Диссертация (1140840), страница 10
Текст из файла (страница 10)
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— 4.61,9B?A;@<9NNRL :;@J<HLNAJ ;9BBK;@PBK< HAON@BKA :@ KA:> BLIQLNK9;N@PGL:L;B@N9HAW9MAA AQLHA QLBK@ LZL W9G@HI@ G@ Q9NASLBK9MAA B@Q9KAOLB?@P:9K@H@IAA:@KQLO9H9BVNLW9ANKL;LB@<9NN@BKV<:@GGL;Y9NAA=@;@TLPSAWAOLB?@P S@;QR (NL;LI>HJ;N@L :AK9NAL; @KB>KBK<AL ;LYAQ9 @KGR=9, «NL K;9KAH<;LQLNA N9 WG@;@<VL»), B@OLK9XZ9JBJ B SAWAOLB?@P <RN@BHA<@BKVX (:;@BK>GNRLW9U@HL<9NAJ :L;LN@BAH «N9 N@I9=») A @KB>KBK<ALQ 9BKLNAOLB?@I@ :9KKL;N9 (:;AB@?;9ZLNN@Q ?@HAOLBK<L BN9 NL AB:RKR<9HA GNL<N@P B@NHA<@BKA, B@=;9NJHA;9U@K@B:@B@UN@BKV).CAON@BKNRL9N@Q9HAA(BQ.K9UHAM>3.22):;AAW>OLNN@QKA:L:BA=@B@Q9KAOLB?A= B@@KN@TLNAP :;LGBK9<HLNR TAW@AGNRQ (5 N9UHXGLNAP),IA:L;KAQNRQ (5 N9UHXGLNAP) A :9;9N@AGNRQ (1 N9UHXGLNAL) ;9BBK;@PBK<@QHAON@BKA.'BA=@B@Q9KAOLB?APBANG;@Q@:;LGLHJHBJJ<HLNAJQA9UL;;9NKN@PA:@=@NG;AA.
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«:;L:JKBK<ALQ N9:>KA».2JYLH@LAN<9HAGAWA;>XZLLW9U@HL<9NAL:L;LYA<9H@BVNL?9?U@HLWNLNN@L B@BK@JNAL, 9 ?9? :@KLNMA9HVN@ >BK;9NAQ9J :;LI;9G9 (ANKL;:;LK9MAJ62:9K@H@IAA?9?«?;9K?@<;LQLNN@I@BU@J»<@;I9NAWQL),<;LQLNN@@I;9NAOA<9<9XZ9J B@MA9HVN>X 9?KA<N@BKV.
';A [K@Q G9YL @:L;9KA<N@Q><QLT9KLHVBK<> :9MALNK :;AB<9A<9H BK9K>B ;>KANN@I@ B@URKAJ < OL;LGL:@<BLGNL<NR= @UBK@JKLHVBK<.-HLG>LK @KQLKAKV, OK@ G9YL WN9OAQRL U@HLWNLNNRL :;@J<HLNAJ /#(:;ABK>:R BKLN@?9;GAA A/AHA @GRT?9 < :@?@L, W9KJYNRL 9NIAN@WNRL :;ABK>:R,NL ?>:A;>LQRL :;ALQ@Q NAK;9K@<) NL ANKL;:;LKA;@<9HABV G@HYNRQ @U;9W@Q A NL<RWR<9HA @:9BLNAP W9 WG@;@<VL, U@HVNRL <@B:;ANAQ9HA [K@ HATV ?9? <;LQLNN>X:@QL=> ;9U@KL, ><HLOLNAJQ.% G<>= :9MALNK@< :;@J<HLNAJ 9UL;;9NKN@P A:@=@NG;AA AQLHA QLBK@ A G@Q9NASLBK9MAA /#- < <AGL NLG@@MLN?A <R;9YLNN@BKA BAQ:K@Q@< W9U@HL<9NAP<N>K;LNNA= @;I9N@<, OK@ :;A<LH@ ? ;9W<AKAX BL;VLWNR= @BH@YNLNAP (<@KB>KBK<AA KL;9:AA JW<R YLH>G?9 — >;ILNKN9J I@B:AK9HAW9MAJ :@ :@<@G>:;@U@GLNAJ JW<R; NLB<@L<;LQLNN@L @U;9ZLNAL :;A 9::LNGAMAKL, :@<HL?TLLIN@PN@L <@B:9HLNAL U;XTANR)..HANAOLB?9J ?9;KAN9 =9;9?KL;AW@<9H9BV :L;BABKA;>XZAQ (NLBQ@K;J N9U@HLWNV) B9Q@B@WN9NALQ WG@;@<@I@ OLH@<L?9 B NLG@@MLN?@P KJYLBKA B@UBK<LNN@I@B@BK@JNAJ A BK;LQHLNALQ ? QANAQAW9MAA :;LGBK9<HLNAP @ <@WQ@YN@P ?