Отзыв ведущей организации (Изучение роли рецептор-подобной киназы К1 гороха в контроле формирования симбиотических субклеточных структур)

<YTBEPXIAiO>:,{lrpexrop6toIiHepanbHoforocyAapcTBeHHofouayxu EoranrlvecxriiiPocclritcnoiaxaaeMr.rr.r,{.B. fensruar05 ruoss 2018 r.OT3bIBBeAyuIero yqperrAeHus Ha Arrccepralluro KrEpueuno AHHr'r Huno.naesnbI<I43YTIEHI4E POJIII PEUENTOP-IIONOFHOIZ KIIHA3bI Kl |OPOXA BKOHTPOJIE OOPMIIPOBAHI4fl CI4MEI4OTI4qECKIIX CYBKJTETOqHbIXCTPYKTYP)rrpeAcraBJreHHoii lta collctcauue yueuoii crenenlr KaHAI,IAara 6uo"'roruuecrux nayxno cneqrraJrr,Hocrqlr: '03,01.05 - <<@ulHo.[orr't q Il 6Hoxurvrlrq pacrenuib>1 03.02.03 <rMunpo6uo,rorun>.Arrya,rr,nocrr,TeMr,r r{ ee o6ocnonaHue(Doprr.rrponanueHa KopHqx 6o6onr,Ix pacreuuii oco6rrx opranon-xny6enrxon,o6ecneuznarorqux cuaa6r.ros Melr(Ay pacreHueu u asor$uKclzplroltrlrMl{ 6axrepunttu rrpeAcraBnser co6oft cloinur,ril npoqecc, roroprdi co cropoHrl pacrlrrenbHoro opraHlt3MaHaxoArrrcr noA MHoroypoBHeBr,IM KoHTponeM.

B6Issreul4e MexaHn3MoB, KoHTponl4pyloulixpa3BHTr{e rcly6eHsrca- rr\4eer Bar(Hoe jHaqeHI-Je 4,rr $y uaar'leHraltHofi uayxu o pacreHhrx. aTaKlKg An.rr [pI4KnaAHbIX nccreAosaHllii n pa:pa6oror e o6racrz ceneKuul4 rr celbcKoroxogsitcrea. Oco6rril rrHTgpec, a raK)Ke nau6oree o6ruupur,re [epcrIeKrI4BbI c roqKl{ 3peHl4lrttoreHIII.IaJIr,Hr,tx npaKTurrecKoro npu:roNeuuft, npeAgraBnser I.I3yqeHIIe ir{exauug}4oe o6a4eHacIrrlra.llaMrr Mo)r(Ay pacrenr4tuLt '11 6arrepuxua B apouecce B3aI4MHoro pacrlo3HaBaulrg,ycrarroBlreHur u Qyur<quoHllpoeaHul cfial6uorzqecxltx sgaur4oAeilcrgfii. [auuuii npoqecc3anycKaerc.rr 6arreplranr,unrur4 JrrrloxrrrooJrlrrocaxaplrraMu - Nod-rparropavl4, a co cropoHrlpacrenuil Knlor{eB}To ponb B pacno3HaBaHlilr Nod-Saxropoe llfpalor peuefiTop-nogo6nr'reKrrHa3br, coAepiKarqfie LysM-uorunu.

Onu 6rrru BnepBbre BburBJIeHrI Ir oxapaKTepa3oBauE] HaMoAeJrr,HoM o6sexre ntrBeHIIe, $opIraIapl'rouerr.t rny6eurrtl AerepMnur'rpoBaHnoro runa. Vpac:renuit c r:ry6enr,raun HeAerepMrrHrrpoBaHHoro rlrna, K Korop6M orHoclrrct raKat Ba)r(Hasce:rscroxogqftcrBeHHar Kynbrypa, KaK ropox nocennoit, pauee 6r,uu Br,IrIBneHbr ABe raKlreru4Ha36r - PsSyml0 u PsSym37, r{ rrora3aua I4x ponb, coorBercrBeHHo, B IrHl,Iquaqu[ cura6uosa'Ir pa3BrrrLru uu$erquu; oaHaKo, KI{Ha3Hlri 4onaen :tttx 6ernoe o(a3aJlcs Hea(rugHlll4. KaxBocllplisTl-Is clIfHaJIa TaI{I{e KI{Ha36I ,4OJr)I(Hbr O6paSOAarr C ApyfUMnKoM[oHer{TaMr{ cr4fHaJrr,Horo [yrl4, Taxxe orHoctlrlnMIic.{ K rpy[ne peqenrop-rogo6ntxKIrHa3, Ho c aKTTTBHIIM KI-IHa3Hr,rM aoMeHoM.

