Отзыв оппонента 2 (Синтез и зондовая мессбауэровская диагностика перовскитоподобных манганитов AMn7O12 (A = Ca, Sr, Cd, Pb) и AMnO3 (A = Tl, Bi))

OT3bIB O@klqklAJIbHOTO OUIIOHEHTAH a nMccepTauMIor~1a31co~oiiH H ~CI e p r e e ~ ~ b ~( ( C H H TM ~3OHAOBM~M ~ C C ~ ~ Y ~ PAMaTHOCTMKaO B C K M I I ~ P o B c K M T o I I o ~ o ~ H ~ I MaHTaHMTOBXAMn7012(A= Ca,Sr, Cd, Pb) H AMn03 (A= TI,Bi))), n p e n c T a B n e H H y r o H a CoMcKaHMey r e ~ o iciT e n e H HK a H n M n a T a XMMH9eCKMX H a y K lI0 CIIeuHaJIbHOCTXM:02.00.01 - H e O p T a ~ k l 9 e C ~XMMMXMM 01.04.07 - @113MKaKOHAeHCMPOBaHHOrO COCTOXHMXb~ ~ ~ O B C K ~ I T O I I OMaHTaHMTbI~ O ~ H ~ I ~XBJUUOTCX BeCbMa MHTepeCHbIMM M IIepCIIeKTHBHbIMH nJIXE I C C J I ~ , ~ O B ~ H M 0# 6 ' b e ~ ~ a ~ M%'o.HaWbIXCBX3aHOHeTOJIbKOO C O ~ ~ H H O C T X M M HXCK ~ H C T ~ J I J I M W C K CTpYKTYPbIO~~H p a 3 ~ 0 0 6 p a 3 M eXMMM9eCKHX~3JIeMeHTOB(d-M ~~~JI~M~HToB),BJIMXIoUHX H a @ ~ I ~ ~ I K O - X M M M ~C~BCOK~~~IC~TMaHTaHHTOB,B~HO H C BO3MOXHOCTXMM LUkIPOKOTOIIpaKTkI9eCKOrOC B O ~ ~ C T Bpa3JIMYHbIXIIpMMeHeHMXTeMepOBCKMX MOHOBMaHTaHMTOBBTeXHHKe.H a J I m k ~ e XH-ueJIOVH03eMeJIbHbIX HJIH peflKO3eMeJIbHbIX 3JIeMeHTOB B CTPYKTJJpeI I ~ ~ o B c K M T o I I o ~ o ~ H ~ I X MaHTaHMTOB,MMeIOIQMXHeCKOJBKOK~McT~JIJIoT~~@H~~cKHIIHe3KBMBaJIeHTHbIX l l 0 3 M ~ f AJIXiMOHOB MeTalIJIOB, OIIpeneJIXeT kIHTepeC K M3YSeHMIO O C O ~ ~ H H O C T ~ ~ ~MX @ M ~ M ~ ~ C KCMBOX~ ~ C T B 3aBMCMMOCTH OT XMMMSeCKOTO COCTaBa, CTPYKTyPHbIX O C O ~ ~ H H O C T ~ ~ ~ ,B3 ~ 0 f iCBX3MM ~ C C ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ CIIeKTpOCKOIIMHO B C K O ~Ha m p a XBHeIIIHHX ~ 0 3 ~ e f i C ~ ~MM@f ai 3 0 ~ b I XIIepeXOnOB.MCIIOJIb3OBaHkIe0~06b1fi HHTepeC5 7 ~ eKOTOPbIe,C T p y K T y p y ~ ~ ~ ~ O B C K M T O I I O , I ( OMaHTaHMTOB,~H~IX3 a M e I 4 M KaTHOHbITJIaBHMtMn.IIpeACTaBJIXeTBHeHpXKlTCXB3 n e C b BO3HHKaeT IIepBiW3Wa98 - CkIHTe3MPOBaTb HOBbIe Mal-ITaHMTbI C A O ~ ~ B K ~ @M ~HK T H ~ ~ C W3CTOTOKMM30TOIIa5 7 ~ eOueHMTb,MX C T p y K T y p y H C B O ~ C T BB~ CPaBHeHMM C aHaJIOTM9HblMB MaHTaHHTaMH, H eC O n e p X q H M M XeJIe30.S~T~C J IMenyeTBTOpM rJIaBHM3wa9a -kI3MepMTb M ~ C C ~ ~ Y ~ P O B C K H ~CIIeIcrpbI CMHTe3MPOBaHHbIX Mal-ITal-IMTOB, IIPOBeCTH MX ~ I I I I P O K C M M ~ ~ I KM) H H T e p l T p e T a ~ H I o .

