Отзыв оппонента Зайцева-Зотова (Оптические и фотоэлектрические свойства композитных структур на основе пористой матрицы SnO2 и гетероэпитаксиальных нанокристаллов CdSe-CdS)

Apo3~osan o c s m e H a k i 3 y u e ~ a mS@@~KTHBHOCTH @OTOc e ~ c k i 6 m a 3 a q a aI I O p k i ~ T 0 f iMaTP-ISnOz C I I O M O w b m reTepO3IIHTaKCkiaJIbHbIX HaHOKPACTaJIn o B CdSeICdS. A k i c c e p ~ a L ( H s r C O C T O ~113 BsefleHkix, Y e T b I p e x m a B , 3ammsemsr ki c n k i c K a q m k i pye~ofim e p a T y p b 1 .~ k i c c e p ~ a q k i o mpa6o~amK .A.B0 B s e ~ e ~ uO u~ O C H O B ~aKTYaJIbHOCTbH~06'be~113JIOXeHO C O A e p X a H k i e pa60~b1IIP0BO)JHMbIX k i ~ ~ J I e f l 0 B a H k i fkii Bb160pTOB, C@OPMYJIP~POB~H~IVeJIki ki 3 W a r I l l ~ ~ ~ J I e f l O B a H kI4i fKPaTKOino r n a a a M .r f l a ~ a1 HaukiHaeTCXC OlTHCaHkiX OCHOBHbIX C B O ~ ~ C THki3KOpa3MePHbIXBO ~ ' ~ ~ K T OB BTOM,YHCJIe KBaHTOBbIX TOYeK, kl3YYaeMbIX B A ~ ~ c c ~ P T ~ ~ o pa6o~e.H H o ~ ~P ~ C C M O TBJIkiXHHe~ ~ H Op a 3 M e P O B KPkiCTaJLTIOB H a HX 3HepreTkiYeCKkie CIIeKTPbI, POJIb IIOBepXHOCTki,TIlrrIIOBePXHOCTkiIIpHC03flaHkiH~ 0 ~ l I 0 3 1 1 ~ ~CTPYKTYPbI,0fiB 0 3 H H K a H ) w e B reTep03IIkiTaKCkiaJIbHbIX HaHOKpFiCTaJIJIaX,BaTa m e BJIllXHkie IIOKpbI-TOMki3yYeHkim'4kiCJIe~@@KT~I,KOTOPbIX I I O C B q e H apa6o~a.P a c c ~ o ~ p e mT a~m e n p o q e c c b 1 r e H e p a q k i a @ O T O B O ~ ~ Y X , ~ ~ H H ~~ o c a ~ e n e f3apmaiki n p o q e c c b 1 n e p e H o c a ~oca~enefis a p ~ ~Mae q y H a H o K p a c T a n n a M k i a~ a ~ p k i q e f iB, TOM wcne H e K o T o p b I e B o n p o c b I KkiHeTkiKki n e p e H o c a .

3 a ~ a w k i s a e ~ c srnasar@OPMYJI~IPOBKO~~I I p 0 6 J I e M a T k i ~ k iHCCJIeflOBaHFiH Ei I I O C T ~ H O B K3 OQ ~a ~Y HCCJIe~OBaHFiH.OIIIIOH~HTXOTeJI 6b1 OTMeTkiTb O Y e H b X O p O u I e e 0 6 0 c ~ o ~ a msb160paeO ~ ' ~ ~ K T aCCJIe~OBaHkiX,OBKOTOpOeyW4TbIElaeT KaK c I I e L ( H @ l l ~ y Fix KpHCTNIJEFIeCKOrO CTPOeHHR, T a K ki 3 H e p r e T H Y e C K y I o CTPYKTYPY,mccepTamoHHarrB TOM W C J I e B3akiMHOe PaCIIOJIOXeHkie MkiHkiMYMa 3 0 H b I IIpOBOmMOCTki I4 MaKCkiMyMa BaJIeHTHofiB rnarre 2 n p e A c T a s n e H b r M e T o m m 3 K c n e p n M e m a n b H b r x k i c c n e ~ o ~ a mkif iK p a T K o o n k i c a HbI OCHOBHbIe 3 K C n e p k i M e H T U I b H b I e YCTaHOBKH ki O X a P a K T e P k i 3 0 B a H b I HCCJIeAOBaBIIIkieCR 0 6 p a 3 ~ 1 .B rnarre 3npeAcTasneHbr 3KcnepkiMemanbHbIepe3ynb~a~b1k i~ y ~ e3 n~e ~m~ p o @ k i 3 k i q e -Sn02c KBaHTOBbIMki TO'4KilMki CdSe pa3JIki'4HOrO p a 3 M e p a .c o n k i c a m s r p e 3 y n b ~ a ~H coc~n e A o s a H a r r K k i H e m K k i H a p a c T a m s r ki c n a a @OTO-CKHX Pi OllTki'4eCKkiX C B O ~ ~ C TCTPYICTyPBr n a ~ Ha a s m a e T c s rIIpOBOmMOCTbi, C B k i A e T e J I b C T B y I o w X 0 IlIZIPOKOM PaCnpeAeJIeHkikI B p e M e H peJIaKCaI@ikiBeCHbIX H O C H T ~ J IBnJIOTb~~~A0HepaBHO-H e C K O J I b m X '4aCOB.

