Отзыв оппонента Гуфана (Квантовые основные состояния низкоразмерных магнетиков)

OT~~IBo # u q u a ~ b ~ o ronnoHeHTaoHaOuccepTaqum BOJ-IKOBO~~Onbru C e p r e e ~ ~ b l< < ~ B ~ H T OOBC~HIO~BHbIe COCTORHUR HU3KOpa3MePHbIX MaTHeTUKOB)),-npeOcTaBneHHym H a couclcaHue y s e ~ o i cTeneHuiOorcTopa # e s u ~ oMaTeMaTU9eCKUX H a y K IIO CIIeuUaJrbHOCTU01.04.09 - #usurcaHUSICUX TeMnepaTyp.Ecna IIOnbITaTbCR B HeCKOJIbKllX CJIOBaX O X a p a K T e p H 3 0 B a T b I I p e A M e T IlCCJIeflOBaHllR~ H C C ~ ~ T ~ ~ H pa60~b1O H H O O~ J~I b r H C e p r e e ~ H b 1B o n ~ o ~ o f TOi , 3TO M O H O ~ ~ @ H ~ ~ CTPYA,~ I O C B X ~ ~ H HLICCJIeAOBaHHH)~ I ~ ~B ~ U ~ CCTM B~ ~~~ I L I T H~ Oo A~ C~ H C T ~ M O~GO H H X C H H Opa3MePHOCTLI~~MaTHeTHKOB.6onee@ H ~ H ~ ~ C K HCXB O ~ ~ C T B Hki3KOpa3MepHbIXYHCeBOTn O J I y B e K a Hell3MeHHO HaXOjJRTCR B U e H T p e BHHMaHllR BCeX @ H ~ H K O BId XLIMHKOB,H 3 y 9 a I o m k i X @ y ~ ~ a M e H ~ a J I b H BOnpOCbIbleCTpOeHWI K O H A ~ H C H ~ O B ~ HMHaOT e~p~H H .BenoB TOM, 9 T O HL13KOpa3MePHbIe M a r H H T H b I e nOACHCTeMb1 3 T 0 OAMH H 3 T P ~ X@kl3119e~KI.I~O~S~KTOB,HaCOCTORHHeKOTOPbIXBeaeCTBaBC B O ~ ~ C T Bki3MeHRIoTCR~MOHCIIOpeaJIki30BaTbH3KCnepllMeHTaJIbHO~ P O M ~ X J ' T O ~ H OOG~ X ~ C T LBHeUIHLIXIOTnp0RBJIeHaR~ @ @ ~ K T O B9llCTOLICCJIeAOBaTbYcJIoBLI~~, BKOTOPO~~K B ~ H T O B O ~@LI3LIKH~A0a A e K B a T H 0 O I I H C b I B a e M O ~ O3aKOHaMH K J I ~ C C H ' I ~ C K O@~H~ ~ H K I I .

B IIOCJIeAHHeCOCTORHkiR,rOAb1 H H T e p e C K HH3KOPa3MePHbIMnoAcTerHyna06'bema~@113LIKHe eOTK~~IBUI~HCXHHeAOKOHAeHCkiPOBaHHOI'O COCTORHHRKoHqaBbIxcHeHHaxnepcnemmaHCnOJlb30BaHI?R 3THX O ~ % ~ K T OBB TeXHHKe AJIR CO3AaHWi MaTepLIaJIOB, O n p e A e J I R I o w H Xnporpecc cnenj m u a x n o ~ o n e ~ aYCT~OGCTBfin e p e p a 6 0 ~a~x~p a H e H H r r a ~ @ o p ~ a q m( K B ~ H T O B ~ I XK O M ~ ~ I O T ~ P O BT) .~ K E I A ? O ~ P ~ ~ O TMe M, a A H C C ~ ~ T ~ ~ L I O Hp aH6 0OT ~b 10.C.B O J I K O B O ~HaXOflHTCR~H a IILIKe HHTepeCOB C O B ~ ~ M ~ H@Hy OH I~( ~a ~ e H ~ a J I b ~ Ho fa yi K H kie&H e n 6 3 2 H e n p H 3 H a T b aICTya.rlb~0ff.UenbIIpeACTaBJIeHHbIX B A H C C ~ P T ~ ~ L I O H Hpa6o~eO~~HCCII~~OB~YCTaHOBLlTbHH~~:XapaKTepHCTHKIl HOnb-,I I P O C T M p a I o ~ H X C 5 l OTOAHO-I? ABYMePHbIXo6nac~eiiP-T-chlarHeTHKOB BO BHeUIHHX YCJIOBHRX,@a30~0fiALIaQaMMbI,B KOTOPbIX IIPORBJIRIOTCR9HCTO KBaHTOBbIe C R O ~ ~ C T BA~0, YCJIOBLI~~C T ~ ~ H ~ ~ H O CCOTCMT O X H H ~ ,C B O ~ ~ C TKOTOPbIXB~0IIHCbIBaH)TCR 3aKOHaMH K J I ~ c c H ~ ~ c K@H?LIKH.o~~06nac~efiIIpORBJIReTCRCBepxnpoBofixweepRKBaHTOBbIXc o c T o a a a e BeruecrBa.nH&~KM~@@~KToB.H a n p k i ~ e p ,H 9aCTI?O3THXnepeXOABT ~ Kx e ~ a 6 .