@;@N9;N@P?9K9BK;@SL.#@HLWNLNNRL :;@J<HLNAJ /#- (:;ABK>:R BKLN@?9;GAA :;A SAWAOLB?@PN9I;>W?L, @GRT?9) ANKL;:;LKA;@<9HABV HATV ?9? NLWN9OAKLHVNRL @K?H@NLNAJ @KN@;Q9HVN@I@ S>N?MA@NA;@<9NAJ @;I9NAWQ9 A ;9BMLNA<9HABV ?9? <;LQLNN9J,:;L@G@HAQ9J «:@QL=9» GHJ :;A<RON@I@ @U;9W9 YAWNA./N@IG9 :;A G9NN@Q KA:L B@@KN@TLNAP ;9BBK;@PBK< HAON@BKA A 7/#U@HVNRL,NL AB:RKR<9XZAL K;L<@IA W9 B<@L WG@;@<VL, :;ANAQ9HA HL?9;BK<LNNRL:;L:9;9KR K@HV?@ :@ :;@BVUL UHAW?A= (4 N9UHXGLNAJ).633.1.6.
8L$.*J-(-P QK%W+*+Z%NLKI+Z+ +'K*L#+/(&%M Q(T%L&-+/$B@ULNN@BKA U@HVNR= B ;9WHAONRQA <9;A9NK9QA ;9BBK;@PBK<9 HAON@BKA :@KA:> B@Q9K@:L;ML:KA<NR= 9?MLNK>9MAP =@;@T@ <AGNR :;A :BA=@H@IAOLB?@Q@UBHLG@<9NAA.)LW>HVK9KR :BA=@QLK;AOLB?@I@ 9N9HAW9 :;LGBK9<HLNR N9 ;AB>N?L 3.6.)AB>N@? 3.6. -;LGNAL WN9OLNAJ :@ T?9H9Q SHAI A «'JKAS9?K@;N@I@ @:;@BNA?9»(n = 106).9? <AGN@ AW ;AB>N?9, N9AU@HLL <RB@?AL WN9OLNAJ S9?K@;9 «NLP;@KAWQ»URHA =9;9?KL;NR GHJ :9MALNK@< B NL<;@:9KALP (I;>::9 1), B;LGNAL — GHJU@HVNR= AW I;>::R # (B@Q9K@K@NAJ), NAW?AL — GHJ :9MALNK@< B BLIQLNK9;N@PGL:L;B@N9HAW9MALP (I;>::9 &).2;L<@I9 @ WG@;@<VL, UGAKLHVN@BKV ? KLHLBNRQ BLNB9MAJQ A BK;9= BQL;KAURHA N9AU@HLL <R;9YLNR B;LGA :9MALNK@< B NL<;@:9KALP.
0HJ :9MALNK@< B64B@Q9K@K@NAOLB?@P 9?MLNK>9MALP [KA WN9OLNAJ @?9W9HABV B;LGNAQA. & I;>::L:9MALNK@< B BLIQLNK9;N@P GL:L;B@N9HAW9MALP G9NNRL :@ :;A<LGLNNRQ T?9H9QWN9OAQ@ NAYL, OLQ > :9MALNK@< G;>IA= I;>::.)LW>HVK9KR ABBHLG@<9NAJ ?9OLBK<9 YAWNA :@?9W9HA N9HAOAL WN9OAQR=;9WHAOAP :@ SAWAOLB?@Q> ?@Q:@NLNK> (:;A " = 0,043). 39AU@HLL <RB@?ALWN9OLNAJ (B;LGNAP U9HH 52,6±1,7)@?9W9HABV =9;9?KL;NR GHJ :9MALNK@< BBLIQLNK9;N@P GL:L;B@N9HAW9MALP, B;LGNAL (B;LGNAP U9HH 45,3±2,1) — GHJ:9MALNK@< B B@Q9K@K@NALP, NAW?AL (B;LGNAP U9HH 37,1±1,4) — B NL<;@:9KALP.$U;9Z9LK N9 BLUJ <NAQ9NAL, OK@ > U@HVNR= B ;9BBK;@PBK<@Q HAON@BKA :@KA:> BLIQLNK9;N@P GL:L;B@N9HAW9MAA AQLHA QLBK@ NL9GL?<9KN@ <RB@?AL (:@@KN@TLNAX ? S>N?MA@N9HVN@Q> ?H9BB> BKLN@?9;GAA A 7-3) WN9OLNAJ :@ T?9HL«!AWAOLB?AP ?@Q:@NLNK ?9OLBK<9 YAWNA».& I;>::L :9MALNK@< B B@Q9K@:9KAOLB?@P 9?MLNK>9MALP WN9OAQRL ;9WHAOAJURHA @UN9;>YLNR :@ T?9HL K;L<@IA @ WG@;@<VL @:;@BNA?9 SHAI < W9<ABAQ@BKA @KKLOLNAJ W9U@HL<9NAJ.
