Диссертация (1140840), страница 7
Текст из файла (страница 7)
$B@ULNN@BKA KLOLNAJ /#- (n = 106)0@BK@<L;NRL?@;@N9;NRL B@URKAJ)L<9B?>HJ;AW9MAJ";>::R :9MALNK@<1 (n = 42)14(33%)# (n = 51)38(74%)& (n = 13)7(54%)QA@?9;G92@ONRP ?;AKL;AP!ATL;91 vs # — p < 0,011 vs & — p > 0,01*& vs # — p > 0,01*/NS9;?K QA@?9;G9,34(81%)43(84%)13(100%) 1 vs # — p > 0,01*1 vs & — p > 0,01*& vs # — p > 0,01*< K@Q OABHL::@<K@;NRP1 vs # — p > 0,01*11(26%)14(27%)4(31%)1 vs & — p > 0,01*& vs # — p > 0,01*!"#$%&'(#%: * — ;9WHAOAJ BK9KABKAOLB?A NLWN9OAQR..9? <AGN@ AW K9UHAMR, <RJ<HLNR G@BK@<L;NRL ;9WHAOAJ :@ ?@HAOLBK<>:;@<LGLNNR= ;L<9B?>HJ;AW9MAP QA@?9;G9 > :9MALNK@< AW I;>:: 1 (NL<;@:9KAJ) A# (B@Q9K@K@NAJ).-;LGNLL OABH@ 0.- N9 1 U@HVN@I@ < I;>::L 1 URH@ ;9<N@ 1,7 ± 0,9, < I;>::L# — 1,6 ± 1,1, < I;>::L & — 1,8 ± 0,8.
0@BK@<L;NR= ;9WHAOAP QLYG> I;>::9QA :@[K@Q> :@?9W9KLHX @UN9;>YLN@ NL URH@.40& K9UHAML 3.8 :;LGBK9<HLN =9;9?KL; KLOLNAJ 7/#- > :9MALNK@< B;9WHAONRQA <9;A9NK9QA B@Q9K@:L;ML:KA<N@P 9?MLNK>9MAA, 9 < K9UHAML 3.9 —:;AOANR :L;<@I@ @U;9ZLNAJ ? <;9O> :@ :@<@G> /#-.29UHAM9 3.8.
79;9?KL; KLOLNAJ 7/#- (n = 106)79;9?KL; KLOLNAJ";>::R :9MALNK@<1 (n = 42)3LUH9I@:;AJKNRP9 (21%)# (n = 51)0(0%)2@ONRP ?;AKL;AP!ATL;9& (n = 13)11(85%)1 vs # — p < 0,01(?@NLONRL K@O?A1 vs & — p < 0,001LBKV)& vs # — p < 0,001#H9I@:;AJKNRP33 (79%)51(100%)2(15%)(?@NLONR= K@OL? NLK)1 vs # — p < 0,011 vs & — p < 0,001& vs # — p < 0,001.9? <AGN@ AW K9UHAMR, AQLXKBJ <R;9YLNNRL ;9WHAOAJ :@ =9;9?KL;> KLOLNAJ7/#- > U@HVNR= <BL= 3-= I;>::, :;AOLQ N9AU@HLL NLUH9I@:;AJKNRQ <9;A9NK@Q;9BBK;@PBK<9 HAON@BKA J<HJLKBJ BLIQLNK9;N9J GL:L;B@N9HAW9MAJ.29UHAM9 3.9. ';AOANR :L;<@I@ @U;9ZLNAJ :9MALNK@< (n = 106) ? <;9O> :@ :@<@G>/#';AOAN9";>::R :9MALNK@<1 (n = 42)$BK;RP ?@;@N9;NRP15(36%)# (n = 51)25(49%)& (n = 13)2@ONRP ?;AKL;AP!ATL;913(100%) 1 vs # — p > 0,01*BANG;@Q1 vs & — p < 0,001& vs # — p < 0,01BK9UAHVN9J27(64%)26(51%)0(0%)BKLN@?9;GAJ1 vs # — p > 0,01*1 vs & — p < 0,001& vs # — p < 0,01!"#$%&'(#%: * — ;9WHAOAJ BK9KABKAOLB?A NLWN9OAQR.41.9? BHLG>LK AW K9UHAMR, :L;<@L @U;9ZLNAL ? <;9O> > U@HVTLP O9BKAU@HVNR= B NL<;@:9KALP URH@ B<JW9N@ B@ BK9UAHVN@P BKLN@?9;GALP.
