Диссертация (1140840), страница 6
Текст из файла (страница 6)
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— >H>OTLNAL B@?;9KAQ@BKA < @UH9BKJ= B N9;>TLNN@P B@?;9KAQ@BKVX <:@?@L [29].';A NL<@WQ@YN@BKA :;@<LGLNAJ -K;LBB-\=@." B SAWAOLB?@P N9I;>W?@P(K;LGQAH-KLBK):;@<@GAHAABBHLG@<9NALBS9;Q9?@H@IAOLB?@PN9I;>W?@P(G@U>K9QAN) [98].';A N9HAOAA :@?9W9NAP :9MALNK9Q :;@<@GAHA .1".&>BH@<AJ=?HANA?@-GA9IN@BKAOLB?@PH9U@;9K@;AA:;ABK9MA@N9;L<R:@HNJH@BV H9U@;9K@;N@L @UBHLG@<9NAL :@ BK9NG9;KNRQ QLK@GA?9Q.&BL U@HVNRL URHA @BQ@K;LNR :BA=A9K;@Q A QLGAMANB?AQ :BA=@H@I@Q,:@BHL OLI@ :;@<@GAHBJ ?HANAOLB?AP ;9WU@; B >O9BKALQ 9?9GLQA?9 )13 1.
#.-Q>HL<AO9 A :;@SLBB@;9 1.#. &@HLHV.32'BA=@QLK;AOLB?@L @UBHLG@<9NAL#@HVNRL W9:@HNJHA BHLG>XZAL @:;@BNA?A:— SHAI (?;9K?AP @:;@BNA? K;L<@IA @ WG@;@<VL, < 9G9:K9MAA, 2014);— «'JKAS9?K@;NRP HAON@BKNRP @:;@BNA?» < 9G9:K9MAA -.0. #A;X?@<9 A,.&. #@G>N@<9 (1989) A ,.-. (I@;@<@P A $.&. '9;TA?@<@P (2016);— SF-36 (@:;@BNA? ?9OLBK<9 YAWNA);— @:;@BNA? HAON@BKN@P A BAK>9KA<N@P K;L<@YN@BKA -:AHUL;IL;9—79NAN9.2.4.>-(-%K-%NLKI(M +'"('+-I( #(&&PW-K9KABKAOLB?>X@U;9U@K?>G9NNR=:;@<@GAHABAB:@HVW@<9NALQ:;@I;9QQR SPSS.19. 0@BK@<L;NRQ :;AWN9<9HA >;@<LNV WN9OAQ@BKA p < 0,05.-;9<NLNAL QLYG> I;>::9QA :@ ?9OLBK<LNNRQ :;AWN9?9Q @B>ZLBK<HJH@BV BAB:@HVW@<9NALQK@ON@I@?;AKL;AJ!ATL;9[FischerR.].->OLK@QW9:H9NA;@<9NN@P QN@YLBK<LNN@BKA B;9<NLNAP QLYG> K;LQJ I;>::9QA A < MLHJ=B@=;9NLNAJ @UZLI@ >;@<NJ BK9KABKAOLB?@P WN9OAQ@BKA 5% ?;AKAON>X <LHAOAN>@TAU?A :L;<@I@ ;@G9 GHJ ?9YG@I@ ANGA<AG>9HVN@I@ B;9<NLNAJ @:;LGLHJHA B>OLK@Q :@:;9<?A #@NSL;;@NA [Bonferroni C.E.].
& [K@Q BH>O9L G@BK@<L;NRQA;9WHAOAJ BOAK9HA :;A p < 0,013.0HJ <RJ<HLNAJ ;9WHAOAP QLYG> I;>::9QA :@ ?@HAOLBK<LNNRQ :@?9W9KLHJQ(;LW>HVK9KR :BA=@QLK;AOLB?@I@ @UBHLG@<9NAJ) AB:@HVW@<9HA NL:9;9QLK;AOLB?AL?;AKL;AA .;9B?LH9—%@HHLB9 [Kruskall W., Walles W.A.] A ,9NN9—%AKNA [MannH.B., Whitney D.R]. 0HJ <RJ<HLNAJ WN9OAQR= ;9WHAOAP < BKL:LNA <R;9YLNN@BKAHAON@BKN@P, BAK>9KA<N@P K;L<@YN@BKA A K;L<@IA @ WG@;@<VL :;AQLNJHBJNL:9;9QLK;AOLB?AP 9N9HAW (?;AKL;AP .@HQ@I@;@<9--QA;N@<9).3312!3! III.
847:2=9!9; )>>24603!5)?3.1. 3*%M&%L "(KK-"+UK-/( *%N&+K-% Q+ -%Q. K+O(-+QL"TLQ-%/&PW(ITL&-.(T%U &( W("(I-L" -LNL&%M W"+&%NLKI+U %XLO%NLKI+U '+*L$&% KL"#T(('*(Z+Q"%M-&PU/&L'*(Z+Q"%M-&PU)& W9<ABAQ@BKA @K KA:9 B@Q9K@:L;ML:KA<N@P 9?MLNK>9MAA U@HVNRL URHA;9WGLHLNR N9 3 I;>::R (;AB>N@? 3.1).& I;>::> U@HVNR= B NL<;@:9KALP (1) <@THA 42(40%) OLH@<L?9; 51(48%)OLH@<L? B B@Q9K@K@NALP B@BK9<AHA I;>::> #, 9 13(12%) :9MALNK@< B BLIQLNK9;N@PGL:L;B@N9HAW9MALP — I;>::> &.)AB>N@? 3.1.