m r r a e ~ c uenb~iixp x ~H O B ~ I X1I I B J I ~ H H ~ ~CBII3aHHbIX,C@ O P M ~ ~ P O B ~ H H ~~M~ H H C H ki~ ~AEiJIbHerOOHH3KOPa3MePHbIXMaTHeTHKaX,UIbTepHHpOBaHHeMMeXaTOMHbIXBKpkiCTUIJIa.~ 0 n p 0 ~ 0 ~ f l a e ~ b l f i~ n k iP ~ C C T O I I H H ~ ~B06nac~xx 4a30~0fiA H a p a M M b I4a3o~b1en e p e x o A b r .

KP03epH,Bk i ~ ~ y u k i pb1yfie ~CY~CTPYKTYOAHOMePHbIXP R A e O ~ L ~ K T OUBI T e p H H p O B a H H e c ~ I I 3 e f IlPkiBOAHTiK c J I o X H O ~ ~CTPYKTYPePaCnOJIOXeHHII AHMepOB M ~ ~ H I Z T HnOACkiCTeMb1O~~MeXaHH3MOMIIOPRAKa(npll~ep:Sr CUZ( B03)z). BnpO5IBJIIIIoTCII((HeKJIaCCH9eCKHe))npOIIBJIeHHeX a p a K T e p H b I M AnII OAHOMePHbIX~aa6oneeKOTOpOrOXeCTPYKTYPHbIeHHM OTHOCIITCR C T p y K T y p H b I e y n o p x A o 9 e H m ,nafiepJIct3,3THXOnpeAenxeMbIe06'beKT0~,MeXaHki3MOM K)M-HHTepeCHOT B ~ P A ~ I X PaCTBOpaX.B~ ~ K J l I o ~ k i ~ e J I bH~HbTlefpie C npeACTaBJIReT H e B C e r A a ( I C H ~ IMeXaHH3M~~0npe~eJIIIIoIIJklfi((nJIaBJIeHHe))M ~ T H I I T H O ~nOACHCTeMbI~ki I I p O u e C C @ O P M I I P O B ~ H ~ ~ RnPOMeXYT09HbIXyIIOpIIAO9eHHbIXGa3,O ~ P ~ ~ Y I ~ ~ H Xn pCk iI I ((pa3pyIIIeHHki))nOACHCTeMe JIOKUIH30BaHHbIX CIIkiHOB HAkiCCepTauHHIIlHpoKHfiBOnpOCOB kiCkiCTeMbIHH3KOPa3MePHbIX~ a 6 o p06'beKTo~ HCCJIeAOBaHHR.