& I;>::L #:;AQL;N@ :@H@<AN9 U@HVNR= <:L;<RL @U;9KAH9BV ? <;9O> :@ :@<@G> BK9UAHVN@PBKLN@?9;GAA, 9 <K@;9J :@H@<AN9 — :@ :@<@G> $.-. % <BL= :9MALNK@< BBLIQLNK9;N@P GL:L;B@N9HAW9MALP :;AOAN@P :L;<@I@ @U;9ZLNAJ URH $.(;9WHAOAJ QLYG> I;>::9QA 1 A &, 9 K9?YL QLYG> # A & G@BK@<L;NR).';AOANR I@B:AK9HAW9MAA :9MALNK@< :;A <?HXOLNAA A= < ABBHLG@<9NAL:;LGBK9<HLNR < K9UHAML 3.10.29UHAM9 3.10. ';AOAN9 I@B:AK9HAW9MAA :;A <?HXOLNAA :9MALNK@< (n = 106)< ABBHLG@<9NAL';AOAN9";>::R :9MALNK@<1 (n = 42)$BK;RP ?@;@N9;NRP11(26%)# (n = 51)3(6%)& (n = 13)1(8%)BANG;@Q2@ONRP ?;AKL;AP!ATL;91 vs # — p > 0,01*1 vs & — p > 0,01*& vs # — p > 0,01*';@I;LBBA;@<9NAL8 (19%)8(16%)12(92%)1 vs # — p > 0,01*=;@NAOLB?@P1 vs & — p < 0,001BL;GLON@P& vs # — p < 0,001NLG@BK9K@ON@BKA0;>IAL :;AOANR**23(55%)40(78%)0(0%)1 vs # — p > 0,01*1 vs & — p < 0,01& vs # — p < 0,001!"#$%&'(#%: * — ;9WHAOAJ BK9KABKAOLB?A NLWN9OAQR;** — :@BKL:LNN@L :;@I;LBBA;@<9NAL BKLN@?9;GAA, :@GI@K@<?9 ?@:L;9KA<NRQ <QLT9KLHVBK<9Q, GLBK9UAHAW9MAJ 10.39 Q@QLNK <?HXOLNAJ < ABBHLG@<9NAL (K@ LBKV :@ :;@TLBK<AA ?9? QANAQ>Q3-= HLK) — K9UHAM9.
3.8 — K9?YL AQLXKBJ <R;9YLNNRL ;9WHAOAJ QLYG> U@HVNRQAB BLIQLNK9;N@P GL:L;B@N9HAW9MALP A :9MALNK9QA AW G<>= G;>IA= I;>::. & I;>::L42& U@HLL, OLQ < 90% I@B:AK9HAW9MAJ URH9 B<JW9N9 B :;@I;LBBA;@<9NALQ 7-3 (>YLG@BKAIN><TLP III—IV !..). ,LYG> I A II I;>::9QA G@BK@<L;NRL ;9WHAOAJ@KB>KBK<@<9HA.';A AW>OLNAA UA@=AQAOLB?A= :@?9W9KLHLP G@BK@<L;NR= ;9WHAOAP QLYG>I;>::9QA NL <RJ<HLN@. 09NNRL :@ >;@<NX HA:@:;@KLAG@< NAW?@P :H@KN@BKA(C'3') A IHX?@WR :;LGBK9<HLNR < K9UHAML 3.11.29UHAM9 3.11. -@GL;Y9NAL < :H9WQL ?;@<A C'3' A IHX?@WR (n = 106)-;LGNAL WN9OLNAJ";>::R :9MALNK@<(M ± m) :@?9W9KLHJCA:@:;@KLAGR1 (n = 42)3,2 ± 1,2# (n = 51)3,1 ± 1,12@ONRP ?;AKL;AP!ATL;9& (n = 13)2,8 ± 0,81 vs # — p > 0,01*NAW?@P :H@KN@BKA,1 vs & — p > 0,01*I/H& vs # — p > 0,01*"HX?@W9, QQ@HV/H6,2 ± 2,26,0 ± 1,75,3 ± 0,71 vs # — p > 0,01*1 vs & — p > 0,01*& vs # — p > 0,01*!"#$%&'(#%: * — ;9WHAOAJ BK9KABKAOLB?A NLWN9OAQR;-;LGNAL :@?9W9KLHA 5-- (<?HXO9J ;LW>HVK9KR =@HKL;@<B?@I@Q@NAK@;A;@<9NAJ \.") A 10 :;A :@BK>:HLNAA :;LGBK9<HLNR < K9UHAM9= 3.12 A3.13.29UHAM9 3.12.
