Отзыв_Офф.Опп.__Данилочкина_НГ (Разработка методического инструментария проведения оценочных процедур в сфере научно-исследовательских и опытно-конструкторских работ)

BAlrcceprallrloHHbrfi coserM|TYr4M.[212.141.2IH.3. EavuanaOT3bIB O@I4I-U,IAJIbHO| O OIIIOFIEHTAHraAr{cceprallurc .{anerrana llasrta Izlropenuua Ha reMy: <Pa:pa6orKaMeTo,4LIqecKorO LTHcTpyMeHTapvIfl rIpoBeAeHLIf, oIIeHorIHbIx npoqeAyp a cSepeH€rlrqHa-rccJreAoBareJrbcKrrx r{ orrbrrgo-KoHcrpyKTopcKl,Ix pa6or>, [peAcraBneHHyloHa cotrgKttwde yrreHofi crerreHu Kar{A.vAara:exonouuqecKux nayri:cnefiuaniHocrl{0 8.00.05 - <<3rouoMr,rKa lr yrpaBneHr4e HapoAHblvt xossfi crBoM>, c[eqplankrcatJkrfl.<<MeselxMeHT)>Arcrya.nrHocrb reMbr Aucceprarluu o6yclouenaueo6xo4raMocrbrorpoueAypSopvrzpoBa:nus. s{lQerrunHoro r4HcrpyMeHrapvr rIpoBeAeHI4t oIIeHoqHbIXn c{epe Ha)rqHo-r4rlcJreAoBareJrbcKrlxcBt3llLTorlblrHo-KoHcrpyKropcKl4x pa6or (HI4OKP) nC:- ofpaHLTqerlHocrbloSzHaHconbIX, KaApoBbIX, BpeMeHHbIX pecypcon n cQepeHLIOKP;-rlbrooKrrMlypoBHeM pucKoB, HeonpeAeneHHocrefi, sarpar B AaHHofi o6nacrvtLTCCJIeAOBantI,'IS.;-HaJrt{rrr4ervrronSnzKTa uHTepecoe crefiKxoJlAepon n cQepe HZOKP;- rrHeprHoolbK) AaHHoro Btrna 6zsneca;-1II43KI4M yp,osHeNd unQopnrarqgalJkIqr BKpoue roro,ucrroJrb3yeMbreBl4ccJleAyeMofio6lacruLIT.A.rrpaKTlaKe orerrecrBeHHblx upe4uplaxrufiB cQepe HZOKP He coorBercrBylorcoBpeMeHHoro 6ragseca: Hoctr pa3po3Hennrrfi x aKTep, orcyrcrByrcTr{HcrpyMeH'rbr orleHorrHbrx nporleAyprpe6onanlrrrMTIpLI3HaKLIuxI(oMIrJIeKcHocrrI, B3auMocBt3LI, xpoHoJIorLII{, o6rexrzsHocrll,OTIepaTLIBHOCTLI LI CO|JIaCOBaHHOCTLI.l[cer,IrueHtle ypoBHt cofJlaooBaHHocrkI crpareruqecKllx, TaKTI4rIecKLlxoneparraBHt;rx qeJtefiueneBoronvrn cSepe HZOKP anrop npeAnaraer ocyqecrBllrb Ha ocHoBeoAXoAa cr4creMHoro aHaJrI43a, rlo3Bon{IoIr1elo rloBErcrrrb eSQerrueHocrrpecypcoB, cHI{xeHLIeAocrr4x(eHuJr KoHKlle Hbrx rleJrefi MeHeAXMeHTa (ouruura:a\v5.cpoKoB, lltrcKoB, Hrgo peAeJIeHHOcTeii uHI4OKP .tacrrerLICnOJIb3OBAHVI''.r.l.)B BoIIpocaxaHuIvI3acooTBeTcTBytoulzxIII4MoIIeHr<IEn cQepeT4HCTpyMeHTOBKOHTpOnnuHra.c Bbrrrreu3JroxeHHbrM, aKTyzLJIbHocrb Auccepraul,IoHHofi pa6oruAan6run:a n.I4.

