Отзыв оппонента 1 (Основы технологии получения хлористого метила каталитическим окислительным хлорированием метана под давлением)

OT3hIBonrronerrraoljlHQllaJIhHOrOBaHqYPIIHaBIIKTOpa HJIJIaplIOHOBllqaCepreeaasrHa )l,IICCepTaQIlIO CIIJIIIHOÜ HPIIHhl«ÜCHOBhl TeXHOJIOrll1lrrorrynenaaXJIOplICTOro MeTIIJIa KaTaJIIITllqeCKIIM OKIICJIIITeJIhHhlM xnopnponauaesrnaanenaesr»,rrpe)l,CTaBJIeHHyIO Ha COIICKaHlle yqeHOÜ CTerreHII05.17.04 -HaYK rro crreQllaJIhHOCTII,I1pe'[(CTaBJIeHHa5IOCHOB M TeXHOJIOrMMKaTaJIMTM'lecKMHMeTaHa (OXM)JIerKMecrrpocHaoCHoBHoHCMHTe3aOJIe~MHbIM3OTHOC5ITC5I K 'lMCJIY 6a30BbIXOJIe~MHbI06YCJIOBJIeHcrpepsrnepcnexmnnsrxOKMCJIMTeJIbHOe XJIOpMpOBaHMeI1PM 3TOM caxrpszte~apMaIIeBTMKeBTeXHOJIOrMMCMHTe3ape)l<MMHbIXnarrpaaep,I10CT05IHHbIHrrOJIM3TMJIeHarrpMMeHeHM5I.JIerKMXOJIe~MHOBMeTMJI C rrOCJIe,n:y!o:IUMM ero,[(JI5I rrOJIJ'leHM5IMillMPOKO5IBmreTC5IrrMpOJIM30M.MCrrOJIb3yeTC5I BMeTMJIIIeJIJIIOJI03bI,CMJIMKOHOB, BXJIOpMCTOroM3Y'leHHOCTbIOMeTMJIaMMeIOTC5IM HeCOBepilleHCTBOMCY:IUeCTBeHHblerrpoöensr,KaTaJIMTM'leCKOHMo,[(eJIM OKCMXJIOpMpOBaHM5I MeTaHaCMCTeMbI,M 060CHOBaHHbIMMCCJIe,[(OBaHMeB3Ha'lMTeJIbHOHMeperr03BOJI5IeTpenrarr,3TMM rr03TOMY 5IBJI5IeTC5Iaxryam.asnr.- Pe3YJIbTaTbIBbIHOC5ITC5ICJIe,[(YIO:IUMerrOJIO)KeHM5I:M3y-qeHM5I npoueccapearerrros,KaTaJIM3aTOpa,'resmeparypst,B TOM 'lMCJIe npaBpeMeHM~M3MKO-XMMM'leCKOrOMeTo,[(aMM nopomxonoäperrrrenoscxoäPe3YJIbTaTbIKOHTaKTa,- MexaHM3MbICOJIM CuChpeaKIIMM,COCT05IHMM Me,[(M M JIaHTaHaM3Y'leHM5I,[(M~paKIIMM,KMHeTM'leCKOrOrrpe,[(CTaBJI5IIO:IUeM C060HKMHeTM'leCKOrOOXM,BapbMpOBaHMM,[(aBJIeHMM,rraPIIMaJIbHbIXpassrepasepna~OCTaBaKaTaJIM3aTopa.- Pe3YJIbTaTbIonorpeönenaearrpOM3BO,[(CTBaB XJIOPMCTbIllHe~TexMMMM.napaxerpos,Ha 3a:IUMTY asropov-XJIOpMpOBaHMeMM.,[(.I1pe,[(CTaBJIeHHOe,[(aBJIeHMHnponyxrosMX TeXHOJIOrM'leCKOrOOTCYTCTBMeM a,n:eKBaTHOH KMHeTM'leCKOHrrp06JIeMbIHaY'lHbIXKO~OPOH 5IBJI5IeTC5IOKMCJIMTeJIbHbIMB03paCTaIO:IUMMMeTO,[(OBMeTaHaCMHTe30B,CB5I3aHHble C He,[(OCTaTO'lHOHBbI6opOMOJIe~MHOB,XJIOPMCTbIH MeTMJI, KaK MH,[(MBM,[(YaJIbHbIH rrp0,[(YKT,nposesnnneansrxBeIIJ,eCTBrrOCB5I:IUeHa paspaöorxeJIerKMXMeTMJIaTeXHllqeCKIIX,[(aBJIeHMM.M pacumpemrenO,[(HMMXJIOpMCTOroxannana'raopramrsecicnxpaöoracTa,[(MM rrpoM3Bo,[(cTBarroasnnenaonnerxaenonanporraneaaHa