Диссертация (1140840), страница 13
Текст из файла (страница 13)
& K@ YL <;LQJ < B<@LP GABBL;K9MAA #.1.&@HLHV (2009) < ;9WGLHL, :@B<JZLNN@Q «A:@=@NG;AA cum materia»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
';A [K@Q >;@<LNV BAK>9KA<N@P A HAON@BKN@PK;L<@YN@BKA :@ T?9HL -:AHUL;LIL;9—79NAN9 @?9W9HBJ @GAN9?@<@ <RB@?AQ <@ULA= I;>::9=.'9MALNKR B NL<;@:9KAOLB?@P ?@NBKAK>MALP =9;9?KL;AW>XKBJ <R;9YLNN@PHAON@BKN@P K;L<@YN@BKVX, OK@, <L;@JKN@, J<HJLKBJ B>UBK;9K@Q GHJ S@;QA;@<9NAJK;L<@IA @ WG@;@<VL. \K@ B@@KN@BAKBJ B G9NNRQA ,. Hollifield et al. (1997), R. Noyeset al.
(2008) [96, 97]. .9? URH@ :@?9W9N@ < ABBHLG@<9NAJ= A.L Stanton et al. (1994),J.K. Connor-Smith (2007), :9MALNKR B :@<RTLN@P HAON@BKN@P K;L<@YN@BKVXB?H@NNR ? AB:@HVW@<9NAX QLNLL :;@G>?KA<NR= BK;9KLIAP B@<H9G9NAJ: :;ANJKALYLH9LQ@I@ W9 GLPBK<AKLHVN@L, [Q@MA@N9HVNRP ?@:ANI [67, 68, 97].
& BAK>9MAANLUH9I@:;AJKN@I@ KLOLNAJ W9U@HL<9NAJ, K@ LBKV :;A N9HAOAA 9GL?<9KN@I@B>UBK;9K9 GHJ S@;QA;@<9NAJ K;L<@IA @ WG@;@<VL, B@BK@JNAL [KA= U@HVNR= Q@YLK<K@;AON@ >=>GT9KVBJ <<AG> O;LWQL;N@I@ A NL9GL?<9KN@I@ :@<RTLNAJ K;L<@IA @WG@;@<VL. & ;LW>HVK9KL :@G@UN@I@ [Q@MA@N9HVN@I@ B@BK@JNAJ @B@U@L QLBK@ <YAWNAU@HVNR=W9NAQ9LK«WG@;@<VL-BUL;LI9XZLL»:@<LGLNAL,W9O9BK>X:;@KA<@;LO9ZLL ;L?@QLNG9MAJQ <;9O9 (? :;AQL;>, @K?9W @K HXU@P SAWAOLB?@PN9I;>W?A).&B<JWAB[KAQ,NL@U=@GAQRQ:;LGBK9<HJLKBJQ@NAK@;ANI<R;9YLNN@BKA K;L<@IA @ WG@;@<VL > U@HVNR= 7/#- B ;9BBK;@PBK<@Q HAON@BKA :@KA:> NL<;@:9KAOLB?@P 9?MLNK>9MAA A @KGLHVN9J :BA=@KL;9:L<KAOLB?9J ;9U@K9 :@?@;;L?MAA [Q@MA@N9HVN@I@ B@BK@JNAJ A NL9GL?<9KN@I@ :@<LGLNAJ < U@HLWNA >G9NNR= :9MALNK@<.
29?, < =@GL N9TLP ;9U@KR U@HVTANBK<@ U@HVNR= I;>::R 11 (6OLH@<L?) :@H>OAHA :BA=@KL;9:L<KAOLB?>X :@Q@ZV, :@BHL OLI@ OLK<L;@ AW NA=B@IH9BAHABV N9 K;LNA;@<@ONRL N9I;>W?A, G<@L —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«2;L<@I9 @WG@;@<VL», «#GAKLHVN@BKV ? KLHLBNRQ BLNB9MAJQ» A S9?K@;> «NLP;@KAWQ» :@«'JKAS9?K@;N@Q> @:;@BNA?>» < B@OLK9NAA B NL9GL?<9KN@ <RB@?AQA (:@@KN@TLNAX ? S>N?MA@N9HVN@Q> ?H9BB> BKLN@?9;GAA A 7-3) WN9OLNAJQA :@T?9HL«!AWAOLB?AP?@Q:@NLNK?9OLBK<9YAWNA».';A<LGLNNRLG9NNRL:@?9WR<9XK, OK@ W9:@G@W;AKV BLIQLNK9;N>X GL:L;B@N9HAW9MAX > U@HVN@I@ B /#Q@YN@ :;A @GN@?;9KN@Q :BA=@H@IAOLB?@Q KLBKA;@<9NAA.)9BBK;@PBK<@ HAON@BKA :@ KA:> BLIQLNK9;N@P GL:L;B@N9HAW9MAJ J<HJLKBJBL;VLWNRQ S9?K@;@Q ;AB?9 NLUH9I@:;AJKN@I@ KLOLNAJ /#- [39, 41].