He Bbr3brBaer covfirenrafi. IIpe4craBJIeHH€It Ar4caeprarlws',BcB,flsvrHecoMHeHH(f,,rBJrrercr coBpeMeHHbrM HayqHbIM I4ccJIeAoBaHueM a c$epe HI4OKP, aee peSylrTatTblI4MT3IOT[paKTnr{eCKyIrC 3HaqLIMOcTb'o(S.rrarcrr nccJreAoBaHrrf cooTBeTcTByeT flacnopry HOMeHKJraTypbIcreqlr€rnbngcrefi ,BAK Muuo6puayKvr PO 08.00.05 - 3lconouuKa v ynpaBneHueHapoAHErM xog-f,.ficrsoNr (rvrene4xvrenr)yrrpaBneHpL,r opIzlHI{3aIIuxMLl.n.10.10: <dlpoerrnpoBaHpreHonue Qopvrrr QynxquoHl4poBannfl'ucLIcreMpa3BIdTLTsclrcreM yrrpaBneHlrf, opraHr43a\vflMu.

Zn$opvtaul4oHHble cucreMbl B ynpaBreHr4r4opraHr43a\trflM1r. Kaqec:reo ynpaBJIeHLIrI opranzsaqzefi. MeroAolorLIt pa3Bvrrv[6usHec-1npc)qeccor]. Pagsurze MeroAotrortrr414 MeroAOB yrlpaBnonvs Koploparl'IBHofi14HHOBaTII4O HHOft 0t4 CTeMOfiHaYunar>.HOBII3HApe3yJIbTaToBALTCCepTaqI,IOHHOfOLTCCJIE.IIOBAHIdflo6vcnorlnerga co3AaHr{eM HoBbrx rcnaccnQuraqnfi, uo4eneft, na6opoe lpy[noBbrxrIoK€BaTeJIeI4,MeroAI4qecrufiynpaBneHrrecKuxQOpunponarr rovrnlerccurrfiIrHcrpyMetrapuir., HallpaBnensufi Ha npl4HflTue eQSemzrnux[poqegcoB,peruenufiIIO3BOJITIOqLIXrpunpoBeAeHLII4 oIIeHoqHbIXrpolleAypBcQepeHI4OKI'.B nepnofri rJraBe <<O6ouroBanueHeo6xoAI4MocrI4 coBeplxeHcrBoBaH.vrflorleHoqlilbllK npox:eAyp B cQepe HLTOKP) rpoBeAeH o6:op HopMaruBHo-npaBoBoroB csepe HI4OKP B PoccuH.

Anropou BbIAeJIeHbI ocHoBHbIeupo6leuu rpoBroAeHLIt oIIeHoqHbIx ilpolleAyp B cQepe HI4OKP' npeAnoxeHblperyrrlrpoBaHhrlHaflpaB::Ie1;.Lrs, vI>( coBepIueHcTBoBaHVt.Ha ocHoBe BbItBJIeHHbIX upo6levrVoco6eHHocrefiBcQepe HI4OKP craBvrrcfl rlenbMeTO.qUqr3CKOfO r4rFrCTpyMeHTapr.Is.odlacru-paspa6orKa eQSerrznHoroB[pOBeAeHr4r OrIeHOrrHbrX [pOUeAypAaHHOr4rlccJreAorlaHufl. lzccepraHToM rrpeAnaraercr r4crroJrb3oBaHkre rleneBororroAxoAa cu:creMHoro ananrvr3a npvr [poBeAeHr4r4 orleHorrHbrx flpoqeAypB c$epeHLIOKP, npoBoAr{rc.fl Kracca;,$urcaryut MeroAoB a;aalrvsa 14 oIIeHKI{ I{HHoBaIIrIonnoficpeAbr.Bo nropoii rJraBe<<Hayruo-MeroAr4rrecKLre rroAxoAbrr4FrcrpryeHrapvrs.