OT3bIB zracceprauaonnaanponeccrrpaTeXHOJIOrllSlnonMeTaHaCOCT05IHM5I rrOBepXHOCTM3JIeKTpOHHOH MMKpOCKorrMM.MCCJIe,[(OBaHM5I peaKIIMM- KCl-LaCh,npennoaceaasrenaneceaasreC Y'leTOMHa rrOBepXHOCTMKaTaJIM3aTOpaOXMHaKaTaJIM3aTOpeHa arrIOMOCMJIMKaT.MMeIO:IUMXC5I M rrOJIY'leHHbIXHOCMTeJI5I B xo,[(errpOIIecca,[(aHHbIXM pe3YJIbTaTOBMCCJIe,[(oBaHM5I.Co,[(ep)KaTeJIbHa5Isxcnepavearam.asreztannsre.KMHeTM'leCKa5Ia,[(eKBaTHOorrMCbIBaIO:IUa5I2TIPMHll;JHIHClJIbHa5IOXMTeXHOJIOrMqeCKa5ICXeMarrpoxrsnrmeaaoäYCTaHOBKMnpoueccaC rrOCJIe,n;YIOIIIMM rrMpOJIM30M XJIOpMCTOrO MeTMJIa.,n:McCepTaIIMOHHa5ICrrMCKacOKpaIIIeHMß,CTpaHMIIaxCMJIMHOß H.C.6M6JIMOrpaqmMMalliMHorrMCHoroIIMTMpyeMoßBopaöoramrreparypsrMTeKCTaM161BKJIlOqaeTBBe,n;eHMM M JIMTepaTypHOMrrOJIyqeHM5IHM3Iill1XOJIe<pMHOBOKMCJIMTeJIbHOrO XJIOpMpOBaHM5Irrepepaöorxa'BOKMCJIMTeJIbHOrOKMHeTMKepeaKlIM5I3KCrrJIyaTaIIMM rrpoersnrmenasrxAHaJIM3rnrreparypnsrxOTcYTCTByeT eztanoe44MCOBpeMeHHoexapaKTepMCTMKMnpapozmororasa,C rrOJIyqeHMeM196HaCnacoxTa6mlIIbl.nonpoönoMeTMJIa 'M0crroc06eroMexaHM3MeJIaHTaHOBOMOXMo<popMJIeHM5I npoueccaMeTO,n;KaTaJIM3aTOpOBrraansreMe,n;HOM McnocoöoapasoöpanxapaKTepM3aIIM5ICMCTeMaTM3MpOBaHblHaCOCT05IHMe npoueccaM oc06eHHOCTMXJIOpMCTOroIlpasezteaaMeTaHa,zraansrxnozrrsepzoraer,MKaTaJIM3aTope.M pe)KMMHbIXqTO B HaCT05IIIIeeOXMMCCJIe,n;OBaHMMßnponeccanpezrcraaneaae0 MexaHM3Meee 3KCrrJIyaTaIIMM,cpezna, B qaCTHOCTM, naposBM3Me,n;bJIaHTaHOBOM KaTaJIM3aTOpe,CMCTeMbl B xorteM3JIO)l(eHanapasrerposYCTaHoBoK.5IBHbIß ,n;e<pMUMTKMHeTIfqeCKMXnaaeceamaxnpaaezteusrannaparypnoroPMCYHKOB0603HaqeHOOKCMXJIOpMpOBaHM5I MeTaHaPaCCMOTpeHbl norrpocsrPa60TaBbIBO,n;OB,HaMMeHOBaHMe.MeTaHaXJIOpMpOBaHlUI77conepxaronerpaasr.HM311IMenpnnoacenaä.,n;BYX0630peOKMCJIMTeJIbHOrO XJIOpMpOBaHM5I MeTaHa,COCTOMT M3 BBe,n;eHM5I, CeMM rJIaB,sonsr0IIIYIIIaeTC5IrrOBbllIIeHHOM,n;aBJIeHMM,OKMCJIMTeJIbHOrO XJIOpMpOBaHM5I MeTaHa HaHeT ,n;aHHbIX 06M3MeHeHM5IXKaTaJIMTMqeCKOßa TaK)I(e 0 BJIM5IHMMOT,n;eJIbHbIX KOMrrOHeHTOB peaKIIMoHHOßHa rrOKa3aTeJIM3KcnepMMeHTaJIbHOßnpnBpeM5IqaCTMOXM.rrpe,n;CTaBJIeHHa5Ipaöoracoztepzorrztsa60JIbllIMXMCCJIe,n;OBaHM5I.Bo-rrepnsrx,OXMHa3TO paspaöorxaKaTaJIM3aTOpeMaTeMaTMqeCKOßCuCb06pa60TKMHOBOß conepxarensnoä-KCl-LaCh/a-Ab03MaCCMBa