#@HVNRL B NLUH9I@:;AJKNRQ KLOLNALQ U@HLWNA :;LG`J<HJHAWN9OAQ@ U@HLL <RB@?AP >;@<LNV K;L<@IA @ WG@;@<VL (p = 0,01) < B;9<NLNAA B:9MALNK9QABU9H@:;AJKNRQKLOLNALQW9U@HL<9NAJ.';A[K@Q>;@<LNVBAK>9KA<N@P A HAON@BKN@P K;L<@YN@BKA :@ T?9HL -:AHUL;IL;9—79NAN9 @?9W9HBJ@GAN9?@<@ <RB@?AQ < @ULA= I;>::9=.3.2. D("#%+QL"K+&%[%T%"+/(&&PL K%&#"+OP39@BN@<9NAA9N9HAW9B@@KN@TLNAJ=9;9?KL;9KLOLNAJ7/#-,B@Q9K@:L;ML:KA<N@P ?@NBKAK>MAA A N@W@ILNAP > <?HXOLNNR= < ABBHLG@<9NALU@HVNR=N9QAURHA<RGLHLNRK;AKA:9:BA=@B@Q9KAOLB?A=(«?9;GA@:L;B@NASAMA;@<9NNR=») BANG;@Q@<:— I KA: — 7/#- B UH9I@:;AJKNRQ, ?@NI;>[NKNRQ ;9BBK;@PBK<> HAON@BKA(B@Q9K@K@NAJ/NL<;@:9KAJ) KLOLNALQ;— II KA: — 7/#- B NLUH9I@:;AJKNRQ, :;@<@MA;@<9NNRQ ;9BBK;@PBK<@QHAON@BKA (BLIQLNK9;N9J GL:L;B@N9HAW9MAJ) KLOLNAQ;65— III KA: — 7/#- B NLUH9I@:;AJKNRQ, ?@Q@;UAGNRQ ;9BBK;@PBK<>HAON@BKA (NL<;@:9KAJ).I KA: B@BK9<AHA 84 :9MALNK9 B UH9I@:;AJKNRQ KLOLNALQ 7/#-, > ?@K@;R=B@Q9K@K@NAJ A NL<;@:9KAJ B >QL;LNN@ :@<RTLNNRQ >;@<NLQ K;L<@IA @ WG@;@<VL@ULB:LOA<9HA 9G9:KA<N@L :@<LGLNAL < U@HLWNA..@ II KA:> URHA @KNLBLNR 11 :9MALNK@< B ;9BBK;@PBK<@Q HAON@BKA(BLIQLNK9;N@PGL:L;B@N9HAW9MALP),J<HJXZAQBJ@BN@<@PGHJ;9W<AKAJGLW9G9:KA<N@I@ :@<LGLNAJ < U@HLWNA.& I;>::> U@HVNR= B ?9;GA@:L;B@NASAMA;@<9NNRQ BANG;@Q III KA:9 <@THA9 U@HVNR= B NLUH9I@:;AJKNRQ KLOLNALQ /#-, NL<;@:9KAOLB?@P ?@NBKAK>MALP B?;9PNL <RB@?AQ >;@<NLQ K;L<@IA @ WG@;@<VL A BS@;QA;@<9<TAQBJ GLW9G9:KA<NRQ«WG@;@<VL-BUL;LI9XZAQ»:@<LGLNALQ<U@HLWNA.0@HL<@L;9B:;LGLHLNAL?9;GA@:L;B@NASAMA;@<9NNR= BANG;@Q@< :;LGBK9<HLN@ N9 ;AB>N?L 3.7.&'())*+,&'())*+,,&'())*+,,,%#"$#!"#)AB>N@?3.7.)9B:;LGLHLNALU@HVNR=?9;GA@:L;B@NASAMA;@<9NNR= BANG;@Q@<.(n=104):@<9;A9NK9Q663.2.1.
