otzyv_veduwej_organizacii_matveevoj_m_v (Права ребенка в семейном праве проблемы законодательства, теории и практики)

q((YTBEPII(AAIO>>tArunpcxnli vnu,Br pcil TETSAMARA UNIVERSI:TYflepnrulrpopeKrop - flpopeKrop ro HayKe I,I ITHHoBaTIITJIMcI,ITera,Cauapcroro yHI,rBeprocyAapcxBeilHoeEsroHoMHoe{Fe$epanbHoeyqpex4eHueBblcueroo6paroeo6pa:oearenbHoe,Haqilonanblrulilytl<<CauapcrrftuccnegoaareaucrrftilMer{}taKa&eMrKaC.l'}"Koponeea>AOKTOp TeXHUTIeCKIIX HayKyn. MocroecKoeuocce,A. 34, n Cnr*apa,44An4pefi Bponnc;raBoBrrrrTen.:*7 tS46)3,15-19-26, gaxc:+Z(846)335.Cafir::www.sEau.ru,e-mailissfiu,glssau.ru68310,oKno 0206'9410rorpH 102s3011lrHH6315000532,Knn631501001/4 as,"t/Ne /al-r'?zzHaNe22uapma2017zodaOT3bIBBEAvrrIEfropru,nrl3Alllrr4ynnnepcrrrerHaurroHaJnnufi uccJreAoBareJrbcKrtfiBO <<CarvrapcrcufirrMerrr aKaAeMnKac.fl. Kopo.lena)o Arrcceprallufl Ha corrcKaHneyrleHoft crenenuroplrArrqecKlrxHayKKaTIAUAaTaMarseenofi Mapnu Bura.nrennrrrra reMy:<<[Ipanape6enrcas ceMefiuoMrlpaBe: npo6leuuTeopuu u npaKTrlKrl>3aKOHOAareJrbCTBa,npaso;npa6o; npednpuut'ti,tamerbcKoe(cneryuamHocmb12.00.03 zpacrcdaHcKoeqacmHoenpoeo)ceueiluoe npa*o; uecrcdynapoduoe(OfAOyHa HarIrtIccJIeAoBaHLrfl,HecounenHafl aKTyaJlbHocrbreMbl AI,IccepraIILIoHHoroB3rrr.f,A, [peAorrpeAeJrf,ercr prAoMo6crosrerbcrB.Bo-neperrx,coqnalrnofigHaquMocrbloreMbl Hacrorrqero rpy4a, no.(rBep)KAaeuoftTeM, qro o6ecne'reHvrewoxpaHa [paB pe6enrca celoArur rBJrf,rorct oAHIaMw3 np[op]rrerHbrx naupanneHlafipoccuftcrofiBo-ntoprrx,rocyAapcrseHHofi rroJII4TLIKI4.cocrotHl4eM ceueftnoroB ToM qI,IcJIeHopM, orHocflIlll{xct K rIpaBaMAerefi, Koropoe He B3aKoHoAareJrbcrBa,uomrofi Mepe coorBgTcrByer Aocrr,rrHyroMy ypoBHIo o6ulecrneHHblx otttoluennfi,'araxll(e uIaBHoMy MexAyHapoAHorrpaBoBbrMaKraM PO,Apyrr,rMHopMarr,rBHbrMnpaBoBoMyarcry - KonseHrluz o npaBax pe6ema.

Bo-eroprrx, neo6xoAuMocrbloKoMrrJreKcHoro a:auwrga HafrHrrxvnpaKruqecKrrx upo6reru,cBr3aHHbIx cvt o[peAeJIeHI,ItperJraMeHTa\tteia3aKoHoAareJrbc-TBqnpan pe6eHKaB coBpeMeHHoMKar cupaBeAJrrrBouoAqepKl,IBaerHarrpaBJreHnfiero Aalruefiurero coBeprrreHcrBoBanva.coucKareJrb,B cBr3H c rrrrrpoKoMacrura6nrrupe$opunpoBaHLIeMrpiDrAaHcKoro lrceuefinoro 3aKoHoAareJrbcrBaqerrrftpfl[npeAcraBJresuir ocJrolKr4BrrrrrrxcrB HayKe K HacTo-[IrIeMyBpeMeHr4,rpe6ytorrpaBax pe6eura,nepeocMblcJleHl{tugamnefiurefi reoperwrecrofi npopa6orxu (c.

