Отзыв__Офф.Опп.Яшин_СН (Разработка методического инструментария проведения оценочных процедур в сфере научно-исследовательских и опытно-конструкторских работ)

oT 3bIBOOI4III4AJIbHOT o OITI0HEHTAcceprarluro [anexunaflaua lllropenuuaHa reMy <Paspa6orKa MeroAl4llecKoron cQepe Hay!{HorlHcrpyMe HTapvfl'npoBeAeHzf, olleHorrHbrx flpolreAyppa6o'r>>, npeAcraBJleHHor{ Ha14 onbrrHo-KoHcrpyKTopcKllxccJreaoBareJrbcKr4xcneqv aJIbHOCTHyueHofr creIreHI'I KaHAuAara 3KOHOMllrIecKI'IX HayK rloxogsfi creonn (vrene4xvrenr)>>08.00.05 <3rosor'tvKa pr ynpaBneHlle HapoAHbIMcKaHLIeopraenraqrar rurapoaofiHa I{HTeHCrasuraqraro I4HHOBaUIIOHHO|opa3pelueHlllo saxHefiurux BoIIpocoB' KoTopble3KOHOMLIKI4pasBvrTr4fl"rro"o6"t"yaflepeA IIpOMbIIUneHHbIMI4 I4 Hayr{HbIMLt [IpeArpuflTl1lflMlr4SarrOpOv[e, T.K.

I4MeHHo [IHHoBaIInLI tBJIfIOTct [pI'I3HaHHbIM cTpaTerI4qeCKI'IMCTpyKTypHbIX14I sKOHOMr4Kpr, croco6crnyrorql4M pa3BLITpIIO Op|aHI43aIIUOHHbIX rITo BHeApeHIle3aKoHoMepHo'119p1ult coBpeMeHHoIo o6rqecrsa. Bnogevt3rexnolornfi Aaer Bo3MolKHocrrI IIo pacIxI4peHI4Iot4 eHHo uHHoBa\LroH brxyo*n.1::l::::IIecTByIoquX pbIHKoB [poAyKToB LI ycJIyI' I4X accopTuMeHTa'ypoBHf, AOXOAHOCTI4 Cy6renoeII Tpe6uTenbcKoro cllpoca, IIOBbIIIIeHUIOI4X punounOfi AOJII4' CnOcO6crByeT pa3BI'ITI4IO14 nonaquonnofi AeqTelbHocTI'I,II qeccoB B HHreJIJIeKTyanbHofi cQepe I4 rlp'rno6alruofio.4Uaro, HecMoTpr Ha I,IHHOBaIIUOHHyIO COCTaBJItTo[IYrcI4 TIaCTHOTO 6ragnega HeOMr4KI4, OTerIecTBeHHbIe CeKTOpbI IoCyAapCTBeHHOTOBHeApeHI4I4 IlHHoBaqnfi' 3roBJrf,IoT.[OlNnofr cTeIIeHI4 3anHTepecoBaHHocTI{ BoynpaBneHl4-f, cycJroBneHo HI43KI4M ypoBHeM cyIqecTByIoqVX TeXHoJIorI4frqaCTbIO yHacJIeAOBaHHbIX eule I43 (coBeTgKoro>6OpOrra I.{HCTpyMSHTOB, 6OnuUefiCrpyrrypofi clpoca Ha UHHOBaIII4LI B s'tpaHe'Ha COBpeMeHHOMHr,rKaroT,-rroro, nees$eru{BHofi.yTcTBUeM cr4cTeMHOrO LIHBeCTLIpOBaHUf, B I{HTeJIJIeKTyalrHrrfi KafII',ITaJI',,ryraru"eM oaKTOpa Heo[peAeneHHocTII B O6lacrz I4HHOBaUHZ.peureHl4fiB erou ,*"r.n.

