Отзыв_Офф.Опп.Литвинюк (Механизм формирования набора компетентностей управленческих кадров для предприятий электроэнергетики)

or3brB ooI4rII4AJrbHOrO OIIOHEHTAHa ArrcceprauroHHyr0A6parvronofi ErenrrpaoorylOprennu<<Mexanur*r QoprvrnpoBaHrrn na6opa KoMrrerenrnocrefi yrpaBJreHqecKI{xKaApoB AJrfl r peAnpnrrn fi sJleKTpogHeprerl{Ku>)CueqzalbHocrb 08.00-05 - YnpanneHrre oKoHoMrlqecKr4Mlr cI4creMaMLI, [pt4HIILIIrbI,Sopvru u MeroAbr ero ocyqecrBJreHurr. 1I.10.19.

Ka4pu yrpaBneHlzrl: ponb I4 Mecro BcLrcreMe yrrpaBneHzr. @opvu4poBaHlre, rroAroroBKa r{ pa3Blrrr4e KaApoB yrIpaBneHLIt.Vnpannenlre Kapbepoit u upo$eccuoHulrrbHo-AoJrxrHocrHbrM rrpoABLIx{eHLIeM yrlpaBreHqecKr4x KaApoB. Mero4u crkrMyJrr4poBaHlre MeHeAlKepoB Bblcrxero 3BeHa)IIa orsrrB1.

,{uccepraqur o6qzurrpeAcraBJreHbr :o6rdvrorr,r 143 crpaHlrrlbr, cocrorrqafl.kr3 BBeAeHuq, crII4cKaTepMuHoB r4 onpeAeteuuit, Tpex rJraB, BbrBoAoB r{ 3aKrroqeuuir,lu6r'uorpaQuue-cKoro crrrrcKa Lrclonb3oeaHHofi nureparypbr, BKJrroqaroulero 116 nazvrenonauufi,araKxe 19 pncynKoB r{ 7 ra6rrw\.2. AnropeSepar,BKoropoM AaHa o6qaq xapaKTepr4crr4Kapa6orrr, KparKo rr3JroxeHoocHoBHoe coAep)KaHurecorvnpvrBeAeHbr ocHoBHbre pe3ynbrarbr r4ccJre4oBaHnfl,.Cnu-ony6nr4KoBaHHrrx pa6or corrcKareJu rro reMe ALrcceprarlrlr4 BKJIIoqaer 19HALIMEHOBAIIIdVI.3. CraHzpoBaHHbIe ouy6nzroBaHHrre pa6oru coucKareJrr.4. Ha ocHoBaHrrrr [peAcraBJreHHbrx Marepr{€uoB Mox(Ho orMerr4Tb cneAyrcIqee.Arcrya.nuHocrb reMbr pa6oruArcryamnocrr pa6omr o6ycJroBJreHa neo6xo,qzMocrbrorroBbrrrreHLrf, pe3ynbra-TLIBHocrr4 TpyAoycrpoficrea BbrrrlicKHrlKoB rocyAapcrBeHHbrx By3oB no npoQzJIIo rro-ny-reHHoro LrMLr o6pasonaHus.?raupo6rerunafl, cvryarlrrr Bo3Hr4KJra B pe3ynbrareHapyureHus, csssefi, Me)KAy npeAnpr4rrvrflMvr npoMbrr[neHHocrpr lr cr{creMoft errcrueroo6pa:onanzx, cQopMlrpoBaHHbrxB rrepr4oAnranoeofioKoHoMLrKrz.Hoerre gKoHoMrtqecKlre ycnoBrrr B KoHTeKcre crpeMr4TeJrbHo pasnepruBaloqe-rocr HafrHo-TexHrzrrecKoro rrporpeccane4TflBJrrror xdcmze rpe6onauvs.