6 4ncceptaqzu).VIcxoM rr3 aKTyaJrbnoerr,rreMbr AuccepraunoHHoro rpyAa, aBTopoMnocraBJIeHbIu, KaK HaM npeAcTaBJrreTcr, AocTaToqHo yc[eruHo pelreHbr [epequcreHHbre ua c,7u reMe pa6oru. floAxoArr zAlrcceprarlnu saraqn, KoropbreorBeqaK)To6qenay3aMbrcJryMeroAbr pe[reHrlf, paccMorpeHHbrx coLrcKareJreMBo[pocoB r{ pe3yJrbrarbr npone4eHnoftpa6oru rroKa3brBnror AocraroqHo BbrcoKr,rfireopernqecKr4ft H rrpaKrruecrraft ypoBeHbnoAroroBKlr AtlccepranTa, a raKlKe ero ciloco6nocrrycnerrrno pa3pellrar6 HayqHblenpo6reurr.IlenroupeAeJruJrnrorr{quyrov 3aAaqv r4ccJreAoBaHprrcrpyKTypy pa6orrr,cocrorrqefi us rpex HraB, crpyKT'ypHrresreublrrbr AucceprarlrIouHororpyAa JIon4lIHoB3araMocBs3aHbr,rI tlx nocrpoeHl,Ie[oArlr,rHeHouau6oree [oJIHoMysganl,roo6ycJroBJreHblvrBcecroponHeMy paccMorpeHr,fio [peAMeraIloJloxllrreJlbHorouaparpaQaMoMemarrroroBbrxTaK)Ke MoxHoBbrBoAoB, rrror,rccJreAoBaHnt.

BoTMeTr,rTb HaTII{tIlIecBvAereJrbcrByeroKaqecrBeB KoHIIeKaxAorocrpeMJreHI,Iu aBTopaMaKcuMaJrbHoroqHo c$opuynzpoBarb cBoro no3r4rlr4rorro caMbrM BaxHbIM u nau6oleenpo6nenanbrMBorrpocaMTeM6r.CrurrH .f,3brK.qr{cceprarluu floJrHocrbro coorBercrByrcT xapaKrepy pa6oru xarHayqHoro TpyAa.IIpuroAroroBKepa6orurryqeHneo6xoAraurrfi nopuatunnrrfiMarepI{aJI urrpaKrr{Kaero uptrMene:avrs,Tpyau poccuficrux yrreHbrx. ,{nccepraquoHHaf,pa6orae Heft AaHHbIeo6la,qarorocHoBy,a [pr,rBeAeHHbrer,rMeercepbesHyronnQopnaaquoHrryroueo6xo4r,ruofi4ocroBepHocrrro.Ilpe4noxeHHbreaBTopoMperueHl{f,apryMelrrl,IpoBaHbrpelreHwrMvr.c ApyrnMu u3BecTHbIMLrr,rKp[TuqecKr,rorleHeHbrrro cpaBHeHLrrcac[eKTe u o6reuecooTBeTcTBytouII{Xpa6ot B paccMaTpLIBaeMOMparpaootanHocTl'I TeM6I'o HeAocTaToqnofi cTefleHu uayruoficBr4,4eTeJrbcTByeTorcyrunueBoc[oJlHteuofi anroPou.HayruarHOBU3Ha TpyAa M.B.MarseesofiHe B6I3bIBaeT counenufiurMoHol-pasuuecroM ypoBHe [poBeAeH AeralnnHfi3aK[rcqaeTQ{ B TOM, ETO S Hefi HarptDKAaHcKIax vr ceueftnrrxa*urvr3 ,,paB pe6ema cKBo3b [pu3MyrouulercnsrfiTeOpeTI4KOB KOMIJIeKCIIOMToJIbKOCO6CISeHHO[paBooTHoruesufi.