)9B:;LGLHLNAL U@HVNR= (n = 106) :@ KA:> B@Q9K@:L;ML:KA<N@P9?MLNK>9MAA.3.1.1. >+T%+-#LO+Z"([%NLKI(M W("(I-L"%K-%I( Q(T%L&-+/34"LNGL;NRL ;9WHAOAJ A B;LGNAP <@W;9BK :9MALNK@< :;LGBK9<HLNR < K9UHAML3.1, 9 <@W;9BKNRL =9;9?KL;ABKA?A :@ I;>::9Q — < ;AB>N?L 3.2.29UHAM9 3.1. '@H A <@W;9BK :9MALNK@< (n = 106)79;9?KL;ABKA?9";>::R :9MALNK@<1 (n = 42)# (n = 51)& (n = 13)Q>YB?@P;19(45%)39(76%)*10(77%)YLNB?AP23(55%)12(24%)3(23%)-;LGNAP (M ± m) <@W;9BK, HLK67,5 ± 8,662,8 ± 12,967,1 ± 9,0'@H, < K@Q OABHL:!"#$%&'(#%: * — ;9WHAOAJ :@ OABH> YLNZAN A Q>YOAN < I;>::L # G@BK@<L;NR (p< 0,01; K@ONRP ?;AKL;AP !ATL;9).9? <AGN@ AW K9UHAMR, Q>YOAN URH@ G@BK@<L;N@ U@HVTL <@ 2-P I;>::L.,!"!!#+!"!!#*!"!!#)!"!!#(!"!!#'!:(,;<='!"!!#)!:*,;<=&!"!!#+!2>2?@;<<%!"!!#$!"!!#!"!!#-./00123456 '%72-./00128456 ($72-./0019 456 $&7)AB>N@? 3.2.
&@W;9BKN9J =9;9?KL;ABKA?9 U@HVNR= (n = 106)35.9? <AGN@ AW ;AB>N?9 3.2, <@ <BL= I;>::9= :;L@UH9G9HA :9MALNKR <<@W;9BKN@Q :;@QLY>K?L @K 60 G@ 79 HLK.-LQLPN@L :@H@YLNAL :9MALNK@< :;LGBK9<HLN@ < K9UHAML 3.2 A N9 ;AB>N?L3.3.29UHAM9 3.2. -LQLPN@L :@H@YLNAL :9MALNK@< (n = 106)79;9?KL;ABKA?9";>::R :9MALNK@<1 (n = 42)# (n = 51)& (n = 13)YLN9K/W9Q>YLQ;27(64%)40(78%)9(69%)NL YLN9K/ NL W9Q>YLQ;9(21%)5(10%)3(23%);9W<LGLNR;2(5%)4(8%)0(0%)<G@<LM/<G@<94(10%)2(4%)1(8%)-LQLPN@L :@H@YLNAL,< K@Q OABHL:)9WHAOAP QLYG> I;>::9QA :@ K@ON@Q> ?;AKL;AX !ATL;9 :@ <BLQ:9;9QLK;9Q K9UHAMR 3.2 NL <RJ<HLN@+!"*!")!"(!"567089:0;.<6;'!"=61<67089761:0;.<6;&!"> 0:?6@67A1%!"4 @B?6C9?@B?0$!"#!"!",-.//012,-.//013,-.//014)AB.
3.3. -LQLPN@L :@H@YLNAL :9MALNK@< (n = 106).36$BN@<NRLB@MA9HVNRL=9;9?KL;ABKA?A(B@@KN@TLNAL;9U@K9XZA=,:LNBA@NL;@< A N9HAOAL I;>::R AN<9HAGN@BKA) :;LGBK9<HLNR < K9UHAML 3.3. A N9;AB>N?L 3.4.29UHAM9 3.3. $BN@<NRL B@MA9HVNRL =9;9?KL;ABKA?A :9MALNK@< (n = 106)79;9?KL;ABKA?9";>::R :9MALNK@<1 (n = 42)# (n = 51)& (n = 13);9U@K9XK;18(42%)22(43%)4(31%):LNBA@NL;R;17(40%)24(47%)6(46%)@S@;QHLN9 AN<9HAGN@BKV7(17%)5(10%)4(31%)-@MA9HVN9J =9;9?KL;ABKA?9,< K@Q OABHL:)9WHAOAP QLYG> I;>::9QA :@ K@ON@Q> ?;AKL;AX !ATL;9 :@ <BLQ:9;9QLK;9Q K9UHAMR 3.3 NL <RJ<HLN@#!"'#"'!"&#"&!"1 ,234,56 78-%#"98:; 73:8)<%!"=:>,?7@:3; 4A-8; 4A$#"$!"#"!"()*++,-.()*++,-/()*++,-037)AB>N@? 3.4. -@MA9HVN9J =9;9?KL;ABKA?9 :9MALNK@< (n = 106).29?AQ @U;9W@Q, :@ GLQ@I;9SAOLB?AQ A B@MA9HVNRQ :@?9W9KLHJQ QLYG>K;LQJ I;>::9QA G@BK@<L;NR= ;9WHAOAP NL <RJ<HLN@, KLQ NL QLNLL, BK@AK@KQLKAKV, OK@ < I;>::L & QLNVTL G@HJ ;9U@K9XZA= :9MALNK@< A U@HVTL — BAN<9HAGN@BKVX, OLQ < I;>::9= 1 A #; K9?YL :@ ILNGL;N@Q> :;AWN9?> URHAG@BK@<L;NRL ;:9WHAOAJ QLYG> I;>::9QA 1 A &.3.1.2.