CBeweCTB.HOHeTB03MOXHOCTkiKOJIki9eCTBOOTpaHHrIeHkiIIX H a kiX pa3AeJIeHkie,pa3JIH9aIowkiXCIIY ~ ~ T O TOTO,Mc ~ e ~ k i ~ e ~ k i3f ~i .0 , C0.C.9TO 9aCTb O ~ ' ~ ~ K T O BTO9HOHCCJIeAOBaHHbIXnpeBbIIUaeTOnpeAeJIHTbrIHCJI0O~'~~KTOBn p, k iCaMbIXABaAeCIITKaY ~ ~ T O MCJIOXHOCTHMarHHTHbIXHOHOB.TOT06'be~~blHCCJIeAOBaHkiRCTPYKTYPbIKOTOPbIX3KCnepHMeHTaIIpHnonxx ("(1 -+ 2)Tn),HepeUIH3YIoTCIIAOnyCKaeTBAki3JIeKTPHKaX,~ J I H ~ K O ~POaCnOnOXeHHIIr e o ~ e T P H 9 e c ~ k i f@i a K T o p OnpeAeJIkiJI TO,9 T O OCHOBHbIenpeACTaBJIeHHble B A ~ ~ C C ~ ~ T ~ Q H pO aH6Ho O~ e~0.C.~3 T 0 MHOrOKOMlIOHeHTHble CMJIHUkiAbI,OKkiCJIbI,6 e p ~ o J I J I k i ~ b 1 ) , apCeHkiAb1 H A p y r H e MarHkiTOo 6 a e ~ ~ aHCCJIeAOBaHkiIIxCTPYKTYPHOewe Hki OAHH pa3 l I p k i ~ e ~ c BI IO 3 B p a ~ a T b C I I .H k i 3 ~ 0 p a 3 ~ e p ~ b lMea r H H T H b I eCTpyKTypa06cy~~ae~oB O J I K O B O ~HaKOnJIeH~O ~ O M H 3~~ Ic ~n e~ p k i ~ e ~ ~ U I b ~M a T e p H U I , K O ~ C Y X A ~ H H EKOTOPOrOOKpHCTUIJIHrIeCKtUBCHCTeM OnpeAeJIkiJIaT e M n e p a T y p a x H H x e r e n e e B b I x , B ~ I C O K H XA a B n e H k i x x H M a r H H T H b I xnO3BOJIIIeT Y T B e p X A a T b , 9 T OBnOpIIAKapa6o~e0 .

C . B O ~ K O Bn OpeA~c~T a, B J I I I e T co6ofi B ~ I ~ O P Kki3YT B ~ P A ~ I X PaCTBOPOB,HCCJleAOBaHHbIXCTPOrHXAp. mkipo~aOXBaTbIBaeMbIXn p o 6 n e ~4ki3kiKHC B O ~ ~ C TKOTOPbIXB~H3y9eHbI BAUIbHerO-HHTPkiAbI,rkiAPaTbIBon~o~of( A E ~ J I ~ T O H H A ~kiIpa36a~JIe~~bCOeAHHeHkiII.leBTaKHXTakiTCII ki3BeCTHaR OnaCHOCTb, n P O I I B J l l I I o ~ a I I C I I n p k i n O n b I T K eK O J I H ~ ~ C T B ~ H HHO T~e~p n p e T a u H H p e 3 y J I b T a T O B 3KCnepkiMeHTa.AenoO ~ M ~ H H B~~ ~I H~ M O A ~ ~ ~ C T B3KCnOHeHukiEiJIbHOI~IIOT3aBHCIITB TOM, 9 T O n p I I M b I ePaCCTOIIHHlIMeXAy2MaTHHTHbIMH HOHaMH.K O C B ~ H HO ~~I M~ ~~M eHX A yKHCJIOpOAa HJIH, KaK BS T C U(BO3)2~, sepe3AOHbIMarHHTHbIMH HOHaMHgo3sepe3AOHbIT O X e O W H b syBCTBHTeJIeH KCMemeHkIIIM HOHOB JIHraHAa, B saCTHOCTH K A ~ @ O P M ~ U H R MH p a 3 B O p O T a M CJIOXHbIX( I I ~ ~ ~ H o c ~ H K oBB~ ~ H M o A ~ ~ ~ c T B H RB) .HOHOB-MeAHaTOpOBT I p H M e p a I I p H B e A y 3aHMCTBOBaHHOe A 3CUCABHr HOHOBCOCTORHHeHaloA(-3) A06cyX~ae~ofiAHCCepTaUAHKOHKPeTHOrOYTBepXAeHHe, s T 0O l I p e A e J I l e T l I e p e X 0 A CHCTeMbI ClIHHOB AOHOB MeAH BH30JIHPOBaHHblXMHT~HCHBHOCT~PeHTreHOCTPYKTyPHbIXAHMePOB.p e @ n e ~ c oOT~ n o ~ p e m e ~C~Ta ~ O H ~ n~p Ie BI bI I m a e TI I o ~ p e I l I e ~ ~Bk BiKaseCTBe--- 64 pa3a, 0B25 pa3.

