Отзыв второго оппонента (Математическое и программное обеспечение для управления базами знаний на основе многоуровневых семантических моделей гетерогенных информационных ресурсов)

OT3bIB O<I>Hll;HA.JlbHOro OIIIlOHEHTA0 ,n;HccepTau,HH rperep Cepre.SI 3.n;yap,n;OBWia «MaTeMaTWieCKOe H nporpaMMHOe o6ecrreqeHHe ,ll;Jlll yrrpaBJieHH.SI 6a3aMH 3HaHHH Ha OCHOBe MHoroypOBHeBbIX ceMaHTHqecKHX MO,n;eJieH», npe,n;cTaBJieHHOH Ha COHCKaHHe yqeHOH CTerreHH KaH,ll;H,ll;aTa TeXHHqecKHX HayK no crre:u;HaJibHOCTH05.13.11 -«MaTeMa-THqecKoe H rrporpaMMHOe o6ecrreqeHHe BbJqHCJIHTeJibHbIX MaIIIHH, KOMIIJieKCOB H KOMIIbIOTepHbIX ceTeH»,[I;HccepTa:u;HoHHaJI pa6oTa Cepreg 3.n;yap.n;oBWiafperep rrocBm:u;eHa HC-CJie,n;oBaHHIO H pa3pa60TKe MeTO,ll;OB rrpoeKTlipOBaHH.SI H pa3pa6oTKH HHcpopMa:u;HOHHbIX CHCTeM H HarrpaBJieHa Ha COBepmeHCTBOBaHHe MeTO,ll;OJIOrHH rrpoeKTHpoBaHH.SI HHcpOpMa:u;HOHHhlX Be6-CHCTeM H pa3pa60TKH HHCTpYMeHTaJibHbIX cpe,n;CTBc HCIIOJih30BaHHeM cpe,n;cTB yrrpaBJieHH.SI 3HaHH.SIMH.

BhIIIOJIHeHHhlH aBTopoM HCcJie,n;oBaHH.SI aHaJIH3 H3BeCTHbIX rro.n;xo,n;oB K pemeHHIO ,ll;aHHOH rrpo6JieMhl IIOKa3bIBaeT, ~o 0,ll;HHM H3 HaH6oJiee rrepcrreKTHBHbIX .SIB.JllleTC.SI rro.n;xo.n;, OCHOBaHHbIBHa HCIIOJib30BaHHH ceMaHTWieCKHe MO,ll;eJieH.AKT}'aHbHOCTbAHccepTa~uouuoroucCHeAOBaHHHorrpe,n;e.IDieT HaJIWIHeHepemeHHhIX 3a,n;aq, CB513aHHbIX c IIpaKTWieCKHM HCIIOJib30BaHHeM ceMaHTWieCKHX MO,ll;eJieH H o6ycJIOBJieHHbIX OTCYTCTBHeM HJIH HeCOBepmeHCTBOM MeTO,ll;OBrrpe,n;cTaBJieHH.SI, xpaHeHH.SI H ynpaBJieHH.SI MHoroypoBHeBhlMH CM, o6ecrreqffBaIOI:QHX e,n;HHoo6pa3HOe ynpaBJieHHe pa3HOpO,n;HbIMH HHcpOpMa:u;HOHHbIMH pecypCaMH.Hayttuau uoeu1ua AHccepTa~uu rrponJI.SieTc51 B•IIpe,n;Jio)l(eHcJie.n;yIOI:QHX acrreKTax:o6neKTHo-opHeHTHpOBaHHhmMeTo.n;rrpe,n;cTaBJieHH.SI,xpaHeHH.SI