c06CTBeHHbIXc MCrrOJIb30BaHMeM Mo,n;eJIeß öearpazraearnoroHa-KaKnapaaerpsrCeJIeKTMBHOCTbrrposeneaaarroXMpeaxroparrpoueccaM crerrensOXMKMHeTMqeCKa5I Mo,n;eJIb M npennozsenMapllIpYToBOXMBO-BTO~bIX,CMCTeMbl B xozteC ysacraenM peaxropa3KCrrJIyaTaIIMM,norryseasrnonsreoCYIIIeCTBJIeHHa5Inyreu,n;aHHbIX, rrOJIyqeHHbIXM,n;eaJIbHOrO BbITeCHeHM5I.cpensrHa rrOKa3aTeJIM npoIIecca,MeTaHa,BbI6paHbl,n;aBJIeHMM, nonysenaMexaHM3M,naansreB3aMMOBJIM5IHMM eeMe,n;Horo KOMrrOHeHTa B COCTaBe KaTaJIM3aTOpa,JIaHTaHa.rrOBbllIIeHHOMoparaaansasräM3MeHeHM5IX rrozr B03,n;eHcTBMeM peaKIIMoHHOHrrOBepXHOCTMKOHBepCMMMo,n;eJIM nponeccaBKJIlOqaIOIIIMßorrraxansm.rea,n;eKBaTHa5IconpxxenaeXJIOPM,n;OBMe,n;MM JIaHTaHa.,n;MccepTaHTOMeenpnSi02,3KcrrepMMeHTaJIbHbIX3TOM rrYTM YCTaHOBJIeHO BJIM5IHMe COCTaBa peaKIIMoHHOßTaKMeHaKMHeTMqeCKOßHOCMTeJI5I, YCTaHOBJIeHacpensr,063BOJIIOIIMM KaTaJIMTMqeCKOHKOMrrOHeHTOBOrrpenenenoM MO,n;M<pMKaIIMOHHbIXOrrTMMaJIbHOe conepxaaaeBbI5IBJIeH COCTaB arnoxeparoarrOJIO)l(MTeJIbHa5IM OTpMIIaTeJIbHa5IaKTMBHbIX COJIeHPOJIb XJIOpM,n;a3HaOCHOBe rrpOBe,UeHHbIX I1CCJIe,UOBaHIill ,UI1CCepTaHT npennaraerOXMC rrOCJIe,UyIOIIII1M eroTeXHOJIOrl1"IeCKYlOcxexyrrpoueccaCxexraC6aJIaHCJ:IpOBaHa rro XJIOpy, co,Uep)KI1T rro,Up06HyIO I1HcpopMaIll1lO 0 TeXHOJIOmqeCKI1XKOHCTPYKTI1BHbIX napasrerpaxpa60TbIrrl1pOJIl130M C nonyseaaesrOT,UeJIbHbIXY3JIOB11JIerKI1X OJIeqmHOB.·,UorrOJIHeHairpacseraaaMaTepl1aJIbHOrO 6aJIaHCa YCTaHOBKI1MOIIIHOCTblO 100 TbIC.T 3Tl1JIeHa B rozr.He06xo,UI1MoTIIIaTeJIbHbIe,rpyzroesooreKaTaJIl13aTOpe,TaK)KerroOTMeTI1Tb, qTO ,UI1CCepTaHTOMHa nporpeccnoaansnoa11 TOHKl1expotaarorpadnrsecxoxrycöopyaHaJIl13bIrroonpeztenenaroorrpezreneamo11 rro,UrOTOBKeMaCCI1BayposneBbIIIOJIHeHblco,Uep)KaHI15IKOMrrOHeHTOB peaKIIl10HHOll,UaHHbIX ,UJI5I nocnenyromeäMe,U11 BCMeCI1, a.I1X 06pa60TKl1MaTeMaTl1qeCKI1MI1 MeTo,UaMI1.Crenem,rrOJIO)KeHl1ll,oTpa60TaHHbIXH JJ:OCTOBepHOCTh rrpOBe,UeHHbIX I1CCJIe,UOBaHl1ll, nayxnsrx060CHOBaHHOCTHBbIBO,UOBpexoveananaä11MeTO,UI1K axcrrepaaerrra11 aHaJIl13a,rrOJIYQeHHbIX P~3YJIbTaTOB 11 xoppexrnoäKQI1CJIY rJIaBHbIX06pa60TKOllI1CrrOJIb30BaHl1eMMHorOKpaTHOllrronysenmrxI1TOrOB ,UI1CCepTaIlI10HHOll paöoreXOPOIIIOBOCrrp0I13BO,UI1MOCTblO3aBI1CI1MOCTell.CI1JII1HOll RC.C T.3.

