Диссертация (1140840), страница 11
Текст из файла (страница 11)
8L$.*J-(-P I("#%+*+Z%NLKI+Z+ +'K*L#+/(&%M&;LQJ, :;@TLGTLL, @K :L;<@I@ 0.- G@ <?HXOLNAJ :9MALNK@< <ABBHLG@<9NAL :;LGBK9<HLN@ < K9UHAML 3.26, A B;LGNAP <@W;9BK, < ?@K@;@Q N9TA:9MALNKR :L;LNLBHA [K@ B@URKAL — < K9UHAML 3.27.29UHAM9 3.26. -;LGNAP B;@?, :;@TLGTAP @K :L;<@I@ 0.- G@ <?HXOLNAJ:9MALNK@< (n = 104) < ABBHLG@<9NAL79;9?KL;ABKA?9";>::R :9MALNK@<I (n = 84)II (n = 11)III (n = 9)-;LGNAP (M ± m)B;@? @K :L;<@I@ 0.-2@ONRP ?;AKL;AP!ATL;9I vs II — p > 0,01*9,6 ± 6,410,3 ± 7,75,7 ± 2,4G@ <?HXOLNAJ <ABBHLG@<9NAL, HLK!"#$%&'(#%: * — ;9WHAOAJ BK9KABKAOLB?A NLWN9OAQR.I vs III — p > 0,01*II vs III — p > 0,01*6929UHAM9 3.27. -;LGNAP <@W;9BK, < ?@K@;@Q :9MALNKR, <?HXOLNNRL < ABBHLG@<9NAL(n = 104) :L;LNLBHA :L;<@L 0.79;9?KL;ABKA?9";>::R :9MALNK@<I (n = 84)II (n = 11)!ATL;9III (n = 9)-;LGNAP (M ± m)<@W;9BK, HLK2@ONRP ?;AKL;API vs II — p > 0,01*64 ± 13,567,8 ± 8,969,5 ± 8,1I vs III — p > 0,01*II vs III — p > 0,01*!"#$%&'(#%: * — ;9WHAOAJ BK9KABKAOLB?A NLWN9OAQR..9? <AGN@ AW K9UHAM, @U9 :@?9W9KLHJ <@ <BL= I;>::9= G@BK@<L;N@ NL;9WHAO9HABV.0ABHA:AGLQAJ URH9 @UN9;>YLN9 > <BL= :9MALNK@<, <?HXOLNNR= <ABBHLG@<9NAJ; G;>IAL S@N@<RL W9U@HL<9NAJ :@ I;>::9Q :;LGBK9<HLNR < K9UHAML3.28.29UHAM9 3.28.
!@N@<RL W9U@HL<9NAJ (n = 104)69U@HL<9NAL";>::R :9MALNK@<I (n = 84)II (n = 11)III (n = 9)"A:L;K@NAOLB?9JU@HLWNV2@ONRP ?;AKL;AP!ATL;9I vs II — p > 0,01*79(94%)10(91%)9(100%)I vs III — p > 0,01*II vs III — p > 0,01*-9=9;NRP GA9ULK37(44%)3(27%)8(89%)I vs II — p > 0,01*I vs III — p > 0,01*II vs III — p > 0,01*$YA;LNAL24(29%)4(36%)4(44%)I vs II — p > 0,01*I vs III — p > 0,01*II vs III — p > 0,01*!"#$%&'(#%: * — ;9WHAOAJ BK9KABKAOLB?A NLWN9OAQR.700@BK@<L;NR= ;9WHAOAP :@ S@N@<RQ W9U@HL<9NAJQ K9?YL @UN9;>YLN@ NLURH@.$B@ULNN@BKA KLOLNAJ /#- :;LGBK9<HLNR < K9UHAML 3.29.29UHAM9 3.29.