AJUI npoBeAeHr4rr orleHoqHbx rrpolleAypKpaspa6omen cQepe HI4OKP) Ha 6aselrpeAJIoxr3HErhIX aBropoM rrprrHrlHnoB rrpoBeAe]Hr4s. orIeHoqHbIXrpolleAyp B cQepeHMOKP ryleAcrarlJreH parpa6oranurrfi MeroAruecrurfi r4HcrpyMemapufr: MoAenbrrpoBeAeHlrrr orlenroqHhrx nporleAyp B cQepe HI4OKP rpu B3auMoAeircrewuMeHeAXNreHTavKoHTpomrr4Hla; rpyrlrroBofi na6op qeneBbrx rroK€BareJrefi uo ypoBHflMyrrpaBrreHzs HZOIKP, BbrAeJreHHbrM gTarraM aHarrlr3a Lr orleHKrr,3aprHTepecorlaHHbrxcropoH; rovrnnercnrrfi r4HcrpyMeurapuitc ) {eroM IlerefiKoHTpoJTJILIHTa rroocHoBHbrM 3TanaM aBTopcKorf,) rrpoqecca or6opa rpoeKroB HI4OKP rocyAapcrBeHHoroo6oponnoro 3aKa3il n fpax(AaHcKoro Ha3HaqeHvrflHacraAvrvpaccMorpeHurs3aflBrar.B rperrefirJraBe <<|lpar<rzuecKoenpLTMeHeHr4epe3ynbraror] rporleAeHlnr orleHoqHbrx rpolleAyprronf{eHHblx HafrHblxB cQepe HI4OKP)aBropoMrrpoBeAeH aHaJrlr3i zHHoBaru4oHHoro uoreHrluana uccneAyeMblx rtpeynputruit,aupo6upoBarH rrpoqecc or6opa npoeKron HITIOKP rocyaapcrBeHHoro o6opoHHoro3aKa3a rr.

tpax{Aa,HcKofo HtBHarreHLrr AaHHbrxcy6rerron 6uzneca HapaccMorllen,vfl, 3aflBnvL onpeAeneHbr HopMarzBHbrev QartzuecruerreneBhrx noKa3areneit, pazpa6oranrr Kaprbl Mepo[pl4sruir rpoeKToBAocruxeHLrro qeneBhlxrloKutgflpax:rnuecKaq3HaqeHurlHZOKP ro.3HIAIII{MOCTbAucceprzu{zouHofi pa6orerrocKonbr(y BHocflT BKnaAareleficra4vru[ccJreAoBannfl. llorlnrenHrrepe3ynbTaTbr npeAcTaBJI.f,IoTHar{HyIoB coBeprueHcrBoBaHLre cyqecrByroqefrB3HarILIMocTb,MeroAonorI4LIrrpoBeAer[ur orleHorrHbrx npo]qeAyp B cQepe HI4OKP B npoMbIIrJIeHHoM I{ HaTITIOMceKTopax or4r3Heca.KHiocoMHeHHbrMIocroI{HcrBaMpaoorbr cneAyerAaHHofiyHI4BepC€trIbHOCTb LI KOMIIJIeX:CHOCTb rIpeAnO)KeHHOTOLrorHeorrrHCrpyMeHTApvs.

npoBeAelrurlorleHoqH.srx rpoqeAyp B cQepe HZOKP.TeopelrzuecKrre rroJroxeHvrs.AI4CCepTa;HTOM,u MeroAuqecKl{epeKoMeHAar\vrvr, [peAnoxeHrlbleI{MeIoT [paKTI,IqecKOe IIpI4l\,IeHeHLIeHZOKP Ha rrpoMbrr[rreHHbrxnpu pelxe]F.vIrLr HayqHo-rpoI43BoAcrBeHHbIx3anlaqncoepenpeAnpvsTtrflx c IlerlbrorroBbrrueHur eQQerrLIBHocrI4 ynpaBneHus HZOKP.Ilprar<:rra.recKoe 3HarreFrlre npoBeAeHHbIX ,.{andrunrrvrn.V\.I4ccneAoBavuit[oATBep)Kkaercfl. aKTaMr4 Br{eApeHlrr pe3yJrbraroB AklccepraqlaosnofiAerrenbrroc'mAO (AII3) n yre6usrfi npoqecc ApaauaccKoror4Hcrl,Iry:ta (Qunual)pa6orblBrIoJII4TexHI,IqecKoroOfEOy BO HfTY uu.