pa:pa6brr<a eQQeru.IBHbIX LlHcrpyMeHroB npvrHrrvfl'perrarb AaHHbIOCCOM B o6lacrz I4HHoBaIIIlfi rIo3BoJIlIT rrocTyrIaTeJIbHOclrcreMy Poccnu,, orBer{arcqyrcLIHHoBaIII{oHHYIoEMbIV$opuraponarrrlepc[eKTrIBaM pa3RvrTlls"lloBbIM TpeHAaM I4AOCTOBepHocrblr(rlnxrr1\rno rt'vyrYrnHv.rll-opslJn'ra rrocBtuleHaQopvtutpoBaHuroflasna I4roPenu'raAaneruua llaBJIa|.{UCCepfaqUf /{al€fUUaB cSeperpolleAypKrLrBHoro coBpeMeHHoro I4HcrpyMeHrapas' oIIeHoqHbIXoqIIJIII(HI4OKP).

BHo-rrocJreAoBareJrbcKlrx pr orrbrTHo-KOHCTpyKropcKI,IX pa6orcraBJreHHofi aBropoM pa6ore llpeAnoxeH MeroAl{qecKl4fi uHcTpyMeHTapvit'oqHbrx rporleAyt B c6epe HI{OKP, pa:pa6orannrrft Ha nesael4cllNlofrpMe KoHTpoJIJILIHfa IIpI4MeHI'ITeJIbHO K IIpOMbIIIneHHbIM v HaTIHOACTBeHHbIM IIp eArlprrflTuflM.flolyvennsre [aneruurrvr n.Vl. pe3ynbTaTbl tB[{IoTcqcJIeAcTBLIeMHa I{CTIOJIb3OBaHVLToJTHeHHOfO CT4CTeMHOfO I4CCneAOBaIgir4fl., 6a:rapytotuefocflKoro crreKTpa TeopeTl4qecKoro MaTepl{ana. HayruO-MeTOAI4qecKLIe rIoJIoXeHpItCI4CT9M6IparOTCf, HA CTaT1ICTI4T{SCK e AaHHbIe' IIeJIeBOfi IIOAXOA' AOCTUIXSHI'Iq3Kc[epTHbIeTpoJrJrLrHIa, IIoJIoxeHus Teopull KPI, TeopLIrc cTefiKxonAepoB'NbI OIIEHOK, METOAOJIOIIIrc HEIIETKTIX MHOXCCTB.npoBeAeHHoIo I4cCneAoBaHI4fl,{OcronepHocTb LI O6ocHoBaHHocTb pe3yJIbTaToBO Ae'flTeIbHOCTkIBep)r6AaeTctr vrx Aflpo|AI1;,4ei1 C I4cnoJIb3oBaHueM AaHHbIxI1onojlox(eHLIqtrpvrfltvit.

HzxeropoAcKofi o6lacru. c$opvryll4poBaHHble Ha)rqHblenpaCcMaTpIIBaeMofi TeMeBoAbI HaIIIJII4 orpaxeHrae B c6opHl4Kax rly6nuKalll4ir ilo14qro raK}r( e rroATBepxAaer I4X o6OCHOBaHHOCTb.n epu oAI4tI e C KO fi rI e q arl{,LIAAHVTflX66flo reue AuccepTarlr4oHHofi pa6oTbl aBTOpoM oly6[r4KoBaHbl 1 rvronorpa$ut"t..r. 14 n xypHuulax, peKoMeHAOBaHHbIX BAK P@.

o6IIIdHayrrHbrx pa6or,u"14,06ny6nrar a\ufi, cocraBnf, eT 27,1g fr.Jr., JII4IIHbIII BKnaA aBTOpa cocTaBJIqeTocHosHrtMr4 [roJrox{eHr4tMll, COAep)I(arqI4MI,I HOBLI3Hy I4 IIeHHOCTb, tBr.f,roTcq:1) npeAnox(eH IleneBofi IIoAXoA K ynpaBneHl4lo HI4OKP rpLI IIoAAepx{Keit u (c.25).