$B@ULNN@BKA KLOLNAJ /#- (n = 104)0@BK@<L;NRL?@;@N9;NRL B@URKAJ";>::R :9MALNK@<I (n = 84)II (n = 11)III (n = 9))L<9B?>HJ;AW9MAJQA@?9;G92@ONRP ?;AKL;AP!ATL;9I vs II — p > 0,01*50(60%)7(64%)2(22%)I vs III — p < 0,05*II vs III — p > 0,01*/NS9;?K QA@?9;G9,69(82%)11(100%)8(89%)I vs II — p < 0,05*I vs III — p > 0,01*II vs III — p < 0,05*< K@Q OABHL:23(27%)3(27%)2(22%):@<K@;NRP;I vs II — p > 0,01*I vs III — p > 0,01*II vs III — p > 0,01*!"#$%&'(#%: * — ;9WHAOAJ BK9KABKAOLB?A NLWN9OAQR.7@KJ B >OLK@Q :@:;9<?A #@NSL;;@NA QR NL :@H>OAHA G@BK@<L;N@BKA;9WHAOAP QLYG> I;>::9QA, N@ @U;9Z9LK N9 BLUJ <NAQ9NAL KLNGLNMAJ ? U@HVTLQ>OABH> U@HVNR=, :L;LNLBTA= /,, <@ II-P I;>::L, 9 K9?YL ? QLNVTLQ> OABH>U@HVNR=, :L;LNLBTA= @:L;9MAA ;L<9B?>HJ;AW9MAA QA@?9;G9, < III-P I;>::L.-;LGNLL OABH@ 0.-, :;A=@GJZLLBJ N9 @GN@I@ :9MALNK9, K9?YL G@BK@<L;NR=;9WHAOAP NL AQLH@ (I I;>::9 — 1,7 ± 1,1, II — 1,9 ± 0,8, III — 1,3 ± 0,9).';AOANR :L;<@I@ @U;9ZLNAJ ? <;9O> :@ :@<@G> /#- :;LGBK9<HLNR <K9UHAML 3.30, 9 :;AOANR I@B:AK9HAW9MAA :;A <?HXOLNAA < ABBHLG@<9NAL — <K9UHAML 3.31.7129UHAM9 3.30.
';AOANR :L;<@I@ @U;9ZLNAJ :9MALNK@< (n = 104) ? <;9O> :@ :@<@G>/#';AOAN9";>::R :9MALNK@<I (n = 84)II (n = 11)2@ONRP ?;AKL;AP!ATL;9III (n =9)$BK;RP?@;@N9;NRPI vs II — p < 0,0138(45%)11(100%)2(22%)BANG;@Q, < K@QI vs III — p >0,01*II vs III — p < 0,01OABHL:ANS9;?K QA@?9;G9; 25(30%)4(36%)2(22%)I vs II — p > 0,01*I vs III — p > 0,01*II vs III — p > 0,01*NLBK9UAHVN9J13(15%)7(64%)0(0%)BKLN@?9;GAJ;I vs II — p > 0,01*I vs III — p > 0,01*II vs III — p > 0,01*BK9UAHVN9J46(55%)0(0%)7(78%)BKLN@?9;GAJI vs II — p > 0,01*I vs III — p > 0,01*II vs III — p > 0,01*!"#$%&'(#%: * — ;9WHAOAJ BK9KABKAOLB?A NLWN9OAQR.29UHAM9 3.31.
';AOAN9 I@B:AK9HAW9MAA :;A <?HXOLNAA :9MALNK@< < ABBHLG@<9NAL(n = 104)';AOAN9";>::R :9MALNK@<I (n = 84)II (n = 11)III (n = 9)$BK;RP ?@;@N9;NRPBANG;@Q2@ONRP ?;AKL;AP!ATL;9I vs II — p < 0,0016(7%)0(0%)8(89%)I vs III — p < 0,01II vs III — p < 0,05*72';@G@HYLNAL K9UHAMR 3.31';@I;LBBA;@<9NAL15(18%)11(100%)1(11%) I vs II — p < 0,01=;@NAOLB?@PI vs III — p > 0,01*BL;GLON@PII vs III — p < 0,01NLG@BK9K@ON@BKA0;>IAL :;AOANR**63(75%)0(0%)0(0%)I vs II — p < 0,01I vs III — p < 0,01II vs III — p > 0,01*!"#$%&'(#%: * — ;9WHAOAJ BK9KABKAOLB?A NLWN9OAQR;** — :@BKL:LNN@L :;@I;LBBA;@<9NAL BKLN@?9;GAA, :@GI@K@<?9 ? @:L;9KA<NRQ<QLT9KLHVBK<9Q, GLBK9UAHAW9MAJ 10.5K@ ?9B9LKBJ :;AOANR I@B:AK9HAW9MAA :;A <?HXOLNAA < ABBHLG@<9NAL, K@@UN9;>YLNR G@BK@<L;NRL ;9WHAOAJ QLYG> <BLQA I;>::9QA: @BN@<N9J :;AOAN9I@B:AK9HAW9MAA <@ II-P I;>::L — :;@I;LBBA;@<9NAL 7-3, 9 < III-P — ;9W<AKAL$.-.!>N?MA@N9HVNRP ?H9BB BKLN@?9;GAA > N9TA= :9MALNK@< :;A :@BK>:HLNAA:;LGBK9<HLN < K9UHAML 3.32.29UHAM9 3.32.