A3aTeM,IILIIOCTPYKTYPHbIe,BO3MOXHOCTH,3JIeKTpOHHbIeIIOCTPOMTbkI@ M ~ H S ~ C K H MOneJIM,~MWHHTHbIeO~'~SICHMT~IIO3BOJIXIOuMeO C O ~ ~ H H O C T HHCCJIe,L(yeMbIXTeOpeTMYeCKkIe IIOnXOnbI K MX OIIkICaHMIo. ~ O ~ T O MnMCCePTauMOHHllXYMaHTaHHTOB,pa6o~aA.C.~ a f i ~ M~ J I ~ ~ K o B o ~ ~XBJIReTCX BeCbMa a K ~ y a J I b ~ 0 f i .H a y s ~ aHOBU3Ha~A H C C ~ ~ T ~ ~ I O pHa H6 0O~ b~ 1~OlIpe,JJeJIXeTCX,~ C J - I O B MCkiHTe3a~~HOBbIX ~ I ~ ~ o B c K M T o I I o ~ o ~ HMaHTaHMTOB~IXCKOTOPOTO B C T p Y K q P e MaHraHMTOB, CCBO~CTB,CABTOPOMnpyr0fi - IIO3BOJIkIJIO0n~0fiCTOPOHbI,IIPWMeHMTbI I p e m e BCeTO,pa3pa60~~0fin o 6 a ~ ~ M3OTOIIaa ~ a 5 7 ~ eHaJIHrMe,IIpHBeJIO K M3MeHeHkIK) HeKOTOPbIXM~CCG~Y~POBCKJ'IOCIIeKTpOCKOIIMIOMX M3PeHMX.IIPOBeneHO MCCJIenOBaHMe IIOJIMKPMCTaJIJIOB CEiHTe3MPOBaHHbIX HOBbIX Mal-ITaHMTOB Mn o n y q e H b 1 nal-IHbIe06HX K P M c T ~ J I J I M ~ ~ c K OCTPYKTYpe.~~n O K a 3 a ~ 0 ,S T 0n 0 6 a ~ ~H30TOIIaa"FeIIPklBOnMT K IIOHMXeHEIIO T e M I I e p a T y p CTpYKTYPHbIX @ a 3 0 ~ b I XIIepeXOAOB B MaHTaHMTaX, B TOspermK ~ KT e M n e p a T y p a I MWHHTH~IX @ ~ ~ O B ~n eI pXe x o n o B H e M~M~HIIIOTCX.ABTOPOMBnepBbIe1HCCJIeAOBaHbI 3JIeKTpHYeCKHe CBepXTOHKHe B ~ ~ M M o ~ ~ ~ ~ c RT ABeHp R5.FeXOl2(ACa, Sr, Cd, Pb)=( A = T1, Bi), conepxamixH AMnl,FeXO35 7 ~ eO.

~ H ~ ~ Y X9 T~O HHOHbIO , XeJIe3a7 ~ Be3 a M e W a m T KaTHOHbIMnHeMaHraHHTaXAMn7-6onee 1 a ~ . %~ s o ~ o n aB B W e H T H b I X COCTORHHRx4-3H+4,YTO O T p a X a e T C R H a CBepXTOHKHX I I a p a M e T p a X COOTBeTCTByIOIIJHX KOMIIOHeHT M ~ C C ~ ~ Y ~ P O B C K H X4 a 3 0 ~ b 1I I ~e p e X O n O BCneKTpOB, IIOKa3aHO BJIHRHHe CTPYKTYPHbIX H3neKTpwsecKorononxHaxnpax 5 7 ~ eA.C..r n a 3 ~ o ~06~apyxuna,aYTOAMn7-xFexO~2B e n r r s H H a panuycaHUIHPHHYCTpYKTYPTeMIIepaTypHOrO3TUXKaTuoHanHaIIa30HaMaHTaHHTOB.B n e p ~ b I e AJIR3 a H H M a e M b I X HOHaMH X e J I e 3 a .H3OTOIIbI5 7 ~3ea H H M a m TAA B O ~ ~ H ~ IMXa H r a H H T O B5 7 ~ e3 a, M e W a m W H XUeHTpiUIbHOrO~HOHbICnBHraaBTOpOqeHHJIan H ~~ n +~H a+ OCHOBe,BCJIeACTBHeMaHTaHHTOBAMnl,FeXO3 (A=KBa~paTHYHOrOTI, Bi) IIOKa3aH0,Mn.CTPYKTYPHO H e 3 K B H B W e H T H b I e I I 0 3 H q H H KaTHOHOB~ 1 TaKHX~ +=TpeX~ B ~ ~ C K O ~ ~H