHO, HanpLtMep,KflerKaXrposoOnacraMfleKonnraoqux.

cygn nonpeAcraMeHHblM B paoore AaHHbrM, TaKae oLleHKa BnoflHe cnpaBeAnnaa. llo4o6ubte eBneHHflH3peAKaBcrpeqaprcn TaKXe B npoBn3opHbtx opraHax pacreurri, B culMnnacrhqecKoM TeryMeHTecxpe6uefi H B pe,4e Apyrux rxauefr pa:ruoo6pa3Hbrx xl4BorHbrx ,t pacrennil. Tpy4no He corflacfirbcec 3aMeqaHneu E.A.

KoH4axoaofi, BbtcKilgaHHonr a O6cy44eHhn, o roM, r.tro sAepHbte Qparuexrur Hecnoco6gu K ctlHTe3y ,QHK, uo nph DroM oHh He HBrnrorcfl rnbuyqrnnra, xorq $parueHraqunnpohcxoAutr Ha no3AHr,rx cpoKax Oeperrneuxocrr. flo aHanorun c srr4M nphMepoM, uuoroo6pa3Hbte,B ToM tl4cfle nonacrHbre H qacrrqHo QparueurupoBaHHbte sApa XCC pbf6, BosMoxHo,npeAcraBnflpr coOoft uernfr oco6urfi Tvrn opraHH3aqnn nAep, rAe yBenuqeHa nnou{aAb noBepxHocruconphKocHoBeHhncr-p4TonnasMoli,Llro no3Boreer HApy perynrpoBarb npoqeccbl cr4HTesanpollemnHra cra4necneqn$nvnux OenroecoxpaHnfl xl4SHecnoco6uocruaBbrfBfleHHHeopraHn3aqnu4onApyrHX coeAnHeHnfrpasnuqHbtx 3oHax XCC,KoHqa nhqmHor{Horo pagBurtl*. l-.leHHurrur npe4craBnfftorcffpa6ore gaKoHoMepHocn4ocBsgr4 Mertq.4y ocoOeHHocrHMH gAep, cnoxHocrbtoXCC n ycnoBnflMh cyrqecrBoBaHhexr4Byqero npn uanOonee BbrcoKr4xekrr4syqeHHbtx BytAoB pur6.Tar, AnH AaHuo-pepho,remneparypax, xapaKTepeH orHochrenbHo npocro ycrpoeuuurilXCC; FApa ero hMelor HahMeHbukl,r pasuep ils Bcex ilsyqeHHbrx BnAoB.

Hanporre, xar6oneecfloxl{afl opraHhsaqhr XCC h c€rMbre KpynHbre HApa xapaKTepHbl AnF cnroBbtx c HXnpoAonxhTenbHbrM pa3BnTheM nph Hr43Kr4x TeMnepaTypax, qTo yKasbtBaeT Ha aAanTyrBHoe3HaqeHhe cnoxuori, BbrcoKoopraunsoaaHHofr srpyKrypbr }l(CC, BKfltoqafl ocoOeusocrr opraHHgaLlnuflAep.B"O6cylrgeHHr" aBTop4aa'paOorut, Koropbre c$opnaynrpoBaHbro6ocHoBaHne ocHoBFrbrx o6o6qexrfr AhrcepraqnounorlB"3axnlo.reHnu,".

Kpoue BbtueynoMflHyrrbrx xoqercsBbrAenrTb GneAyrcqee: noKaSaHo npnHLlhnranbHoe e4MHcTBo opraHh3aLlh14 xenTolrHorowtH1nrnanbHoro cflorryKocrhcrbrx psr6. flpt,r oroMyQlrnorererhqecKh 5nusrux Br4AoB,npnHaAnexau4hx K oAHoMy ceueilcray n poAy (Coregonus) raOno4atorcfl Baphaqhn crpoeHhtxeflTol{Horo cHHql4THaflbHoro cnofl, B qacTHocT[, npoFBngloqnecfl B pa3nhLtktHx no ToaqhHeHQopue orAenbHbrx yqacTKoB h BcrpeltaeMocryr n4ep onpeAeneuHori rou$nrypaqrr.C,qenaunue aBTopoM BbrBo4br @orBercrBypr nocraBneHHbrM saAaqaM, oHh apryMeHTurpoBaHblh norhqHo BbtTeKa|oTflony.leHHuree pa6orepeqeHsrpyenaofrrc nonyqeHHbxAaHHbtx.pe3ynbrarbr orrrhr.tBlorcf, esrcoxofr creneHbto HoBh3Hbt,pa6ore AnF)K(lC qenoro pFAa Kocrr4crbrx pur6 6urnaT.K.BBbrnBneHaBnAocneqhQrvnan crpyKTypHafl pernoHanv3aqt A, Koropan npoflBneercfl yxe HaqhHae co craAhu7Onacrynut,rKoropafl cBF3aHao6ycnoaneHa opraHhsaqraefrx XGCnphnexaulhMhnr,rr1cpa3AefleHheM $ynrqraD4 Mel14y yqacrKaMh cnMnflacra n(a vacrnocrh, HarhqneM xypoBbtx xanens) H esahMoAeicrehenil ccrpyKTypaMn.

flonysenrueepa6ore E.A. KoH4axoeoil 4aunslecBilAererbcTByloT o ToM, LrTo B nephqA affineHor,r yrnnv3aqwA xenrKacrpyKTypy, rAe MHoroqilcneHHbreopraHilsoBaHHylorxccnpe4cTaBflfler co6oilpasroo6pa3Hbre opfaHohAbt BbtcrpoeHbtBcnoxHocncreuy c 6onsueh vnn naenuulerl creneHbto noflHprsaqhh.f'lonyveHuutil E.A. KoH4anoaoil oKcnepuMeuranuHurri Marepnan, ero aHanh3 h c,AenaHHbte3aKnnqeHilg LtMelor HecoMHeHHoe Teoperr4qecKoe 3HaqeHue, T.K.