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«:@QL=9» GHJ :;A<RON@I@ @U;9W9YAWNA.
&@:;L?A <@WQ@YN@Q> ;AB?> ;LMAGA<9 BL;GLON@P ?9K9BK;@SR, U@HVNRL <;JGL BH>O9L< B :@Q@ZVX N9;9BK9XZA= N9I;>W@? (>U@;?9 BNLI9 N9 >HAML, W9NJKAL9?KA<NRQA <AG9QA B:@;K9 — I@;NRL HRYA A K. :.) :RK9HABV <@BBK9N@<AKVSAWAOLB?>X 9?KA<N@BKV. .HANAOLB?9J ?9;KAN9 9UL;;9NKN@P A:@=@NG;AA > G9NN@PI;>::R U@HVNR= @:;LGLHJH9BV NL K@HV?@ NLG@@MLN?@P >I;@Y9XZLI@ BQRBH988GA9IN@W9AKJYLBKABL;GLON@P:9K@H@IAA,N@A@K?9W@Q@K:;ALQ9;L?@QLNG@<9NNR= HL?9;BK<LNNR= B;LGBK< A B@UHXGLNAJ GALKR, :;L<RTLNALQG@:>BKAQ@I@ >;@<NJ SAWAOLB?A= N9I;>W@?.
$BN@<N@P :;AOAN@P NLUH9I@:;AJKN@I@KLOLNAJ 7/#- > K9?A= U@HVNR= J<HJLKBJ AIN@;A;@<9NAL AQA <BL= >I;@Y9XZA=9B:L?K@<BL;GLON@I@NLG@BK9K@ON@BKA;W9U@HL<9NAJ<@WQ@YN@BKA(BKLN@?9;GAABQL;KLHVN@I@A:;@J<HLNAPAB=@G9;;AB?9BL;GLON@P:@KL;A;9U@K@B:@B@UN@BKA A ;9W<AKAJ AN<9HAGN@BKA A G;.). \K@ :;A<@GAK ? NLB@@K<LKBK<>XZLQ> KJYLBKA BL;GLON@I@ W9U@HL<9NAJ @U;9W> YAWNA: @U;9ZLNAX ?<;9O> K@HV?@ < ?;9PNA= BAK>9MAJ= A :;L<RTLNAX G@:>BKAQR= N9I;>W@?,BK;LQHLNAX :;L<@WQ@OV U@HLWNV.
$I;9NAOLNAL SAWAOLB?@P 9?KA<N@BKA > NA=B<JW9N@ AHA B :@J<HLNALQ ANKLNBA<NR= 9NIAN@WNR= :;ABK>:@<, AHA B KJYLH@PBL;GLON@P NLG@BK9K@ON@BKVX.& ?9OLBK<L ?@NLON@P K@O?A > 11 AW 13 U@HVNR= <RBK>:AH9 7-3 III—IV !.N9 Q9?BAQ9HVN@P <@WQ@YN@P KL;9:AA, OK@ @U`JBNJLKBJ KLQ, OK@ <BL :9MALNKR [K@PI;>::R :L;LNLBHA =@KJ UR @GAN /, A U@HVTANBK<@ AW NA= NL :;ANAQ9HAUH@?9K@;R ;LNAN-9NIA@KLNWA<N@P BABKLQR.
';A .1" > U@HVNR= [K@P I;>::RURH@ <RJ<HLN@ QN@I@B@B>GABK@L :@;9YLNAL.$U;9Z9H@ N9 BLUJ <NAQ9NAL N9HAOAL > :9MALNK@< I;>::R & N9HAOAL:;@G@HYAKLHVNR= :L;A@G@< ;LQABBAA 7/#- :;A @KB>KBK<AA ;LI>HJ;N@PQLGA?9QLNK@WN@P KL;9:AA, IA:@HA:AGN@P GALKR, K;LNA;@<@ONR= N9I;>W@? A:;@SAH9?KAOLB?A= <;9OLUNR= @BQ@K;@<. #@HVNRL NL K@HV?@ =@;@T@ B:;9<HJHABV B@URONRQA URK@<RQA N9I;>W?9QA, N@ A ;LI>HJ;N@ :;L<RT9HA ;L?@QLNG@<9NNRP>;@<LNV SAWAOLB?A= N9I;>W@? (N9:;AQL;, K;@L U@HVNR= ?9K9HABV N9 I@;NR=HRY9=, @GN9 U@HVN9J — B QN@I@B@B>GABKRQ :@;9YLNALQ :@ G9NNRQ .1" —;9U@K9H9 NJNLP, :@BK@JNN@ :@GNAQ9J N9 ;>?A GLKLP, G;>I@P U@HVN@P — B Q@U;9W>XZAQ /, < 9N9QNLWL — B9Q@BK@JKLHVN@ :@BK;@AH W9I@;@GNRP G@Q, LZL@GAN NLB?@HV?@ ;9W :;ANAQ9H >O9BKAL < <RB@?@I@;NR= [?B:LGAMAJ= A K.