IIOKa3aJIa, YTO 3 T H T e M I I e p a T y p b I OAHHaKOBbI nJIR AByX He3KBHBiUIeHTHbIXno3uqaii,CJIyYaJIp 0 ~ 6 0 3 n p ~ ~ e c ~H o Kf iYCOCyWeCTBOBaHHRT ~ M I I ~ P ~ T Y ~3aBHCHMOCTHH O ~ ~3 4 4 e ~ ~AonnepaaB ~ B O G H ~ IMXa H r a H H T a xA ~ B+n u R e T H a T e M n e p a T y p y 3 a p ~ n o ~ oyr noo p a n o s e H mM ~ C C ~ ~ Y ~ ~ OT Be MCI IKe pHa T~y p b I AJIR H30TOIIOBH3MePeHHRB MaHraHHTaX H a r p a H e H T" ~ eOKa3bIBaeTCRI I 0 3 U q H f i AJIR X A e pC B ~ ~ X T O H KCTpyKTYPbIO~~nJIX COOTBeTCTByIoWHXnap KOMIIOHeHTYeTbIpe.YTon p H 3TOM nrUIO ~ H ~ IKI a pOa M e T p b ICIIeKTPOB OKa3iUIHCb ~ J I H ~ K HYTO,CBHAeTeJIbCTByeT 0 C y W e C T B e H H O MeHbLLlHX CTePeOXHMHYeCKHX OTJIHYHXX CTPYKTYPbI J I O K W b H O r OOKpyXeHHRnnep 5 7 ~ e 3,a M e W a I O W H XCOOTBeTCTByIOWHeMnn a p b 1 KaTHOHOB~JIU~KHMIICKpHCTiUIJIOXHMHYeCKUMH I I a p a M e T p a M H ( C O ~ J I ~ C H O ~ O ~ H ~ Y ~ H A.C.H R M ~ J I ~ ~ K oB AJIXo ~ ~IIapbIMnlHMn4KaTHOHOBHIIap MnlPaCWeIIJIeHHRCyWeCTBeHHOMn2napbIHHMn3).Mn2, Mn4HOTJIHYHRMn3xeM e m yH COOTBeTCTByIOIIJHXM ~ C C ~ ~ Y ~ P O B C K CIIeKTpOB,HXKOMIIOHeHT~ o J I ~ U I H M H .An2MaHraHHTac ~ p y ~ ~ y pJIOKiUIbHOTOoiiBiMnl,FeXO3KaKOKpYXeHHR3 ~ a Y e ~ HKBaApyIIOJIbHOrOcIIOKa3aJIaaBTOpOMaBTOp,OKa3UIHCbO ~ H ~ P Y X ~nepexonH0 p 6 H ~ i U I b ~ 0 - ~ I I o ~ R ~ o Y ~ H BH o ~Oo P ~ H T ~ U I ~ H O - P ~ ~ Y I I O P R A O ~ COCTORHHe~HHO~C113POCTOMT e M I I e p a T y p b I BbIUIe K O M H ~ T H O ~5 0~ J.

I e e TOrO, IIO AaHHbIM M ~ C C ~ ~ Y ~ P O B CIIeKTPOCKOIIHHC K O ~ ~aBTOP0 6 ~ a p y x ~ n raH C T e p e 3 H CBCOOTHOUIeHHUOTHOCHTeJIbHbIXH a r P e B a H H H H O X J I a X n e H H H 3 T O r 0 M a H T a H H T a , 9 T O II03BOJIHJIOer0 KaK~0JIefi2.C.o6owxCOCTORHH~ IIpHr J I a 3 ~ 0 ~ 0 fXia p a K T e p H 3 0 B a T bCJIeACTBHe @ ~ ~ O B O TIIepeXO&3OI I e p B O r O P O A a B M a H r a H H T e BHCMYTa.l l p a ~ ~ u s e c r c o es ~ a g e ~ u neu c c e p ~ a q u o ~ ~ opa6o~b1fi2.C.~ J I ~ ~ K O BCOCTOHTO ~BP ~ ~ P ~ ~ O T ~ HMHe TOOMn e C H H T e 3 a pa3JIHYHbIX I I ~ ~ O B C K H T O I I O ~ O ~ MH a~HI rXa H H T O B C A O ~ ~ B K ~ M HHsOTOIIa5 7 ~ eKOTOPbIe,HeCOnepXaT~ e c c 6 a y 3 p o ~ c ~CIIeKTpOCKOIIHHofiIIpHMeCHbIX4%.