C T O J I ~60JIbIIIkie B p e M e H a P e J r a K C a W k i CTaBXTBO~OCOMeTO~kiKeH3~'4eHkiRC~eKTpUIbHO~OOTKnkiKa,ki3MepeH~eKOTOpO~OCTaHOBkiTCRBeC~ e T P k i ~ k i a J I b ~ 0 fkii B P ~ M I I ~ M K 3aAarefi.O~~HOG rrpo6nem1, KOTOpOeki3y'4aeMbIXB J@iccep~aqkio~~ofipa60~enpeJ(JIOXeH0nO3BOJIHJIO AkiCCepTaHTy nOJIy'4HTb C n e K T p b I @ O T O ~ ~ O B O J ( H M O CBCeX~O ~ ' ~ ~ K T O OBI.I H c a H b I p e 3 y J I b T a T b I@ o T O ~ ~ O B O ~ H M O CAJIRT ~ ~ CTpyICTypSnOz CEiCCJIeAOBaHWICneKTpZUIbHbIXKBaHTOBbIMki TOZIKaMkiCdSekiccnenyeMoro~~BHCHMOCT~~pa3JIkIYHOTO p a 3 M e p a ,n p e A C T a B n e H b 1 T e M n e p a v p H b I e 3aBkiCkiMOCTki n P O B O ~ k i M O C T k i3THX CTPYKTJ'PnoncsemeP e I I I e H H e AaH-IIPH ~ e n p e p b 1 ~ ~ 0 f i06pa3qa.

rnasa sa~epruae~crro 6 c y . l r c s e ~ ~n oeJ~I y r e H H b r x pe3ynb~a-TOB.B rnaBe 4IIpHBeAeHbI p e 3 y J I b T a T b In o ~ p o 6 ~ o r3oK C n e p k i M e H T U I b H O r O~ J I ~ K T P o @ H ~ ~ ~ ' ~H~ OnTkiW2CKHXcK~IxC B O ~ ~ C TCTPYICTyPBkiCCJIeAOBaHEi5lSn02C KBaHTOBbIMki TO'4KaMEi CdSeICdS Cpa3JI11'4~0fi T O J I ~ H H O0~6~0 ~ 1 0 'CdS.4 ~ ~ ~ P ~ A C T ~ B J pI e~3 yHJ I~b TI a T b I HCCneAOBaHkiR C n e K T p a J I b H b I X~ ~ B H c P ~ M o cn OT r~J I~O~u e H k i H ki @ O T O J I H ) M ~ I H ~ C ~ ~ HJJJ~R H EKBaHTOBbIXITO'4eKH e , p e 3 y n b T a T b I E I C C J I ~ .