HaYQHOHHa MOll B3rJI5I,U,CJIe,UyeT OTHeCTI1:HOBH3HbI,1)pa3pa60TKYKaTaJIl13aTOpeKl1HeTI1QeCKOll Mo,UeJIl1CuCl,-KCl-11 KI1CJIOpo,Ua. KaK cnenyerTOqffOCTblO onacsrsaer2)HaHeceHHOM113 rrpaaeneansrxOXMnponeccpaspaöorxaLaCh,OKCI1XJIOpl1pOBaHI15I MeTaHaHaHaCOJIeBOMaJIIOMOCI1JII1KaT, noxaasraaionieäBO,UbI Ha CKOPOCTb OXM 11 rrpaKTI1QeCKOe OTCYTCTBl1eBJII15IHI15I3HaQl1TeJIbHOe BJlIDIHl1e naposxnopaorrpe,UeJI5IeTC5I)J;aHHbIX, Kl1HeTI1QeCKa5IMo,UeJIb C BbICOKOHB IIII1POKOMnaanasone11 060CHOBaHl1eMeXaHl13Ma113MeHeHI15I.n:aBJIeHI15I;KaTaJIl1TI1QeCKOrO OKCI1XJIOpl1pOBaHI15I CYQeTOM I1MelOIIII1XC5I11 rrOJIYQeHHbIX ,UaHHbIX 0 COCT05IHI1I1Me,U1111 JIaHTaHa Ha rrOBepXHOCTI1HOCI1TeJI5IB xozre nponecca3)HOBbIe zranasre11pe3YJIbTaTOB KI1HeTI1QeCKOrOI1CCJIe.n:OBaHI15I;06 3BOJIlOIIl1l1 KaTaJIl1TI1QeCKOll CI1CTeMbI B xorre ee 3KCrrJIyaTaIll1l1 nonB03,UellCTBl1eM peaKIIl10HHOllIIpaKTHQecKan1) paapaöorxecpeztsr,l(eHHOCThpa60TbICOCTOI1TB:TeXHOJIOmQeCKI1X YCJIOBl1ll CeJIeKTI1BHOll KaTaJIl1TI1QeCKOllMeTaHa B XJIOPI1CTbill MeTI1JI xepea0,9oc06eHHOCTl1 B3aI1MOBJIl15IHI1I1ee KOMrrOHeHTOB.CTa,Ul1lOOKCI1XJIOpl1pOBaHI15InpanepepafiorxarrOBbIIIIeHHOM ,UaBJIeHI1I1,UOMITa.2)YCTaHOBJIeHbI 3HaQeHI15I OrrTI1MaJIbHbIX napanerpos'rexmeparype,060cHoBaHoOnpezrenenooöecneaasaromeeCOOTHOIIIeHl1lOcozrepxcaaaeOrrTI1MaJIbHOeI1CXO,UHbIX pearearos,aKTI1BHbIX COJIeH BconepxaaaeBpeMeHI1COCTaBeMe,UHorooCYlIleCTBJIeHI15I nponeccaKOHTaKTa.KaTaJIl13aTOpaKOMrrOHeHTaBITo,U06paHoXM.KaTaJIl13aTOpa,BbI5IBJIeHa POJIbXJIopl1,Ua JIaHTaHa B COCTaBe aKTI1BHOrO KOMrrOHeHTa, 5IBJI5IlOlIIeroc5I rrpOMOTOPOM 11 B TOBpeM5I YBeJII1QI1l3alO~erO nerysecrsxnopanaMe,Ul1.11OKCI1XJIOpl1pOBaHI15I.COCTaBe,UOCTI1)KeHl1eMaKCI1MaJIbHOll rrp0I13Bo.n:I1TeJIbHOCTI1 rrorrozce43) rronyaensrnonsie ztanasre 0 <pa30BhIXII TeKCTypHhIXlI3MeHeHlI5IXKaTaJIlI3aTOpa nonB03.n;eHcTBlIeMpeaKIIlIoHHOH cpezrsr.