P.E. AnerceeBa.O$ocnoeaHHocrb H A:ocroBepHocrb HafIHbIX rroJlo)KeHuit Auccepralllln HeBbr3brBaer corunenufi,o6qeuay'rrHbrxoc HoBaxcvTaK KaKuccJle.4oBaHug. 6asupyrorc.acleqr4€urbrlrbrx MeroAoBvrHa[pI4MeHeHLILTI{HcrpyMeHTaptrfl,, KoHIIeTITyULIIIITIIXI4oTeMbr KoHTp onnvrHta, qen eBoM IIOAXOAe CLICTeMHO|O aHaIII43a.HerynueuccneAoBaHr4tfl, [poBeAeHHbIe aBTopoM, ocHoBaHbI Ha AocroBepnofi uo6rerru.sHclfi crarvrcrvrqecxofi uusopuaquucllpe4loxenHbre aBropoM HiryrrHbre pe3ynbrarblnocne4yroqefi ee o6pa6orr<ofi.14 peKoMeHAaIII4lIuMelor qerl(yrcnorr4rrec,Kyro crpyKTypy. Ypoeesr o6ocHoBaHHocrr4 pr AocroBepHocrl4 pe3ynbraroBLrccneAoBattufl rroATBepxAaercfl o6Iuupnurra un$oprr,raunoHHhlM o6ecne'reHueM'uIcToTb3I)BaHHbIM ABTOPOM[PI4pe3ynbr€rrolt anpo6a4uu vrvxNOATOTOBKE PA6OTTT, H€IIIUI{I4EM TIOJIOXI,ITEJIbIIbIX6usuece, a raKxe n yue6uoM rrpoqecceyrrp aBneHLI.,{ I4HH o B ar\vrflvtur,HaB rIpoMbIImeHHoMcreqvalll4croB n cQepe[paKTI4rIecKuM rIpI{MeHeHI4eMI{I4OKP,KorpuHrp onnrloAroroBKeI4 Hra.ocHoBaHr4lr Br,rurel43JroxeHHoro Mo)I(Ho cAeJrarb BbIBoA, rITonpeAcraBJre)HHair Aurccepra\tts.o6ralaerHoBI4sHofi.

flocraeueHHbleIlenu kr 3a4arrvrAOCTI,IfH)'.Tb\ A Har{Hbre pe3ynbraTbr uMeroT HarrHyro rIeHHocTbnpLr MeHerrv e,qTo rroATBep)KAiLeT c fl,unpaKTurrecKoeyclerrrHoft anpo6a4ueir.Cqqepxanue ny6"rrurcaqufinanropeQepara nonHocrbro coorBercrByrorHayqHyrorroJrolr(eHlirrrN[ Ar4ccepTar\uu, aoAepxarr{r4MHoBr43HyI4MCIOUI,IM[paKTr4qe cKJffo 3HaqkrMo cTb.3aMe.{aH[qro AlrccepraIluoHnofi pa6ore. laear-BbrcoKyro oqerrKy[onr{eHIIbII\d Har{HbIM pe3y.[bTaTaM AI4CCepTaHTa, MO]KHO OTMeTVTb CneAyroqueHeAOCTaTKLI:1.Bpa6ore He rlpeAcraBneHo roH.flrLre(MeroArrrrecxufiI4HcrpyM(>utapwir>>.

.{annoe rr,oHrrrze rro3BoJrrzJro 611 6oree qerKo olpeAenLTTb, KaKLreI4MeHHO H€Ir{HbIe pe3ynbTaTbl aBTOpa MOX{HO OTHeCTT4Kt4HCTpyMeHT'aMKOHTpOnnUHfa.2.Bo nropofi rJraBe npeAno)KeH ua6op qeneBbrx norcasarerefi ilplrrrpoBeAenr4la oIIeHorrHbIX rprolleAypBcQepe HZOKP. ,{anurrfi ua6op uMeerHe3aBeplreHrryro cocTaBJrfrornyro no [peAno]KeHHbrM gTarraM, ypoBHrM, rpylrraM.J.B rperrefiruase rpoBeAeHa anpo6arlur npoqecca or6opa npoeKroBHITIOKP Ha crarvru paccMorlpeHzs3€uIBKLr,Ho He pacKpbrr Bonpoc orHoclrreJrbHoor6opa :)Kcr[eproB, orleHlrBarorrlkrx rleneBbreycraHoBneHr{brM lpyrrrraM.[annoerroKa3areJrr4 rrpoeKToBAononHeHlreTIO3BOJILIJIOHI4OKPObIrroTIOBbICT'TTb[paKTlrqe cK)rIo IIeHHocrb p€s1r151uton pa6orrr.O6urnrft BbrBoA rr 3aK.[roqeHrre rro Arrcceprarl[[.