H ynpaBJieHH.SI MHoroypoBHeBhlMH CM, o6ecrreqffBaJOI:QHHe,n;HH006pa3HOeynpaBJieHHereTeporeHHhlMHHHcpOpMa:u;HOHHbIMHpecypcaMH;•IIpe,n;JIO)l(eH o6'beKTHO-OpHeHTHpOBaHHbIB MeTO,ll; IIOCTpOeHH.SI H HHTerpa:u;HH apXHTeKTYPHhIX Mo,n;eJieifE3,pa3pa6oTaHHbIX B paMKax pa3-JllillHbIX MeTO,n:OJIOrHlleCKHX rro,n:xo,n:oB, OCHOBa.HHbIB Ha a,z:t;arrTan;HHCM u;eJieaoli CYE3 K CM 06ecrre11HBruom;eli CHCTeMhl;•Pa3pa60Ta.H1>1 <l>opMaJibHhle Mo,n:eJIH, MeTo,n:hl H aJiropHTMhl o6pa6oTKH HH<i>opMan;HH,n:mIyrrpaBJieHIDI E3 Ha OCHOBe MHOroypoBHeBblXCM reTeporeHHbIX HH<i>opMan;HoHHhIX pecypcoa.TeopeTu11ecKaH 3Ha11HMOCTb pa6oTbI38.KJIJOqaeTCH B pa3pa6oTI<e MaTeMa-THllecKHX MeTO,n:OB, MO,n:eJieli H aJirOpHTMOB o6pa6oTKH HH<i>opMan;HH,n:mIyrrpaa-JieHHH E3 Ha ocHoBe MHoroypoBHeBblX CM reTeporeHHblX HH<i>opMan;HoHHbIXrrpou;eccoa.Ilpanu11ecKaH 3H811HMOCTb HCCJie,ZJ;OBaHHH•Co3,n:a.Ho rrporpaMMHoe o6ecrreqeHHe38.KJIJOlJaeTCH B TOM, lJTO:,n:m1rrpaKTHllecKoro HCIIOJib30-Ba.HHH pa3pa6oTaHHoro KOMIIJieKca KOHQerrryaJibHDIX Mo,n:eJieli E3 Ha:narre rrpoeKTHpOBa.HHH CYE3.•Pa3pa6oTa.H Ha6op areHToB, 06ecrre11HBruoI.QHX peaJIH3an;mo 3arrpocoaK E3, <PopMHpOBa.HHe HHCTPY~teHTaJibHoli cpe,n:D1, BH3)'aJIH3aJJ;HH E3.•Co3,n:a.H rrporpaMMHhlli HHC'Tp)'MeHT ,n:m1 co3,n:a.HHH H pe,n:aKTHpOBa.HHHMo,n:eJieli E3 OntoEditor.•Co3,n:a.Ha lfC ,n:m1 rrpoeKTHpOBa.HHH E3 PloneModeler.•IIpe.n;JIO)KeH crroco6 HHTerpan;HH pa3pa6oTa.HHoro rrporpaMMHoroo6ecrreIJeHIDI c cym;ecTB)'IOIIJ;HMH CYE3, IJTO o6ecrrelJHBaeT ero a,n;arrTan;mo K H3MeIDIIOIIJ;HMCH B rrpou;ecce 3KCIIJIYaTaJJ;HH 'Tpe6oBa.HHHM.KpoMe Toro, B IIpHJIO)Kemrax K pa6oTe ecTu aKThl BHe.n:peHIDI, rro,n:Taep)K,n:ruom;He,qTo pa3pa60Ta.HHOe MaTeMaTJllieCKOe H rrporpaMMHOe o6ecrrelJeHHe HCIIOJib30BaHhl rrpH C03,n:a.HHH H BHe,n:peHHH «lfHTeJIJieKT)'aJibHOH