C npaane-reaaere<plI3lIKO-XlIMlIqeCKlIXMeTo.n;OBaHaJIlI3aYCTaHOBJIeHCOCTaB arJIOMepaTOB aKTlIBHhIX COJIeH Ha rrOBepXHOCTlI HOClITeJI5I, nonyseasrztanasre 06 ynoce XJIOPlI.n;OBMe.n;lIC rrOBepXHOCTlIxaranasaropa.4) KaK arornonsmreanoxrpa60ThInpeztnoacenaTeXHOJIOrlIqeCKa5I cxexra.n;aBJIeHlIlI,BKJIIOqeHHOrOB cxesry rrpoaanozrcrsaaKTlIBHhIX COJIeH B KaTaJIlI3aTOpe, a ratoxeOXMnpaJIerKlIX OJIe<plIHOB.Hossre '.n;aHHhle 0 KlIHeTlIKe II MexaHlI3Me npoueccaconepxcaaaanpoueccaOXM,BJIlI5IHlIlI COCTaBa II0 rrpeBpaIIIeHlI5IX KaTaJIlITlIqeCKOHClICTeMhI B xone ee 3KCrrJIyaTaIIlIlI nozt B03.n;eHcTBlIeMpeaKIIlIOHHOH cpensr rrpe.n;CTaBJI5IIOTHecoMHeHHhIH mrrepec.n;JI5Ipa3BlITlI5I 'reopnaII nparcrnxaKaTaJIlI3aTOpoB II rrponeccosn, BqaCTHOCTlI,.n;JI5I Mo.n;epHlI3aIIlIlI TeXHOJIOrlIlIOKlICJIlITeJIhHOrOXJIOplIpOBaHlI5Iyrnesoztopozton.COBOKyrrHOCTh lI3JIO)l(eHHOrO rr03BOJI5IeT peIIeH3eHTYlICCJIe.n;oBaHlIH,BhIIIOJIHeHHhIX.n;JI5I ztocncsemrarroztxonoa, rpaxroraocranay-nrsrxpaccaarpaaaenas paöorac-mrars,qTO rro06beMYrrOCTaBJIeHHOHB paöore IIeJIlI, 060cHoBaHHocTlI0606IIIeHlIH, a 'rarose Ba)l(HOCTlI npaxraaecxaxpemenaäy.n;oBJIeTBOp5IeTTpe60BaHlI5IM, rrpe.n;b5IBJI5IeMhIMK zurcceprarrassrHacrenem, KaH.n;lI.n;aTaTeXHlIqeCKlIXHaYK.3AMEYAHH5Irro ztnccepranaouaoäpaöore.1) I1PlI lI3yqeHIflI KlIHeTlIqeCKlIX sasoaonepnocreälIJIlI sapaaarsrrrpoc-raraasr0 B03MO)l(HOMMexaHlI3Me npoueccaOKOJIO 20axcnepmrearam.asreynacrnaxapeaxnna.Mo.n;eJIeH COXM.Pa3HOHBhI.n;BlIraeT ranoreasrHa 3TOM nyrncreneasropaccerorpeasrIITOqHOCTlI orrlIChIBaIOIIIlIX.n;aHHhle.