!>N?MA@N9HVNRP ?H9BB BKLN@?9;GAA :;A :@BK>:HLNAA (n = 104)'@?9W9KLHV";>::R :9MALNK@<I (n = 84)II (n = 11)III (n = 9)2@ONRP ?;AKL;AP!ATL;9!>N?MA@N9HVNRP?H9BB BKLN@?9;GAA,I vs II — p < 0,01< K@Q OABHL:I vs III — p < 0,01I—II60(71%)0(0%)0(0%)II vs III — p > 0,01*73';@G@HYLNAL K9UHAMR 3.32III—IV24(29%)3(27%)8(89%) I vs II — p > 0,01*I vs III — p < 0,01II vs III — p < 0,01!"#$%&'(#%: * — ;9WHAOAJ BK9KABKAOLB?A NLWN9OAQR..9? <AGN@ AW K9UHAMR, > U@HVNR= I-P I;>::R :;A :@BK>:HLNAA G@BK@<L;N@O9ZL AQLH9 QLBK@BKLN@?9;GAJ NAW?@I@ !., 9 > U@HVNR= III-P I;>::R — <RB@?@I@.';A AW>OLNAA UA@=AQAOLB?A= 9N9HAW@< ?;@<A G@BK@<L;NR= ;9WHAOAP QLYG>I;>::9QA NL <RJ<HLN@.
09NNRL :@ >;@<NJQ IHX?@WR A C'3' :;LGBK9<HLNR <K9UHAML 3.33.29UHAM9 3.33. -@GL;Y9NAL < :H9WQL ?;@<A C'3' A IHX?@WR (n = 104)-;LGNAL (M ± m)WN9OLNAJ :@?9W9KLHJ";>::R :9MALNK@<I (n = 84)II (n = 11)III (n = 9)CA:@:;@KLAGRNAW?@P :H@KN@BKA,2@ONRP ?;AKL;AP!ATL;9I vs II — p > 0,01*3,1 ± 1,22,5 ± 0,93,3 ± 1,6I/HI vs III — p > 0,01*II vs III — p > 0,01*"HX?@W9, QQ@HV/H6,1 ± 1,95,7 ± 0,76,4 ± 1,9I vs II — p > 0,01*I vs III — p > 0,01*II vs III — p > 0,01*!"#$%&'(#%: * — ;9WHAOAJ BK9KABKAOLB?A NLWN9OAQR.%;@<LNV 10 A 5-- :;A :@BK>:HLNAA (K9UHAM9 3.34), 9 K9?YL 5-- :@G9NNRQ =@HKL;@<B?@I@ Q@NAK@;A;@<9NAJ \." (K9UHAM9 3.35) <@ <BL= I;>::9=G@BK@<L;NR= ;9WHAOAP NL AQLH.7429UHAM9 3.34.