K a4an-TrrBHocrz crpyKTypbr rroAroroBKLr Bocrpe6oBaHHbrx pbrHKoM TpyAa KaApoB. Heo6xoALrMbr r,rHcrpyMeHTbr r4 MexaHr{3Mbr corJracoBaHpr{rerylqefi u 6y4yIqefi uorpe6Hocrl4sHepfeTurrecKhx rrpeAnpr4rrTvrvrB KaApax c Bo3MoxrHocTrMLI By3a HaAeJIflTb cBoLIX BbIrrycKHr{Kos Heo6xoALrMbrM na6oporvr KoMrrereHrnocrefi.SopvrnpoBurbu rro,qAepxrvrBarb ycrofivunbreMbrrrrJreHHocTbro LI By3aMr4KaHarrrrB eroficBfl3v I4Meer cMbIcJIo6patroit csssu Mex{Ay rpo-Am TpaHcnflrJkrvr nyqlllux npaKTLrK npI,IKJIaAHoro ynpaBne-HIlg Bo Bcex Bvrnax gKoHoMr4rre crofi AetrenbHocrl4.Bnra4y oqeBr4AHofi nuepruocrr4 pa3BurLrs, crpyKTypbl Bblclrero o6pa^:oBaHlltn e o6xoAzMa peKcrpyKrypr43 arlvs r oAxo4arQoprrar4poBaHuro na6 opoa KoMrIereH \uir.

uopraHlr3ar\uv yre6uoro npoqecca, oplreHTr4poBaHHoro Ha rroAroroBKy ynpaBneHqe-cKlrx KaApoB, cnoco6nrrx peruarb ALrHaMuqHo pa3BltBarorlrrecfl. ga4a'uv opraHLI3aIII4I4B3alrMoornoruenufiBycnoBLtrx BbrcoKoKoHKypeHrsofi pbrHoqHofi cpe4rr. Mex4y revrHayqHhre r43brcKaHlrs s o6racrr4 clrHxpoHlr3arlr4r4 Bo3Mox(Hocrefi Bysakruorpe6nocrefiBbIcoKorexHorofHrIHbIX KoMrlauuit AocraroqHo peAKLI LI, KaK IIpaBLrJro, He Hoc.f,T cLIcTeMaTnqecKoro xapaKTepa.B curyBbrrrrer43Jrox{eHHoro pa6ora A6parr,roaofiE.IO., uocnxrqdnH€ul pelueHl4roooo3HarIeHHbIX IIp ooJIeM, flBlrfler c fl aKTy€rnbHoLI.HayuHan HoB[3Ha pe3yJrbraroB ArrcceprarlrroHHofi pa6oruflo uarueuy MHeHuTro,BAr4cceprarlr4oHHofi pa6ore LrMeK)Tc.[ cneAyroqze BbIBoAbII{ IroJIo)KeHLIt LIMercrrILre gneMeHTbr nay.rHofi HoBI{3HII.l.flpe4roxeH MeroA rrocrpoeHlrr MoAenrlpbrHKa rpyAa BbInycKHLIKoB, ocHo-BaHHbTLI HA AHaJrVrce COBOKyTIHOCTIT CpTCTeMHbIX MOAener4 9HepTOKOMTIaHLILIrr conprxEnnrrx c HkrMz opraHlr3arlufi.

3Q$eKTLrBHocrb AaHHoro MeroAao6ycnoueHa oflopofi, rta npr4Hrlzflbr y[paBJreHprfl KaqecrBoM corJlacHo MCI4CO 9001, nrrpa6oraHHbre ro pe3ynbraryaHaJrr43aryrrrrrprx Mt4poBbIX rlpaK-TUK MeHeAX(MeHTa.2. AeropoM pa3pa6oran €Lrrropr4rM QopvrzpoBaHr4fl na6opon Heo6xoAzIuuxJKOMIIeTeHr\krVrVr [pOBeAeHUr{ OrIeHKI{ KarIeCTBa UX OCBOeIJVIfl, BbIIryCKHI4KaMLlrro pe3ynbraraM o6yuenux, ocHoBannrrfi Ha BhrcrpavrBanvrv nsazuo4eficrBurfl, By3ac qeneBbrM cerMeHTorvr pa6oro4arerefi c uc[oJrb3oBaHLIeM npo-rleccHoro noAXoAaKMoAenapoBaHuro roAo6Horo poAa AetreJrbHocrrl.3ror2rroAXoA, npeAllonafaloulufi oAHo3HarIHoe onpeAeneHl4e I4 AoKyMeHTLIpOBa-Hrle rpe6yeMbrx pe3ynbraroB, crroco6crnyer rroBbIIrreHI4Io pe3yJIbrarI,IBHocrr4 TpyAoycrpoficrBa BbrrrycKHrrKoB no npo$ranrc nonyqeHHoro o6pasona-Ill4fl.3.