CHCTeMhl rrpoeKTHpOBa.HHHae6-rrpHJIO)Kemrn» H «lfHTeJIJieKT)'aJibHoli cHcTeMa yrrpaBJieHIDI yqe6HblM rrpou;eccoM», lJTO rro,n:TBep)K,n:eHO aKTaMH 0 BHe.n:peHHH pe3)'JlbTaTOB ,n:HccepTan;HOHHOH pa60T1>1.D;eJiblO HCCJie,ZJ;OB8HHH61>IJ1a pa3pa6oTI<a HayqHo-o6ocHOBa.HHbIX MaTeMa-THlleCKoro H rrporpaMMHoro o6ecrreIJeHHH,n:m1yrrpaaJieHHH 6a3oli 3Ha.HHH Ha oc-HOBe MHOroypOBHeBbIX ceMa.HTlflleCKHX MO,ZJ;eJieH reTeporeHHbIX HHCpopMau;HOHHbIX pecypcoB.,[(11ccepTau;IDI HMeeT qen<yro H norH11eCI<y10 CTPYKTYPY· Cne,ZJ;y.si KJiacclfllecKoii MO,ZJ;eJIH HCCJie,ZJ;OBaHH.H, OHa rrpe,D;Bap.sieTC.H BBe.i.euueM, B KOTOpOM OIIHCaHblOCHOBHbie BBO,Zl;Hbie ITO pa6oTe, C.3.rperep paCCMa'Tp:HBaeT OCHOBHbie HCCJie,ZJ;O-BaHH.H, HMerom;Hec.si Ha ,Zl;aHHbIB MOMeHT H CTerreHb rrpopa60TaHHOCTH TeMbl HCCJie,ZJ;OBaHH.H H rrpHXO.ZJ:HT K BbIBO.ZJ:aM, ~o Yff:HBepcaJibHhle CM rrpe,D;CTaBJieHH.H Ho6pa60TKH 3HaHHH, BapHaHThl HX TeXHH11eCKOH peaJIH3au;HH ceMaHTlflleCKHX MO,ZJ;eJieH HCCJie,ZJ;OBaJIHCb B pa6oTax A.C.

Krrem;eBa,11.JI.ApTeMbeBOH, B.B. roneH-KOBa, B.<I>. XopomeBCKoro, T.A. raBpHJIOBOH H ,D;p. TeM He MeHee OCTaeTC.H HepemeHHbIMP.H.ZJ:rrpo6neM, CB.H3aHHbIX c rrpaKTH11ecKHM HCIIOJib30BaHHeM CM, a:HMeHHO OTCYTCTBHeM MeTO,Zl;OB rrpe,D;CTaBJieHH.H, xpaHeHH.H, H yIIpaBJieHH.H MHOroypOBHeBbIMH CM, o6ecrreqJIBaroIIJ;HX e,ZJ;HHoo6pa3Hoe yrrpaBJieHH.H reTeporeHHhlMH HH<jlopMau;HOHHbIMH pecypcaMH; MeTO,Zl;OB IIOC'TpOeHH.H H HHTerpau;HH apXHTeKTJPHbIX MO,ZJ;eneii CYE3, pa3pa6oTaHHbIX B paMKax pa3JIH11HbIX MeTo,ZJ;onorHqecKHX rro,ZJ;XO.ZJ:OB, rrporpaMMHoro o6ecrreqeHH.sJ WUI yrrpaBJieHH.H E3.1-aH rJiaBa ,ZJ;HCcepTau;HH IIO,Zl; Ha3BaHHeM «AHAJil13 CoBpeMeHHOfO COCTO.HHH.H METO,[(OB rrpoeKTHpOBaHH.H H pa3pa6oTKH HH<jlopMau;HOHHbIX cHcTeM.IlocTaHOBKa 3a,u,aq11 HCCJie,ZJ;OBaHH.H».

