Отзыв_2_оппонента (Механизм формирования набора компетентностей управленческих кадров для предприятий электроэнергетики)

B 4Iaccepralll4oHHbrfi coeerA212.141.21 ua 6ase O|EOY BO<<Mocr<oscnufi ro cyAapcrseHHrrfi rexHruecKllfiyHrrBepcl4rer rIMeHIa H.3. Eayvraua>rro aApecy: 105005, r. Mocr<sa,2-t Eayvaucr<at'ytr., 9.7.OT3bIBOOUUI4AJIbHOI O OTIfTOHEHTAHa Ar{cceprarlrroHHyro p a6ory A6panroeofi Eneurr lOprenurtHa reMy <MexaHustr QopnrrapoBaHrrt na6opa KoMrrereHruocrefiyrrpaBneHqecKux KaApoB Anq [peArrputtuit 3neKTpooHeprerl4Kz)), rpeAcraereHHofiHa col4cKaHr,re yr{eHofi creneHV KaHg:r,.p.ara 3KoHoMI4r{ecKI4x HayK rlo cnequaJlbHocrl4<3r<onoMuKa rr ynpaBneHr4e HapoAHblrr4 xosqfrcrBoM)) (10. MeHe4xueHr)08.00.05-Ha orstrn [peAcraBJIeHLI:-Arrcceprar\r4fl o6rerraona 143 crpaHI4IIbI, cocrotulaq r{3 BBeAeHvrs, crrr4cKaTepMr{HoB v onpe4eleHrafr, Tpex rJIaB, 3aKrroqeHl4q, crrl4cKa nr{Teparypbl,BKJrroqaroxrero I 16 narzvreHosaHl4fi, 19 pvrcyHKoB u 7 ra6tutl;- aBTopeSepar, B KoropoM AaHa o6ula-s xapaKrepverr4Ka pa6orrr, KparKor43JrOlKeHO O CHOBHO e COAepXaH Ve V \pr4BeAeHbI o cHo BHbIe p e3ynbraTbl.Cnucox ony6luroBaHHbrx pa6or cor4cKarer-s ilo reMe Al4ccepralll4rr BKnroqaer19 nazrr,reuonauuit, B ToM r{r4cre 5 ny6nzxa\uit B }rypHaJIaX, peKOMeHAOBaHHbIXBAK Poccun.Pesylrrarbr u3yr{eHVA rrpeAcraBJreHHbIX AoKyMeHToB rrpeAcraBJleHbl HI4xe.Pazsu1ye 3Heprerr,rqecKoro KoMrrJreKca Poccuficr<ofr (De4epaqvttr, B r{acrHocrl4oneKTpo3Heprerfirrecr<ofi orpacJrrl, flBIrflercs, ocuoeofi crparefuqecr<ofi 6esonacHocrl4crpaHbl, orHocrrrcr K rrr,rcny KJrroqeBbrx $arropoB BblcoKorexHoJlorrrrlHoro pa3BLrrufl'oKoHoMI4Ku Poccrau.Peattuu coBpeMeHHoro Mrrpa ALrKTyror poccuficrzu 3neKTpo3HeprerI'IKaMHoBbre npoSecczoHarrbHbre Bbr3oBbr vr craBflT cJro)KHbIe 3aAaql1 coAepxaqvecs' B3ueprerv.recKofi crparerr{ra Poccuu lo 2030 roAa.

Peurenrae au6uquosHblx 3aAar{pa3Br4Ttfl gneKTpo3Heprerur{ecrcofi orpacJltr HeBo3MoxHo 6es BocrIoJIHeHrrt vrpa3Bvrr1rfl, saxHefruero pecypca - r{eJloBerlecKoro, 6es nupa6orr<u ornevarorqeilcoBpeMeHHbrM Tpe6oeaHuqNa cr4creMbr rloAroroBKr4 kr neperloAroroBKll KaApoB, BrrepBylo oqepeAb, y[IpaBneHqecKl4x.3a uocleAHr{e roAbr rocyAapcrBo npnno)I{I4Jlo HeMaJIbIe yckrnvfl. n'nfl, pa3BZTr4flKaApoBoro rroreHrlr4aJra npoMbrruneHHblx npeanputtuit, aKTHBHo crr4Mynvrpyfl'o6pa:onareJrbHbre opraHlr3arruu Bbrcrrrefo o6pasonauzr K B3arlMoAeftcreurc cpeanbHbrM ceKTopoM 3KoHoMr4Kz.