HosugHa cocTOlITHerr Brr r4MyruecrBeHHbrxupan pe6eHKa' Ho9M[upuqecKoM rrccJreAoBag1rur[qHLrxIIoBLI3HeuoJryqeHHblxaBTopoMpByJIbTaToB'HaIIIeAIIIXcBoeoTpulxeHueB]I3u [peAJIOXeHI4'trX' nan6Onee 3HaIIuMbIeTeOpeTUqeCruIXU IIpaKIIIIIeCKITx BbIBOAaxHa 3aIqIITy (c' 9'13B6IHOCI',IMbIXKOTOpbrx ilpeAcTaBireHbl B BUAe IIOJIOXeHI{IIX,4ncceptaqlu).TeMbI cHarIuHaeT U3JIOII(eHU9BOIIpOcoB safleIeHHOfi(c' 15'24v pe3nnrvrfl L4lcrvryra npan pe6euraucropr.nrecKoro acreKTa craHoBJreHr4rrI4CTOpUqecKoIo3KCI(ypca npeAcraBJIflIOTCO6CTBeHHO4UCCepraqnu). 3Aecs uoMlIMO[paB v o6sgaHHOCteft po4rrrelefi'r4rrTepec paccyxAeHut aBTOpa o 0oOTHOIIIeHUI{C OAnOft CTOpOHbI'IIO JIOII'IKeCAeJIaTbrepUHfi B6IBOAO TOM' IITO'KOTOpbIeIO3BOJILuILIC'flBJIflIOTCtr',rx o6sgaHHOCTf,MII'a'3aKOHOAaTe[t ilpaBa poAmenefi oAnospeMeHHOAuropo6ocnonannoApyrofi,_AaJIeKoHeBcgo6gsaHHoct[oAHoBpeMeIIHof,BJUIIoTcf,npaBaMupo4uterreft(c.2l wcceqaqun).upan pe6eHKau ero MeCTOUHCTI',ITyTaIIOIUITI',IeAanee coucKaTeJlbpaccMaTpIIBaeTTOIIKII(c.24-40 AI4CCepTaquu)'c MeToAoJloilr'IecrofiB CgBpeMeluofi npanonofi cucTeMell3yrreHulorIoJIoxfl'ITeIIbHbIM flBlrflgrcfl' rIoAxoA K3peHr{fi s srofi qacrfl TpyAa BecbMaKaKqepe3 IIpll3My O6ulereOpeTI'ItIecKLIX nOu'r114fto TaKI{X3arIBIIeHHbIx BoIIpOCoB((cucTeMa IIpaBa)' 3ro AaJIO BO3MOXHOCTb(oTpacJrb rrpaBa), ((rlHCTlITyT IIpaBa))'CaMOCTO'f,TeJIbHocTIInblftrra ua o6cyNgeHl4e llpo6leublAUCCepTaHTyB AtulbHefiureueMy CAenaTbIITo, B cBolo orlepeAb, IIo3BoiIlIJI[ceuefilroro flpaBa KaK oTpacJII,I,cucteue' floI4HCTIITyTaupan pe6eHKa B UpanonofiMecTeOBbIBOAbIcooTBsTcTByroque9THOIIIeH]IflM' HeAOCTaTOqHac11euno uKa' IIpVrcylqa[ ceMefisguMH9HI4IOCOTIAKaTSJIS,KHopM' peryJlllpyrcIllux STII OTIIorugHI4fl'coBOKyuHocTb.iloorrOTHeCTnAJr.f,TOIO,STII oTHOIIIeHI{fl AOCTaToIIHOoTpacJIlI IIpaBa' oAHaKo oHa AeIasTorAelblroficnoeo6pasHblMllAJI.f,ToIo,.ITo6rrpacIIeHuBaTbceuefirroe[paBoBKaqecTBeelqeoAnofiJrp3rrAaHcKororpaBa (c.36-37,40 4nccepraquu).B cnrgu c sTtIMuHcrrrryrroAorpacJrr,rI,Irvrennoc raKITxnpan pe6eHKapaccMarpr,rBaercrB KaqecrBerpoKAaHcKo-upaBoBoro.npeAnocbrJroK aBTop rIocJIeAoBaTeJIbHonpoBoIIrT aHaJIrB BCeXMeTOAOJTOTUqeCKIIXBonpocoB TeMbr.Hecnaorpr Ha ro, rrro c naruefi ToqKI,I3peHlIrI cenrefinoe [paBo flBlIg.eraflcaMocrorrenruofi orpacJrlro [paBa, Mbr He Mo)KeMHe npl,I3Haru Hacroft.rllBocrb aBTopaBeFo rIoAXoAa.LI apryMerrTl,IpoBaHHocTbMHeHI4TIoTcTar4BaHLrLICBOeTOBaxnoeKoropoeMecro n pa6ore 3aHr4Maerv3yqeHre ruraccllQuKallntr npan pe6eura,6asupyercxrnaccuQllraqnft,HaMe)KorpacJreBoM noAxoAe,BcocrotlueMuMercrqr,rx Mecro B AoKTpI,IHe pa3rltrrHblxorpacnefiaHaJII'I3e[paBa(nKoHcrr,rryquoHHoM npaBe; cJroxfllBrrreircs.s pocczficroM upaBe o6uefi rnaccuQnnar\vLrilpaB qeroeera).