8L$.*J-(-P I("#%+*+Z%NLKI+Z+ +'K*L#+/(&%M-;LGNAP B;@?, :;@TLGTAP @K :L;<@I@ G@BK@<L;N@I@ ?@;@N9;N@I@ B@URKAJ(0.-) G@ <?HXOLNAJ :9MALNK@< < ABBHLG@<9NAL, :;LGBK9<HLN < K9UHAML 3.429UHAM9 3.4. -;LGNAP B;@?, :;@TLGTAP @K :L;<@I@ 0.- G@ <?HXOLNAJ :9MALNK@<(n = 106) < ABBHLG@<9NAL'@?9W9KLHV";>::R :9MALNK@<1 (n = 42)# (n = 51)!ATL;9& (n = 13)-;LGNAP (M ± m)B;@?, :;@TLGTAP @K2@ONRP ?;AKL;AP1 vs # — p > 0,01*8,3 ± 5,110,2 ± 7,49,3 ± 7,3:L;<@I@ 0.- G@1 vs & — p > 0,01*& vs # — p > 0,01*<?HXOLNAJ <ABBHLG@<9NAL, HLK!"#$%&'(#%: * — ;9WHAOAJ BK9KABKAOLB?A NLWN9OAQR..9? <AGN@ AW K9UHAMR, B;LGNAP B;@?, :;@TLGTAP @K :L;<@I@ 0.-, URH:;9?KAOLB?A @GAN9?@< <@ <BL= I;>::9=.29?YL NL URH@ <RJ<HLN@ G@BK@<L;NR= ;9WHAOAP QLYG> I;>::9QA :@B;LGNLQ> <@W;9BK> <@WNA?N@<LNAJ :L;<@I@ 0.- (K9UHAM9 3.5).3829UHAM9 3.5.
-;LGNAP <@W;9BK, < ?@K@;@Q :9MALNKR, <?HXOLNNRL < ABBHLG@<9NAL(n = 106) :L;LNLBHA :L;<@L 0.'@?9W9KLHV";>::R :9MALNK@<1 (n = 42)# (n = 51)!ATL;9& (n = 13)-;LGNAP (M ± m)<@W;9BK, HLK2@ONRP ?;AKL;AP1 vs # — p > 0,01*59,3 ± 8,856,5 ± 8,952,5 ± 11,2 1 vs & — p > 0,01*& vs # — p > 0,01*!"#$%&'(#%: * — ;9WHAOAJ BK9KABKAOLB?A NLWN9OAQR.0ABHA:AGLQAJ AQLH9 QLBK@ > <BL= :9MALNK@<; O9BK@K9 G;>IA= S@N@<R=W9U@HL<9NAP :;LGBK9<HLN9 < K9UHAML 3.6.29UHAM9 3.6. !@N@<RL W9U@HL<9NAJ (n = 106)69U@HL<9NAL";>::R :9MALNK@<1 (n = 42)"A:L;K@NAOLB?9J41(98%)# (n = 51)47(92%)& (n = 13)10(77%)U@HLWNV2@ONRP ?;AKL;AP!ATL;91 vs # — p > 0,01*1 vs & — p > 0,01*& vs # — p > 0,01*-9=9;NRP GA9ULK22(52%)23(45%)4(31%)2-I@ KA:91 vs # — p > 0,01*1 vs & — p > 0,01*& vs # — p > 0,01*$YA;LNAL15(36%)13(25%)4(31%)1 vs # — p > 0,01*1 vs & — p > 0,01*& vs # — p > 0,01*!"#$%&'(#%: * — ;9WHAOAJ BK9KABKAOLB?A NLWN9OAQR.3939 Q@QLNK <?HXOLNAJ :9MALNK@< < ABBHLG@<9NAL G@BK@<L;NR= ;9WHAOAP :@S@N@<RQ W9U@HL<9NAJQ QLYG> I;>::9QA NL URH@.$B@ULNN@BKA KLOLNAJ /#- :;LGBK9<HLNR < K9UHAML 3.7.29UHAM9 3.7.
![](https://s.studizba.com/z.php?f=/templates/si/i/noavatar.png&w=100&h=100&t=1"){kind=avatar}