5-- A 10 > :9MALNK@<, <?HXOLNNR= < ABBHLG@<9NAL (n = 104)-;LGNAL (M ± m)WN9OLNAJ :@?9W9KLHJ";>::R :9MALNK@<I (n = 84)II (n = 11)III (n = 9)5--2@ONRP ?;AKL;AP!ATL;9I vs II — p > 0,01*67,9 ± 11,776,1 ± 15,178,2 ± 17,2I vs III — p > 0,01*II vs III — p > 0,01*10, QQ ;K.BK.,135,2 ±121,7 ±< K@Q OABHL:20,621,2143,3 ± 29,6 I vs II — p > 0,01*I vs III — p > 0,01*BABK@HAOLB?@L;GA9BK@HAOLB?@LII vs III — p > 0,01*79,3 ± 9,477,3 ± 10,287,2 ± 13,5I vs II — p > 0,01*I vs III — p > 0,01*II vs III — p > 0,01*!"#$%&'(#%: * — ;9WHAOAJ BK9KABKAOLB?A NLWN9OAQR.29UHAM9 3.35. 5-- (:@ G9NNRQ =@HKL;@<B?@I@ Q@NAK@;A;@<9NAJ \.") A 10(n = 104)-;LGNAL (M ± m)WN9OLNAJ :@?9W9KLHJ";>::R :9MALNK@<I (n = 84)II (n = 11)III (n = 9)5-- B;LGNJJ2@ONRP ?;AKL;AP!ATL;9I vs II — p > 0,01*64,8 ± 7,869,5 ± 11,065,8 ± 9,7I vs III — p > 0,01*II vs III — p > 0,01*5-- QANAQ9HVN9J49,3 ± 6,655,3 ± 9,050,1 ± 10,8 I vs II — p > 0,01*I vs III — p > 0,01*II vs III — p > 0,01*5-- Q9?BAQ9HVN9J100 ± 19,8102,5 ±96,9 ± 19,4 I vs II — p > 0,01*15,6I vs III — p > 0,01*II vs III — p > 0,01*!"#$%&'(#%: * — ;9WHAOAJ BK9KABKAOLB?A NLWN9OAQR.75!>N?MA@N9HVNRP ?H9BB 7-3 > N9TA= :9MALNK@< :;A :@BK>:HLNAA:;LGBK9<HLN<K9UHAML3.36,9;LW>HVK9KR\=@."(<?HXO9J:;AWN9?AS@;QA;@<9NAJ IA:L;K@NAOLB?@I@ BL;GM9) — < K9UHAML 3.37.29UHAM9 3.36.
!>N?MA@N9HVNRP ?H9BB 7-3 :;A :@BK>:HLNAA (n = 104)'@?9W9KLHV";>::R :9MALNK@<I (n = 84)II (n = 11)2@ONRP ?;AKL;APIII (n = 9)!ATL;9!>N?MA@N9HVNRPI vs II — p < 0,001?H9BB 7-3, < K@QI vs III — p < 0,001OABHL:II vs III — p < 0,010— II;78(93%)0(0%)0(0%)III—IV6(7%)11(100%)1(11%)I vs II — p < 0,01I vs III — p > 0,01*II vs III — p < 0,01!"#$%&'(#%: * — ;9WHAOAJ BK9KABKAOLB?A NLWN9OAQR29UHAM9 3.37. )LW>HVK9KR \=@." :;A :@BK>:HLNAA (n = 104)'@?9W9KLHV";>::R :9MALNK@<I (n = 84)II (n = 11)III (n = 9)&RJ<HLN9 GAH9K9MAJC]2@ONRP ?;AKL;AP!ATL;9I vs II — p > 0,01*51(61%)9(82%)5(56%)I vs III — p > 0,01*II vs III — p > 0,01*&RJ<HLN9I vs II — p > 0,01*IA:L;K;@SAJ C]I vs III — p > 0,01*&RJ<HLN953(63%)6(15%)6(67%)II vs III — p > 0,01*22(26%)4(36%)3(33%)I vs II — p > 0,01*GA9BK@HAOLB?9JI vs III — p > 0,01*GABS>N?MAJII vs III — p > 0,01*76';@G@HYLNAL K9UHAMR 3.37-;LGNAL (M ± m)I vs II — p <0,01WN9OLNAJ S;9?MAAI vs III — p > 0,01*<RU;@B9 C], %53,1 ± 11,641,9 ± 17,952,3 ± 12,8 II vs III — p > 0,01*-;LGNAL (M ± m)I vs II — p <0,01WN9OLNAJ ?@NLON@-I vs III — p > 0,01*GA9BK@HAOLB?@I@100,3 ±@U`LQ9 C], QQ42,3102,3 ±149 ± 78,4II vs III — p > 0,01*73,3!"#$%&'(#%: * — ;9WHAOAJ BK9KABKAOLB?A NLWN9OAQR.9? <AGN@ AW K9UHAM, :@ S>N?MA@N9HVN@Q> ?H9BB> 7-3 > :9MALNK@< :;A:@BK>:HLNAA B>ZLBK<@<9HA G@BK@<L;N@ <R;9YLNNRL ;9WHAOAJ.














