Отзыв официального оппонента 2 (Механизмы ускорения диффузии кластеров на чешуйчатой поверхности)

OT3bIBpa6oryo(f uqvranrnoro orrroHeHTaHa AprcceprarlrroHHyroKpacnonofi Arencan,upu KupuJrJroBHbrooMexaulrgMbrycnopeHun gn{Sy3rrrr KJracrepoBua.reuryftuarofi nosepxHocruot,(pu:uro-rrrareMarr,rqecKr,rxnpeAcraBJreHHyloHa corrcKaHzeyuenoft creneHr.rKaHAr4AaraHayKrro cleqrranbHocrpr0L04.07 @uszra KoHAeHcHpoBaHHofococrorHr4tr,{zccepraqux A.K. Kpacronoft npeAcraBnf,er co6ofi reoperkrqecKoe lrccJreAoBaHr4eqacrrirq,3aKoHoMepnocrefi croxacrr.rrrecxofi AI,rHaMIaKr{ AByMepHoro ancala6rsegaulaoAeficrByrorquxc 4nuxyrqeftcx rroBepxuocrbro. Pa6ora raMeer gKcnepraMeHTanbHyrorrpeAnocbrnKyB Br,rAena6nroAaeproftariouamno 6rrcrpoft gu$@ysrrr,rKnacrepoBpsAa MeraJrJroB[[porr.rrr4qecKoro rpa(frara. O6qeupuusrorono rroBepxHocrlr BbrcoKoopr4eHTlrpoBauHoroo6rscHeH[r groro rBJreHr.rrAo cr4x nop He 6ruro noryreHo, rrro rrpzAaer Ar{ccepraurEoHnoftpa6ore aKTyanbHocrr.

Vrasauurrft npoqecc flporeKaer rrpr4 co3AaHr,MAByMepHbrxcrpyKTyp(ronruxrrJreHoK,MaccrirBoBuaHouacruq) MeroAoM rasepuofi orrr,rraKcr{p1.IlonuruaHue ero3axonoMepnocrefi BaxHo [rfl pazur4Tr4qHaHorexnonorrafi,qro o6ecuequeaer rIpaKTI,IqecKyIo3HaquMocrb rrpoBe.4eHnbrx reoperrrqecKrixuccre4onanufi.o6rscneHzecynepau$$y3prurcBflsaHoc renJroBbrMABrrxeHLIeMcJroenrpa$ura Apyr rro Apyry, qro MoxerIIpI,IBOAT,ITbK yCKOpeHHOMy ABIrXeHr4rO KnaCTepOB 3a CqeT [epeAaquBoguoNnoer4M 3HeprUU B pe3ynbTaTenaauruo4eficrBvrfl.c ABprxyrqeficr rpa$rrosofinoAroNnoft.

Pa^enrarueerofi HAeH B paMKaxplnTepnperallllfl cocraBJrrJlooAHy rr3crarllcrlrqecrofi lrexannKr4 Lr ee repMoAr4HaMl,IqecKasfJraBHbrxAocrrrrHyrsrx qenefi flpeAcraBJrennofipa6oru. .{pyroff saNHoft uenbro Arrcceprarlr4r46ruro uareMarlrqecKoe I,IccJreAoBaHI,IeBo3HriKaroqrlx .qI,IHaMI,rqecKLtxpexr,rMoB c rroMorrlbloTeopulacryrafinux rpoqeccoB r.rqrrcJreHHbIXsKcrIepr4MeHToB.Ha grov nyru 6un noryqeH p{AHoBbIx pe3ynbraroB, Koropbre, MoxHo HaAe.rrrbc.rr,uaft.ayt cBoe [pLIMeHeHr{eAIrfl olancanvrflcoBeplrreHHor,rHbrxQrasuuecr<uxsnreuuft .nr{TeparypHoro o6sopa, onr4cankrfl.Lrccne4yeMbrx[uccepraqus cocronT r.r3 BBe.4envrs,pesynrrarauu, rJIaBhI,Susuvecxnx rd MareMarnqecKl4xnao4enefi,Tpex rJIaBc alaJrrTvrrrecKlrMr4rrocBflIrleHHofi.IucreHHoMy MoAeJrr{poBaHHIo,3aKrroqeHr.,rs.,crmcr.a coKparrleul,Ifin ycronusrxo6osHa.reHIEft,cnucnoB Jrureparypbr,prrcyHKonrara6uaq, a raKxe ognofo [punoxeHlrs.