BHHTeHcHBHocTbo ~ p a x e ~ OT~fiH ~ ~ ~ T ~ o H o ~ ~ @ HACCneAOBaHHRX~ ~ c K H xCTPYKTyPbI H ~ O ~ O P OHTe ~ ~ T KTIPORBJIRIOTCROp e @ J I e ~ c b 1OTHOCHTeJIbHO T R X ~ J I ~ IHOHOB.XT p e 6 o ~ a ~Ka ~p a 3 M e p a M 06'bemo~BHCCJIeAOBaHHX CTPYKTyPbI p a 3 H b I e .3THX,T.0.A@nOJIHIIIOmHX A P Y rApyraMeTOAaXCYWeCTBYIOT TOHKOCTA B COlIOCTaBJIeHHHp e 3 y J I b T a T O B 3KClIepHMeHTa, KOTOPbIe H e lI03BOJIXIOT O A H 0 3 H a q H O H H T e p I I p e T H p O B a T b13KCIIepAMeHT IIO pa3AeJIeHHIO M a r H A T O p e 3 0 H a H C H b I X IIAKOB B06nac~11IIJIaTO (; m,,,)Ha3aBHCHMOCTH H a M a r H H s e H H O C T H OT M a r H H T H O r O IIOnR, O T H ~ C ~ H H ~KI X11 p a 3 H b I M THlIaMHOHOBCU ,KaK2LJIbTepHHpOBaHHXCBepXCTpyKTypyc~R3efi.B3TOMAHCCepTaIJHH, KOTOpaR O v a A H J I axapamepaHnos~onanaBO ~ Y C ~ O B ~ ~ H TH I Y~ ~I ~~ ~ ~ J I c o B c K AMeXaHH3MOMMIInaHeOTMesyXOpOIUyIo0.C.

B o n ~ o ~OTy Pe3KAXHHTYHUHIOaBTOpaBbIBOAOB KOJIHWXTBeHHOrOr r o n o x e H m x , B ~ I H O C H M ~ IHXa ~ ~ W H T YO r,p a H E i s H T c x T o n b K oKaseCTBeHHbIMH YTBePXAeHHRMH.HCCJIeAOBaHAIO @ H ~ H ~ ~ C K ICI BXO ~ ~ C TCHnHKaTOB,BHHTpaTOB, CJIOXHbIX OKCHAOB,aTa m eB. I ~ T B ~ PrnaBeT O ~ npeACTaBJIeHb1~p e 3 y J I b T a T b l IlCCJIeAOBaHHR HOBOrO KJIaCCaHki3KOPa3MePHbIX ~ 0 e ~ k i H e H k if i HkiTpaTOB IIepeXOflHblX MeTaJIJIOB.B3 ~ 0 f i TJIaBeCOeAkIHeHMIlCIIbITbIBaIoTMarHkiTHOeBceIlCCJIeAOBaHHbIeYIIOpRAOYeHkIenpkiHH3KkIXT e M n e p a T y p a X . r e 0 M e T p k I R PaCnOJIOXeHkIR MarHkiTOaKTkIBHbIX KaTkIOHOB kl TpeyTOJIbHbIXrpynn,HkiTpaTHbIXy K a 3 b I B a e T H a TO, YTO06MeHHble B ~ ~ H M O A ~ ~ ~ CMTe XBA~y MkiOHaMkiTOMeAkI O C y u e C T B J R I o T C RY e p e 3 T p e y T O J I b H b l e HkiTpaTHbIeH e 0 6 b 1 ~ ~ 0 f TOnOJIOTkikIiH k i 3 ~ 0 p a 3 ~ e p H 0 f iM ~ T H H T H O ~nOACkICTeMb1:~npORBJIeHkiIo ~ @ @ ~ K T O6BJ I k I x ~ e ~nOpRAKa.0B(NO)[CU(NO~)~]IIpeAJIOXeHa"@JIaTT ~ KAJIR,PiCCJIeAOBaHHbIX3 @ @ e ~ ~6 nbk1I x ~ e r on O p R A K aC B O ~ ~ C T B ~~X6 n k i 3 k i0 6 ~ 3 a ~AOnOJIHHTeJIbHbIM0nOpRAKaMopkIGkI.BnYCTOTblN i ( N 0 3 ) 2 kIOHblOnkiCaHkiR MaTHkITHOTO nOBeAeHkiRNilCBR3efipacnonoxeassMeKayB O ~ ~ I I O M ~M~ ~H AO H~ O~U e~n O Y K e BO BCeX100 K.@OPMIIPOB~HH~ AaJIbHerOCTPYKTJ'PbIkiOHaMkiBBceNi2.O ~ M ~ H H MaTHkiTHbIe~ I ~nepeXOAB-38 TpeYrOJIbHbIXAkiccepTaUkiki n p e A n o n a r a e T c x , YTO @ p y c T p a r ~ k i xkIOHaMkikiRBJIRIOTCR npkiYkIH0fi TOTO, YTOIlCnbITblBaeTMarHkiTHOTO@ O ~ M I I ~ ~PeLUeTKyF ~ TT k I n a KaTOMe, TeKCarOHaJIbHbIeHOHOB.MarHkiTHbIMkI3 ~ aCkiCTeMaK B ~ A P ~ T H OPeIIIeTKkI.~~B ~ ~ I I M O A ~ G C T B ~~I RH T I ~ @ ~ P P O M ~ ~ H I I Tki H ~@I P Y C T ~ ~ I P O B ~ Hk13~IMOTHBOB B@ p y ~ T p a U k I k I kiC J I ~ ~ ~B I~ M~ ~ ~ M O A ~ ~ C T TBkLi nIaR~M~~RJIoIIIHHcKoTo-K O T O P O ~ ~ 3anOJIHeHbIBHpkiBOAkiT KMOAeJIb O ~ M ~ H H ~MarHkiTHbIXI X~ 3 a l l M o ~ e f i ~ ~ BTkHi nf ai~ O H @ e ~ e p a ~ a "p ,a 3 p a 6 0 ~ a H H a R AJIRAeMOHCTPkiPYeTrpynnbI.TpeyrOJIbI-lbIenpkiHeKOJIJIkIHeaPHOeMOTkiBbl~pki~TaJIJIki~e~~0fCaMbIX Hki3KkIX TeMIIepaTJ'paXCkiCTeMa~ H T T ~ @ ~ P P O M ~ T H ~ I TCOCTORHkieHO~COCnOHTaHHblM MOMeHTOM.