Paspa6oraHopraHr43arlzonnrrfi MexaHr43M r4HTerpa[ruofi oIIeHKI4 Kar{ecrBaBbrrrycKHr'rKoB, 6asupyrorquitcs. ua yudre MHeHI4t Bcex 3al4HTepecoBaHHbrxcropoH: pa6oro4arerrs, BbrrrycKHrrKa r4 Bbrclrero y.re6noro3aBeAeHr4fl. By3a.[ocronepHocrb HayqHbrx pe3yJrbraroB rr o6ocHosaHHocrb HayrrHblx uo.noxtennfi,BbrBoAoB r{ peKoMeH4aqu fi , coAep}Kalrl[xcq B Al{ccepralll{HCoucrareneM r43yqeHbrHkrfl. kr TeopeTr4qecKr4eI,I Kpl4TrrqecKr4 npoaHanv3r4poBaHbl Iz3BecrHhleAocrllxe-rroJrox{eH[fl ilpyrux aBTopoB no BorrpocaM Teopvl4 ynpaBne}jr4fl.r4 crparerr4qecKoro pa3Bvrrr4s, KoMrraHl4it, pazr,urr4s, cor1narrbHo-gKoHoMlzqecKl4x cu-creM pa3nr{rrHoro ypoBHq [ocpeAcrBoM r4HHoBarlnouuofi AerrenbHocrll, paspa6oxzB OoJIaCTI{uoIOA|OTOBKI{ yIIpaBIeHTIeCKVX KaApOB B SHepfeTVtKe)np o6neM arr4 Ke crp are ruqe cKoro yrrpATaKme UCCneAoBa}Ikrfl.aBJre H r4fl y H:zBep c r4TeroM.[ocronepHocrb Haf{Hbrx pe3ynbraroe u o6ocHoBaHHocrb Hayr{Hbrx rroJloxtettuit,BbrBoAoB r4 peKoMes4a\uit noATBepx{Aaerae, TeM, rrro ouu 6asnpylorcs Ha ocHoBHbIXrloJloxeHr4.f,x oKoHoMlrqecKoit reopuu, o6lerrzBHbrx gKoHoMzqecKrlx 3aKoHax pa3Bvr-ru-s o6qecrBa, penpe3eHTarr4BHoM o6l6lae un$oprr,raqlroHHoro MaccvrBa.

