Диссертация (1140840), страница 12
Текст из файла (страница 12)
&@ II I;>::L:;L@UH9G9HA :9MALNKR B III—IV !. 7-3; > NA= K9?YL @KQLOLNR A BNAYLNN9J !&C] A :@<RTLNNRP ?@NLON@-GA9BK@HAOLB?AP @U`LQ C]. '@ @BK9HVNRQ:9;9QLK;9Q \=@." ;9WHAOAJ QLYG> I;>::9QA @KB>KBK<@<9HA.79;9?KL;ABKA?A .1" (<R:@HNLNNRL G@ AHA <@ <;LQJ I@B:AK9HAW9MAA,;L?@QLNG@<9NNRL) 9 K9?YL A= ;LW>HVK9KR :;LGBK9<HLNR < K9UHAML 3.38, 9=9;9?KL;ABKA?9 ;L<9B?>HJ;AW9MAA QA@?9;G9 (<9;A9NKR >YL <R:@HNLNN@P A<@WQ@YN@BKA LL :;@<LGLNAJ) — < K9UHAML 3.39.29UHAM9 3.38. 79;9?KL;ABKA?A ?@;@N9;@9NIA@I;9SAA (n = 104)79;9?KL;ABKA?9";>::R :9MALNK@<I (n = 84)II (n = 11)III (n = 9)2@ONRP ?;AKL;AP!ATL;9.1" <R:@HNLN9 G@I vs II — p > 0,01*I@B:AK9HAW9MAAI vs III — p > 0,01*67(80%)9(82%)6(67%)';@G@HYLNAL K9UHAMR 3.38II vs III — p > 0,01*77.1"I vs II — p > 0,01*;L?@QLNG@<9N9**29(35%)1(9%)2(22%) I vs III — p > 0,01*II vs III — p > 0,01*.1" <R:@HNLN9 <@I vs II — p > 0,01*<;LQJI vs III — p > 0,01*I@B:AK9HAW9MAA25(30%)1(9%)2(22%) II vs III — p > 0,01*';A .1" <RJ<HLN@I vs II — p > 0,01*QN@I@B@B>GABK@LI vs III — p > 0,01*:@;9YLNAL55(65%)4(36%)8(89%) II vs III — p > 0,01*!"#$%&'(#%: * — ;9WHAOAJ BK9KABKAOLB?A NLWN9OAQR;** — :@?9W9NAJ ? .1" > U@HVNR= ULW $.- @:;LGLHJHA :@ ;LW>HVK9K9QN9I;>W@ONR= :;@U.29UHAM9 3.39.
79;9?KL;ABKA?A ;L<9B?>HJ;AW9MAA QA@?9;G9 (n = 104)79;9?KL;ABKA?9";>::R :9MALNK@<I (n = 84)II (n = 11)III (n = 9)2@ONRP ?;AKL;AP!ATL;9)L<9B?>HJ;AW9MAJI vs II — p > 0,01*<R:@HNLN9, < K@QI vs III — p > 0,01*OABHL:26(31%)4(36%)1(11%)II vs III — p > 0,01*1.D;I vs II — p > 0,01*BKLNKA;@<9NAL36(43%)3(27%)1(11%)I vs III — p > 0,01*II vs III — p > 0,01*)L<9B?>HJ;AW9MAJI vs II — p > 0,01*<@WQ@YN9I vs III — p > 0,01*23(27%)0(0%)1(11%)II vs III — p > 0,01*78';@G@HYLNAL K9UHAMR 3.39$K?9W @KI vs II — p > 0,01*;L<9B?>HJ;AW9MAAI vs III — p > 0,01*3(4%)0(0%)1(11%) II vs III — p > 0,01*!"#$%&'(#%: * — ;9WHAOAJ BK9KABKAOLB?A NLWN9OAQR.'@ ?@HAOLBK<> :;@<LGLNNR= .1", <?HXO9J A <R:@HNLNNRL W9 <;LQJI@B:AK9HAW9MAA, A OK@ U@HLL <9YN@, :@ ?@HAOLBK<> <R:@HNLNNR= A :H9NA;>LQR=;L<9B?>HJ;AW9MAP QA@?9;G9 G@BK@<L;NR= ;9WHAOAP QLYG> I;>::9QA NL <RJ<HLN@.79;9?KL;ABKA?A ;L<9B?>HJ;AW9MAA <@ <BL= I;>::9Q K9?YL G@BK@<L;NR= ;9WHAOAPNL AQLHA.)9B:;LGLHLNAL ?@NLONR= K@OL? :;LGBK9<HLN@ < K9UHAML 3.40.