llpu erou aBTopoMrrpeAnpuHflTaB IIeJIoM yAaqHat [orrbrrKa, c oAnoficropoHbr, paccMorperb Bce r<naccraQuKarlilnB AI4iuIeICLIqecKoMeAI,IHcrBe,a, c Apyrofi Aarb KpurrqecKyroorIeHKy roror,rJIpII,IHoro AeJIeHVTI(c. 40-58 gnccepraqun).p$yJrbrare aBTop [prrxoAr{T K trHTepecHoMy,xortI,I He6eccnopHoM}, 3aKlIoqeHLIK)oToM, qro Jruqubre Her,rMyrrlecrBeHHbre[paBa pe6emaorpacJrrxB3aKoHoAareJrbcrBa(roncruryqrloHHoro,3alqrerrJlrrlrctlpexAaHcKoroB pit3Jll4qubrxvrAp.),ar,rMyrucarBeHHbrerrpaBaHe o6naAarorcuequQkxofi, I{ rlogToMyMoryr I,I AoJIXHrI6rrtr(c. 56, 58 Arccepralluu).pacoMorpeubrqepesrplr3My lpa4AaHcKoro3aKoHoAareJlbcrnanpan pe6eHra,BorpocaM peaJIpBaIIHrIB pa6ore ygeJrrercr 6olruoe BHI,rMaHue11pI,IsroM B Ha3BaHr,r[ coorBercrByroqercuaparpa$ape6emou cBor,rx rrpaB, r{To He coBceM ToqHo orporaerroBopl4Tcfl o peufi43ar\nLrero coAepn€Hlle (c.

58BorlpocoB,Ar,rcceprarlnn).B cBflsvrc err,rMpaccMarpuBaerct qeluft p.tA I,IHTepecHbrxnMeroilIrfrx Bax(Hoe TeopeTr4qecKoeu npaKil{qecKoe 3HaqeHI,Ie, B qacTHocTu,(c. 59 Aucceprallnvr 144anee), ceueftuyro npaBo- I'IpoAr{reJrbcKoenpaBoorHorrrenr,reAeecnoco6uocm (c. 61 4uccepraquu), [paBoBoe noJIoxeHLIeHecoBepmeHuoJlerHprxpo4rrrenefi (c. 70-72) n Ap. B .racrnocru, 3acJryxuBaer noMeplKKI,I rpeAJloxeuneilpaB I4 o6sgannocreft po4ureJleft c MoMeHTa,cor{cKarers o[peAeJrrrr Bo3HtrKHoBeHLIeoHI,I y3HaJIvro 3aqufirvKorAa npu nceft crerreHlr pa3yMHocTuI,I ocMorpl{TeJlbHocrl,Ipe6eura(c.