B pa6oreAlaccepraHT rpaMorHo r4cnoJr*yer Ar{aneKTl4vecxufi, crlcreMHbrit, auasturr,r.{ecrczfrN4e-TOAbr LTCCIeAOB aHLIfl..flparcruvecKaq rleHHocrb u peaJru3arlrlq noJryqeHHbrx pe3yJrbraroBflpamzvecKar 3Haqr4MocrbTn3arluvSarrop on,o rrp eAen-fl roHoro By3a. OHz vroryr6urrr4ccneAoBala:zfl 3aKnroqaercf, B yrorrHeHl4l4 I,I KoHKpe-rqzxnocrpe6 oB aHHocrbBbrrrycKHr4Ka ro cyAap crBeH-r4crroJrb3oBaHbr npoQunrHblMr4 MI4HIlcrepcrBaMIi rr Be-AoMcrBaMu, a raKxe aAMzHr4crpaqzefi By3oB KaK ocHoBa pa^:pa6orKrr crpareruit,,rrrraHOB LrilporpaMM pa3Br4TldflCr,rCTeMbrBbrollrero oopa3oBaHl4t.flpe4loxoe^nafl, MoAenb cerMeHTr{poBaur4fl, pbIHKa rpyAa BbIrrycKHLIKoB,HapaBHe c rrpeAJraraeMbrM aBTopoM rroAXoAoM r QopuupoBaHl{ro Habopon ueo6xo4uMbrx KoMnerenqufi, MoryT 6urr trc[oJrb3oBaHbl npl4 Bblpa6orre HoBbIX naupauenufiyue6urxrroAroroBKr.r clequaJrr4croB, pa:pa6orre pa6oul4x rlporpaMM ALIcqvIrrIrvIH,rrJraHoBrloAroroBrIa upoSzJIbHbIX clequalucroB T T.A.OpraHzsaqzonnrrfi MexaHu3M r4HTerpanrnofr oIIeHKI4 KaqecrBa BbInycKHt4KoBMo)Ker6urr npuueudn Anfl, peanurca\vrv o6paruofiaBfl3vr Mex{Aypa6oro4arelrflv'vrvrBy3oM c rleJrbro coBeprueHcrBoBaHr4-a yue6Horo [poqeo ca, HailpaBJleHHoro Ha Sopvra-poBaHr4e BbrcoKoKBanz@uqrapoBaHHbrx cnellzanl4croBc ua6opauzrovtuereHqlafi,nocrpe6oBaHHhrx B petrnbHoM ceKTope gKoHoMur<u.

PealLrcarJLrr coBoKyrlHocrlr nPeA-noxenzfi Ar4ccepraHTa Mox{er perxLrrb npo6rel,rrrpaccI4HXpoHI43aIILII4norpe6nocrefipa6oro4arenefi n uayrodMKoM ceKTope oKoHoMI,IKLl I4 Bo3Moxnocrefi By3oB noAroTOBKLT BOCTpe0OBaHHbTX KaApOB.3apreqanus rto pa6ore1. Paccrrl urpuBafl e1-ft rJraBe Aprcceprar1la:apa3nrqHble IIapaAV rMu o6pa:o-BaHvrs, s AanrHefiIIIeM aBTop ue O6palqaeTc-f, K KoHIIen\uV [ucTaHIILToH-Horo o6yvenur KaK oAHoroI43cnoco6os B3aI4MoBbIroAHoro n:auuo,4efi-crBur By3a 14 npeArlpl{trufi, peastbHoro ceKTopaBpeMrB ro xeoKoHoMI{KI,I.y eHeproKovruanufi 3aqacryro cyqecrByer o6lerrvrBlnafl. neo6xo-ArrMocrb rocro.flHHoro rroBbllrreHut rnalr,rSzra\Lrkr cBoLIX corpyAHIrKoB,Korop€u Mo)Ker 6 urr yAoBnerBopeHa Auar a:ar\proHHoro o6yu eHzx.2.O6ocnosbrBar so 2-ir rJraBe Alrcceprarlzu neo6xoAl{Mocrb H€uIurII4rI MoAenefiAef,TenbHocrl4 sHepleTldqe cKLIX opfaHI43a\uitAtts.