Hexoropsre lI3 HlIX He conepxar XJIOPlI.n;Me.n;lI KaK rnaanoro113 rrpe.n;CTaBJIeHHhIXxroneneä Mo.n;eJIh18P MO)l(eT6hITh lICrrOJIh30BaHa .n;JI5Ipa3pa60TKlI TeXHOJIOrlIlI nponeccaOXM, rrOCKOJIhKYonacsrsaerHalI60JIee TOqHO, B HeH y-rreno conpazcenae6hIJIa ztoxasanaznrcceprarrrzracceprarrroxipaneeKlIHeTlIKY nponeccaOXMCOJIeHMe.n;lIII JIaHTaHa. AKTlIBHOCTh3TlIX COJIeH3KcrreplIMeHTaJIhHhIM rryrexr. A BOT MHOrOqlICJIeHHhleMo.n;eJIlI,B KOTOPhIX3TlI COJIlI OTCYTCTBYIOTlIJIlI OTJIlIqaIOTC5IBhICOKOHnorpenmocrsroTOJIhKO06peMeH5IIOTznrcceprarnno,2))J,JI5IJIyqIIIlIX xrozteneä18 II 18P, 6hIJI npoasneneaKOHIIeHTpaIIlI5IXconeä xaranasaropa.COlICKaTeJIh, Haxo.n;lIJIC5I B npeztenaxnpennoxeanoäPasöpoc rrorpennrocreäpacxer.n;JI5Inpn pa3HhIX MOJIhHhIXscex cnysaen,.n;BYXrrpOIIeHTOB, qTO nozrrsepaoiaerMo.n;eJIlI.K CO)l(aJIeHlIIO,zraccepraar3TlI pacserKaK crae-raera.n;eKBaTHOCThhI He npnaoznrr.3) He rrOH5ITHO,KaKlIM 06Pa30M .n;lIcCepTaHTpaCCqlITaJI 3HaqeHlI5I KOHCTaHTcxopocreäanexrearapnuxpeaKIIlIH, COCTaBJI5IIOIIIlIXMexaHlI3M peaxnun?4) Hexoropsre PlICYHKlI, npasenemnaeB zraccepranaa,rpynnopnc.

21 Ha c.72. pnc, 46 Ha c.l 09, pnc, 22 Ha c.80, pnc. (6e3 nozmacn)qlITaeMhI, aanpanep,Ha C.114.55) Ha c. 104 pexonennoaaaoHCrrOJIb30BaTbKaTaJIH3aTOpbI C paaaepox2 MM, a Ha c.19 - He 60JIee 5 MM? ,[(Ba paaxeparpaHYJI He 60JIeeH o6a C ozmoä IIeJIblO - 'ITo6bI H36e)I<aTbrrOBbIIIIeHHoro ynoca COJIeH.LITOaepno?6) HaCKOJIbKO cYllleCTBeHHO BJIH5IHIieBHelIIHe,n:Ii<PY3IioHHoro TOpMO)KeHH5I,eCJIIi OHOcymecreyer,Ha npoueccOXM?KOMMeHTapmIMH. B7) ITPIiBo,n:HMbIe Ta6JIIiIIbI Ii PIiCYHKH ,n:OJI)KHbIconposoaorarsca,n:IiccepTaIIIiIi 3TO rrpHCYTCTByeTHe ncerna, Hanpnsrep,Ta6JI.l.9 Ha c.62. ITpIi'IeM, He rrOH5ITHO,rrO'IeMYKOHBepCH5Ixreraaa COCTaBJI5IeTscero 2,8%.8) Ka)KeTc5I He COBceM xoppexrnoäcozrepacaaas3aBHCHMOCTb aKTHBHOCTIi K~TaJIIi3aTOpa OTB HeM Me,n:H (pnc.d l , c.98), nocrpoennaanpa pa3HbIX 3Ha'IeHIi5IX OTHOIIIeHIiH060IiX aKTHBHbIXMCTaJIJIOBMe,n:IiH JIaHTaHa, BJIH5IIOIIIIiXztpyr Ha ztpyra?9)LIeM 06ocHoBaHBbI60pTeXHOJIomqeCKOH cxexre npoueccapeaxroparroztasa peaxunonnoroaenocpencrneaaoB armapare,OXM?a,n:Ha6aTHqeCKOrO peaxropaKaK oöecne-rasaercaBpaBHOMepHa5I rro cexenarorasa? ITpopa6aTbIBaJIC5I JIIi sonpocYJIaBJIIiBaHH5IcOJIeH Me,n:IiqTo6bI He Pa3HOCHTbHX rro BceMY TpaKTY?10) B mrreparypaoxrrrOMIiMOxa-recrnenaoroqeTbIpexcTyrreHqaTOrOoösope npa orracanaaPa3JIH'IHbIX MeTo,n:OBnorryseuaacorrOCTaBJIeHIi5IIIeJIecoo6pa3HO npasecra11) 3HaqeHH5I BbIXO,n:HbIXnoxasareneäOXM,OJIe<pHHoB3KOHOMHqeCKIierrOK3.3aTeJIIi.TaKHX KaK CeJIeKTIiBHOCTb, crenensKOHBepCIiHcoztepzcar 2 3HaKa rrOCJIe 3arr5IToH.