PaccMa'Tp:HBaeT TaKHe acrreKTbl KaK: MO,ZJ;eJIHPOBaHHbie MeTO.ZJ:bI aHaJIH3a CHCTeM, oHTonorH11eCKYffi MO,ZJ;eJib HC, rrpe,D;MeTHoe rrpoc'TpaHCTBO HC, ApXHTeKTJPHbie OIIHCaHH.H HC, iKH3HeHHbIH I.J;HKJI HC,MeTaMO,ZJ;eJib CTaH,D;apTa ISO24744,oco6eHHocTH rrpoeKTHpOBaHH.H H pa3pa6oTKHCHCTeM yIIpaBJieHH.H E3 H IIOCTaHOBKY 3a,u,aq HCCJie,ZJ;OBaHH.H.2-aH rJiaBa ,ZJ;HCCepTau;HH IIO,Zl; Ha3BaHHeM «Pa3pa6oTKa MaTeMaTH11eCKOroo6ecrreqeHH.H ,Zl;JUI yrrpaBJieHH.H 6a3aMH 3HaHHH Ha OCHOBe MHOroypoBHeBbIX ceMa.HTlflleCKHX MO,ZJ;eneii reTeporeHHbIX HH<jlopMau;HOHHbIX pecypcoB» BKJIIOqaeTo60CHOBaHHe BbI6opa MaTeMaTH11eCKHX MeTO,Zl;OB rrpe,D;CTaBJieHH.H H o6pa6oTKHceMa.HTlflleCKHX MO,ZJ;eJieH, o6ocHOBaHHe rrpe,ZJ;JIOiKeHHhlX aBTOpOM MO,ZJ;eJieH H aJIropHTMOB o6pa6oTKH HH<jlopMau;HH, pa3pa6oTKY MO,ZJ;eJieH, MeTO,Zl;OB H anropHTMOB rrpoeKTHpOBaHH.H rrporpaMMHbIX CHCTeM3-H r JiaBarreqeHIDI,n:mI,n:HccepTa:QHH rro.n: H33BrurneM «P33pa6oTKa rrporpaMMHoro o6ec-yrrpaBJieHIDI E3 Ha OCHOBe MHOroypOBHeBhlX ceMaHTlfqeCKHX Mo,n:e-rreii reTeporeHHhIX HmpopMa:QHOHHhIX pecypcoB» rrpe,n:cTaBJieHa IIJiaTcpopMaPloneModeler, rrpoH3Be,n:eH Bb16op cpe,n:o1 p33pa6oTKH H rrpoBe,n:eHa p33pa6oTKaKOMIIOHeHToB HHCTPY~rnHTaJihHOH cpe,n:I>I.3aKJIIO'ICHHe,n:HCCepTau;HH HOCHT cpopMarrbHhlH He p33BepH)'TbIB xapaKTep,no KOTopoMy cy,n:HTh o pa6oTe, 6e3 ee rroJIHoro rrpoqTeHIDI rrpaKTlfqeCKH HeB03MO)KHO.K 1aMe'laHHHM MO)KHO OTHecTH:•BhICK33aHHhIH B pa6oTe rroczyrraT, o OTC)'TCTBHH rrporpaMMHoro o6ecrreqeHIDI,n:mIyrrpaBJieHIDI 633aMH 3Ha.IIHH H TaK .)Ke OTC)'TCTBHH MeTO,n:OB xpa-HeHIDI rrpe,n:cTaBmieTC.H COMHHTeJibHbIM, T.K.,n:mIyrrpaBrreHIDI TaKoro po,n:a633aMH ,n:aBHO HCIIOJib3)7lOTC.H pemeHIDI KOMIIaHHH Oracle H SAP;•HeKOTOpbie c,n:eJiaHHhle B pa6oTe rrpe,n:rro)KeHIDI HOC.HT 6e3aJibTepHaTHBHblHxapaKTep (HarrpHMep, HCIIOJib30Brurne IIJiaTcpopMhI PloneModeler);•OTC)'TCTBHe p33BepH)'Toro 3aKJIIOqeHIDI 3aTPy,n:H.HeT BOCIIpH.HTHe pa60Tbl Bu:erroM 6e3 ee IIOJIHOro rrpo~eHIDI (3aKJIIOqeHHe COCTOHT H3 TPeX a63au;eB.HBHhlM o6p330M He ,n:ocTaTOqffblX,n:mIcpopMHpOBaHIDI IIOJIHOH KapTHHhl 0pa6oTe).•HaJilfqlfe o6HJibHOro KOJilfqeCTBa ycTapeBmHX HCTOqfflfKOB HCIIOJib30BaHHOH JIHTepaTYPhI (HeKoTopbIM KHHraM, cTaTh.HM 6orree 15-TH rreT).KpoMe Toro, pa6oTa HecBo6o,n:Ha OT HeTOqffOCTeii B ocpopMrreHHH, TaK,HaIIpHMep: orJiaBJieHHe OTcpopMaTHpOBaHO p33Hb1M mpHcpTOM;B pa6oTe OTC)'T-CTByeT rryHKT 2.3, rrocrre rryHKTOB 2.2.