%;@<NA 5-- A 10 (n = 106)-;LGNALWN9OLNAJ";>::R :9MALNK@<1 (n = 42)# (n = 51)2@ONRP ?;AKL;AP& (n = 13)!ATL;9(M ± m):@?9W9KLHJ5--69,2 ± 12,168,6 ± 13,073,1 ± 15,81 vs # — p > 0,01*1 vs & — p > 0,01*& vs # — p > 0,01*43';@G@HYLNAL K9UHAMR 3.1210, QQ ;K.BK.,1 vs # — p > 0,01*< K@Q OABHL:1 vs & — p > 0,01*BABK@HAOLB?@L139,8 ± 23,28 133 ± 19,2127,7 ± 23,2& vs # — p > 0,01*GA9BK@HAOLB?@L82,1 ± 9,878,3 ± 10,11 vs # — p > 0,01*78,8 ± 12,61 vs & — p > 0,01*& vs # — p > 0,01*29UHAM9 3.13.
5-- (:@ G9NNRQ =@HKL;@<B?@I@ Q@NAK@;A;@<9NAJ \.") A 10(n = 106)-;LGNALWN9OLNAJ";>::R :9MALNK@<1 (n = 42)# (n = 51)2@ONRP ?;AKL;AP& (n = 13)!ATL;9(M ± m):@?9W9KLHJ5-- B;LGNJJ65,8 ± 7,263,9 ± 8,668,5 ± 11,12 1 vs # — p > 0,01*1 vs & — p > 0,01*& vs # — p > 0,01*5-QANAQ9HVN9J1 vs # — p > 0,01*50,9 ± 7,347,9 ± 6,555,2 ± 9,5& vs # — p > 0,01*& vs # — p > 0,01*5-Q9?BAQ9HVN9J1 vs # — p > 0,01*99,1 ± 19,9100,3 ± 19,6 100,5 ± 19,8 1 vs & — p > 0,01*& vs # — p > 0,01*!"#$%&'(#%: * — ;9WHAOAJ BK9KABKAOLB?A NLWN9OAQR;44!>N?MA@N9HVNRP?H9BBBKLN@?9;GAA:;A<?HXOLNAA:9MALNK@<<ABBHLG@<9NAL :;LGBK9<HLN < K9UHAML 3.14, 9 !. 7-3 — < K9UHAML 3.15 A N9;AB>N?L 3.5.29UHAM9 3.14. !>N?MA@N9HVNRP ?H9BB BKLN@?9;GAA (n = 106)'@?9W9KLHV";>::R :9MALNK@<I (n = 42)II (n = 51)III (n = 13)2@ONRP ?;AKL;AP!ATL;9!>N?MA@N9HVNRPI vs II — p > 0,01*?H9BB BKLN@?9;GAA,I vs III — p > 0,01*< K@Q OABHL:II vs III — p > 0,01*0—I18(43%)28(55%)9(69%)II7(17%)10(20%)1(8%)I vs II — p > 0,01*I vs III — p > 0,01*II vs III — p > 0,01*III—IV17(40%)13(25%)3(23%)I vs II — p > 0,01*I vs III — p > 0,01*II vs III — p > 0,01*!"#$%&'(#%: * — ;9WHAOAJ BK9KABKAOLB?A NLWN9OAQR;29UHAM9 3.15.