Anropo^a npoBoAl4rcs o6ocHoeaHl4e Bbl6opa AaHHorooAa, efo rpel4MytrlecrBa v HeAocrarKvr (c.26-27).2) npe4noxeHa Knacczor{Karlus MeroAoB aHaJrv3a u OIIeHK?I LIHHOBaIIUOHHOII:4rr ( c. 3 7 ) . Anroporvr rrpoBeAe Ha Kn ac cr4 0 vKar\vrfl. p iBpo3HeHHbIX M eroAoB alluru3aoUeHKlI tIHHoBaIII4oHHofi cpeAbl, rpy[ruIpyt ux rro olpeAeneHHoMy HafopypueB Ha ocHoBe E,III4HOfO rIoAXOAa, rrpeAcraBJleHbI OTJII,IqAIOUIUEwcT1rKvr MeTo.IIoB aHaJrr43a I4 oqeHKpI LIHHoBaIILIoHHofi cpeAbl, cQepa zxr..rMeHeHus(*7-aQ.3) paspa6oraHa MoAerIb npoBeAeHll{ oIIeHoqHbIX rpolleAyp B cQepe HI{OKP14 B3auMo.IIeitcrs;,zrl- MeHeAXMeHra u KoHrponnuHra (c.57).

llpu rpoBeAeHI4I'IeHoqHbrx rporleAyp B coepe HI,IOKP aBrop BbrAenter rpl4 ypoBHt: crparefvfl".b, rIpoeKT, rIpeABapI{TeJIbHO [poBoAI{TCt OIIeHKa I{HHOBaIII4OHHO|OHeHrII4ana flpeAnpl,lsTl4{, qTo [o3BorseT ocyqecrBr4Tb OIIeHOTIHbIe llpolleAypblbKo BHyrpz cseprr HI4OKP, Ho r4 r4HHoBaIIVoHHofi cpeAbl cy6beKra 6ugneca nrr,r. Kporvre rofo, ilpeAnoxenlP.as. MoAenb Aaer Bo3MoXHOCTb BbrAeJrtrb ueneBbleTypbr, rrpoBoAr4Tr Sopuanr,r3arlurc qenefi no ycraHoBJIeHHbIM rpynnaM IIeJTeBbIXKa3areJreft, oy"*qrroH€urbHbre KoMrIereHIIuu MeHeAxMeHTa 14 KoHTponnI4Hra{OKP, UenI4 ApyrI{X 3aI,IHTepecoBaHHbIX cropoH.

Ha ocHoBe llpeAnoxeHHoftroIIeHoqHbIx rpolleAyp B cQepeaBropoM pa3pa6oraH anIopI4TM IlpoBe ;rIHI4I'[poBeAeHI{to6ocnosaH Ha6oP TIeJIeBbIX rloKa3arenefiHbrx npoqeAyp B coepe HI{OKP (c'61-63)' '{aHnvro-:1]:Y:::ffiH}Tro rpyrnaM' vpoBHr*'r e csepe HI4oKP'orreHor{H'rx rporreAvp. rlperlro)KeHHbrfi ua6opI TN \'AITIILTI\'IA[peAnoxeHHbIMLIrelefi no3BOJI'eT ycTaHOBllTb B3aI{MOCB{3I4 Me)IqyonpeAenllrb cTefleHbrleleft,e cQepe HI,IOKP Ha ocHOBe QOpvranvl3aIlv|r4cropoHbl Ha onpeAeneHHoM"r"r"rlenefr z rpe6ona.Fi]ns.