Pa6oraI,I3noxeHa na 89 crpaHrrrlax, co,qepxr4t 79 nuteparypHbrx r,rcroqHlrron, 27 plrcyHKoB r{ 1ra6nzqy.Bo BneAenupro6ocnoBaHaaKTyanbuocrbreMbrAr4cceprarlrau,c$opuynupoBaHaocHoBHafnpo6lenaav pr4efl.ee pemeHr4"fl,rrocraBJreuao6qas qem pa6orbr- r.rccJreAoBaHr,recroxacrr4qecKr,rxnpoqeccoB Ha ABrrxyilIefics nosepxHocrr.ru c$oprvryrr{poBanbrKonKperHbrezanaqu, Koropbreneo6xo4IaIvropeilrl4Tb AJrr ee AocrH}KeHI,Ifl.[zuree lepelrr,rcJreHbrocHoBHbrelloroxteHr,r.s,BbIHocI4MbIeHa 3aIqI,ITy, o6ocnosaHrr :uayrrnafl.HoBH3Ha,Teoperl4qecKa-flu [paKTl,IqecKatr3Haqr4MOCTb,aTaKXeAOCTOBepHOCTb [OJryqeHHbrXpe3ynbTaToB,npr4BeAeHCrilrCOKxon(fepeHquit, na Koropbrx rrpoBoAr.rJracranpo6aqus.irvrx p$ynbraroB, onprcannuqHr,rftBKna.qcozcrareni B r4xnoryrreHkre,yKa3aHo6nenar{ crpyxTypa Akrcceprar\vv.B uepnofi rJraBecoAepxr.{Tcxo6:op nrrreparypbr,cocroflrquirus rpex pa3Aenoe.B [epBoMpI3HI,IX[poaHiInI,I3I,IpoBaHbrny6ruraqun, nocBsrleHHbre6unrrpAnrrM A[HaMr,rrrecKr,rMMoAeJrrMrrux [pr.rMeHeHrzrorrrfl orrlrcanvrs.Su:uuecr<ux ssnenlrfi.

Han6onruree BHhMaHLreyAeJreHorroHrrr4roycKopeHr,rr@epua, ero npzpoAe I4ycnoBLIrMBo3HHKHoBeHLrre 6vrupAnbrx cprcreMax.(DepuH B cnyqae croxacrr,rqecKoroABrrxeHrltrrpaHprrlycKopeHr4.f,flpune4eu pacqer Berr.rtrr4HbrpacceraBarenfl. Bropoftpa3.4en nr{Teparypuoro o6sopa nocBrrueH gKcnepr4MeHTaJrbHbrMny6rurxaqzxnro arE$$y3r4r{KnacrepoBr{3 aroMoBMerannoBHa rroBepxHocrurpa(pura. floxasano,qro Kaxyuuftcx xoe(f(fuqvreHrara$$yarEIrKnacrepar4MeeraHoMilJrbHo6onruyro BeJrr,rqr4Hy,HocraHAaprH)'ro appeHr{ycoBcKyro3aBlrcnMocrb orreMrreparypbr.

BrocJreAHeM pa3AenelepeqkrcreHbrJrnTeparypHbrecJroeB(ueuryerc)rpa$nra orHoclrreJrbHoAaHHbreo noABI,IXHocrr.rorofo ABprxeHr4f,,B qacrHocrr,r,Apyr Apyra, n o $arcropax, oflpeAenrrcruux xapaxTepr{crr4xr,rcBepxcKonb3Kocrb. O6sop nr{Teparypbr noABo.{r4T rrr{TareJrr K r.rAee florrcKa [purruHbrycKopenux@epurl B HccneAyerr,rBo3HlrKHoBeHr,rsofi S u:uuecrcoficucreue.Bo nropofi rJraBepaccMorpeH psA (fIa:uvecrrax rrao4erefi.llpeN4e Bcero, Ha ocHoBesKcnepr.IMeHTaJrbHbrxKnacrepoB3oJrorana rpa(fvrreAaHHbrxcAenaHBbrBoAo roM, uro 4raqp$ysr4figKc[epLrMeHTyHe Moxer r4MerbaKTr.rBarlrronnufixapaKTep.Bne4enrr ABe He nporr,rBopeqaur4eMoAeJrr,rnepeMerrleHr,rflKJracrepoBrro rroBepxHocrn: npaKTr.rqecKzcso6oAHoe ABuxeHr.rer{MeAneHHat4ra$(fysux B pe3ynbrare rrepexoAoBMexAy rreracra6purbHbrMrlcocrorulrsruu.