TaxIru o6pa:ou, Bo3HIrKaer BnorHe 3aKoHoMepHr'IBorrpoc o naprHepax PsSym.10 ra PsSym37, Koropbre KpI,ITI{qecKIi neo6xoAnir.rlr A;u ycueuuoitr4Hr.ruuaqrrn 14 pa3Brrrr4r a:orQur<cupyroruux uy6eur,xoo Ha KopHlIx ropoxa. Heo6xo4ztvtoorMernTr,, qro Ans 6o6osoro pacreHlr{, $opuupylouero HeAerepMl.tHl.iponauuue xny6eutrllrr3BecTHo,Arr(rar<onul,r flBrxerc ropox), 4o clrx op ire 6rrlu orucarlrl peqerlTopr'r c axruBHbIM KI'IHa3HLIMAoMeHoM B cocraBe lrunqrraropHofo onlltoMepuofo KoMnnerca. Ovenu4no, qro petueHlleaaHrroro Boflpoca [peacrasrqer 6o:turoi;i lrHTepec He roJIbI{o c rfyugalreHra,rruoil, uo tt clpaKTurrecKoit ToqKri 3penur.

B ceqga B BbrrrerrJrolr{eHHblM Al{ccepralluonnar pa6ora AnnuHuroraenur,r Ktpneurco, nocB.srqgnuas BruIBJIeHIzIo I1 xapaKTepltcrl{Ire peqenrop-no4o6noiiKnua3r,r K1 - raprHepa PsSyml0 lr PsSym37, fiBnflercs'. Br'IcoKo anTyarrr,Hl'lMrrccJreAoBaHrreM. I{e"rr,ro peqenszpyerrofi AricceprarluoHHoil pa6orst crano Ir3yqel{I4e ponlrLysM-co4epx<arueil peqenrop-noIo6uoft runa,:sI K1 fopoxa llpu pa3B'tlTr4u clrrv6no:a crly6entronr,rur.i 6axrepurulr. O6r,exran.ru rrccJIe,4oBaHI{{ cranrr ropox noceBHoii, pacreHl{ltALIKofo rlrrla u psA foMo3l.irorHblx MyraHTHbrx nuldt4li. [onyr]eHH6rx aBTopoM caMocrotrenbHorra ocHoBe ceMsH I43 KoJIJIeKIII,Iu TILLING-rtryranroB B qeHTpe INRA (@pauuur).

Ha oruxo6texrax aBTopoM npoBeAeubl gKcrreprrMeuTa;IbHr,Ie uccneAoBaHug, v Ha ocgone o6o6rlesagpe3yJrbraroB nocrpogHa Mo4enr pa6orur peqenropoe r Nod-{taKTopaM y ropoxa rroceBHoro.Crpynrypa u coAepxaHr{e Arrcceprarlnrr,{uccepraqnrr{3Jro)r(eHana 112 crp.MalrrliHorlrrcHoro reKcra, coaepxlrr7ra6rlutt,u cocrour rz:: Bne4euux, 3-x r:rae, 3aKJrIoqeHI'It, BLIBoaoB IrtqurrEpyeuofinllTeparypbl; 6lr6ruorpaQuuecxnil yKa3arenb BKJIToqaer 203cnrlcKaHauMeHoBaHVr t4crciqHuKoB, s r. .r. 198 - sapy6en<uux aBTopoB.

Pa6ora narucaua [paBI4nr'Hr'IMr{JrJrrocrprrpoBaHa 15 pucyHKaMnorHocrrre-rrlno ue6o:rr,rruu KoruqecrBoM ofleqaroK, Ir aKKyparHo o$opuleua.Pa6or:a npe4napsercq BneaeHHeM, B KoropoM y6egure:rtno noKa3ana a(ryanbHocr6lrccneaoBaHrir; KpoMe Toro, Bo BBeAeHI-II4 cQopnyrupoeanbl IIen6 Ii 3aaaqll IlccneaoBaHl{{..,I3bIKoM,cf.rasaB1. O6rop,rureparyprr (crp.