Bce 6es ucrmoqeHl,I-fl LrHlzlJlzurvert MuHo6puayrrzPoccuu, TaKr.re KaK flporpaMMbr pa3BrTr4fl Qe4epanrHbrx, HarlproHanbHbrxr4ccneAoBareJrbcKr4x yHrrBepcr{TeroB, onopHblx By3oB, llpeaz4enrcKa-s nporpaMMaroBbrrreHuq rnarz$ur<a\vvr r{HXeHepHbIX KaApoB B 2012-2014 roAbr,Be4orrcrneHHas rlereBa-s nporpaMMa <<Hosble KaApbI OIIK)) H \pyrvq B KaqecrBeoS.sgaremHofo ycnoBr,r-s flonyr{eHr4rMep focyAapcrseHHofi rroAAep)KKr4npeAnonafarrv co$zuaHcurpoBaHrre npoeKToB pa3Br'tr4fl. yHr{Bepcr4TeroB, B nepByroorrepeAb, B ooJracTr4 noAfoToBKr{ r{ rroBbrrlreHz.fl KBanvQHKaI\vLl KaApoB, co cTopoHbr3ar{HTepecoBaHHbrx pa6oro4arerefr .Brraecre c reM, HecMorpq Ha rrpeAnpr4Hr,rMaeMbre ycr4nr.rfl) B Hacroslqee BpeMqMox(Ho KoHcrarllpoBarb HaJrr4r{r{e AocraroqHo cJro)KHofi curyaqupl, cJroxrur.lteircsuapbrHKe rpyAa B 3neKTpo3HeprernKe: KoMnereHrlrru BbrrrycKHkrKoB npo$unrurrxBy3oB, B ToM r{rrcJre z B o6racrl4 yrrpaBJreHut, He B nonuofi uepe yAoBnerBop-srorrpe6onaHnrru pa6oro4arerefi.

llpo6neua KaApoBoroo6ecneqeuu-syrrpaBneHr{ecKr4Mr4 KaApaMr4 3neKTpogHeprerr4Kr4 raMeer crzcreruurrfi xapaKTep6rrrr perxeHaLrcKJrroqkrreJrbHo rryreM frparHflTlzr KoMrrJreKcHbrxcrparer[r{ecKr.rx Mep npn cofJIacoBaHHbIX geitcrnul^x Bcex yqacrHr4KoB npoqecca.Kax rroKa3brBaer sapy6eNurrfi v yxe Haxourenuufi oreqecrBeusrrfi orrbrr,eS$er<uanHoe 83al4MoAeficrsue Bcex 3ar4HrepecoBaHHbrx cropoH (rocy4apcrna,o6pa:onareJrbHbrx opraHrr3aqwi'r, luzuec-coo6rqecrBa, o6yuarorqvrxefl rz 4pyrux) nnpoqecce $oprr,rzpoBaHnfl t<ovuereuquft kr KoMllereHruocreft KaApoB, Bbr3brBarorMeroAr.rqecxuft I4HTepec y l4ccneAoBarerefr v [paKTr4r{ecxuft r.rHTepec yrp eArpprr rwfi,-zarcazqnKo B KaApoB.B cs-flsz c 3TrrM Al4cceprarluoHHa-fl pa6ora A6panronofr E.IO., nocBf,IrleHHa.f,pa:pa6orKe MexaHrr3Ma $opnrzpoBaHkrfl ua6opa KoMrrereHruocrefr ylpaBneHrrecKr4xKaApoB, yAoBnerBopf,rcIrlnx rpe6oeaur4-flM npeAnpuxtuit 3neKrpo3Heprerr{qecKoroKoMrrJreKc a) flBrrs.ercr aKTyars nofi .Crpyr<rypa Arlccepralluouuoft pa6orrr Jrorr4r{Ha v coorBercrByerMo)Kerr4fIOCTABJIEHHbIM 3AAAqAM.Ilepean zna6a (ctp.

14-58) nocB-srleHa aHaIru3y o6pasoBareJrbHbrx cr{creM,$opvnpyrculux coBpeMeHHrrfr prrnox o6pasoBareJrbHbrx ycnyr. B rrase orpaxeHbrnpeAflocbrnKr{ pa3Burr4fl Mr4poBoro pbrHKa cncreM o6pa:onaHz-a. focrarouHoBHHMaHI4.TI yAeneHo raKoMy BaxHoMy [oHqrzro, KaK qeroBeqecxufr KaIII{Ta[.OrpaxeHa ero rrepBocrereHHa-s 3HarruMocrb KaK apafiuepa oKoHoMr{qecKoropa3Bvr-tkrfl o6rqecrna. B pa6ore aBTopoM r4ccJreAoBa:nnfl, AaHo orrzcaHr4er{HHoBarluougofr 3KoHoMIrKI4, Koropa-s ocHoBbrBaerct Ha BbrcoKoKar{ecrBeHHoMqeJroBeqecKoM KarIr4TaJIe, pa3Br{Tofi nay.ruofr czcrerrae I4 BbIcoKoM KarlecrBe )KI43HI4rreJroBeKa.