.{a-ueeoIII4caHbITpr4 TI,InaABr{xeHr,r{ueruyfir<nrpa$rara: 6ucrpoe KBa3r,rnepnoAurrecKoeABr4xeHr4e,6rrcrpoe cryuafinoe ABr,rlxeHr{er{ MeAJreHHoeclyuafiHoe ABr.rxeHrre.fnana 3aKaHrrr4Baerctpa3AenoM, fAe paccqprTaHaKpr,rTrlrrecKascKopocTb KJracTepa,rtpI,r npeBbrrrreHr4r4roropofi1utrcxpgnanMoAeJrbycKopenuxOepruu.6omrue ue o6ecne.rlrBaerBo3Hr,rKHoBeHr,reTperr.a rJraBa rrocBrrrleHao6o6qeuurc ypaBHeHr,rs@oxrepa-llnaHxa, orrrcbrBaroueropaccer.rBarersMr,r(ueuryfireABI{xeHI4e qacrllrlbr (rnacrepa) Ha 6ranrrpAe c noABraxHbrMurrpa(pura), ua crryuafrrepuoAlrqecxux rone6anzft creuox 6umxp4a.

C$opuynrapoBaHbrycJroBr4r,npz Koropbx r.BMeueHr,reMo.qynflcKopocrraMo)KHopaccMarpr4BarbKaKMapKoBcKr.rftupoqecc, nKoropoM pac[peAeneHlreqacrr,rq rro cKopocrrM orrrrcbrBaercsypaBHenuerrOorrepa-lllaur<a.Perueuue orofo )paBneHr{s rro3Bonser paccqr,rrarb Benuqr4HyycKopeHr4r@eprrrra,hpu srouoKtnblBaergfl,rITo oHa poBHo B Tpr4 pasa 6onure, qeM B cryqae, KorAa rone6auus creHoK1utrcxp4a Hocf,T croxacrurrecruft xapaKTep.[a"nee rroKa3aHo,trro pacaMorpeHHoeABlrxeHr4eMox(HooilucbrBarbc rroMorrlbroypaBHeHr{.flJlanNeeeHaKaKKBa3r{cra6nnrsrrfinopnenofi rrpoqeccBeccers.CyruecrneHnrrfir,rHTepecnpeAcraBnserTepMo,4prHaMr{qecKasrpaKToBKa 6unsxp4uofi[peAJroxeHHascorrcKareJreMMoAenr{.

PaccuarpunaxHepaBHoBecnsrftcrarr4crr4rrecrnfiaHcarr6nr (4nynaepHufiH4eamHsrfi ras) raxux cr4creM,B Koropbrx rracrr{rlbrnpuo6peraror oneprlrrc 3a c.rer reurolepegauu tn6o B pe3yJrbrarecoBepmeHr{rMexaHprqecroftpa6omr (npu croxacrr,rrrecKoMpaccer4Barerefi,coornercrnenno), ar4nepr{oArrqecKoMABrDKeHr4r4TaKXe frocrorHcrBo rrr4cra qacrr4rl s aHcal46re 3a crrer rn6enz (Hnruo6urusarluu) nan6oreeqacrr.IrIaMLI,col{cKarenbnpllxo.ql4TK6srcrprrx kr3 Hr4xkt rrorloJrHeuns.ancaM6rg naeAreHHbIMr4BbrBoAyo cyqecrBoBaHlrr4pexr{Ma co crarluouapHbrMpaclpeAeneHr4eMcxopocreft aracrrrrr,xapaKTeplrsyevrru e$(ferrunnofirenneparypofi. Orueuaercx, qro paccMorpeunafl MoAenbnpeAcTaBnfleTTeopeTr4qecKr4ftlrHTepec, nocKonbKy B Hefi peanr43yeTcrIlpoqecc, KoTopbrfto6naAaerKBa3HpaBHoBecHbrMlrxapaKTepr{crr,rKaMl4,Ho Heo6fl3areJrbHoflBlrflercs.MeAJTeHHrIMBoBpeMeHH.Buerneprofi HraBe onlrcaH 4n$$yeraonuufi rpoqecc B 6ranrxp4nofi cr{creMe,xapaKTepl{:ytoqeftcxpacceuBareJrflMrr,pacrroJroxeHHbrMraB y3nax KBaAparHoitu:l.urpeyrolluoftnepnoAIlqecrcofipeurerKr414 LrMeroqr4M]rpa3Mep, cyuecrBeHHo rrpeBbrurarouufi paccrosuueMexAy lr'vtMut.PaccrrrorpeHHa.flMoAeJrborBerraer pexkrMy cr,rJrbHoronsararro4eficrBrlflMexAyKnacrepaMuu rpa$uronoft uoAroNxoft, rrpta KoropoM KJracrepcoBepmaer peAKr{enepexoAbrMexAy l,reracra6uJlbHblMl{lloragano, qro cpegruafiKBaAparcMeqeHI{{ qacrl4rlbrBcocTo.gHr,rsuu.raroficr4creMe pacrernponopq[oHaJrbHo KBaApary BpeMenlr, To ecrb na6lroAaercscynepan$(pysrzx.