A N9 ;AB>N?L3.10.29UHAM9 3.40. )9B:;LGLHLNAL ?@NLONR= K@OL? (n = 104)'@?9W9KLHV";>::R :9MALNK@<I (n = 84)II (n = 11)2@ONRP ?;AKL;APIII (n =!ATL;99)7-3 III—IV !. N9I vs II — p < 0,001Q9?BAQ9HVN@P KL;9:AAI vs III — p > 0,01*:;A NL<@WQ@YN@PII vs III — p < 0,01;L<9B?>HJ;AW9MAA0(0%)11(100%)1(11%)-KLN@?9;GAJ III—IV !.I vs II — p > 0,01*:;A NL<@WQ@YN@PI vs III — p < 0,001;L<9B?>HJ;AW9MAA0(0%)3(27%)8(89%)II vs III — p < 0,001-@OLK9NAL :L;<R= G<>=0(0%)3(27%)0(0%)I vs II — p < 0,001<9;A9NK@< (7-3 AI vs III — p > 0,01*BKLN@?9;GAA III—IV !.)II vs III — p > 0,01*!"#$%&'(#%: * — ;9WHAOAJ BK9KABKAOLB?A NLWN9OAQR79)AB>N@? 3.10.
)9B:;LGLHLNAL ?@NLONR= K@OL? (n = 104)3.2.3. D+OQ*(L&-&+K-J '+*J&PW K "($*%N&PO% -%Q(O%I("#%+QL"K+&%[%T%"+/(&&PW K%"+O+/)LW>HVK9KRAW>OLNAJ?@Q:H9LNKN@BKAU@HVNR=:@K;LQ@BN@<NRQN9:;9<HLNAJQ (@U;9W YAWNA, :;ALQ HL?9;BK<LNNR= :;L:9;9K@<, B@UHXGLNAL;L?@QLNG@<9NNR= N9I;>W@?) :;LGBK9<HLNR < K9UHAM9= 3.41—3.43.29UHAM9 3.41. )LW>HVK9KR AW>OLNAJ ?@Q:H9LNKN@BKA (n = 104): B@UHXGLNAL;L?@QLNG@<9NN@I@ @U;9W9 YAWNA'@?9W9KLHV?@Q:H9LNKN@BKA";>::R :9MALNK@<I (n = 84)II (n = 11)III (n = 9)2@ONRP ?;AKL;AP!ATL;9-@UHXGLNALI vs II — p > 0,01*IA:@HA:AGN@PI vs III — p > 0,01*GALKR,30(36%)1(8%)5(56%)II vs III — p < 0,0180';@G@HYLNAL K9UHAMR 3.41< K@Q OABHL::@BK@JNN@I vs II — p > 0,01*21(25%)0(0%)2(22%) I vs III — p > 0,01*II vs III — p > 0,01*.>;LNAL K9U9?9,I vs II — p > 0,01*I vs III — p > 0,01*30(36%)6(55%)3(33%) II vs III — p > 0,01*< K@Q OABHLI vs II — p > 0,01*:;@G@HY9XKI vs III — p > 0,01*?>;AKV19(23%)6(55%)0(0%)II vs III — p < 0,01!"#$%&'(#%: * — ;9WHAOAJ BK9KABKAOLB?A NLWN9OAQR.29UHAM9 3.42.