I ( O B ~ H RKHHeTHKki~~HapaCTaHkIII ki Cn&alTyp S n O 2 C KBaHTOBbIMkiTO'4KaMkireKCa-~OTOIIPOBO,I(~~MOCTHAJIR CTPYK-CdSeICdS, C n e K T p a J I b H b I X ~ ~ B H C H M O C@ TO ~T O~ ~ P O B O ~ ~ M O C T ~ Im R CTpyICTypSn02CAHMOCTHCTPYICTyP S n O 2 C KBaHTOBbIMH TO'4KaMHm e M nonyreHHbrxCdSeICdS BKBaHTOBbIMki TO'4KaMHCdSeICdS, T e M n e p a T y p H b I XCdSeICdS. r~ ~ B H C H M O Cn pTO~B~0 -~~ r a 3~a Bae P I U a e T C R06cyme-pe3ynb~a~o~.Ilocne~miipa3~enW c c e p T a q m - ocHoBHaIe p e s y n a ~ a ~ubB~~ I B O A ~KI .OCHOBH~IMpe3YJlbTaTaM J ( H c c ~ ~ T ~ ~ o H pa6om1H o ~ ~ MOXHO OTHeCTki CJIeAYWUJHe:1. YCT~HOBJI~HO,ZIT0CdSe, CdSeICdS MOrYT 6 b 1 ~ b ~@@~KTI.IBHOBHeApeHbI B MaTPlTL(Y Sn02.

B H ~ W ~ HHaHOKpkiCTaJIJIbIH~I~COXPEiHRIoT O C O ~ ~ H H O C T H3 ~ e p r e T l i Z I e c ~ O fCTPYKTYPbI,i06ycnosne~~b1ep a 3 M e p H b I M KBaHTOBaHkieM. C Y ~ ~ C T B YHaHOKpkiCTaJIJIbI3apXJJo~bIfi O ~ M M~ He w BHeffpeHHbIMkI HaHOKpkiCTaJIJIaMII ki ~ a T P k i q e f i .2. 0 6 ~ a p y r n e ~ 0ZITO, B CneKTpaJIbHbIX 3aBkiCkiMOCTRX @OTO~POBOJ@~MOCT~.AJIX CTPYKTYPSnO2-QD ki C n e K T p a J I b H b I X ~ ~ B I I C ~ ~ M OlTTkiZIeCKOrOO C T ~ ~ ~lTOmOUJeHUX HaHOKPkiCTaJIJIOBnPRCYTCTBYeT C M e a e H k i e O C O ~ ~ H H O C CTn~e K~T~p O B , OTBeZIaIoUJHX KBaHTOBbIM TOZIKaM.Y ~ a 3 a H b OCHOBHbIeI@IKTOP~I, BJIR5IIOllJHe H a BeJIkizIkiHy CABkira kier0 3HaK:BJIEiSIHkIe M I T -P m I H a ~ ~ c x o A H3~HIe~p r e ~ W I e ~ ~ kCinfeiK T p HaHOKpkiCTaJIJIOB H YMeHbUIeHRe kiX3@@e~-TIlBHOrO p a 3 M e p a BCJIeACTBRe OKkiCJIeHEiX nOBepXHOCTR.3.n O ~ a 3 a H 0 ZIT0,~ ~ K O M ~ I I H ~B ~CITIP XY K T y p a X S n 0 2 - Q D B OCHOBHOM OCYaeCTBJIXeTCX H a~ ~ K O M ~ H H ~ ~ ~ q~ e OH THp aHX ~, BI XKaZIeCTBe KOTOPbIX B b I C T Y n a I o T BHeApeHHbIe HIHOKPH-c~mmr.P ~ K O M ~ E I H ~ I @kiMeeT~Xsageprna~~brfixapaKTepAJIXBcexkiccneAoBaHHbIxC T P y K T y p .