10-38)o6sope nlrreparypbr, lr3Jro)KeHHoM ua 29 upaywlax, IaH no4po6uufi auatruscoBpeMennoro cocrorHrr{ uccJreAosauriil n o6racru BbrtB.[eHus I4 xapaKTeplrcrl{KrrpacrrrrenbHbx peqerrTopoB, B nepByro oqepe,qb peIIerITopoB, peryJrrrpFolq x pacrlzTenr'Honaurpo6nrre n:arairrogeftcrnux. O6sop cocrotlr Ir3 ABlx .Iacreii. B nepnofi .racra paccMorpeHllocHoBr{r,re rpy[rrbr peqenropon, c SorycoM Ha rpyfifie peqenrop-no4o6ubrx KLIHa3, r Itoropoiforuocurc.fl uccne4yermrfi aBTopoM 6e:ror.

3ra vacrr o6:opa craBlir rlpoBo.qlrMbre aBTopoM[ccre,4oBaHr4q n uuporufi uayuuui;i KoHTeKcr; e neil rparxo, Ho eMKo cyMMlipyrorcscoBpeMer{rrbre npeAcraBneHrir o pasuoo6pa:un pacrr{Terbl{rrx pe{enropoB. Heclrorp.r ua eeaocroriHcrBa, s AaHHoii qacrri BcrpeqarcTcfi Ir HeKoropr,Ie HerorlHocrlr. Tarc, n pa3,qelre,orrrrcbrBarorqeM r.ioHHble KaHa!'IbI c perlenropuofi $yurqr.reii, HecKoJtrKo pa3 yfior4uHaerclt, LITopacrer{[t o6lagaror cne]lnanl43l4poBaHHbrMr'r Ka,'rbIIueBbIMlt KaHaJraMu [Jra3MaJIeMMbr, oAHaKo,KaK pa3 y pacreuufi xa,rr,quil [ocryrraer B KnerKI.i qepe3 HgceJrgKT]rBHbre Karr.roHHbre KaHaJIbI, Heo6raaaroulze cnequ@uunocruo K Karrbrtr{rc (Demidchik, Davenport, Tester, Annu Rev PlantBiol 2002).

Bropar vact, o6:opa m.meparyp6l IlocBtrqeHa no4po6uouy anuru3y coBpeMeHHr,IXAaHHbrx o poJrrr LysM-co4epNarqux peuenropoB pacreuaft B pacrro3HaBaHnlzMuKpoopraHrl3Moe. llpueo4arcx Ii aHanlBlrpyrorct coBpeMeHHr'Ie AaIrHr,Ie o6 opranusaquupeqeflrlr4lr Nod-Saxropon y pacrenr.rii c AerepMIrHIrpoBar{I{6IM v HeAerepMV IrupoBaxHbIMTr4naMLr KJry6eHbKoB, onyqeHHbre Ha ABlx MoneKyn{pHbIX MoAersx .qns Kar(Aoro rfina nf,ABeuua rr Jrrouepl-I6l, coorBercrBeHno. I4z 4a:u:uoi't qacrfl rofutrHo Br,ITeI(aer tr{nore3a ocyqecTBoBaHr{u erqe o,4Horo KJIIoT{eBofo KoMloHeHTa peqerlTopHblx KoMrIJreKcoB,ocyqecTBnsrourrx uHuuvaqaro pannux clrrr.r6r.toTlzqecKlrx pearqr]il LI pjIA [o3AHI.lx 3Ta oB,cBr3aHH[,rx c uurf ercquonur,rM rrpoqeccoM, u neo6xoAnltocrb rror4cKa tcau4u4aruoro 6e:rra)cpeAlr LysM-peqenrop-noAo6Hbx Kr{Ha3.

llpr.rueuaremuo, vro no4o6utre uccJIeAoBaHIrl HanroqepHe (N.toAe:t Hoaa o6:sexr:e c ceKBeHI,IpoBaxHbIM feHoMoM u xo,uerqueit MyraHroB) Irenpr4Benri K pe3yJrr,Tary, vro npuno4n'r A.H. Kupueuro K B6IBo,qy o Bo3MoxHoM ycrlexe rroficKa cI.IcnoJIb3oBaHaeM MoAeJII4fopoxa. I4lrennoB3ToM 3aKJllollaercf,ql4ccepraql4oHHoerrcgJreaoBaHr.re, pe3ynbrarbl Koroporo trpeAcraBneHbl B coorBercrB]'Torqeit r,rane.l:l.ana2.