)LW>HVK9KR AW>OLNAJ ?@Q:H9LNKN@BKA: :;ALQ HL?9;BK<LNNR=:;L:9;9K@< (n = 104)'@?9W9KLHV?@Q:H9LNKN@BKA";>::R :9MALNK@<I (n = 84)II (n = 11)III (n = 9)';ALQ BK9KAN@<,2@ONRP ?;AKL;AP!ATL;9I vs II — p > 0,01*I vs III — p > 0,01*61(73%)9(82%)3(33%)< K@Q OABHL::@BK@JNN@II vs III — p > 0,01*I vs II — p > 0,01*40(48%)5(45%)2(22%)I vs III — p > 0,01*II vs III — p > 0,01*';ALQI vs II — p > 0,01*9NKA9I;LI9NK@<,I vs III — p > 0,01*75(89%)7(64%)6(67%)II vs III — p > 0,01*81';@G@HYLNAL K9UHAMR 3.42< K@Q OABHL::@BK@JNN@I vs II — p > 0,01*57(68%)6(55%)6(67%) I vs III — p > 0,01*II vs III — p > 0,01*';ALQ ULK9-81(96%)10(91%)8(89%) I vs II — p > 0,01*UH@?9K@;@<,I vs III — p > 0,01*II vs III — p > 0,01*< K@Q OABHL:I vs II — p > 0,01*:@BK@JNN@I vs III — p > 0,01*57(68%)5(45%)4(44%) II vs III — p > 0,01*I vs II — p > 0,01*';ALQ A1'!/#)1,72(86%)7(64%)7(78%) I vs III — p > 0,01*II vs III — p > 0,01*< K@Q OABHL:61(73%)3(27%)3(33%) I vs II — p > 0,01*:@BK@JNN@I vs III — p > 0,01*II vs III — p > 0,01*!"#$%&'(#%: * — ;9WHAOAJ BK9KABKAOLB?A NLWN9OAQR.29UHAM9 3.43.
)LW>HVK9KR AW>OLNAJ ?@Q:H9LNKN@BKA: B@UHXGLNAL K;LNA;@<@ONR=A URK@<R= N9I;>W@? (n = 104)79;9?KL;ABKA?9";>::R :9MALNK@<I (n = 84)II (n = 11)III (n = 9)2@ONRP ?;AKL;AP!ATL;9&R:@HNLNALI vs II — p > 0,01*K;LNA;@<@ONR=I vs III — p > 0,01*N9I;>W@?23(27%)0(0%)2(22%)II vs III — p > 0,01*82';@G@HYLNAL K9UHAMR 3.43&R:@HNLNAL;L?@QLNG@<9NNR=32(38%)10(91%)0(0%)I vs II — p < 0,001URK@<R= N9I;>W@?, <I vs III — p > 0,01*K@Q OABHL:II vs III — p < 0,001:;L<RT9XK;@I;9NAOA<9XKI vs III — p > 0,01*I vs III — p < 0,0130(36%)1(9%)8(89%) II vs III — p < 0,01!"#$%&'(#%: * — ;9WHAOAJ BK9KABKAOLB?A NLWN9OAQR.';AAW>OLNAA?@Q:H9LNKN@BKA:9MALNK@<B;9WHAONRQAKA:9QA?9;GA@:L;B@NASAMA;@<9NNR= BANG;@Q@< (BQ.
K9UHAMR 3.41—3.43) BK9N@<AKBJ@OL<AGNRQ, OK@ @NA G@BK@<L;N@ @KHAO9XKBJ @KN@TLNALQ ? N9I;>W?9Q. '9MALNKR B?9;GA@:L;B@NASAMA;@<9NNRQ BANG;@Q@Q II KA:9 (10 AW 11) :;L<RT9HAG@:>BKAQRL N9I;>W?A, :;A [K@Q NA @GAN AW NA= NL K;LNA;@<9HBJ.'9MALNKR B ?9;GA@:L;B@NASAMA;@<9NNRQ BANG;@Q@Q III KA:9 O;LWQL;N@@I;9NAOA<9HA URK@<RL N9I;>W?A; K@HV?@ 2 OLH@<L?9 W9NAQ9HABV «K;LNA;@<?9QA»— :;@I>H?9QA < QLGHLNN@Q KLQ:L :@ 30—60 QAN>K..@Q:H9LNKN@BKV<@KN@TLNAA:@BK@JNN@I@:;ALQ9HL?9;BK<LNNR=:;L:9;9K@< URH9 NAW?@P <@ <BL= I;>::9=. 2LQ NL QLNLL, :;A KZ9KLHVN@Q 9N9HAWLBK9H@ @OL<AGN@, OK@ U@HVNRL I-P I;>::R, LBHA A :;L?;9Z9HA KL;9:AX, GLH9HA [K@K@HV?@ :@BHL GHAKLHVN@I@ :L;A@G9 BK9UAHVN@I@ KLOLNAJ 7/#-; < K@ YL <;LQJU@HVNRL II-P I;>::R, :L;LBK9<9<TAL :;ANAQ9KV QLGA?9QLNKR, @K?9WR<9HABV @KNA= <B?@;L :@BHL <R:AB?A AW BK9MA@N9;9.