3 ~ HeCKOJIbKO0CnOpHOe YTBepXAeHkie.B~ I R T rnaBeo ~ ~ OnkiCaHbI MarHkiTOynOpRAOYeHHbIe CJIOXHble HkI3KOPa3MePHbIeMeTaJIJIOOKCkIAbIABYXC 0 6 p a ~ e H k I e M HaMarHkIYeHHOCTkIKOHKYPkiPYIoukIXnoTeMnepaType~ H T ~ ~ @ ~ P P O M ~ ~ H ~@a3~ T I -(AgFe02),F~IXC3 n e ~ ~ p k i s e c~mK T H B H O~~O~ A C H C T ~ MJIIITHXO~~6JIki30cTbTenkIKOkiAK( a -Cr3(P04)2), @ O P M I I P O B ~ H I ~ ~ M(Li2CuZr04). B Li2CuZr04 o 6 ~ a p y x e ~ aK B ~ H T O B O ~K~P L ~ T I ~ ~ ~ CTOYKe,K O ~ ~ pLl3~€,.XRIo~ef~i HTH@~PPOM~THLITH~IH@ ~ P P O M ~ T H H T H Y K ) IJenOqKy,'IT0npORBJIReTCRBHe0661YHb1~T e p M o A k i H a M k i s e c m x x a p a K - r e p k I c T m a x B e w e c T s a n p H H H ~ K L I XT e M n e p a T y p a x .BlIIecT0firnaBenpeACTaBJIeHb1M e T ~ J I O O K C k I A O B Ba3Cu3(Inl~,Sc,)4012(X =mnaTpexMepHoroBa3Cu31n4012H"LUac~pa -pe3yJlbTZFbI0 - 4)Ca3epnenna".kiCCJIeAOBaHkiRCeMefiC~BaC ~ 0 n O J I o r k i e f iM ~ ~ H H T HPOe I~I I~e T mBPoAkiTenbcKoMCoeAmeHkiti~ ~ J I I ~ A ~ ~ aTJ Icb RH k i f i ~ H T ~ I @ ~ P P O M ~ T H ~ InOpRAOK,TH~IOCHOB~HH~I~~,5npeAnOJIOXHTeJIbH0,PeIIIeTKaX.TOAaarpaMMe.HaTpeXB3aHMHO-OpTOrOI-IaJIbHbIX~HTHQ>~PPOM~~H~~TIlPORBJIReTCR B BHAe AOnOJIHkiTeJIbHbIX I'paHkiII H a M ~ ~ H H T H(ha30~0fiO~~ManaxnojIcrBerrnsnHaIIpeAIIOJIOXHTb rJIaBeHCTByEoJJyKlPOJIb~ a c b 1 ~ q e ~ 1 B.