S opvrnpoyre6nrrx [porpaMM, aBTop He no-f,cH{er, KaKoBbI KpllTepvvrrpr.recrofi rleHHocrt4, KaKoB MexaHr43MBaHuflr4x rrparMa-r4x corJracoBaHvrs.I4 aKTyzlnn3ar\Lrpr,KaK rlacTo I4 KeM UMeHHO OHLI AOJIIKHbI rIepeCMaTpUBaTbC{.3. lloAnrarvrasrarofi eaxHrrfi Borrpoc, KaKrlcl4xoJlorl4qecKatrrpeApac[oJlo)I(eHHocTb K pa3nr4qHblM Br,rAaM Aet{TenbHocTLIvouncbrBaflHa6op neo6xo4uMbrx rrcuxororLrqecKlrx KaqecrB BbInycKHI,Irca $t.2.6),aBTop ne Aadr KoHKperHbrx rrpeAJroxenufi, KaK IlMeHHosrl{KatlecrBaAoJrxHbr SopvlapoBarbc-s B paMKax o6yueunx B By3e.,{ocrouncrBa pa6oruOcnonnuM Aocror4HcrBoM ArrcceprarJkrvr flBnflerc{ To, tITo, [peAJIo)KeHHbIft ueToAlrrrecKuit uycrpyMeHTapr4fi npe4craBJrrer co6ofi noerrfi MexaHLr3M I4HTerpaIILII4qeneft By3av npeArrplTruafi eneprerr,rqecKofi orpacnu, HarrpaBJrennrrfi Ha rIoBbIIueHzepe3ynbrarr4BHocrr,r ra eQQeru,rBHocrLr pa3Bprrvrfl, qeroBeqecKoro Kanuralla B paMKaxrocyAapcreeHuofi clrcreMbr Bbrcruero o6pasonaHzq.

OH opr,reHTlrpoBaHHa yAoBJIerBo-peamnofi rorpe6uocrrz 3HeproKoMrraHkrfi s roNrnereHTHbIX KaApax.peHrzellpegnoxennrrfi noAXoA r SopivrzpoBaHlrro KoMrrereHTHocrHbIX lro4elefi cnoco6crnyer rrepeopvreHTar\vv aAMr4Hr4crpar\vLr By3oB or Synrqr4oHzlrrbHofi r npoqeccttofi cucreMe yrrpaBlrelrrvrfl, rrro, rro HarrreMy MHeHLrIo, croco6uo cyqecrBeHHoIToBJILI-f,Tb Ha KoHKypeHrocnoco6Hocrb clrcreMbr Bbrcrrrero o6pasonanz.s Poccuficrcofi (DeAeparlr4r4.flpurvreHeHrre rroJryrreHHbrx pe3yJrbraroBflp arruvecKlre pe3ynbrarbrAr{cceprarlr4oHHoro prccJre 4oBanvrs npprMeH{JrLIc bBpa:uofi crerreHr{:onpLr pa3pa6orrce peKoMeHAa\uit no recrlrpoBaHlrro suauuit, yvrenufiKaHAr4AaroB Ha riaranrHrre pa6ouue Mecra eO NPU NOAOOPE COTPYAHI4KOB14HaBbrKoB|IAO <Znrep PAO>;C HEOOXOAI4MbIMLI KOMIIETEHIII{flMI414 KOMTIETEHT-Hocr;rMr4, a raK)r(e AJU{ [epuoAr4qecKo arrecrarlr4u rrepcoHa-rra OOO <<Macca>>;oIIpu pa3pa6orre yre6urx rrJraHoB r4 ocHoBHrrx upoQecclroHarlbHrrx o6pa":onareJIbHbIX rpofpaMM Bbrcrrero o6pasonaHlrr BOfBOy BO (HI4y (M3I4).PercoprenAarlrllr no ncrroJrb3oBau[ro pe3yJrbraronpa6oruZcnonrsoBaHr4e pa^:pa6oraHHbrx aBropoM peKoMeHAa:quit, MeroAr4K14aJIropI,IT-MoB Aaer Bo3Mox(Hocrb rroBbrclrrb pe3ynbrarlrBHocrb 14 eQQerrznHocrb rpyao-ycrpoficrBa BbrrrycKHr.rKoB By3oB, rroBbrrrrar reM caMbrvr eQ$eru.rBHocrb pacxoAoBanuq 6loAxerHbrx cpeAcrB vt uur,ectutluitp€r3Br{Tr{ecrlcreMbr Bbrclrlero o6pa:oeannrP@.