O6rercr Ir Meroar,I uccreAoBaHus (crp.39-56)r:rase Marepraanu Il MeroAtI npuBoA.lrc.[ 4annue o6 uc[oJrr,3oBaIIHbD( n pa6oreMeroAax, rAe flpr.rMeH{Jrrrcb noAxoAbr rrorer<y:upnofi 6uonorraa, 5uoxuvuu, qliroilofuu.Cnercrp nero4raK rxupoK, rr rroJrrrocrr,ro coorBercrByer Macrrrra6y pelraerroii ArrccepraHToM:agaun. Ou BxJrroqaer KaK craHAaprHbre Mero,4riKrr, HarrpuMep, BI'IIe-rreHI4e HyKJIeIzHoBbIXKr.ic.rror r{ MeroAr,r Ha ocHoBe III]P, rax rr aocraroqHo cJro}KHbre, TaKr4e, KaK nonyqeHuerpaucreHnbrx r<opueft (hairy roots) 14 Btr3yurfisalJ:ufr 6arrepuil Ir roHKIIx crpyl{ryppacrllTeJrbHbx KJreroK, HarlpuMep, l*rQexquouuux gureft.

TaKrte erreqallrter I4 Kpyf )Io4BbrxcrcreM, c Koropr,rMrr [purnJrocb pa6orars aBTopy: noMIrMo craHAaprHr'Ix KnonIipoBanr]fi BE, coli, aeropy nprrxrocr pa6orarb c pr,qoM IIITaMMoB arpo6arrepuii (xax tumefaciens, TaK I4rhizogenes), Apoxxefi, npoBoAlrrl, rpauc$oplrauuro 14 ruyqarb rpaH3ueHrH]ro 3Kcnpecclrrc6e:rron unrepeca B Jrucrbrx ra6ara, a raxn<e orpa6orar6 rlzcrororllqecKlie r.r MoneKynflpHr,IeloAXoAbr AJrq ocFroBHbIX o6reKros uccneAoBaHltt lunvfi ropoxa.Bf.nana 3.

Pery,'rrrarr,rr.ro6cyxgeHue (crp. 57-86)llo:ryveuurre AaHHbre nprrBoArrcr rz o6cylr(Aarorcs B o4uolaueunofi uane. 3anorouycnexa B pemeHrrrr aBTopoM nocrasJreHHoii cnor(Hoit 3aAaqri craJro r:o, uro A.H. Kupzenr<oyAanocb cpeArr BbrrBneHHr,rx MyrauTHr,rx no K1 rurnufi, noreuqtraJlrHo zMerorlzx tlenorun,ce.flgaHHrrii c OopMr.rpoBaHr4eM EoJrHorIeHHbx a:or$lrxcrzpy.rorqux xry6eur,roB, c noMollbro l/?silico artarusa o6napyxtzrr JruHrr r4-KaHAr4Aar6r c $euoruuon Nod-, uro ri noarBepar4nr4aaltgefiuue uccreaoBaltl4t. B cootgeTctgur.r c runore3ofi aBTopa. y MyraHTHblx ,rrHnfi uenporicxoAr.rno ge$opuaqufi KopHeBbrx BoJrocr(oB B orBgr Ha r4HoKyJrsrlurc pr.rso6rznr,ru, uroKpacr4Bo r'r y6e4lirenruo AeMoHcrplrpyer po:n K1 B rrHrirluarlr4r.r cutut6uoza.