:.). ';AKZ9KLHVN@Q ;9BB:;@BL <RJBNAH@BV, OK@ > U@HVTANBK<9 AW NA= UR<9HANLANKLNBA<NRL :;ABK>:R BKLN@?9;GAA, @GN9?@ U@HVNRL NL <@B:;ANAQ9HA A= ?9?:;L:JKBK<AL?B@=;9NLNAX:;LYNLPSAWAOLB?@P9?KA<N@BKA.-@WG9H@BV89<:LO9KHLNAL, OK@ O9BK@L :;L<RTLNAL «G@:>BKAQR=» SAWAOLB?A= N9I;>W@? > [KA=U@HVNR= AI;9H@ B?@;LL :@H@YAKLHVN>X, NLYLHA @K;AM9KLHVN>X ;@HV < =9;9?KL;LKLOLNAJ7/#-[34].\K@W9BK9<HJLK<B:@QNAKVSLN@QLN:;L-A:@BK?@NGAMA@NA;@<9NAJ [15, 22].3-+"+U \-(Q ;9U@KR URH :@B<JZLN AW>OLNAX ;9WHAOAP QLYG> I;>::9QA,BS@;QA;@<9NNRQA < W9<ABAQ@BKA @K KA:9 B@Q9K@:L;ML:KA<N@P 9?MLNK>9MAA A=9;9?KL;9 KLOLNAJ 7/#-.#RHA <RGLHLNR K;A ?9;GA@:L;B@NASAMA;@<9NNR= BANG;@Q9:— KA: I — 7/#- B UH9I@:;AJKNRQ, ?@NI;>[NKNRQ ;9BBK;@PBK<> HAON@BKA(B@Q9K@K@NAJ/NL<;@:9KAJ) KLOLNALQ;— KA: II — 7/#- B NLUH9I@:;AJKNRQ, :;@<@MA;@<9NNRQ ;9BBK;@PBK<@QHAON@BKA (BLIQLNK9;N9J GL:L;B@N9HAW9MAJ) KLOLNALQ;— KA: III — 7/#- B NLUH9I@:;AJKNRQ, ?@Q@;UAGNRQ ;9BBK;@PBK<>HAON@BKA (NL<;@:9KAJ) KLOLNALQ.#@HVNRL B ?9;GA@:L;B@NASAMA;@<9NNRQ BANG;@Q@Q I KA:9 NL AQLHA?@NLONR= K@OL?.
0HJ NA= URH@ =9;9?KL;N@ 9G9:KA<N@L :@<LGLNAL < U@HLWNA: KL AWNA=, ?K@ NL :;ANAQ9H :@BK@JNN@ N9WN9OLNN>X QLGA?9QLNK@WN>X KL;9:AX <:@HN@Q @U`LQL, @KQLNJHA LL K@HV?@ < :L;A@GR :;@G@HYAKLHVN@P ;LQABBAA 7/#A <@W@UN@<HJHA LL :;A Q9HLPTA= :;AWN9?9= GLBK9UAHAW9MAA B@BK@JNAJ.
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—3O9B9 >GLHJHA :;@I>H?9Q.
& K@ YL <;LQJ >;@<LNV K;L<@IA @ WG@;@<VL :@ T?9HLSHAI @BK9<9HBJ > NA= B;LGNAQ AHA >QL;LNN@ :@<RTLNNRQ.% U@HVNR= B ?9;GA@:L;B@NASAMA;@<9NNRQ BANG;@Q@Q II KA:9 < ?9OLBK<L.2 URH9 <RJ<HLN9, < :L<>X @OL;LGV, KJYLH9J 7-3 (III—IV !.), NL90:@GG9<9<T9JBJ QLGAMA?9QLNK@WN@P ?@;;L?MAA. % 3 :9MALNK@< AQLH9 QLBK@ ABKLN@?9;GAJ III—IV !.. ';@<LGLNAL ;L<9B?>HJ;AW9MAA > NA= URH@ NL<@WQ@YN@.$GAN U@HVN@P URH N9:;9<HLN N9 AQ:H9NK9MAX CRT-D..9? :@?9W9HA ;LW>HVK9KR ;9BB:;@B9, > :9MALNK@< [K@P I;>::R < 9N9QNLWL?9? :;9<AH@ URHA :;ABK>:R BK9UAHVN@P BKLN@?9;GAA, < K@Q OABHL B;LGNA= AQ9HR= N9I;>W@?, N9 ?@K@;RL @NA NL @U;9Z9HA <NAQ9NAL. ';AOAN@P :L;<@I@@U;9ZLNAJ ? <;9O> A @GN@<;LQLNN@ :L;<RQ 0.- J<HJHBJ $.- (BQ.
![](https://s.studizba.com/z.php?f=/templates/si/i/noavatar.png&w=100&h=100&t=1"){kind=avatar}