64 4zccepmqnu).qacrb pa6orbr uocBtlrleHa upodileMaMocyqecrBJleHl{t raKI'IxCauocro.sreJrbHrurJrr{rrHbrx Her,rMyrqecrBeHHbrx[paB pe6eHKa KaK [paBo Ha xI,I3Hb, npaBo xl4rblrBocrILITbIBarbcr B ceMbe, rrpaBo pe6euxa Ha vrMfl, ortlecrBo u $anrruuro, [paBo HaBbrpDKeHLreMHeHLrrru ero yqer. Baxuo iloArlepKr{yrb, qro K aHaJILI3ynepequcneHHbrxnpaB aBTop no.[xoAt4T c caMbrx rutrpoKr{x uoguurafi, oAHoIipeMeHHoocBelqan Bonpocbr,Korop6re c )rureroM coBpeMeHnbrx reHAeuuufi e sroft crfepe [o3BoJII'IJII4pirABur{yrbIpaHr,rrlbr o6rr.rHbrx [peAcraBJresufio6 ocyuecrBJleHurlJILITIHrIX HeI'IMyIrIecrBeHHbrxnpan pe6eura. Tar, aBTop ocraHaBJurBaerct ua upo6leMax rrpepbrBannr 6epeuenuocru3arlarbrx, Ho elqe He po)K,4eHHbrx4vrefi (c.(c. 78 Alrcceprarlull), upanoBoro rroJro)KeHkIllB84 4uccepraryuvt), 1rpuMeHeHur BcuoMorareJlbHbrx penpoAyKTt4BHbrxtexnolorufi,[epByro oqepeAb - TaK Ha3brBaeMorocypporarHoro MareprIHcrna (c.

94 guccepraryuu),pefncTpaqunpoXAeHLItpe6euraMarepblo,He cocrorrqefi(c.B 6pareL22pe6enraAr4cceprar{uu), noapacra pe6enKa, c Koroporo Moxer 6rrtr peiulkrcoBaHonpaBoBblp3:Karb eBoe MHeHI4e (c.124-132 4uccepraqzu)nAp. llpusroM ItrllpoKorrpr4Merurercr Me)Korpacresoft rro4xoA, Ha[puMep, trPtr ocBeIrIeHLIlI Bo[poca o [paBepe6egKa Bbrpaxarb cBos MHeHr4e aBTop rIpoBoAI,IT o6o6ulenue npaKTI'IqecKLIBcexcJD raeB, KorAa rpe6yercr MHeHue (comacue) pe6eura, a He orpaHurlvBaerc.tt paMKaMucr.

57 CK PO. 3Aecr 3acJryxr4Biuor roAAep)KKrI vt ogo6peur,Ia BbrBoAbr aBTopa,Kacarcullrgc{MoMeHTa Bo3HtrKHOBeHrlUIrIpaBOC[OCO6nOCrpIqeloBeKa(c.78-83ga6orenauutrt, Ha3BaHHbIxs cr. 15Alrcceprarlun), upe4noxeHulr pacu[pkITb flepeqeHrCK P@ (c. 86 4ncceptaquu),BHecru I,I3MeHeHrIt s a6g. 2 n. 4. cr. 51 CK PO,Kacarc[U,recs [paBur BHeceHr4rrsafiucr4 B KaqecrBe poAuTeJlefi nuq, cocTotlqEx e 6parenrelqy co$ofi r,r AaBrur,rx corJracue Ha EMIUIaHTaIIwo eu6puona Apyroft x9HIIII'IHe BrleJrrx ero BbrHarrvB4n4s.