>+T%+-#LO+Z"([%NLKI(M W("(I-L"%K-%I( Q(T%L&-+/"LNGL;NRL ;9WHAOAJ A B;LGNAP <@W;9BK :9MALNK@< :;LGBK9<HLNR < K9UHAML3.23.29UHAM9 3.23. '@H A <@W;9BK :9MALNK@<(n = 104)79;9?KL;ABKA?9";>::R :9MALNK@<I (n = 84)II (n = 11)III (n = 9)'@H, < K@Q OABHL:2@ONRP ?;AKL;AP!ATL;9I vs II — p > 0,01*Q>YB?@P;56(67%)9(82%)2(22%)I vs II — p > 0,01*YLNB?AP28(33%)2(18%)7(78%)II vs III — p > 0,01*-;LGNAP (M ± m)<@W;9BK, HLKI vs II — p > 0,01*67 ± 8,964 ± 13,569,5 ± 8,1 I vs III — p > 0,01*II vs III — p > 0,01*!"#$%&'(#%: * — ;9WHAOAJ BK9KABKAOLB?A NLWN9OAQR.-LQLPN@L :@H@YLNAL :9MALNK@< :;LGBK9<HLN@ < K9UHAML 3.24 A N9 ;AB>N?L3.8.29UHAM9 3.24. -LQLPN@L :@H@YLNAL :9MALNK@< (n = 104)79;9?KL;ABKA?9";>::R :9MALNK@<I (n = 84)II (n = 11)III (n = 9)YLN9K/W9Q>YLQ;62(74%)8(73%)5(56%)NL YLN9K/ NL W9Q>YLQ;11(13%)2(18%)3(33%);9W<LGLNR;6(7%)1(9%)0(0%)<G@<LM/<G@<95(6%)0(0%)1(11%)-LQLPN@L :@H@YLNAL,< K@Q OABHL:67+!"!!#*!"!!#)!"!!#(!"!!#3452678290:49'!"!!#;4-:4526754-8290:49< 28=4>45?-&!"!!#@ >A=4B7=>A=2%!"!!#$!"!!#!"!!#,-./0112,,-./0112,,,-./0112)AB.
3.8. -LQLPN@L :@H@YLNAL :9MALNK@< (n = 104).$BN@<NRL B@MA9HVNRL =9;9?KL;ABKA?A :9MALNK@< :;LGBK9<HLNR < K9UHAML3.25 A N9 ;AB>N?L 3.9.29UHAM9 3.25. $BN@<NRL B@MA9HVNRL =9;9?KL;ABKA?A :9MALNK@< (n = 104)79;9?KL;ABKA?9";>::R :9MALNK@<I (n = 84)II (n = 11)III (n = 9);9U@K9XK;37(44%)2(18%)3(33%):LNBA@NL;R;38(45%)5(45%)5(56%)@S@;QHLN9 AN<9HAGN@BKV16(19%)4(36%)1(11%)-@MA9HVN9J =9;9?KL;ABKA?9,< K@Q OABHL:68)!"!!#(!"!!#'!"!!#1 .234.56 78/&!"!!#98:; 73:8+<=:>.?7@:3; 4A/8; 4A%!"!!#$!"!!#!"!!#*+,--./0*+,--./00*+,--./000)AB>N@? 3.9. -@MA9HVN9J =9;9?KL;ABKA?9 :9MALNK@< (n = 104).'@ GLQ@I;9SAOLB?AQ A B@MA9HVNRQ :@?9W9KLHJQ G@BK@<L;NR= ;9WHAOAPQLYG> I;>::9QA NL <RJ<HLN@, W9 AB?HXOLNALQ ILNGL;NR= ;9WHAOAP QLYG> II-P AIII-P I;>::9QA.3.2.2.
![](https://s.studizba.com/z.php?f=/templates/si/i/noavatar.png&w=100&h=100&t=1"){kind=avatar}