M r H o ~ e H H b r eB p e M e H a XH3Hkl 3 a g e p X C a H H o f i @OTOITPOBO~MOCTR n O 9 T U H e3aBkiCXT O T p a 3 M e p a HaHOKpkiCTaJIJIOBCdSe,C y u e C T B e H H O B O 3 p a C T a I o T n p k i C03AaHkiki0 6 o n o . r ~CdS~ ki y s e n u r e m k i ee T o n q m b r .4. YCT~HOBJI~HO,ZITO npkiB a P b R p O B a I M k i p a 3 M e p a HaHOKpkiCTaJIJIOB@ O T O ~ ~ O B O ~ M OBC TCTPYKTYpaX~SnO2-QD AOCTliraeTCXCdSeMaKCkiMaTIbHaRnpki B H e A p e m B MaTPRqyKBaHTOBbIX TOZIeK MMHkiMaJIbHOrO p a 3 M e p a .5.n O ~ a 3 a H 0 ZITO,H m W e O ~ O J I O ~ K CdSHBOKPYr XJJpaHCXOJ(HO~~K B ~ H T O B OTO=~~CdSen p k i B 0 w T K C M e a e H M I o l T o J I 0 ~ e ~ k i MaKCkiMYMOBfiB CIIeKTpaJIbHbIX 3aBkiCkIMOCTXX IIOrJIO-a e m x M @ o ~ o m m e c q e ~ q k i Bk ci n e A c m k i e ~6.M ~ H ~ Hp aM3R~ e p oO~~WKT~.0 6 H a p y ~ e H 0 , ZITO B e J W i H H a KBaHTOBOrO BbIXOAa JnoMkiHeCqeHqkikiCdSeJCdS&lHHbIMkiki a M n m T y A a@o~oo~wrm@ aO T O ~ ~ O B O ~ O C AJUITHHaHOKpkiCTZUIJIOBCTPYKTYPSno2-QD cHaHOKpkiCTaJIJIaMki X a p a K T e p H 3 y I o T C X H ~ M O H O T O H H O ~3aBkiCkiMOCTbIo~OT TOJI-UJHHbI 0 6 0 ~ 1 0 9 ~ k i CdS.XPKO BbIp-eHHiWCKOppe-XYZIeTOM OKI.ICJIemX O~OJIOYKHHaHOKpkiCTaJIJIOB H ~ ~ J I K I ~ ~ ~ ~ TM e m Y npHBeAeHHbIMki BbIUIe 3aBUCkIMOCTXMki.~ O C T O B ~ ~ H OliC HTO~B l i 3 H a p e 3 y J I b T a T O B A H C C e p T a ~ A A .n e p e z ~ k i c J I e H H b ~BbIUIeeOCHOBHbIe pe3yJIbTaTbI ~ c c ~ ~ T ~ H o Hpa6o~b1H o ~ nOJIyZIeHb1~BnepBbIe.

OHM IIOpBeP>KAeHbIno)~po6~b1-~a6~11o~aemrxHBJIeHufi ki OIIHCbIBamTCX B P a M K a X0 6 a e n p k i H H ~ b I x TeOpeTMZIeCKkiX ~0~eJIefi.B PXJJe C J I y Y a e B BbInOJIHeH aHaJIki3 B03MOXHbIX aJIbTePHaTIlBHbIX MIlKPOCKOnkiZIeCKkiX MeXaHkl3MOB ~a6~11o~aemrx~ @ @ ~ K T O kiB H a OCHOBe C p a B H e Mki 3KCnepkIMeHTaJIbHbIMII IlCCJIeAOBaHkiXMkiOm0fi ki3 O C O ~ ~ H H O pa3~006pa3ue IlClTOJIb3OBaBrutIXCRC ~ e I l e H bO ~ O C H O B ~ H H O C T HWa y r H b I X I ~ o J I o x ~ H H ~W~ BbIBOAOB.c ~ f im ~ ~ e p ~ a I p i 0 H H O pa60~b1fiR s n X e T c X 6onbruoeM e T O m K IICCJIeAOBaHWI. T ~ K B, m C C e p T a q l u HCIIOJIb3OBaJIHCb M e T o m 1 ~ T P O C B ~ Y I I B ~ I O ~ ~~ J I ~ K T P o H H oM~k~i K P O C K O ~ U I l(TEM) H P ~ H T ~ ~ H O B C ,QH(PP~KIJHE~KO~~(XRD), TeMHOlTOJIbHaX MEIKPO-(HAADF-STEM), P e H T r e H O B C K m CneKTpOCKOIIHX (EDX) , c n e K T p o c K o n m n O r J r O u e H k i X ,H3yYaJIHCb C n e K T p b I ( P O T O J I I ~ M M H ~ C ~ ~ H I JAJ ~(POTO~POBO~MOCTU,AUClTOJIb30BaJIaCb 3 H e P r O m C IIepCkiOHHasI CneKTpOCKOnHX, a T a m e ki3yYaJIaCb KHHeTliKa H a p a C T a H H X ki C n W a ( P O T O ~ ~ O B O ~ C K O MMOCTU.A ~ H H IIOJIYYeHHbIe~I~,C T O n b pa3HbIMM MeTOAaMH, C y u e C T B e H H O AOnOJIHXIoT A p y r A p y r a liIIOBbIWaIoT AOCTOBepHOCTb p e 3 y n b T a T O B .