raN4ofi KoHKpeTHofi4)/tnpeArloxeHIlPsAJr\',^vrrLrffii'J#;;;:'#J'#;;.-;;ener#:;:"Tiffi#il;; ;;;;;,XeHr4{BHC I,l9TATIC.Ha cTal.vn paccMoTpeHI4fl'5) parpa6oraH rrpoqecc or6opa rpoeKroB HI4OKP\TTq IJEITETI{IT)(HerrerKllxa"nn'finpoqecc ocHoBaH Ha LrcrroJrb3oBaHr{H MeroAa"*^tr{.15-iil14 MeroAa peruaroulrx MarpLIuox{ecrBf'C'flocnenoea'HecouneHHbIMMyuIecTBoMIIpeAJIoxeHHoIo[poqeccaflBqIg'eTcg'BbIAeJIeH?IegTaIIasKcnpeccpaIII4OH€UIbHO IICIIOJIb3OBaTb OIpaHurIeHHbIe[I3A UOIIeHKI4, xOrOprtfi IO3BOIqeTxoAe paspa6orrra ilpoqecca or6opa rpoeKroBp.",rpoeKroB)KP HafilOfp. BID'|r.lr;2I{1-I.InpeAnoxeHbl BapLIaHTbIcTaAuI4 paccMoTp e1vfl, 3aflBKI4 aBTopoMO6Opounofo 3aKa3a LIaHvrs.on" ,rpo.nro" Hl{oKP IocyAapcrBeHHOrOuLlOHr4poB)KAaHCKO|O Ha3HaqeHuq.o 3aKOHTIeHHOCTI4Ananug cTpyKTypbl pa6otH cBLIAeTeJIbCTByeT147 cTpaHI4II 11 COSTSIIT LI3 BBeAeHvIs''neAoBaHI{r, o6lel,r roropoft coCTaBJIfletJII4TepaTypH' ,{uccepralllloHHa{x rJraB, o6'Iux BbrBoAoB u 3aKJrroq el:afl.

u cnucKaBKrrrcrlaerece6fl' 42m6twlvTpI4cyHKoB'Ce6s' o6rqyro xapaKrepl4crl4Kynr rrrn^rtrrr-rA Ha14OOJIcAUItIt0OJIcaoBOCHOBHbIe noJloxeHl',Iq [poBeAeHHOfOrrvreBbIBoAbI v crrllcoK rtylrrurcaguit rro reMe Ar4cc[p.o.tu"nennrrfi anropeQepar BKnIOqaeT BTbI,r.ty,rrlafl'p"E"putu coorBercrByer Alrcceprallul4 I4 pacKpblBaercooTBeTcTByroTLOo"u""". O6tena, coAepxaHvre 14 oQoplaneHple aBTopeQeparaoBaHI,IrM BAK PO.3aueqanus no Aucceprauzu6H nO4pO6nee 3aTpoHyrr npo6neMbl HLI3KO|O ypoBHsyIIpaBreHI4q csepofi HI4OKP (c'24)'Marlr3auur4 Lr rrpofpaMMHofo o6ecne.{eHllf,TaKXepaccMoTpeTbcoBpeMeHHbIe[polpaMMHblenpoAyKTbI'IIo3BoJI,gIoquenpoqeAyp n c$epe HI4OKP'oBbrcr4rb eSQegnnHocrb IIpoBeAeHI4t oIIeHoqHbIXT.K. II3BeCTHO' r{To BHeApeHI4epeAcTaBr4Tb I4X BO3MOXHOCTI4 14 QyuxquoHal'rexHolorufi s 6ugHec-rpoqeccbl yIIpaBJIeHI4s HI4OKP IIOBbIIIIaeT1.ArropycJreAoBanoporpaMMHbrxBeH6 r4X p e3ynbTaTuBHoctlt, o6lelctI4BHOCTLILI CTaHAap T n3at\vIu'pa3AeneHl4eocHoBaHr4I4 KaKLIX KpllTepueB IIpoBeAeHoLI KoHrpoJIJII4HroM HI4OKPHKqI4oH€InbHbIx KoMreTeHrlufi uexAy MeHeAlI(MeHroMB csepe Hl{oKPMoAeJrLl rpoBeAeHrfl oIIeHoqHbIX rpolleAyp--,.^,,-o-,r'orrpeAnox(enHofirrvvArrvrF2.