Bp a 6 o ~ e IIOKa3aHbIB03MOXHOCTHB H3YYeHHH O C O ~ ~ H H O CJIOKiUIbHOrOT ~ ~ ~O K P Y X e H H R B CJIOXHbIXCHCTeMaX, KOTOPbIMH RBJIRIOTCX MaHTaHHTbI. P a 3 p a 6 0 ~ a ~ ~ aBTOPOMb I eIIOnXOAbI K a n I I p O K C H M a q H HM ~ C C ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ O BCIIeKTpOBC K H X H aHiUIH3y p e 3 y J I b T a T O B H a OCHOBe Y Y e T a CTPYKTYPHbIX 0 ~ J I B 9 k I f iJIOKiUIbHOrO O K P Y X e H H R H I I O B e n e H H R ~ - ~ J I ~ K T ~ o HH3OTOIIOBoB2" ~ eM O r Y T6 b 1 ~ bHCIIOJIb30BaHbIHaYsHbIMkiTPYnnaMki,BeAYUI.UMkinOA06HbIeHCCJIeAOBaHUII.nOJIyseHHb1epe3yJIbTaTbIk i C C J I e ~ 0 ~ a H H MaHTaHUTOBfiIIBJIIIIoTCR BKJIaAOM B p a 3 B U T H e KaK H ~ O ~ T ~ H H ~XkiMUU,~ C K OT a~K ~ H@ki3kiKH KOHneHCHPOBaHHOTO COCTOIIHHR TaKHX CHCTeM.OHHT a K X eMOTYT ~ 0 f i ~ Bk iKYPCbI JIeKqHfiAJIX ~ ~ K ~ J I ~ BM a~r Ho CBT P, a H T O B H a C I I U p a H T O B no COOTBeTCTBYIoUI.HM AHCqkiIIJIkiHaM.HaAeXCHOCTb H AOCTOBepHOCTb p e 3 y J I b T a T O B ~ H C C ~ ~ T ~ ~ H pa60~b1O H H O 0~6 ~e c n e s k i ~ a m ~ c 1 1KaseCTBOMp a 3 p a 6 0 ~ a ~ ~ O T OLIBTOPOMMeTOAaCUHTe3aa~~ec~aqllefiMaHTaHATOB,CHHTe3UPOBaHHbIX MaHTaHHTOB, KOMnJIeKCOM @ U ~ H ~ ~ C KMeTOAOBHX(CTPYKTYPH~IX, MaTHHTHbIX,T ~ ~ M O ~ H H ~ M H ~ ~ C K HAOnOJIHIIIoUI.HXX),IIOJIyseHHbIXA.C.~ e C C 6 a y 3 p O ~ ~ K y I oC n e K T p O C K O n H I o ,COTJIaCkieMr J I a 3 ~ 0 ~ 0 pf ei 3 y J I b T a T O B a n n p O K C H M a U U H ki H H T e p n p e T a q k i H M ~ C C ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ O B C K U XCneKTpOB C TeOpeTHseCKUMkiOUeHKaMHIIOJIyseHHbIXnapaMeTpOB.Bce3T0 O ~ O C H O B ~ I B ~ ~ TBblBOAbl a B T O p a ~ H C C ~ ~ T ~ U H O pHaH6 0O~~b ~1 H UX JIOTHKy B P a M K a X nOCTaBJIeHHbIX3aAasHp a 3 p a 6 0 ~ a H H b I xIIOnXOAOB K UX P e I I I e H k i I o .noT e M e ~ ~ ~ C C ~ ~ T ~ ~ pa60~b1I H O H HaBTOPOMO ~ ~O~~~JIHKOB7~ HCO~ a ~ e Bf i ~OCCH~~CKHki XBAK P a ,MeXAYHaPOAHbIX X y p H a J I a X H 3 n e p e s H I ISCO~UHSWebHayYHbIXOfScience, HB12 T e 3 U C a X AOKJIanOBKOTOPbIe HHAeKCHPyIoTCR BK O H @ ~ P ~ H U U R XH H a5AaHHbIXM e X A Y H a P O A H b I X ki P O C C ~ ~ ~ ~ ICI PKo @~ ~H XJI~H~IxK O H @ ~ ~ ~ H ~ H PRe X3 y.