TarNe nonaganrrge$exrrr n pocre vHrferqrroHHbrx ullreii. Br,ua npoaHaJrr43rrpoBaua LI ucKnror{eHa Bo3Mo}KHa{pom Kl B rrMMyHHoM orBere ropoxa, rrro erqe pa3 floarBepnano y:tcocnequ$urluylo ponbAaHHoro 6erxa s cur\a6zose. Haxoueq, c rroMoulrro apoxr(eBoii 4nyrr6pz4uoii cucreurr 6rr:rurrpoAeMoHcrprrpoBaurr rlpsMBre esar.rrrao4eitcrwrr ueN4y 6e:xaulr PsSyml0, PsSym3T u K1.Iocne groro aBTop B6r[onHr4n KoMurgMeHTal\urc u3yqaeMbrx rulnujt rorulna xlonou rclHKKl. B pe:ymrare Nod- (fenorun 6su ycnemno BoccraHoBJreH; K coxaJIeHIiIo, n pa6ore uenprrBoar.rrc.f, KorrzqegrBeHHoit oueHr(Ir urcna rtry6eurron Ha KopeHL y ArlKofo rrina,nosgor.{rcrqeft cpaBHzrr ypoBeHb BoccraHoBreulrs. I(polre KoMnneMelrraqrru rznliii-uyrauronno K1 npone4eua KoMrrJreMeHTarlu.a Kl rvnuii, ,qe$exrurx uo PsSyml0 z PsSy.rn37.Bpesymrare BbrrroJrrreHnbrx Ha BbrcoKoM Hayr{HoM 14 MeroAr.rr{ecKoM ypoBHeuccneAonanuitA.H.

Kr.rpueuroyAanoc6 y6egnre:nuorroKa3arr,,qropeqenrop-[o,4o6Ha.{K1, npe4uonoNrrreJrr,Ho r.r4eurr.rQrzqupoeaHHa;l KaK KaHAVAaT Ha ponr' BToporoKJrtoqeBofo r(oMrloHeH]a cHrHarbHbrx peuenropHblx KoMureKcoB y ropoxa. aeficrBxre,lbHonrpaer ory poJrb u perynupyer y ropoxa (1) coarvrecruo c PsSyml0: rrHuIIIIauIlIoSoprrauponanu.a HeaerepMr.rHr.rpoBaHHr,rx rry6enrron, v (2) coBMecrFro c Hen4eura$aqzponanur,ru nor<a 6e:rKoM: BbrxoA 6anrepzii ut uuSexquouurx uurefi.rrporeriHKr4Ha3afloc:re o6cyrxAeH[r loJryrreHnbx pe3yJrbraroB Ar4ccepraur nepexoArrr x 3ax.rro.reuuro(crp. 8?-91).

Cre4yer corJracr{rbcr c A.H. Kupuenxo, qro r43yrreHHa.{ erc K1 KuHa3a Mox(ercTaTr, oaHr'rM r.r3 KrrorreBr,rx reHoB-rzHcTpyMeHToB p9rxeHr4q 3aAaqir pacIxlrpeHr{s Kpyrapacreuuft, cnoco6nr,x o6pa:onr,rnarr cr.rNr6uos c aror$urcupyoqlrMli Mr{KpoopraHr{3MaMrr,nyreM rpaHcrgne:a.

.{aree cJreAyror Brrnogrr (crp. 92), rlolluocrrlo lo.qrBep]r(Aenu6leSKCnepl4MeHTZIJILHbIMIi AaHHLIMI{.Ilpra o6rqelr [oJror(rrreJrbHoM BneqarJronr{r.r or Ar.rcceprarluonnoit pa6orrr xorerocr 6rro6cy4zrr p-xA BonpocoB:1.Ecrr.r rrocrpor{Tr,rfu:rorenerr.ruecroe ApeBo LysM-peuenropoeuLysM-peuenropHr,x KvHa3, To KaKoe floJro)r(eHae safi\aer K1-xzHa,:a ropoxa?2.llpegno:raraer Jrv aBrop uccreAoBarr Bo3Hr.rKHoBeHr4e B rApe KaJrr,qr4eBbrxcnaftr<oe B orBer ua Nod-iparcroprr y MyraHToB fopoxa, nv reHuux $ynxqlrona:nnoft K1KUHASlI?3.lloqenry Anr rroATBeplrAeHr.rr e3aulro4eiicreur uccJreAyeMr,rx xuna: 6r,rranrr6pana gnyxru5puauan Apor{xeBaq cr4creMa, a ue uero4 FRET?llpzne4euuue Bonpocbr He [oABeprarcT coMHeHr{ro HoBr]3Hy Ir op}IrI,IHaJIbHocrr,npe4craelennofi Ar4ccepraJlr4ouHoii pa6orlr. Ona sersercr qenocrubru ri 3aBeprrreHHr,rMrrccJreAoBaHI4eM.Anrope$epar rroJrHocrbro orpaxaer coAepxaHrie AricceprarlrzoHHoft pa6or:;r, Pesy:rlraruIzccjreAoBaHllr 6suu 4oron<eurr A.H.