He rIoHtTHo, Ha'c.Si). ,IlaHuoeonDe.treJ]eHuto NMgcra cnyx6blnyer onpeAeJleHl'ltocnoco6c RVery lorrHeHlle enocoScrr1ra HI4OKP:AT(c.SopnruPoBaHl,IroB o6rqefiaopraHl,I3aqraoHuofi crpyKrype flpeArlpl4f,Tllfl'KPI'ITePI4eBAnroPoru He YKa3aHbI5a\uu rpoqecca or6oPa uPoI4cro, c.109). Haluque coBoKyrlHocrl4neo6xo4nuofi Anfl ilpoBeAeHLIt aHalILI3a vF{aJ{vrb rrepeqeHb orqerHocrrr,3.;;;p".*rouHl{oKPHa ocHoBe rlpeAnoxeHHoro rlpouecca'4,flpu'pou*"""anpo6aqzuaBTopoMBHeAocTaTo.IHoficTeIIeHI4crarvvla*urv3a vr oqe*i.'ios,c'r25).nfficnoco6crBoB€LiII4[poeKroB'Hr,rf, pecypcoB rlpoqecca or6opa AaHHbIxVl He cHux(aloT ypoBeHb3aMeqa Hufl. flBIIflIOTCS He3HarII{TeJIbHbIMI{YxasaHHrreHHOCTpI npeAcraBrleHHoroIIcoJIeAOBAIlVTfl 'flp aruqecraq gHa'{uNlocrrilpoBeAeHl4ffpaspa6orannufi aBropoM MeToAI4r{ecrufi I4HcTpyMeutapuit'orrHo yHuBepcarrbHbrM I4rrHbrx rpoqeAyp ,s.pe HI4oKp flBrrflercs' Aocra-rnrrrreecr)R"vro4enefi, airropr4rMoB' rlpoqeccoB'pa6ouuxBrrAeB;; ffi"'t"""1-Jn"3oBaHrreJ'x: pocraE 4sJr'1^'Yvvre AocroBep"ot]1_ 1 :6i:i:1-::,::1,"^:l1l-1-Y-i:y::icrpyrurafr BCTpyKI-U4l'lr2 nrrrr4qecKoI4.alJlaJrurTPlqecKot4'oBaHVr''' eAIAnOfi MeTOAI4rIecrofi'paBIeHqecKr4X peurenrafi, QopN,rup14CIIOJIb3OBaIIVIIpaIII4OHaJIbHOIOunarsoprnr KOHTpOnnvIHra)$oprr,lauuoHsofrrerrrrocrefr BI4I{eHHbIXpecypcoB,cHLlXeil:,1 tflpI4cKoB]l4HeonpeAejleHHocTezBHoBaIII4oHnofi cPe4e 6usHeca'Or,4elrUUe TeopeTl4qeCKueI4 npaKTI4rIeCKI4epe3ynbTaTbl I4CCneAOBAHvIfl' MOIyTbITbraK}I(€lIcfIoJIb3oBaHbIByue6rrux[poqeccaxHa3KoHoMI4tIecKI4xIdzauesetuit', UMeIOT nepcIIeKTUBy3xH'rqecKlrx sarynrrerax BbICIULIX yve6HuxA AK VT3YTIEHI4E IO3BOJII4TBVITVTfl'B PAMKAXLICCJIE.qONAHUfi,AAITHEftTUI4X HAYIIHbIXrultpllTblrn$opvrallfioHHoeIroJIeI'IHHoBaIII4osuoftcpeAbl'3arffo'{eHlaecAeJIaTb BbIBOA O TOM'flpe4cranJreHHoe aBTOpOM UCCneAoBaHvre fIo3BOJI{eTllasra l4ropenuua Ha reMy: <<Pa:pa6offiaAuccepTaqr4oHHar pa6ora [aneruua^*.o^orporleAyp B c0epe:ffi;#J*J,T'"""rrow .'rapvn rpoBeAeHr4q orleHoqHbrxpa6oo>K 3aIIII4Te HaayrrHo-uccneAoBaTeJrbcKlrx v ofIbITHO-KOHCTpyKTopcKLIXTTLI{|.f (:TLTgKOHOMI',IqecKnx HayK IIO CneqI{€uIbHocTLI^narlrtqKaHAI4AaTacTerreHl4y.reuoficucKaHlreg.00.05 <<Sronouura 14 ynpaBneHl{e apoAHbIM xogqficrsoNl (rvreue'4xvrenr)>>TeMy' f,BJIf,eTCq 3aKOHtIeHHbIM HayrIHbIMbIfroJIHeHa Ha AOCTaTotIHo aKTyanbHyIOfI.