!>N?MA@N9HVNRP ?H9BB 7-3 :;A :@BK>:HLNAA (n = 106)'@?9W9KLHV";>::R :9MALNK@<1 (n = 42)# (n = 51)2@ONRP ?;AKL;AP& (n = 13)!ATL;9!>N?MA@N9HVNRP1 vs # — p > 0,01*?H9BB 7-3, < K@Q1 vs & — p > 0,01*OABHL:& vs # — p > 0,01*0—I;29(69%)40(78%)1(8%)45';@G@HYLNAL K9UHAMR 3.15II7(17%)10(20%)0(0%)1 vs # — p > 0,01*1 vs & — p > 0,01*& vs # — p > 0,01*III—IV6(14%)1(2%)12(92%)1 vs # — p > 0,01*1 vs & — p < 0,001& vs # — p < 0,001!"#$%&'(#%: * — ;9WHAOAJ BK9KABKAOLB?A NLWN9OAQR.+!"*!")!"(!"1!5617 8'!"16617 8&!"1666569 17 8%!"$!"#!"!",-.//012,-.//013,-.//014)AB>N@? 3.5.
!>N?MA@N9HVNRP ?H9BB 7-3 :;A :@BK>:HLNAA :9MALNK@< (n = 106))LW>HVK9KR \=@." N9TA= :9MALNK@< :;A :@BK>:HLNAA :;LGBK9<HLNR <K9UHAML 3.16.4629UHAM9 3.16. )LW>HVK9KR \=@." :;A :@BK>:HLNAA (n = 106)'@?9W9KLHV";>::R :9MALNK@<1 (n = 42)# (n = 51)& (n = 13)&RJ<HLN9GAH9K9MAJ HL<@I@!ATL;91 vs # — p > 0,01*21(50%)36(69%)10(77%):;LGBL;GAJ (C')&RJ<HLN92@ONRP ?;AKL;AP1 vs & — p > 0,01*& vs # — p > 0,01*26(62%)33(65%)6(46%)1 vs # — p > 0,01*IA:L;K;@SAJ HL<@I@1 vs & — p > 0,01*YLH>G@O?9 (C])& vs # — p > 0,01*&RJ<HLN912(29%)13(26%)5(38%)1 vs # — p > 0,01*GA9BK@HAOLB?9J1 vs & — p > 0,01*GABS>N?MAJ& vs # — p > 0,01*-;LGNAL WN9OLNAJ1 vs # — p > 0,01*(M ± m) S;9?MAA1 vs & — p > 0,01*<RU;@B9 C], %-;LGNAL WN9OLNAJ52,78 ±53,25 ±10,12612,7299,1 ± 44,9 101,6 ±(M ± m) ?@NLON@-43,46 ± 18,07 & vs # — p > 0,01*146,5 ± 11,446,1GA9BK@HAOLB?@I@1 vs # — p > 0,01*1 vs & — p < 0,05*& vs # — p < 0,05*@U`LQ9 C], QQ!"#$%&'(#%: * — ;9WHAOAJ BK9KABKAOLB?A NLWN9OAQR.& I;>::L BLIQLNK9;N@P GL:L;B@N9HAW9MAA (&) :@ B;9<NLNAX B G;>IAQAI;>::9QA G@BK@<L;N@ (p < 0,001) :;L@UH9G9XK :9MALNKR B III—IV !.
7-3.& [K@P I;>::L K9?YL ><LHAOLN ?@NLON@-GA9BK@HAOLB?AP @U`LQ C] AAQLLKBJ KLNGLNMAJ ? U@HLL NAW?@P !& C]. '@ @BK9HVNRQ :9;9QLK;9Q \=@."(:;AWN9?A S@;QA;@<9NAJ IA:L;K@NAOLB?@I@ BL;GM9) G@BK@<L;NR= ;9WHAOAP QLYG>I;>::9QA NL <RJ<HLN@.4779;9?KL;ABKA?A .1" (<R:@HNLNNRL G@ AHA <@ <;LQJ I@B:AK9HAW9MAA,;L?@QLNG@<9NNRL) 9 K9?YL A= ;LW>HVK9KR :;LGBK9<HLNR < K9UHAML 3.17.29UHAM9 3.17.
![](https://s.studizba.com/z.php?f=/templates/si/i/noavatar.png&w=100&h=100&t=1"){kind=avatar}