Hecnrorpfl. Ha yKa3aHHbIe3aMerraHr,arx,pa6ory .{an€rzna flaena Zroperzua MoxHo cqr4Tarb caMocrotreJrbHbrM,3aBeprrreFtHbrMv rny6oxuvrHaf{HbrM LrccneAoBaHI{eM, LIMeIoqLIM Haf{HyIoHoBtr3Hy. OcnosHHN4r4 Aocror{HcrBaMlr Ar4ccepralluosnoficTpyKTypI4pOBaHHocTbvIKOIvIIIJIOKOHOCTbI4ccneAoBaHvrp\pa6orrr sBrrK)TctaeeTaKxte upaKTHqecKoerrplrMeHelrlre pa3pa6orannrrx aBTopoM zHcrpyMeHToB: rnaccuQnr<aquft, uo4enefi,na6opon u<lrca^:arenefi, [poqeccoBrprrpoBeAeHkrpl artpodaquuHarIpLIMeperocyAapcrBeHHoro o6oponHoro 3aKa3arpoeKroB III4OKPvrrparrAaHcKoroHA3HAIIEHI,l'.[ucceprarlr4oHH€ur pa6ora :aar'ucana HayrrHo fpaMorHblM t3bIKoM, aKKyparHoo$opulena, rlMeercfl AocrarorrHoe KoJrrrqecrBo rpa$nuecKoro Marepl4alla, rrrorroBbrrrraeT 'ypoBeHb HaDIqAr{ocTIa Vr BOCIpUI{MTII4BOCTLI MaTepl,Ialra.raxAofiIIOLITOI'aMr'Jrallbl npeAcraBJIeHbI rlerKrle BbIBOAbI.Ocnonurre rloJloxeHuf, Al,IccepraqraoHnofi pa6oru npeAcraBJIeHbIvonorparfnu, 66 HayqHbItK pa6orax, 14 vI3 KoTopbIX BB1la34aHuflx,BAK PO.

,{uccepranr [pI4HLIM€rn aKT]rBHoe 1^racrl4e Banpo6aqlu HafrHbIX pe:tyJlbTaroB Ha MexAyHapoAHbIX, Bcepoccufict<ux,peKoMeHiIoBaHHbrxperuoH€urbH bIX Ia MexBy3oBcK:LIX,{zccerpra\LroHHafl,<<flonoxenuqonpeAb.rrBJrreMbrMI4ropennuronQepenqutx.pa6ora rronHocTblo oTBeqaeT rpe6onaHz.ru rr.rtop.f,AKe rlpllcyx(AeHvs.Kf{eHbrx cTeneHefi) BAK I'O,KaHAr4AarCKkrM Ar,rCCepTaIILI{M,a eeaBTOp-.{an€r<zH3acnyxuBaer [pr4cyxAeHnfl, eMy LIcKoMoI{ crerIeHI,IgKoHoMr4qeoKr{x HayKllaserKaHAI4Aararro c[erlniulbHocrl,I 08.00.05 - 3rosouvKa Lr ynpaBneHLIeHapoAHbIM >logsfi crBolvr (Mene4xlreHr).llproQeccop raQe4puIrp or43BoAcTBeHHOrO MeHeAXMeHTaI4HX3B:WIaOfBOy BO <Mocroecrrfi aBLIaIILToHnrrfi uncrvrryr(naqu ouanrnrrfi l4ccJleAoBarenrcrzfir49lrap KerI4HrayHHBepcplrer)>A.:).H., npo$eccop [anrano'Ixl,IHaH.f.ip;.t::!-llo,4nzcr .{aHulovKZHrofi H.f .

sanepxroilk/-cJ K/4t/ke/q"lto-{ ('. B,Moorcosc rcnit asuaquonnufi r4Hcrr4Tyr (Haquonanruufi I{ccJreAoBarelrcrzfryHl4Bepcnrerlt I4nxeHepHo-sKoHoMLlrlecrzfi LIHcrI4Tyrengecin.ruTeneQou:+7 499 158-19-53,l2:;gg3.r. Mocrsa, A-Ei0, fClI-3, BolorolaMcKoe ulocce,4.4., ropnyc 5.@,.