59BKV U@HVNR= [K@P I;>::R (5 OLH@<L?):@G G9<HLNALQ ;@GBK<LNNA?@< <BL YL :;ANAQ9H9 BK9KANR, 9B:A;AN A ULK9UH@?9K@;R, N@ A1'! :@BK@JNN@ :@H>O9HA K@HV?@ 3. 3L@U=@GAQ@ @KQLKAKV, OK@83U@HVNRL III-P I;>::R, G9YL :;ANAQ9<TAL HL?9;BK<LNNRL :;L:9;9KR :@BK@JNN@,B9Q@BK@JKLHVN@ >QLNVT9HA A= G@WA;@<?>.&RJ<HLNR G@BK@<L;NRL ;9WHAOAJ QLYG> II-P A III-P I;>::9QA :@ AWQLNLNAX@U;9W> YAWNA — GALK9, ?>;LNAL (BQ.
K9UHAM> 3.41), N@ NL @?9W9H@BV G@BK@<L;NR=;9WHAOAP QLYG> ?9YG@P AW NA= A I-P I;>::@P.8412!3! VI. 0,>:@645)4 A02:B455;C 847:2=9!903";>::R U@HVNR= (1, #, &), BS@;QA;@<9NNRL < W9<ABAQ@BKA @K KA:9B@Q9K@:L;ML:KA<N@P ?@NBKAK>MAA, NL @KHAO9HABV G;>I @K G;>I9 :@ B@MA@GLQ@I;9SAOLB?@P =9;9?KL;ABKA?L (LGANBK<LNN@L G@BK@<L;N@L ;9WHAOAL URH@<RJ<HLN@ :@ ILNGL;N@Q> :;AWN9?> QLYG> I;>::9QA 1 A # — < I;>::L #:;L@UH9G9HA YLNZANR), S@N@<@P :9K@H@IAA, <@W;9BK> ;9W<AKAJ :L;<@I@ 0.-,?@HAOLBK<> :L;LNLBLNNR= /, A ;L<9B?>HJ;AW9MAP QA@?9;G9. 2LQ NL QLNLL, URHA<RJ<HLNR G@BK@<L;NRL ;9WHAOAJ QLYG> <BLQA I;>::9QA :@ =9;9?KL;> KLOLNAJ7/#- (UH9I@:;AJKN@L/NLUH9I@:;AJKN@L)29?AQ @U;9W@Q, QL"/PU \-(Q ABBHLG@<9NAJ :@?9W9H, OK@ ;9BBK;@PBK<9HAON@BKA :@ KA:> B@Q9K@K@NAA J<HJLKBJ S9?K@;@Q UH9I@:;AJKN@I@ KLOLNAJ 7/#-,9 ;9BBK;@PBK<9 :@ KA:> BLIQLNK9;N@P GL:L;B@N9HAW9MAA — BL;VLWNRP S9?K@;NLUH9I@:;AJKN@I@ KLOLNAJ 7/#-.
\KA G9NNRL ?@;;LHA;>XK B 9N9HAW@Q <HAJNAJ;9BBK;@PBK< HAON@BKA, :;@<LGLNNRQ < ;9U@K9= F.,. 3A?AKAN@P (2009) A !.F..@:RH@<9 (2009) [23, 31], @GN9?@ > N9B AQLXKBJ B>ZLBK<LNNRL ;9B=@YGLNAJ <@MLN?L O9BK@KR UH9I@:;AJKN@I@ A NLUH9I@:;AJKN@I@ KLOLNAJ 7/#- < N9TA=<RU@;?9= (< ;9U@KL F.,.