H.D:YT rryHKTbl 2.4; B CIIHCKe COKpam;eHHiirrpHC)'TCTB)'IOT He Bee HMe101.u;Hec.s B TeKcTe coKpam;eHIDI ( HarrpHMep, CYE3,yrroMHHaeMa.s co CTPaHHUbI 6 Hccrre,n:oBaHIDI); OTC)'TCTBHe ,n:aT o6pam;eHIDI B3JieKTPOHHbIX pecypcax B CIIHCKe JIHTepaTYPhl.OcHOBHbie rrorro)KeHIDI ,n:HccepTau;HH arrpo6HpOBaHhl B p.s.n:e ,n:oKJia,n:oB, c,n:eJiaHHhlX aBTOpOM, B TOM qlfcrre H Ha Me)K.D:yffapo,n:HhIX KOHcpepeHU:H.HX, a TaK)KeH3JIO)KeHhl B 25 rry6JIHKau;IDIX, 3 H3 KOTOpbIX HarreqaTaHhl ,n:HccepTaHTOM B Be-~pe:u;eH3HpyeMI>IX HayqHI>IX H3,n:a.HIDIX, peKoMeH,n:oBa.HHLIX BAK P<I>. Beeorry6JIHKOBaHHDie pa60Thl, a TaIOKe aBTOpe<)lepaT ,n:HccepTa:u;HH COOTBeTCTByeTrrpe,n:ocTaBJieHHOMY B Harne pacrropIDKeHHe ee rreqaTHOMY TeKcry, H IIOJIHOCTblOOTPIDKaeT ee co,n:ep)l(aHHe.,lJ;HccepTa:u;IDI BbIIIOJIHeHa B cooTBeTCTBHH c TPe6oBaHIDIMH BAK MHHHcTepcTBa o6pa30BaHIDI H HaYKH P<I> K ,n:HCCepTa:u;IDIM Ha COHCKaHHe yqeHOH CTerreHH KaH,n:H,n:aTa HaYK.

Ilo CBOeMY co,n:ep)l(aHHIO, CTeIIeHH rrpopa60TKH Bhl,n:BHraeMbIX Ha 3am;Hry HayqHhIX IIOJIO)l(eHHH, HOBH3He H aKTYaJibHOCTH rronyqeHHDIX,n:HccepTaHTOM pe3yJibTaTOB OHa COOTBeTCTByeT rryHKTaM «IlOJIO)l(eHIDI 0 rrop.si,n:KerrpHc~eHIDIyqelil>IX CTerreHeH», YTBep)l(JJ:eHHoro IIOCTaHOBJieHHeM IlpaBHTeJih-CTBa P<I> OT 24 ceHu16p.S1 2013 r.CqHTaro, qTo aBTop ,n:HccepTa:u;HH «MaTeMaTlfqeCKoe H rrporpaMMHoe o6ecrreqeHHe,n:JI.SIyrrpaBJieHIDI 6a3aMH 3HaHHH Ha OCHOBe MHOrOypOBHeBblX ceMaHTH-tJ:eCKHX Mo,n:ene:H:» fperep C.3.

3aCJIY)l(HBaeT rrpHc~eHIDI eMY yqeHo:H: cTerreHHKaH,n:H,n:aTa TeXHH1IeCKHX HaYK no crre:u;HaJibHOCTH 05.13.11 -«MaTeMaTlfqeCKOeH rrporpaMMHOe o6ecrreqeHHe Bhl1IHCJIHTeJibHblX MaIIIHH, KOMIIJieKCOB H KOMIIblOTepHDIX ceTeH»OcpH:u;HaJihHhIH orrrroHeHTKaH,n:H,n:aT TeXHH1IeCKHX HaYKcTapurn:H: HayqHI>IH COTPYJJ:HHK<l>fEYH llilcTHryT IIpo6neMYrrpaBneHIDI HM. B.A. Tparre3HHKOBaPoccHlicKo:H: AKa,n:eMHH HaYK:>KHranoB KHpHJIJI IOpI>eBlfqPoccIDI, 117997, MocKBa yn.

Ilpocpcoro3Ha.R, ,n:. 65illIY PAH, 22 na6.Tene<}loH: +7 (495) 334-89-913neKTpoHHhlii a,n;pec: kshakalov@mail.ru03.04.2017f..:m..