Anrop Alzccepraql4oHHoro rrccneAoBalavfl TaKXe BblrBr-ser KJrror{eBbrerroKa3arenrr Bocrpe6oeaHHocrr4 noAroroBKr4 BbrrrycKHr4KoB rr orpaxaer cnoco6rr ux|IoBbI[IeHn.f,.2Bo emopoil znaee (crp.59-106) pacrpblBarcrc-s MexaHl4srvru $opMI4poBaHI{qHa6opa KoMuereHrnocrefi ilpv noAroroBKe yrIpaBJIeHr{ecKHX KaApoB cr4crroJlb3oBaHureM npoqeccHbrx MoAeJIefi 4exrelbHocrl4 3HepfernrlecKl4xAnrop [poBoAr4T rny6oruftrouuauufi.aHarrr43 TepMI,IHa ((KoMrrereHIII4I4)), AeranbHopas6upaer MoAenH QopvrupoBalulafl.

r<orunerenqufi BbIrIycKHI4Ka o6pa:onarelruoftopraHV3arIr4LI Bbrclrrero o6pasonauur. Ha ocHoBe lpoee4eHHofo aHaIrr43anpeAnaraercr cr4creMa ynpaBneHu.s no4roronxofi ynpaBneHr{ecKlzx KaApoB,pe3ynbraroM Ae-flTenbHocrrr xoropofi qBrtercq BbIrIycKHr{K, nocrpe6oeaHHtrfiorpacnbro. Oupe4eleHnufi Hayvuufr r4Hrepec ilpeAcraBr.ser rlpeAnaraeMafl.

MoAenbpbrHKa BbrnycKHI'IKoB, B noropofi BblAen.serct HecKoJllro ypoenefi.HayuuyrorleHHocrb r4Meer crpyKTypl4poBaHHoe ofII4caHI4e3neKTposHepfeTuqecKofo KoMrrJreKca no BUAaM AeqTenbHocTII c BbIAeJIeHueM fpynfirtpegnpv.xruit u aHzltrrr3oM vx xapaKTepHbIX oco6euuocrefi. Cne4yer orMerl4Tb[pr4MeHeHr4e npoqeccHofo rroAxoAa K OIII4caHIIIO AeqTenbHOCTI4 Vr BbIqBIeHHIOnorpe6uocreir pa6oroAareneft. 3acnyxr4Baer BHIIMaHI4a cQopvupoBaHHa.f, aBTopoMcoBoKyrrHocrb KarrecrB, KoropblMu AonxeHo6la4arrBbInycKHlrK.B mpemueil zno6e (ctp.l07 -I27) aBropoM rlpeAnoxeH anropl4rMB3ar4MoAeircrlvts, c pa6oro4areJl-xMl4 B paMKax QopnrupoBatkrfl ua6opaKoMrrereHrnocrefi BbrnycKHr4Ka. Irlnrepec npeAcraBr.f,er paspa6oraHHafl cxeMaB3ar{MoAeitctsuq 6HsHeca u o6pa:oBareJrbHofr oprauz3ar\krr4 Bblcllrero o6pasonaHu-4.B xa.recrBe 3HaquMoro HayqHoro-MeroAl4rlecKoro pe3ynbrara vccileAoBaHllg MoxHooTMeTI4Tb rrpeAnafaeMylo MoAenb cIIcTeMbr cTpaTefl'IqecKofo ilnaHl,IpoBaHvrfl B By3e,a TapKe npe,4nox{eHHyro MeToAr4Ky orIeHKr{ KarIecTBa BbInycKHI4Ka, IIOCTpOeHHyIOCyqeToM ocHoBHbIX IpIIHIII4TTOB OIIeHKT{ KaqeCTBa.Creneuro6ocno ea HHocrrrrI oJIo?I(eHufi , nu noAoB I{ pe KoMeH ila\utrl,cQopvryrrpoBaHHblx B AncceprallnuOcuosHrIe HayqHble froJrox{eHvf,, BbIBoAbr I4 peKoMeHAaIJprr4 Mo}IGo crrl,ITarbo6ocHoeaHHbrMr.I, rITo [oATBep](Aaerc-s:oVcrroJrb3oBaHr4eM B KarlecrBe reoperl4r{ecrofi Sasrt uoloxeHufrHopMarrrBHbrx npaBoBbrx aKToB PO, [porpaMMbl crparerll.recKoro pa3Bkrrr4floHeprerr4rrecKoro KoMrrJreKca Pocczz, TpyAoB orerlecrBeHHblx u :apy6exnrrxyr{eHbrx B pa3Br4Tr4fl, coquanbHo-3KoHoM[qecKl4x cklcreM pa3nuqHblx yponHefr,cTpaTefr4qecKofo yrrpaBneH[A yHVBepcr4TeTaMr4, yllpaBneHvrfl I4 OIIeHKI4 IIepCOHana.olIpuMeHeHI,IeM B Ar,Icceprarlr4oHHoM I{ccJIeAoBaHkrv B KaqecrBeTeoperr4Ko-MeroAoloruqecr<ofi 6asrr: AlaaJleKTrrqecKofo, clrcreMHoro v ApyrI,IXMeTOAOB r{CCneAOBAHI,{fl, TeOpUn ynpaBneHI4t, KOHIIeIIqUI4 3aI4HTepeCOBaHHbIXcropoH, Teopr{r4 crpaTefkrrrecKofo IInaHnpoBaHLrfl., IlpoqeccHoro rIoAXoAa.oOrcyrcrBr4eM nporr4nopeuufr Teoperl4rlecKuM 14 rIpaKTpIqecKI4M AaHHrIM,coAepxaqvMcfl B TpyAax rr3BecrHbrx yqeHbrx e o6racru 3KoHoMI4KlI, MeHeAXMeHTa,rroAfoToBKr,r y[paBJleHrrecKux KaApoB.06 cyx4eHLIeM ( anpo6 aqzefipa6orbl Ha Bcepoccllficrux 14) ocuoBHbrxrrorro)KeHuir gnccepraquouuofiex{AyHapoAHbrx HayrrHo-[paKTr{qecKlrxrcoH$epenrJLrflx.ollcrroJrb3oBaHrreMMaTepr4aJroB AHccepTarlr{oHHofo r.rccJreAoBaHvrfl.