3A?AKAN@P > U@HVTLP O9BKA U@HVNR= URH@NLUH9I@:;AJKN@L KLOLNAL 7/#-, < N9TLP — UH9I@:;AJKN@L). '@-<AGAQ@Q>, [K@B<JW9N@ B ;9WNAMLP < @:;LGLHLNAA ?@NLONR= K@OL? < N9TA= ABBHLG@<9NAJ= (BQ.;9WGLH 1.3. — «,LK@G@H@IAOLB?AL :;@UHLQR AW>OLNAJ :;@IN@W9 > U@HVNR=7/#-»).0HJ>K@ONLNAJ;9WHAOAPQLYG>:9MALNK9QABNL<;@:9KAOLB?@P?@NBKAK>MALP, AQL<TA= UH9I@:;AJKN@L A NLUH9I@:;AJKN@L KLOLNAL 7/#-, URH85:;@<LGLN G@:@HNAKLHVNRP 9N9HAW [KA= G<>= I;>:: (I;>::R11 A 12). & I;>::L 11G@BK@<L;N@ O9ZL AQLH QLBK@ -0 2-I@ KA:9.-0 — B9Q@BK@JKLHVNRP S9?K@; ;AB?9 ;9W<AKAJ /#- A NLW9<ABAQRP:;LGA?K@;BL;GLON@-B@B>GABKR=@BH@YNLNAPABQL;KA,@B@ULNN@:;ANL?@NK;@HA;>LQ@P IA:L;IHA?LQAA, > YLNZAN — @B@ULNN@.
% [K@P ?9KLI@;AAU@HVNR= ?@NK;@HV N9G @BN@<NRQA S9?K@;9QA ;AB?9, <?HXO9J 10, GABHA:AGLQAX,AWURK@ONRP<LB,NAW?>XSAWAOLB?>X9?KA<N@BKV,?>;LNAL,G@HYLN@B>ZLBK<HJKVBJ B @B@U@P KZ9KLHVN@BKVX. ';A QLGA?9QLNK@WN@Q HLOLNAA /#- N9S@NL -0 @UJW9KLHVN@ N9WN9OLNAL ANIAUAK@;@< 1'! (AHA #)1) A BK9KAN@<.4LHL<RQ >;@<NLQ 9;KL;A9HVN@I@ G9<HLNAJ :;A -0 BOAK9XK < 140/80 QQ ;K. BK[78].';A :BA=A9K;AOLB?@Q @UBHLG@<9NAA > U@HVNR= I;>::R 11 < @BN@<N@Q URHA<RJ<HLNR K;L<@YN@-A:@=@NG;AOLB?AL ;L9?MAA, I;>::R 12 — NL<;@KAOLB?9JA:@=@NG;AJ. % :9MALNK@< I;>::R # :;L@UH9G9HA A:@=@NG;AOLB?AL ;L9?MAA(Q9B?A;@<9NN9J A B<L;=MLNN9J). & I;>::L & :BA=@B@Q9KAOLB?AP BANG;@Q@:;LGLHJHBJ J<HLNAJQA 9UL;;9KN@P A:@=@NG;AA.& N9TLQ ABBHLG@<9NAA > U@HVNR= B Q9B?A;@<9NN@P A:@=@NG;ALP@KQLO9H@BV UH9I@:;AJKN@L KLOLNAL 7/#-, OK@ :;@KA<@;LOAK ;LW>HVK9K9Q F.,.3A?AKAN@P (2009) A !.F.
.@:RH@<9 (2009), < ;9U@K9= ?@K@;R= Q9B?A;@<9NN9JA:@=@NG;AJ N9;9<NL B 9UUL;9NKN@P 9BB@MAA;@<9H9BV B U@HTAQ ?@HAOLBK<@Q?@NLONR= K@OL? [23, 31]. - N9TLP K@O?A W;LNAJ [K@ B<JW9N@ B NL:;9<AHVN@PGA9IN@BKA?@P Q9B?A;@<9NN@P A:@=@NG;AA < >?9W9NNR= ;9U@K9=, K9? ?9?:;A<LGLNN@L @:AB9NAL U@HVNR= B?@;LL B@@K<LKBK<>LK ;9BBK;@PBK<> HAON@BKA :@KA:> BLIQLNK9;N@P GL:L;B@N9HAW9MAA.