O C H O B H ~ Ip ~e 3 y n b T a T b 1 , npeflCTaBJIeHHbIe B AHCCepTa-IQi0~~0fipa60~e,o ~ T ~ ~ J I H K o B ~BHpelJeH3lipYeMbIX~IX y p H a J I a X , HeOAHOKPaTHO AOKJIWbIBaJIIlCbpoccufic~uxu M e x q y H a p o m b I x ~ o ~ ( P e p e H q u ~Hxa H a y y H b I x c e M u a a p a x . Haywb~enonoxeHWI, BbIHOCIlMbIe H a 3auHTY, 06061qam~p e 3 y J I b T a T b I 3KCnepUMeHTaJIbHbIX H C C J I ~ A O B ~ H H ~HX~a ~ m u 3 aB p a M K a x c y u e c T B y I o u u x n p e ~ c ~ a s n e ~uucfoir n a c y I o T c x c OCHOBH~IMUBbmoAaMki pa6o~b1.Hanuana3oHanapaMeTpoBCucTeMbI,npuKOTOP~IX c n e K T p b InEoMuHecqeHquuuApyruemmaB2 pasa. I l p e q c ~ a s n ~ eYTO~ c ~c T, o n bIIPOBOJ@lMOCTkIy 3 ~ M jmi anaso~H ~ M ~ H ~ HTWe MI n e p a T y p b IaHeAOCTaTOYeH AJIR AOCTOBepHOrO YCTaHOBJIeHkIR @ Y H K ~ o H ~ J I ~3aBkIHO~~CHMOCTH IIPOBOmMOCTII O T T e M n e p a T y p b I .n o MHeHkIIO OIInOHeHTa, e C T b OCHOBaHwI ripen-nOJIaTaTb, YTO H a CaMOM AeJIe BCR COBOKYIlHOCTb 3KCnepkIMeHTSUlbHbIX AaHHbIX r O p a 3 A OJIyYLUealEIpOKCHMIipyeTCR~ @ P O C ~ - ~ I U I O B C K O0~ O , e ~ p ([TdT]'"),-3aKOHOMOIIHCbIBaIOLIJHM, B TOM WCJIe, T e M n e p a T y p H y I O 3aBIICkIMOCTb nPOBOAkIMOCTki r p a H y J I P i p 0 BaHHbIX CIICTeM.Bce npllsegembre sames a ~ e s a ~ HOCRTk i ~ ~ e n p ~ m p f r n a n b ~xapamepb~fia HecHmamTH a y Y H o f i qeHHOCTkI p a 6 0 ~ b 1 .A B T o p e @ e p a ~Pi o I I ~ ~ J I H K o B ~ H pHa 6~ 0I T~b 1 IIOJIHOCTbIO ki TOYHO O T p W a I O T COAepXaHkIemccepTaqmi..' <c ~ p y q ap ~ o ~ ~~oa rc om~a6aMP3 HM.

B.A. K o ~ e n b ~ a ~PAH,osa/L4'3aiiu:8-30~0~Cepreii BnOKTOP @ E I ~ ~ I K O - M ~ T ~ M ~ T ~ I YH~aCy K E I Xn a ~ a ~ k i p o ~ a sh p e c : 125009 MOCKB~,Moxosm 11, c ~ p7.O T ~ ~C.B.I B 3aiiqesa-30~osasaseprrm:B.A. K o ~ e n b ~ a kPAHsayYeHb1B c e K p e T a p b kIP3 MM.K.@.-M.H.lT@CM.M. Y y c o ~a""9.+..