BnpaKrr'rqecrcofi AerreJrbHocrrr IIAO <IrIurepPAO>, OOO <<Macca>>, a rarcKe Byve6novr ilpoqecce raQe4pu DKoHoMr,rKr'r B 3Heprerr,rKe H rrpoMbrrxJreHHocrlr OfBOyBO (HI,IY (M3I4>.flo reue I4ccJIeAoBaHr4fl. ony6ruxoBaHoB rrerrarr4 19 pa6or, B ToM qracle 5ny6:i'urcaquit B LrcAaHkrtx, peKoMeHAoBaHnux BAK P(D, qro cBr.rAereJrbcrByer oAOCTaTOqHOM ypOBHe aIpOOaIIHH pe3ynbTaToB LrccJreAoBaHvrfl,, noATBeplKAaroqr{x3Haql4Mocrb nortyqeHHblx BbIBoAoB Lr paspa6oraHHbrx peKoMeHAa\uit.Ony6nuxoBaHHble MarepI4anbl IlonHocrbro orpalKaror pe3ynbrarbr rrpoBeAeHHoroI4ccneAoBaHtas, cAeJraHHbIe aBTopoM BbrBoAbr r4 HoBr43Hy Allcceprarlr{oHHofi pa6oru.Hay.rHan HoBu3Ha u 3Harr[Mocrb pa6oruHayvuax HoBI43Ha Ancceprar\Lrvr 14 lonyrreHHbrx pe3ynbraroB pa6omr3aKlroqaeTct B perueHl,Iu aKTyanbHbIX HayqHbIX I4 npaKTr4rlecKux 3a4aq, Kacarcqr4xcf,paspa6orKl4 TeoperzqecKl4x [ono]KeHrzfi uo co3AaHr{ro r4 npvMeHeHr,rro MexaHr43MavKoMllereHrnocrefinpuSopvrzpoBaHkrfl na6opar<ouuereHqrauyrrpaBJreHqecKr4x KaApoBAnfl SneKTpoSHepreTI{Kpr, ocHoBaHHoM HaIIoAroroBKerrpr4MeHeHr4ur[poqeccHofo rroAxoAa.HayvHa-r 3Harrl4Mocrr pa6orrt orrpeAenrerc.f, ee o HoBHbrMr4 pe3ynbraraMkr:l.