Teprrro4zHaMvqecKaflTpaKToBKa3Toro pe3yJrbrara cBflsana c pocroMe(f$exruenofi TeMneparypbr qacrr4ubr B pe3ynbrare n:arauo4eficrBvrs.c paccer4BareJrrMr{,r4MerorqlrMn6ecrcone.*ro6onrruyro Maccy14TeMneparypy.llporznonoroxnrrftcnyuafi [oqrrir cno6o4lroro ABlrxeHr.r{KnacrepoBr{3freH s nsrofirJIaBeAl,Icceprallzn. CoornercrByrouar MoAeJrbrrpeAcraBnserco6oft AByMepHbrfiras Jlopenqapacce[Barerefi. floxasaHo, qro B oroM cnyqae noe(f(fuqrzenrco cry.rafiHblM pacrpeAeneHr4eMco BpeMeHeM,KaK rr AJrfl MoAeJrrd,4Ia$(fy:ura 6um-ap4Hofi uacrzqrr nanefiHo yBenl4qr,rBaercflusyreuuofi B rJIaBe4.

Taxanr o6pasorra,o6e uoAerr rpeAcKa3brBarorcynepau$$y3r,rrcqacrrarl,Koropat Moxer o6rscHsm ycKopeHHblftpocr crpyKrypbr ocrpoBKoBMeranJraHa rroBepxnocrr4rpa$ura.lllecras rJIaBa rrocBrrrleHa q[cneuHoMy MoAenrdpoBaHr,rro[oBeAeHus rracrurlbr B6nlrrp4ax . c ABl{xyrquMuc . rpaHr4rlaMr.r.Onucana co3.{aHHa{ corrcKareJreMrrporpaMMa, Bxoropoftpeanl43oBaHaBo3MoxHocrb [epr4oAI4qecKoro vrJrv cryuafinoropacrroJroxeHr.rtpaccel{Barelr.eit,a raKxe cnyuafiurrx rlnu rapMoHr.rqecKrzxxore6anprft HX creHoK. llpune4enupe3ynbTarbrBbrrroJrHeHHbrxc ee noMolrlblo pacqeroB, Koropble B IIenoM [oKa3aJrr{xopomeeconlacl4e c reoperrarrecKr4MurrpeAcKa3aHuflnavlHa6nroAaeMbrepacxoxAeHzr Bo3pacraror cyBenl{qeH[eMaMrrJrr.rTyAbrcKopocrr.rpaccerrnarereftv vx panuyca u o6t scHflrorcsHapymeHr,reMnpeAnonoxenuit, [pI,IHsrbIXB Teoperr,rrlecKl{xMoAenrx.MoNno cAeJrarb BbrBoA, rrro B Aucceprarluossofi pa6ore BbrnoJrHeHo.ueranbHoeI4ccneAoBaHVecreHKaMprvrroJrf{eHbrrLrnaMvKprAByMepHHx6umspHbrx crtcreMc noABr4xHbrMr.r(pvlsz.recru ocMbIcJIeHHbIe pe3ynbrarbr, no3BoJrrrorqrre o6rscHIlm na6ruoAaeurrfi BgKcnepl4MeHTaxycKopennsrftpocr MeraJrnuqecKl,IxcrpyKTyp Ha rroBepxHocrurpa$rara.Bce sHHeceHHbIecol4cKareJreMHa 3aIrIpITyrroJroxeHlrfl rrpeAcraBJrrrorco6oft HoBbreHayqHble pe3ynbrarbr.

Brrno4rr Lr peKoMeHAaur{uxoporrro o6ocnoeaHH. ,{ocronepnocunoryqeHHblx pe3ynbraroB o6ecne.reua npzMeHeHr{eMrr3BecrHbrxreoperr.rqecKr4xrroAXoAoBcrarncrzqecroft MexaHr.rKHvrHepannonecnoft TepMoAHHaMr,rKr,r,a raKxe qr4creHnoroMOAenr4poBaHpr'.Pa6o:ra HanucaHa AocrarorrHo JrofLrrlno, AocryrrHbrM s3bIKoM vt B IIenoM xopomoo$opunena, xor.fl r,rcoAepxr4ToreqarKr4z op(porpa(fuuecxueorupr6rcu.Brrcrcaxy p{.4 3aMeqaHufiu noNerralouit.1) Cn.ssr c lpra:uuecroftcucreuoft,ucnoJrb3oBasnofi rrrfl rrocraHoBKr4 3ara'ur4, rro MepeBbInoJIHeHI4tr,4llcceprarlzonnofi pa6orrr 6r'rna 6esno3BparHo yreprHa. Hu oAun u3 pacqerubxpe3ynbraroB He colocraBJreH c gKc[epr{MeHTaJrbHbrMr.rAaHHbrrvru.Pa6ora cyx{ecrBenHo 6srBbrr4rpaJra, npeAJrorfl4xor.r{corrcxareJlb6urro3BonflroilIue npoBepaTb HeKoropbre H3 rrpeAcKa3aHuit reopuu.